Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
The last lecture ended in the Middle Ages. This one carries the story to our own time in four steps: the Reformers, who criticised one use of reason and kept another; the long period of Protestant university teaching that followed; the Enlightenment, which challenged old authorities in the name of reason; and the conversation of the last century, in which philosophy of religion has grown again. The aim is not a full history. It is to see how the same question, how far to trust reason in matters of faith, kept returning in new forms, and to look again at the four stances of lecture 1-1.
Some of the names in this lecture are famous and others will be new to you. You do not need to remember dates. A century or a period is enough.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Explain, in general terms, how the Reformers both criticised and used reason, and what is meant by the ministerial and the magisterial use of reason.
- Describe in a sentence or two the main concern of Descartes, Hume and Kant.
- Say why the Enlightenment was a challenge to theology and name two kinds of response.
- Describe in general terms the revival of philosophy of religion in the late twentieth century.
- Use the four stances (enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox) to describe a period or a writer.
I turned around, and my heart sought to know and to search out, and to seek wisdom and the scheme of things, and to know that wickedness is stupidity, and that foolishness is madness." — Ecclesiastes 7:25
World English Bible
Yes, if you call out for discernment, and lift up your voice for understanding; If you seek her as silver, and search for her as for hidden treasures: then you will understand the fear of Yahweh, and find the knowledge of God. For Yahweh gives wisdom. Out of his mouth comes knowledge and understanding." — Proverbs 2:3-6
WEB
What the text says. In Ecclesiastes 7:25 the writer turns his whole heart to know, to search out and to seek wisdom and "the scheme of things". The same book also says, elsewhere, that this search has limits and can be wearying. Proverbs 2:3-6 describes seeking understanding as a deliberate and costly search, and says that the Lord is the one who gives wisdom.
A tradition's reading. Christians across the churches have read these passages as showing that Scripture itself praises serious inquiry. Some stress the first part of each (the seeking). Others stress the second (the gift). Many hold both together.
Our judgement. These passages do not say what a Christian should think of Descartes, Hume or Kant. They are included because every period in this lecture faced the question that these verses raise: how a person is to seek understanding, and where seeking ends and receiving begins.
1. The Reformers: criticism and use
In the sixteenth century, the Reformers called for a return to Scripture and criticised much of what the schools of the late Middle Ages had taught. Part of their criticism was aimed at reason. They worried that scholastic theology had become a system of human argument which sat above the Bible, and that Aristotle in particular had been given too much authority. Martin Luther could speak very sharply about what he called reason, when it sets itself up to judge God's word, and his words on this are strong.
It would be a mistake to stop there. The Reformers were themselves educated in the schools, and they used logic, grammar and rhetoric in their teaching and writing every day. Luther, who was a university teacher, argued with care. John Calvin, in the Reformed stream, wrote that all people have some sense of God, and that the world shows God's work, even though sin distorts how people use that knowledge. Their criticism was of a certain use of reason, not of thinking.
Later Protestant writers have often put this in a short way. Reason may be used ministerially, meaning as a servant: it helps to read, to order and to explain what Scripture says, and it works under Scripture. Reason may also be used magisterially, meaning as a master: it sits above Scripture and decides what Scripture may say. On this way of speaking, the first use is welcome and the second is refused. A student should notice that this is a way of describing the Protestant concern, and that not every writer used these words. It is also a place where the lines are not always easy to draw. Is a reader who says, in an invented sentence, "a loving God would not do this, and so the text must mean something else", using reason as a servant or as a master? Careful people disagree about particular cases.
Other traditions looked at the Reformers' criticisms and answered in their own way. In the Catholic church, the movement known as the Catholic Reformation and the great council of the sixteenth century defended the use of the schools and the place of tradition and the church's teaching, while also reforming practice. The Orthodox churches were in a different setting and did not take part in these Western debates in the same way. They have their own history of the relation of faith and reason, rooted in the fathers and in worship.
2. The Reformation schools
In the century and a half after the first Reformers, Protestant universities and colleges taught their theology with careful method. Because they needed to train pastors and defend their churches in debate, teachers in several Protestant streams used the tools of the medieval schools, including Aristotelian logic, to set out doctrine precisely. Writers speak of this period as Protestant . Readers disagree about how to judge it. Some see it as a necessary and fruitful use of reason as servant. Others see a drift toward system-building that the first Reformers had warned against. We mention it so that you do not suppose that Protestant thought gave up the tools of the schools after the first generation. In general terms, it did not.
3. The Enlightenment: reason on trial
The seventeenth and eighteenth centuries in Europe are often called the Enlightenment. The word is a label for a loose collection of movements, and not everyone in it thought alike. What many shared was a conviction that reason, and observation of the world, should be the test of belief, and that inherited authority, including the authority of churches, should be examined, not simply accepted. This was not always hostile to faith, and many Enlightenment thinkers were Christians. But it raised sharp questions, and three names can serve as examples.
- René Descartes (French, seventeenth century) asked what a person could be sure of if everything that could be doubted were set aside. He found that he could not doubt that he was thinking, and he tried to build knowledge from that starting point. The importance of his move for our story is that it made the individual mind, and its certainty, the starting point of knowledge. Descartes himself believed in God and offered arguments for God's existence. But his method, adopted widely, made a question out of what had once been simply received.
- David Hume (Scottish, eighteenth century) asked what grounds we have for believing that one event causes another, and wrote critically about reports of miracles and about arguments for God from the order of the world. Many readers have taken him as the chief example of a sceptical challenge, and we will meet his question about cause in week 3.
- Immanuel Kant (German, eighteenth century) argued that human reason has limits: it works on what we can experience, and when it tries to reach beyond experience, to God or to the whole world, it falls into trouble. He held that the traditional arguments for God from reason alone do not succeed. Yet he did not deny God, and he gave a large place to morality as the way into belief. Later thinkers have read Kant in very different ways, and have used him both to protect faith from reason and to limit what faith may claim.
These three, with others, produced what many call the modern challenge. Reason was now being asked to stand on its own, to be the judge of religion, and religion was asked to justify itself before it. They also criticised the churches, and it is fair to say that some of the criticism was deserved.
4. Theological responses
Theologians responded in many ways. In very general terms, some tried to answer the challenge on its own ground, showing that Christian belief is reasonable by the standards of the age. Some retreated from argument and rested faith on experience, on feeling, or on the moral life, believing that these were safer from criticism. Some rejected the challenge, holding that the church should not allow reason to set the terms. And some tried to absorb the criticism and rebuild theology on a new footing. Each response had real insight and real cost. Following them in detail belongs to the course on contemporary theology. Here it is enough to know that the argument of the Enlightenment did not end, and that theology learned to live with it in several ways.
5. A revival of philosophy of religion
In the late twentieth century, philosophy of religion, which is the study of the questions raised by religious belief (does God exist, what does it mean to say so, what is faith, what about evil), grew again as a field in English-speaking universities. Among the philosophers who took part were several who were openly Christian, and who wrote about the existence of God, about the rationality of belief and about the problem of evil in a way that was widely read. Their work, and the work of others who disagreed with them, made it more common to see the arguments set out in careful form and discussed on their merits. We meet some of this work in weeks 2, 3 and 6.
At the same time, a different tradition of philosophy, often called the continental tradition after the countries of continental Europe where much of it developed, took its own path. In general terms, it paid more attention to experience, history, language and interpretation than to arguments set out in numbered premises. Some of its writers were hostile to religion, and some were deeply interested in it. We do not follow it in detail here. It is enough to say that there is more than one tradition of philosophy, and that the present conversation has more than one voice.
6. The four stances again
Return to the four stances of lecture 1-1. It is possible to look at a period or a writer and ask, which stance? The Reformers in the first generation seem to have held a suspicion of one use of reason, with a ready use of the other. The scholastic period seems closer to servant. Many Enlightenment thinkers seem to have set reason as a judge, which is a fifth stance that we did not name in lecture 1-1 and that is better seen as a challenge to all four. Many modern philosophers of religion work as conversation partners. And a student today who learns logic to read an argument is using a toolbox.
Such labels are crude, and it would be a mistake to push them hard. Notice, though, that the same four stances have returned in every period, and that none of them has gone away. They are not stages that history has moved past. They are ways of holding one question, and in this course we try to hold that question with care.
Diagram 1. Reformation to today
In short
- The Reformers criticised reason set above Scripture, and used logic, grammar and rhetoric every day.
- Later writers speak of reason used ministerially, as a servant under Scripture, and magisterially, as a master over it.
- Protestant universities kept the tools of the schools; writers differ on whether this was fruitful or a drift toward system.
- Descartes asked what cannot be doubted, Hume asked what grounds belief in cause, and Kant argued that reason has limits.
- Theologians responded to the modern challenge in several ways: answering on its terms, resting faith on experience, rejecting it, or rebuilding.
- Philosophy of religion revived in the late twentieth century, alongside a continental tradition with its own path.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ministerial and magisterial | Reason as servant under Scripture, and reason as master over Scripture; a way of describing the Protestant concern. |
| Descartes, Hume, Kant | What cannot be doubted; what grounds belief in cause; the limits of reason. |
| The modern challenge | Reason asked to be the judge of religion, and religion asked to justify itself; responses varied. |
| Four stances revisited | Enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox: ways of holding one question that return in every age. |
One sentence to remember From the Reformers to today the same question has returned: how far to trust reason in matters of faith, and in what role.
This week's action Name one writer or teacher you know and say which of the four stances they seem to hold most often, and what concern lies behind it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What did the Reformers criticise about the use of reason, and what did they keep? Why is it too simple to say they rejected reason?
- Explain the ministerial and the magisterial use of reason in your own words. Give an example of a case where it is hard to say which is in use.
- What did Descartes, Hume and Kant each ask? Which question seems closest to a question you have met?
- Why was the Enlightenment a challenge, and why was it not always hostile to faith?
- Choose one of the four stances. Describe a recent conversation in which you saw it.