Lecture 6-3: Rebuilding Trust and Telling the Story Again
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Lecture 6-1 said that trust is the slowest of the three things that follow a conflict. It cannot be decided and it cannot be announced. This lecture is about how a community works at it anyway, in ordinary and practical ways, and about a second task that goes with it: telling the community's story again, with the wound inside it.
A congregation that has been through a hard conflict or a hard change has a new chapter in its history. There are two easy ways to handle that chapter. One is to hide it ("we don't talk about that"). The other is to make it the only chapter ("since that time, nothing has been the same"). Both are lies of a kind. The honest way is harder: to say what happened, to say what was lost, to say what is still true, and to go on.
This lecture is about repair in the whole body. It does not make the person who was harmed responsible for the repair. In a case of harm, the community's first duty is to that person's safety and care, and the rebuilding of trust is the community's work, not theirs.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Describe five practical ways a community rebuilds trust: small promises kept, open reports, care for those harmed, naming failure, and lament.
- Explain why trust cannot be restored by declaring that the matter is closed.
- Say what Lamentations 3:19-24 and Nehemiah 8:9-12 show about remembering and rejoicing, without turning them into rules.
- Tell the congregation's story again in a short, honest form that keeps the wound inside it.
- Say why the story of a person who was harmed belongs to that person.
Remember my affliction and my misery, the wormwood and the gall." — Lamentations 3:19
World English Bible
This I recall to my mind; therefore have I hope." — Lamentations 3:21
WEB
It is because of Yahweh’s loving kindnesses that we are not consumed, because his compassion doesn’t fail." — Lamentations 3:22
WEB
Then he said to them, “Go your way. Eat the fat, drink the sweet, and send portions to him for whom nothing is prepared; for this day is holy to our Lord. Don’t be grieved; for the joy of Yahweh is your strength.”" — Nehemiah 8:10
WEB
But all things are of God, who reconciled us to himself through Jesus Christ, and gave to us the ministry of reconciliation;" — 2 Corinthians 5:18
WEB
Notice the order in Lamentations. The writer first remembers the affliction and the gall. Only then does he say, "This I recall to my mind; therefore have I hope." The hope does not come in place of the memory. It comes through it.
1. Why a declaration is not enough
After a conflict, many leaders feel a strong wish to say, "It is over. Let us move on." The wish is understandable. People are tired. Meetings have been long. The leader may be carrying more than anyone knows.
There is a fair case for it, and it should be put at its strongest. A community cannot spend its life on one wound. Long discussion can keep a sore open. A fresh start, plainly offered, lets people who want to give a gift of peace do it. And some of the people most eager to "go on" are those who have been hurt most and want their ordinary life back.
All of that is true. But a declaration does not carry out the work it names. If the things that caused the loss of trust are still unnamed, the people who lost it will hear "let us move on" as "let us stop talking about what you suffered." The declaration does not end the matter. It ends the conversation about the matter, and the matter goes under the floor.
A better test than "is it over?" is "what is still open?" Trust is a list of things that were promised, things that were broken and things that were never said. A community can close that list one item at a time.
2. Five ways a community rebuilds trust
1. Small promises, kept. Trust is not rebuilt by a large gesture. It is rebuilt by small things done when they were said: a report given on the day it was promised, a meeting that starts on time, a question answered within the week. Notice what "small" is for. Small promises can be kept, and kept promises add up to a record. A leader who makes a large promise in order to calm a room, and then cannot keep it, has set the clock back.
Practical step: make one or two promises, with dates. Write them where everyone can see them. Report on them.
2. Open reports. Silence feeds suspicion. After a conflict or a decision, people want to know what is happening: what has been done, what has not, and what is being decided. Open does not mean everything. Personnel matters, personal confidences and the names of people who need protecting are not told. But the state of the work is told, as far as the community's rules allow.
Practical step: give a short written report at a fixed time, say monthly for six months. Say what was done, what was not done and why.
3. Care for those who were harmed. The word "harmed" here covers a wide range: a person embarrassed in a meeting, a family who felt pushed out, a worker whose duties were removed without a word. It also includes, at the far end, cases of real harm in the sense of lecture 4-4. The way of care differs, but one rule runs through all of them: the person decides what they need.
Offer. Do not push. A visit, a call, the name of a person to talk to, a decision about whether they wish to attend a certain event or serve with a certain person: these are the harmed person's to answer. In the case of real harm, a trained person or a pastor or priest named in the policy is the right carer, and the leader does not investigate. Psalm 34:18 and Psalm 147:3 speak of God being near the broken-hearted and binding up their wounds. A community that wishes to be like that offers nearness without demand.
Practical step: ask, "What would help?" and "What would you like us not to do?" Write down the answer, and do it.
4. Naming the failure. A community that has failed someone, or has failed in a process, builds trust by saying so in plain words. A good statement of failure is short. It says what went wrong. It says that it was wrong. It does not blame a person who cannot answer. It does not explain it away with "mistakes were made." It does not identify the person who was hurt. And it says what will be different.
Here is a sample (an invented example): "Last year we changed the time of the main service in one meeting, without asking the families who work on Sunday mornings. Several of them told us afterwards that they felt they did not count. That was a failure of ours. From now on, any change to the times of worship will be announced at least two months ahead, and the people it will affect will be asked first."
Notice what it does not say. It does not say "some people felt." It says "we failed." It makes a promise that can be checked.
5. Lament. The book of Lamentations is a book of grief for a city and its people, and it gives words to a whole community. In chapter 3, the writer speaks plainly: "Remember my affliction and my misery, the wormwood and the gall" (3:19). He does not skip to the praise. He says what it was like. Only after that does he say: "This I recall to my mind; therefore have I hope" (3:21). The hope sits on the far side of the memory.
A community can do something like this in its own way, within its own tradition's forms of prayer: a service of lament, a litany, a time of silence, a prayer in which the loss is named before it is placed in God's hands. This is not an exercise in blaming. It is a way of saying together that something hurt, and that it is held before God. Lecture 2-1 gives the reasons for naming loss aloud.
3. Nehemiah 8:9-12: weeping, and then a meal
Nehemiah 8 tells of a gathering at which the law was read to the people. The people wept as they heard it. Nehemiah, Ezra and the Levites told them, "This day is holy to Yahweh your God. Don’t mourn, nor weep." Then Nehemiah told them to go and eat and drink and "send portions to him for whom nothing is prepared" (8:10). The people went away to eat and drink and celebrate "because they had understood the words that were declared to them" (8:12).
Be careful with this passage. It is easy to read it as "leaders should tell grieving people to stop crying." That is not what it shows. The weeping here is the weeping of a people who have heard a hard word and understood it, and the leaders' answer is tied to a particular day, a holy day, and to a particular act: a meal, in which the people with nothing are not forgotten. What the story shows is a shape: a community hears a hard truth, feels its weight, and is then sent to share a meal and to give to those in need. The sorrow and the feast do not cancel each other.
It does not say when a community should stop grieving, and it does not command a leader to hurry anyone's grief. Lecture 2-1 says the opposite: a loss that is rushed is a loss that returns.
4. 2 Corinthians 5:18-19: a word of caution
Two verses speak of "the ministry of reconciliation," and they are sometimes used as if they command one human being to reconcile with another at once. Read them carefully. The reconciling spoken of here is God's act: "God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself" (2 Corinthians 5:19). The church is given a message about that. The verse does not set a rule for what a person who has been wronged must do about the person who wronged them. A leader who uses it to press a harmed person to meet the one who harmed them has taken a verse about God's work in Christ and made it a weapon.
5. Telling the story again
A congregation lives by its story. Lecture 2-2 said that every community has one, with proud moments, wounds and heroes. After a conflict, the story needs a new paragraph. Who writes it, and what does it say?
A short honest telling has four parts.
- What we were. Something of the community before the conflict, in true and modest terms.
- What happened. In a few plain sentences, not the whole history, not names, not the detail of any person's pain.
- What it cost. The people who left, the friendships that changed, the plans that were dropped, and what was learned.
- What is still true. The things that held: the worship, the work, the people.
Here is an example (an invented example). "For fifteen years this fellowship has met at the corner of the market, and has fed twenty families every Thursday. Two years ago we made a hard decision about our building, and we made it too fast. We lost eleven families, and trust between some of us. We have listened, we have changed how we decide, and the Thursday meals have never stopped. We are not the same community. We are still a community."
Notice what this telling leaves out: who was right, the names of the families, and any account of what any person felt. It does not need them.
The story of the person who was harmed belongs to that person. A congregation does not tell it, shorten it or "close" it for them. If a person who was harmed wishes to tell their own account, in their own words and in their own time, that is theirs to give and the community's to hear. If they never wish to, that is theirs too. A community's retelling of its history can say that something harmful happened and that the community is changed by it, without repeating or describing the harm.
6. What a leader does
- Make two or three promises with dates, and keep them.
- Report openly and on time.
- Ask those who were hurt what would help, and do it.
- Say plainly what failed. The leader who is the author of the failure says so first.
- Find a form of lament that fits your tradition's prayer and use it once.
- Write the short story and read it aloud at a gathering, and ask people to say what is missing.
- Be patient. A year is not long.
Diagram 1. A staircase of trust
Diagram 2. A short, honest retelling: the four parts
| Part | Question it answers | What it leaves out |
|---|---|---|
| What we were | Who were we before? | Boasting |
| What happened | What took place, in a few sentences? | Names; blame; detail of anyone's pain |
| What it cost | Who and what did we lose? | Any claim about who was right |
| What is still true | What held? | A pretence that nothing changed |
In short
- A declaration that it is over does not rebuild trust; the better question is what is still open.
- Five practical ways: small promises kept, open reports, care for those harmed, naming failure, and lament.
- The person who was harmed decides what help they need; a leader offers and does not push.
- In Lamentations 3 the hope comes after the memory of the affliction, not in place of it.
- Nehemiah 8:9-12 shows a people weeping at a hard word and then sent to a shared meal; it does not command anyone to stop grieving.
- A short honest telling of the story names what happened, what it cost and what held, and the account of a person harmed belongs to that person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Better test than "is it over?" | "What is still open?" Close the list one item at a time. |
| Five ways to rebuild trust | Small promises kept; open reports; care for the harmed; naming failure; lament. |
| Lamentations 3:19-21 | The affliction is remembered first, and hope comes through the memory. |
| The harmed person's story | It belongs to that person. The community does not tell it or close it for them. |
One sentence to remember Trust is rebuilt by small promises kept, and the story is told again with the wound inside it.
This week's action Write two small promises with dates that your community could keep in the next month, and the name of the person who will report on them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is the strongest argument for saying "let us move on"? What is its weakness?
- Which of the five ways of rebuilding trust would be hardest in a community you know? Why?
- Write one sentence naming a failure without blaming a person and without excusing it.
- What does the order of Lamentations 3:19-21 (memory first, hope after) suggest about the order of grief and hope in a community?
- How would you answer someone who says Nehemiah 8:10 means a leader should tell grieving people to stop?
- Why does the story of a person who was harmed belong to that person?