FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry

Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority

Contents 31
PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Held in Trust
  1. Introduction: Held in Trust
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Words
  1. Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
  3. Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
  4. Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Collecting, Keeping, Using, Letting Go
  1. Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
  2. Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
  3. Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
  4. Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Notes, Prayer Requests and People at Risk
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
  2. Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Digital Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
  2. Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
  3. Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
Chapter 5 · Week 5: When It Goes Wrong, and When Hands Change
  1. Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
  4. Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Policy and Culture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Writing a Plain Policy
  2. Lecture 6-2: Teaching and Culture: Making It Ordinary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
  4. Lecture 6-4: Known and Kept: A Theology of Being Held
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My Rule and Our One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

32 min

Lecture 2-1 taught a church to ask for less and to say why. This lecture asks what happens after the question is put. A person says "yes", or signs, or ticks a box. Does that mean they agreed?

In most areas of life, a person who is asked for something can say no, and the asker has no power to make them regret it. In a church that is not always true. The person asking for a date of birth may also be the person who decides whether a child is baptised, whether a couple is married in the church, whether a family receives help with rent, or whether someone is welcome to serve. When that person asks, a refusal can feel like disloyalty, or like a risk. A "yes" given under that feeling is worth less than it looks.

This lecture is about the difference between a form that has been signed and a person who has agreed. Its piece of the chapter's principle is that information is used only for the reason it was given, and a reason that was never truly understood or freely accepted is a weak foundation. The lecture is not legal advice. Whether a particular form must contain a particular sentence, and what counts as valid agreement in law, differs from place to place; ask a qualified person where you serve. What follows is the pastoral side: what it takes for a member's "yes" to be real.

What these 32 minutes give you

  • List the marks of real consent: told what for, free to refuse, able to withdraw, understandable and not bundled.
  • Explain why a request from a pastor, elder, teacher or decision-maker makes free refusal harder.
  • Describe practical ways to make "no" costless when the asker holds authority.
  • Identify groups of people who cannot easily say no, and adjust the way you ask them.
  • Write a plain consent sentence that names a specific purpose, a specific circle and a way to withdraw.

But let your ‘Yes’ be ‘Yes’ and your ‘No’ be ‘No.’ Whatever is more than these is of the evil one." — Matthew 5:37

World English Bible

Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29

WEB

Love doesn’t harm a neighbor. Love therefore is the fulfillment of the law." — Romans 13:10

WEB

Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:2-3

WEB

Jesus speaks of a "yes" that means yes and a "no" that means no. The sentence was spoken about oaths, and we use it here by extension: a church's forms are healthiest when a "no" can be said plainly and a "yes" is not squeezed out of someone. Paul's word about speech that builds up gives the standard for the way a request is worded. Romans 13:10 gives the measure: a request is wrong if answering it harms the neighbour. Peter speaks to elders about the way they hold authority: not by compulsion, and not by lording it over those entrusted to them. A request put to a member by someone who holds power over them is a place where that teaching is tested.

When we ask a person for information, we hope for more than a signature. We want the person to have decided. Consent is the way a person remains the owner of what they entrust: they decide what is handed over, for what, and to whom. The church is the keeper, and a keeper who takes without the owner's real agreement has taken something that was not given.

It follows that a consent which is not real is worse than no form at all, because it makes the church feel covered while leaving the person unprotected. A pastor who says "everyone signed" may be describing a room in which nobody felt able to refuse.

Five marks are worth carrying in your head. They are not a legal test. They are a pastoral test, and they are useful because each can be checked by asking a plain question.

Told what for. The person knows the purpose, the circle who will see it, and roughly how long it will be held. "We need this for church records" does not say what for. "We will give this to the three people who organise the harvest supper, so they can phone you about it, and we will remove it after the supper" does.

Free to refuse. A refusal has no cost. The person will not be treated as less loyal, less welcome or less eligible. If the form is required for something the person needs (a camp place, a service) and the information really is needed for it, say so openly: "We cannot register a child without a contact number." That is honest. What is dishonest is to pretend that a field is optional when it is not, or to make it feel compulsory when it is.

Able to withdraw. The person can change their mind later, and knows how. A withdrawal does not undo what has already properly happened, but from then on the church stops. The person should know whom to tell, and should not have to explain.

Understandable. The wording fits the reader. A long page in legal language, or in a language the person reads with difficulty, is not an explanation. Many people in a church read English as a second or third language, or read slowly, or not at all. Where that is so, say it aloud as well, or in the person's own language, or give them a short version.

Not bundled. One signature should not cover several different things. If a single line says "I agree that my details may be used for the directory, the newsletter, the fundraising appeal and sharing with other churches", the person must accept all or none. Separate purposes need separate questions, each of which can be answered alone.

A useful check is to read your own form and ask of each of the five marks: could a person who disagreed with us find a way to say so, without fuss, on this page?

3. Why authority bends the answer

The reasons that make it hard to refuse a pastor are not mysterious. A member may fear that a refusal will be read as distrust, or that it will cost them a favour later. Some members were taught that questioning a leader is a kind of disrespect. Some belong to a small community in which everyone knows who did not tick the box. Some depend on the church for friendship, for a place to live, or for help with money. Where a person's standing is held by the one who asks, "freely given" becomes a delicate phrase.

None of this requires the pastor to be a bad person. A kind and trusted pastor can create exactly this pressure, because the trust itself makes refusing feel like a betrayal of someone who has been good to you. The pressure can also come from someone other than the pastor: a youth leader who decides who goes on the trip, a volunteer coordinator, a treasurer who decides who receives help, a teacher who prepares candidates for baptism or confirmation. The test is not the title of the asker but whether the person asked depends on that asker for something.

Peter's instruction to elders is therefore practical. An who is not "lording it over" those entrusted to him will arrange the asking so that a member does not have to be brave in order to refuse.

4. Making "no" cheap

There are ways to arrange a request that lower the cost of refusal. None is perfect, and a small church will have to adapt them.

  • Separate the asker from the decider. Where possible, the person who asks for consent is not the one who decides about membership, baptism, marriage or aid. A church-office volunteer can hold the form while the pastor never learns who ticked what.
  • Give time. A form handed over after a service and "signed now, please" is not the same as a form taken home. Say that the person may think about it and return it later, or never.
  • Ask in writing and in person. Some people refuse more easily on paper; others in conversation. Offer both where you can.
  • Make the short route the main one. If a person says no to an optional field, nothing further is asked. The form is accepted without it. Nobody follows up with "are you sure?".
  • Keep refusals unremarkable. Do not make a list of those who declined, and do not mention it to others. A refusal is recorded only so that you respect it.
  • Offer the smaller circle. Instead of a flat yes or no, offer a choice: "Your name may appear in the printed directory / only to the small group / not at all." Many people will accept a narrower use who would refuse a broad one.
  • Say aloud that no is welcome. A sentence from the leader costs nothing: "Please say no to anything here you would rather not share. Nothing about your place here depends on it."

5. People who cannot easily say no

Some people are in a position where refusing is harder than usual, and the church should lower the cost further for them rather than assuming that their signature settles the matter.

  • The sick and the frail. A person in a hospital bed, or recovering at home, may agree to what is put in front of them because they are tired or want the visitor to be pleased.
  • The grieving. A family that has just lost someone will sign nearly anything the minister brings. Funeral arrangements are not the time to ask about general consent for future use.
  • Those who depend on the church. People receiving food, rent help or other aid may feel that refusing could end the help. Information collected as part of aid should be strictly what the aid needs, and the aid should never be made to depend on agreeing to something unrelated, such as permission to appear in the newsletter.
  • Recent migrants and newcomers. A person who does not know the local rules, may not read the language well, and may come from a place where a refusal to an authority was dangerous, cannot be assumed to be speaking freely. A document that asks about status, family abroad or past religion is an especially serious request (Lecture 3-4).
  • The lonely and the isolated. A person with few friends may give anything to keep the one place where they are known.
  • Those in a dispute or under discipline. A person facing a decision by the church is rarely free to refuse the people who will make it.

For these groups, the habits in the previous section matter more: more time, someone other than the decider asking, a smaller circle offered, and a gentle reminder that no is permitted. Often the best course is to ask for less. If a piece of information is not really needed, do not collect it from a person who cannot easily refuse.

6. Children and those who cannot decide alone

A child cannot give consent in the full sense. In most places a parent or guardian gives permission on the child's behalf, and the rules about at what age and for what a young person may decide alone differ from place to place. Learn the rule where you serve and, where there is doubt, ask a qualified person.

Two things are worth saying beyond the rule. First, a guardian's permission is not the same as the child's agreement. As a child grows, they have their own view of which photograph of them is displayed and which fact about them is shared. A church that asks the young person as well ("May we use this photograph of you?") teaches respect and often avoids hurt. Second, a guardian's permission must itself be real: the parent should be told what for, and be free to refuse, with no effect on the child's place in the group. Where the guardians disagree, or where the child's safety may be affected, take counsel from the responsible leader. Lecture 3-3 returns to children's records.

The same care applies to adults who cannot easily decide for themselves: a person with a serious illness, with a disability affecting understanding, or in confusion because of age. Who may agree on their behalf, if anyone, differs by place. Ask the person as far as they can answer, and involve the people who care for them.

"Do you agree that we may use your details for church purposes?" sounds harmless. It is very hard to keep, because "church purposes" has no boundary. A directory, a fundraising letter, a note to a denominational office, a message about a political meeting hosted by the church: each may be called a church purpose.

Specific consent names one use at a time. "Your phone number will be used to remind you of the youth group. It will not be shared with anyone outside the youth team." A person who agrees to this has agreed to something definite, and the church can be held to it, by the member and by its own conscience.

General consent is not always wrong. It can be honest where the purposes really are few and known, such as the membership register of a small church. But the more a general phrase is stretched, the more the person is surprised later. The pastoral test is this: would the person be surprised by this use? If so, the original agreement did not cover it, and a new, specific question is owed.

8. Two tendencies in the world

This section is about general tendencies, and it is hedged on purpose. Do not treat it as describing any particular country.

In some places the guiding idea of the rules about personal information leans on consent: a person's agreement is the main reason a body may hold and use their information. In other places the idea leans more on purpose and notice: a body may hold information for a stated, legitimate purpose, provided it tells the person plainly, collects no more than the purpose needs, and respects the limits of that purpose, whether or not the person has agreed in each case. Many systems mix the two. And in some places there are few rules, or rules that are not enforced, or rules that serve the state more than the person.

What does this mean for a church? Two things. First, you cannot tell from this course which of these describes your place; ask where you serve. Second, the pastoral duty does not depend on which one applies. In a consent-led place, a church should seek real consent for the reasons given in this lecture. In a purpose-and-notice place, the church still owes the person a clear statement of purpose and a respectful hearing if the person objects. Law is a floor, and love does not stop at the floor.

Consent has limits, and honest teaching says so.

First, some information a church needs in order to do what the person has asked. A parent who registers a child for camp must give a contact number. Here the better frame is not "do you consent?" but "we need this for this, and we will do only this." The honest sentence is a notice, not a request.

Second, some requests should not be made at all, however freely the person might answer. A pastor who asks a recent migrant to hand over documents "just for our records" is asking for something the church probably has no need for, and which may put the person at risk. No consent makes it wise. Here the answer is to collect less, as Lecture 2-1 taught.

Third, consent cannot fix a bad purpose. If a use would harm the person, the person's agreement does not make it right, and Romans 13:10 puts the measure in the harm done to the neighbour, not in the signature.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some traditions, especially those with membership, hold that joining the church means entering a life in which members are known to one another and to the elders, and that accountability is impossible if every item of personal knowledge needs separate permission. On this view, membership itself carries an understanding that elders may ask about a member's life, and the member agreed to this when joining. Others, including many that place great weight on the freedom of conscience, hold that a member's agreement to belong is not an agreement to be an open book, and that each use of information needs its own consent. Both views have strong arguments. The first protects a community's ability to correct and care for its members. The second protects the member from a community whose authority has grown beyond what any member intended. This course does not choose between them. It asks both to keep a common minimum: the member knows, before joining, what the community expects to know; anything beyond that is asked for specifically; and no one is made to feel that a refusal is a breach of loyalty.

A consent sentence is better short. A pattern that works in many settings has five parts:

  1. What we will hold.
  2. For what we will use it.
  3. Who will see it.
  4. Until when, in words tied to the purpose.
  5. How to say no or change your mind, and that nothing will be held against you.

For example:

"With your agreement, we will use your phone number to send you a reminder about the Sunday school. Only the Sunday school team will see it. We will remove it when your child leaves the class. You may say no now, or ask us at any time to stop, by telling the teacher or the church office. Nothing about your child's place in the class depends on your answer."

Notice what it avoids: no "church purposes", no number of years, no threat, no legal language. It says what a reader needs and tells them they are free.

11. A worked example

(An invented case.) Daniel is the youth leader of a small congregation. Before a weekend away, he hands each parent a form after the service and says, "Just sign here, so we can get going." The form has one signature line under the words: "I give permission for my child to take part, for photographs to be taken and used by the church in any way, and for medical details to be shared with helpers."

A parent, Esther, is new to the country and reads the language slowly. She signs because Daniel is waiting, because her son badly wants to go, and because she is unsure what else to do. Later she says to a friend that she did not understand the part about photographs and would have preferred to say no.

Reading the case against the five marks: she was not fully told (the wording was wide and quick); she was not clearly free (Daniel was waiting, and her son's place seemed to depend on her answer); the form could not be withdrawn because it did not say how; it was hard to understand for a slow reader; and it was bundled, with three separate purposes under one signature.

Nobody here meant harm. Daniel was in a hurry. Now see how he might revise it. He splits the form into three parts: permission to go, which is needed; the medical details, which are needed for the weekend and will be destroyed afterwards; and the photographs, which are optional, with separate choices for the printed newsletter, the private group, or none. He gives the form out a week earlier so it can be taken home, offers to go through it aloud in any language a helper can manage, and says plainly that the photograph section can be left empty. He asks a church-office volunteer, not himself, to collect the forms. Esther can now say no to the photographs and still send her son.

One more thing is worth saying. Esther's confidence in the church is part of the good that was at stake. A church that handles her question well will find that she asks it more freely next time.

12. Where this lecture stops

This lecture does not say what any law requires of a consent form, and does not give you wording that will satisfy a court or a regulator. If a form matters (for children, for health, for anything sent abroad), have someone qualified look at it. The aim here is the part that no lawyer can supply: a community in which a person may say no and still belong.


Is the "yes" real? Five marks, each checked by one plain question Told what for Does the person know the use, the readers and the end? Free to refuse Can they say no with no cost to their place here? Can withdraw Do they know whom to tell if they change their mind? Understandable Is it in words, and a language, this reader can follow? Not bundled Can they answer each purpose on its own? Harder when the asker decides about baptism, marriage, membership or help. Lower the cost of "no".

Diagram 2. Who asks, and how to lower the cost of refusing

Where the person stands What makes "no" hard A gentler way to ask
Waiting for baptism or marriage The asker decides the outcome A church-office volunteer collects; no questions beyond need
Receiving aid Help may seem to depend on the answer Aid never depends on unrelated permissions
Sick, grieving or tired Wants to please the visitor Ask later, ask little, offer to return the form
New to the country or language Does not know the rules; may fear refusing Say it aloud in their language; ask for less
A child or young person Cannot decide alone Guardian's permission, and the young person's own voice

In short

  • Consent is how a person stays the owner of what they entrust. A signature without real agreement protects no one.
  • Real consent is told what for, free to refuse, able to be withdrawn, understandable and not bundled.
  • A request from someone who decides about baptism, marriage, membership or help makes refusal feel disloyal, however kind the asker.
  • Lower the cost of "no": separate asker from decider, give time, offer a smaller circle, and say aloud that no is welcome.
  • Take extra care with the sick, grieving, dependent, newcomers and children. For children, ask the guardian and, as they grow, the child too.
  • Consent cannot fix a request that should not be made. A need is a notice, and a harmful use is not cured by a signature.
Front Back
Topic Consent when the asker holds authority: what makes a member's "yes" real.
Remember Five marks: told what for, free to refuse, able to withdraw, understandable, not bundled. A plain sentence says what, for what, who sees it, until when, and how to say no.
Caution Consent does not repair a request that should not be made. What counts as valid consent in law differs by place, so ask a qualified person where you serve.
One line to carry into ministry Make it easy for a person to say no, and then believe their yes.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a time you signed something because the person asking was waiting, or was someone you respected. What would have made it easier to say no?
  • Which of the five marks of real consent is weakest in your community's forms? Which would be easiest to repair this month?
  • Peter tells elders not to lord it over those entrusted to them. What is one concrete thing an elder could change in the way forms are handed out?
  • A leader says, "Membership means being known, so a separate permission for each thing would be unworkable." Another says, "Joining a church is not agreeing to be an open book." How would you state each view at its strongest, and what common minimum could both accept?
  • Where you serve, who might find it hard to refuse the church, and what would change if you asked them differently?
  • Write a consent sentence of your own for one use of one piece of information. Read it aloud. Does it sound like a request or like a command?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.