FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT714E Leading Through Change and Conflict

Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change

Contents 31
PT714E Leading Through Change and Conflict
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Change Is a Road People Walk Together
  1. Introduction: Change Is a Road People Walk Together
Chapter 1 · Week 1: What Must Change, What Must Stay
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
  3. Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
  4. Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
Chapter 2 · Week 2: People in the Face of Change
  1. Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
  2. Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
  3. Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
  4. Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Walking the Change
  1. Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
  2. Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
  3. Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
  4. Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Reading a Conflict
  1. Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
  2. Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
  3. Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
  4. Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
Chapter 5 · Week 5: In the Middle of It
  1. Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
  2. Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
  3. Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
  4. Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Chapter 6 · Week 6: After the Conflict
  1. Lecture 6-1: Forgiveness, Reconciliation and Trust
  2. Lecture 6-2: When People Leave and When a Church Divides
  3. Lecture 6-3: Rebuilding Trust and Telling the Story Again
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Wounded Leader
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Review and a Policy for Our Community

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

A proposal is easy to make and hard to take back. Once a leader has said "I think we should..." in front of a congregation or a committee, it is no longer only a thought. People will remember it, repeat it, favour it or fear it. Some will begin to grieve before anything has been decided.

For this reason a leader needs a short, honest check before speaking. The check is not a technique for getting a proposal accepted. Its purpose is the reverse: to find out whether the proposal is ready to be spoken, and whether it is the leader's to speak. A proposal that fails the check is not wicked. It is simply early.

This lecture gives six questions. They come from the first two lectures of the week: the question of what is faith and what is clothing, and the question of what kind of problem you have. They are practical, and a leader can ask them alone in a quiet hour. The lecture ends with a harder matter: the temptation to hide behind either tradition or novelty.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Ask the six questions of a change you are considering, and write an honest answer to each.
  • Explain why a leader should find out who would lose something before the proposal is spoken.
  • Say how a community's own standard (its Scripture, confession, liturgical rule or constitution) belongs among the questions.
  • Distinguish a reversible change from one that cannot be undone, and say why the difference matters.
  • Name the temptation to hide behind tradition and the temptation to hide behind novelty, and describe how each one sounds.

A simple man believes everything, but the prudent man carefully considers his ways." — Proverbs 14:15

World English Bible

For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it? Or perhaps, when he has laid a foundation, and is not able to finish, everyone who sees begins to mock him, saying, ‘This man began to build, and wasn’t able to finish.’" — Luke 14:28-30

WEB

Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21

WEB

A prudent person considers his or her steps. A builder counts the cost before laying the foundation. A community tests what it hears and holds on to what is good. These three verses are not rules for committees. They describe the habits of someone who does not hurry, and the six questions are one way of keeping those habits.

1. Why ask before speaking

Many leaders lose the trust of a congregation not by what they propose, but by how early and how carelessly they propose it. A suggestion made out loud at the end of a meeting, in order to "float an idea," can be heard as a decision. A rumour spreads that the Sunday service will be moved, that the hall will be sold, that the old hymns will go. By the time the leader has worked out what was really meant, the community has already reacted to something else.

The proverb quoted above says that "a simple man believes everything, but the prudent man carefully considers his ways." A simple person goes with the first idea and the first impression. A prudent person thinks about the next step before taking the first. In the same way, Jesus says that a person building a tower sits down first and counts the cost, "to see if he has enough to complete it," or else, having begun, will be unable to finish and "everyone who sees begins to mock him" (Luke 14:28-29). The point of the picture is not that building is dangerous. It is that building without reckoning is unkind to the people who will watch it fail.

The six questions below are a way of sitting down to count the cost. They are not a test that a good proposal always passes. They are a means of finding out what you have.

2. Question one: What problem is this answering, and is it the real one?

Begin by writing the problem in one sentence, without naming the solution. If you find you cannot, the proposal may be a solution looking for a problem.

Suppose a leader wants to start a second service. The first sentence might be "We need a second service." That is a solution. The problem might be "Our hall is full and people stand at the back." Or it might be "Our young adults say they cannot come at the present hour." Or it might be "I am tired of leading the same service for twenty years." Each of these is a different problem and calls for a different answer. The third is a real problem, and an honest one, but it is the leader's, and the congregation should not be asked to solve it in the guise of another.

Then ask whether the problem is the real one or the visible one. Lecture 1-2 gave the sorting. A shortage of money may be the visible problem, and a loss of confidence the real one. If it is the real one, a technical answer will not hold.

3. Question two: What would be lost, and by whom?

This is the question most often skipped, because it is uncomfortable. A leader excited about a proposal tends to count its gains with ease and its losses with difficulty.

Make a list of losses, and make it from the point of view of other people. A seat in the front rows. A familiar order of service. A room where a funeral, a baptism or a wedding took place. A role someone has held for thirty years. The status of being the one who knows how things are done. The sense, for people who have given their lives to a community, that what they gave was right.

Then ask who loses each item, and write names or kinds of people. If the only people on your list are those who already disagree with you, look again. Quiet losses are common: the housebound member who cannot attend a new evening service, the person whose first language is not the language of the new materials, the one who will not complain.

Here is an example (an invented example): a council proposes to replace the printed order of service with screens. The gains are plain: cost, flexibility, easier access to the words for visitors. The losses are less plain. A member with poor eyesight, who used to hold a large-print copy, may no longer be able to follow. A member who finds meaning in turning the pages may feel that something has gone. Someone who keeps the sheets from services of grief and joy may lose a record. None of these losses is a reason not to proceed. All of them are reasons to know about them before proceeding.

4. Question three: Does our own standard speak to this?

Lecture 1-1 asked what is faith and what is clothing. This question applies it. Before proposing, look at the standard your community lives under. It may be Scripture read in a particular way, a confession, a liturgical rule, a book of order, a diocesan or denominational policy, a written constitution of a local church. Ask:

  • Does it speak directly to this matter?
  • Does it set a boundary, so that the proposal is ruled out, or ruled in?
  • Does it say who may decide, so that the matter may not be mine or this committee's to decide at all?

The last point is important and often forgotten. In some communities, a matter such as the form of worship or the use of a building is reserved to a bishop, a synod, an assembly or a congregational vote. A leader who proposes something that is not the leader's to decide may do damage even if the idea is good. If the standard does not speak, say so honestly, and do not manufacture an authority for what you want.

Be fair in looking. The temptation is to read the standard for support and not for correction. Apply the verse from Thessalonians: "Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21). Testing means being willing to find that the proposal fails.

5. Question four: Can it be undone, and at what cost?

Some changes can be tried and set aside. A different time for one service, for three months, can be reversed. Others cannot be: a building sold, a ministry closed, a person dismissed, a name changed in a legal document. Between the two lie changes that can in theory be reversed but only at a cost of trust.

Write down for your proposal: if it goes badly, what is the way back, and who pays for it? If there is no way back, then the proposal needs more time, more people and more caution than one that has one. This is not an argument against irreversible change. Some changes have to be made. It is an argument for knowing which kind you are proposing. Lecture 3-2 comes back to small and reversible steps.

6. Question five: Who must be heard before it is spoken of in public?

Some people should hear about a proposal before the whole community does. Those most affected by it. Those who hold an office that is touched. Those whose formal approval is required. Those who are likely to be hurt if they learn of it from the notice board.

This is not a way to manage opinion in advance. It is a matter of courtesy and of honesty. If a proposal touches the work of the organist, the organist ought not to learn of it in the meeting. If it touches the use of a room by a group that has met in it for years, the group should hear it from the leader and not from a neighbour.

There is a limit to this. A leader cannot talk to everyone in advance, and quiet consultation must not become a way of building a party. A reasonable test is to ask: if the people I did not speak to later find out whom I did speak to, would they feel that I had been fair? Lecture 3-3 comes back to how to speak about a change in public.

7. Question six: Am I proposing this for the community or for myself?

This is the hardest question and the one that only the leader can answer. It does not ask whether the proposal is good. It asks where it comes from.

A proposal may come from habit: the way I learned to do this in my last place. It may come from taste: I prefer this music, this layout, this style of preaching. It may come from fear: I am afraid the community will die on my watch. It may come from ambition: I want to be known for having done this. It may come from tiredness. None of these makes a proposal wrong. All of them make it harder to see clearly. A leader who has mixed motives, as almost everyone has, does better to name them than to pretend they are absent.

A simple way to ask is this. Imagine that the proposal came from someone else, someone you do not particularly admire. Would you still think it sound? And imagine that the proposal were to be carried out by a successor, after you have gone. Would you still want it?

8. Two ways of hiding

When a leader is uneasy about answering these questions honestly, two hiding places are available.

The first is tradition. "We have always done it this way." "Our fathers did it." "It is not what a church of our kind does." At their best, these phrases point to something worth keeping: a form that has carried the community well. At their worst, they avoid giving a reason. A leader who opposes a change by invoking tradition without examining what it is protecting has not answered the questions; he or she has avoided them.

The second is novelty. "Everyone is doing it now." "The young will not come otherwise." "We must move with the times." At their best, these phrases point to a real need: people who cannot be reached as things are. At their worst, they replace a reason with a fashion. A leader who proposes a change by invoking novelty, without asking what is lost and by whom, has also avoided the questions.

Neither hiding place belongs to one kind of person. A cautious leader may hide behind novelty by saying "we have to" about something he or she fears; an adventurous leader may hide behind tradition when a proposal threatens his or her own authority. The remedy is the same: say your reason in plain words, and say the cost.

9. What the questions are not

They are not a way to prove you are right. A person can go through all six and still be mistaken. They are not a way of postponing a change for ever. Some leaders, once they learn to ask questions, ask without end. There comes a point at which the proposal has been weighed enough, and it must be spoken, or dropped.

They are also not a script for the meeting. Having asked them, you will know more than you should say all at once. What you say in public, and in what order, is the subject of lecture 3-3.

10. Back to the central claim

Each question guards something. The first guards the truth about the problem. The second guards the people who will lose. The third guards the faith and the community's own order. The fourth guards the way back. The fifth guards the people's right to be told. The sixth guards the leader's honesty. Together they serve the central claim of this course: change asks people to put down something they treasure, and the work of the leader is to tell what to keep from what to change, and to open a road that people can walk together. A proposal that has been through these questions is not yet a road. But it has been cleared of some of the stones that would otherwise be found by the community's feet.


Diagram 1. The six questions, with a warning sign for each

Six Questions Before You Propose Ask them in order, and write the answers down 1 What problem is this answering, and is it the real one? Warning: you cannot say the problem without naming the solution. 2 What would be lost, and by whom? Warning: the only losers you can name are people who already disagree with you. 3 Does our own standard speak to this? Warning: you have not looked, or you looked only for support. 4 Can it be undone, and at what cost? Warning: no way back is planned, but the step cannot be reversed. 5 Who must be heard before it is spoken of in public? Warning: some will learn of it from a rumour. 6 Am I proposing this for the community or for myself? Warning: habit, taste or fear is doing the arguing. A proposal that survives all six is ready to be spoken of. It is not yet decided.

Diagram 2. Reversible and irreversible changes (invented examples)

A change Can it be undone? What follows
Moving a weekly meeting for three months Yes, at small cost Try it, and set a date to look again
Replacing printed books with screens In part; books can be bought again, but the habit may not return Tell people what is being tried, and keep a few copies
Selling a hall No, in practice More time, more voices, written authority first

In short

  • A proposal is easy to make and hard to take back. A leader should check it before speaking.
  • Ask first what problem is being answered, and whether it is the real one. Write it without naming the solution.
  • List what would be lost and by whom, from the point of view of other people, including the quiet ones.
  • Check whether the community's own standard speaks, and whether the matter is the leader's to decide at all.
  • Ask whether the change can be undone, who must be heard first, and whether the proposal is for the community or for the leader.
  • Tradition and novelty can both be hiding places. The remedy is to say the reason and the cost.
Front Back
Questions one and two What problem, and is it the real one? What is lost, and by whom?
Questions three and four What does our standard say, and who decides? Can it be undone, and at what cost?
Questions five and six Who must be heard before it is public? Is it for the community or for me?
Two hiding places Tradition, which avoids giving a reason; novelty, which replaces a reason with a fashion.

One sentence to remember A proposal that has been through honest questions is not yet a road, but it has fewer stones in it.

This week's action Take a change you have been thinking about and write one honest sentence in answer to each of the six questions.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a change you have seen announced too early. What was heard that was not meant?
  • Of the six questions, which would you find hardest to answer honestly? Why?
  • In your community, which matters are reserved to someone else to decide? How would you find out?
  • How do you tell the difference between a loss that is a reason not to proceed and a loss that is a reason to proceed with care?
  • Which hiding place is easier for you, tradition or novelty? What would a friend say?
  • Luke 14:28-30 speaks of counting the cost. Who pays the cost of a change in your community, and are they in the room?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.