FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry

Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures

Contents 31
PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Held in Trust
  1. Introduction: Held in Trust
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Words
  1. Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
  3. Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
  4. Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Collecting, Keeping, Using, Letting Go
  1. Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
  2. Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
  3. Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
  4. Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Notes, Prayer Requests and People at Risk
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
  2. Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Digital Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
  2. Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
  3. Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
Chapter 5 · Week 5: When It Goes Wrong, and When Hands Change
  1. Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
  4. Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Policy and Culture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Writing a Plain Policy
  2. Lecture 6-2: Teaching and Culture: Making It Ordinary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
  4. Lecture 6-4: Known and Kept: A Theology of Being Held
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My Rule and Our One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

A church's information is usually kept by a few people, and often by one. It is in their desk, their phone, their email, their memory. As long as those people stay in their posts, the arrangement may work well enough. The danger comes when hands change.

A pastor retires, is moved to another post, falls ill, resigns in a quarrel or dies without warning. A volunteer who ran the office for twenty years steps down. A church plants a daughter congregation and divides its list. Two churches merge. A church divides over a doctrine or a person, and each half wants the records. A church closes. At each of these moments, a quantity of information about people, built up by their trust over years, changes keeping. The people it concerns are rarely asked. They often do not know that it has happened.

This lecture is about what to do with records when hands change. The central claim of the course applies in a particular way: a handover is a chance to be careful. What is handed over, what is not, who may see what afterwards, and what ends. And at every point, the persons concerned are not exposed by the change.

A caution. The rules about records at the end of a church, and the rules about who may be given what, differ by place and by the legal form of the church; in some traditions, a diocese, a presbytery or a denominational office holds some records by right. This lecture teaches the questions to ask and a minimum standard, not the law. Where it matters, ask a qualified person.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Name the moments at which a church's records change hands, and say why each is risky.
  • Draw up a handover list showing what is handed over, what is not, who holds what access and what is closed, deleted or archived.
  • Explain why access must end for the person who leaves on the day they leave.
  • Describe the temptation to use files as leverage in a conflict, and say what a fair way to deal with a list in a split looks like.
  • State a minimum standard for handing over sensitive records that people of different traditions can accept, and say where the traditions differ.

Moses spoke to Yahweh, saying, “Let Yahweh, the God of the spirits of all flesh, appoint a man over the congregation, who may go out before them, and who may come in before them, and who may lead them out, and who may bring them in; that the congregation of Yahweh not be as sheep which have no shepherd.”" — Numbers 27:15-17

World English Bible

The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also." — 2 Timothy 2:2

WEB

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13

WEB

In Numbers 27, Moses, knowing that his own time is ending, asks that the people not be left without a shepherd; his concern is for the congregation, not for his own legacy. In 2 Timothy 2:2, what is passed on is passed to faithful people and in the open, before many witnesses, so that the handing over does not depend on one person's private word. That is a useful picture for a church's records: handing over done openly, to someone trusted, for the good of those served. Proverbs 11:13 reminds us that a handover can turn into a betrayal if what was told in confidence is passed on to someone who was never told.

1. Why a handover is the risky moment

Three things make a change of hands dangerous for information.

First, the knowledge is in a person, not on paper. A pastor of many years may know where the old registers are, which computer holds the giving records, which password opens the shared folder and which conversations were meant for no one else. The successor knows none of this. Either the successor is left without what the church needs, or the successor finds things never meant for them.

Second, the person's authority ends but their access does not. The pastor who retires still has a key, a phone with the group chats and a copy of the member list in an email account. The volunteer who steps down still has the login. Nobody thinks to remove them, because it feels discourteous, and it is so easy to leave until later.

Third, feelings run high. Partings are often sad and sometimes bitter. People who would not ordinarily misuse information may be tempted, in anger or grief, to do so. Others, in a muddle, may do something innocent that causes harm.

The measures that follow are not suspicion. They are kindness to both sides: they protect the persons whose information it is and they protect the person leaving from any later accusation.

2. The moments

A pastor or leader leaves, retires or is moved. The ordinary case, and the one that can be planned. There is usually time for a handover list, a meeting and an orderly end to access.

A leader dies or falls suddenly ill. The case that cannot be planned for in the moment and must be planned for before. The family holds the phone, the laptop and the boxes of papers. Nobody in the church knows what is on them. A grieving family may open private notes with no understanding of what they are reading. A church with a second person who holds a list of what is where, a sealed note of where the keys and passwords are kept and a written rule about what happens to private pastoral notes has far fewer troubles. The remedy is short: no one person should be the only holder of anything the church needs, and no one person should be the only holder of anything the church must protect.

A ministry changes hands within a church. A youth leader gives way to another; a treasurer is replaced; the person who ran the welcome desk stops. The same list applies, in smaller form.

A church plants or divides. A daughter congregation is formed. Who goes with whom, and what information goes with them?

Two churches merge. The records of two communities, with two sets of habits and promises, are brought together. What each church told its people about its records may differ. The merged church should not use a person's information in a way that the person would not have expected from the church they joined.

A church splits. The hardest case, which we take below.

A church closes. The records outlive the community that made them.

3. The handover list

A handover list is a page, or a few pages, written by the person leaving, with the person arriving and a third person present. It has five parts. In this lecture the parts are written in plain terms; a church can adapt them.

What is handed over. The records that the church needs to carry on its work and that belong to the office rather than to the person: membership and sacramental registers, finance records, current files on volunteers and children's ministry, the calendar and the current lists. For each, say where it is kept, in which form (paper, device, online service), who else can see it and what its sensitivity is, by the four layers of Chapter 1.

What is not handed over. Some records are not the successor's to read. The predecessor's private notes of pastoral conversations, personal letters from members, any record of confession, the personal correspondence of the pastor and records that belong to someone else (for example, notes kept as part of a professional role outside the church). These are not simply removed; a decision must be made about them, which we come to under "Who owns the record?" below.

Who holds what access. A table: each account, store or key; who held it before; who holds it now; and when the previous holder's access ended. Write categories, not passwords. Passwords are never written on the list.

What is closed or deleted. Accounts no longer needed, old groups, shared folders, copies of records on personal devices and in personal email. If the church keeps a rule about what to let go, apply it now (Chapter 2).

What is archived, and where. Records the church has reason to keep for the long term: sacramental and membership registers, histories, minutes. Say where they go, who may open them, and under what conditions.

The list is signed by the people present, kept in a closed place and not shared more widely. It need not take long: an hour or two on paper at a table, with the necessary people.

4. The day the leaver leaves

On the day the person leaves, their access ends. Not next month, and not when someone remembers. The practical details were taught in Chapter 4: accounts closed or passwords changed, shared drives and groups checked, the former helper removed from group chats, keys returned, files on personal devices returned or deleted, recovery options (the phone number or email that would let someone regain an account) changed to point to a current person.

Two points are worth stressing. The first is courtesy: say to the person leaving, in advance, that this is the church's habit for everyone and is not a statement about them. A leaver who has been told this in good time will usually be glad, because it also protects them from any later suspicion. The second is the leaver's own copies. A retiring pastor may have personal copies of lists and notes on a home computer, a phone, a memory stick or paper at home. These need dealing with, gently and openly, by a conversation about what is to be returned, what is to be destroyed and what the pastor will keep for a proper reason. Where the pastor is leaving in a dispute, or has died, the matter is harder, and it calls for a leader above the local level, such as a bishop, a district officer or an from another congregation, rather than an interested party.

5. Files as leverage

When a church divides, or a pastor leaves in anger, the congregation's information becomes a weapon. The member list is the most valuable object in the building, because whoever holds it can write to everyone. So it gets held back, copied, deleted, locked or demanded. Giving records can be used to say who supported whom. Notes of private conversations can be quoted in a meeting. A leader who fears losing the congregation may hold the list to prevent a rival's reaching them; a leader who is leaving may take it, believing that the people are his.

Look at this from the point of view of the people whose names are on the list. They gave their details to a church, for the church's ordinary purposes. They did not agree to be the pieces in a dispute. Some of them are caught between two groups of friends. Some will be hurt by being contacted, and some by not being contacted. Some may be in danger if either side learns where they now worship.

A fair way to handle this has a few features. Nobody uses the information for a purpose it was not given for, and a list given to a church to help it care for its members is not given to help one party win a quarrel. Each person is told, by the church itself and in a neutral way, that a change has happened and how to reach each part, so that each person chooses where to go. The notice does not come from one side with a plea attached. Contact with a person for the purpose of persuading them in the dispute is only with that person's own prior agreement, and where there is no such agreement it is not made. Sensitive records (counselling, discipline, safeguarding) do not move to either side as a prize; they are held by a neutral person or an office above both until a rule decides. And if the dispute cannot be settled between the parties, an outside person (a denominational officer, a mediator or a lawyer experienced with churches) is asked to hold the list and the sensitive files while it is settled.

This asks for restraint at a moment when restraint is hardest. It is worth saying that in many such disputes both sides believe they are acting for the good of the flock. That may be true of each. It does not change what the list is.

6. Who owns the record?

A question lies under much of this lecture: who owns a pastor's record of a private conversation? The person who spoke? The pastor who wrote it? The church that appointed the pastor? Or is "own" the wrong word, because these are not things, but trusts?

This is a point where readers will not agree. There are at least two serious positions.

One holds that a pastor's private notes of pastoral conversations belong, in the sense that matters, to the relationship, and the relationship ends with the pastor's ministry to that person. On this view, the pastor holds the notes as a trustee, for the sake of the person who spoke; when the pastor leaves or dies, the notes should be destroyed, or sealed, and not passed to a successor, who is a stranger to what was said. Many in the Catholic, Orthodox and Lutheran worlds, and in traditions where private confession or confidential spiritual direction are valued, lean this way. They would add that a person who confided in one pastor did not confide in the office, and that reading the notes would be like reading another person's letters. The strength of this view is that it puts the person first and cannot be used as a weapon.

The other holds that the record belongs to the church, which called and appointed the pastor, and that the church has a legitimate interest in continuity of care: a successor who knows nothing of a person's history may do harm by ignorance, or may fail to protect someone who needs protecting; and a church that cannot see what its pastors have recorded has no way to be accountable. Many in Reformed, Presbyterian and congregational traditions, and in churches with strong elder or board oversight, lean toward this view, and so do some who stress safeguarding records. They would add that a record kept in private by one person is a risk in itself, and that accountability requires someone besides the writer to be able to see it. The strength of this view is that it takes continuity and accountability seriously.

Neither view is foolish. The first is weaker when a record is needed to protect someone, or to answer a serious complaint. The second is weaker when it forgets that the person who spoke did so to a person they trusted and may never have imagined a stranger reading it. A great deal depends on what the notes contain. Short, factual notes of visits and agreed steps, written on the understanding that the church may need them (as Lecture 3-1 recommended), are not in the same category as a pastor's reflections on a person's inner life, which should not have been written, or should be destroyed.

It would be too neat to say that the two views are really the same. They are not. But there is a minimum on which people from different traditions can often agree, and the lecture states it so that a church can use it whatever it decides on the larger question.

7. A minimum standard

Whatever your tradition's view of who owns a pastor's notes, hold to these four points when hands change.

  1. Nothing is used as a weapon. No record of a private conversation is quoted, hinted at or held over anyone, in a dispute, a meeting or a campaign.
  2. Sensitive records are sealed or deleted by a rule written before the need arises. Counselling notes, safeguarding concerns, discipline files and confessional material are either destroyed, or sealed and held by a named person under a written rule, and the rule says who may open them, for what reason and with whose knowledge. Records that the church must keep because of a safety or legal reason are kept under that reason and not otherwise opened.
  3. The persons concerned are not exposed by the handover. The successor does not read private material by default. The persons concerned are told, ideally by the one who is leaving, that a new pastor is coming, that what they said before remains private to the earlier relationship unless they choose to share it, and how they may speak to the new pastor if they wish to.
  4. Nothing is done in secret from a trusted person above the local level. A second person, such as a bishop's officer, a presbytery clerk or a senior elder, knows that the handover has taken place and that the list was made. This protects everyone, including the pastor leaving.

These four points do not settle who owns the record. They do make sure that, whoever does, the person whose story it is is not harmed by the change.

8. Two invented cases

(An invented case.) Pastor Daniel is retiring after many years. He keeps, in a cupboard at home, a box of notebooks in which he wrote short notes of visits and sometimes more. The church board wants the notebooks for the archive. Daniel says some of them contain things said to him alone. The board says that the church has paid for his time and the notes are the church's. They reach an impasse that is not about information at all, but about trust.

A way through: a retired elder from another congregation, whom both trust, reads nothing but sorts the notebooks by a simple rule agreed in advance. Notebooks that are only visit dates, who was present and agreed next steps go to the church archive. Notebooks with anything else are not read by the board; Daniel destroys them in the presence of the elder, who signs that it was done, or he seals them with a written instruction that they be destroyed on his death. Daniel writes to the people most likely to be named in them to say what has been done. Nobody is exposed. The board has what it needs. Daniel's integrity is intact.

(An invented case.) A small assembly divides. A group of members leaves with the elder Joy to start a gathering across town. The members' phone list is kept in a shared online folder that Joy administers. The elders who stay want Joy to hand over the list at once and to delete her copy; Joy fears that the remaining elders will use the list to pressure people to stay. For two weeks, each side contacts members to give its account, and members begin to complain.

A way through: both groups agree that a neutral person, such as a minister from a nearby church, sends one short, jointly approved message to every name on the list, saying that the assembly has divided, where each part now meets and that nobody is expected to choose at once. Each person who wishes to be on either list says so. The folder is then divided according to those answers, and each side deletes the rest. The members' contact details for those who say nothing are held by the neutral person for a defined time and then deleted. It is slower than seizing the list, and it treats the people on it as people.


Diagram 1. The handover list

When hands change: the handover list Written by the person leaving, with the person arriving and a third person present. Handed over Registers, finance, current files, lists: what the office needs. Each: where, in what form, which layer. Not handed over Private pastoral notes, confessional material, personal letters. Sealed or destroyed by a rule, not left to chance. Who holds access Each account, store, key: before, now, and the day the old access ended. Categories only. No passwords on the page. Closed or deleted Old accounts, groups, folders, copies on personal devices and in personal email. Archived, and where Registers and history kept for the long term, with who may open them and why. A minimum on which traditions can often agree Nothing is used as a weapon. Sensitive records are sealed or deleted by a prior rule. The persons concerned are not exposed by the handover. A trusted person above the local level knows it was done.

Diagram 2. Records at the end of a church

Kind of record Question to ask Usual direction
Sacramental and membership registers Does a denominational office or another church take them? Kept, and archived with someone who will keep them safely
Finance and property records Which local rule says how long they must be kept, and by whom? Kept for the period the local rule asks, then let go
Counselling, discipline and safeguarding files What is the written rule for sealing or destroying them? Sealed or destroyed by rule; not passed on by default
Members' contact lists Has each person been told where to find a successor group? Used only to tell people of the closure, then deleted
Accounts, pages, domain names, cameras Who could take them over once they are abandoned? Closed, or handed to a named trustworthy body

In short

  • A change of hands is the risky moment: the knowledge is in a person, access outlasts authority, and feelings run high.
  • A handover list sets out what is handed over, what is not, who holds what access, what is closed or deleted, and what is archived and where.
  • The leaver's access ends on the day they leave. This is the church's habit for everyone and says nothing against the person.
  • A member list is not a prize in a dispute. People are told neutrally of a change so that each can choose.
  • Traditions differ on who owns a pastor's private notes: the relationship or the church. A common minimum: no weapon, sealed or deleted by prior rule, no exposure, a trusted person above knows.
Front Back
Topic What happens to a church's records when a pastor or leader leaves, retires or dies, when churches divide or merge, and when a church closes.
Remember Make a handover list: what is handed over, what is not, who holds access, what is closed, what is archived. End the leaver's access the same day.
Caution Never use files as leverage in a conflict. Traditions disagree on who owns a pastor's private notes; the rules about records differ by place and church.
One line to carry into ministry When hands change, nothing is used as a weapon, sensitive records are sealed or ended by rule, and the people they concern are not exposed.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Who in your community is the only holder of something the church needs, or of something the church must protect? What would happen if that person were unavailable tomorrow?
  • Why does the lecture say that ending a leaver's access "is not a statement about them"? How could you say this to a retiring leader so that it is heard as kindness?
  • Set out, as strongly as you can, the view that a pastor's private notes should end with the pastor. Then set out, as strongly as you can, the view that the church should keep them. Which weaknesses of each did the lecture mention, and do you agree?
  • In the divided assembly, why might a neutral person send the first message, and why might each side find that hard to accept?
  • A person asks: "My old pastor knew about my past. Will the new one read it?" What would you want to be able to say truthfully?
  • Proverbs 11:13 and 2 Timothy 2:2 both concern what is passed on. How do the two verses together help in thinking about a handover?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.