Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Why is there a wet street? Because it rained. Why did it rain? Because of the weather. We ask "why" so naturally that we seldom ask what we mean by it. This lecture looks at three connected ideas that sit behind the ordinary word: cause, possibility and necessity. They matter to a student of theology because when Scripture and the creeds speak of God as the maker and keeper of all things, a reader is already using these ideas, named or not.
The lecture gives a beginner's picture of cause and effect, separates a thing that must be from a thing that merely is, and shows why the old distinction between a first cause and a sustaining cause is easy to mix up. It also names one famous doubt about cause. It does not argue for or against God's existence. That comes in lecture 3-4. Here we only sharpen the words.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain what a cause is and give an everyday example of a cause and its effect.
- Distinguish a necessary thing from a contingent thing, with an example of each.
- Explain the difference between a cause that starts something and a cause that keeps it going.
- Say what Aristotle's four kinds of cause are, in the simplest form.
- Say why these ideas matter when Christians speak of creation, without claiming that they prove anything.
Yahweh, how many are your works! In wisdom have you made them all. The earth is full of your riches." — Psalms 104:24
World English Bible
His Son is the radiance of his glory, the very image of his substance, and upholding all things by the word of his power, when he had by himself purified us of our sins, sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high;" — Hebrews 1:3
WEB
He is before all things, and in him all things are held together." — Colossians 1:17
WEB
What the text says: the psalmist praises the many works of God and says they were made in wisdom. Hebrews says the Son upholds all things by his word. Colossians says that in him all things are held together. The verbs are about making and about holding. A tradition's reading: many Christians, ancient and modern, have read these verses as saying that creatures depend on God not only at a beginning but at every moment. Some readers point out that the passages are in hymn-like and praise language, and that the writers are not setting out a theory of cause. Our judgement: the verses give a reader good reason to ask whether "cause" means one thing or two, which is what the lecture does. They do not choose between theories.
1. What we mean by a cause
A cause is something that brings about something else, so that the second would not have happened, or would not have been as it is, without the first. The match causes the fire. The rain causes the wet street. The teacher's question causes the room to go quiet. The thing brought about is the effect.
Notice that in ordinary talk we use "cause" for very different things. If you ask "what caused the bridge to fall?" one person says "the engineer's mistake", another says "the flood", another says "the rust in the beams". All three may be right. We choose the one that interests us. This is the first lesson of the lecture: cause is a flexible word, and a careful reader asks which kind of cause is meant.
2. Aristotle's four kinds of cause
The ancient Greek writer Aristotle sorted the answers to "why?" into four kinds. Many medieval Christian writers used his list, and you will meet it in older theology. Take a statue as the example.
- The material cause: what it is made of (the marble).
- The formal cause: the shape or pattern that makes it this statue (the form of a man with a raised arm).
- The efficient cause: what does the work of making it (the sculptor's hands and tools).
- The final cause: what it is for (to honour a hero, or to stand in the square).
Today, when people say cause they usually mean only the efficient cause, the thing that does the pushing. Older writers meant more. The reason this matters is that when an older text asks "what is the cause of the world?" it may be asking not only "what set it going?" but also "what is it for?" and "what holds its pattern?" A modern reader may hear only the first question and misread the rest. Whether Aristotle's list is the right one is a question for philosophers. For us it is enough to know that the list exists and to notice which kind of cause a speaker means.
3. A doubt about cause
A famous doubt was raised by the Scottish philosopher David Hume in the eighteenth century. In a beginner's form it goes like this. We see one billiard ball strike another, and the second moves. What we see is the first thing and then the second. We do not see a thing called "causing" passing between them. We believe in causes because we have seen the same pattern many times. So, Hume asked, what is our right to believe that the future will follow the pattern, or that there is a real tie between the two events and not just a repeated sequence?
Philosophers have answered this in many ways, and the question is still discussed. Some say that we do see causes at work when we push a door and it opens. Some say that causes are real powers in things. Some say the question shows only that our belief in cause is a habit. A student of theology does not need to settle this. But it helps to know that "everything has a cause" is not an idea that every thinker has accepted without question, and that those who use it in arguments for God (lecture 3-4) are making a claim that can be examined.
4. Necessary and contingent
Here is a pair of words that you will meet often. A thing is contingent if it exists, but it could have failed to exist, or could have been otherwise. A thing is necessary if it could not have failed to exist or could not have been otherwise.
Take an umbrella that someone left on a train. It exists. But it might not have: if the owner had remembered it, it would be at home. Its existing is contingent. Now take the fact that two plus two is four. It is hard to imagine it being otherwise. Many philosophers call such truths necessary. (Be careful: necessary here is a word about how a thing is, not about how useful it is.)
Notice something about contingent things: they depend. The umbrella depends on the factory that made it, on the owner who bought it, on the cloth and the metal. If any of that were different, there would be no umbrella. Contingent things need something other than themselves to explain why they exist at all.
This gives us the idea that is behind much old Christian talk about God and the world. Christian writers have said that all created things are contingent: they exist but did not have to. God, on the other hand, is not like that. Many Christian traditions have said that God is not one more thing among things that happens to exist. He is the one on whom all other things depend, and who depends on nothing. Whether that last step can be argued from the first is a question for lecture 3-4. Here we only say that the vocabulary of contingent and necessary is one that Christian thought has long used.
A caution is needed. We said that the umbrella could have failed to exist. Notice that we are talking about what could have been, not about what will be. Possibility, in this sense, is not a claim about the future. It is about the range of ways things might have been. Possibility is the field of what could have happened. Necessity is what holds in every case. Contingency is what holds in some cases and not in others.
5. Two kinds of "first" cause
When people say "first cause" they can mean two quite different things. The difference is worth getting clear, because it is often the source of confusion in arguments about creation.
Picture a line of dominoes. The first domino was pushed, it knocked the second, and so on. The one who pushed the first is the cause of the start of the line. This is a cause in time: it comes first in a series, before the others.
Now picture a lamp that is lit by a power station. As long as the power station works, the lamp shines. If the power stopped, the light would go out at once. The power station is not "first" in time. It is underneath, holding the light in being at every moment. This is a sustaining cause. Its work is going on now.
Many writers in the older Christian tradition, Aquinas among them, are thought to have been mostly interested in the second kind. When they speak of God as the cause of all things, they mean something like the power station: that everything depends on God now, whether or not the universe had a beginning in time. Others, in the same tradition and later, have been very interested in the first kind: whether the universe began, and what began it. Both questions are asked by Christians, and they are not the same question. If you hear someone say "science shows the universe had a beginning, therefore God" or "science shows the universe may be endless, therefore no God", they may be speaking only about the first kind of cause, while the older tradition spoke mostly about the second.
(An invented example.) Two students argue over a river. One says, "The river is caused by the rain upstream." The other says, "The river is caused by the shape of the land that holds it." They are not contradicting each other. One names the source of the water, the other what keeps it in its bed. Neither would stop if you asked "but which came first in time?" The question is about what the river depends on, and a river depends on many things at once.
6. Why this matters for talk about creation
When Christians say God created the world, the word may carry several senses.
It may mean that God made the world at a start in time. It may mean that God keeps the world in being now. It may mean that the world has the order and the goodness that its maker gave it. Scripture speaks in all these ways, in different places. The psalmist praises works made in wisdom, and Hebrews says the Son upholds all things by the word of his power. The tradition has tried to hold them together.
Here is where the vocabulary of this lecture helps. A student who hears "God is the cause of the world" can ask: which kind of cause? Starting, sustaining, shaping or giving purpose? And a student who hears "the world is contingent" can say what is meant: that it exists, but did not have to, and so depends on something else. These words do not prove that God made the world. They make clearer what the claim is, so that a person may agree or disagree with the claim rather than with a misreading of it.
7. What this lecture does not say
It does not say that there must be a first cause. It does not say that a series of causes cannot go on without end. It does not say that every philosopher accepts that things are "contingent" in the sense above. Those are the questions that arguments for God try to answer, and they are examined fairly, with objections, in lecture 3-4. The task here is only to see that when Christians speak of God as maker, they are using words that carry a philosophical history, and to know what some of those words mean.
Diagram 1. Two kinds of "first" cause
Diagram 2. Necessary and contingent
In short
- A cause brings something about; ordinary speech uses the word for many kinds of reasons, so ask which is meant.
- Aristotle listed four kinds: material, formal, efficient and final; modern speech mostly means the efficient one.
- Hume asked what we really see when we say one thing causes another; philosophers have answered in several ways.
- A contingent thing exists but could have been otherwise; a necessary thing could not have been otherwise.
- A starting cause comes first in time; a sustaining cause keeps something in being now. The two are different questions.
- These words clarify what Christians mean by creation; they do not prove it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four causes | Material (what it is made of), formal (its pattern), efficient (what makes it), final (what it is for). |
| Contingent and necessary | Contingent: exists but might not have. Necessary: could not have been otherwise. |
| Starting and sustaining cause | A starting cause begins a series in time; a sustaining cause keeps a thing in being now. |
| Hume's question | What do we actually see when we say one thing causes another, beyond one event following another? |
One sentence to remember When you hear the word cause, ask which kind is meant, and whether it is about the beginning or about what holds things in being now.
This week's action Pick a statement about creation you have heard, and ask whether it speaks of a starting cause, a sustaining cause, or something else.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a recent event. Give two or three different answers to "what caused it?" How do you choose which one to name?
- Using a statue, a house or a meal, name its material, formal, efficient and final cause.
- Hume's question asks what we see when we say one thing causes another. Does it seem a real problem to you, or a puzzle that everyday life settles? Why?
- What is the difference between a cause that starts something and a cause that keeps it going? Which of Psalm 104:24, Hebrews 1:3 and Colossians 1:17 speaks most clearly of each?
- If someone says "the world is contingent", what are they claiming, and what are they not claiming?