Lecture 8-4: Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar — Two Catholic Responses to Modernity
Contents 40
- Lecture 1-1: The Turn to the Reasoning Subject
- Lecture 1-2: Kant's Critique and the Limits of Reason
- Lecture 1-3: Hegel and the Historicizing of Doctrine
- Lecture 2-1: Schleiermacher and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
- Lecture 2-2: Ritschl, Harnack, and the Essence of Christianity
- Lecture 2-3: Troeltsch and the Crisis of Historicism
- Lecture 3-1: The Collapse of Liberal Optimism and Barth's Break with His Teachers
- Lecture 3-2: Barth's Mature Theology of the Word
- Lecture 3-3: The Barth-Brunner Controversy over Natural Theology
- Lecture 4-1: Kierkegaard, Heidegger, and the Turn to Existence
- Lecture 4-2: Bultmann and the Program of Demythologization
- Lecture 4-3: Tillich's Correlation and the Hermeneutical Turn
- Lecture 5-1: Reinhold Niebuhr and the Recovery of Sin as Political Realism
- Lecture 5-2: H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture, and Its Limits
- Lecture 5-3: The Wider Legacy of Christian Realism
- Lecture 6-1: Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Prison Writings
- Lecture 6-2: Harvey Cox's The Secular City and the Debate It Provoked
- Lecture 6-3: The "Death of God" Theology of the 1960s
- Lecture 7-1: Process Philosophy's Foundations — Whitehead and Hartshorne
- Lecture 7-2: Process Theology Proper — Cobb, Griffin, and the Problem of Evil
- Lecture 7-3: Open Theism within Evangelicalism
- Lecture 8-1: Jürgen Moltmann — Hope and the Crucified God
- Lecture 8-2: Wolfhart Pannenberg — Revelation as Universal History
- Lecture 8-3: The Second Vatican Council and Catholic Renewal
- Lecture 8-4: Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar — Two Catholic Responses to Modernity
- Lecture 9-1: Rahner's Complaint and the Rule That Answered It
- Lecture 9-2: Zizioulas and the Orthodox Recovery of Personhood
- Lecture 9-3: Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question
- Lecture 10-1: Gutiérrez, Cone, and the Theology of Liberation
- Lecture 10-2: The Global South and the Method of Contextual Theology
- Lecture 10-3: Pentecostal Theology's Academic Emergence and Amos Yong's Pneumatology
- Lecture 11-1: Postmodern Philosophy's Challenge to Enlightenment Reason
- Lecture 11-2: George Lindbeck and the Cultural-Linguistic Model
- Lecture 11-3: Hauerwas's Narrative Ethics and Milbank's Radical Orthodoxy
- Lecture 11-4: The Religious Pluralism Debate
- Lecture 12-1: The New Evangelical Mind — Carl F. H. Henry, J. I. Packer, and the Turn Toward Engagement
- Lecture 12-2: Reformed Epistemology — Plantinga, Wolterstorff, and the Rationality of Belief
- Lecture 12-3: Analytic Theology and Vanhoozer's Doctrine as Drama
- Lecture 12-4: The Contemporary Frontier and Course Synthesis
Karl Rahner (1904-1984) and Hans Urs von Balthasar (1905-1988) were near-exact contemporaries, both German-speaking, both formed by the same ressourcement recovery of patristic and biblical sources that shaped Vatican II's documents studied in the previous lecture, both among the most significant Catholic theologians of the twentieth century, and both, in their different ways, deeply committed to showing that Catholic theology could engage the modern world seriously without simply surrendering to it. They were also, for a period, close: von Balthasar entered the Jesuit order the same year Rahner did and the two studied together, and von Balthasar's own early theological formation owed a real debt to Rahner's teaching. What makes them worth studying together in this closing lecture of the chapter is not primarily their friendship, however, but the real and lasting methodological disagreement that opened between them as their mature projects developed - a disagreement von Balthasar himself stated directly and in print, not a difference this course is constructing after the fact for the sake of a tidy contrast.
Rahner's mature project, transcendental Thomism, begins from a question about the structure of human knowing and freedom itself: what must be true about every human being, prior to and independent of explicit Christian revelation, for that revelation to be intelligible and to be received as good news rather than an arbitrary external imposition? Rahner's answer runs through what he called the human being's "transcendental" orientation - a built-in, universal openness to the infinite mystery Christian theology calls God - present, he argued, in every act of human knowing and choosing, whether or not the person recognizes it in explicitly religious terms. From this Rahner developed his best-known and most controversial concept, the "anonymous Christian": the claim that a person who has never heard the Christian gospel, but who lives in openness to that transcendent mystery and responds to grace as it reaches them through their own conscience and circumstances, may be saved through Christ's grace without knowing Christ by name. Von Balthasar's mature project, developed most fully across the multi-volume The Glory of the Lord (Herrlichkeit, 1961-1969), begins from a different starting question: theology, von Balthasar argued, had for centuries treated beauty as at best a decorative afterthought to truth and goodness, the two transcendentals theology took seriously as proper theological categories, and von Balthasar set out to restore beauty - the "glory" (Herrlichkeit, doxa) of God's own self-revelation, perceived and not merely reasoned to - as a genuine third transcendental alongside the true and the good, arguing that God's revelation in Christ has a real, objective form that must first be beheld, in something closer to aesthetic perception than to either propositional argument or existential decision, before it can be properly known or lived.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Explain Rahner's transcendental method and his concept of the "anonymous Christian," in terms a sympathetic Catholic theologian would recognize as fair, including what the concept does and does not claim.
- Explain von Balthasar's theological aesthetics and his argument for beauty as a genuine third transcendental alongside the true and the good.
- State von Balthasar's own published methodological criticism of Rahner's transcendental approach accurately and specifically, distinguishing it from a caricature of "traditionalist versus modernist."
- Identify at least one point of genuine agreement between Rahner and von Balthasar, so that their real disagreement is not mistaken for total opposition.
- Place both theologians within the wider Catholic renewal studied in lecture 8-3, explaining how each relates to Vatican II's own documents and spirit.
The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork. Day after day they pour out speech, and night after night they display knowledge. There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard. Their voice has gone out through all the earth, their words to the end of the world. In them he has set a tent for the sun,
That which was from the beginning, that which we have heard, that which we have seen with our eyes, that which we saw, and our hands touched, concerning the Word of life (and the life was revealed, and we have seen, and testify, and declare to you the life, the eternal life, which was with the Father, and was revealed to us); that which we have seen and heard we declare to you, that you also may have fellowship with us. Yes, and our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son, Jesus Christ.
Psalms 19:1-4 (World English Bible)
Von Balthasar returns often to texts like this psalm as evidence that Scripture itself treats God's glory as something perceived - "declared," seen, heard as a kind of wordless speech reaching "through all the earth" - rather than only reasoned to through philosophical argument or known through a private existential encounter. The psalm's heavens do not offer propositions or arguments; they display a form, a glory, that communicates itself directly to whoever beholds it, which is close to what von Balthasar means when he insists that God's revelation in Christ must first be beheld in its own objective form - its "glory" - rather than approached first through the transcendental structures of the human knowing subject, which is closer to Rahner's starting point.
1 John 1:1-3 (WEB)
Von Balthasar's theological aesthetics draws heavily on this passage's emphasis on sensory perception - hearing, seeing, touching - as the ground of apostolic witness to Christ, taking it as evidence that the earliest Christian proclamation itself began from a form beheld and perceived, not from an abstract philosophical starting point. Rahner, for his part, would not deny the importance of this text, but would characteristically ask what must be true about human beings as such - their transcendental capacity for exactly this kind of perceiving, hearing, and receiving in the first place - for an encounter like the one 1 John describes to be humanly possible at all, which is the kind of question von Balthasar came to worry Rahner's method asked too insistently, and too early, of every theological topic it touched.
1. Rahner's transcendental method
Karl Rahner's theological method draws on the German philosophical tradition running through Kant (chapter 1) and, more directly, on the twentieth-century Thomist revival associated with his teacher Joseph Maréchal, who had attempted to read Aquinas's account of human knowing through categories drawn from Kant's transcendental philosophy - asking not simply what objects the human mind knows, but what conditions must already be true about the human mind's own structure for it to know anything about objects, including God, at all. Rahner's own development of this "transcendental Thomism" argues that every act of human knowing and free choice - not only explicitly religious acts, but any act of genuine understanding or moral decision whatsoever - involves, often unthematically and without the person's explicit awareness, a reaching toward, an openness to, an unlimited horizon of being that Christian theology names God. This transcendental openness, for Rahner, is not itself a natural achievement earned by unaided human effort in the way some earlier natural theology (of the kind chapter 3's Barth-Brunner debate addressed from a Protestant angle) had debated; Rahner holds it is itself a universal gift of grace, built into the very structure of human existence by God's own prior self-communicating intention for every human being, which Rahner calls the "supernatural existential."
From this transcendental starting point, Rahner develops the "anonymous Christian" concept for which he remains best known, and most frequently misunderstood, outside specialist Catholic theology. The claim is not that all religions are equally true, nor that explicit Christian faith and church membership do not matter - Rahner insisted repeatedly, against this common misreading, that explicit, thematic Christian faith remains the fuller, more complete realization of what grace is already accomplishing anonymously, and that the church's missionary task loses none of its urgency on his account. The claim, more precisely, is that a person who has had no genuine opportunity to hear the Christian gospel, but who nonetheless responds in freedom and love to the grace reaching them through their own conscience and life circumstances - a grace Rahner holds is never absent from any human life, because of the universal transcendental openness and the "supernatural existential" - may be saved through Christ's grace, even without explicit conceptual knowledge of Christ, because it is Christ's grace, on Rahner's Christologically centered account, that is at work in that person's response whether or not they have the theological vocabulary to name it as such.
2. Von Balthasar's theological aesthetics
Hans Urs von Balthasar's mature project takes a strikingly different starting point. Where Rahner begins with the structure of the human knowing subject and asks what must be true about that subject for revelation to be received, von Balthasar begins with the objective form (Gestalt) of revelation itself - God's own self-disclosure in Christ, which von Balthasar argues has a real, perceivable shape and splendor, a "glory" (the German Herrlichkeit, deliberately chosen to carry echoes of the biblical doxa and Hebrew kavod), that must first be beheld, contemplated, and received in something closer to the way a work of art or a beautiful natural scene is first perceived - not first analyzed, argued for, or fitted into a prior philosophical framework - before theology's other work of understanding and articulating that revelation can properly begin. The Glory of the Lord, the massive multi-volume work developing this argument across seven volumes, surveys both a wide range of theological witnesses across Christian history (Irenaeus, Augustine, Dante, Pascal, and many others) whom von Balthasar reads as exemplars of genuinely aesthetic theological perception, and a range of "styles" - metaphysical, historical, and other approaches to beauty in the Western tradition - that von Balthasar sets his own theological aesthetics both alongside and against.
Von Balthasar's argument for beauty as a genuine third theological transcendental, alongside the classical transcendentals of the true and the good inherited from medieval scholastic philosophy, is not merely an aesthetic preference for beautiful theological writing (though von Balthasar's own prose is often noted for its literary and even musical quality, reflecting his serious training in German literature before he entered theology). It is a substantive methodological claim: that a theology which reasons about God's truth and God's goodness while neglecting God's beauty - the sheer, self-evidencing splendor of revelation's own form, which compels attention and wonder before it compels assent to a proposition - has lost something essential to how Christian revelation itself, on von Balthasar's reading of Scripture and the wider Christian tradition, actually presents itself to those who receive it.
3. The real disagreement, stated fairly
This is a point where readers will not agree, and it is a real, specific, published disagreement between two major Catholic theologians who otherwise shared a great deal - a common Jesuit formation, a common commitment to ressourcement retrieval of patristic sources, and a common project of engaging modernity seriously rather than defensively. Von Balthasar's criticism of Rahner's transcendental method, developed most directly in later essays and interviews rather than as a single systematic treatise against Rahner by name, centers on a specific methodological worry: that beginning theology from an analysis of the universal structures of human subjectivity - what must be true about human knowing and freedom as such - risks subordinating God's own free, particular, historically concrete self-revelation in Jesus Christ to a prior philosophical framework about human nature in general, so that revelation's genuine strangeness, its capacity to surprise and exceed what any prior account of human transcendental openness could have anticipated, is at risk of being quietly domesticated into confirmation of a structure theology already expected to find. Von Balthasar worried, more specifically, that the "anonymous Christian" concept, whatever its pastoral and missionary intentions (which von Balthasar did not doubt were sincere), risked treating explicit, historically particular Christian revelation - the actual, contingent, surprising form of God's self-disclosure in the man Jesus of Nazareth - as, in the end, simply one especially clear confirmation of a transcendental openness to God that Rahner's method had already, in some sense, established as present in every human being prior to and apart from that revelation, which von Balthasar thought risked getting the theological order of priority backward: revelation's own particular, concrete form, on von Balthasar's account, should be the starting point theology reasons from, not primarily a confirming instance of a general human structure theology reasons toward.
Rahner's own response, and the response of theologians working in his tradition, was that this criticism understates how carefully Rahner's own account subordinates the transcendental structure to grace and to Christ - the "supernatural existential" is not, on Rahner's account, a natural human capacity discovered independently of grace and revelation, but is itself already a gift of grace, given by God in view of Christ from the very beginning, so that Rahner's method is not smuggling in a Christ-independent philosophical anthropology as von Balthasar's sharpest formulations of the criticism sometimes suggested, but is describing how grace, always already Christocentric in its origin, is universally present and at work even before a person can name it. This course states both sides of that exchange without declaring von Balthasar's criticism simply correct or simply a misreading of Rahner; readers of both theologians' own texts continue to disagree about how fully Rahner's careful qualifications answer von Balthasar's worry, and a fair account of this dispute has to leave that live disagreement in place rather than resolving it on one figure's behalf.
4. What the two share, and how both engage Vatican II
Despite this real methodological difference, Rahner and von Balthasar shared far more than the disagreement above might suggest in isolation. Both were committed to a fully Trinitarian and Christocentric theology, both drew extensively on the patristic ressourcement that shaped Vatican II's documents (studied in the previous lecture), and both served, in different capacities, as theological advisers whose earlier work fed into the council's own theological vocabulary - Rahner as an official peritus (theological expert) at the council itself, directly involved in drafting portions of Lumen Gentium and other documents, and von Balthasar, though not himself a conciliar peritus in the same formal capacity, as a theologian whose earlier work on the concreteness of Christian revelation and on beauty as a theological category influenced the wider theological climate the council's bishops and advisers were working within. Both, in their own ways, embody the chapter's opening claim that postwar Catholic renewal moved toward a more dynamic, historically engaged account of God than a static neo- had offered - Rahner through a theology attentive to the concrete structures of human historical existence and freedom, von Balthasar through a theology attentive to the concrete, particular, historically unrepeatable form of God's self-revelation in Christ - even as they reached that shared destination by two genuinely different roads.
6. Further Reading
- Karl Rahner, Foundations of Christian Faith: An Introduction to the Idea of Christianity, trans. William V. Dych (Crossroad, 1978; German original 1976).
- Karl Rahner, Theological Investigations, multiple volumes, trans. various (Darton, Longman & Todd / Crossroad, 1961-1992) — especially the essays on the "anonymous Christian."
- Hans Urs von Balthasar, The Glory of the Lord: A Theological Aesthetics, 7 vols., trans. various (Ignatius Press, 1982-1991; German original Herrlichkeit, 1961-1969).
- Hans Urs von Balthasar, The Moment of Christian Witness, trans. Richard Beckley (Ignatius Press, 1994; German original 1966) — includes von Balthasar's own reflections on theological method that bear on his disagreement with Rahner's approach.
- Karen Kilby, Karl Rahner: Theology and Philosophy (Routledge, 2004) — includes a careful treatment of the von Balthasar criticism and Rahner's own responses to it.
- Edward T. Oakes, Pattern of Redemption: The Theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar (Continuum, 1997).
In short
- Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar shared Jesuit formation, ressourcement (return to the sources) and a wish to engage modernity seriously. They also disagreed about method, in a disagreement von Balthasar stated in print.
- Rahner's transcendental method asks what must be true of every human knower for revelation to be received. He holds that all people have an openness to God, itself a gift of grace.
- Rahner's "anonymous Christian" is a person who responds to grace without hearing the gospel and may be saved through Christ. He did not mean all religions are equally true, and explicit faith stays fuller.
- Von Balthasar begins with the objective form of revelation, God's "glory," which must first be beheld. He argues for beauty as a third transcendental beside the true and the good.
- Von Balthasar feared Rahner's method makes revelation confirm a prior human structure. Rahner's tradition replies that the structure is already grace, given in view of Christ. The lecture leaves this open.
Topic: Two Catholic theologians, Rahner and von Balthasar, who both answered modernity but began from different places: the human knower and the beauty of God's revelation.
Remember: Rahner starts from the structure of human openness to God. Von Balthasar starts from the particular, perceivable form of revelation in Christ. They share Trinitarian, Christ-centred theology and Vatican II's patristic roots.
Caution: Do not read this as "traditionalist against modernist." Von Balthasar did not doubt Rahner's pastoral sincerity, and readers still disagree about whether Rahner's qualifications answer the criticism.
One line to carry into ministry: Let people meet the beauty and particular shape of Christ first, while trusting that God's grace may be at work in people before they can name it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- State the "anonymous Christian" concept in terms Rahner himself would recognize as a fair description, including what it does not claim about the equal truth of all religions or the importance of explicit Christian faith.
- Von Balthasar argues beauty deserves standing as a genuine theological transcendental alongside truth and goodness. Do you find this a persuasive addition to how theology is usually organized, or would you argue truth and goodness already sufficiently cover what von Balthasar wants beauty to contribute? Explain your reasoning.
- Restate von Balthasar's specific criticism of Rahner's transcendental method in your own words, and then restate the response Rahner's tradition gives to that criticism. Which side do you find more persuasive, and why?
- This lecture notes that Rahner served as an official theological expert (*peritus*) at Vatican II itself, directly involved in drafting conciliar text. Does knowing this change how you read the relationship between his theological method and the council's own documents, discussed in lecture 8-3?
- Von Balthasar draws on Psalms 19:1-4 and 1 John 1:1-3 to argue that Scripture itself treats revelation as something perceived before it is argued. Do you find this scriptural basis for his method persuasive, or could Rahner's transcendental starting point claim equally strong scriptural support from different texts? What might those be?