Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
When a conflict reaches you, the first question is not "What should I do?" The first question is "Where am I standing?" A leader who acts before answering that question usually does one of two things. Either the leader uses the power of the office to end the argument, or the leader leaves the argument alone and hopes it will end by itself. Both feel like solutions. Both leave the real problem where it was.
This lecture is about the ground under your feet. Weeks 1 to 3 asked what must change and how a change is walked. Week 4 taught you to read a conflict: its layers, its stages, and the difference between a conflict and a harm. This week asks what you do once you are standing inside one. Lecture 5-1 is about your position. Lecture 5-2 is about the meeting. Lecture 5-3 is about when to call in help. Lecture 5-4 is about the point where mediation must stop. Lecture 5-5 is a Practice Lab.
The central claim of the course applies directly. Conflict is where treasured things collide. A leader who stands well is one who can see what each side treasures and does not need to win in order to feel safe.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe the two exits a leader is tempted to take in a conflict, and say what each costs.
- Explain what it means to stand fairly without being indifferent.
- Name signs that you are yourself a party to the conflict, and say what to do when you are.
- List four uses of authority that a leader should not make in a conflict, and say why each fails.
- Explain why fairness between two sides does not apply where there is harm.
Mercy and truth meet together. Righteousness and peace have kissed each other." — Psalm 85:10
World English Bible
But the wisdom that is from above is first pure, then peaceful, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, and without hypocrisy. Now the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace." — James 3:17-18
WEB
The fear of man proves to be a snare, but whoever puts his trust in Yahweh is kept safe." — Proverbs 29:25
WEB
The psalm puts truth and peace in one sentence and does not let either one swallow the other. James says what the wisdom that makes peace looks like in a person. Proverbs names what usually pulls a leader away from both: fear of other people.
1. The two exits
Picture a leader in the middle of a dispute. Two groups in the congregation disagree. Each wants the leader on its side. Each says the other is not listening. The leader is tired, and a door opens at each end of the room.
The first door is the door of force. Behind it are the agenda that is closed, the vote that is called early, the private word to a difficult member, the remark that "this matter has been decided". The leader keeps the authority of the office and uses it to make the noise stop.
The second door is the door of absence. Behind it are the meeting that is postponed, the matter that is "left to settle", the hope that people will pray and forget. The leader keeps the peace of the room and gives up the work of leading in it.
Both exits have a reason that is not foolish. A person who walks through the first door often believes that a community needs a firm hand, and in some matters it does. A person who walks through the second often believes that people need time, and in some matters they do. The error is not in the belief. The error is in using the belief as a way out. The first door ends the conversation. The second door leaves it unfinished. In both cases the people who were in dispute are left alone with it, and in both cases something that should have been heard goes underground.
The position this lecture describes is the one between the doors. You stay in the room, you keep your authority, and you do not use it to settle who is right.
2. Fair is not the same as absent
"Stand fairly" is easy to say and easy to misread. Some leaders hear it as "say nothing", "have no view" or "never be moved". That is not fairness. It is a third exit made to look like a virtue.
To stand fairly is to do four things.
- You make sure each side is heard in its own words. Not in the words of the other side, and not in your summary of what they probably meant.
- You are open about the road. People should know how the matter will be handled, who will decide and when, before they find out by accident.
- You keep the same rules for everyone. A friend does not get a longer hearing. A person you find tiring does not get a shorter one.
- You say what is yours to decide and what is not. Some matters belong to you by the community's written rules. Others belong to a council, a meeting or a higher authority. A fair leader does not pull a question into the office because it is more comfortable there.
Notice what this list does not contain. It does not ask you to feel the same warmth toward everyone. It does not ask you to have no opinion about the question. A leader who has a view may hold it, and may say it, once the matter has been heard and in the proper place. What fairness asks is that your view does not arrive before the hearing, and that you do not use your position to give your view more weight than it would have if it came from anyone else.
(An invented example.) The chair of a parish council, whom we will call Teodor, is asked to say at the start of a meeting what he thinks about moving the weekly meal from the church hall to a rented room. He thinks it should move. If he says so first, the others will hear it as an instruction. He says instead, "I have a view and I will give it after you have spoken. I want to hear what the meal means to the people who run it, and what it means to those who come." After the discussion he gives his view, and says that it is one voice among several. The meeting is not any shorter. It is more honest.
3. The anxious leader
A conflict in a community makes people anxious, and the leader is a person too. The wish to be rid of the tension is strong, and it can pass itself off as wisdom. Some signs that anxiety, not judgement, is steering you:
- You want the matter closed this week, whatever the matter is.
- You find yourself counting who is for you and who is against you.
- You rehearse, at night, what the most critical person will say.
- You feel relief when a person leaves the room, and you do not ask why.
- You want to be thanked for ending the argument.
Proverbs says that the fear of other people is a snare. A snare is a trap that holds a thing by the foot. A leader who is afraid of displeasing the powerful will give them the longer hearing. A leader who is afraid of losing a few people will let a matter that needs attention wait. A leader who is afraid of being thought weak will use force. Each is acting on the fear and it a policy.
You cannot remove the fear by deciding to. What you can do is notice it, say to yourself what it is, and ask one question before you act: Am I doing this because it is right for the community, or because it will make me feel less afraid? If the honest answer is the second, wait, and speak to someone who is outside the dispute (lecture 6-4 returns to this).
The word steady is useful here. A steady leader is not calm because nothing matters. A steady leader is calm enough to listen, and slow enough to avoid saying what cannot be taken back. The same quality is what James calls "gentle, reasonable". It is not a personality. It can be practised: a pause before replying, a question in place of a verdict, a night's sleep before a letter is sent.
4. When the leader is a party
The most difficult question in this lecture is one most leaders do not ask: Am I one of the parties?
You are a party when any of the following is true.
- The conflict is partly about something you did, said or decided.
- A person or a group has told you that you are the problem, and you have already decided they are wrong without hearing them out.
- A close family member, a close friend or someone who depends on you is on one side.
- The outcome would give you something, or take something from you: money, standing, a role, your preferred way of doing things.
- You find that you cannot imagine the other side being sincere.
None of these makes you a bad person. Leaders are often parties. The failure is not being a party. The failure is not knowing it, or knowing it and hiding it.
When you are a party, three things follow. Say so. You do not need to give a long account. "I am part of this question, and I will not be the one to decide it" is enough, and it frees people to speak. Hand the chair. Someone who is not a party takes the role of leading the discussion, or an outside person does (lecture 5-3). Keep your voice. You are not removed from the community. You speak, as one member, and you accept what is decided by the road the community has agreed.
This will feel like a loss of authority. It is the opposite. A leader who can say "I am part of this" has more authority at the next meeting, because people have seen that the leader would rather be fair than be in control.
5. Truth and peace together
The psalm says that mercy and truth meet and that righteousness and peace kiss. It does not say that one is exchanged for the other. In a conflict, the temptation is nearly always to give up one for the sake of the other.
Some leaders give up truth for peace. They say "I am sure nobody meant anything", when somebody did. They turn a clear fault into a misunderstanding. They ask a person who was wronged to "let it go for the sake of unity". The room becomes quiet, and the quiet is paid for by the person who spoke.
Some leaders give up peace for truth. They say all that is true, in the harshest order, at the worst moment, and call it honesty. They are right about the facts and wrong about the people.
James describes the wisdom that is "first pure, then peaceful, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy". The order is worth noticing: pure first, then peaceful. The wisdom is not afraid of the truth. But it does not use the truth to wound. It says what is true in a way that leaves a road open. The fruit of righteousness, James adds, is sown "in peace by those who make peace". Peace-making is a skill and a labour; it is not the avoidance of difficulty.
A practical test: after you have spoken, could every person in the room say that you told the truth, and could every person say that you treated them with respect? If the answer to one of those is no, the sentence needs more work.
6. Tools a leader should not use
Authority is real, and it is given for a purpose. But there are four uses of it that damage the work of peace. Each looks like leadership. Each is the door of force in a more careful form.
Using authority to silence. "We will not discuss this." "I have heard enough." "This is not the place." Sometimes a matter really does belong elsewhere, and a leader may say so, and say where it does belong. But a ruling whose purpose is to stop people saying what they are afraid to say is not leadership. It teaches the community that disagreement is dangerous, and it moves the argument into corridors and car parks.
Pushing a person out. The leader who finds one person to be the cause of the trouble and works, openly or quietly, for that person to go, has decided the matter before it was heard. Sometimes the person leaves, and the trouble remains, because the person was a symptom. Removal from membership or from office follows each community's own written rules; this course does not teach it, and no leader should invent a way of doing it by pressure.
Hiding the matter. A leader may not tell everyone everything. Some personal and personnel matters must be kept private, and that is proper. But there is a difference between private and hidden. If the community will have to decide something, it has to be told what the decision is about. If the matter concerns a harm, it must go to the people the written policy names (lecture 5-4). A matter hidden to protect the peace of the community usually protects the comfort of the leader.
Using the pulpit, the newsletter or the meeting to speak about a person without naming them. Everyone knows who is meant. The one spoken about cannot answer, and the others learn that this is how the leader deals with disagreement.
(An invented example.) In a small congregation, a retired teacher, Ilse, has written three letters to the council asking why the building fund was moved to a new account. The pastor is tired of the letters. In his sermon he talks about "those who cannot trust their brothers and sisters". The sermon makes no difference to the account. It makes a great difference to Ilse, and to every other person who might have had a question. The question about the account is a fair one that deserves an answer in the open, from the person who knows. The sermon was a use of authority to silence.
7. The limit of fairness
A last matter, and the hinge to lecture 5-4. Everything above assumes a conflict: two or more people with real concerns, none of them being hurt by the other in a way that the community must stop. Standing between the sides is the right position for that.
Standing between is the wrong position where there is harm. If one person is abusing, threatening or exploiting another, there are not two sides with equal claims, and fairness does not mean treating them as equals. The psalm in lecture 5-4 says that the weak and the poor are to be defended and rescued. A leader who stays "neutral" between a person who is hurt and a person who is hurting has chosen a side: the side of the one with more power.
So the stance of this lecture has a boundary. In a conflict, you stand fairly. Where you suspect harm, you stand with protection, and you pass the matter to the people whose task it is. The skill is to know which one you are in, and week 4 gave you the beginning of that skill. If you are unsure, assume the harder case and ask the person named in your community's written policy before you go further.
Diagram 1. Between the two doors
In short
- A leader in a conflict has two exits: force, which ends the conversation, and absence, which leaves it unfinished. Both leave the people alone with the problem.
- To stand fairly is to hear each side in its own words, be open about the road, keep the same rules for all, and say what is yours to decide.
- Fear of other people is a snare. Ask before acting: is this for the community, or to make me less afraid?
- You are a party when the matter touches your own actions, your close ones or your interests. Say so, hand the chair and keep your voice.
- Do not use authority to silence, push a person out, hide what must be known, or speak at someone from the front.
- Fairness between two sides is for conflict. Where one person is harming another, the stance is protection.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The two exits | Force, which ends the conversation, and absence, which leaves it unfinished. |
| Signs you are a party | The matter touches your action, your close ones or your interests, or you cannot imagine the other side being sincere. |
| What to do when you are a party | Say so, hand the chair to someone who is not, and keep speaking as one member. |
| The limit of fairness | It is for conflict. Where one person harms another, the stance is protection, not neutrality. |
One sentence to remember Stand in the room, keep the office, and do not use it to decide who is right; where someone is being harmed, stand with protection instead.
This week's action Write down one conflict you know of, without names, and answer in two lines whether the leader was a party and which door the leader took.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which door is easier for you: force or absence? What does that tell you about what you are afraid of?
- Think of a conflict you have seen in a community, without naming anyone. Was the leader a party? How could you tell?
- Psalm 85:10 holds truth and peace together. Which of the two do you give up more easily when you are tired?
- A leader says, "I will give my view after you have spoken." Is that fair, or is it a way of controlling the room? What would make the difference?
- Where is the line between keeping a matter private and hiding it? Describe the difference in your own words.