FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry

Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person

Contents 31
PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Held in Trust
  1. Introduction: Held in Trust
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Words
  1. Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
  3. Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
  4. Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Collecting, Keeping, Using, Letting Go
  1. Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
  2. Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
  3. Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
  4. Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Notes, Prayer Requests and People at Risk
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
  2. Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Digital Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
  2. Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
  3. Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
Chapter 5 · Week 5: When It Goes Wrong, and When Hands Change
  1. Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
  4. Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Policy and Culture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Writing a Plain Policy
  2. Lecture 6-2: Teaching and Culture: Making It Ordinary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
  4. Lecture 6-4: Known and Kept: A Theology of Being Held
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My Rule and Our One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

Few things are more natural in a church than saying, "Please pray for her." It is the way a community carries its own. A person in the hospital, a family in trouble, a young man looking for work: the church prays, and the praying is a good thing. Nothing in this lecture is meant to make it smaller.

But anyone who has served in a church for a while has also seen the other thing. A request begins, "Please pray for Marta, who is..." and what follows is her illness, her husband's behaviour, her son's arrest or her debt. The request is sincere. It is also a story about a person, told by someone else, to as many people as are in the room, the group chat or the bulletin. A prayer request is one of the most common ways a community passes on a person's private life, and one of the least noticed, because everyone in the chain means well.

This lecture is about the circle around a person. It asks whose story a prayer request is, who may decide how far it travels, and how a community can pray together without telling more than the person agreed to be told. It also looks at what happens to requests once they are in print, in a chat or on a recording.

This lecture is not legal advice. It does not describe any country's law, and it does not teach a theology of intercessory prayer. It teaches how to carry another person's trouble in words without dropping it.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Explain how a prayer request can become gossip even when everyone intends good.
  • Ask a person what may be shared, with whom, where and until when.
  • Place a request on a ladder of circles, from the person alone to the whole congregation, and choose the smallest circle that serves the purpose.
  • Rewrite a specific request into general language that still lets people pray.
  • Say what to do when the person cannot speak for themselves.

Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the assembly, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord, and the prayer of faith will heal him who is sick, and the Lord will raise him up. If he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective. — James 5:14-16

World English Bible

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ. — Galatians 6:2

WEB

But you, when you pray, enter into your inner room, and having shut your door, pray to your Father who is in secret, and your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly. — Matthew 6:6

WEB

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret. — Proverbs 11:13

WEB

Here the elders are called to the sick person, and the person does the : "Is any among you sick? Let him call." The movement of the passage begins with the sick person's own choice. It describes a small, close circle (the elders come to the person), and a confessing and praying together that is mutual. The verses are often used to defend open sharing, and they do defend a community that prays for one another. They do not say that a person's sickness is to be announced.

Bearing burdens is the purpose of every prayer request. A burden is carried by being known, at least a little. This is why a church cannot simply keep everything silent. But carrying is different from broadcasting: someone who helps carry a heavy load takes the weight, not a photograph of it.

Jesus speaks of prayer in the inner room, with the door shut, to a Father "who sees in secret." The verse is about the manner of the one who prays, not about intercession for others, and it must not be stretched too far. But it reminds us that God does not need the details to be public in order to hear them. A prayer can name a person before God without naming them before the room.

The proverb sets "gossip" against "a trustworthy spirit." It is the shortest account of the dilemma in this lecture: the same words, said in the same tone, can be care or betrayal, depending on whose they were to say.

1. The Good of Praying Together

Let us begin by saying what is good here, since the rest of the lecture could make it sound as if every request were a risk.

A community that prays aloud for its members says something no other practice can say: you are not alone, and your trouble is ours. A woman who learns that dozens of people have prayed for her while she was in hospital is sustained by that, not embarrassed. A family who find meals on the doorstep after a death are carried by a church that knew. For many believers, to be prayed for by name is one of the great comforts of belonging.

There are traditions where this openness is central. In many Pentecostal and charismatic assemblies, the sick come forward and are prayed for in front of everyone, and the open sharing is part of the faith: nothing hidden, everything brought into the light and into God's hands. In many small groups and house churches, "prayer time" is the heart of the meeting, and what is told is told among people who know each other well. These are not careless practices. They come from a conviction that bearing burdens means being known.

Other traditions lean the other way. In liturgical churches the intercessions are often written in general terms ("for the sick of this parish," "for those in prison") and names are given only when a person has asked, for example by writing in a book. Some of this is for dignity. Some of it is a discipline of speaking of a person before God with respect for their privacy.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some believers hold that a congregation which asks a member to say nothing about their troubles has made the church a place where people suffer alone, and that the risk of being gossiped about is the price of being truly known. Others hold that a congregation that expects every trouble to be told has made the person's privacy a form of disloyalty, and that the strongest love is the love that asks first. Each side has seen real harm: one has seen people who suffered in silence because they thought no one would care; the other has seen people whose lives were spread across a room against their will. This lecture does not pick a winner. It asks that, whichever tradition you serve in, the person decides how far their own story goes, and that the congregation's habits make it easy for them to decide.

2. How a Request Becomes Gossip

The change is gentle. Consider how it happens.

(An invented case.) A woman in a small group, Dora, tells her friend Ana in confidence that her son has been arrested and she is ashamed. Ana is moved. That evening, in the group chat, she writes: "Please pray for Dora. Her son has been arrested, and she is very low." Ana is not a gossip. She loves Dora. She wants other people to help. But the story was not hers. Dora has not agreed to this circle. Seven people now know. By the next week it is in the wider congregation, shorter, less kind and not always accurate.

Three things are worth noticing.

First, the request was sincere. Prayer-as-gossip is rarely malice. It is love without a pause for permission.

Second, the circle widened without anyone deciding to widen it. Each person who knows tells one more, and a request that began as a whisper is now a rumour.

Third, the form helped. The phrase "please pray" makes it hard for anyone to say, "should this be shared at all?" To question a prayer request feels like questioning prayer. That social pressure is why prayer requests carry more private information than almost any other kind of church talk.

A useful honest question to put to oneself before passing on a request is: Would I be comfortable if the person were in the room, hearing me say this? If not, the question is not whether to pray, but how.

3. Whose Story Is It?

The principle of this week is that the closer information comes to a person's pain, the smaller the circle should be, and the more it should be the person's own choice. Applied to prayer, the principle says: the story belongs to the person it is about, even when it has been told to you. They told you; they did not give it to you.

There are several practical consequences.

  • Ask before sharing. The simplest practice, and the one most often skipped, is to say: "May I ask others to pray for this? And what may I say?" A person who is asked is respected. A person who is not asked may be wounded for years.
  • Ask what may be shared, with whom, where and until when. There are four parts to a good permission. What: the fact of the illness only, or the diagnosis too? With whom: the pastor, the prayer team, the small group, the congregation? Where: said aloud in the room, written in a bulletin, posted in a chat? Until when: for this week, or until the person says otherwise? A person who says "yes" to the first and has not been asked the last three has not really given a full permission.
  • The person may say no, and may change their mind. A request that was shared on Sunday can be withdrawn on Monday, and the community should be ready to stop. The community may not be able to unsay what has been heard, but it can stop saying it.
  • A told story is not a licence. If someone confides in you, that does not mean they have agreed to anyone else knowing. If they ask you to pray, ask whether you may also tell others to pray.

4. Permanence: The Bulletin, the Chat, the Board, the Recording

A spoken request in a room fades. The places where we now put requests do not.

  • A printed bulletin is carried home, left on a bus, picked up by a neighbour, kept in a drawer.
  • A group chat keeps its history. People who join later can read all of it. A person who leaves the group may still have the messages. A message can be forwarded or captured and shown to people who were never in the group.
  • An online prayer board may be open to anyone who finds it, and a request on it can be found long after the person has recovered, moved or died.
  • A recording or livestream of a service in which a request was read aloud keeps it, and in the form of the voice, with the name.

Each of these converts a moment of prayer into a record. A record does not know that the illness has passed, that the family has since reconciled or that the person would now prefer silence. This is the same lesson as the one about notes: what is written lasts, and what lasts can be used by people we never meant. The practical rule is that the more permanent and the more public the place, the more general the words should be, and the more certain the permission.

Where a church publishes any prayer list at all, it is good to give it a plain rule: requests are listed only with the person's permission; they come off after a stated time unless renewed; and anyone may ask for a request to be removed. The rule is for the whole community; it should be said aloud sometimes, not only written.

5. A Ladder of Circles

It helps to think of the circles around a person as a ladder, from the smallest to the widest. For each request, the question is: what is the lowest rung that serves the purpose?

  1. The person alone. Sometimes the right thing is to pray privately and say nothing. A minister who prays for a member in the quiet of the morning has not broken any trust.
  2. The pastor or priest. The person tells one trusted leader, who prays and who may visit. For many troubles this is enough, and the person feels safe.
  3. A small prayer team under a promise. A few chosen people who have agreed, in words, to hold what they hear and not repeat it. The promise matters; a team without one is only a group of friends.
  4. A small group, without names. "A member of our group is facing a very hard decision about their work. Please pray." The group prays with the person's permission but without the identifying details.
  5. The whole congregation, in general terms. "We pray for the sick of this parish," or, with consent, a name and nothing more: "We pray for Marta, who is in hospital."

The ladder is not a rule of how far to go; it is a rule of where to stop. Many requests belong on the first three rungs. Some belong on the fourth. A few, with consent, belong on the last. The ladder also shows something else: the higher the rung, the more people who can retell the story, and the less the person can control it.

6. Requests Where the Stakes Differ

Here are several kinds of request, each with an invented case and a note on how to handle it.

Illness. (An invented case.) Joseph, an older man, is told that his illness is serious. He wants his family and his pastor to know, and no one else. A rule of thumb is that illness belongs to the person: the fact that someone is in hospital is often shared in the congregation with permission; the name of the illness usually is not, unless the person says so. Some people want everyone to know. Some do not. Ask.

Family trouble. (An invented case.) A woman asks for prayer about her marriage. The temptation is to say, in the group, "Pray for the Okafor marriage." A woman's marriage is not hers alone; her husband also lives in it, and he has not agreed to be discussed. The kind form is general: "Please pray for a married couple in our group who are facing a difficult time." Better still, ask her what she wants said.

Unemployment and money. (An invented case.) A young man has lost his job and is anxious. Shame about work and money is strong in many communities. A request for prayer for "those out of work" lets people pray for him without singling him out. If he wants practical help, he can ask for it, or someone can offer privately.

Imprisonment. (An invented case.) A member's brother has been arrested. The member did nothing wrong, and the brother has not been tried. The details of a charge are the brother's, and a rumour about a charge can follow a family for years. "Pray for a family going through a hard time with the courts" may be as far as the congregation needs to go.

Addiction. (An invented case.) A man tells his pastor he is struggling with drink and asks for prayer. This is among the most painful things a person can say, and it is exactly the kind of fact that can be used against a person. Pray privately; invite the person to say what they want; if a small team is formed, make it a small team under a promise. A public request, even a kind one, is not for the pastor to start.

Abuse. (An invented case.) A woman tells a friend that her husband hits her, and asks the friend to pray. Here the situation changes: this is no longer only a prayer matter. A person may be in danger. A request for prayer is not an answer to violence. The friend should urge the woman to speak to a responsible leader, who should involve a trained professional, and where there is danger to life, the local emergency number. Safety comes before confidentiality, and above all before a prayer chain. Do not put anything about it in a group chat: a message there can be seen by the very person who is the danger. The next lectures return to this.

7. The Kindness of General Language

General language is not evasion. It is a form of love that makes room for prayer without making room for gossip.

"We pray for those who are ill." "We remember those facing hard decisions." "We hold in prayer the families who are grieving." These sentences let a congregation pray for people they do not know, and they let the person who is in the room hear that they are included, without being named.

A good habit is to teach the congregation a sentence to say when they want to share a need: "May I ask others to pray? What may I say?" Another is to give the leader of the prayer time a short script: "If you wish to be named, tell me before the service. If not, we will pray in general words, and God knows who you are." Many people, once offered this, are relieved.

General language does not mean the community knows nothing. People who need help should also be able to say so, and a community should have a way for someone to say "I need help" without being exposed to everyone. A quiet card, a word to a , a private line to the pastor: these are all good. The aim is not silence but a choice.

8. When the Person Cannot Speak for Themselves

Sometimes the person cannot say what may be shared: a person unconscious in a hospital, a person with severe illness, a young child, a person with a condition that affects their understanding, a person who has died. What then?

The first rule is: do the least that serves the need. If a family must be told, tell the family. If a community must pray, general words may be enough. If someone must make a decision, the person closest to them, the person they trusted to speak for them, or the family, should be asked, and their answer treated as an answer on the person's behalf, and not as a licence to say everything.

The second rule is: ask yourself what the person would have wanted, based on what you know of them. A man who was always private is not honoured by a public announcement of his illness, even if his family now wants one. If there is a disagreement, the person's own earlier word, if there is one, weighs more than ours.

The third rule is: go gently with the dead. A funeral or memorial often involves names and stories. The person has no further say. The community may hold back what would shame a person's memory or hurt the living. A later lecture takes this up.

9. Praying for Others Anonymously

Last, a gift the church already has. A person who wishes to be prayed for, but not known, can write the need on a card without a name, or ask the leader to pray without naming the person. Some churches keep a prayer box or book for this. Some communities pray for a stated list of needs without names: "for a person in grief, for a person who is afraid, for a family in debt." Anonymous prayer is a reminder that God does not need names to know us, and that a community can be tender without being nosy.

A note on the minister's own prayers. A minister who prays aloud in a service must watch the words. It is easy to preach or pray at someone: "Lord, help those among us who have been unfaithful to their spouses." Everybody looks at somebody. A public prayer should not be a public judgment. Examples teach this better than rules; this lecture ends there, with the reminder that the room is full of people, and the prayer should be one they could all say Amen to without looking around.


Diagram 1. The Ladder of Circles

A ladder of circles around a person Choose the lowest rung that serves the purpose; the higher the rung, the less the person controls the story 1. The person alone You pray privately and say nothing 2. The pastor or priest One trusted leader prays and may visit 3. A small prayer team under a promise A few chosen people who agreed in words to hold it 4. A small group, without names "A member of our group faces a hard decision" 5. The congregation, in general terms More people can retell it Fewer people can retell it Before each step up, ask What? With whom? Where? Until when? Has the person agreed to each of these? If a person may be in danger, involve a responsible leader and your local emergency number.

In short

  • A prayer request is a story about a person told by someone else, and it is one of the commonest ways a church passes on private life.
  • The story belongs to the person it is about. Ask what may be shared, with whom, where and until when.
  • The more permanent and public the place (bulletin, chat, board, recording), the more general the words and the clearer the permission should be.
  • Use the lowest rung of the ladder that serves the purpose: the person, the pastor, a promised team, a small group without names, the congregation in general terms.
  • General language lets a community pray without exposing anyone; a person who cannot speak is served by the least that meets the need.
  • Where someone may be in danger, a prayer request is not enough: safety comes first.
Front Back
Topic Prayer requests and the circle around a person: how a request becomes gossip and how to ask first.
Remember Ask what may be shared, with whom, where and until when; choose the lowest rung of the ladder that serves the purpose.
Caution Bulletins, chats, boards and recordings keep a request long after the need has passed; a prayer request is no answer to danger.
One line to carry into ministry Before you say "please pray for her," ask her what you may say.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Recall a time when you heard something about a person in the form of a prayer request. Looking back, did the person know the request was being made? What would you have wanted to be asked?
  • Some communities share prayer needs openly, believing that people are meant to be known; others pray in general terms. What does each position protect, and what does each risk?
  • A friend tells you something painful and says, "Please pray for me." Write the sentences you would use to find out whether you may tell anyone else.
  • A church puts its weekly prayer list on a website where anyone may read it. Which of the cases in this lecture would worry you most, and what rule would you suggest?
  • A man is unconscious in hospital and his family wants his illness announced from the pulpit. He was always a private man. What would you say to the family, and to the congregation?
  • Why is it harder to question a prayer request than to question other kinds of news about a person?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.