FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL10E World Christian Theology: Asia, Africa and Latin America

Lecture 4-2: Liberation Theology

Contents 31
STEL10E World Christian Theology: Asia, Africa and Latin America
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Read Theology from the Global South?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Read Theology from the Global South?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Theology Made Somewhere
  1. Lecture 1-1: Every Theology Has an Address
  2. Lecture 1-2: Ways of Making Theology Local
  3. Lecture 1-3: Between Translation and Syncretism
  4. Lecture 1-4: Voices of the Younger Churches and the Older Ones
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I Do Theology From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Asia
  1. Lecture 2-1: Doing Theology in Asia
  2. Lecture 2-2: Pain, the People and the Poor
  3. Lecture 2-3: Among Other Religions: Thinking with Neighbours
  4. Lecture 2-4: Korea, Japan, China, the Philippines: Local Roads
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbours and My Theology
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Africa
  1. Lecture 3-1: Doing Theology in Africa
  2. Lecture 3-2: Community, Ancestors and Ubuntu
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spirits, Healing and the African Independent Churches
  4. Lecture 3-4: Reconciliation, Women's Voices and the Public Square
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Community and My Theology
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Latin America
  1. Lecture 4-1: Doing Theology in Latin America
  2. Lecture 4-2: Liberation Theology
  3. Lecture 4-3: Popular Catholic Piety, Pentecostals and Evangelicals
  4. Lecture 4-4: Other Voices: Women, Indigenous and Afro-Latin American Theologies
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Poverty, Faith and My Theology
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Scripture, Worship and the Spirit
  1. Lecture 5-1: Reading the Bible from Many Places
  2. Lecture 5-2: Worship in the World Church
  3. Lecture 5-3: Authority and the Shape of the Community
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Holy Spirit, Healing and Gifts across the World Church
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Voices I Have Not Heard
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Learning from One Another
  1. Lecture 6-1: In Conversation with Western Theology
  2. Lecture 6-2: What Northern Churches Can Learn from the South, and the South from the North
  3. Lecture 6-3: Where Voices Differ: A Map of the Disagreements
  4. Lecture 6-4: One Body, Many Places: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Theology and the World Church on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Liberation theology is the name given to a family of theologies that grew in Latin America from the late 1960s. They have been praised and criticised more than almost any other theology in the world church. Some Christians see in them a recovery of what the Bible says about the poor. Some see in them a danger that the gospel is turned into a programme of politics. Some see both. Many people who have an opinion about liberation theology have read very little of it. This lecture tries to do the reading first.

We look at what the main theologians say in their own terms: the idea that theology is critical reflection on practice in the light of the word, the "preferential option for the poor", and the idea of structural sin. We meet several voices by name, but only as far as we are sure of them: Gustavo Gutierrez, Leonardo Boff, Jon Sobrino, the Protestant Jose Miguez Bonino, and the evangelical writers of "integral mission", Rene Padilla and Samuel Escobar. We then look at the criticisms: the two instructions of the Vatican in the 1980s, which both warned and affirmed, and the criticism that came from inside the movement. We give a place to a paragraph where readers will not agree.

The lecture gives no verdict on any government, party or political movement. Liberation theology has been linked with political events, and those events are a matter for history and for each reader's conscience. Here we ask only what the theologians argue and how others have answered.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Explain the idea that theology is "critical reflection on practice in the light of the word", and why it is called a second step.
  • Describe in plain words the preferential option for the poor and structural sin.
  • Name some Catholic, Protestant and evangelical voices and say, at a general level, what each contributed.
  • State the main concerns of the Vatican instructions of 1984 and 1986, including what each recognised as important.
  • State the strongest case and the weak point of two views about liberation theology, and name a criticism that came from inside the movement.

The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to heal the broken hearted, to proclaim release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, to deliver those who are crushed, and to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord.”" — Luke 4:18-19

World English Bible

I hate, I despise your feasts, and I can’t stand your solemn assemblies. Yes, though you offer me your burnt offerings and meal offerings, I will not accept them; neither will I regard the peace offerings of your fat animals. Take away from me the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps. But let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream." — Amos 5:21-24

WEB

What good is it, my brothers, if a man says he has faith, but has no works? Can faith save him? And if a brother or sister is naked and in lack of daily food, and one of you tells them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled”; and yet you didn’t give them the things the body needs, what good is it? Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead in itself." — James 2:14-17

WEB

What the text says. In Luke 4, Jesus reads a prophetic passage in the synagogue at Nazareth. It speaks of good news to the poor, release for captives, sight for the blind and freedom for the crushed. In Amos, God rejects worship that is not joined with justice. In James, faith without works is said to be dead, and the example is a brother or sister who lacks food and clothing. A tradition's or a place's reading. Liberation theologians have read these texts as showing that God's work includes freeing people from the powers that oppress them, and that the church's worship and faith must be joined to action for justice. Our judgement. Other readers agree that these texts call for justice and mercy, and still hold that "the poor" in Luke 4 can be read in more than one way, for instance as those who are materially poor, or as those who are humble before God, or as both. They hold that the "release" is first God's gift of forgiveness and new life. The disagreement is not about whether the texts speak to the poor. It is about how far, and in what way, they bear on social structures.

1. A second step: reflection on practice

Gustavo Gutierrez, a Peruvian priest, is the person most often named as the founder of . His book A Theology of Liberation appeared in Spanish in 1971 and in English a couple of years later. It is long, and it has often been summarised unfairly, so we mention only the ideas that readers agree he proposed.

One is a description of what theology is. Gutierrez said that theology is critical reflection on practice in the light of the word. Here practice means the actual life of Christians: prayer, worship and also work with the poor and for justice. Critical means that this practice is examined, not accepted as it is. The word means the word of God. So theology comes second. The first step is a life of faith and love in a place; the second step is to think about it, with Scripture and tradition as guides. This was not meant to replace the older understanding of theology as wisdom or as "faith seeking understanding", which Gutierrez also honoured. It added a question: where does the reflection begin, and whom does it serve?

Notice that this is a claim about method, not first of all about politics. A reader who disagrees with some of what liberation theologians conclude may still find that the method asks a good question of any theology: whom does my way of thinking serve? A reader who accepts the method may still ask whether practice can really sit in judgement on tradition, or whether the word must always remain the standard. Both questions are fair.

2. Liberation: three levels

Many liberation theologians speak of liberation at more than one level, and it matters to keep these apart. The first is social and economic: freedom from hunger, unjust structures and abuse. The second is personal and historical: the growth of a person or a people into their own dignity and responsibility. The third is liberation from sin: freedom through Christ from guilt and from the power of evil, which makes possible communion with God and with others. Gutierrez wrote that these are distinct levels that belong together, and that the third is the deepest. Critics have asked whether others who use the same words keep all three. This is one of the main points of the argument, and we return to it below.

3. The preferential option for the poor

The phrase preferential option for the poor was used by the bishops at Puebla in 1979 and has since been used widely, including by popes. It means that the church deliberately gives first attention to those who are most in need, because God does so in Scripture: the poor are those whom the law protects, whom the prophets defend and to whom Jesus announces good news. The word preferential does not say that God loves the poor and not the rich. It says that where the weak are crushed, love does not wait in the middle. The word option means a choice made by the church and by each believer.

Not everyone reads this in the same way. Some stress that it is an expression of the love that every Christian owes to every neighbour, and that it asks the church to choose a place of service. Some stress that the poor are not only the objects of charity, but people through whom God speaks, so that the church must also listen to them. Some ask whether the phrase could be heard to divide people into groups, and to suggest that class is the most important fact about a person. The theologians who use it generally reply that it does not say this, and they say that the preference is for the poor and excludes no one. The disagreement is about how the phrase works in practice, and we should say so.

4. Sin in structures

Another idea concerns structural sin. Traditionally, Christian teaching speaks of sin as an act, a habit, a disorder of the heart. Latin American bishops and theologians pointed out that sin also takes social forms: a law that favours the strong, a system of landholding in which the same few families hold everything, a way of doing business that harms workers. Structural here means built into the arrangements of a society. The theologians argued that to speak only of the sin of a single person leaves these forms in the dark, and that Christians must name them.

The idea was taken up in Catholic social teaching, with some care. Critics, then and now, have worried about two things. One is that structures cannot repent; only persons do, so naming "structural sin" may excuse individuals. The other is that if all evil is placed in structures, personal conversion may seem less important. Defenders reply that they do not say this: a structure is made by persons and kept up by persons, so the two belong together. Both the worry and the reply are in the literature, and a student should know both.

5. Several voices

Here are a few names, each with only what we can say with confidence. A person is more than a one-line summary, and no student should think after reading this that they know these writers.

Leonardo Boff is a Brazilian theologian who wrote widely on Christ, on the church and on the lives of the poor, and who drew attention to base communities as a form of church. He was at one time in discussion with Vatican authorities about his writings on the church. Jon Sobrino, a Jesuit who worked in El Salvador, wrote on Christ from the point of view of the poor, giving attention to the life of Jesus and to the cross as the place where God is with those who suffer. Some of his writing on Christ was the subject of a notification from the Vatican in the 2000s that asked whether it kept to the church's teaching on Christ's person; Sobrino and others replied that it did. Jose Miguez Bonino, an Argentine Methodist, wrote a book in the 1970s on doing theology in a time of social upheaval, one of the earliest Protestant contributions. He argued that Christians must think seriously about the social tools they use, and he did not simply accept every liberationist proposal.

There are also evangelical voices. Rene Padilla and Samuel Escobar, from Latin America, were among the people who pressed an international evangelical gathering in 1974 to say that social responsibility belongs to the mission of the church. They and others developed what is often called integral mission: the idea that proclaiming the gospel and serving the neighbour are not two jobs, one of which is more spiritual, but parts of one mission. They did not, in general, adopt the language of liberation theology, and they were at times critical of it; but they shared the concern that the church not turn from the poor. The existence of these voices shows that concern for the poor is not the property of one stream.

6. The two Vatican instructions

In 1984 and 1986 the Vatican's office for the doctrine of the faith issued two documents on the matter. They are often described as "against" and then "for" liberation theology. It is more accurate to say that each does both, in different proportions.

The 1984 instruction said that the longing for freedom is among the great signs of the times and that the church must respond to the cry of the poor. It then voiced serious concerns about some tendencies that used Marxist ideas without enough care. Its concerns, as it stated them, included the risk of reducing salvation to political liberation, of treating the idea of class struggle as the key to history, and of weakening the unity of the church by setting a "church of the people" against the church of the bishops. It said that some writers, not all, had these tendencies. Some theologians said that this described views few of them held, and some agreed that the warnings were needed.

The 1986 instruction took up the theme of liberation at greater length and said that it was an important and rightful theme of Christian teaching, rooted in the Bible. It linked freedom and liberation with the church's teaching on justice and with the work for the poor. Readers disagree about how the two documents fit together. Some see a change of tone. Others see a single position that was always balanced. A student can say that both documents exist and that they must be read together.

7. The criticism from inside

Not all criticism came from outside. Some theologians who stood with the poor asked liberation theology hard questions. We will mention three, as questions rather than as the position of named persons.

One question was whose poverty. Early writing, some said, often spoke of "the poor" as one class, and passed over the ways in which poverty falls differently on women, on Indigenous peoples and on people of African descent. The next lecture takes this up.

Another concerned the tools of social analysis. If a theologian uses an analysis of society built by someone who is not Christian, what comes with it? Gutierrez and others replied that every theology uses outside tools, as the early church used Greek words, and that the test is whether the tool serves the word and not the other way round. Critics replied that the test is hard to apply and that some writers failed it.

A third concerned the poor themselves. In some places, many of the poor turned to Pentecostal churches, and some writers asked whether liberation theology had spoken for people who did not wish to be spoken for, or had not listened to the questions of faith, healing and hope that they were bringing. We say more in the next lecture.

8. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether liberation theology, as a whole, is a faithful recovery of the gospel for the poor or a serious distortion of it. One view, held by many Catholics, Protestants and others in Latin America and elsewhere, is that its central insight is true: God hears the cry of the poor, the church is judged by how it treats them, and sin has social forms. In its strongest form, this view says that for centuries theology was written by those who were comfortable and that this left whole parts of Scripture unread. Its weak point, as other readers see it, is that the language can slide from "God stands with the poor" to "God stands with one political side", and that some writers did not guard the difference clearly enough. Another view, held by many Catholic and Protestant critics, is that the gospel is first a message of forgiveness and new life offered to every person, rich or poor, and that a theology which begins from social practice risks making that message secondary. In its strongest form, this view points to the real danger of tying the church to any programme of any party, and to the fact that Scripture sets the standard for practice and not the reverse. Its weak point, as other readers see it, is that it has sometimes been used to avoid the biblical demand for justice altogether, and that the same objection about borrowed tools could be made against any theology. A third view holds that "liberation theology" is too many things to judge as one and that each writer should be read on his or her own terms. The course requires only that a student can state each view fairly, say what it protects and where it is weak, and listen to the others.

9. What a student can take from this

You do not have to agree with liberation theology, or reject it, to learn from it. Three questions are worth keeping. Whom does my way of speaking about God serve? Which parts of Scripture have I not read because I did not need them? And do I let people who live with hardship tell me what they find in a text, or do I tell them what they should find? Those who criticise liberation theology can ask the same questions of their own position, and many do.


Diagram 1. Three levels of liberation, and the question of how they are held together

LIBERATION AT THREE LEVELS Distinct, and meant to belong together Level 1: social and economic freedom from hunger, unjust arrangements and abuse Level 2: personal and historical a person or a people growing into dignity and responsibility Level 3: freedom from sin in Christ forgiveness and communion with God and with others; the deepest level, in Gutierrez's account The contested question: does a given writer keep all three, or let one stand for all? Ask it of every writer, on any side, before judging.

Diagram 2. Two criticisms, two replies

CRITICISM AND REPLY, SIDE BY SIDE Criticism: salvation may shrink to political change, and borrowed social tools may bring a whole way of seeing with them Reply: levels kept together liberation from sin is the deepest level; every theology borrows tools, and the test is whether they serve the word Criticism from inside: whose poverty? "the poor" may hide women, Indigenous and Afro-descended people and other voices Reply: a task still unfinished many later writers took up this question themselves (see lecture 4-4); the poor are many people, not one

In short

  • Gutierrez described theology as critical reflection on practice in the light of the word, a second step after a life of faith and love.
  • Many liberation theologians distinguish three levels of liberation: social, personal and from sin; critics ask whether all three are always kept.
  • The preferential option for the poor means a deliberate choice to give first attention to the poor; it is meant to exclude no one.
  • Structural sin means sin built into social arrangements; critics fear it excuses persons, defenders say persons make and keep structures.
  • The 1984 and 1986 Vatican instructions each warned against some tendencies and each affirmed the importance of liberation.
  • Evangelical writers developed integral mission, and some theologians who stood with the poor asked liberation theology hard questions from inside.
Front Back
Theology as a second step Critical reflection on practice in the light of the word; practice comes first, and the word remains the guide.
Preferential option for the poor The church's deliberate choice to give first attention to those most in need; meant to exclude no one.
Vatican instructions, 1984 and 1986 Each warned about some tendencies, such as reducing salvation to political liberation, and each recognised liberation as a real theme of the gospel.
Criticism from inside Asked whose poverty is meant, what borrowed tools carry with them, and whether the poor were being listened to.

One sentence to remember Liberation theology asks a question every theology should face, whom it serves, and it has been answered by supporters and critics who are both reading Scripture.

This week's action Read Luke 4:18-19 and James 2:14-17 side by side, and write one sentence on what each adds to the other.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In your own words, what does it mean that theology is "critical reflection on practice in the light of the word"? What does it add to older ideas of theology, and what question might a critic ask about it?
  • Explain the preferential option for the poor. Give one reading that stresses love for every neighbour and one that stresses listening to the poor. What worry do some have about the phrase?
  • What is structural sin? Give the worry about it and the reply of its defenders.
  • Why is it too simple to say that the Vatican was "against" liberation theology in 1984 and "for" it in 1986? What did each instruction recognise, and what did each warn against?
  • Choose one of the views in the paragraph where readers will not agree. State its strongest form and its weak point. Then do the same for a view you find less persuasive.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.