Lecture 3-2: Community, Ancestors and Ubuntu
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Every Theology Has an Address
- Lecture 1-2: Ways of Making Theology Local
- Lecture 1-3: Between Translation and Syncretism
- Lecture 1-4: Voices of the Younger Churches and the Older Ones
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I Do Theology From
- Lecture 2-1: Doing Theology in Asia
- Lecture 2-2: Pain, the People and the Poor
- Lecture 2-3: Among Other Religions: Thinking with Neighbours
- Lecture 2-4: Korea, Japan, China, the Philippines: Local Roads
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbours and My Theology
- Lecture 3-1: Doing Theology in Africa
- Lecture 3-2: Community, Ancestors and Ubuntu
- Lecture 3-3: Spirits, Healing and the African Independent Churches
- Lecture 3-4: Reconciliation, Women's Voices and the Public Square
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Community and My Theology
- Lecture 4-1: Doing Theology in Latin America
- Lecture 4-2: Liberation Theology
- Lecture 4-3: Popular Catholic Piety, Pentecostals and Evangelicals
- Lecture 4-4: Other Voices: Women, Indigenous and Afro-Latin American Theologies
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Poverty, Faith and My Theology
- Lecture 5-1: Reading the Bible from Many Places
- Lecture 5-2: Worship in the World Church
- Lecture 5-3: Authority and the Shape of the Community
- Lecture 5-4: The Holy Spirit, Healing and Gifts across the World Church
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Voices I Have Not Heard
- Lecture 6-1: In Conversation with Western Theology
- Lecture 6-2: What Northern Churches Can Learn from the South, and the South from the North
- Lecture 6-3: Where Voices Differ: A Map of the Disagreements
- Lecture 6-4: One Body, Many Places: Putting the Course Together
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Theology and the World Church on One Page
Many African theologians begin with a question that Western theology has often asked last: who is a person? On one common African answer, a person is not first a separate individual who then joins a group. A person becomes a person through other persons: through a family, a village, the living, the dead and those not yet born. The word often used for this idea in southern Africa is ubuntu. This lecture asks what that idea means, how it has been used in theology, and where it has been questioned.
The lecture then turns to a harder subject, the ancestors. In many African societies, the dead are not gone. They are still members of the family, honoured and remembered, and in some traditions asked for help. What can a Christian theology say about this? Catholic and Orthodox Christians have the communion of saints. Many Protestants are wary of any prayer that turns toward the dead. Some African theologians have proposed that Christ may be understood as an ancestor in an African way, and others have criticised the proposal. We set out these positions as their holders would set them out. The lecture does not decide between them.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Explain in your own words the idea that a person becomes a person through other persons, and say where the word *ubuntu* comes from.
- Describe how Desmond Tutu used the idea, saying only what the lecture states.
- State how Catholic and Orthodox thought about the communion of saints, and Protestant concerns about the dead, bear on the question of the ancestors.
- Describe the proposal that Christ may be understood as an ancestor, and give one strength and one criticism of it.
- Explain that African theologians disagree with each other on this subject, and that the community-centred view has also been criticised, including by women.
Therefore let us also, seeing we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, lay aside every weight and the sin which so easily entangles us, and let us run with patience the race that is set before us," — Hebrews 12:1
World English Bible
They continued steadfastly in the apostles’ teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and prayer." — Acts 2:42
WEB
Fear came on every soul, and many wonders and signs were done through the apostles." — Acts 2:43
WEB
All who believed were together, and had all things in common." — Acts 2:44
WEB
They sold their possessions and goods, and distributed them to all, according as anyone had need." — Acts 2:45
WEB
Day by day, continuing steadfastly with one accord in the temple, and breaking bread at home, they took their food with gladness and singleness of heart," — Acts 2:46
WEB
praising God, and having favor with all the people. The Lord added to the assembly day by day those who were being saved." — Acts 2:47
WEB
For as the body is one, and has many members, and all the members of the body, being many, are one body; so also is Christ." — 1 Corinthians 12:12
WEB
For the body is not one member, but many." — 1 Corinthians 12:14
WEB
When one member suffers, all the members suffer with it. Or when one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it." — 1 Corinthians 12:26
WEB
Now you are the body of Christ, and members individually." — 1 Corinthians 12:27
WEB
For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus," — 1 Timothy 2:5
WEB
What the text says. Hebrews 12:1 speaks of a "cloud of witnesses" around the readers; the chapter before it names people of faith from earlier times. Acts 2 describes the first believers living closely together: teaching, fellowship, bread, prayer, and sharing what they had. In 1 Corinthians 12 Paul says that the church is one body with many members, and that when one suffers all suffer. First Timothy 2:5 says that there is one mediator between God and human beings.
A tradition's reading. Many African Christians read Acts 2 and 1 Corinthians 12 as close to the shape of their own communities, where a person's joy and grief belong to the whole. Catholic and Orthodox Christians read the "cloud of witnesses" with the : those who have died in Christ are alive to God and are united with the church on earth. Many Protestants read Hebrews 12:1 as an encouragement by example, not as a call to address the dead, and they hold 1 Timothy 2:5 as the reason that no one else stands between a believer and God.
Our judgement. None of these verses settles the question of the ancestors. Hebrews 12:1 does not tell us whether the dead can hear us. First Timothy 2:5 does not say whether asking another believer, living or dead, to pray is a way of setting up a rival mediator or only a sharing in Christ's one mediation. We should keep the text, the readings and our own conclusion apart.
1. A person through other persons
In several languages of southern Africa the same saying is heard in a short form. In the Nguni languages, such as Zulu and Xhosa, it is umuntu ngumuntu ngabantu, which is often put into English as "a person is a person through other persons". The idea behind it is called ubuntu. The word is related to the word for "person" and means, roughly, the quality of being a person among persons: generosity, hospitality, belonging, shared responsibility. Similar ideas, with other words, are found in many other languages across the continent. We should not say that ubuntu is "what Africans believe". We can say that it is a widely known idea in some African societies, and that it has been used by some African theologians.
The idea contrasts with a picture often taken for granted in the modern West, in which the individual comes first and then decides which groups to join. On the African idea, you do not choose to be in a family; you are born into a net of relations, and you become a person by taking your place in it. A child learns to be a person by being greeted, fed, named, corrected and included. A person who is cut off from everyone is not free but diminished.
Desmond Tutu, an Anglican archbishop in South Africa, used the idea of ubuntu in his public speaking and in his writing, notably in his book No Future Without Forgiveness (1999). On his use, a person's humanity is bound up with the humanity of others, so that harm done to one diminishes everyone, including the one who does it, and healing must include both. We return to this in lecture 3-4.
Many African theologians have seen in this idea a close relation to the Christian view of the church as one body in which every member needs every other, and in which suffering and joy are shared. The reading of 1 Corinthians 12 given above shows why. Some say that Western theology had often forgotten this side of Scripture because it began with the individual's relation to God. Others reply that Scripture also calls each person by name, and that a community-centred view should not forget that a person stands alone before God. The best of the discussion holds both: a person is called by name, and the name is spoken in a family of faith.
2. Strengths and criticisms of the idea
The idea has real strengths. It makes hospitality a theological matter. It treats the elderly, the sick and the poor as persons who belong, not as problems. It gives a way to speak about sin as damage to a web of relations, and about salvation as being brought back into relation. It matches much in Acts 2 and 1 Corinthians 12.
It has also been criticised, and some of the sharpest criticism comes from Africa. First, critics have asked whether "ubuntu" is sometimes used as a slogan that hides real differences. A village is not always a place of harmony. Women, young people, those regarded as outsiders and those accused of witchcraft have sometimes been hurt by the community that was supposed to protect them. Oduyoye and other women theologians have said that African culture holds both life and harm for women, and that a theology of community must ask who is heard in it. Second, critics note that a community can press a person to conform, so that conscience is silenced. Third, some scholars point out that talk of "African communalism" can be romantic: African cities, with their migration and their poverty, show the strain on every community. Defenders of the idea reply that it does not claim that every community lives up to its ideal. It names a standard by which a community can be judged, in the way that the Christian ideal of the church is held up even when churches fail.
3. The ancestors
In many African societies, the death of a person does not end that person's place in the family. Elders who have died are remembered by name, are thought to watch over their descendants, and are honoured at certain times with words and gifts. In some societies they are asked to help or to bless. The practices vary a great deal from people to people. We cannot describe "the African view of the ancestors", and we do not try.
This raises an ordinary question for a Christian family. Here is a case (an invented example). A grandmother dies. At the funeral, the older relatives expect certain rites, and the church members ask whether they can take part. A young pastor does not know what to say. That is the question beneath the theology. It is a very practical one, and it is felt by people who love Christ and love their family.
The traditions of the world church answer it in different ways, and a student should know the main ones.
The communion of saints. Catholic and Orthodox Christians hold that those who have died in Christ are alive to God and that the church on earth and the church in heaven are one family. In these traditions, believers remember the departed in prayer, pray for the dead, and ask the saints to pray for them, as one asks a living friend to pray. Catholic teaching and Orthodox teaching differ in details, and each has careful distinctions, such as the difference between honour given to the saints and worship given to God alone. For these Christians, the African instinct that the dead are still in the family is not strange; it is close to what they already hold.
Protestant concerns. Many Protestants hold that Scripture does not teach praying to the dead, that it warns against consulting the dead, and that 1 Timothy 2:5 states a principle that rules out any other go-between. They worry that honouring ancestors can slide into fear of them, or into practices that belong to another religion. Many are also glad to remember the dead with love and to give thanks for them. Protestant traditions differ among themselves; some are warmer to the idea of remembering than others, and many African Protestants are grieved when church leaders treat all family rites as idolatry without listening.
African proposals. Some African theologians, mainly in the Catholic tradition, have proposed that the idea of the ancestor could help to say who Christ is. Charles Nyamiti, a priest from Tanzania, wrote about Christ as an ancestor. Bénézet Bujo, a priest from the Congo, wrote about Christ as an ancestor in the sense of the one from whom life and the moral order come. We give only the idea, and not the details. The proposal in outline is this: in many African societies, an ancestor is a person who has lived well, who is part of the family's life, and who is a source of blessing and a link between the living and God. Christ, on this proposal, can be seen as the one in whom the whole family of humankind has its life, and who is the model of every good ancestor. The proposal has been made as an attempt to say, in an African way, what the church has long said in other ways.
The criticisms are serious. First, an ancestor in most African societies is a member of a particular family or clan, linked by blood. Christ is not the founder of a clan. Critics ask whether the word will bend the message into something smaller, or will be misunderstood as saying Christ is one ancestor among others. Second, ancestors are usually thought to need honour and offerings, and to be able to punish, which is not how Scripture describes Christ. Third, some African theologians reply that Christ is the one mediator of 1 Timothy 2:5 and cannot be placed in any scheme with other mediators. Defenders reply that the proposal does not set Christ beside the ancestors but above them, as the one who fulfils what the ancestor figure points toward, in the way that the Letter to the Hebrews takes the figure of the high priest and shows how Christ fulfils and goes beyond it.
4. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is whether Christian theology may honour the ancestors, ask for their help or understand Christ in the language of ancestry.
One position says yes, to a measure. Its holders, among them many Catholic and Orthodox Christians and some African theologians in other traditions, say that the communion of saints already teaches that the dead in Christ are alive, belong to the church and may be remembered with love. They say that a theology that refuses any place for the ancestors leaves African families to choose between their church and their grandparents, and that the gospel should not require that choice. The strongest form of this view is that the Christian doctrine of the church already includes the dead. Its weak point is that "ancestor" is not the same as "saint": many ancestors were not Christians, the dead are not all with God in the same way, and the old practices may carry beliefs that Christian teaching does not hold. Those who hold the view must say which practices they are speaking of and how they differ.
Another position says no, or not in this form. Its holders, including many Protestant, evangelical and Pentecostal Christians, say that Scripture directs the believer to God through , that it warns against seeking the dead, and that a rite for the dead may open the door to powers that are not God. They say that Christians can honour their parents, remember the dead and keep family bonds without any ritual of address. The strongest form of this view is that the line must be kept clear for the sake of the gospel's uniqueness. Its weak point is that a flat refusal can leave grieving families without any way to honour their dead, and can place on a new believer a heavy cost in separation from kin. Those who hold the view must say what the church offers in place of the old rites.
A third group seeks a way between: keep the remembering, the funeral gatherings, the family meal and the giving of thanks, and leave out the invocation and the offerings. Others say that this middle way is too neat and that the line between "remember" and "invoke" is not always clear to those who grieve.
This course requires you to state each position fairly, to say what it protects and what it risks, and to see that all are held by people who love Christ. It does not require you to adopt one. If you must make a decision in a family or a congregation, ask your pastor or priest, and follow your community's own teaching and your own conscience, with respect for the others.
5. The community that does theology
One more point. African theologians have often noticed that theology is done in a community. A proverb is argued over by elders; a funeral is a theological event, with songs, sermons and silence; a church council may sit under a tree until agreement is reached. This way of working has its own risks, for it can silence a dissenter. But it also reminds a reader that theology is not a private thing. The community-centred view fits with the next lecture's subject. Where a person's life is bound up with others and with powers beyond human sight, illness and misfortune are not only a private matter. They are matters for the whole community and for prayer.
Diagram 1. A person through other persons
Diagram 2. The ancestors: four ways of speaking
In short
- Ubuntu names the idea that a person becomes a person through other persons; it is used by some African theologians and has been criticised.
- Tutu used the idea to say that harm to one diminishes all and that healing must include all.
- Catholic and Orthodox Christians hold the communion of saints; many Protestants are wary of address to the dead and hold one mediator.
- Some African theologians propose understanding Christ as ancestor; critics ask whether the word bends the message or sets up a rival.
- Readers disagree about honouring the ancestors; each side has a strength and a weak point, and both are held by Christians.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ubuntu | A person becomes a person through other persons; used by some theologians, and criticised where community hides harm. |
| Communion of saints | Catholic and Orthodox teaching that the dead in Christ are alive and one family with the church on earth. |
| Protestant concern | Scripture points to one mediator and warns against seeking the dead; many still remember the dead with love. |
| Christ as ancestor | An African proposal to say who Christ is; critics say clans differ from Christ, and it may set up a rival. |
One sentence to remember Africans disagree about the ancestors, and the way to hold the question is to state each position fairly.
This week's action Write two sentences stating the strongest case for the view on the ancestors that you do not hold.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what does it mean to say a person becomes a person through other persons? How does the idea resemble 1 Corinthians 12, and how does it differ?
- What are two strengths of the community-centred view, and what are two criticisms of it, including those made by women theologians?
- How do Catholic and Orthodox Christians, and many Protestants, read Hebrews 12:1 and 1 Timothy 2:5 differently?
- State the proposal that Christ is an ancestor, one strength of it and one criticism. Why might a thoughtful African theologian reject it?
- Where does this lecture say readers will not agree? State both positions in a form their holders would accept.