Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Open a serious book of theology and you soon meet words that Scripture does not use: nature, substance, cause, person, analogy. Some readers feel that such words make a simple faith hard. Others feel that without them theology would go blurred. Both feelings are fair, and this lecture begins between them.
Philosophy, in this course, means the careful study of the most basic questions: what is real, what we can know, what our words mean, how to reason well, and what makes something good or bad. Theology means the study of God and of everything in relation to God, done within the life of faith. The two have been talking for more than two thousand years. They have not always been polite. This lecture asks why the talk cannot simply stop, what four stances a Christian may take toward philosophy, and what each stance risks.
You do not need any training in philosophy for this course. Every technical word is explained in the sentence where it first appears. If a paragraph is hard, you may skip it and still follow the rest.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain what is meant by "faith seeking understanding" and why it calls for distinguishing, defining and giving reasons.
- Give two examples of a question that Scripture raises but does not answer directly, and show why answering it needs a philosophical decision.
- Say why every theologian already uses some philosophy, whether named or not.
- Describe the four stances toward philosophy (enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox) fairly, with one danger of each.
- State the central claim of the course in your own words.
in whom are all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge hidden." — Colossians 2:3
World English Bible
The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge; but the foolish despise wisdom and instruction." — Proverbs 1:7
WEB
Yes, if you call out for discernment, and lift up your voice for understanding; If you seek her as silver, and search for her as for hidden treasures: then you will understand the fear of Yahweh, and find the knowledge of God. For Yahweh gives wisdom. Out of his mouth comes knowledge and understanding." — Proverbs 2:3-6
WEB
What the text says. Colossians 2:3 speaks of Christ as the place where wisdom and knowledge are stored. Proverbs 1:7 ties the beginning of knowledge to reverence for God, and warns against despising instruction. Proverbs 2:3-6 describes the search for understanding with strong pictures: out, seeking silver, searching for hidden treasure. In these verses knowledge is something to seek hard, and also something God gives.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians have read such verses as a licence for the whole work of study: if wisdom is a treasure, then digging is honourable work. Others read them as a reminder that every kind of knowledge sits under God and that the search must begin in reverence. Both readings are common, and they are not opposed.
Our judgement. These verses are not a philosophy textbook, and they do not say what a student should think of Greek or modern philosophy. We use them only to show that Scripture values the seeking of understanding, and that it places that seeking inside a relationship with God. Nothing in this lecture should be taken as a proof from these verses for any one stance toward philosophy.
1. A question the Bible raises and does not settle
Scripture speaks of God as eternal. What does that word mean? One answer is that God lives through endless time, with no beginning and no end, so that for God there is always a "before" and an "after". Another answer is that God is outside time altogether, so that all of time is present to God at once. The Bible's own phrases about God lasting from age to age can be read in either way. Which reading is right? Scripture does not stop to say. Yet the answer changes how we think about prayer, about promises, and about how God knows the future. To choose, a person has to think about what time is. That is already a philosophical question. (We return to it in week 3.)
Here is a second example. Scripture uses the word know in many ways. A believer's knowing that her Redeemer lives is not the same kind of knowing as knowing that two plus two is four. When a believer says "I know that God loves me", is that knowing, or believing, or trusting, or something that includes all three? What is the difference, and does it matter? To answer, a person must ask what knowing is. That is another philosophical question. (We take it up in week 2.)
These two examples are not tricks. They are ordinary questions that any serious reader of the Bible meets sooner or later. The Bible gives the reader words and stories. It does not always say how those words fit together or what they mean when a hard question is pressed. When a student does press such a question, philosophy has arrived, whether or not anyone invited it.
2. Faith seeking understanding
A phrase that Christians have used for many centuries is faith seeking understanding. It means that a believer, having trusted God, wants also to understand what is believed: to see how the parts hang together, to know what is being claimed and what is not, and to answer honest questions. The phrase is old, and writers in the Western church have used it a great deal. Notice what it does not say. It does not say that understanding comes first and then faith follows as a reward. It does not say that faith is complete only when every question is answered. It says that faith, being alive, asks questions.
Seeking understanding involves three simple activities, and all three are tools of philosophy.
- Distinguishing. To distinguish is to separate two things that look alike. Example: a doctor says a patient is "recovering" and "cured". These are different, and a good doctor knows the difference. In theology, a writer may need to distinguish knowing about God from knowing God.
- Defining. To define is to say exactly what a word means in this place. Example: a recipe says "a cup of flour". Which cup? A cook who does not ask will spoil the bread. In theology, a word like nature or person needs a definition before an argument can use it.
- Giving reasons. To give a reason is to say why we hold a belief, so that another person can examine it. Example: "I take an umbrella because the clouds are dark and the forecast says rain." A person who gives a reason can be answered, and a person who gives none cannot.
A student of theology who does these three things carefully is already doing philosophy at a simple level.
3. Everyone already uses some philosophy
It may seem that a believer could avoid philosophy by reading Scripture and stopping there. But reading Scripture already involves choices that philosophy studies. When you read a story, you assume that words refer to things, that sentences can be true or false, that cause is followed by effect, and that an earlier event can be told about in a later one. When you move from "the text says this" to "so we should believe that", you are reasoning. When you decide that a word is literal and another is picture language, you are making a judgement about how words work.
So the real question is not whether a theologian uses philosophy. Every theologian does. The question is whether the philosophy is named or unnamed, careful or careless. An unnamed assumption is like a pair of glasses worn so long that the wearer forgets they are on. It may be a good pair or a bad pair, but it shapes everything seen. A useful part of studying philosophy is to notice the glasses. This is not to throw them away. It is to know what they do.
An invented example. A teacher says to a class, "God cannot change, because God is perfect." A student asks, "But the Bible says God 'relented'. Does God change or not?" The teacher's sentence depends on an unnamed assumption: that a perfect being must be unchanging, since any change would be a move toward something better or worse. That assumption has a long history, and some thinkers have questioned it. The student's question is not disrespectful. It is a request to name the assumption.
4. Four stances toward philosophy
Christians have taken different attitudes toward philosophy. It helps to name four. The names are not official; they are a map. Each stance has had thoughtful holders and each has a real concern behind it.
1. Philosophy as an enemy. On this view, human thought, left to itself, tends to drift away from God, and philosophy is the clearest example. The concern behind this stance is real: it wants to keep the faith from being replaced by a human system, and it points to Scripture's warnings about being led astray by empty talk. The danger of the stance is that nobody can think without some philosophy. A person who rejects philosophy may simply carry an unnamed one, and so be less able to notice and correct it. Fear of philosophy can also turn into fear of questions, and then into fear of the people who ask them.
2. Philosophy as a servant. On this view, philosophy is a tool that supports the faith. It prepares the way, helps to explain doctrine, and answers critics. The concern behind this stance is also real: it takes seriously that God made the mind, and that true thinking cannot be at odds with God in the end. The danger of the stance is that the servant may become the master without anyone noticing. If a particular philosophical system is treated as the framework in which doctrine must be put, then doctrine may quietly be bent to fit it. And a servant who is only told to say "yes" is not much use as a check.
3. Philosophy as a conversation partner. On this view, philosophy and theology talk with each other as two disciplines with their own ways of working. Each asks questions of the other. Philosophy may challenge a theological claim, and theology may challenge a philosophical assumption. The concern behind this stance is honesty: neither side is protected from the other. The danger is that "conversation" can become a polite word for never deciding anything, or for treating the two as equal when the believer holds that revelation has a different kind of authority.
4. Philosophy as a toolbox. On this view, philosophy is not a school with a message but a set of tools: distinctions, definitions, ways of testing an argument. A carpenter may use a saw made by someone who does not share her faith. The concern behind this stance is practical: use what helps, and do not accept a whole system to get a single useful tool. The danger is that tools are not always neutral. A tool is made for some kind of job, and it may carry the habits of the one who made it. A saw cuts wood well; it does not carve glass.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Thoughtful Christians in every tradition disagree about which of these stances is best, and about how far each is a fair summary of their own tradition. Some Protestant writers have been wary of philosophy, fearing that it may take the place of Scripture, while others, in the same streams, have used it freely. Many Catholic writers have spoken of faith and reason as two partners that work together, and the church has long taught that reason can reach some truths about God. Many Orthodox writers stress that God is beyond all human concepts, and that theology is first of all prayer and worship, though the Eastern church has also used philosophical tools with great skill. Within each tradition there are people who would choose each of the four stances at different times. The strongest argument for suspicion is that philosophy has often been used to explain away what Scripture says plainly. The strongest argument for welcome is that suspicion does not remove philosophy, it only hides it. The weak point of suspicion is that it may leave a person defenceless against an unnamed assumption. The weak point of welcome is that it may hand to philosophy a role that belongs to revelation. This course requires less than any one tradition requires. It asks only that you can describe each stance fairly, see its danger, and give reasons for your own view.
5. The claim this course will keep making
All six weeks return to one claim:
Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle theology's conclusions. Christians do not shun philosophy as an enemy, nor use it as a servant. They borrow its tools (distinctions, definitions, arguments) and know their limits; they do not close the relation of reason, revelation and faith with one formula; and they ask honestly, listening to the paths that Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Christians have each walked.
Read slowly, the claim has four parts. First, theology needs philosophy: it cannot do without distinctions, definitions and reasons. Second, philosophy does not decide the conclusions: being clever does not make a claim true, and a clever argument against a doctrine does not by itself end the matter. Third, tools with limits: we borrow, we test, and we keep in mind what a tool was made for. Fourth, no single formula: the relation of reason, revelation and faith has not been closed with one sentence, and different Christians have given different accounts of it.
This lecture is the beginning of that claim, not the proof of it. In the next three lectures we see how the claim looks in history: in the early church, in the Middle Ages, and from the Reformation to today.
6. What this course does not do
It does not train you in apologetics, the defence of the faith to outsiders; a separate course on Christian apologetics does that, and here arguments appear as exercises in reading, not as ways of winning. It does not survey modern theologians; that is another course. It does not teach general writing and research skills, or the doctrines of God, the and Christ themselves; the doctrine courses do those. It looks only at how doctrine has borrowed philosophical words. And it does not ask you to become a philosopher.
Diagram 1. Four stances toward philosophy
In short
- Faith seeking understanding asks questions, and distinguishing, defining and giving reasons are tools of philosophy.
- Scripture raises questions it does not settle, such as what "eternal" or "know" means, and answering them needs philosophical decisions.
- Every theologian uses some philosophy; the choice is between named and unnamed, careful and careless.
- Four stances are enemy, servant, conversation partner and toolbox, each with a real concern and a real danger.
- Readers disagree about which stance is best; the course asks only that you describe each fairly and give reasons for your own view.
- Theology needs philosophy, but philosophy does not settle theology's conclusions.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Faith seeking understanding | A believer who trusts God also wants to understand what is believed; faith, being alive, asks questions. |
| Three tools | Distinguishing, defining and giving reasons: the simple tools of philosophy used in theology. |
| Four stances | Enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox; each has a real concern and a danger. |
| Named or unnamed | Everyone uses some philosophy; naming it lets us test it instead of being ruled by it unseen. |
One sentence to remember Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle what theology concludes.
This week's action Write down one word from your tradition's teaching that Scripture does not use, and say in one sentence what it means.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a word in your own tradition's teaching that is not found in Scripture. Why do you think it was needed? What would be lost if it were dropped?
- In the example of "eternal", what is the difference between endless time and being outside time? Which does your own tradition's way of speaking lean toward, if it leans at all?
- Think of an unnamed assumption you have met in a sermon, a lesson or a book. What would naming it help you to do?
- Which of the four stances do you meet most often in your own community? What is its real concern, and what is its danger?
- In what way does "faith seeking understanding" differ from "understanding first, then faith"?