Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
This is the second Practice Lab of the course. A lab does not ask you to agree with anything. It asks you to do something. This week the task is to look at the assumptions behind your own "I know": when I say I know something, what am I resting on, how sure am I, how sure should I be, and what one step will I take?
This week's lectures gave you words for knowing (belief, truth, justification), four models of faith and reason, three positions on evidence and basic beliefs, and a picture of knowing in company, with its virtues and dangers. It is easy to nod at these and still go on speaking by habit. The lab slows that down. It asks about the assumptions you use, your questions and one step. It does not ask you to write about a crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or any other personal pain, and you should not write any of those on the form. Choose a general claim that is not about your private troubles.
The lab neither urges nor forbids any view about faith and reason. You may skip any part, and you may stop at any time.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Complete the "When I say I know" form in writing, on a general claim, without real names or personal pain.
- Say what kind of knowing a claim is, and what grounds it rests on: your own experience, another's word, Scripture, reasoning or the community.
- Tell the difference between how sure you feel and how sure the grounds allow.
- Write one question you still hold and one step you will take.
- Explain the four privacy promises of the lab and keep them in a group.
Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." — Acts 17:11
World English Bible
Acts 17:11 says of the people of Berea that they received the message eagerly and also examined the Scriptures daily to see whether it was so. Readers take this in different ways. Some hear in it praise for testing what one is taught. Others stress the eagerness and the daily habit of reading. The verse does not say how much evidence any claim needs, and it does not say that testing is always called for. It is a picture of a mind that is both open and careful. You may use it as a prayer for that kind of mind, not as a rule for judging others.
1. What this lab is for
The lab is for practice, not for display. Nobody will check what you wrote, and there is no right answer. Two honest people may find different grounds and different questions. What the lab asks, and only you can answer, is whether you have looked at what you rest on when you say "I know".
2. The four promises
Say these aloud before anyone begins, whether you work alone or with others.
- Nobody reads what you write.
- Nothing is marked or graded.
- You may pass on any part.
- The leader fills in a sheet too.
Never write on the form the name of a real person, church, employer or any confidential matter. Write "a relative", "a colleague", "someone I know", "a teacher". This lab does not ask you to write about a crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or any other personal pain. If you start to, stop and leave it out. If the lab brings a real harm to light, such as abuse, violence or danger, the lab stops. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and if there is danger now, call your local emergency number. If you or someone you know is in distress or thinking of ending their life, speak at once to a pastor or priest and to your local emergency number or a local crisis line. This course does not cover that.
3. Before you begin
Have a pen and paper, or open a blank page and copy the headings of the form below. Allow about thirty minutes. Sit somewhere you will not be interrupted. Choose a general claim that you often say you know. It should not be about you or anyone you know. For example: "I know that the earth is round." "I know that the Scriptures are trustworthy." "I know that my church teaches the truth about baptism." "I know that honesty is better than lying." Pick one that you can look at calmly. If a part of the form touches something painful, skip that box.
4. The first way: in your own place
Take your claim and fill in the form.
Write the claim at the top. Then ask what kind of knowing it is: knowing how, knowing someone or knowing that (lecture 2-1). Next, write the grounds. Where did this belief come from? Was it my own seeing or experience, someone's word (testimony), a book or Scripture, my own reasoning, or the shared life of a community (lecture 2-4)? Most beliefs rest on several. Write which carry the most weight, and do not guess: writing "I do not remember" is a good answer.
Then write two numbers on a scale from one to five. The first is how sure I feel. The second is how sure the grounds allow. They may differ. A big gap in either direction is worth noticing and is not a failing. Then write what might make you change your mind: what evidence, what person's word or what argument would count? If you cannot think of anything, write that, and ask yourself whether the claim is held as a basic belief (lecture 2-3), and whether that is reasonable here.
Next, name one intellectual virtue that this claim asks of you (humility, patience, honesty, carefulness, open-mindedness or courage) and one danger that it tempts you to (false certainty or paralysing doubt). Then write the weak point of your claim: the best thing a fair critic would say against it. Then write one question you still hold, and one step you will take. The step may be small: to ask someone from another tradition how they know it, to read the whole passage, to say "I do not know" next time it is true.
If you cannot find anything to say, do not invent it to please the exercise. Try the second or the third way.
5. The second way: the observer's way
Use this invented case (an invented example).
A study group of seven people meets weekly in a community hall: a driver, a teacher, a nurse, a student, a baker, a retired accountant and a . This week the student has brought a printed page from the internet. It says that a "recent discovery" proves that a famous event in the past could not have happened as it is usually told. The student says, "I know this is true, because it is on the page and the page looks serious."
The baker says, "I know it is false, because my grandfather told me the old story and he never lied." The accountant asks who wrote the page and what they would gain. The nurse says she is not sure, and that she would like to see what other people who study the matter say. The teacher says she has read something about it years ago, but cannot remember where. The driver says, "I do not need to know. I trust the church." The deacon says he is troubled, and that he does not want to say anything he does not understand.
The group does not agree. Someone suggests that they write down, for next week, who knows what, and how. Everyone takes one question home.
Fill in the form from this case. The claim is: "I know that this page is true," and "I know that it is false." For each member, ask what kind of knowing the claim is, what grounds it rests on, how sure the speaker feels and how sure the grounds allow. Ask who is trusting testimony well, and who is not. Ask which virtues and dangers appear. Do not decide that anyone in the group is foolish or faithless. Describe the grounds each one gives.
6. The third way: the partner's way
Sit with a trusted partner. Take turns. One of you reads the invented case aloud, slowly. The other listens, then says in one or two sentences which member's grounds seemed strongest to them, and why. Swap. Then, if you wish, each tells the other one general thing about how you tend to know things, such as "I trust what I read too quickly" or "I find it hard to say I do not know". Say nothing about real people, events or private pain. The listener says only, "Thank you", and does not offer advice or a verdict. If you disagree about the case, say "I saw it differently" and move on.
7. What usually happens
Three things come up often. None means you have done it wrong.
"I cannot say where it came from." That is usual. Many beliefs were absorbed long ago. Your step may be to ask a teacher or to read a source.
"I feel much more sure than the grounds allow." Most people find this at least once. The lab does not say you are wrong. It asks you to notice. Your step may be to say "I believe" instead of "I know" for a week, to see what changes.
"I thought of a hard time in my life, and it hurt." You may stop. If it helps, say to a pastor, priest or trusted friend what you thought of. Do not write the details on the form.
8. Leader's note, for running this in a small group
Privacy comes first
Say the four promises first, aloud, even if you said them in the introduction. People write honestly only when they know no one will read it.
Fill in your own sheet. A leader who watches while others write makes the room an examination. Sit and write.
Give a full twenty to thirty minutes in silence. Do not fill the silence with talk or music.
Then ask about what it was like, not about what was written. Say: "Which box was the hardest to fill?" Do not say: "What did you write?"
Allow anyone to pass. Say the words: "If you would rather not say anything, just pass." Then move on without a pause that makes passing costly.
Keep the claim general. If someone begins to speak of a crisis of faith, a loss or a private illness, gently stop the discussion and say that the lab is not for this. Offer to speak privately afterwards, and help the person find a pastor, priest or counsellor. If what they raise is beyond you, say so.
Do not argue over the claim. The aim is not to agree about what is true, and not to rank any model of faith and reason. Never present one view as the church's answer to a person's real doubt.
Expect that someone may be grieving or afraid. Do not single anyone out. If someone says they want to end their life, do not leave them alone: bring in a pastor or priest and your local emergency services or crisis line.
Diagram 1. The form: When I Say "I Know"
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises aloud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Gave twenty to thirty minutes of silence | [ ] |
| Did not ask "what did you write?" | [ ] |
| Did ask "which box was hardest to fill?" | [ ] |
| Kept the claim general and gently stopped any account of a crisis, loss or illness | [ ] |
| Offered a real option to pass and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Did not rank any model of faith and reason | [ ] |
| Offered private follow-up to anyone who seemed troubled | [ ] |
In short
- The lab asks you to look at the assumptions behind a general claim that you say you know.
- It never asks you to write about a crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or any personal pain, and nothing of that should be written.
- Name the kind of knowing, the grounds, how sure you feel and how sure the grounds allow.
- Write what would change your mind, one virtue and one danger, the weak point of your claim, one question and one step.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at the grounds of a general "I know", how sure you feel against how sure the grounds allow, and choosing one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or other personal pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Look honestly at what you rest on when you say "I know", and take one small step.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, on a general claim, and keep it where only you will find it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which box of the form was easiest to fill, and which was hardest? If you wish to say, say it; if not, pass.
- In the invented case, which member was trusting testimony well, and which was not? How could you tell?
- What is the difference between "how sure I feel" and "how sure the grounds allow"? Where does a gap come from?
- Which intellectual virtue did the study group most need? Which danger, false certainty or paralysing doubt, was nearest?
- How does Acts 17:11 describe a mind that is open and careful? What would it look like in a study group?