FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil

Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction

Contents 31
STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
  3. Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
  4. Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
  1. Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
  3. Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
  4. Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
  2. Lecture 4-2: Analogy
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
  4. Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
  2. Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
  3. Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
  4. Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More
  3. Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross
  4. Lecture 6-4: Neither Enemy nor Servant: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Philosophy and My Theology on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Christians often say that some things about God are a mystery. Critics sometimes say that some Christian teachings are a contradiction. A teacher in the middle may say it is a paradox. These three words are often used as if they meant the same thing, and they do not. If we confuse them, one of two errors follows. We may use "mystery" to stop thinking whenever a question gets hard. Or we may take every puzzle as proof that a teaching is nonsense.

This lecture explains the three words, shows the logical structure of the charge that the Trinity and the incarnation are contradictory and of the usual replies, and says why mystery must not be an excuse and why argument cannot dissolve every mystery. It does not set out the doctrines themselves: what Christians believe about the Trinity and about Christ belongs to the doctrine courses. We look only at how the argument about them is built. It ends with a short habit for teaching and speaking kindly, and a one-page tool for reading a theological text.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Define contradiction, paradox and mystery, each with an everyday example.
  • Explain why a statement is not contradictory when its terms are used in different senses or respects.
  • Describe the structure of the charge that the Trinity and the incarnation are contradictory and the usual reply, and say where each side feels the weak point.
  • Explain why "mystery" must not be used to stop reasoning, and why argument cannot remove every mystery.
  • Use a one-page tool to read a theological text.

Come now, and let us reason together,” says Yahweh: “Though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow. Though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool." — Isaiah 1:18

World English Bible

But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear:" — 1 Peter 3:15

WEB

Brothers, don’t be children in thoughts, yet in malice be babies, but in thoughts be mature." — 1 Corinthians 14:20

WEB

What the text says. In Isaiah 1:18 God invites the people to "reason together", and the verse goes on with a contrast between sin and cleansing. The words of invitation are found in a passage that is also about justice and judgement; the verse should be read in that setting. First Peter 3:15 tells its readers to be ready to give "an answer" and "a reason" concerning their hope, "with humility and fear". The same verse sets this readiness beside reverence in the heart. In 1 Corinthians 14:20 Paul tells his readers not to be children in their thoughts and yet to be babies in malice, which sets maturity of mind beside innocence of heart.

A tradition's reading. Many readers take these verses to support careful thinking and the giving of reasons, joined to reverence and gentleness. Some read Isaiah 1:18 as a legal summons to a hearing, and not mainly as an invitation to philosophical debate; others read it as an invitation to talk together. Readers in the Orthodox and mystical traditions often stress the reverence of 1 Peter 3:15, and readers in the scholastic tradition the readiness to give a reason. Each would say the other emphasis is also present.

Our judgement. These verses do not tell us how a particular doctrine should be defended, and none of them says that a doctrine can or cannot be shown to be free of contradiction. They do give a spirit for the work: thought and humility together.

1. Three words

Contradiction. A contradiction is a statement that says something both is and is not so, in the same sense and at the same time. "This table is square and this table is not square", said of one table in one sense, is a contradiction. A contradiction cannot be true. It is not a deep truth in disguise: whatever it says, it says nothing coherent. If a teaching really were a contradiction in this strict sense, we should have to give it up or restate it.

Paradox. A paradox is a statement that seems to be a contradiction, or that goes against what we expect, but is not on a closer look. Everyday examples: "He was the youngest person in the room and the oldest in his family." That sounds odd, but it is not contradictory, because "in the room" and "in his family" are two different groups. "Less is more", said of a short sermon that moved the listeners, is a paradox: it seems to say the opposite of itself, and what it means is that in one respect (length) there was less and in another (effect) there was more. The key to most paradoxes is to ask: in what respect? Once the respects are separated, the apparent contradiction goes away. Scripture and Christian writing are full of paradox: strength in weakness, losing a life to find it. Often the paradox is a way of making a reader stop and look again.

Mystery. A mystery, in the sense used by theology, is a truth whose depth is more than we can take in, even though we may be able to say true things about it. Everyday example: a small child can say that the sun gives light and warmth and that it is very far away, and say it truly, though the child does not understand what the sun is. Mystery does not mean "something unintelligible" or "a puzzle that will be solved when we try harder". It means something real that exceeds our grasp, such that our words reach it truly and never fully. In the Christian tradition, Eastern and Western alike, to call something a mystery is to say that we can speak truly of it, and that we cannot speak exhaustively.

The three are different. A contradiction says nothing. A paradox seems to say two opposite things, and a careful distinction shows that it does not. A mystery says something true and leaves more unsaid. The trouble comes when we put the wrong label on a statement. Someone may call a real contradiction "a mystery" to protect it, or call a mystery "a contradiction" because they cannot see the whole of it.

2. Why terms and respects matter

Most of the logic of this lecture comes down to one habit: look at the words, and ask whether they are used in the same sense and respect in each place.

(An invented example.) A woman is a daughter and a mother. Is that a contradiction? A daughter is someone's child; a mother has a child. Both are said of the same woman, and no one thinks a contradiction has been found, because "daughter of" and "mother of" are different relations, to different people. A man may be both a teacher and a student, since he is a teacher of some and a student of others. The same person is said to have two roles, in two respects.

Now suppose that someone says, "The bridge is long and the bridge is not long." A listener asks: long for a footbridge, perhaps, and short for a river bridge? Or long compared to the road? If the speaker means one thing in the first sentence and another in the second, the contradiction is only on the surface. If the speaker means exactly the same in both, the statement is a contradiction and cannot be true.

So the question for any apparent contradiction is: Are the words used in the same sense and the same respect? If yes, it is a real contradiction. If no, it may be a paradox, and then we ask whether the distinction is a fair one or is only a trick to escape.

3. The charge, and the reply: an overview of the structure

Critics have said that the Christian teaching about the and the is self-contradictory. Defenders have replied. We look at the shape of the argument on each side, and not at the doctrines as such; their content, and the Scriptures and councils behind them, belong to the doctrine courses. The purpose is to practise reading an argument about a hard doctrine.

The charge about the Trinity, in its structure. The critic says: Christians say the Father is God, the Son is God, and the Spirit is God. They also say the Father is not the Son, and the Son is not the Spirit. And they say there is one God. If "is God" means "is identical with God", then the Father, the Son and the Spirit would all be identical with the one God, and so with one another, which contradicts the claim that they are not the same. If instead there are three who are God, then there are three Gods, which contradicts "one God". So, the critic concludes, either way there is a contradiction.

The reply, in its structure. The defender says: the critic has used "is God" and "is not the Son" in only one sense. In the Christian statement, one word (traditionally, "nature" or "being") answers the question "what is God?", and another (traditionally, "person") answers the question "who is the Father, who the Son, who the Spirit?" Thus "the Father is God" says that the Father has the divine nature, not that the Father is identical with the whole of God. "The Father is not the Son" says that they are distinct as persons, not that they differ in nature. The two sentences are said in different respects, so there is no "same thing both is and is not". The defender adds that the church chose its words carefully for this purpose.

Where each side feels the weak point. The critic says that the distinction between nature and person is brought in after the fact to escape the charge, and that the words are used so that they cannot be tested. The defender says that the distinction was not invented to escape an objection; it came from an attempt to say what the whole witness of Scripture and worship required. The defender also feels a weak point on their own side: the words "person" and "nature" are old words, and their meaning is not the same today as in the ancient world, so one must be careful. Defenders do not all agree about how best to state the distinction, and several different models are discussed by theologians and philosophers.

The charge about the incarnation, in its structure. The critic says: Christians say that Jesus Christ is God and that he is a man. God is not limited by place or by time, and a man is. So the same one is limited and not limited, which is a contradiction.

The reply, in its structure. The defender says: the statements are made in different respects. The church has taught that Christ is one person who has two natures, divine and human, and that what is true of one nature is said of the person in that respect. So "limited" is said in respect of the human nature, and "not limited" in respect of the divine, and the one person is not limited and unlimited in the same respect. This is the shape of the teaching given by the in the fifth century.

Where each side feels the weak point. The critic asks whether one person can really have such opposite properties, even in different respects, and whether "respects" is a way to say two things and hold neither. The defender replies that some very ordinary things have properties in different respects, as a person may be at once a seeker and a finder; but the defender also admits that the incarnation is unlike anything else, so that ordinary examples can only point.

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether these replies succeed. Some philosophers and theologians hold that the distinction of respects, carefully drawn, shows that the central statements are free of contradiction, and that this is all the logical charge requires. Their strongest reason is that a contradiction needs the same thing said and denied in the same respect, and this is not done. Others hold that the replies do not succeed, because they think the distinctions are either empty or bring in new difficulties. A third group, found especially in the Eastern tradition and among some Western mystics, would say that the proper response to these doctrines is adoration and silence before a mystery, and that the whole exercise of testing them for contradiction asks too much of logic. The first view is weak if it makes the doctrine seem fully tamed. The second is weak if it assumes that the terms are used in the same sense without having shown it. The third is weak if it is used to avoid any reply to a fair question. This course does not decide among them. It requires that you can state the charge and the reply fairly and that you can name the weak point in each.

4. Mystery must not be an excuse

Notice what the reply above does. It does not say "this is a mystery, so stop asking". It tries to show that the statements do not contradict each other. That is the honest way to work. A defender who says "it is a mystery" in response to every hard question is not honouring mystery; they are refusing the conversation. And a listener who has asked a fair question has a right to a fair attempt at an answer, even if the answer includes "I do not know" or "we cannot say more".

So the first rule: mystery is not a licence to contradict yourself. If a statement really is a contradiction in the strict sense, it a mystery does not rescue it; the statement has to be restated.

5. Argument cannot dissolve every mystery

The second rule runs the other way. A student may think that if a doctrine cannot be fully explained, it is untrue, or that a teaching that cannot be reduced to a logical diagram is empty. That does not follow. We know many true things that we cannot explain fully: what a number is, why there is something and not nothing, what it is to be a person, how a loved one is known. A doctrine that stays beyond our full grasp after our best reasoning has been done is not thereby false. It may be that what is true about the greatest realities cannot be completely stated in the words of our ordinary life.

The two rules together: do the reasoning you can, honestly, and be willing to stop where reason stops, without pretending that the stopping place is an answer. Some traditions will put the stopping place earlier than others, and that is part of what readers disagree about.

6. Define your terms

Many disputes about mystery and contradiction are really disputes about words. Before arguing, write down what each key word means. If the Father "is" God, what does "is" mean here? What does "person" mean, in this sentence? A few minutes spent on definitions often shows that two people who seemed to disagree were using the same word in different senses. And sometimes it shows that they really do disagree, and then the work can begin on the true point.

7. Kindness in argument

When we teach or preach on these questions, we speak to people who may be troubled by exactly the objections above. The critic who raises the charge may be an honest seeker. A member of the congregation may have been told that a doubt is a sin. First Peter 3:15 joins the reason with "humility and fear", and, in its wider verse, with reverence. That suggests some habits.

  • State the question fairly, and not as a trap.
  • Say plainly what you can show and what you cannot.
  • Do not use hard words as a way to shut up someone who asks. A person who asks "How can this be?" is not a heretic for asking.
  • Do not hide behind "mystery" when you have not tried to answer.
  • Do not hold your own view with such force that you cannot hear a better argument.

None of this makes truth less important. It reminds us that the way a thing is said belongs to what is said.

8. A one-page tool for reading a theological text

Here is a short tool that gathers the work of this week into questions. You may copy it onto one page and use it on any article, chapter or sermon.

  1. What kind of text is this? Argument, witness, prayer, story, teaching, or a mix? (5-1)
  2. What is the main claim? Say it in one sentence.
  3. What reasons are given? List the premises; draw the bones. (5-1)
  4. What is assumed but not said? Find at least one hidden premise. (5-1)
  5. What kind of support is it? Deduction, induction, best explanation? How strong? (5-2)
  6. What sources does it use, and how much weight does it give each? Scripture, tradition, reason, experience; any proof-texting? (5-2)
  7. Are any common traps present? Check without naming as a weapon. (5-3)
  8. Are the key words used in one sense? Is a contradiction claimed, or a mystery, or a paradox? (5-4)
  9. What is the strongest form of the view I disagree with, and what is the weak point of my own?

For general skills in writing and research, one sentence of pointer: the course Theological Study and Writing covers them. Here we are concerned with reading and speaking.


Diagram 1. Contradiction, paradox, mystery

Three words, three different things Ask first: same sense, same respect? Contradiction Is and is not, in the same sense and at the same time. Example: this table is square and not square, in one sense. Cannot be true. Restate it. Paradox Seems contradictory, but the words are used in different respects. Example: a woman is a daughter and a mother. Separate the respects. Mystery A truth deeper than we can take in; we can speak truly of it, never fully. Example: a child says true things about the sun. Not an excuse to stop. Two rules 1. Mystery is not a licence to contradict yourself or to refuse a fair question. 2. Argument cannot dissolve every mystery; be willing to stop where reason stops. An invented set of examples; the doctrines themselves belong to the doctrine courses.

Diagram 2. The shape of the charge and the reply

The charge A is X. A is not X. The same words, the same sense, the same respect. So: a contradiction. The reply A is X in one respect. A is not X in another. The words are not used in one sense. So: no contradiction. The critic asks: is the distinction real, or brought in to escape? The defender asks: did the critic use the words in one sense? Each side has a weak point to answer.

In short

  • A contradiction says something both is and is not so in the same sense and respect, and cannot be true; a paradox only seems to, and the respects can be separated; a mystery is a truth deeper than we can take in.
  • The first test for any apparent contradiction is whether the words are used in the same sense and respect.
  • The charge that the Trinity and the incarnation are contradictory, and the reply by distinguishing respects, can be set out as a structure without setting out the doctrines.
  • Readers disagree whether the replies succeed, and each side has a weak point.
  • Mystery must not be used to stop reasoning, and argument cannot dissolve every mystery.
  • Teaching and preaching on these questions calls for plain definitions and kindness; a one-page tool helps in reading a text.
Front Back
Contradiction, paradox, mystery Contradiction: is and is not in the same respect. Paradox: seems so, but the respects differ. Mystery: truth deeper than we can take in.
The first test Are the words used in the same sense and the same respect?
Two rules about mystery It is no licence to contradict or to refuse a fair question; and argument cannot dissolve every mystery.
The shape of the debate The charge: the same thing is and is not. The reply: said in different respects. Each side has a weak point.

One sentence to remember Ask whether the words are used in one sense; do the reasoning you can, and be honest where reason stops.

This week's action Use the one-page tool on one paragraph of a theological text this week.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Give an everyday example of a paradox, and show by naming the respects that it is not a contradiction.
  • Why does it matter whether a statement is called a mystery or a contradiction? What goes wrong if the wrong label is used?
  • State the charge that a doctrine is contradictory, and the reply, in a form that a critic and a defender would each accept. Where does each feel the weak point?
  • How can "it is a mystery" be used well, and how can it be used as an excuse? What would you say to a person who asks a fair question about a doctrine?
  • Apply the one-page tool to a paragraph from a theological book or a sermon you know. Which question was hardest to answer?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.