Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
- Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
- Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
- Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
- Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
- Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
- Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
- Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
- Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
- Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
- Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
- Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
- Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
- Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
- Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
- Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
- Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
- Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
This lab turns the four lectures of Week 1 into one piece of paper. You will draw an information map: a plain table that lists the kinds of information a community holds, who holds each kind, where it lives, who can see it, and which of the four layers it belongs to. Most communities have never done this. The first time is often a surprise, because the information is spread across more places than anyone realised, and it is held by more people than anyone intended.
The purpose is not to find fault. It is to see clearly, so that later decisions (what to collect, who may see it, how it is kept, when it ends) are made about something you have actually looked at. The lab asks for no software, no account and no internet. It uses a pencil and paper. It does not ask anyone to bring a real list, record, note or password. Do not bring any. You will work with an invented case, with a partner who knows no real details, or with categories only.
The course claim sits behind the exercise:
What people entrust to a church is theirs, and the church is its keeper. So a minister collects only what is needed, says why, lets only the people who must see it see it, uses it only for the reason it was given, lets it go when that reason ends, and, when something goes wrong, does not hide it and cares first for the people who were hurt.
A church cannot be a good keeper of what it has not counted. This lab is the counting. It is not legal advice, and it does not tell you what your country requires; it helps you see what you have so that you can ask good questions of someone qualified where you serve. Labs are not examined.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Fill in an information map with kinds of information, holders, places, viewers and layers.
- Place each kind of information in one of four layers and say, in a sentence, who could be hurt if it were exposed.
- Spot where one kind of information lives in more than one place, or is seen by more people than its purpose needs.
- Ask a partner, kindly, "who could be hurt if this left the room?" and answer the same question about your own community without naming a person.
- Run the lab for a small group, holding the four promises.
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
World English Bible
Therefore whatever you desire for men to do to you, you shall also do to them; for this is the law and the prophets." — Matthew 7:12
WEB
The aim of the lab is to practise being the trustworthy person of this proverb. Keeping a secret begins with knowing what secrets there are to keep.
Each column of the map asks one question from the side of the person whose information it is. Would I want it held like this, if it were mine?
1. The map sheet
Take a sheet of paper and rule it into six columns. Write these headings across the top, in pencil.
- Kind of information. A category, such as "membership register", "visiting notes", "children's allergy list", "photographs", "online attendance".
- Who holds it. A role, not a name: "the secretary", "the pastor", "the youth leader", "any volunteer".
- Where it lives. Choose from: paper drawer or cabinet, notebook, shared computer, phone, messaging group, cloud storage service, memory, other.
- Who can see it. Roles again. Count honestly: everyone who could open the drawer, the file or the group, not only those who do.
- Layer. Open, internal, restricted or specially sensitive (Lecture 1-3).
- Who could be hurt, and how? One short sentence. For example: "a woman who has left a violent home: she could be found."
Leave a seventh column, Worry, for any item that makes you uneasy as you write it. You will not have to explain it to anyone.
A few notes on filling it in. Write one row for each kind, not for each record. If a kind lives in two places (a paper register and a copy on a phone), write two rows or put both in the "where" column. If you do not know who can see something, write "don't know". That is a useful answer, and often the most important one. When you cannot decide on a layer, put it one layer higher.
2. Way one: the observer's way
Use this way if you want to practise on a case, with nothing of your own on the table. Read the description below, and fill in a map sheet for it.
(An invented case.) The parish in the case is small and sits in a market town. About eighty people come on a Sunday. It has one pastor, Father Tomas, a part-time secretary, Ruth, a treasurer, Daniel, and a youth leader, Imre, who is a volunteer. Ruth keeps the register of members, baptisms and marriages in a large book in the parish office and also in a spreadsheet on the office computer, which she lets Imre use for printing the youth rota. The office has a door that is often open. Father Tomas keeps short notes of visits in a small notebook that he carries, and he sometimes types longer notes on his phone so that he does not forget. Daniel keeps the giving envelopes in a drawer in his house and enters the totals, by name, in a spreadsheet he sends to Father Tomas by email. Imre has a messaging group for the young people and their parents. In it he has put the allergy and medical details that parents gave him on a form, so that other helpers can see them on trips. The group also has a photograph from the last camp, with the faces of eleven children, and the group has twenty-six members, some of whom Imre has never met. Every Sunday the bulletin carries a list of those in hospital and those who are grieving. Recently, a family from another country joined the parish. They gave their details to Ruth, and one of the parents has said that their papers are not yet settled. Ruth wrote this beside the family's name in the spreadsheet "so we remember to be kind". The parish also keeps a prayer book in which anyone may write a request, and the book is left open on a table by the door.
Fill in the map. Then answer three questions on the back. Which row would you worry about first, and why? Which rows are in the wrong layer, in your judgement? Which one change, made this week and costing nothing, would reduce harm most?
There is no single right answer. Some readers will worry first about the note beside the family's name; some about the allergy details in the group; some about the open prayer book. Compare with another person if you can. Notice that your worries differ, and listen to why.
3. Way two: the partner's way
Use this way if you have one or two other people, and want to practise the question that matters most. The roles are:
- The mapper. Describes, in general terms, one kind of information their community might hold, and fills in the row. They may use the observer's case above if they would rather not talk about their own.
- The asker. For each row, asks one question and only one: "Who could be hurt if this left the room?" The asker does not advise, correct or approve. The asker may ask a follow-up of the form "how badly?" or "could it be undone?".
- The listener (if there are three). Watches the time and, at the end, says one thing they noticed. The listener does not comment on the answers.
Take about five minutes for each of three rows. Then change roles. At the end, each person writes, alone, one sentence: "The row where the answer surprised me was ___ because ___."
The partner's way works because the question, asked by someone else, is harder to wave away than the same question asked of yourself. It is also a small rehearsal of the habit the course wants: asking "who could be hurt?" before deciding what to do with information.
4. Way three: the own-community way
Use this way when you want to map your own community. Use categories and structures only. Never write a real name, an entry from a real record, an account name, an address, a phone number or a password. If you find yourself writing one, stop and replace it with a category.
For example, instead of "Maria's husband's illness", write "health information about a member's family". Instead of the name of a messaging group, write "a messaging group for the young people". Instead of the person who holds the key, write "the secretary".
Proceed in this order.
- List the kinds of information your community holds, using the lists in Lecture 1-3 as a prompt. Aim for ten to fifteen rows. Do not try to be complete.
- For each, fill in who holds it, where it lives and who can see it. Where you do not know, write "don't know". Plan to find out from the right person, by asking in general terms.
- Give each a layer. When in doubt, go one higher.
- In the last column, write one sentence on who could be hurt. Include at least one row where the answer is a person who is weak or at risk in your community, described as a category ("a newcomer", "a child", "a person who is ill", "someone who has left a difficult home").
- Mark with a star the three rows you would look at first. Put a different mark by any row where one person holds everything.
- Fold the sheet and keep it. It is yours. You are not asked to show it to anyone, and nobody in this course will see it.
When you finish, write one sentence at the bottom: "The first thing I will ask about is ___." That is all the lab asks. Chapter 2 starts from there.
5. A leader's note
If you are running this lab for a small group (four to twelve people), here is one way to do it. The leader needs only paper, pencils and a clock. Allow about ninety minutes.
Opening (10 minutes). Say what the lab is and what it is not. Read the four promises aloud. Say again that no one will be asked to bring or reveal a real list, record, note or password, and that you will not ask anyone to say what is on their sheet.
Observer's way (25 minutes). Everyone fills in the sheet for the invented parish alone for fifteen minutes, then speaks to the person beside them for ten. Take no report from each pair. Ask the room one question: "What did you notice about who can see things?"
Partner's way (25 minutes). Pairs or threes. Keep to the time. Move around, but do not listen closely to a pair. If a pair is stuck, give them the invented parish and let them work on that.
Own-community way (20 minutes). Quiet individual work. Remind people to use categories. Walk round only to remind of the rule about names.
Closing (10 minutes). Ask one question to the whole group: "Was there a row where you thought, we had no idea?" Take a few answers, only of categories. Then ask each person, silently, to write the sentence "The first thing I will ask about is ___." Thank them.
How to hold the room. Keep a calm voice. Treat every answer as useful. If someone is troubled by what they have seen on their own sheet, thank them and say that this is what the lab is for, and that Chapter 2 gives them steps. Do not allow comparing of communities or boasting about the size of one's own. If a discussion turns into criticism of a named person or church, stop it gently: "Let's keep to kinds of information, not to people."
What to do when someone shares something private. It will happen: someone will say a name, or tell the story of a person in their church. Do not let it go on. Say kindly, "Thank you, I am going to stop you there, because we promised not to share real names or stories. You may say what kind of case it is." If a person says something that suggests that someone is in danger now, or that a child is being harmed, do not go on with the lab. Speak to the person privately at the break, and follow the rule that safety comes before confidentiality: involve the responsible leader of your community, a trained professional and, if someone is in immediate danger, your local emergency number. If someone is plainly upset, let them leave and check on them afterwards.
The leader writes too. The leader fills in a sheet in the quiet times and says so at the start. The leader does not share it.
6. The four promises
Say these aloud at the start. They hold for every way of doing the lab.
- Nobody reads your sheet. It is yours. It is not collected, photographed or marked.
- Nothing is marked. There is no right map and no score. A row marked "don't know" is a good row.
- You may pass. At any point you may stop, skip a step or say nothing, and no one will ask why.
- The leader writes too. The person who runs the lab fills in a sheet like everyone else, and keeps it to themselves.
7. What to do afterwards
Keep your map somewhere private, perhaps with your own notes. Look at it once a week for a month. Look especially at the starred rows. At the end of Chapter 2 you will have tools for deciding what to collect and what to let go. At the end of Chapter 3 you will have more for the rows closest to people's pain.
If you want to take a step before then, choose the smallest one that costs nothing: decide that a name will not go in the bulletin without a yes, or ask who can open the cabinet. A small change made kindly is worth more than a plan.
Diagram 1. The information map sheet
In short
- An information map lists kinds of information, who holds each, where it lives, who can see it, its layer, and who could be hurt.
- Use roles and categories only. Never bring or write a real name, entry, account or password.
- "Don't know" is a useful answer, often the most important one. When unsure of a layer, choose the higher one.
- Asking a partner "who could be hurt if this left the room?" is harder to wave away than asking yourself.
- The four promises hold the room: nobody reads your sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Topic | An information map: kinds, holders, places, viewers, layers and who could be hurt, drawn by hand in a lab. |
| Remember | Use categories only. Write "don't know" where you do not know. When unsure of a layer, choose the higher one. |
| Caution | Never bring a real list, record, note or password. If someone in danger is mentioned, stop the lab and follow the rule that safety comes first. |
| One line to carry into ministry | The first thing I will ask about is the row where I wrote "don't know". |
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which row of your map, or of the invented parish's map, surprised you most, and why?
- Where did you write "don't know"? Whom could you ask, in general terms and without breaking a confidence, to find out?
- In the partner's way, was it harder to ask the question or to answer it? What did the asking teach you?
- Which of the four promises matters most to you in a group like this, and what would be lost without it?
- What is the smallest change you could make this week, at no cost, that would reduce the risk to the person you named in your last column?