FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

Review by summary

All 31 lectures of PT714E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.

Chapter 0 Introduction: Change Is a Road People Walk Together

  • Change asks people to put down something they treasure, and conflict is where those treasures collide.
  • Leading through change is not the skill of winning; it is telling what to keep from what to change, and opening a road people walk together.
  • Conflict is not by itself a failure, and a community that never disagrees may have people who are afraid to speak.
  • The course does not teach winning, hiding a conflict, legal advice or church discipline, and it names other courses for neighbouring ground.
  • Abuse, violence, danger to a child or vulnerable adult, and theft are not conflicts to mediate: protect, report, and call the local emergency number if danger is present.
  • Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four promises of privacy, and traditions that decide differently are described, not ranked.
Front Back
The central claim Change asks people to put down what they treasure; the work is to tell what to keep from what to change, and to open a road people walk together.
Why change and conflict meet A change puts down something, and when people treasure things that cannot both be kept, they collide.
The safety line Abuse, danger and theft are not conflicts to mediate: protect first, report, and call the local emergency number if danger is present.
Three ways into a lab In your own community; as an observer with an invented case; with a partner in an invented scene.

One sentence to remember A leader's task is not to win, but to tell what to keep from what to change, and to open a road people can walk together.

This week's action Write down one change your community has lived through, and name one thing it asked someone to put down, without naming any person.

Chapter 1 Week 1: What Must Change, What Must Stay

  • A community holds some things as the faith itself and has chosen other things in a time and place. A leader must be able to tell them apart honestly.
  • Acts 15 kept the gospel of grace, released an added yoke, and still asked something of all. The council shows a way of deciding, not a formula.
  • Paul changed much of his manner for others, and kept his loyalty to Christ. The test of a change is whether it serves the message without altering it.
  • Jesus warned that a tradition meant for God can end by cancelling God's word. This danger belongs to every tradition.
  • The two errors are making a form into the faith, and calling the faith a form.
  • Traditions draw the line differently. A leader must give a reason from the community's own standard and must not call another's line faithless.
Front Back
The question before every change What is the faith here, and what is its clothing?
Acts 15 The gospel of grace kept, an added yoke released, a letter written for the common life.
The two errors Making a form into the faith; calling the faith a form.
The leader's duty Give a reason from the community's own standard, and do not call another's line faithless.

One sentence to remember Before you ask how to change something, be able to say, from your community's own standard, whether it is the faith or its clothing.

This week's action Choose one practice in your community that people defend strongly and write down whether it is held as the faith or chosen as a form, and by what standard you say so.

  • A technical problem has an answer that someone already holds. An adaptive problem is solved only when the people who have it learn and change.
  • Three sorting questions: does someone already know the answer, will anyone have to behave differently, and who has to change?
  • The usual error is to treat an adaptive problem as technical. It feels like progress, but the real question is left unasked.
  • A leader names the real problem, holds the question open, sets a pace people can bear, and gives the work back.
  • Nehemiah named the problem before he offered a plan. Jesus did not say everything at once.
  • Most real problems contain both kinds. Split them and ask of each part which it is.
Front Back
Technical problem The answer already exists in the hands of an expert. Nobody has to change.
Adaptive problem Solved only when the people with the problem learn and change.
The usual error Treating an adaptive problem as a technical one.
The leader's task Name it, hold it open, set the pace, give the work back.

One sentence to remember If a problem is solved only when people change, no expert can solve it for them, and a leader's first work is to help them face it.

This week's action Take one problem your community has met before and split it into its technical part and its adaptive part, then write one sentence on who would have to change.

  • The Bible gives stories of change. They show a way and do not lay down a rule for today's decisions.
  • In Acts 6 a complaint from the edge of the community was heard, and the whole body took part in choosing seven to serve.
  • In Acts 11 Peter answered those who challenged him by explaining in order what had happened, and they held their peace and glorified God.
  • Nehemiah mourned, prayed and looked at the wall before he spoke to the people. Then he stated the problem and invited them to build.
  • In each story those affected were not ignored and the change was walked over time, not settled by one announcement.
  • The four questions are how it began, who lost something, who was heard, and how it was received.
Front Back
Acts 6:1-7 A complaint from the neglected widows; the Twelve called the whole body; seven were chosen.
Acts 11:1-18 Peter explained in order to those who challenged him; they held their peace and glorified God.
Nehemiah 1-4 Grief and prayer, a night survey, a plain statement of the problem, then the work and the mockery.
The four questions How it began; who lost something; who was heard; how it was received.

One sentence to remember The Bible does not settle a change in a day; it walks one as a story, and it shows a way to walk, not a rule to apply.

This week's action Take one change your community has lived through and answer the four questions about it in four short sentences.

  • A proposal is easy to make and hard to take back. A leader should check it before speaking.
  • Ask first what problem is being answered, and whether it is the real one. Write it without naming the solution.
  • List what would be lost and by whom, from the point of view of other people, including the quiet ones.
  • Check whether the community's own standard speaks, and whether the matter is the leader's to decide at all.
  • Ask whether the change can be undone, who must be heard first, and whether the proposal is for the community or for the leader.
  • Tradition and novelty can both be hiding places. The remedy is to say the reason and the cost.
Front Back
Questions one and two What problem, and is it the real one? What is lost, and by whom?
Questions three and four What does our standard say, and who decides? Can it be undone, and at what cost?
Questions five and six Who must be heard before it is public? Is it for the community or for me?
Two hiding places Tradition, which avoids giving a reason; novelty, which replaces a reason with a fashion.

One sentence to remember A proposal that has been through honest questions is not yet a road, but it has fewer stones in it.

This week's action Take a change you have been thinking about and write one honest sentence in answer to each of the six questions.

  • The lab sorts what a community keeps from what it might change, and asks for a reason and an authority for each line.
  • A reason is why a thing matters. An authority is the community's own standard you can point to. They are not the same.
  • Where the standard is silent, say so. That is a useful discovery about how the matter should be decided.
  • The lab has three ways in: your own community, the invented case, or an invented scene with a partner.
  • Four promises govern it: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader writes too.
  • If the lab brings a harm to light, it stops, and the person is directed to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person.
Front Back
The form Two columns, keep and might change, each line with a reason and an authority.
Reason and authority The reason is why it matters; the authority is the standard you can point to.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
If harm comes to light The lab stops; speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person; call the emergency number if there is danger now.

One sentence to remember Before a community decides what to change, it should be able to say what it keeps, why, and by what authority.

This week's action Fill in the form on a real sheet of paper, for your community or for the invented case, and keep it where only you will find it.

Chapter 2 Week 2: People in the Face of Change

  • A change asks people to put something down, and they want to know someone has noticed what they are holding.
  • Five common losses are a place, a rhythm, a memory, a belonging and a competence. One change can take several from one person.
  • Unnamed loss often returns as objection to the schedule, the cost or the wording. Naming a loss does not cancel the change; it changes how it is received.
  • Not every objection is grief. Some are about facts or about the faith itself, and the argument may be right.
  • Scripture keeps room for lament, and it tells hard truth before comfort. Romans 12:15 says to weep with those who weep.
  • Words that acknowledge loss are true sentences, said aloud before the benefits; words that rush a loss tell people to feel something else.
Front Back
Five losses A place, a rhythm, a memory, a belonging, a competence.
Grief and argument Unnamed grief often comes out as objection to details; but not every objection is grief.
Order of telling Say the hard truth and the cost first, then the hope (John 13:33 and 14:1; Lamentations 3).
Words that rush "It's only a room." "You'll get used to it." "Focus on the positives."

One sentence to remember A change asks people to put something down, and a leader who has not heard what it is has not yet understood the objection.

This week's action Choose one change your community has made or may make, and write down, for three different people, what it might take from each.

  • A congregation has a story, with proud chapters and wounds. A change that touches the story touches the group's sense of itself.
  • Listening is not agreement. Begin every session by saying that nothing is decided, there is no vote, and no promise is made except to hear and report.
  • Invite across ages and standing, include the quiet and the edge, and hold small groups of six to ten for sixty to ninety minutes.
  • Ask questions that invite a story: when were we most alive, what has hurt us, what do you hope never changes.
  • Record where people can see, without names unless agreed, and mark contradictions. Report back within a few weeks, including what will not happen.
  • If someone speaks of abuse or danger, stop for that person and refer the matter to the written safeguarding policy.
Front Back
First sentence of a session "We are here to listen. Nothing is decided. This is not a vote."
Who to invite Different ages and standing, the quiet, the edge, each language group; small groups of six to ten.
Story questions When were we most alive? What has hurt us? What do you hope never changes?
Fair report in four parts Shared story; what is treasured; where people differ; what happens next and what does not.

One sentence to remember Listening is not agreement, but a change proposed without listening is proposed to a stranger.

This week's action Write down six story questions you could ask in your own community, and the names of the kinds of people (not individuals) who would be least likely to be asked.

  • Age, mother tongue and culture each turn into disagreement about change: different memories of worship, a language of prayer that carries home, different habits of respect.
  • Do not make one generation the problem. Disagreements about form often cut across ages.
  • Acts 2 and Acts 6 show a community of mixed languages meeting wonder and complaint; they show a way, not a rule.
  • Paul's strong and weak are not insults; each owes the other patience. Do not despise, do not judge, do not cause another to stumble.
  • Readers disagree about worship style and language. The course asks only that nobody's way of praying be called wrong in the discussion.
  • Ask who is always asked to give way, and say aloud what each arrangement costs.
Front Back
Three differences Age, mother tongue, culture.
Acts 6:1 A complaint that widows of the Greek-speaking group were neglected; the community involved the aggrieved group in the remedy.
Strong and weak Not labels of insult: the free must not despise or cause a stumble; the cautious must not judge.
Three views of worship form Form carries received meaning; form should follow the people reached; a congregation can hold several.

One sentence to remember A way of praying is a treasure, and in the discussion nobody's way of praying is called wrong.

This week's action For one change in a community you know, write the cost of each of the four arrangements in the table and ask who always pays.

  • The conditions of a meeting (hour, place, language, length, stairs) decide who comes. People are excluded without anyone choosing it.
  • Newcomers, the young, shift workers, the housebound, those who left, the poor and neighbours who never came may all be touched by a change and absent from it.
  • James 2, Luke 14 and Matthew 18 direct attention to those not given the good place, not invited, or not in the fold; they are not rules for voting.
  • Reach the absent by changing the meeting, going to them, asking those who know them, and asking simply in writing. Report back.
  • Absence is not consent. Do not speak for people. Accept a no from those who left.
  • Hearing is not deciding: the constitution says who decides, and a leader may hear many whom it does not allow to vote.
Front Back
Who builds the room? The hour, place, language, length and stairs of a meeting decide who is in it.
Who may be missing? Newcomers, the young, shift workers, the housebound, those who left, the poor, neighbours.
Hearing and deciding A leader may hear those the rules do not let vote; the constitution says who decides.
Those who left Approach without an agenda, accept a no; if harm is named, start the protection road and press no one to forgive.

One sentence to remember The room is built by its conditions, and a leader must ask who the room was built for.

This week's action Write the hour, the place and the language of your community's regular decision meeting, and list three kinds of people each of them keeps out.

  • A change is never a thing to the person it touches. It is a particular morning, a particular seat, a particular hour.
  • Writing from one seat slows a leader down, makes loss specific, and shows that a change may take much from one person and give much to another.
  • The form asks what the change takes, what it offers, what would be missed most, what would make it bearable, and what the writer has assumed.
  • Four promises govern the lab: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
  • The lab has three ways in: your own community by kind of seat, the invented case, or a short scene with a partner. No real names are written.
  • If a harm comes to light the lab stops, and the person speaks to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person; if there is danger now, call the local emergency number.
Front Back
The task of the lab Fill in "A Change Seen from One Seat" for one invented or unnamed person.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
Three ways in Your own community by kind of seat; the invented case; a short scene with a partner.
Question for the group Not "what did you write?" but "what did you notice from that seat?"

One sentence to remember Behind a refusal there is often a loss, and a leader who has not heard the loss has not yet understood the opposition.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper for one kind of seat in a change you know about, without writing a name, and keep the sheet where only you will find it.

Chapter 3 Week 3: Walking the Change

  • A good decision can be spoiled by a bad road. People argue about the road when they feel they were not treated as members.
  • Four questions work in any church order: who proposes, who must be consulted, who approves, who may object.
  • Episcopal, presbyterian, congregational, connectional or independent, and the Catholic and Orthodox parish within its diocese each decide big matters by a different road. None is ranked here.
  • A leader reads the community's written constitution before speaking, and asks someone who knows the rules; the leader does not give legal advice.
  • Readers differ on how widely a big decision should be shared. This course asks for the written constitution to be followed and the process to be open.
Front Back
The four questions Who proposes? Who must be consulted? Who approves? Who may object?
Consulted or deciding Being consulted means giving counsel before the decision; it is not the same as approving it.
First act of a leader Read the written constitution and ask someone who knows what it means.
If the rules are silent Ask the body that holds authority how it will decide, write it down, and tell those concerned.

One sentence to remember A decision made by a road that people knew and could trust is more likely to be accepted, even by those who disagree.

This week's action Find the written rules of your own community and mark the section that says who approves a large change.

  • The harder a change is to undo, the more counsel it needs and the smaller the first step should be.
  • Changes fall into three groups: reversible and small, reversible with cost, and hard to reverse. A change that cannot be undone must not be called a trial.
  • A pilot needs five parts written beforehand: what is tried, how long, what counts as working, who decides afterward, and the way back.
  • Hurrying and delay both have costs. A leader counts both and says aloud which one is being chosen and why.
  • Acts 15 shows a way of deliberation: name the disagreement, gather, discuss, hear witnesses, test against Scripture, speak a judgment, write it down and send messengers.
Front Back
The rule of thumb The harder to undo, the more counsel and the smaller the first step.
Five parts of a pilot What is tried; how long; what counts as working; who decides at the end; the way back.
Not a pilot A change that cannot be undone, or a trial whose answer cannot be "no".
Acts 15 shows Disagreement named, a gathering, witnesses heard, Scripture tested, a judgment spoken, a letter sent.

One sentence to remember A change that can be tried, judged and undone asks much less of people than one that cannot.

This week's action Take one change you have thought about and write its five-part pilot plan on half a page, including how it would end.

  • People learn of a change from what they hear, in what order, and from whom. Most damage comes when they hear it from someone other than the leader.
  • Say the real reason briefly, say what will be lost, ask for questions in a way the quiet can use, and say it more than once.
  • Rumour grows in a gap. The remedy is a reliable place for facts, not scolding.
  • A leader may decline to speak of a private matter, but may not say something false.
  • Speaking the truth in love means both: truth without love wounds, and love without truth leaves people unprepared.
Front Back
Five habits Say why; name the loss; ask for questions; say it more than once; meet rumour with plain facts.
Why a rumour grows Where there is a gap in what people are told, anxiety fills it with the worst.
A limit and a lie "I cannot speak of that" is honest; "there is nothing to tell", when there is, is not.
Two misuses of "truth in love" Truth without love; love without truth.

One sentence to remember A change is not only done; it is said, and the way it is said decides whether people can bear it.

This week's action Write, in four sentences, the reason for a change you know of, including what will be lost, and read it aloud once.

  • Buildings, money and endings are felt deeply because they hold memory, belonging and the sense that a life's work mattered.
  • This course gives no legal, financial or property advice; the leader follows the written constitution, the law of the place and a qualified adviser.
  • Decisions about money are made in the open as far as the rules allow, by a known body and a known road, with the cost counted honestly.
  • An ending done with respect has four parts: truth, thanks, farewell and remembering.
  • A leader must not rush grief, judge the past, hide the reasons, promise beyond the rules, or forget those at the edge.
Front Back
Why these changes cut deep They carry memory and belonging, and an ending asks people whether their work was wasted.
Three steps for legal and financial matters Follow the constitution; follow the law of the place; ask a qualified professional early.
Four parts of an ending Truth, thanks, farewell, remembering.
Money in the open Decided by a known body, by a known road, with the figures the rules allow to be shown.

One sentence to remember An ending told truthfully, thanked, marked and remembered can be grieved; an ending disguised leaves a wound that does not close.

This week's action Write down who in your community holds the written rules and who could advise on legal or financial steps, and ask where the community's records are kept.

  • A proposal that can be put on one page, with its loss and its way back, can be read, questioned and answered by others.
  • The form has eight boxes: problem, proposal, loss, who must be heard, trial, way back, who decides, and what is told.
  • The loss box is the one most often left short; write it in the words of the person who feels it.
  • The lab can be done in your own community, by the observer's way with the invented case, or by the partner's way.
  • Four promises of privacy govern the lab, and if a harm comes to light the lab stops and the student speaks to a trusted person.
Front Back
The eight boxes Problem; proposal; loss; who must be heard; trial; way back; who decides; what is told.
The three ways in Your own community; the observer's way with the invented case; the partner's way with an invented scene.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
If harm comes to light Stop the lab, speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and call the emergency number if there is danger now.

One sentence to remember A proposal is an invitation to counsel, and the page that shows its loss and its way back is the one that can be trusted.

This week's action Fill in the one-page form for a change, real or invented, and then read it aloud as someone who is against it.

Chapter 4 Week 4: Reading a Conflict

  • Conflict is ordinary among believers: the New Testament records a complaint, a sharp parting and a public dispute without calling any of them a failure.
  • The three conflicts differ in kind: fairness (Acts 6), judgement (Acts 15), the gospel itself (Galatians 2). One method will not fit all three.
  • A disagreement tends to build when it concerns the matter, everyone can speak, people can change, and it moves toward a decision.
  • Silence may mean agreement, honour or fear. A leader finds out which, gently, and does not assume the worst.
  • Unity is not quiet. Ask who is paying for the calm.
  • Conflict is where treasures collide, so a conflict can be read as a map of what people love.
Front Back
Three New Testament conflicts Fairness (Acts 6:1), judgement (Acts 15:36-41), the truth of the gospel (Galatians 2:11-14).
Four signs of a conflict that can build About the matter; everyone can speak; people can change; it moves toward a decision.
Three reasons for silence Real agreement; a culture of honour; fear.
The test of a calm community Not "is there noise?" but "who is paying for the calm?"

One sentence to remember Conflict is where treasures collide, so a leader reads it before judging it.

This week's action Think of one quiet person in a group you belong to. Without asking them anything yet, write down what their silence might mean: agreement, honour or fear.

  • A conflict has a top (the question said aloud) and a bottom (what people are defending). Work only on the top and it returns.
  • Five layers: facts, methods, values, relationships and power. Each needs a different tool.
  • A fact is found out together. A method is compared and tried. A value is named and respected. A relationship is acknowledged. Power is made clear and fair.
  • The wrong tool makes things worse: a vote on a fact, a compromise on a value, a new procedure for a hurt.
  • The layers are for the leader's understanding. Never announce to a person what their "real problem" is.
  • If anyone is afraid, the power layer is asking a harder question: is this conflict, or harm?
Front Back
The five layers Facts, methods, values, relationships, power.
A fact needs Finding out together, not a vote or an appeal to loyalty.
A value needs To be named and respected; a compromise on the surface will not settle it.
The caution The layers help you ask questions. They are not a way to read hearts or to accuse.

One sentence to remember The question people ask is seldom the question they are fighting about.

This week's action Take a disagreement you know of, written without names, and write F, M, V, R or P beside each thing that has been said about it.

  • A conflict commonly grows through six steps: discomfort, taking sides, talk behind backs, the person made the problem, attack, and leaving. It is a working picture, not a law.
  • The first three steps need no meeting and no villain. They happen in ordinary talk, which is why they are easy to miss and easiest to turn aside.
  • A triangle eases tension between two people by spreading it over three. The two who need to talk have not talked.
  • A useful test: is the telling meant to mend something, or to line someone up?
  • Anxiety is catching. A calm leader helps a group think; an unaware, anxious leader becomes part of the conflict.
  • Withdrawing, whispering and leaving can also be the signs of a harm. Always ask whether anyone is afraid.
Front Back
The six steps Discomfort; taking sides; talk behind backs; the person made the problem; attack; leaving.
A triangle Two people in tension; one turns to a third instead of to the other. The tension spreads, nothing is mended.
A test for telling someone Am I telling this so that something is mended, or so that someone is lined up?
A warning The same signs may mean a harm is being survived, not a quarrel. Ask if anyone is afraid.

One sentence to remember The first steps of a conflict need no meeting and no villain, only ordinary talk that never reaches the person concerned.

This week's action The next time someone tells you a complaint about a third person, ask: "Have you been able to speak to them?" Listen to the answer before saying anything more.

  • A conflict is between people who can each speak and leave. A harm is the use of power, fear or deceit by one person against another who cannot freely refuse.
  • Harm covers abuse, violence, sexual misconduct, bullying, danger to a child or vulnerable adult, and theft of funds. It is not mediated.
  • Neutrality between the strong and the weak is not neutral. A shared table puts the afraid person before the one they fear.
  • A leader first protects, records, tells the person named in the written policy, and calls the local emergency number if anyone is in danger now.
  • A leader never confronts the accused alone, promises secrecy, joins the two at one table, or asks the harmed person to forgive or reconcile.
  • Fairness to the accused and protection of the harmed belong together. Doubt is a reason to ask the right person, not to wait.
Front Back
Conflict or harm? Conflict: people who can each speak and leave. Harm: one holds power and the other is afraid and cannot freely refuse.
Why not "meet and compromise"? The harmed person is asked to give up safety or truth, and the meeting exposes them to the one they fear.
A leader does first Protect; listen without interrogating; promise no secrecy; write it down; tell the person named in the policy; emergency number if in danger.
A leader never Confronts the accused alone; investigates; joins the two; asks for forgiveness; tells the congregation; waits.

One sentence to remember Where a person is harmed, the road is protection, not mediation.

This week's action Find out whether your community has a written policy for matters of harm. Write down who is named in it, and tell one other leader where it can be found.

  • The lab puts the layers, the stage and the people on a single page, so that a leader slows down before acting.
  • The harm box comes first. If any answer is yes, the exercise stops and the leader speaks to the person named in the written policy.
  • A few words can move a situation from conflict to harm. The map should never make a villain.
  • There are three ways into the lab: your own community, the invented case, or an invented scene with a partner.
  • Four promises govern it: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills one in too.
  • A group leader asks about the experience, not the contents, and knows beforehand whom to tell if a harm comes to light.
Front Back
The boxes of the map Harm check; surface issue; layers; stage; people and what they treasure; one first step.
When the lab stops When any answer in the harm box is yes. Tell the person named in the written policy; emergency number if in danger now.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills one in too.
What a leader asks afterwards "What was it like to draw it?" Not "What did you write?"

One sentence to remember Draw the map before you act, and look at the harm box first.

This week's action Complete the conflict map for the invented case on a real sheet of paper, using only letters or roles for the people.

Chapter 5 Week 5: In the Middle of It

  • A leader in a conflict has two exits: force, which ends the conversation, and absence, which leaves it unfinished. Both leave the people alone with the problem.
  • To stand fairly is to hear each side in its own words, be open about the road, keep the same rules for all, and say what is yours to decide.
  • Fear of other people is a snare. Ask before acting: is this for the community, or to make me less afraid?
  • You are a party when the matter touches your own actions, your close ones or your interests. Say so, hand the chair and keep your voice.
  • Do not use authority to silence, push a person out, hide what must be known, or speak at someone from the front.
  • Fairness between two sides is for conflict. Where one person is harming another, the stance is protection.
Front Back
The two exits Force, which ends the conversation, and absence, which leaves it unfinished.
Signs you are a party The matter touches your action, your close ones or your interests, or you cannot imagine the other side being sincere.
What to do when you are a party Say so, hand the chair to someone who is not, and keep speaking as one member.
The limit of fairness It is for conflict. Where one person harms another, the stance is protection, not neutrality.

One sentence to remember Stand in the room, keep the office, and do not use it to decide who is right; where someone is being harmed, stand with protection instead.

This week's action Write down one conflict you know of, without names, and answer in two lines whether the leader was a party and which door the leader took.

  • Decide the purpose of the meeting before writing the agenda: to hear, to understand, to explore or to decide. A first meeting about a heated question is rarely for deciding.
  • Send an agenda beforehand, set a time for each item, allow a break, and end by reading back what was agreed and what was not.
  • Keep to a few ground rules, said aloud: one speaker at a time, speak for yourself, speak about the matter and not the person's character.
  • Hear facts first, so everyone stands on the same ground, then hear what the facts mean to people. Feeling is information.
  • Keep a record, checked by those present. Do not decide before people have been heard, but say when the decision will be made.
  • Protect people from exposure they did not choose, and do not hide from the body what it must decide.
Front Back
Four purposes of a meeting To hear, to understand, to explore, to decide. Say which one in the invitation.
Order of hearing Facts first, so that all stand on the same ground; then what the facts mean to people.
The record Kept by someone other than the chair, read back at the end, sent within days, open to correction.
Open or private? Protect people from exposure they did not choose; do not hide from the body what it must decide.

One sentence to remember A meeting about a conflict is for hearing before it is for deciding, and it always ends with what was agreed read back.

This week's action Write a one-sentence purpose, five ground rules and an order of speaking for the next difficult meeting you may have to chair or attend.

  • Leaders wait too long for help because of shame, but shame delays, closeness blinds, and help is cheaper early. Asking for a pilot is not a failure.
  • Kinds of help: a trusted person outside the dispute, a trained mediator or facilitator, a wider body where there is one, qualified professionals, and a person for the leader.
  • Call early when the leader is a party, when the conflict repeats, or when a person is afraid.
  • A good helper hears each side, states the role in writing, declares any tie, and does not decide what belongs to the community.
  • Prepare a one-page factual account: the matter, the people by role, events in order, what was tried, what you ask.
  • Mediation is not for harm. Discipline, law and removal follow the written constitution and qualified professionals, not the helper.
Front Back
When to call early The leader is a party; the conflict repeats; a person is afraid.
Kinds of help An outside friend, a mediator or facilitator, a wider body, a qualified professional, a person for the leader.
A good helper Hears each side, states the role in writing, declares ties, keeps to agreed confidence, and leaves the decision with the community.
What mediation is not An investigation, a trial, or a way to bring a harmed person and an accused person to one table.

One sentence to remember Calling for help early is a leader's duty, not a leader's failure, and the call for harm goes to protection, not to a mediator.

This week's action Find your community's written rule about outside help, and write down the name or office of the first person or body you would call.

  • Where harm is suspected, the road is protection and reporting, never mediation. The leader does not need to be sure, and does not decide whether it happened.
  • Mediation fails where there is harm: it assumes equal power, may put the harmed person near the accused, implies shared blame, and keeps the matter private.
  • Steps: safety first, listen without investigating, no promise of secrecy, write down facts, and tell the person named in the written policy the same day.
  • Never bring the harmed person and the accused to one table, and never ask the harmed person to forgive, apologise or reconcile.
  • Support the harmed person, treat the accused fairly without deciding or confronting alone, and leave investigation to those trained and authorised.
  • Laws differ. Follow your written policy and local law, ask a qualified professional, and call the local emergency number if anyone is in danger.
Front Back
The line Where harm is suspected, the road is protection and reporting, never mediation.
The first steps Safety now; listen without investigating; promise no secrecy; write down facts; tell the person named in the policy.
What a leader never does Mediates, confronts the accused alone, investigates, or asks the harmed person to forgive, apologise or reconcile.
Fairness to the accused Do not decide, name or punish; protective steps are not verdicts; those trained and authorised investigate.

One sentence to remember When harm is suspected the leader protects, listens, writes it down and tells the right person; the leader never mediates, never promises secrecy, and never asks the harmed to reconcile.

This week's action Find your community's written policy on protection from harm, write on a card who receives a concern and the local emergency number, and keep the card where you can find it.

  • The first minutes set the tone of a meeting about a conflict, and the opening is the part a leader can prepare.
  • A good opening states the purpose, a few ground rules, what is not being decided tonight, and what happens next and when.
  • If you are a party, say so in one sentence and hand the chair to someone who is not.
  • Some words close a room: "this is decided", "calm down", "I'm sure nobody meant anything". Replace them with sentences that name the difficulty and promise a process.
  • Always ask: is there harm here, and whom would I tell? If yes, stop the meeting plan and follow lecture 5-4.
  • The lab is private, ungraded and may be passed on; the leader fills in a sheet too.
Front Back
A good opening Purpose, a few ground rules, what is not decided tonight, and what happens next and when.
If you are a party Say so in one sentence, and hand the chair to someone who is not.
Words that close a room "It is decided." "Calm down." "I'm sure nobody meant anything." "Let's forgive and forget."
The harm check Is there harm here? Whom would I tell? If yes, stop and follow lecture 5-4.

One sentence to remember Before the first word of a hard meeting, decide what you will promise the room, and ask whether the thing before you is a conflict or a harm.

This week's action Write and say aloud, once, a two-minute opening for the next difficult meeting you may have to lead, and write the role of the person you would tell if harm came to light.

Chapter 6 Week 6: After the Conflict

  • Forgiveness is a release of the claim to repay; reconciliation is a restored relationship; trust is confidence built by behaviour over time.
  • Forgiveness needs one person; reconciliation needs two; trust needs a record. They can arrive in any order.
  • Forgiveness and accountability are not opposed: Luke 17:3 joins rebuke and forgiveness in one sentence.
  • Forgiveness is not forgetting, silence, staying, a deadline, or the removal of consequences.
  • Matthew 5:23-24 sends the person who may have done wrong; it does not send the person who was wronged.
  • No one who was harmed is pressed to forgive, apologise or reconcile, and where there is harm the road is protection.
Front Back
Forgiveness A release of the claim to repay. It begins in one person and needs no meeting.
Reconciliation A restored relationship. It needs two people, truth and change, and safety where there was danger.
Trust Confidence built by behaviour over time. It is earned, not decided.
Matthew 5:23-24 The person who may have wronged another is the one who goes.

One sentence to remember Forgiveness, reconciliation and trust are three things, and no one who was harmed is pressed to reconcile.

This week's action Write the three words on a card, and the next time you hear one of them used in your community, ask quietly which of the three is meant.

  • People leave for many reasons: a move, a calling, conscience, drift, pain, or harm. The first question is whether harm was involved.
  • A person who leaves after harm is not a deserter and owes the community no hearing.
  • To leave well: offer one conversation, listen, do not bargain, bless them, follow written rules, and tell the community briefly and truthfully.
  • Acts 15:36-41 shows two workers who parted after a sharp dispute and continued to serve; it does not command a modern parting.
  • Christians see division as sin to be mourned, as a sad but sometimes necessary parting, or as an occasion of growth.
  • The course asks of every leader that those who leave be spoken of without contempt.
Front Back
The first question Did something harmful happen? If it might have, follow the road of protection.
Leaving well One conversation, listening, no bargaining, a blessing, written rules, a brief and truthful word to the community.
Acts 15:36-41 A sharp dispute, a parting, and two journeys of service. A way, not a rule.
The requirement Speak of those who leave without contempt.

One sentence to remember Ask first whether harm was done, and then let people go, and speak of them, without contempt.

This week's action Write one honest, kind sentence you could say to a congregation when someone leaves, and one sentence you would never say.

  • A declaration that it is over does not rebuild trust; the better question is what is still open.
  • Five practical ways: small promises kept, open reports, care for those harmed, naming failure, and lament.
  • The person who was harmed decides what help they need; a leader offers and does not push.
  • In Lamentations 3 the hope comes after the memory of the affliction, not in place of it.
  • Nehemiah 8:9-12 shows a people weeping at a hard word and then sent to a shared meal; it does not command anyone to stop grieving.
  • A short honest telling of the story names what happened, what it cost and what held, and the account of a person harmed belongs to that person.
Front Back
Better test than "is it over?" "What is still open?" Close the list one item at a time.
Five ways to rebuild trust Small promises kept; open reports; care for the harmed; naming failure; lament.
Lamentations 3:19-21 The affliction is remembered first, and hope comes through the memory.
The harmed person's story It belongs to that person. The community does not tell it or close it for them.

One sentence to remember Trust is rebuilt by small promises kept, and the story is told again with the wound inside it.

This week's action Write two small promises with dates that your community could keep in the next month, and the name of the person who will report on them.

  • A conflict leaves leaders weary, angry, hurt, doubtful, ashamed and lonely; naming these is not weakness.
  • In 1 Kings 19 Elijah is first given sleep and food; the story shows a way of care, not a rule for every case.
  • A leader needs a person outside the dispute who keeps a confidence and tells the truth; share your own feelings, not other people's secrets.
  • Rest belongs to the work: a weekly day, sleep, and a longer break after the crisis.
  • Look honestly at your own part, without self-justification or self-punishment.
  • Signs it is time to step aside include being a party, ruling anger, harmed health, a community that cannot hear you, and a complaint against you.
Front Back
1 Kings 19:5-7 The first care for the exhausted Elijah was sleep and food.
Who to talk to A person outside the dispute who keeps a confidence and tells the truth.
What to share Your own feelings and part, never others' confidences or any detail of harm.
Signs to step aside A party, ruling anger, harmed health, a community that cannot hear, a complaint against you.

One sentence to remember A leader who is wounded needs rest, an honest friend outside the dispute, and the courage to step aside by the community's rules.

This week's action Name one person outside your community's disputes whom you could ask to be your confidential listener, and set a day of real rest in the coming week.

  • A review turns an experience into a lesson; a written policy turns a lesson into something that outlasts the people who learned it.
  • The review asks about decisions and processes, never about the faults of persons.
  • Four promises of privacy: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
  • A written policy should cover change, conflict, outside help, protection from harm, leaving and endings, and care of leaders.
  • The protection of people from harm must be written first, with a named person, first steps, and the things never done.
  • If the lab brings a harm to light, it stops, and the student is sent to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person; if danger is now, to the local emergency number.
Front Back
The learning review Questions about the problem, the road, the loss, the steps, the conflict, harm, repair and the leader. Process, not blame.
The policy list What the written rules should say about change, conflict, outside help, protection, leaving and care of leaders.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
If harm comes to light Stop the lab. Refer to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. Danger now: local emergency number.

One sentence to remember Look back at the process, not the person, and write down before the next crisis how people will be protected.

This week's action Fill in the policy list for your own community, mark the three rows that are empty, and choose the one to raise first.