Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Another old way of speaking of God works by saying what God is not. God is not limited, not a body, not subject to change or death, not like anything we can point to. This is called the negative way (the Greek-derived word apophatic is often used; the positive way is kataphatic). It is a path of careful denial, and in its deepest form it ends in silence before a mystery that words cannot hold.
This lecture explains the idea in plain terms. It describes how the Eastern church and the mystics of the West used it (only points that are sure), sets out the three ways of affirmation, negation and eminence, and asks about humility and confidence in theology. It then turns to the incarnation, and compares, as two traditions would describe themselves, what a Reformed emphasis on God's revealed name and an Orthodox emphasis on the icon each hold. The traditions are not ranked. A student may skip the paragraph on icons without losing the rest.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain the negative way, with an example of a statement that says what God is not.
- Name the three ways (affirmation, negation, eminence) and say in a sentence what each does.
- Describe, using sure points only, how Eastern writers and Western mystics used the negative way.
- Explain how humility and confidence both belong to theology, and name the danger of each when it stands alone.
- State fairly the Reformed emphasis on God's revealed name and the Orthodox emphasis on the icon, with a weak point of each.
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways,” says Yahweh." — Isaiah 55:8
World English Bible
For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part, but then I will know fully, even as I was also fully known." — 1 Corinthians 13:12
WEB
You asked, ‘Who is this who hides counsel without knowledge?’ therefore I have uttered that which I did not understand, things too wonderful for me, which I didn’t know." — Job 42:3
WEB
What the text says. Isaiah 55:8 says that God's thoughts are not ours. In 1 Corinthians 13:12 Paul says that now we see as in a mirror and know in part, and that a time comes of knowing fully. In Job 42:3 Job answers God from the whirlwind, and says that he has spoken of things he did not understand and that were too wonderful for him.
A tradition's reading. Many readers in the Eastern church hear in these verses the ground of a theology that is humble before mystery. Many Protestant readers hear in them a limit on speculation, and a call to rest in what God has said. Many Catholic readers hear in them what Aquinas also stressed, that what we know of God is little beside what we do not. Job 42:3 is read in more than one way: as repentance, as the end of a long argument, or as a turn from speaking about God to meeting him; the closing verses of the book are also part of the discussion.
Our judgement. These verses do not tell us to stop speaking of God. They tell us to speak as people who see "in part". They fit the negative way, but they do not prove it.
1. Saying what God is not
Imagine you are describing a person to someone who has never seen him. You might say what he looks like. You might also say what he is not: he is not tall, not young, not hurried. Sometimes it is easier, and more honest, to say what a thing is not than what it is. If someone has never seen the sea, and you tell them it is not a river, not a lake, not a pond, not a puddle, you have said nothing about what the sea is, yet their mind has been moved in the right direction.
The negative way does something like this about God, but it does it from respect, not from ignorance. God is called invisible: not able to be seen. Immortal: not able to die. Infinite: without limit. Unchanging: not growing or shrinking. Even these words are made by putting not in front of a human word. Scripture and the creeds use many of them. So the negative way is not a strange habit of a few mystics. Almost every Christian tradition says some of these things.
What the negative way adds is a conviction about what these denials are for. The aim is to clear the mind of small pictures. If I say God is not a body, I take away a picture that may mislead me. If I say God is not limited by place, I remove the idea that God is like a very large person far away. After many denials, the mind is not left with a new picture. It is left with a sense that God exceeds every picture.
2. The Eastern tradition
Writers in the Eastern church have given this way a large place. A few points are sure. The writer who is called Dionysius the Areopagite (the name is from the convert in Acts 17:34, but the books were written much later, probably about the year 500) wrote on the divine names and on a mystical theology that moves through affirmation and denial toward unknowing. Gregory of Nyssa, in the fourth century, wrote of Moses climbing into darkness on the mountain as a picture of the soul coming to know God by knowing that it cannot know him fully. Gregory Palamas, in the fourteenth century, is a central figure for the Orthodox teaching that God in his essence is beyond all knowing, while God's energies (his acts and presence toward us) can be truly met. An Orthodox reader would say much more than this, and would stress that this theology is lived in worship and prayer, not only studied.
3. The Western mystics
The negative way is also found in the West. Thomas Aquinas, as we saw, taught that we know more about what God is not than what God is. The English book The Cloud of Unknowing (written in the fourteenth century by an unknown author) teaches the reader to put a cloud of forgetting beneath him and a cloud of unknowing between himself and God, and to reach toward God by love when thought cannot reach. John of the Cross, in the sixteenth century, wrote of the dark night in which the soul loses its supports and is led to God. Writers in each tradition have used these books; some have also been cautious about them. The point here is only that the idea is not limited to one tradition.
4. Three ways
Many writers who use the negative way do not use it alone. A pattern that goes back to the medieval period speaks of three ways.
- Affirmation. We say what is true of God from what Scripture says and from what creatures show: God is good, wise, a shepherd, a king. This follows the pictures and analogies of lectures 4-1 and 4-2.
- Negation. We then deny that God is these in the way we are: God is not good as a creature is good, not wise by learning. Each affirmation is checked by a denial.
- Eminence. Last, we say that God is these things in a way that goes beyond: God is good beyond all goodness we know, not less than it but more.
The three do not form a staircase to be climbed once. They work together in each sentence. When a believer says, "God is wise", she affirms. If she is thoughtful, she also remembers that this is not wisdom as we have it. And she praises: it is wisdom beyond what she can imagine. Often a good prayer does all three in a breath.
5. Humility and confidence
The negative way teaches humility. It reminds the teacher that she is speaking of someone who is not in her grasp, and it stops a theology that is too sure of itself. In a classroom or a pulpit it can protect against a kind of cleverness that talks about God as if God were an exhibit.
The negative way can also be misused. If it is the only way, the danger is that silence becomes an excuse. A person may say, "No one can say anything about God," and stop learning, or use the word "mystery" to avoid a question that can in fact be answered. Scripture does speak, the church confesses, and Christians pray with words. Praying to a God of whom nothing can be said is hard. Many Christians who value the negative way therefore insist that it must be joined to affirmation: it corrects speech; it does not forbid it.
The opposite danger belongs to confidence that stands alone. A theology that says everything, defines every term and answers every question may give the impression that God has been mapped. Real confidence rests on what God has done and said; it does not claim to see all of God. The healthy state is both: sure of what has been shown, humble about what has not.
6. What the incarnation gives
Christians say that God has not left us with words alone. The Word became flesh (John 1:14, taken up in lecture 4-4). Something that could be seen and heard has been given. How this bears on speaking of God is a place where two traditions give different accents.
This is a point where readers will not agree on how the shapes the way we speak of and picture God. The Reformed emphasis, as its writers would describe it, is on God's revealed name and Word. God has told us who he is, in a name and in Scripture and in Christ, and our speech and worship should stay close to what God has said. For this reason the Reformed tradition has historically been cautious about images of God, reading the commandment against making images as a guard against giving God a shape of our own. The strength of this emphasis is that it keeps speech tied to revelation and guards against idols made by imagination. Its weak point, in the eyes of critics, is that it may seem not to use fully what the incarnation gave: that in Christ God was seen, and that sight and matter have a place in knowing God.
The Orthodox emphasis, as its writers would describe it, is on the icon. Because the Word became flesh and was seen, Christ can be depicted, and the icon confesses that the incarnation is real. The seventh council (held at Nicaea in the eighth century) taught that icons may be venerated, with a distinction between the honour given to an image and the worship that belongs to God alone. In this view the icon is a kind of theology in colour, and it keeps the believer from thinking of God only as an idea. The strength of this emphasis is that it takes the incarnation, and the body, seriously in worship. Its weak point, in the eyes of critics, is the worry that honour paid to an image may slide into worship of the image, and that the use of images may reach beyond what Scripture said.
Other Christians hold other positions. The Catholic tradition also uses images, with the same distinction between honour and worship; many Lutheran and Anglican churches use images; and within the Reformed family there are many views today. Neither emphasis is a rejection of the incarnation, and each holds that the incarnation changes how we speak. This course does not require you to side with either. It requires that you can say what each wants to protect: the one, God's own Word as the measure of our speech; the other, the reality of God made visible in Christ.
7. How the three fit
Put together, this week so far gives a picture. Scripture and the Church speak of God in pictures (lecture 4-1) and by analogy (4-2). They also deny, and wait in silence (4-3). The incarnation means that God has given a human face and a human voice, so the silence is not empty. A person who prays after Isaiah 55 and 1 Corinthians 13 may use all of these: affirming with the Psalms, denying with Job, and trusting that what is seen in a mirror now will one day be seen face to face.
Diagram 1. The three ways, and the two emphases
In short
- The negative way speaks of God by saying what God is not: invisible, infinite, unchanging.
- Eastern writers and Western mystics have both used it; many Christians use some of it without naming it.
- Affirmation, negation and eminence work together: say it, deny the creaturely sense, and praise beyond.
- Humility without speech can become silence as an excuse; confidence without humility can make God an exhibit.
- The Reformed emphasis on God's revealed name and the Orthodox emphasis on the icon are described here in their own terms, each with a weak point.
- These verses suggest speaking "in part"; they do not prove a single theory.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The negative way | Speaking of God by saying what God is not, to clear the mind of small pictures. |
| Affirmation, negation, eminence | Say what is true; deny the creaturely sense; praise beyond what we know. They work together. |
| Danger of negation alone / confidence alone | Silence as an excuse for not thinking; treating God as an exhibit that has been mapped. |
| Two emphases on the incarnation | Reformed: God's revealed name and Word. Orthodox: the icon. Each has a weak point critics name. |
One sentence to remember Good speech about God says what it can, says what it must not mean, and keeps a place for silence.
This week's action Before your next prayer or lesson, say aloud one thing you will affirm of God, one thing you will deny, and then stay silent for a minute.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- List three things we say God is not. What picture does each remove, and what does it leave?
- Take the sentence "God is loving" and run it through affirmation, negation and eminence. What did each step add?
- When is silence before God a form of respect, and when might it be a way of avoiding a hard question?
- State the Reformed emphasis on the revealed name in a way a Reformed reader would accept. Then state the Orthodox emphasis on the icon in a way an Orthodox reader would accept. What does each want to protect?
- How do 1 Corinthians 13:12 and Job 42:3 each help, and what do they not decide?