FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability

Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest

Contents 31
FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Power and Spiritual Authority
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
  3. Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
  4. Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Money and Gifts
  1. Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
  2. Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
  3. Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Relationships and Sexual Boundaries
  1. Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
  2. Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
  3. Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
  4. Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Confidence, Information and Honesty
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
  2. Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
  3. Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
  4. Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Structures of Accountability
  1. Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
  2. Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
  3. Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
  4. Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Chapter 6 · Week 6: When Wrong Comes to Light
  1. Lecture 6-1: Mistake, Violation, Abuse
  2. Lecture 6-2: Taking Responsibility
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Harmed Person First
  4. Lecture 6-4: Forgiveness, Restoration and Return
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Plan for the Day It Comes

Jump to the key points ↓

32 min

Lecture 2-1 said that a minister may be supported and may not make the work a means of gain. That leaves a practical problem. Money does not arrive in the abstract. It arrives as a salary, an envelope, a car, a loan, a promise in a will, a discount from a shop, a contract for a church building. Each of these has a person behind it. Many of those persons have a matter before the church, or a need, or a hope, and some are old, ill, frightened or grieving.

This lecture names the central idea of the week and puts it to work. A conflict of interest is a situation in which your own advantage, or the advantage of your family or friends, could pull on a decision that you make for other people. Having one is not wrongdoing. Every minister has some, because every minister has a household and a living to make. The wrong comes from hiding a conflict of interest, or from deciding alone in the middle of one.

The lecture goes through the places where money and ministry meet most often: personal gifts and gifts to the church, gratitude that turns into pressure, gifts from the elderly and the dying, business and loans with members, and decisions from which the minister would benefit. For each, it asks what a careful minister would do, and for each it asks the same plain test.

What these 32 minutes give you

  • Define a conflict of interest and explain why having one is different from doing wrong.
  • Tell a gift to the church from a gift to the minister, and explain how gratitude can become pressure.
  • Explain why gifts and bequests (gifts left in a will) from the elderly, the ill and the dying need extra care, and what a minister can do to protect both the giver and himself or herself.
  • Name three kinds of business dealing with members that need special care, and say what to do when one cannot be avoided.
  • Apply the self-test "Would I be ready to say this openly? Who decides?" to an invented case.

You shall take no bribe, for a bribe blinds those who have sight and perverts the words of the righteous." — Exodus 23:8

World English Bible

You shall not pervert justice. You shall not show partiality. You shall not take a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise, and perverts the words of the righteous." — Deuteronomy 16:19

WEB

He who is faithful in a very little is faithful also in much. He who is dishonest in a very little is also dishonest in much. If therefore you have not been faithful in the unrighteous mammon, who will commit to your trust the true riches? If you have not been faithful in that which is another’s, who will give you that which is your own?" — Luke 16:10-12

WEB

Now when Simon saw that the Holy Spirit was given through the laying on of the apostles’ hands, he offered them money, saying, “Give me also this power, that whomever I lay my hands on may receive the Holy Spirit.” But Peter said to him, “May your silver perish with you, because you thought you could obtain the gift of God with money!" — Acts 8:18-20

WEB

The first two passages are about judges and the officers of a community, and they speak of the bribe. The third speaks of faithfulness with a little and with what belongs to another. The fourth is an old and striking scene: a man offers money for a share in spiritual power. Together they show that the Bible has long known how money and authority can be mixed up.

1. What a bribe does to the eyes

The old law about judges is short and wise. A judge is not to take a bribe, "for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise" (Deuteronomy 16:19). The sentence does not say that a bribe makes a person decide badly on purpose. It says that it blinds. A judge who has taken a gift may still believe that he is fair. He simply no longer sees what he would have seen.

That is the key to everything in this lecture. A conflict of interest works mostly in the dark of the mind. The person who has one seldom thinks, "I am going to favour this man because he gave me something." The person thinks, "He is a good man, and his case is a reasonable one," and cannot tell afterwards whether that thought would have come without the gift. This is why the sensible remedy is not "be a person of good character and trust yourself." Character matters. But the safest practice is to put someone else's eyes beside your own, which is what the self-test below does.

The word "bribe" here is not limited to money in an envelope, and ministers are seldom offered one. The ministers' version is usually gentler: gratitude, hospitality, a favour, a friendship. It is not the gift that is the problem. It is a gift joined to a decision in which the giver has an interest.

2. Gifts to the church and gifts to the minister

Start with a simple line. A gift to the church belongs to the church and is handled as the community has agreed. A gift to the minister belongs to the minister. Most trouble comes from gifts that are not clearly one or the other.

An offering is given "for the pastor," but the pastor is not told which sense is meant. A family gives a sum at a funeral, and nobody has said whether it is for the service, the church, or the minister's household. In communities where the custom is clear and known, there is no difficulty. Where it is not clear, the person who benefits is the person least able to judge, and the safest course is to ask the council, the elders, the overseer or the person's colleague which it is, and to let the answer be known.

Some gifts are plainly small and ordinary: a meal, a jar of fruit, a scarf, a card at the end of the year. Receiving them gracefully is part of being a person among people, and refusing every one of them can be unkind and even insulting in places where giving is how people show respect. Nothing in this lecture asks a minister to be cold. The difficulty begins when a gift is large, private, repeated, timed or tied.

  • Large: it would matter to the giver or change the minister's life.
  • Private: nobody else knows.
  • Repeated: it has become a pattern of support from one person.
  • Timed: it comes just before or after a decision in which the giver has an interest.
  • Tied: either side hopes, or fears, that it will lead to something.

A gift with two or more of these marks should not be received in private.

3. When gratitude turns into pressure

People are often most generous when they are most grateful, and they are most grateful when the minister has helped them in a crisis: a death, an illness, a crisis in the family, a time of fear. There is nothing wrong with that. But gratitude can pull both ways.

The giver may begin to feel that they now hold something over the minister, or that they have bought a place in the minister's attention. The minister may begin to feel that they owe the giver. Neither is a wicked feeling. Both can bend a decision. The member who gave a large gift to the building fund may be listened to more carefully on the next question. The family that gave the minister a generous present may find a complaint easier to raise, or harder.

The harder case is gratitude from people who cannot afford to give. In a poor community, a family may give the minister a gift that costs them a week's food. It is a gift of love, and it is also a gift that the minister cannot easily refuse, since refusing may shame them. A good minister in this position often finds a way to receive the gift graciously and to give back, quietly and without a show, in some other way. The point is not to refuse love. The point is to make sure the minister's position is never what makes the poor give more than they can.

4. Gifts from the elderly and the dying

This is the place where a minister's power to harm is greatest, and where a minister's care is most needed. An elderly or seriously ill person may be lonely, grateful, afraid, and dependent on the minister for company, comfort and spiritual help. They may also have a house, savings or property, and a wish to leave something good behind. They may want to give it to the church, to the minister, to a ministry or to a person who has been kind.

Three risks stand close together.

The giver may be influenced without knowing it. A person who is frightened or ill may agree to what is suggested, particularly by someone they trust and depend on. Whether a gift was freely given is not easy to see from the outside, and not always easy for the giver to know.

The family may be wronged, or may believe so. A relative who finds that an elderly parent has left a house to the pastor will be suspicious, whatever the facts. The pastor's good name, and the church's, may be harmed even if nothing was done wrong.

The minister may be tempted without noticing. A man who has sat by a bedside for months may come to feel that the gift is only fair.

How do careful ministers behave? In many communities, ministers and priests follow a simple set of habits:

  1. Do not suggest the gift, and do not steer a conversation toward it.
  2. Do not be the person who helps to draw up the will or the paper, and do not be present when it is drawn up. Say that the person should take advice from someone who has no interest in the result, such as a family member, a trusted friend or an independent adviser.
  3. If the gift is to the church, say so to the council or overseer, so that more than one person knows, and so the church deals with it in the open.
  4. If the gift is to you personally, do not accept it alone. In many cases the better course is to decline, and to explain kindly why. At the least, tell the council, and in some places the overseer, before anything is done.
  5. Take the family seriously. A minister who knows that a family is concerned should not press ahead.

The law on wills, on gifts from people who are old or ill, on undue influence (pressure that overrides a person's own free choice), and on what a person in a position of trust may receive, differs from one country and region to another. Some places have strict rules; some have few. This lecture cannot tell you what yours are. Find out what the local law and your community's written rules require, and where it matters, ask a qualified person. And if you are tempted to say, "The law allows it, so I may," remember that the question for a minister is wider than the law: Would this be fair to the giver, to the family, and to the people who trusted me?

5. Business, loans and guarantees with members

Ministers and members live in the same towns and often have dealings with one another. A member sells the minister a car. A minister rents a room from a . A member offers an investment. A priest is asked to sign a loan paper for a parishioner. In a village, a minister may buy bread from a member and need to. Most of this is ordinary and harmless.

Three kinds of dealing deserve special care.

Lending and borrowing. If you borrow from a member, you now owe that person. If you lend to a member, that person owes you, and may be afraid to say no to you later, or afraid to complain. Debt is a form of power in both directions. A minister who owes a member money may find it hard to speak plainly to that member. A minister who has lent to a member may find that the member feels bound.

Guarantees. To stand surety for a member's loan (to promise to pay if the borrower cannot), or to ask a member to stand surety for yours, puts the whole of your finances in another person's hands. If the loan goes wrong, you may be bound in ways that the community never intended to allow.

Selling, investing and recruiting. A minister who sells goods or services to the people of the church, or who invites them to put money into a scheme, is using the trust of the pulpit or the pastoral relation to do so. Even an honest offer carries pressure, because members do not like to say no to their minister. This is true of ordinary businesses and still more of any scheme that promises large returns or asks members to bring in others.

In a small, poor or migrant community, the minister and members may have no choice but to deal with one another, and to help one another in practical ways. Money, work and housing are shared in such places, and a minister who refuses all contact would be cut off from the people. The answer in that case is not to avoid dealing, but to follow four steps: notice that a dual relationship exists, disclose it to someone who can help, consult about it, and limit it so that the minister does not hold power in two places at once. Week 3 will return to this in more detail.

6. Benefiting from a decision you make

The sharpest form of a conflict of interest is a decision in which the minister is both judge and beneficiary. It appears in several ordinary forms:

  • Setting or raising your own pay or allowance. (Lecture 2-3 treats this.)
  • Choosing a contractor, supplier or tenant who is a relative, a friend or your own business.
  • Deciding how church property, a vehicle, a house or a hall is used, when you or your household use it.
  • Hiring, or recommending for hire, a member of your family.
  • Deciding who receives help from a fund you control, when the person is a friend or someone who has helped you.

In each case the question is not "Am I a good person?" The question is "Who else decides?" If the answer is "I do," then the right thing is almost always to bring in another person: to leave the room when the decision is taken, to tell the council about the relationship, and to let others decide. This is called stepping aside in some communities, and in some it is called recusing yourself. It costs a minister nothing but a little pride, and it protects both the church and the minister.

7. Fees, offerings and tax

What is given for weddings, funerals, baptisms, blessings and other services differs greatly. In some places there are set fees. In some places the person gives what they wish. In some places it is expected that the minister will receive nothing, and in others that the minister will receive a great deal. Some of it is paid to the church and some to the minister. How these amounts are treated in tax, and whether a minister is an employee or self-employed, differs from country to country. We will not say what the rule is. We say only this: find out the local law and the community's practice, and be able to explain openly where the money goes. If you are unsure, ask a qualified person. Do not arrange anything so that it escapes the rules that would apply to others.

8. Where readers will disagree

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether a minister should accept personal gifts from members at all.

Some hold that a minister should receive nothing personal from members beyond an agreed support, and that all gifts should pass through the community's account. They say that this is the only way to be sure that gratitude never becomes pressure, and that it protects the minister from the suspicion that every kindness has a price.

Others hold that in their culture, giving to those who serve is a form of honour and love, that refusing would insult the giver, and that a minister who accepts gifts gladly and openly is acting in the spirit of Galatians 6:6. They point out that a minister who must refuse every gift can seem cold and above the people.

Both positions have a strong case. The first can make the minister seem a stranger, and can leave a generous person with nowhere to put their gratitude. The second can become a habit of taking, and can let large gifts pass as small ones.

This course requires less than either. It does not tell a minister to refuse every gift or to accept every gift. It requires that a gift which is large, private, repeated, timed or tied is not received in private, and that the community has some way of knowing what its ministers receive.

9. The self-test

One test helps in almost every case. Ask yourself:

Would I be ready to say this openly, to the people who trusted me, and to the person who holds me to account? And who decides?

If the answer to the first question is no, stop. If the answer to the second is "only I," bring another person in. If you notice that you are looking for a way to explain it, take that as a sign. Two further questions help: If the giver stopped giving tomorrow, would I treat them differently? and If a colleague I respected did this, what would I think?

10. Three short cases

(An invented example.) A bequest. An elderly woman, a faithful member who has no children, tells her priest that she wishes to leave her small house to him, "because you have been like a son." He is moved. What did he do well? He did not accept on the spot. What would a better path be? To tell her that he is touched, and that he would like her to leave the matter to a person who has no interest in it. To tell the council. To urge her to take independent advice and to speak with any relatives she wishes to be at peace with. If she then wishes to leave something to the church, that can be done in the open. If the law or the community's rules forbid or limit what he may receive, he follows them.

(An invented example.) A loan. A leader of a small congregation, who is also a shop owner, offers the pastor a loan to buy a house. The terms are generous and no interest is charged. The pastor is relieved. The leader is also a member of the council that sets the pastor's housing allowance, and the council will soon decide whether to raise it. What was crossed? Nothing yet, but the two matters are touching. The better path is to tell the council about the offer, to ask the leader to step aside when the allowance is decided, and to ask whether a loan from the community, or from an independent lender, would be better.

(An invented example.) A contractor. A deacon is asked to find someone to repair the church roof. His cousin is a builder. He does not mention it and asks for one quote from his cousin. The price is fair. What was crossed? The deacon was judge and beneficiary of a relative. What would a better path be? To tell the others that his cousin is a builder, to ask that at least two quotes be sought, and to leave the choice to the others.

Notice that in each case the better path is not to refuse the help, but to bring in another person and to let the matter be seen.

11. What good use of money looks like here

It is not only failures that deserve attention. A minister who has a small plain house and who lives within a known budget, who tells the council plainly what gifts have been received, who has asked someone to see the books, who refuses to take part in decisions about family or friends, and who gives away much of what is offered, has shown the community that money does not rule the ministry. A community that has a short written rule on gifts, and on what may and may not be received in private, has protected every minister who will ever serve it, including the honest ones. The structure is not a sign of suspicion. It is a gift to the minister.

Practical bookkeeping for the church's own money is the subject of Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards (PT712E). The ethics of counselling and of referring a person to other help are the subject of Caring Within Limits: Ethics, Boundaries and Referral in (PT723E). This lecture is concerned with what a minister does when his or her own interest sits beside a decision.


Diagram 1. The self-test for any gift, loan or decision

A conflict of interest is not a sin. Hiding it is the danger. Put another person's eyes beside your own A GIFT OR OFFER to the church? to me? large, private, repeated, timed or tied? THE SELF-TEST Ready to say it openly? Who decides? Would I act the same if the giver stopped giving? THEN tell the council or overseer step aside from the decision seek another quote or view Where the pull is strongest gifts from the old, ill or dying loans, guarantees, sales to members pay, housing and use of church property contracts for relatives and friends A warning sign You are looking for a way to explain it. You hope nobody asks. Only you know the whole of it. The law says you may, but is it fair? Law on gifts, wills and tax differs by country. Check local law and your community's rules.

Diagram 2. Five marks of a gift that should not be received in private

Mark Meaning
Large It would matter to the giver or change the minister's life
Private Nobody else knows
Repeated One person has become a pattern of support
Timed It comes near a decision in which the giver has an interest
Tied Either side hopes or fears it will lead to something

In short

  • A conflict of interest is a situation where your own advantage could pull on a decision made for others. Having one is not wrong; hiding it, or deciding alone, is.
  • A bribe blinds without the person knowing, so the safest remedy is another person's eyes beside your own.
  • A gift that is large, private, repeated, timed or tied should not be received in private.
  • Gifts and bequests from the old, ill or dying need special care: do not suggest them, do not draw up the paper, tell the council, urge independent advice.
  • Loans, guarantees and sales to members make debts and pressure. Where dealing is unavoidable, notice, disclose, consult and limit.
  • Law on gifts, wills, fees and tax differs by country; follow local law and your community's rules.
Front Back
Conflict of interest Your own advantage, or that of family or friends, could pull on a decision you make for others.
Deuteronomy 16:19 A bribe blinds the eyes of the wise; the person does not see what they would have seen.
Five marks of a gift Large, private, repeated, timed, tied.
The self-test Would I be ready to say this openly? Who decides?

One sentence to remember You do not have to be rid of every conflict of interest; you have to make sure you are not alone with it.

This week's action Write down any gift, loan or arrangement you or a minister you know could face this year, and name the person who would be told.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Deuteronomy 16:19 says a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise. Why is it important that the blindness comes without the person knowing? What does that tell us about trusting our own judgement?
  • Think of a gift you have seen given to a minister. Which of the five marks (large, private, repeated, timed, tied) did it have, if any?
  • In the invented case of the bequest, what would have been lost if the priest had accepted on the spot? What would have been gained by waiting?
  • When a minister must deal with members in business because no one else is near, how can the four steps (notice, disclose, consult, limit) be followed in your place?
  • The self-test asks, "Would I be ready to say this openly?" Where in your own tradition is there a person or a body to whom a minister may say it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.