Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
- Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
- Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
- Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
- Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
- Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
- Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
- Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
- Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
- Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
- Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
- Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
- Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
- Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
- Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
- Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
- Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
- Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
This course has said, again and again, that it does not teach the law of any country. It is written for readers in many places, and rules about records, privacy, children, reporting and religious bodies differ widely and change over time. A course that quoted one country's rules would mislead most of its readers and would be out of date within a few years.
But every reader serves somewhere, under some rules, written or unwritten, friendly or hostile. A minister who says "the law is different everywhere" and stops there has not finished the thought. The next sentence has to be: so here is how I find out what applies to me, and what I do with the answer. This lecture teaches that sentence. It gives the categories of rules to ask about, the people to ask, the way to read what they tell you, and the habit of writing down what you asked and what you were told.
It also deals with a harder question: what a church should do when it believes the rules ask too little, or too much, or the wrong thing. That is a place where Christians, and whole traditions, differ. This lecture sets out the positions fairly and teaches a way of deciding that does not depend on which you hold.
This lecture is not legal advice and does not replace anyone who can give it.
What these 31 minutes give you
- List the categories of rules that a community should ask about, without needing to know what the rules are.
- Name the kinds of people and bodies you can ask, and say what to take them.
- Read an answer as a floor, not a ceiling, and explain what that means in practice.
- Describe general tendencies in how places treat consent, notice, clergy communications and reporting, marking them as general.
- State the main positions on whether a church should hold a higher standard than the law, and keep a written note of a decision.
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God. Therefore he who resists the authority, withstands the ordinance of God; and those who withstand will receive to themselves judgment. For rulers are not a terror to the good work, but to the evil. Do you desire to have no fear of the authority? Do that which is good, and you will have praise from the same, for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil. Therefore you need to be in subjection, not only because of the wrath, but also for conscience’ sake. For this reason you also pay taxes, for they are servants of God’s service, attending continually on this very thing. Give therefore to everyone what you owe: taxes to whom taxes are due; customs to whom customs; respect to whom respect; honor to whom honor. — Romans 13:1-7
World English Bible
But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men. — Acts 5:29
WEB
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established. — Proverbs 15:22
WEB
Paul writes to believers in a city whose authorities were not Christian. He asks for subjection to the authorities, gives a reason (they serve God for the good of the community), and lists ordinary duties such as paying what is owed. This is the basis of the widespread Christian instinct to learn the local rules and follow them where they are not against conscience. Readers differ on how far the passage reaches and how it is balanced with other texts, as the next reading shows.
When the authorities forbade the apostles to teach in the name of Jesus, Peter and the others said that they must obey God rather than men. The verse sets a limit on obedience, and many traditions hold the two passages together. They also warn that "we must obey God" is a sentence to say after counsel and prayer, with the cost counted, and not a quick answer to a rule that is merely inconvenient.
Plans fail without counsel. A minister who is unsure what the rules require does not guess, and does not rely on the memory of a friend of a friend. The wise step is to ask more than one qualified person.
1. The problem: rules you cannot see
Most ministers learn the rules that apply to them by accident. A letter arrives from an authority. A member's family asks a question no one can answer. A neighbouring church faces a problem and tells its story. By then a decision has often already been made, without the knowledge it needed.
Part of the difficulty is that "the rules" are not one thing. They include formal rules from the state (written, enforced, sometimes severe), rules of your church body or association (a bishop's office, a synod, a union of churches, a network), the terms of the places and services you use (the landlord, the bank, the services that hold your information), the rules of the people who fund you, and the unwritten expectations of your community. They may agree with one another. They may pull in different directions.
The first step is to know that you do not know, and to decide to find out. The second step is to find out in an orderly way.
2. The categories to ask about
You do not need to understand the answers in detail. You need to know which questions to put. Here are ten categories. For each, the question is, "Is there a rule where we serve, and what does it ask of us?"
Records and how long. Are there kinds of record that you must keep, and for how long (for example, financial, employment, sacramental or membership records)? Are there kinds you must not keep beyond a point? Are there any you may not hold at all?
Consent and notice. What must you tell people when you collect their information? When do you need their agreement, and in what form? Are there special rules for sensitive categories such as health, belief or family circumstances? Is a church treated in the same way as other organisations, or differently?
Children and young people. At what age may a young person agree to things for themselves? When is a parent's or guardian's agreement needed? Are there rules about photographing, recording, or holding information about minors, and about who may work with them?
Reporting suspected harm. Is there a rule that you must report, or may report, suspected abuse or serious danger? Who must report (every adult, certain roles, those who work with children)? What must be reported, to whom, and how quickly? Does the rule reach what is learned in pastoral conversation?
Telling people when information is lost. If a record is lost or taken, must you tell the people affected, an authority, or both? In what time, and in what form? Is there a size or kind of loss below which you need not?
Clergy communications and legal protection. Does the legal system recognise any protection for what is said to a minister in confidence or in confession or counselling? Whom does it cover, in what circumstances, and what are its limits? Can you be required to testify or to hand over records?
Cameras and recording. What are the rules on cameras on the premises, on recording services and live streaming, on notices to those present, and on who may view and how long a recording may be kept?
Fundraising and giving records. What must you record about gifts? Is there a requirement to issue receipts, to report to an authority, or to keep donors' details private or public? Are there rules about how gift information may be used?
Employment and volunteer records. What are the rules on information about staff and volunteers: screening, references, personnel files, and the right of those people to see what is held about them?
Church registration and denominational rules. Is your community registered, and does registration carry duties about records, accounts or reporting? Does your church body have its own rules on records, safeguarding, confession or the disclosure of information, and do they bind you?
Some readers will find that for several of these the honest answer is "no rule that I know of", and some will find that the question itself is dangerous to ask, because to ask may attract attention. That is addressed in a later section.
3. Where to ask
There is no one right person, and a good answer often comes from two.
Your church body or association, if you have one. Many have staff who answer exactly this kind of question, and they know the position of churches in your tradition and place. Their advice also carries the weight of your own church's order.
A lawyer with experience of charities, religious bodies or non-profit organisations. Many offer a first conversation at low cost or free, and some are members of the community of faith and will help with little or no fee. Ask for someone who understands how churches work, not only the general law.
A competent authority. In some places there is a public office that advises or regulates bodies of your kind, or one that deals with the protection of personal information. Writing to ask general questions is usually safe and often welcome. In places where contact with an official body would be unwise for the church or its members, skip this step and rely on trusted private advice.
A trusted colleague in another church, preferably one with a similar size and setting and some years of experience. This is not a substitute for a qualified person, but it is a good way to find out what questions to ask and what has gone wrong elsewhere.
When you ask, take your one-page policy, a list of the categories above that matter to you, and a short, concrete description of what you do. Ask what the rule is, what it asks of you in practice, what the consequence of not following it is, and what you should do first.
4. How to read the answer: a floor, not a ceiling
When you are told what the rule requires, you have learned the least that is asked of you. A rule is written for everyone, with an eye on the worst case, and it has to be something that can be enforced. It says what must not be done or must be done. It does not say what love requires.
A few consequences follow.
Following the rule is the minimum, and not yet the answer. A rule may allow you to publish a name that love would keep private. A rule may not require you to tell members of a loss of data in a case where honesty says that you should. The next paragraphs deal with what to do about that, but the first discipline is to know the floor and not to fall below it.
Rules change. What was permitted may be forbidden next year. Add the date and the source to your note, and set a time to ask again.
Rules may conflict. The rule of the state, the rule of your church body and the commitment of your own community may not agree. When they do not, do not choose silently. Take the conflict to the leader who is responsible, and, where it is serious, back to your qualified adviser.
An unclear answer is still an answer. "Nobody can tell you for certain" is a real finding. Write it down, take the careful path, and ask again.
A rule you do not understand is not yet a rule you can follow. If you cannot say in a sentence what you must do, ask again, in simpler words, until you can.
5. General tendencies in the world
In general terms, and with the warning that every place differs and that these are tendencies and not descriptions of any one country, you may meet the following.
On consent. Some systems build their rules around a person's agreement: you may use someone's information because they said you could. Others build their rules around purpose and notice: you may use it for the stated purpose, with a lawful reason and with notice to the person, and agreement is only one of several possible reasons. A church can be caught between the two, because a community tends to speak of "consent" in a pastoral sense (the member is glad to be asked) that may or may not be what a rule means by the word.
On clergy communications. In some places, what a person says to a minister in confession or pastoral counselling is protected by the legal system, and the minister may refuse to disclose it; the protection may reach only some traditions, some kinds of conversation or some kinds of minister. In others there is no such protection, or it is limited, and a minister may be required to speak or to hand over records. Some traditions also hold a sacramental seal of confession that does not depend on the legal position at all. Do not assume that a protection exists where you serve, and do not assume that it does not. Ask.
On reporting. Rules about reporting suspected harm to children or other vulnerable people differ in who must report (everyone, or only certain roles), what must be reported (a suspicion, or only knowledge), to whom, and whether clergy are covered, or exempted for certain conversations. In some places there is no formal rule, and a community has to rely on its own policy and on conscience. The safest assumption for a church is that where a child may be in danger, safety comes before confidentiality and the responsible leader and the proper authority should be involved, and that you must learn the local rule before the day you need it.
On records. Some places require certain records to be kept for a stated period; some require certain records to be destroyed; some require both for different records. Churches that hold sacramental or historical registers may find that a church-body rule and a state rule treat them differently.
On safety. In some places it is not safe to keep certain lists at all, such as a list of members, of converts or of those who have asked for help. There the first question is not "what must we keep?" but "what must we not hold?" See the lecture on exposure that endangers. Where holding information could put people in danger, the church's duty to the people held may be best served by holding less, and by asking trusted advisers, outside the reach of those who would misuse the list, what to do.
None of these is a rule. Each is only a reason to ask the question in your own place.
6. Should a church hold itself to more than the law?
This is a point where readers will not agree.
Two questions are bound together here, and it helps to pull them apart.
Should a church hold itself to a higher standard than the rules require? One answer says yes. A church claims to be a community of love and truth, and the rule written for all organisations describes only the least that can be enforced. A church that does only what is required is a church that has accepted the world's measure of care. On this view, where a rule allows something that would hurt a person, the church should refuse to do it, and the law should be treated as a floor on which the church builds. The reasoning has a strong root in the way that many traditions speak of conscience and of the duty to go beyond what is merely required.
Another answer says that the church should do what the rules require, honestly and fully, and should be wary of inventing standards of its own. Its reasons are not careless. A church that sets itself a stricter rule than the rest of the world can make promises it cannot keep, can burden volunteers who have no training, can create duties that become traps in a dispute, and can slip into a pride that looks down on the ordinary rule. On this view, the discipline of following a clear, shared, checkable standard is itself a form of humility, and extra standards should be added only where the community can really carry them.
Both views can be held with integrity, and many communities land somewhere between them: following the rule, and adding a few specific commitments that they have counted the cost of, such as "we ask before we publish a photograph" or "we tell people when we have lost their information, even if no rule requires us to".
Do a state's rules apply to the life of the church at all? This second question is older. Some traditions hold that the church has an internal life, including the confession of sins, the discipline of members, the sacraments, and the choosing and care of ministers, which belongs to Christ's rule and not to the state's, and that the state should not enter it. They point to the long history in which churches were required by authorities to hand over their members or their teaching, and to Acts 5:29. Other traditions hold that a church is a body of people living in a place, under the same rules as every other body, and that the protection of persons, especially children, is exactly where the church should not claim exemption; they point to the failures of communities that appealed to their own order when they should have protected a child. Others hold something between: the church is subject to rules about the protection of persons and property, and free in what concerns worship, teaching and the care of souls.
The course does not settle this. It asks of every reader two things. First, that you know which position your community holds, and that your community has said so in writing, so that the position is not invented in a crisis. Second, that whatever the position, you do not use it as a reason to leave a person in danger or to avoid a duty to a person who was hurt. A claim of church autonomy that costs a child safety is not a claim the course can support.
7. Deciding, and writing it down
Whenever you ask about a rule, and whenever the community makes a decision about how it relates to a rule, keep a short note. It need not be long. It should say:
- the date;
- the question you asked, in a sentence;
- whom you asked, and what their role is;
- what they said, in your words, and whether they put it in writing;
- what the community decided to do, and who decided;
- when you will ask again.
(An invented case.) A congregation in a mid-sized town wanted to begin live-streaming its Sunday service. The administrator, Ruth, wrote a note after speaking to the office of the church body. "Asked whether we need to tell people we are recording. The office said that in their experience a notice at the door and a spoken sentence at the start are expected, but that they could not give legal advice and suggested we ask a local lawyer for charities. Spoke to the lawyer: confirmed notice at the door; said children's images need the permission of a parent. Decided with the elders: sign at the door, a sentence at the start, a seat away from the camera, no close shots of children without written permission. Will ask again at the annual review." A year later, when a family asked why their daughter's face was not on the recording, the answer was in a file, with a date.
The note protects the community in a dispute, and it helps the next leader. It also shows the habit this lecture has been teaching: that the response to "the rules differ" is neither to ignore the question nor to pretend to be a lawyer. It is to ask, to write, to decide together and to ask again.
8. When asking is itself a risk
In some places, asking an official body about how to handle a list of members, or about the church's records, may draw attention to a church that depends on being unnoticed. In some places the rules are used as a means of pressure, and compliance means handing over what the church most needs to protect. There the order of questions changes. Ask your church body, or a trusted adviser outside the reach of the local authorities, first. Hold less, not more. Do not create records whose existence would endanger people. Take counsel with elders about what is to be done if the community is asked to give up a list it has chosen not to keep. And remember that the reading from Acts has a context: it was said by people who counted the cost, took counsel and stood together. It is not a sentence for a lone volunteer to act on.
Diagram 1. Ten kinds of rule to ask about
Diagram 2. From a question to a written note
In short
- No course can teach the rules where you serve. A minister's duty is to find out: ask a church body, a qualified lawyer, a competent authority or a trusted colleague, and ask more than one.
- Ten categories cover most of what to ask: records, consent and notice, children, reporting harm, loss of data, clergy communications, cameras, gifts, staff and volunteers, and registration or church-body rules.
- An answer is a floor. A rule says the least that is asked; love may ask more, and rules change and may conflict.
- Traditions differ on whether a church should hold itself above the law's standard and whether the state's rules reach the church's inner life. Safety of a person is never given up by either view.
- Keep a short written note of what you asked, whom, what they said, what was decided, and when you will ask again.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Topic | Finding out which rules apply where you serve, and deciding how to relate your community to them. |
| Remember | Ask more than one qualified person across ten categories, treat the answer as a floor, and write down the question, answer and decision. |
| Caution | Do not assume a legal protection exists or does not exist, and where asking is dangerous, hold less and ask someone outside the reach of those who would misuse the list. |
| One line to carry into ministry | Learn the floor, then decide what love asks above it, and write it down. |
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Of the ten categories of rule, which do you know least about for the place where you serve? Whom would you ask first, and what would you take with you?
- Think of a time when a rule allowed something that you felt would be unloving. What did you do, and what would you do now?
- Give the strongest reason for holding a church to a higher standard than the rules require, and the strongest reason for not doing so. Where does your community stand?
- Some traditions claim that a church's inner life is beyond the state's reach; others say that the protection of persons is exactly where no church should claim exemption. Where does your tradition stand, and what do the others see that yours may miss?
- In your place, could asking an official body about your records put anyone at risk? If so, who is the trusted person outside it whom you could ask?
- Draft the first lines of a note recording what you asked about one category of rule, as the invented case did.