Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
So far we have talked about knowing as if each person stood alone, weighing reasons. That is not how knowing mostly happens. You know your own birthday because others told you. You know the way to a distant city from a map made by people you will never meet. You trust a doctor with a body whose workings you have not studied. Most of what any of us knows, we know because someone else said it, and we trusted them. Theology is the same, and more so: faith, in all traditions, is handed on.
This lecture looks at three things that shape knowing but are easy to overlook. First, testimony: knowing from the word of another. Second, community: the way a church, with its creed, worship and shared reading of Scripture, is a place where knowing grows. Third, virtue: the idea that the character of the knower, such as humility, patience and honesty, shapes how well a person knows. The lecture ends with two dangers, false certainty and paralysing doubt, and with some plain things a student of theology can do.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain why much of what we know rests on testimony, and how to trust a source well without being careless.
- Describe how a church, through creed, worship and the reading of Scripture, can be a community in which knowing grows.
- Explain virtue epistemology in a few sentences and name three intellectual virtues and a matching vice.
- Describe false certainty and paralysing doubt and say what each does to a learner.
- Name two practical steps a student can take, and say what Scripture says, what a tradition reads and what we judge about the Emmaus story.
They said one to another, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?”" — Luke 24:32
World English Bible
The heart of the discerning gets knowledge. The ear of the wise seeks knowledge." — Proverbs 18:15
WEB
But you remain in the things which you have learned and have been assured of, knowing from whom you have learned them." — 2 Timothy 3:14
WEB
From infancy, you have known the holy Scriptures which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith, which is in Christ Jesus." — 2 Timothy 3:15
WEB
What the text says. In Luke 24, two disciples walking to Emmaus meet the risen Jesus without knowing him. They speak of how their hearts burned while he opened the Scriptures along the road. They recognise him when he takes bread, gives thanks and breaks it (verses 30-31). Proverbs 18:15 pairs the "heart" and the "ear" of the discerning, as if knowing needs both thinking and listening. In 2 Timothy 3:14-15, Paul reminds Timothy to hold to what he has learned and to remember from whom he learned it, and that from infancy he has known the Scriptures.
What traditions read. Many traditions see in the Emmaus story a pattern of the Word opened and the bread broken, and so find in it a picture of the church's worship, with the reading of Scripture and the meal together. Traditions that celebrate the Eucharist or Divine weekly, and traditions centred on the preaching of the word, each find themselves in the story, in different ways. In 2 Timothy 3:14-15, some readers stress the handing-on from person to person, and others the place of Scripture itself; most readers hold both.
Our judgement. These verses were not written as a theory of knowledge. We use them here as pictures of something that our everyday experience also shows: that people come to know in company, by being taught and by being walked with. Nothing in our lecture requires one tradition's reading of the Emmaus story over another's.
1. Knowing from the word of another
Ask yourself how you know each of these things: the date of your birth, that the earth goes round the sun, that a medicine is safe at a given dose, that a faraway country exists, that you are the child of your parents. For most of them you have not checked for yourself. Someone told you, or you read it, and you trusted the one who said it. This is called testimony: knowing from the word of someone else.
Testimony is not a poor second kind of knowing. If we refused to rely on it, we would know almost nothing. Knowledge across a family, a nation or a century is built from it. But it can go wrong. A rumour is testimony. So is a false advertisement. Trusting testimony is therefore not a matter of believing everything, nor a matter of believing nothing. It is a matter of trusting well.
How do we trust well? Here are questions that reasonable people ask, mostly without noticing, of a source.
- Was the speaker in a position to know? A neighbour who saw the accident is a better source than one who heard of it.
- Is the speaker honest and careful? Has this person been right before?
- Do others who know agree? Does the claim fit with what else I know?
- Does the speaker gain from my believing? That is not a reason to reject the claim, only to look more carefully.
(an invented example) A visitor to a village is told by three different people that the bus to the city leaves at eight. She believes it, because three people who use the bus say the same, and the time fits what she saw on the road sign. If one person had told her it left at eight and another at noon, she would have asked for more. Here, ordinary good sense is working.
2. The church as a community of knowing
In every Christian tradition, a person comes to faith largely through others. Someone speaks, teaches, prays, sings, lives in a certain way. Paul writes, as we saw in lecture 2-2, that faith comes by hearing. A child hears the Lord's Prayer long before she can explain it. A convert hears a witness. A student reads books written by those who came before. This is testimony of a particular kind: the handing-on of what is believed to be true.
The church's way of handing on includes more than speaking. Consider three things that nearly every tradition, in different forms, shares.
- The creed. A creed is a short statement of what the church believes, said together. It is a kind of shared testimony: "this is what we have received." A person who says a creed aloud is not necessarily saying "I have proved each line." Often they are saying "I stand with those who have handed this on, and I am willing to be taught further." Different traditions use creeds in different ways, and some do not use written creeds in worship at all. What they have in common is a body of teaching received from others.
- Worship. Praying, singing, hearing the word, sharing a meal: these are ways of knowing God as well as speaking about him. Some traditions stress the ; some the preaching; some the Spirit's moving in the assembly. Each describes the knowing it expects in its own words.
- The shared reading of Scripture. A person who reads alone may miss what a community, with its many ages and experiences, sees together. The traditions differ on how much weight the community's reading carries, and we have met that difference in earlier lectures. Almost all agree that reading with others and learning from earlier readers is a good thing and a protection against private mistakes.
A community can also be wrong, and a witness can be flawed. The church has at times taught error and at times resisted correction. Trusting a community is not turning off one's mind. It is a way of using the mind in company.
3. Virtue and knowing
A recent branch of epistemology is called virtue epistemology. A virtue is a settled quality of character that makes a person good at something, built by practice. Ancient and Christian writers on character long spoke of virtues of conduct; here we apply the word to thinking. The idea is that how well a person knows depends partly on their character, not just on how clever they are or how much evidence is at hand. A philosopher named Linda Zagzebski has written a well-known book on this theme, which is listed in the Further Reading.
Some intellectual virtues:
- Humility: to know what one does not know, and to be ready to learn from anyone.
- Patience: to stay with a hard question without rushing to an answer.
- Honesty: to follow the evidence where it leads, even when one does not like it, and to say "I do not know."
- Carefulness: to check, and to read the whole passage, not only the sentence one wants.
- Open-mindedness: to listen fairly to a view one does not hold.
- Courage: to say a true thing when it is unpopular, or to ask a question when others are silent.
Each has a matching vice: pride, hurry, dishonesty, carelessness, closed-mindedness and cowardice. A very learned person can be proud and a poorly educated one can be wise. Proverbs 18:15 shows something like this: the discerning heart gets knowledge and the wise ear seeks it. Seeking and listening are part of the picture.
It would be a mistake to say that a person with these virtues cannot be wrong. They can. But a person with these virtues tends to notice error sooner and to correct it more kindly. And it would be an equal mistake to say that a person who lacks them cannot say true things. The claim is modest: character shapes knowing.
4. Two dangers: false certainty and paralysing doubt
Two opposite failings trouble many students and teachers of theology.
False certainty is claiming more confidence than the grounds support. It sounds firm. It often arrives with a loud voice and a long list of "obviously" and "everyone knows". It can come from fear, since certainty feels safe. It can come from loyalty, since a group may reward those who sound sure. It does damage when it shuts out questions, silences others or leads someone to act on a belief that was never tested. A person caught in false certainty may mistake a feeling for a standard (lecture 2-1).
Paralysing doubt is the refusal ever to settle. The person says, "Nobody can know anything about God," and stops. Perhaps they have been hurt by false certainty; perhaps they are tired. Doubt of this kind is not wicked, and many honest people live through it. But it can become a hiding place, where the question is never faced. In ordinary life we act on good reasons without having certainty. No farmer waits for proof of the harvest before he sows.
Between them lies a path that is neither loud nor frozen: a settled but open confidence, held according to the grounds, ready to give reasons, ready to listen and ready to be corrected. Many people find that the virtues listed above are the things that keep a person on that path.
5. What a student of theology can do
Here are some plain steps. None is a rule; each is an invitation.
- Notice whose word you rely on. For each important belief you hold, ask: who told me, and were they in a position to know? This is not to doubt them. It is to know where your knowledge came from.
- Read with others. Join a study group, or ask someone from another tradition to tell you how they read a passage. Be a listener first.
- Practise one virtue at a time. For a week, try only to say "I do not know" when it is true. Or try to state a view you disagree with so that its holder would agree you had got it right.
- Check the source and the whole passage. Before repeating a quotation or a claim, ask where it comes from and what comes before and after it.
- Let the question be a question. If you meet something you cannot yet resolve, you can hold it open without shame.
These are small steps. Knowing grows slowly, and usually in company.
Diagram 1. How we come to know: three supports and two dangers
In short
- Most of what we know rests on the word of others; trusting well asks whether a source was in a position to know, is honest and is agreed with by others who know.
- The church hands on knowing through creed, worship and the shared reading of Scripture, which can guard against private error, though a community can also be wrong.
- Virtue epistemology holds that character shapes knowing; humility, patience, honesty, carefulness, open-mindedness and courage help, and pride, hurry and closed-mindedness harm.
- False certainty claims more than the grounds allow; paralysing doubt refuses ever to settle.
- A settled but open confidence is held according to the grounds, ready to give reasons and to be corrected.
- A student can notice whose word they rely on, read with others, practise one virtue and let a question stay open.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Testimony | Knowing from the word of another; not a poor kind of knowing, but it must be trusted well. |
| Three ways a church hands on knowing | The creed, worship and the shared reading of Scripture. |
| Virtue epistemology | The idea that character, such as humility, patience and honesty, shapes how well a person knows. |
| Two dangers | False certainty, which claims more than the grounds allow, and paralysing doubt, which refuses to settle. |
One sentence to remember We know in company, by the word of others and the life of a community, and the character of the knower helps or hinders.
This week's action For one belief you hold, write down who told you, and whether they were in a position to know.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of three things you know only because someone told you. How did you decide to trust them? What would have made you doubt?
- What does a person do when they say a creed aloud with others? Is it the same as saying "I have proved each line"? How might traditions answer differently?
- Which intellectual virtue is the hardest for you to practise: humility, patience, honesty, carefulness, open-mindedness or courage? What helps?
- Which is the greater danger in your own place, false certainty or paralysing doubt? What might a settled but open confidence look like there?
- Read Luke 24:30-32 again. Separate what the text says, how a tradition reads it and what you judge. Where do the three blur?