FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry

Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs

Contents 31
PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Held in Trust
  1. Introduction: Held in Trust
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Words
  1. Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
  3. Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
  4. Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Collecting, Keeping, Using, Letting Go
  1. Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
  2. Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
  3. Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
  4. Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Notes, Prayer Requests and People at Risk
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
  2. Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Digital Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
  2. Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
  3. Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
Chapter 5 · Week 5: When It Goes Wrong, and When Hands Change
  1. Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
  4. Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Policy and Culture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Writing a Plain Policy
  2. Lecture 6-2: Teaching and Culture: Making It Ordinary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
  4. Lecture 6-4: Known and Kept: A Theology of Being Held
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My Rule and Our One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

A church used to keep its information in a few places: a register, a filing cabinet, a notebook in the pastor's coat. Today it also keeps information in places that no one decided on. The choir has a group chat. The youth leader posts from a camp. Sunday worship is streamed and recorded. A camera watches the door of the hall. After the harvest festival forty photographs sit in three people's phones. None of these was planned as a record, and each of them is one.

The claim of this course is that what people entrust to a church is theirs and the church is its keeper. A face in a photograph, a phone number in a chat, a name in a livestream's comment box are all things entrusted, even though nobody wrote them on a form. This lecture is about the practical side: where these things are stored, who can reach them, and how they are deleted. The larger questions, such as whether a photograph of a child should be taken at all, belong to other courses, one on communications and one on safeguarding, and are touched here only in a sentence. This lecture is not legal advice, and rules about cameras, recordings and children's images differ greatly from place to place; learn the rule where you serve and follow your community's written rules.

Everything here is defence. We ask how to protect the people who are in the picture, not how to get at a picture that is not ours.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Describe what a group chat reveals to its members, and who in the group has what power.
  • Ask permission before posting a member's image or name, and offer a way to have it taken down afterwards.
  • Name the questions that govern a livestream, a recording and a camera on the premises.
  • Decide where event photographs are stored, who holds the originals, and how they are labelled and deleted.
  • Write a short notice or rule for a group chat that members can understand.

Even so, let your light shine before men; that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father who is in heaven. — Matthew 5:16

World English Bible

Be careful that you don’t do your charitable giving before men, to be seen by them, or else you have no reward from your Father who is in heaven. — Matthew 6:1

WEB

Therefore when you do merciful deeds, don’t sound a trumpet before yourself, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may get glory from men. Most certainly I tell you, they have received their reward. — Matthew 6:2

WEB

But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, — Matthew 6:3

WEB

so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly. — Matthew 6:4

WEB

Therefore putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor. For we are members of one another. — Ephesians 4:25

WEB

The verse is the strongest reason a church might have for making its life visible: the good works of a community are meant to be seen, and a congregation that hides everything has misread it. Notice what is to be seen, though: works, and the glory goes to the Father. A person's face and private trouble are not the works.

The two passages sit side by side in one sermon and they pull in different directions. Together they give a test of motive: is a picture shown to help others see God's work, or to make the church look good? A photograph of someone receiving help is a good example. The person helped did not agree to be the advertisement for the helper's mercy.

The last clause is the reason for care. Members of one another are not each other's property. Truthfulness includes saying honestly what will be done with a person's image, and what will not.

1. Group chats: who sees whom

A messaging group seems like a small room. It is not quite a room. A few things that are easy to forget:

Everyone can see everyone's number. In many messaging apps, joining a group shows your phone number to all the members, including people you have never met. A woman who joined the prayer group for comfort may not wish a man she barely knows to hold her number. A person who has moved to escape someone may not wish the number to be known at all. Before you add a person, tell them who is in the group and what will be visible, and let them decline. Where the tool allows, use a setting that hides numbers, or use a different kind of group, such as a broadcast list where members receive messages but do not see one another.

Someone is the administrator, and the administrator has power. The person who set the group up often decides who may add people, who may remove them, who may post, and sometimes can read everything that was ever posted. Ask three questions of every group: Who is the admin? Is there a second admin who can take over? Who is allowed to add new people? A group where anyone may add anyone becomes a group with members nobody chose, and the earlier conversation is often open to the newcomer to read. A group with one admin who then leaves the church may carry the group, with all its history, out of the church's hands.

People who left still have the history. When a member leaves the group, what they saw stays on their phone. Sometimes they can still read what was sent before they left. If a sensitive matter was discussed, the number of people who hold it is the number of everyone who was ever in the group. So decide before the group starts what it is for. A group for sending the rota for tea and flowers can be relaxed. A group for the elders is not the place to put a name and a health detail.

Forwarding. A message can be passed on in a second. What you write in a group may arrive in a group you have never heard of, without your words being changed, and without the context in which you wrote them. Write in a group as you would write on a noticeboard in the hall. Ask people not to forward, knowing that the request cannot be enforced; it is a courtesy, and it sets a culture.

One purpose per group. Prayer requests, practical notices, the youth announcements and the elders' business are four different circles, and mixing them gathers more people around a sensitive matter than it needs. Chapter 3 of this course set out a ladder of circles for prayer requests; the point here is that a group chat is a circle, and it should be the circle that fits.

A short group rule, posted at the top, can do much. A good one is plain: This group is for [one purpose]. Please do not share what is written here outside the group. Please do not add anyone without asking the admin. If you want to leave, you may, and no one will ask why. If you need to say something private, write to a leader directly. It is better to say this kindly at the start than to correct someone later in front of the others.

2. Posting people on social media

A church that posts on a public page is speaking in a public square. What is posted can be copied by anyone, and may be hard to remove even after the original is taken down.

Two habits matter more than any setting.

The first is ask before. A person whose image or name will appear should be asked, in a way that makes refusing easy. Parents or guardians should be asked for children, and the child should be heard as he or she grows. The rules about who may agree for a child differ from place to place. The asking should be specific: we would like to post photographs from the youth weekend on the church's public page; may we include your daughter? is better than a general sentence on a membership card that says "photographs may be used". A person who is dependent on the church, who is receiving help, or who has recently arrived, cannot refuse easily; their silence is not consent. Think especially about members who have reasons to be hard to find: someone who has left a violent home, someone whose family does not know they attend, someone whose status in the country is uncertain. Chapter 3's lecture on when exposure can endanger returns to this. A church may not know who they are, and so the safest default for the church's public posts is to show no identifiable face of a child or a vulnerable person unless a specific, recorded permission exists.

The second habit is a way to ask for removal afterwards. Say in the same place where you ask for permission: if you change your mind, tell this person, and we will take it down. Then do it promptly and without asking for a reason. A removal that takes months teaches people not to ask. Remember that "taking it down" means from every place the church put it: the page, the newsletter file, the folder of originals and the archived chat. It cannot reach copies that other people have already made, and it is honest to say so.

Names are as sensitive as faces. A caption that says "Anna, who has just joined us after leaving her family's faith" tells a reader much more than the face does. Captions say what the photograph is, not what the person's story is.

3. Livestreams and recordings

When a service is streamed or recorded, three groups of people are in the frame: those at the front, those in the pews, and those at home who join through a screen. Each is entitled to some thought.

Who is in frame? Decide where the camera points. A camera trained on the choir and the pulpit sees the people who have agreed to serve in public. A camera that sweeps the congregation sees people who came to worship, not to appear. Some communities choose a fixed view that never shows the pews. Some place a notice at the door and a section of seats outside the view. A person should be able to take part in worship without being broadcast.

Chat and attendance. Online services often show a chat, and a list of people who have joined, with names and sometimes email addresses. These are records. Who can see them? Is the chat saved? When someone writes a prayer need in the chat for the whole world to read, who may remove it? A host should be able to hide a message quickly, and should do so without embarrassing the writer, then write to them privately. A watch-party list, saved forever, is a list of people who attended worship, which in some places is itself sensitive.

How long do recordings stay? A recording kept forever may be seen years later by someone who no longer attends, in a context nobody imagined. Decide, in words, how long a recording will be kept, and who is responsible for removing it. The decision is in words like "until the next season" or "while it serves the people who could not attend", not numbers, since the right length depends on the community and the local rules. Make the decision before the first recording is made.

Who owns the originals? The recording is on a device or service belonging to someone. If it is a volunteer's own phone or a private account, the church does not control it. Say at the start where the originals are kept, and that they are not kept anywhere else.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some traditions hold that worship is public by its nature: the doors are open, strangers may come in, and putting the service on a screen only widens the doorway. For them a recording is witness, and a church that hides the has misread its to be seen. Other traditions, including many Catholic and Orthodox parishes, and many house churches, hold that worship is the action of a gathered assembly before God, that some parts of it are not made for the camera, and that a person must be free to pray without wondering who is watching; some of these keep the camera away from the most solemn parts or do not record at all. Others are concerned about the gathering's safety. A church under pressure from authorities, or from a hostile family or neighbourhood, may reasonably decide that no recording is made. Each of these views has real strength. What the course asks of all is the same: decide knowingly, tell the people present what is done, and let the person who does not wish to be filmed sit where the camera does not look.

4. Cameras on the premises

A camera at the door, the car park or the children's room watches people who did not come to be watched. Before one is installed, ask a few questions and write the answers down.

What is it for? A camera for protecting the building after hours is a different thing from a camera in a children's room. A reason such as "we might need it someday" is the same trap as in Chapter 2.

Are people told? A sign at the door, in plain words, tells people that a camera is there and what for. Cameras hidden from the people they watch are a breach of trust, and in many places a breach of rules besides.

Who may view the footage, and in what circumstances? A short list of named people, and a note of when it is viewed, is better than a screen that anyone at the office can glance at. Footage is a record of who came, when and with whom.

How long is it kept? Footage that is kept longer than the reason for it is a record of the comings and goings of the whole congregation. Decide, in words, that it is overwritten or deleted when the reason for keeping it has passed, and follow the local rule if there is one.

Where does it go? A camera that sends footage to a service outside the church puts that footage in someone else's hands. The next lecture asks the questions to put to any such service.

5. Event photographs as records

Photographs from a baptism, a wedding, a camp or a funeral are records, as much as a register. Treat them so.

Where are they stored? After an event, copies are on the phones of the volunteers who took them. Pick one place that the church controls, and ask people to move their photographs there and then delete their own copies, as far as they can. A photograph that sits for years on an old phone may be seen by anyone who borrows it.

Who has the originals? One person should be responsible. If that person leaves, the originals should not leave with them. This is the same handover question as in the following lecture.

How are they labelled? A folder called "Youth camp, summer" says little. A folder labelled with full names of every child and where they live says too much. Label by event and date; keep any list of who was there in a separate, restricted place, not in the folder name or the file names.

When are they deleted? Pick the photographs worth keeping: those that show the life of the church, in a way that the people in them would not mind being seen decades from now. Delete the rest on a schedule, in words: "after the album is made", "at the end of the year". Photographs of a funeral are held with particular care. People weep in them and did not choose to be seen.

A way to ask. The person who asks for a photograph to be removed from an album should find it easy to ask, and should be answered kindly.

6. A worked example

An invented case. (An invented case.) A parish youth group goes on a weekend retreat. Marta, the leader, takes forty photographs. She posts eight on the parish's public page with the caption "Our young people at the retreat, with their names". Among those named is Tomas, fifteen. Tomas's mother had asked, quietly, a month before, that her son's picture not be put online, because of a difficult situation in the family. Marta did not know. She had never asked, because the general consent line on the registration form says "photographs may be used".

When the mother sees the page, she writes to Marta. Marta's first response is to take the photographs down at once. Her second is to go to the parish priest and tell him plainly what happened. Together they check where else the pictures went: the group chat, where two parents had saved them, the newsletter file, the folder on Marta's own laptop. They write to the mother, apologise without excuse, say what has been taken down and what cannot be, and ask what else she would like done. Then they change the practice: the next retreat will have a specific permission for each child, a "no faces of children on the public page" default, and a named person responsible for the photograph folder.

Marta did not act wickedly. Her habits were common ones. What she did next is what the course wants: quick honesty, care for the person affected first, and a change in practice. The later chapter on incidents treats that order of events in full.

Diagram 1. Where a photograph goes after an event

The life of an event photograph Four questions: where, who, labelled how, until when Many phones Copies sit on private devices nobody tracks. Where are they? One church place One named person holds the originals. Phones are cleared after. Labels Event and date only. Who was there is kept in a separate list. Keep or let go Choose the few, delete the rest by a stated rule. Before the photograph goes anywhere public Was this person asked, specifically, and was it easy to refuse? For a child: the guardian, and the child's own voice. Does the caption tell a story the person did not agree to tell? Names are as sensitive as faces. Could someone in the picture be harmed by being found? Default: no identifiable child or vulnerable person. Is there a named person and an easy way to ask for removal, and will it be done promptly and kindly? Removal reaches only what the church holds; say so honestly.

In short

  • Group chats, posts, streams, cameras and photographs are records, even if nobody planned them as such. The questions are where they are kept, who can reach them and how they end.
  • Know who administers a chat, who can add people, and who still holds the history after leaving. Give each group one purpose and a short rule.
  • Ask before posting a person's image or name. Make refusal easy, and make removal afterwards simple and prompt.
  • For streams, recordings and cameras, decide who is in frame, who sees the data, and how long it is kept, in words, before starting.
  • Keep event photographs in one church-controlled place with a named holder, labelled by event, with a stated rule for what is kept.
Front Back
Topic The storage, access and deletion of what group chats, social posts, streams, cameras and photographs hold about people.
Remember Know the admin, give each group one purpose, ask before posting, make removal easy, and keep photographs in one place with a named holder.
Caution A member's number, face or caption can reveal a story they did not choose to tell. Removal reaches only what the church holds.
One line to carry into ministry Let people be seen only as they agreed to be seen, and let them change their mind.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a group chat you belong to. Who can see your number, who can add people, and who would take it over if the administrator left?
  • How might a church tell the difference between a photograph that shows the works of mercy to the glory of God and one that displays the people helped? Who should decide?
  • Describe the strongest argument you know for broadcasting worship, and the strongest for not doing so. Which parts of your own tradition's worship would you wish to keep from the camera, and why?
  • A parent asks you to remove a child's photograph from an album. What do you do in the first hour, and what will you say you cannot do?
  • Why is "we might need the footage someday" the same mistake as "we might need this field on the form"? What would a better reason for a camera sound like?
  • Who in your community is responsible for the originals of event photographs? What would need to be written down so the answer does not depend on one person's memory?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.