Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
This is the most important lecture in the course.
Everything else in these six weeks assumes a certain kind of situation: two or more people, each with something real at stake, each free to speak and free to walk away, who disagree. In that kind of situation, listening, fairness, patience and a shared table are the right tools. A leader who learns them will do well.
But some situations that arrive looking like conflict are not that. A person is being hurt by another person who has power over them. The hurt person may be afraid, may be silent, may be asking for something that sounds like a quarrel to be sorted out. If a leader treats such a situation as a conflict and brings the two people together to "clear the air," the leader may do great damage, and may do it while believing they are being fair.
The lecture draws a line. On one side are conflicts, which can be mediated. On the other is harm: abuse, violence, sexual misconduct, bullying and intimidation, danger to a child or a vulnerable adult, and the theft of money. Harm is not mediated. The road for harm is protection, a written record, the community's written procedure, and the proper authorities.
This lecture teaches how to tell the two apart and what a leader does first. It does not make a leader a judge, a police officer, a lawyer or a counsellor. The leader's part is smaller and more important than any of these: to notice, to stand fairly, to protect, and to pass the matter to those who are trained and authorised. Lecture 5-4 gives the procedure in more detail.
Read this lecture slowly. If you are in a community where harm has been done and not addressed, it may be hard to read. Stop when you need to. If you or someone you know is in danger now, call your local emergency number before you read any further.
What these 34 minutes give you
- State the difference between a conflict and a harm, and give the questions that help to tell them apart.
- Explain why "meet and compromise" is the wrong road when one person has power over another.
- Describe general signs that a matter may be harm, and say why a sign is not a proof.
- List what a leader does first, and what a leader does not do.
- Explain how to be fair to the accused without leaving the person harmed unprotected.
Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked.”" — Psalm 82:3-4
World English Bible
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate. Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy.”" — Proverbs 31:8-9
WEB
He said to the disciples, “It is impossible that no occasions of stumbling should come, but woe to him through whom they come! It would be better for him if a millstone were hung around his neck, and he were thrown into the sea, rather than that he should cause one of these little ones to stumble." — Luke 17:1-2
WEB
These passages are not about procedure. They show where God stands, and what weight he gives to the harm of the weak. Psalm 82 is spoken to those who hold power and judge. Proverbs 31 is spoken to those who have a voice. Jesus' words in Luke are among the most severe in the Gospels. A leader who reads them does not find a policy. A leader finds a seriousness, and the seriousness belongs to the leader as well.
1. The argument for treating everything as a conflict, and what is wrong with it
Let us begin with the view that will tempt many leaders, in its strongest form.
A leader should be fair. Proverbs 18:17 says that the one who pleads first seems right until another comes and questions him. Accusations can be mistaken, and sometimes they are false. A person who is accused is a person too, and a community that believes every complaint without question can ruin someone unjustly. So the safest course, one may say, is to treat every difficulty between two people as a conflict: hear both sides, stay neutral, and bring them together to sort it out. That is what a fair leader does.
There is real truth in this. Fairness matters. Neutrality is a great virtue in a conflict between people of roughly equal standing. And this lecture will insist that the accused be treated fairly.
What goes wrong is that neutrality between a person with power and a person without power is not neutral. It takes the side of the stronger. If one person is afraid of another, a meeting of the two is not a meeting of equals. The person who is afraid will say less than the truth, or will say it badly, or will be pressed to take back what they said. The stronger person has everything to gain by a quiet, friendly meeting that ends in "let's put this behind us." The leader who arranged that meeting, meaning only to be fair, has handed the stronger person a tool.
So the question of this lecture is not "which side is right?" It is first a question about the situation: is this a conflict between people who can both speak, or is it a person being harmed?
2. What conflict is, and what harm is
A conflict is a disagreement between people who each have a real stake, who are each free to speak and free to leave, and who are not afraid of each other in a way that stops them speaking. They may be angry. They may be unfair to each other. But they stand on roughly equal ground.
Harm is the use of power, force, fear or deceit by one person to damage another or to take what is not theirs, in a situation where the other cannot freely refuse or walk away. For this course, the main kinds are these:
- Abuse: physical, emotional or spiritual. Spiritual abuse includes using a position of spiritual authority to control, frighten or silence a person.
- Violence, or the threat of it.
- Sexual misconduct: any unwanted sexual attention, contact or pressure, and any sexual conduct by a person in a position of trust toward someone in their care.
- Bullying and intimidation: a pattern of belittling, threats or exclusion, aimed at one person or a few, that they cannot stop.
- Danger to a child or a vulnerable adult: any situation in which a child, or an adult who depends on others for care or protection, may be at risk. Neglect belongs here as well.
- Theft of funds, and financial exploitation, especially of elderly or dependent people.
Laws differ from country to country, and so do the words they use. This lecture uses plain words. Your community's written policy and your local law will say how these are defined and what must be done. This course gives no legal advice.
3. Questions that help a leader tell them apart
A leader is not asked to prove anything. A leader is asked to notice. These questions help.
- Can both people speak freely? Or does one of them go quiet, change their story, or look at the other before answering?
- Is anyone afraid? Not merely angry or upset, but afraid, of a person, of what will be done, of what will be said.
- Is there a difference in power? Position, age, money, knowledge, the ability to hire, to dismiss, to give a reference, to speak for God. Does the stronger person decide things that matter to the weaker?
- Is something being hidden or kept secret? Is anyone being asked to stay silent, "for the good of the church"?
- Is a child or a vulnerable person involved or at risk?
- Is money missing, or being moved without the usual record or knowledge?
If the answer to all of them is no, the situation is probably a conflict, and the tools of the other weeks apply. If the answer to any of the first four is yes, the leader should slow down and look more carefully. If the answer to the fifth or the sixth is yes, the leader should act on the road described below.
This table sets the two side by side.
| A conflict | A harm | |
|---|---|---|
| The people | Roughly equal in standing; each can speak | One holds power over the other; one is afraid |
| What each wants | Different things they both honestly want | One wants to be safe; the other wants silence or access |
| What a shared meeting does | Helps: each hears the other | Hurts: it puts the afraid person before the one they fear |
| What "compromise" means | Each gives up something | The harmed person is asked to give up safety or truth |
| Who handles it | The people, with a fair leader | The person named in the policy, then those trained and authorised |
| What the leader does | Listens, sorts the layers, helps a road to open | Protects, records, passes it on |
4. Two invented cases
(an invented example) Case one. Two members of a parish council disagree about who should hold the keys to the parish hall. One is the treasurer. The other is the person who sets up for events. Each says the other is careless. Both are annoyed. Both speak up freely in meetings and neither is afraid of the other. They are of similar age, and neither controls the other's place in the community. This is a conflict. A fair leader can sit down with both, sort the layers (lecture 4-2), and help them find a way.
(an invented example) Case two. A volunteer, whom we will call Ruth, tells a leader that she has "a problem with the music director" and asks the leader to "sort it out." When asked, she says he has been sending her messages late at night that she finds frightening. She has asked him to stop. He has not. He chooses who sings solos and he writes the reference she needs for a job. She does not want anyone to know she has spoken. A well-meaning leader's first thought might be: "Let me bring them together over tea so they can clear the air." That would be a serious mistake. Ruth is not describing a quarrel. She is describing a person with power who is pressing her and whom she cannot refuse. A shared meeting would put her in front of him, would show him that she spoke, and would very likely end with her being asked to say it was a misunderstanding.
The two cases may sound alike when first told, since both include a person who "has a problem" with another. The difference lies in the six questions. In the first case, the answers are no. In the second, the answers to the first four are yes.
5. Why "meet and compromise" is the wrong road
Mediation depends on a number of conditions that harm removes.
- It assumes both parties can speak without fear. Where one is afraid, the room is already tilted.
- It assumes each gives something up. In a harm, the person harmed is asked to give up their safety, or their account of what happened, or their right to say no. This is not a compromise. It is a loss with a polite name.
- It assumes the leader may hear both sides before deciding what should be done. But where a child or vulnerable adult is at risk, the leader cannot wait until all sides are heard before acting to protect.
- It exposes the person who spoke. A meeting tells the accused who has spoken. This can bring pressure, retaliation or shame.
- It rests on a wish for peace that can become a weapon. The words "we must not divide the church," "let us forgive and move on," "he is such a good man," are said with kind intentions. In the mouth of a community that does not wish to face a harm, they are a way to ask the harmed person to carry the cost again.
Lecture 4-1 asked: who is paying for the calm? In harm, the answer is almost always the person who was harmed.
For the same reasons, a leader should never ask the harmed person to forgive the accused, to apologise for causing trouble, or to reconcile. Forgiveness, reconciliation and trust are three different things (lecture 6-1), and none of them is a duty a leader may impose on a person who has been harmed.
6. Signs, in general words
No list of signs is complete, and no sign is a proof. Signs are a reason to ask the right person a question. They are never a reason to accuse. With that understood, these are some of the things leaders have noticed.
In a person who may be harmed:
- fear, or a change in manner, when a particular person is near;
- sudden withdrawal from an activity the person used to enjoy;
- a reluctance to be alone with someone, or to go to a particular place;
- in a child, a sudden change in behaviour, sleep, appetite or mood, or knowledge or language not fitting their age;
- in an adult, repeated "accidents," a loss of control over money, a person who seems to need permission for ordinary things;
- a question like "if I told you something, would you have to tell anyone?"
In a pattern around a person:
- a demand for secrecy, or for the matter to be kept "within the church";
- a person who insists on being alone with children or with one vulnerable person;
- a person who refuses questions about money, or whose accounts nobody else may see;
- people who leave a ministry one by one and will not say why.
In a community:
- "Everybody knows," and nobody says;
- a complaint met with "but she is such a good person," or "he has done so much for us";
- an instant demand that the person who spoke be quiet, or be seen as the troublemaker.
There may be harmless explanations for any of these. A child may be tired. A person may be shy. The leader's duty is not to decide. It is to ask the right person.
Harm can come from anyone: a volunteer, a leader, a member, a family member of a member, a visitor. It can come from the leader's friend. It can come from the leader. If the person named in the matter is the one who would normally receive the report, then the matter goes to the next person in the written policy who is not involved.
7. What a leader does first
When a leader has reason to think a matter is harm, these are the steps. They are given in order, and each is small.
1. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number. Do this before anything else. Stay with the person if it is safe, and keep them away from the person they fear. Leave the rest to those whose work it is.
2. Listen. Do not interrogate. Let the person say what they wish to say. Do not press for details. Do not ask leading questions. Do not test whether they are telling the truth. Say, in plain words: "Thank you for telling me. I take what you have said seriously."
3. Do not promise secrecy. This is the hardest promise to refuse, and the most important. If you promise to tell no one, you may be unable to protect the person, and you may find yourself carrying a secret that you have no right to keep. Say instead: "I cannot promise to keep this secret. I will tell only the person whose job it is to deal with this, and I will tell you who that is and what will happen next."
4. Write down what was said and what you saw. Write the date and time, the words as near as you can remember them, and what you observed. Do not add your opinion. Do not correct or tidy. Keep it safe, and share it only with the people named in the policy.
5. Tell the person named in the written policy. Most communities that have thought about this have named a person or a small group: a safeguarding officer, a pastor or a priest, a bishop's or regional office, a trained lay person. Tell that person. If the named person is involved in the matter, go to the next one. If your community has no written policy, go to the highest authority who is not involved, and to the proper public authorities. In many places the law requires certain people to report certain matters, and the law is not the same everywhere. Follow your local law and your community's written policy. This course gives no legal advice, and a qualified professional can say what your law requires.
6. Protect the person who spoke. Make sure they are not put in the same room as the accused, are not pressed to take back what they said, and are not made to carry the matter alone. Tell them who will support them.
7. Leave the investigation to those who are trained and authorised. The leader's part is finished when the matter has been passed to the right people, and when the leader has done what the policy asks.
8. What a leader does not do
Each of these is a mistake made by good people. For each, a short reason.
- Do not confront the accused alone. A private word to the accused can lead to hidden evidence, to pressure on the person who spoke, or to further harm. And the leader may be mistaken about what happened.
- Do not investigate yourself. Questioning witnesses, asking for the accused's version, searching: these belong to those who are trained, and a clumsy investigation can spoil a proper one.
- Do not promise secrecy. Said above, said again because it is so often broken.
- Do not bring the harmed person and the accused to a shared table. Not for tea, not for prayer, not for a "healing conversation."
- Do not ask the harmed person to forgive, apologise or reconcile.
- Do not announce the matter to the congregation. The circle should be as small as the policy allows. Rumour harms the harmed person and the accused.
- Do not decide that it cannot be true because the accused is respected, or because he or she has given years of service. Harm is often done by people who are trusted. Nor should the leader decide that it must be true. The leader is not the judge.
- Do not wait for a better time. After the festival, after the building campaign, after the vote: these are the ways in which harm is allowed to continue.
- Do not move the accused quietly to another place or ministry. This passes the harm to people who have not been told.
9. Fairness to the accused
An accusation is not a verdict. A person who is named is owed fairness, and the fairness is real.
The leader treats the accused as a person who has not been proven guilty. The leader does not gossip, does not tell the congregation, and does not treat the person with contempt. The accused is to be heard, by those who are authorised to hear, in the way the community's written procedure sets out. The leader is not that person.
But fairness to the accused is not the same as leaving the accused in contact with the person who has spoken. A community may need to take protective measures while the matter is looked at, for instance by changing who works with children or who sits on a committee. Those measures are set by the written policy and by the proper authority. They are not a punishment and not a verdict. Fairness to the accused and protection of the harmed are not opposites. A fair process does both.
10. A question some readers will ask
Some traditions hold that what is said in sacramental confession may never be disclosed, and some hold a duty of confidence in . This lecture does not judge any community's rule. It makes two plain points. First, whatever such a rule holds, it covers confession or the defined kind of conversation, and not every conversation a leader has. A person who stops a pastor at the church door has not necessarily made a confession. Second, a leader must never promise a confidence they cannot keep. The community's own written policy should say which conversations are covered by its rule. If it does not say, ask a senior person in your community before you need to.
11. Two ways of failing
There are two ways to fail here, and a good leader avoids both.
The first is to treat harm as a quarrel: to mediate, to reconcile, to ask for peace. We have spent most of this lecture on it.
The second is to treat every disagreement as abuse. This silences ordinary conflict, injures people who are falsely accused, and wears out the meaning of the word. The six questions help to avoid it.
What of the leader who is not sure? Doubt is a reason to ask the person named in the policy, not a reason to wait. The cost of an unnecessary question is some awkward days. The cost of waiting, if harm is real, can be years of harm to a person who trusted you.
12. What Scripture shows
It is easy to use a biblical text to settle a modern decision, and we do not do that here. These passages do not give a procedure for a parish council or a congregation of today.
They show something else. Psalm 82 pictures God speaking to the powerful and asking of them one thing: that they defend the weak and rescue the needy. It is not addressed to the weak. It is addressed to those who can act. Proverbs 31:8-9 tells those who have a voice to use it for people who have none. Luke 17:1-2 tells us that Jesus did not treat the harm of the vulnerable as a small matter. The "little ones" can be children, or the humble and the weak among his followers, and in either reading the warning is for the person through whom the stumbling comes.
These texts place the leader. The leader is one of the people with a voice and with some power. The question the texts put to a leader is not "how do I keep the peace?" but "what did I do with the voice and the power I had?" The procedure then belongs to the written policy, to the law of the place and to those trained to carry it out. The seriousness belongs to the leader.
13. Back to the central claim
The central claim of this course says that leading through conflict is not the skill of winning but the work of telling what to keep from what to change, and of opening a road people can walk together. That is true for conflict. For harm, the road is different, and it is not a road people walk together. It is a road one person is helped to walk away from danger, while others do what only they can do. A leader who knows which road is in front of them has done the most important part of the work.
Diagram 1. Conflict or harm: the leader's first question
Diagram 2. Conflict and harm, side by side
| A conflict | A harm | |
|---|---|---|
| The people | Roughly equal; each can speak | One holds power; one is afraid |
| A shared meeting | Helps | Hurts the person who is afraid |
| "Compromise" | Each gives something up | The harmed person gives up safety or truth |
| The leader | Listens, sorts, opens a road | Protects, records, passes on |
In short
- A conflict is between people who can each speak and leave. A harm is the use of power, fear or deceit by one person against another who cannot freely refuse.
- Harm covers abuse, violence, sexual misconduct, bullying, danger to a child or vulnerable adult, and theft of funds. It is not mediated.
- Neutrality between the strong and the weak is not neutral. A shared table puts the afraid person before the one they fear.
- A leader first protects, records, tells the person named in the written policy, and calls the local emergency number if anyone is in danger now.
- A leader never confronts the accused alone, promises secrecy, joins the two at one table, or asks the harmed person to forgive or reconcile.
- Fairness to the accused and protection of the harmed belong together. Doubt is a reason to ask the right person, not to wait.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Conflict or harm? | Conflict: people who can each speak and leave. Harm: one holds power and the other is afraid and cannot freely refuse. |
| Why not "meet and compromise"? | The harmed person is asked to give up safety or truth, and the meeting exposes them to the one they fear. |
| A leader does first | Protect; listen without interrogating; promise no secrecy; write it down; tell the person named in the policy; emergency number if in danger. |
| A leader never | Confronts the accused alone; investigates; joins the two; asks for forgiveness; tells the congregation; waits. |
One sentence to remember Where a person is harmed, the road is protection, not mediation.
This week's action Find out whether your community has a written policy for matters of harm. Write down who is named in it, and tell one other leader where it can be found.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between a conflict and a harm? Which of the six questions do you think is easiest to miss?
- The lecture says that neutrality between a person with power and a person without power is not neutral. Why? Can you think of an ordinary example, one with no abuse in it, where this is true?
- Which of the "what a leader does not do" items would be the hardest for you, and why?
- How can a community be fair to a person who is accused and also protect the person who has spoken?
- Does your community have a written policy for matters of harm? Who is named in it, and does everyone know?