FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL2E Modern Theology

Lecture 3-1: The Collapse of Liberal Optimism and Barth's Break with His Teachers

Contents 40
STEL2E Modern Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Is Modern Theology, and Why Study It?
  1. Introduction: What Is Modern Theology, and Why Study It?
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Enlightenment Challenge
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Turn to the Reasoning Subject
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kant's Critique and the Limits of Reason
  3. Lecture 1-3: Hegel and the Historicizing of Doctrine
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Nineteenth-Century Liberal Theology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Schleiermacher and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Ritschl, Harnack, and the Essence of Christianity
  3. Lecture 2-3: Troeltsch and the Crisis of Historicism
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Neo-Orthodoxy — Barth and Brunner
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Collapse of Liberal Optimism and Barth's Break with His Teachers
  2. Lecture 3-2: Barth's Mature Theology of the Word
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Barth-Brunner Controversy over Natural Theology
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Existentialist and Hermeneutical Theology
  1. Lecture 4-1: Kierkegaard, Heidegger, and the Turn to Existence
  2. Lecture 4-2: Bultmann and the Program of Demythologization
  3. Lecture 4-3: Tillich's Correlation and the Hermeneutical Turn
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Christian Realism and Public Theology
  1. Lecture 5-1: Reinhold Niebuhr and the Recovery of Sin as Political Realism
  2. Lecture 5-2: H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture, and Its Limits
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Wider Legacy of Christian Realism
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Secularization and Bonhoeffer's Legacy
  1. Lecture 6-1: Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Prison Writings
  2. Lecture 6-2: Harvey Cox's The Secular City and the Debate It Provoked
  3. Lecture 6-3: The "Death of God" Theology of the 1960s
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Rethinking God — Process and Open Theism
  1. Lecture 7-1: Process Philosophy's Foundations — Whitehead and Hartshorne
  2. Lecture 7-2: Process Theology Proper — Cobb, Griffin, and the Problem of Evil
  3. Lecture 7-3: Open Theism within Evangelicalism
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Hope, the Cross, and Catholic Renewal
  1. Lecture 8-1: Jürgen Moltmann — Hope and the Crucified God
  2. Lecture 8-2: Wolfhart Pannenberg — Revelation as Universal History
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Second Vatican Council and Catholic Renewal
  4. Lecture 8-4: Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar — Two Catholic Responses to Modernity
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: The Trinitarian Renaissance
  1. Lecture 9-1: Rahner's Complaint and the Rule That Answered It
  2. Lecture 9-2: Zizioulas and the Orthodox Recovery of Personhood
  3. Lecture 9-3: Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Liberation, Black, and Global Theologies
  1. Lecture 10-1: Gutiérrez, Cone, and the Theology of Liberation
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Global South and the Method of Contextual Theology
  3. Lecture 10-3: Pentecostal Theology's Academic Emergence and Amos Yong's Pneumatology
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Postmodernism, Postliberalism, and Pluralism
  1. Lecture 11-1: Postmodern Philosophy's Challenge to Enlightenment Reason
  2. Lecture 11-2: George Lindbeck and the Cultural-Linguistic Model
  3. Lecture 11-3: Hauerwas's Narrative Ethics and Milbank's Radical Orthodoxy
  4. Lecture 11-4: The Religious Pluralism Debate
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Evangelical Theology and the Contemporary Frontier
  1. Lecture 12-1: The New Evangelical Mind — Carl F. H. Henry, J. I. Packer, and the Turn Toward Engagement
  2. Lecture 12-2: Reformed Epistemology — Plantinga, Wolterstorff, and the Rationality of Belief
  3. Lecture 12-3: Analytic Theology and Vanhoozer's Doctrine as Drama
  4. Lecture 12-4: The Contemporary Frontier and Course Synthesis

Jump to the key points ↓

21 min

By 1914, German Protestant theology looked, to most of the theologians working inside it, like a settled and successful project. The nineteenth century covered in chapter 2 had produced a confident synthesis: Schleiermacher had grounded faith somewhere Kantian philosophy could not touch, Ritschl and Harnack had distilled an ethical "essence of Christianity" out of centuries of doctrinal accretion, and German Protestant culture generally assumed that Christian faith and the moral progress of modern, educated, Christian civilization were advancing together. Liberal theology was not merely an academic position; for many of its adherents it described how history itself was moving.

This lecture is about what happened when that confidence met the First World War, and about one young Swiss pastor, Karl Barth, for whom the war did not simply raise doubts about German politics but permanently discredited the entire theological method he had been trained in. Understanding why Barth reacted as strongly as he did — and why so many other theologians of his generation, in a movement historians call neo-orthodoxy or "dialectical theology," reacted in similar directions — requires seeing the war not as one more historical event theology had to comment on, but as the event that made an entire theological method suddenly look, to its own best students, unusable.

A word of caution before we begin, following one of this course's own rules: it is tempting to tell this story as a clean, satisfying turning point — 1914 as the hinge on which all of modern theology swings. Real intellectual history is rarely that tidy. Liberal theology did not vanish in 1914; it continued to be taught, defended, and developed for decades afterward, and other theologians experienced the war without concluding what Barth concluded. What changed, precisely, was that one figure who would prove enormously influential drew a sharp and public break, and that break gave a name and a rallying point to reactions against liberal theology that had already begun stirring elsewhere for other reasons. Treat 1914 as the moment the reaction became visible and organized, not as the sole cause of everything the rest of this chapter describes.

What these 21 minutes give you

  • Describe the theological assumptions of pre-war liberal culture-Protestantism, especially its confidence that Christian faith and modern civilization's moral progress were aligned.
  • Explain what the "Manifesto of the Ninety-Three" was, why Barth's own teachers signing it functioned as a personal and theological shock rather than only a political disappointment, and state fairly why this reaction, though widely repeated in later accounts, should not be treated as the single or sufficient cause of Barth's later theology.
  • Summarize the central claim of Barth's commentary on Romans (1919, substantially rewritten in 1922): God as "wholly other" (*ganz andere*), qualitatively distinct from human religious and cultural achievement.
  • Explain why Barth judged that the failure went deeper than his teachers' political judgment — that their theological *method* itself, which had made room for confusing German culture with the will of God, was now in question.
  • Place this rupture within the wider crisis named in chapter 2: Troeltsch's historicism had already left liberal theology unable to say, from within its own method, why Christianity was more than one historical development among others; the war supplied the experience that made looking for an answer outside that method feel urgent rather than merely academic.

Barth's central claim in this lecture — that God stands utterly apart from and above every human religious, cultural, and moral achievement, however impressive — has scriptural roots that long predate 1914, and it is worth reading them before turning to Barth's own words, so that his claim is heard as a retrieval rather than an invention.

Ecclesiastes 5:2 warns: "Don't be rash with your mouth, and don't let your heart be hasty to utter anything before God; for God is in heaven, and you on earth. Therefore let your words be few." (World English Bible) The verse does not argue a doctrine of God's transcendence so much as assume it as a reason for a particular kind of speech: because God is in heaven and the speaker is on earth, human words about God — and, by extension, human religious confidence — should be offered carefully, not presumed.

Isaiah 40:25 asks the same question rhetorically, in the voice of the Holy One: "'To whom then will you liken me? Who is my equal?' says the Holy One." (WEB) The context in Isaiah 40 is a long argument against comparing God to anything in creation, human institutions included — precisely the comparison Barth judged German liberal Protestantism had made when it treated the nation's culture, and eventually the nation's war policy, as continuous with or even revelatory of the divine will.

Neither text was written with 1914 in view, and it would be anachronistic to say Barth "discovered" what these verses say. What can be said fairly is that Barth read them, and texts like them, as recovering a biblical claim his teachers' theology had allowed itself to lose sight of: that God's distinction from every human achievement is not a detail to be qualified away but a starting point.

1. The world liberal theology was confident in

To understand the shock, it helps to see what, exactly, was being shocked. Nineteenth-century German liberal Protestantism, as chapter 2 described, was not a single fixed position, but its major figures shared a broad confidence: that careful historical and moral reasoning could recover an authentic core of Christian faith — Ritschl's moral kingdom of God, Harnack's ethical "essence of Christianity" stripped of Hellenistic metaphysics — and that this recovered core was compatible with, even expressed through, the moral and cultural progress of modern civilization. German Protestant culture in the decades before 1914 had, broadly, absorbed this confidence into its own self-understanding. Educated German Protestantism saw itself as standing at a high point of both civilization and Christian faith, the two advancing more or less together.

This was not naive triumphalism in every case, and it would be unfair — a caricature of exactly the kind this course warns against — to say every liberal theologian believed history guaranteed moral progress without qualification. But the general mood, among the educated Protestant clergy and professoriate of Barth's own training, was one of confidence: modern, historically critical, ethically serious Christianity was the faith fit for a modern, advancing civilization, and German culture in particular was often assumed, more casually than any single theologian might defend if pressed, to exemplify that advance.

2. August 1914: the Manifesto and its theological weight

On 4 October 1914, ninety-three prominent German intellectuals, scientists, and artists signed a public declaration — known to history as the "Manifesto of the Ninety-Three" ("An die Kulturwelt!", "To the Civilized World") — defending Germany's conduct at the outbreak of the First World War and denying German responsibility for its atrocities, including the invasion of neutral Belgium. Among the signatories were a number of theologians whose work Karl Barth, then a young Swiss pastor, had studied closely and admired: teachers whose and liberal theological synthesis he had absorbed as the best available account of the Christian faith.

Barth later described his reaction in blunt terms: he found that he could no longer accept the ethics, the of Scripture, the view of history, and the doctrine of faith and life that his teachers had taught him, because all of it now seemed to him to have been unable to withstand the ideology of war. It is important, for the sake of historical fairness, to state precisely what shocked Barth. It was not simply that admired men held a political opinion he found wrong — theologians disagree about politics constantly without their theology being called into question. What alarmed Barth was that the same intellectual and theological training that had produced his teachers' sophisticated liberal synthesis had, apparently, produced no resource within itself to resist a straightforward identification of a particular nation's war policy with a righteous cause. If the theological method itself contained no brake against that identification, Barth concluded, something was wrong with the method, not only with these particular men's judgment in this particular instance.

How decisive was 1914?

This is a point where readers will not agree, or at least where later historians have pressed back on the traditional account. The "1914 as decisive turning point" narrative comes substantially from Barth's own later retrospective accounts, written when he had every reason to present his break as sharp and principled. Some historians of theology (for example, several contributors to more recent critical studies of dialectical theology's origins) have argued that Barth's dissatisfaction with 's method had already been building for other reasons — including his pastoral experience preaching each week in the working-class parish of Safenwil, where he found liberal theology's categories increasingly unable to speak to his congregation's actual lives — and that 1914 crystallized and dramatized a break that was already forming rather than causing it outright. Both things can be true at once: the war was a genuine catalyst, and it was not the sole cause. Treat the Manifesto as the moment that made Barth's break vivid and public, not as a single sufficient explanation of everything that followed.

3. Barth's Romans: God as ganz andere

Barth's response took shape first not as a systematic treatise but as a commentary — a close, line-by-line reading of Paul's letter to the Romans, first published in 1919 and then substantially rewritten for a second edition in 1922 that is the version most read today. The commentary startled its first readers because it did not read like the historical-critical scholarship they expected. Barth was reading Romans as a text that spoke directly, urgently, and disruptively into the present, rather than as an ancient document to be reconstructed historically and then translated into modern ethical categories.

The theological center of the commentary is Barth's insistence that God is ganz andere — "wholly other," qualitatively and infinitely distinct from every human religious, moral, and cultural achievement, however impressive that achievement might be. This was aimed, deliberately, at liberal theology's whole method as chapter 2 described it: if Schleiermacher had located God's revelation in a feeling continuous with ordinary human religious consciousness, and if Ritschl and Harnack had located Christianity's essential truth in an ethical ideal continuous with the best of human moral striving, Barth's Romans declared that God cannot be reached by any such continuity. There is, on Barth's reading of Paul, an infinite qualitative distinction between time and eternity, between the human and the divine, that no cultural, moral, or religious achievement — however sincere, however sophisticated — can cross from the human side. God is known only because God crosses it from God's side, in God's own free act of self-revelation, never because a human method, however refined, arrives there by its own power.

This claim did more than criticize German war theology specifically; it indicted the entire liberal theological method's willingness to speak of a "point of contact" between human culture and divine reality at all — a phrase this course will return to directly in 3-3, when Emil Brunner argues that some such point of contact must still be affirmed, and Barth answers with one of the most famous single-word rejections in twentieth-century theology.

4. What this break was, and was not

It is worth being precise, in a history-of-doctrine course, about what kind of theology Barth's break produced, because "" can suggest something it was not. Barth was not proposing a simple return to pre-Enlightenment Protestant orthodoxy, as though the intervening centuries — Kant's critique, the historical-critical method, the entire argument of chapters 1 and 2 — could be set aside. Barth had been trained thoroughly in that historical-critical method and never renounced serious biblical scholarship; his commentary on Romans is deeply engaged with the text's historical particulars even as it reads them theologically. What Barth rejected was liberal theology's foundational move — grounding faith's truth in some general human capacity (feeling, moral experience, historical consciousness) that made faith answerable to, and ultimately dependent on, categories liberal theology's own critics could not defend as sufficient once those categories had failed to prevent the very culture that produced them from blessing a catastrophic war.

Neo-orthodoxy, then as this chapter will develop it, is best understood as liberal theology's own most brilliant students concluding that their teachers' entire project — however serious, however historically sophisticated — had failed at exactly the point that mattered most, and building something new in its place that was neither pre-modern orthodoxy nor a continuation of the liberal method, but a third thing. Lecture 3-2 turns to what Barth built to replace it: a mature theology of the Word centered entirely on God's own self-revelation in Jesus Christ.

1914: One Event, Two Readings The traditional account, and a historian's caution about it Barth's own retrospective account The Manifesto of the Ninety-Three (Oct. 1914) exposes liberal theology's method as unable to resist identifying German war policy with the will of God — a sharp, dated break A historian's qualification Barth's dissatisfaction with liberal categories was already forming from pastoral experience at Safenwil; 1914 crystallized and dramatized a break already underway, not a bolt from the blue Both can be true together A real catalyst is not the same thing as a sole or sufficient cause. Treat 1914 as the moment the break became public and organized.

6. Further Reading

  • Karl Barth, The Epistle to the Romans, trans. Edwyn C. Hoskyns (Oxford University Press, 1933; from the 6th German edition of 1928) — the classic English translation of the second edition.
  • Eberhard Busch, Karl Barth: His Life from Letters and Autobiographical Texts, trans. John Bowden (Fortress Press, 1976) — the standard biography, drawing extensively on Barth's own later accounts of 1914.
  • Bruce L. McCormack, Karl Barth's Critically Realistic Dialectical Theology: Its Genesis and Development, 1909-1936 (Oxford University Press, 1995) — a major scholarly reassessment arguing for a more gradual development of Barth's break with liberalism than the traditional "1914 turning point" narrative suggests.
  • Timothy Gorringe, Karl Barth: Against Hegemony (Oxford University Press, 1999) — situates Barth's theology within his social and political context, including the Safenwil pastorate.
  • Karl Barth, "Evangelical Theology and Its Present Task," in God, Grace and Gospel (Scottish Journal of Theology Occasional Papers, 1959) — a later, retrospective statement of what Barth believed liberal theology had gotten wrong.

In short

  • Before 1914, German liberal Protestantism was confident that Christian faith and the moral progress of modern civilisation advanced together. The lecture notes this was not true of every liberal theologian.
  • In October 1914, ninety-three intellectuals signed the Manifesto of the Ninety-Three defending Germany's war conduct. Several of Barth's admired teachers were among them.
  • Barth judged that the failure lay in his teachers' theological method, which offered no brake against identifying a nation's war policy with God's will, not only in their politics.
  • His commentary on Romans (1919, rewritten 1922) declared God "wholly other" (ganz andere), infinitely distinct from every human religious or cultural achievement. God crosses the gap from God's side.
  • Historians caution that 1914 was a catalyst, not the sole cause. Barth's pastoral work at Safenwil had already unsettled him. Neo-orthodoxy was neither a return to pre-modern orthodoxy nor a continuation of liberalism.

Topic: This lecture shows how the First World War and the Manifesto of the Ninety-Three led Barth to break with liberal theology and proclaim God as wholly other.

Remember: Barth's complaint was about method: a theology resting on human capacities had no resource to resist blessing a nation's war.

Caution: Do not treat 1914 as the single cause. The lecture calls it a catalyst that made a forming break public. Neo-orthodoxy was not a simple return to the past.

One line to carry into ministry: Be careful never to equate our nation's or culture's cause with the will of God.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Barth judged that his teachers' theological *method*, not only their political judgment, had failed. What is the difference between saying "these theologians made a bad political call" and "the theology that trained them left no resource to resist that call"? Do you find the second claim persuasive, or does it ask liberal theology to bear responsibility for something outside theology's proper scope?
  • This lecture raised a historian's caution against treating 1914 as the single cause of Barth's break, noting his prior pastoral dissatisfaction at Safenwil. Why might it matter, for how fairly we tell this history, whether we treat a dramatic public event or a slower private change of mind as the "real" cause of a theologian's turn?
  • Ecclesiastes 5:2 grounds cautious human speech in the claim that "God is in heaven, and you on earth." How does this differ from grounding cautious speech in humility as a general moral virtue, unconnected to any specific claim about where God is relative to human beings?
  • If God is truly "wholly other" in Barth's sense, can any human theology — including Barth's own — claim to speak truly about God at all? How might Barth (or a sympathetic reader) answer this without simply contradicting the wholly-other claim?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.