Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Weeks 1 and 2 asked what should change and who will feel the change. This week asks a plainer question: by what road does a change actually become a decision, and then become life?
Many conflicts about change are not about the change at all. They are about the road. A proposal that people might have accepted becomes a quarrel because it came from nowhere, or because the wrong body announced it, or because a group that expected to be asked was told. A good decision can be spoiled by a bad road.
Communities decide big matters in very different ways. This lecture describes the main ways, without ranking them, so that you can find the road in your own community before you walk it. It does not teach law. It teaches you to ask, early, who proposes, who approves, and who may object, and to read your own community's written rules before you say a word in public.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe, for at least four kinds of church order, who proposes, who approves and who may object to a major change.
- Explain why a decision made by an unclear or unwritten road is easily doubted, even when the decision is wise.
- State fairly the different views on how widely a big decision should be shared.
- Find, in your own community's written rules, the road a particular kind of change must take.
- Explain why a leader reads the constitution before speaking about a change, and what a leader does when the rules are silent.
Let all things be done decently and in order." — 1 Corinthians 14:40
World English Bible
The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter." — Acts 15:6
WEB
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
Paul's sentence is about public worship at Corinth, and we do not stretch it into a rule for every committee. It does show something that Christians of every order have agreed on: that how a community does a thing is part of whether the thing is good. Acts 15:6 shows one early community meeting about a hard question. We will use it in lecture 3-2 as a picture of how a deliberation can go. It does not tell any community today which body must decide.
1. Why the road matters
Imagine a proposal that is sound. It is wise, it is needed, and most people, asked fairly, would agree. Now imagine two ways it can arrive.
In the first, the proposal is brought to the body that the community's rules name. People who will be affected are told in good time. Those who disagree know where and how to say so. The decision is made, written down, and announced by the person whose task it is to announce it.
In the second, the same proposal is decided in a corridor by a few people, and the rest hear about it on Sunday.
The proposal has not changed. But in the second case the community does not only argue about the proposal. It argues about whether the decision was theirs to make, and whether they were treated as members or as an audience. The anger that follows is real, and it is not foolish. A community is not only a set of results. It is a set of relationships, and the road is where those relationships are either honoured or ignored.
This is why the apostle can say "decently and in order" (1 Corinthians 14:40). A process that is open, known in advance and followed to the end is part of the justice of a decision. A process that is hurried, hidden or changed halfway cannot be repaired by a good result.
2. Four questions about any road
Before looking at kinds of church order, learn four plain questions. They work in any of them.
- Who may propose? Anyone? A committee? Only the pastor or priest, or only the bishop?
- Who must be consulted? Consulted means asked for counsel before the decision. It does not mean the consulted body decides.
- Who approves? Whose "yes" makes the change official?
- Who may object, and how? Is there an appeal, a second vote, a higher body, a waiting period?
Notice that the third and fourth questions can have different answers. In some communities a council advises and a bishop decides. In others a congregation votes and a committee carries out the vote. A leader who does not know which is which will say "we decided" when the community means "we recommended", and the mistake costs trust.
3. Kinds of church order, described without ranking
What follows is a map in broad strokes. Your own community will differ from it in details, sometimes in large ones. Real communities often mix elements, and every tradition has written rules that govern its own case. The map is here so that you can recognise the shape of your road, and so that you can understand the road of a neighbour without it wrong.
Episcopal order (a bishop oversees the church in a region). In the typical case, a parish may propose a change, and a parish council or similar body may advise. For matters of any size, such as the use or sale of church property, a change in worship that the church's own rules regulate, or a new ministry, the bishop or the bishop's council must approve. Objections usually go upward: to the bishop, to a regional council or synod, and sometimes to a court or tribunal that the church itself has set up. Some matters are not the parish's to decide at all, because they belong to the whole church.
Presbyterian order (elders govern, and a church belongs to a wider body of churches). In the typical case, the elders of a congregation, often called a session or council, decide many matters and bring some to a congregational meeting, for example the calling of a pastor. A regional body of elders and ministers oversees the congregations in its area and may need to approve certain steps, such as a major property decision. Objection can go to the congregation's elders, then to the regional body, and in some churches to higher bodies still.
Congregational order (the local congregation is itself the final body of decision). In the typical case, a committee or the pastor proposes, and the members vote at a meeting called under the church's own rules. The vote of the meeting is final for that congregation. Objection is made in the meeting, and where the rules allow, by calling for a further meeting or a second vote. Associations of congregational churches may advise, but they do not usually decide for a member congregation.
Connectional or independent order. In a connectional body, local churches are bound to a wider organisation, such as a conference or a district, that may appoint ministers and hold property for the whole. Here the local church may propose but a regional officer or body may have the last word on certain matters. An independent congregation, by contrast, has no wider body above it, and its own documents say whether a pastor, a board of elders or deacons, or the members decide. These two are listed together only because they are less easily described in general. Read the document of your own community; do not trust the general picture.
The Catholic and Orthodox parish within its diocese. In both, the parish is part of a diocese under a bishop, and the parish priest serves under the bishop. In the Catholic Church the pastor is assisted by councils, usually a pastoral council and a finance council. Their role is largely to advise, and the church's own law sets limits on what a pastor may decide alone and what needs the bishop's permission. In an Orthodox parish, a parish council commonly works with the priest, and the bishop's blessing or approval is needed for certain steps, with the details differing between jurisdictions. In both, the lay people are not bystanders: they give counsel, they carry out work, and they may bring concerns to the priest and, if needed, to the bishop. The decisions that touch worship, the sacraments and doctrine are not a parish matter at all.
(An invented example.) A small parish wishes to turn an unused room into a place for a weekly meal for neighbours. In an episcopal parish, the proposal goes first to the parish council, which advises, and then to the bishop's office if the room's use is regulated. In a congregational church, the committee brings it to a members' meeting, and the vote decides. In an independent church with a board, the board decides and tells the members. The idea is the same in each. The road is different, and so is who must be asked.
4. Why a leader reads the constitution first
Every community that has a written constitution, a book of rules, a law, a charter, or a set of by-laws, has said in advance how it will decide. This is a gift to a leader. It means the leader does not have to invent a road under pressure.
A leader should do five things before saying anything public about a change.
- Find the text. Ask for the current version. If it cannot be found, say so and ask the body that is responsible for it.
- Find the kind of matter. Rules often treat property, money, worship, staff and ministry differently. Find the section for the change in question.
- Find the steps. Notice who must meet, how much notice must be given, and what share of a vote is required.
- Find the objection. Notice who may challenge the decision and how long they have.
- Ask someone who knows the rules. A secretary, a senior member, a bishop's or regional office, or a qualified adviser can say what the text means. A leader does not guess.
The leader here is not a lawyer. This course does not give legal advice, and rules about property, employment and charity differ greatly between countries and regions. If a decision may have a legal effect, the leader follows the community's rules and the local law, and asks a qualified professional.
If the rules are silent on the matter, do not make up a road alone. Ask the body that holds authority to say how it will decide, write the answer down, and tell the people concerned. A road chosen openly is still a road.
5. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how widely a big decision should be shared. Some church orders place the decision with the bishop or the pastor after consultation. Those who hold this view say that a shepherd is responsible before God for the flock and cannot hand that responsibility to a count of hands; that a vote can turn a spiritual question into a contest; and that the faithful are served better when their pastor takes counsel widely and then decides. Other church orders place the decision with the elders, and those who hold this say that Scripture shows churches governed by a plurality of leaders who carry the weight together, so that no single person decides alone and the whole congregation need not decide everything. Others place the decision with the members meeting together, and those who hold this say that the Spirit is given to the whole body, that members who must live with a decision should have a voice and a vote in it, and that a leader who decides without them treats them as less than adults. Each position is held by thoughtful people for reasons they take from Scripture, history and experience.
This course does not decide between them. It asks for something smaller, and every tradition can accept it. Follow the community's own written constitution, and let the process be open. Let people know in good time what is being considered, who will decide, and how they may speak. A process followed openly is part of the justice of the decision. If the constitution calls for broad sharing, do not shorten it; if it places the decision with a few, do not pretend otherwise, and do not hide the matter from those who will carry it.
6. When the road is unclear or contested
Sometimes people disagree about the road itself. One group says the matter belongs to the council; another says it belongs to the whole body. A leader should not settle this by power. A better course is to ask for a ruling from the person or body that the rules name as their interpreter, such as the bishop, the regional body, the moderator or the secretary. Then follow the ruling, even if it is not the one you hoped for.
A leader should also resist two temptations. The first is to treat the road as an obstacle: "We can skip the meeting, because everyone agrees." People who agree are often the ones who will most want the meeting. The second is to treat the road as the whole job: "We followed every step, so nobody can complain." People may still be hurt by a decision that is lawful. Road and conversation both matter. Lecture 3-3 turns to how a change is spoken about.
For the practices of leadership in a church's governing body, and for the stages of leading a change through an organisation, see and Leadership (PT702E).
Diagram 1. Four roads and three questions
Diagram 2. Five steps before you speak in public
| Step | Ask |
|---|---|
| 1. Find the text | Where is the current constitution, rule book or by-laws? |
| 2. Find the matter | Which section covers this kind of change? |
| 3. Find the steps | Who meets, with what notice, and by what share of the vote? |
| 4. Find the objection | Who may challenge, and within what time? |
| 5. Ask someone who knows | Who can say what the text means? |
In short
- A good decision can be spoiled by a bad road. People argue about the road when they feel they were not treated as members.
- Four questions work in any church order: who proposes, who must be consulted, who approves, who may object.
- Episcopal, presbyterian, congregational, connectional or independent, and the Catholic and Orthodox parish within its diocese each decide big matters by a different road. None is ranked here.
- A leader reads the community's written constitution before speaking, and asks someone who knows the rules; the leader does not give legal advice.
- Readers differ on how widely a big decision should be shared. This course asks for the written constitution to be followed and the process to be open.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four questions | Who proposes? Who must be consulted? Who approves? Who may object? |
| Consulted or deciding | Being consulted means giving counsel before the decision; it is not the same as approving it. |
| First act of a leader | Read the written constitution and ask someone who knows what it means. |
| If the rules are silent | Ask the body that holds authority how it will decide, write it down, and tell those concerned. |
One sentence to remember A decision made by a road that people knew and could trust is more likely to be accepted, even by those who disagree.
This week's action Find the written rules of your own community and mark the section that says who approves a large change.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a decision in a community you know (no names) that was wise but arrived badly. What did the way it arrived do to the people who heard it?
- In which of the kinds of order described here do you have the least experience? What would you need to ask a member of it in order to understand its road?
- What is the difference between being consulted and deciding? Where has the difference been blurred in a community you know?
- A neighbour community decides a large matter by a way that is not yours. How would you speak about it, without calling it wrong?
- If the rules of your community are silent on a matter, whom would you ask, and what would you ask them?