Lecture 3-4: Reconciliation, Women's Voices and the Public Square
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Every Theology Has an Address
- Lecture 1-2: Ways of Making Theology Local
- Lecture 1-3: Between Translation and Syncretism
- Lecture 1-4: Voices of the Younger Churches and the Older Ones
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I Do Theology From
- Lecture 2-1: Doing Theology in Asia
- Lecture 2-2: Pain, the People and the Poor
- Lecture 2-3: Among Other Religions: Thinking with Neighbours
- Lecture 2-4: Korea, Japan, China, the Philippines: Local Roads
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbours and My Theology
- Lecture 3-1: Doing Theology in Africa
- Lecture 3-2: Community, Ancestors and Ubuntu
- Lecture 3-3: Spirits, Healing and the African Independent Churches
- Lecture 3-4: Reconciliation, Women's Voices and the Public Square
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Community and My Theology
- Lecture 4-1: Doing Theology in Latin America
- Lecture 4-2: Liberation Theology
- Lecture 4-3: Popular Catholic Piety, Pentecostals and Evangelicals
- Lecture 4-4: Other Voices: Women, Indigenous and Afro-Latin American Theologies
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Poverty, Faith and My Theology
- Lecture 5-1: Reading the Bible from Many Places
- Lecture 5-2: Worship in the World Church
- Lecture 5-3: Authority and the Shape of the Community
- Lecture 5-4: The Holy Spirit, Healing and Gifts across the World Church
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Voices I Have Not Heard
- Lecture 6-1: In Conversation with Western Theology
- Lecture 6-2: What Northern Churches Can Learn from the South, and the South from the North
- Lecture 6-3: Where Voices Differ: A Map of the Disagreements
- Lecture 6-4: One Body, Many Places: Putting the Course Together
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Theology and the World Church on One Page
African theology is not only about village life, spirits and healing. It has also had to speak about public wrongs: racial domination, violent division, the long work of mending a broken society. And it has had to ask who is heard when theology is done, and who is not. This lecture looks at three streams that grew in the twentieth century and continue to be discussed: theologies of reconciliation, Black theology in South Africa, and the work of African women theologians.
We read these as theological arguments and as historical debates. We do not judge any government, party or living person. We say only what we are sure of. Where there is a real disagreement, for example over whether reconciliation can come before justice, we state each side in its strongest form. And we show how these streams join the themes of the earlier lectures: community, the Spirit, and the power of the gospel to meet people where they live.
Some readers know division, loss or discrimination from their own lives. The lecture does not describe violence. If it brings difficult memories, you may stop and speak to a trusted pastor, priest or friend.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain, as a theological argument, what reconciliation means in the thought of Desmond Tutu and why 2 Corinthians 5:18-19 matters to it.
- State the main idea of Black theology in South Africa and one criticism of an understanding of reconciliation that comes before justice.
- Describe the aim and method of the Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians, in outline.
- State fairly where readers disagree about reconciliation and justice, and about women's roles in the church.
- Explain how these streams connect to the themes of community and the Spirit in lectures 3-2 and 3-3.
But all things are of God, who reconciled us to himself through Jesus Christ, and gave to us the ministry of reconciliation;" — 2 Corinthians 5:18
World English Bible
namely, that God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself, not reckoning to them their trespasses, and having committed to us the word of reconciliation." — 2 Corinthians 5:19
WEB
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28
WEB
He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8
WEB
What the text says. In 2 Corinthians 5, Paul says that God has reconciled us to himself through Christ and has given the church a ministry and a message of reconciliation. In Galatians 3:28 he says that distinctions of ethnic group, social standing and sex do not divide those who are in Christ; the verse is about unity in Christ, and what it means for every area of church life is discussed. In Micah 6:8 the prophet says what the Lord asks: to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with God.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians read 2 Corinthians 5 as the root of every work of peace between people, because reconciliation with God leads to reconciliation among those he has reconciled. Others stress that Paul wrote it to a church in a particular dispute, and that the text does not say how to reconcile a wronged people with those who wronged them. Galatians 3:28 is read by some as the ground of the equal standing of women and men in church life; others read it as speaking of equal standing before God and salvation while holding that roles in the church may still differ. Micah 6:8 is read by many as holding justice, mercy and humility together, and by some as a check on any teaching that has only one of the three.
Our judgement. None of these verses gives a programme for a nation. They give a direction: God's reconciling work, the unity of believers, and the call to justice and mercy. How a church applies them is a matter of discussion, and our task is to keep what the text says apart from what a tradition or a theologian draws from it.
1. Reconciliation as a theological argument
In the 1990s South Africa set up a Truth and Reconciliation Commission to hear accounts of wrongs committed under the system of racial domination called apartheid, and to try to find a way forward for a divided country. Desmond Tutu, an Anglican archbishop, chaired it. The Commission's work belongs to history and is discussed in many other places. Here we ask only about the theology that was brought to it.
There is an argument, put by Tutu in his writings, that reconciliation is not a political bargain but a gift rooted in the gospel. On this argument, God has reconciled the world to himself in Christ (2 Corinthians 5:19), and so the church cannot treat any person as beyond reconciliation. He also used the idea of ubuntu that we met in lecture 3-2: the humanity of the wrongdoer and of the wronged are tied together, so that healing must reach both. On this argument forgiveness is not forgetting and does not excuse the wrong; it is a refusal to let the wrong have the last word over the relationship. The truth must be told, for there is no healing without it.
The argument has been criticised, and the criticisms deserve to be heard in their strongest form. One criticism is that a call to reconcile can be made too early, or by the wrong people. If those who suffered are told to forgive while the wrong continues, or while no one has admitted it or repaired it, then "reconciliation" can protect the powerful and silence the wounded. Writers have used the phrase cheap reconciliation for this danger. A second criticism is that forgiveness is the wronged person's to give, and not an office of the church or of the state to demand. A third is that reconciling people without changing the conditions that divided them leaves the old structures untouched.
The replies given by those who hold the argument include these: that, as they understood it, truth and repair were part of reconciliation and forgiveness could not be forced on any person; that the alternative to a hard attempt at reconciliation was, in their view, a cycle of vengeance; and that a Commission is not the whole of what a nation needs. Both the argument and the criticisms are part of one conversation, and some who hold the criticisms also work for reconciliation.
2. Black theology in South Africa
Black theology in South Africa grew from the 1970s, in the setting of the Black Consciousness movement and of apartheid. We say only what we are sure of. It argued that the gospel speaks to the experience of Black people, who had been told by law and often by church teaching that they were lesser, and that theology which ignores that experience has left something out. Theologians associated with it include Manas Buthelezi, a Lutheran, and Allan Boesak, a Reformed minister and theologian whose book Farewell to Innocence (1977) is often cited.
An argument in this stream is that God takes the side of the oppressed in Scripture, from the exodus to the prophets to the cross, and that a church which stays neutral in the face of injustice has in fact taken a side. Another is that human beings are made in God's image, and that to treat any group as less than human is a sin against God. These arguments belonged to a wider conversation with Black theology in the United States and with in Latin America, which we study in week 4. The differences between them matter, and we do not merge them.
The Kairos Document, a statement by a group of South African theologians in 1985, is often named in this setting. As we understand it, it criticised what it called state theology and church theology and called for what it named prophetic theology. We mention it only briefly. Readers who wish to use it should read it themselves and the replies to it.
Black theology has had critics. Some, in the churches, said that it gave too much weight to one group's experience and risked a new kind of division. Some, in other theological streams, said that it did not give enough weight to personal sin and conversion. Some said that a theology of liberation should not become a theology of resentment. Defenders replied that Scripture itself is written for people in oppression, that the gospel includes both personal and communal sin, and that Black theology, in its better forms, seeks the freedom of everyone, including those who have held power.
Some churches that had defended apartheid with theological arguments later changed their position. We do not name them here. We note only that theology can be used to support injustice as well as to resist it, and that every church should ask whether its own theology serves the powerful.
3. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is the relation of reconciliation and justice.
One position holds that reconciliation comes first, or at least that it is the aim that should shape every other step. Its holders say that God's act in Christ is first a reconciling act, that the church's task is to bear witness to it, and that a demand for justice without a will to reconcile can turn into revenge. The strongest form of the view is that justice without reconciliation leaves a society divided in a new way. Its weak point is that the order may be turned to the advantage of those who have done wrong: they can ask for peace while still holding what they have taken.
Another position holds that justice must come first or must be inseparable from reconciliation. Its holders say that the prophets, including Micah, speak of justice first, that to ask the wronged to forgive without repair is to ask them to bear the cost twice, and that real reconciliation cannot exist where the wrong continues. The strongest form of this view is that reconciliation which skips justice is not reconciliation but a truce that suits the strong. Its weak point is that the demand for full justice before any reconciliation may never be satisfied, so that the wounds do not heal and the cycle continues.
Many theologians, in Africa and elsewhere, hold a third view: that the two cannot be put in order, since each is empty without the other, and that the church's task is to hold them together in each case. Others say that this answer is too easy and that in a real situation one must put something first.
This course requires you to state each view fairly, to see what each protects, and to see its weak point. We give no verdict on any government, party or person, past or present.
4. Women's theological voices
In 1989 a group of African women theologians, led by Mercy Amba Oduyoye of Ghana, founded the Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians. Women from many countries and churches joined it. Their aim, in outline, was to do theology from the experience of African women, to write and publish it, and to bring it into the churches and the universities.
We describe their work in general terms, and we do not speak for any member. Some of what they have argued is this. First, African women have long been carriers of the faith in their families and congregations, though their theological work has often gone unrecorded. Second, culture is a gift, and it can also be a source of harm, especially in matters of marriage, widowhood, inheritance and the treatment of those without children. Therefore a theology that celebrates culture without question is incomplete. Third, the Bible has been read in ways that hurt women, and it can be read again with care, in ways that bring life. Their method includes the gathering of women's stories and the reading of Scripture with those stories.
There are criticisms from several sides. Some, in the churches and outside them, say that this theology brings in ideas from abroad. The women theologians reply that they are reading from their own lives and communities, and that to say women's experience is "foreign" is itself to silence it. Some African women hold that the term feminist does not fit their work and prefer other names; the Circle itself has discussed this question. Some, in traditions that hold that roles in the church differ for women and men, ask whether the work asks the church to give up what it understands Scripture to teach. And some from other regions ask whether the work of the Circle has been given enough attention in the writing of "African theology", which has long been written mostly by men.
This is a point where readers will not agree. On the question of women's roles in the church and in church leadership, Christians disagree, and African Christians are on every side of it. Some traditions, among them the Catholic and Orthodox churches, ordain only men to the priesthood and give reasons from Scripture and tradition, and some Protestant and independent churches hold a similar view about pastoral leadership. Other churches, including many Protestant and independent ones in Africa, ordain women and give reasons from Scripture, from Galatians 3:28 and from the evidence of women who have led. The strongest form of the first view is that the church has kept an ordering received from the apostles and cannot change it by its own authority; its weak point is that critics find in the texts and in history more women's leadership than it admits. The strongest form of the second view is that gifts are given without regard to sex and the church is poorer without them; its weak point is that critics say it reads the texts that speak to the question in a way the church has not read them before. This course does not take a side. It asks you to state each position and the reason for it fairly, to see that women hold each view, and to ask who is heard.
5. How these streams meet the earlier lectures
Reconciliation theology draws on the idea that a person becomes a person through others (lecture 3-2): the wrongdoer and the wronged are bound to each other, and healing must reach both. Black theology and women's theology both ask what happens when a community fails some of its members, a question that the idea of ubuntu can also ask of itself. And the Spirit of lecture 3-3, who is believed to heal the body, is also named by many as the one who heals a society and gives courage to speak. These links are not neat, and we should be wary of tying them too tightly. The lecture's point is only that these themes belong to one conversation.
6. Reading with care
Three questions help. Who is speaking and from what experience? What does the writer take from Scripture, and what does the writer take from the situation? And what would the writer's strongest critic say? We do not ask whether the theologian is "right" about a political matter; we ask whether the argument is clear, whether it is faithful to Scripture, and whether it listens to those who disagree.
Diagram 1. Reconciliation and justice: three ways of ordering them
Diagram 2. Three streams and the themes of the week
In short
- Tutu argued that reconciliation is rooted in God's act in Christ, that truth must be told, and that it does not excuse the wrong.
- Critics warn against reconciliation made too early or demanded of the wounded; defenders answer that truth and repair belong to it.
- Black theology in South Africa argued that the gospel speaks to the experience of the oppressed and that neutrality in the face of injustice takes a side.
- The Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians, founded in 1989, does theology from women's experience and treats culture as both gift and possible harm.
- Readers disagree on whether justice or reconciliation comes first and on women's roles; each position has a strength and a weak point.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Reconciliation theology | Rooted in God's act in Christ; truth is told; forgiveness does not excuse; criticised when it comes too early. |
| Black theology (South Africa) | The gospel speaks to the experience of the oppressed; critics fear division, defenders seek freedom for all. |
| The Circle (1989) | African women theologians doing theology from women's experience; culture is both gift and possible harm. |
| Two contested questions | Reconciliation and justice: which first? Women's roles in church leadership. Both sides are held by Christians. |
One sentence to remember Reconciliation, justice and women's voices are held together by listening to each side's strongest case.
This week's action Choose one contested question from this lecture and write the strongest case for each side in two sentences.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- How does 2 Corinthians 5:18-19 shape Tutu's argument for reconciliation? What is the criticism of "reconciliation" made too early?
- What is the main idea of Black theology in South Africa, as described here, and what are two criticisms and two replies?
- State the three views on reconciliation and justice. What does each protect, and what is each one's weak point?
- What did the Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians aim to do? Why does the lecture say culture is both a gift and a possible source of harm?
- How does the lecture treat women's roles in the church? Can you state the two positions in a way each would accept?