Lecture 6-2: When People Leave and When a Church Divides
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Every community loses people. Some move to another city. Some are called to other work. Some drift away, quietly, over a year. Some leave in anger, and some leave in pain. Some leave a conflict behind them, and some leave because of a conflict that was never spoken aloud. Sometimes a number of people leave together, and sometimes a whole body divides into two.
A leader meets these departures in two roles. The first is the person who must do something: speak to the one who is going, answer the question "where has she gone?", say a few words to the congregation. The second is a person who has been left, and who grieves. This lecture takes both seriously.
Its central request is easy to say and hard to keep: speak of those who leave without contempt. It also asks a question that must come first: did something harmful happen? Because a person who leaves after harm is not a deserter.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Distinguish different reasons why people leave, and say why the first question is whether harm was involved.
- Describe a way of leaving well, for the person leaving and for the community.
- Explain what Acts 15:36-41 shows about two workers who parted and continued to serve, and what it does not command.
- State three Christian views of the division of a church fairly.
- Say how a leader speaks to those who remain, and how rumour is met.
Then the contention grew so sharp that they separated from each other. Barnabas took Mark with him, and sailed away to Cyprus," — Acts 15:39
World English Bible
but Paul chose Silas, and went out, being commended by the brothers to the grace of God." — Acts 15:40
WEB
For there also must be factions among you, that those who are approved may be revealed among you." — 1 Corinthians 11:19
WEB
So then, let us follow after things which make for peace, and things by which we may build one another up." — Romans 14:19
WEB
Only Luke is with me. Take Mark, and bring him with you, for he is useful to me for service." — 2 Timothy 4:11
WEB
The first two verses are the end of a dispute between two co-workers. The fourth verse is a sentence of Paul's about the way of peace. The fifth is, much later, a sentence of Paul's about Mark. The third is difficult, and the lecture will say why.
1. Why people leave
There is no single reason, and a leader who assumes one will misread most departures. These are some of the usual reasons. They overlap.
- Life changes. Work, family, health, a move, a new stage of life.
- A . A person is led to another community, another kind of service, another country.
- Conscience. A person comes to hold a conviction that the community does not hold, or cannot go along with a decision.
- Drift. No quarrel, no event. Attendance thins until it stops.
- Pain. Something was said or done. The person is hurt, perhaps ashamed, and cannot come back to the place.
- Harm. Something happened that should never happen. The person is not leaving because of a difference of opinion. They are leaving because it is not safe.
The last two are not the same, and a leader must not mistake one for the other. A hurt can be talked through. A harm cannot be "talked through" with a leader who sits on a council with the person who did it.
2. The first question: did something harmful happen?
When a person leaves suddenly, or leaves in silence, or leaves with a face that looks like fear, the first thing a leader asks is not "how do we win them back?" It is "did anything happen that I do not know about?"
If the answer might be yes, the road is the one in lectures 4-4 and 5-4. Protect, listen without investigating, write down what was said, and tell the person named in the written policy. The leader does not call the person into a meeting with those they left. The leader does not ask them to forgive, to return, or to explain themselves in front of anyone. If a person has left because of harm, they are not a deserter, and they do not owe the community a hearing. A visit or a letter may be offered, once, kindly, and then left alone if it is not answered.
3. Leaving well
Suppose no harm is involved. There are still better and worse ways to part. Both sides, the one who goes and the community, have things to do.
For the community and its leaders:
- Ask, and listen. Offer a conversation, once, without pressing. The aim is to understand, not to argue the person into staying. If they say what they found hard, write it down afterwards (without their name if they prefer) and bring it to whoever should hear it.
- Do not bargain. A person who is being bargained with learns that their leaving was a move in a game.
- Bless them. Where the leaving is amicable, say a word of thanks, and, if your tradition has the custom, commend them to the care of another community. Acts 15:40 says that Paul went out "being commended by the brothers to the grace of God." The parting of the two workers did not end the commending.
- Follow your own rules. Membership, records, transfers and what happens to offices held are decided by the community's written constitution or custom. This lecture does not give rules for them. Keep them separate from any feeling about the person.
- Tell the community, briefly and truthfully. Say what is known and what the person has agreed may be said. "She has moved to another congregation and we wish her well" is enough. Do not describe motives you do not know.
- Leave the door open. Without chasing, make it clear that the person is welcome at a funeral, a feast or a visit.
For the person who leaves:
- Go openly and not by silence, if you can.
- Do not take with you a list of grievances to share around the neighbourhood.
- Do not ask others to leave with you.
- Say thank you for what was good.
Not every person leaving can do all of this, and a person who has been harmed owes none of it. These are descriptions of a good parting between people who are both able to take part in it.
4. Acts 15:36-41: two workers who parted
Luke gives a plain account of a quarrel between two of the early church's most important missionaries. Paul suggested they go back and visit the believers in the cities where they had preached. Barnabas wanted to take John Mark. Paul did not, because Mark had withdrawn from them earlier. "Then the contention grew so sharp that they separated from each other" (Acts 15:39).
Look at what the story says, and be careful not to say more.
- Luke does not hide the dispute. He calls it sharp. He does not tell us that either man was a villain.
- Both men went on serving. Barnabas took Mark and sailed to Cyprus. Paul chose Silas and went through Syria and Cilicia, "strengthening the assemblies" (Acts 15:41).
- Paul's departure was "commended... to the grace of God" (Acts 15:40). The community of believers did not treat him as an outcast.
- Much later a letter in Paul's name says of Mark, "he is useful to me for service" (2 Timothy 4:11). That is a short line, and it does not describe a meeting or an apology. All we can say is that the later record speaks of Mark without contempt.
What the story shows is a way: a sharp disagreement ended in a parting that did not end the work, and the record does not turn either man into an enemy. The text does not say the parting was good, and it does not command any modern community to part in the same way. It does not say who was right. A leader who cites Acts 15:36-41 as proof that separation is fine, or as proof that it is a sin, is asking it to do something it does not do.
5. Grief on the side of those who remain
The people left behind are often forgotten. They have lost a friend, a fellow worker, a teacher, a child's godparent, a person who always sat in a certain seat. They may feel abandoned, or judged ("did they leave because of us?"), or angry, or relieved and then guilty about the relief.
A leader can help in small ways.
- Name the loss. "We will miss them." Lecture 2-1 explains why this matters; a single sentence from the pulpit or at a meeting does more than a speech.
- Let people say how they feel without forcing them to agree with the leader's view of the reasons.
- Do not turn the grief into a chance to speak against the one who left. Even a mild "we all knew she was unhappy" changes the room.
- Mark the going, where it is right to, with a farewell and a thanks.
6. Rumour
Rumour lives in the gap between what happened and what people have been told. A leader who is silent leaves the gap open. A leader who talks too much fills it with half-knowledge and opinion.
Three rules help.
- Say what is known, and only that. If you do not know, say so.
- Say what you will not say, and why. "I will not talk about the reasons she left, because they are hers to tell."
- When someone repeats a rumour to you, do not repeat it on. Ask them gently where they heard it, and ask whether they have spoken to the person.
Proverbs 26:20 (taught in lecture 3-3) is the old warning that a fire goes out for lack of wood, and a quarrel dies down without gossip. A leader can be the one who does not add wood.
7. When a church divides
Sometimes the leaving is not of one person or one family but of a group, and the body splits in two. In some traditions a division is between a local congregation and the larger body. In some it is within the local group. Sometimes it takes place over a period of years, and sometimes in one meeting.
This lecture gives no rule for how to divide, and gives no advice on property, funds, buildings or law. Those belong to each community's written constitution and to qualified professionals who know the law of your country. What the lecture can offer is a way of speaking about it.
This is a point where readers will not agree: how to understand a division of a church.
Some Christians see division as sin to be mourned. They point to Jesus' prayer for his followers to be one, to Paul's rebuke of the Corinthians for lining up behind different teachers (1 Corinthians 1:12), and to the plea in Ephesians 4:3 to be "eager to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace." On this view, a division, whoever caused it, is a wound in the body and should be mourned, not celebrated, even if one cannot see how to avoid it.
Others see division as a sad but sometimes necessary parting. They hold that unity in truth matters more than unity in form, and that there are times when staying together would mean silence about something essential, or would keep a person in danger. They point to Paul's own words that "there also must be factions among you, that those who are approved may be revealed" (1 Corinthians 11:19), and to the long history of churches that divided for reasons they believed were demanded by the faith itself. On this view, a division may be a painful act of loyalty.
Others see a division as an occasion of growth: two bodies reach people the one body did not, or each is free to do what it was called to do. They point to Acts 15:36-41, where the parting of Paul and Barnabas led to two missionary journeys instead of one.
Each of these has something real in it. 1 Corinthians 11:19 is a hard text; scholars have read it as irony, as a statement of what will inevitably happen, or as a description of how a test of faith works, and Paul introduces it with the words "I partly believe it", so it should be used with care and not as a slogan either for or against division.
What this course requires is less than any of these requires. It requires that a leader speak of those who leave without contempt, whichever view the leader holds. A leader need not say that the parting was good. A leader need not say that it was wrong. The leader must not use words that make those who left into enemies, hypocrites, traitors or lost sheep, and must not allow others to use them without gentle correction. It is also required that nobody in the discussion be told that their way of grief or their way of staying or going is faithless.
Romans 14:19 says "let us follow after things which make for peace." After a division, "things which make for peace" can include small, practical things: not competing for the same families, speaking well of each other when asked, letting both groups share a funeral, and not describing the other body in the public language of judgement.
8. A word to the one who is undecided
In a division there are often people in the middle: those who have friends on both sides, those who do not know what they believe, and those who are simply tired. A leader should not press them to choose. They need time, a clear statement of what the options really are, and the freedom to move or to stay without being treated as having betrayed anyone.
9. What the leader must not do
- Do not claim that those who left were wrong because they left.
- Do not count the leaving as proof that you were right.
- Do not use the pulpit, the newsletter or social media to answer them.
- Do not pressure families or children to take sides.
- Do not make a decision about money, buildings or legal rights without the proper process and qualified help.
Diagram 1. When someone leaves: the order of questions
Diagram 2. Three ways of seeing a division
| View | What it holds | Its strongest reason | What this course asks of everyone |
|---|---|---|---|
| A sin to be mourned | Division wounds the one body | Ephesians 4:3; the unity prayed for | Speak of those who leave without contempt |
| A sad but sometimes necessary parting | Truth or safety may outweigh staying together | 1 Corinthians 11:19; churches that divided on conviction | The same |
| An occasion of growth | Two bodies may reach more than one | Acts 15:36-41: two journeys, not one | The same |
In short
- People leave for many reasons: a move, a calling, conscience, drift, pain, or harm. The first question is whether harm was involved.
- A person who leaves after harm is not a deserter and owes the community no hearing.
- To leave well: offer one conversation, listen, do not bargain, bless them, follow written rules, and tell the community briefly and truthfully.
- Acts 15:36-41 shows two workers who parted after a sharp dispute and continued to serve; it does not command a modern parting.
- Christians see division as sin to be mourned, as a sad but sometimes necessary parting, or as an occasion of growth.
- The course asks of every leader that those who leave be spoken of without contempt.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The first question | Did something harmful happen? If it might have, follow the road of protection. |
| Leaving well | One conversation, listening, no bargaining, a blessing, written rules, a brief and truthful word to the community. |
| Acts 15:36-41 | A sharp dispute, a parting, and two journeys of service. A way, not a rule. |
| The requirement | Speak of those who leave without contempt. |
One sentence to remember Ask first whether harm was done, and then let people go, and speak of them, without contempt.
This week's action Write one honest, kind sentence you could say to a congregation when someone leaves, and one sentence you would never say.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why must the first question about a departure be whether harm was involved?
- Which of the six ways of leaving well do you think is hardest for a leader? Why?
- What does Acts 15:36-41 show, and what would be going beyond it?
- Which of the three views of division is closest to your own tradition? State the best argument of one of the others.
- What sentence could a leader say to the congregation when a family leaves that is truthful and also kind?
- How would you answer someone who says, "She left because she was bitter"?