Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
In lecture 5-1 we looked at the bones of an argument and asked whether the conclusion must follow from the premises. That is the strictest test, and many good arguments do not meet it. A doctor who says, "These signs usually mean an infection", cannot prove that this patient has one. A pastor who says, "This word is used in the same sense in four letters, so it probably has that sense here", has made a sound-looking argument that is still only probable. Much of the reasoning that theology uses, and much of the reasoning of everyday life, is of this kind.
This lecture sets out three kinds of reasoning: deduction, induction and reasoning to the best explanation. It talks about degrees of support, which means that a claim may be more or less well supported and not simply proved or unproved. It then looks at how a theological claim is supported by Scripture, tradition, reason and experience, a map that traditions use in different ways. Last, it explains why proof-texting, which means using a verse out of its setting to settle a question, is a poor argument.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Distinguish deductive from inductive reasoning, with an everyday example of each.
- Explain what "reasoning to the best explanation" means and give a short example.
- Say why support for a claim comes in degrees, and why that is not the same as saying nothing can be known.
- Describe the four sources (Scripture, tradition, reason, experience) as a map, and state fairly that traditions weigh them differently.
- Explain why proof-texting is a poor argument and what to do instead.
Since many have undertaken to set in order a narrative concerning those matters which have been fulfilled among us," — Luke 1:1
World English Bible
it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus;" — Luke 1:3
WEB
that you might know the certainty concerning the things in which you were instructed." — Luke 1:4
WEB
Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." — Acts 17:11
WEB
Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
WEB
What the text says. Luke writes that he has "traced the course of all things accurately" and that he writes "in order" so that his reader may know "the certainty" of what he was taught. The passage speaks of careful tracing and ordered writing, and of a purpose: certainty for the reader. Acts 17:11 praises people who examined the Scriptures "daily to see whether these things were so", which describes testing a claim against a text. First Thessalonians 5:21 tells its readers to "test all things" and to hold on to what is good. Together the three passages show that checking, tracing and testing are parts of the life described in the New Testament.
A tradition's reading. Readers do not all agree on what the testing means. Many Protestant readers take Acts 17:11 to show that each hearer may weigh a teaching against Scripture. Many Catholic and Orthodox readers stress that testing happens within the church, which has received the Scriptures and a living teaching together, and they read "test all things" in that light. Each side would add that the verse does not settle the question of who has the final word.
Our judgement. These passages support the idea that examining reasons is not unfaithful. They do not say how much weight each source of evidence should carry, and we should not treat them as if they did.
1. Three kinds of reasoning
Here are three short arguments (invented examples).
All the bakers in this town open before six. Mira is a baker in this town. So Mira opens before six.
This is deduction. If the premises are true, the conclusion has to be. A valid deduction gives certainty about the conclusion, as long as the premises are right. The limit is that a deduction only unpacks what was already contained in the premises. It cannot tell you something that goes beyond them.
I have bought bread from this shop on thirty mornings, and it was fresh each time. So tomorrow's bread will probably be fresh.
This is induction. It moves from what has been seen to what has not yet been seen. It reaches beyond the premises, which is why it is useful, and that same reach means the conclusion can never be certain. Tomorrow the oven may fail. Induction gives degrees of support: thirty fresh mornings make the conclusion more probable than three would, but they never make it a proof.
A warning that belongs here: an induction is only as good as the sample. If I bought bread only on the mornings after a holiday, my thirty cases may tell me little about ordinary days. When someone says "all people in this movement are like that" after meeting three of them, we should ask how many were met and how they were chosen.
The bread on the table is gone, there are crumbs on the floor, and the dog is asleep with a satisfied look. The best explanation is that the dog ate the bread.
This is reasoning to the best explanation. We notice several things and ask which story would account for them all. It is not a proof. Perhaps a child took the bread and the dog came for the crumbs. But when we compare the possible stories, one fits better than the others: it accounts for more of the facts with fewer extra assumptions.
Judging "best" takes care. A good explanation usually accounts for the facts we have, fits what else we know, needs few unlikely extras, and could be wrong in a way we could test. A story that explains everything because it can absorb any fact is not strong, it is only loose.
These are the usual groups; writers draw the lines in slightly different places. Some give a long list of kinds of reasoning, and some say that all non-deductive reasoning is induction. For this lecture the three are enough.
2. Degrees of support
Many students think there are only two states for a claim: proved or not proved. In practice a claim can be well supported, fairly supported or weakly supported. A judge, a doctor and a farmer all work like this. The doctor says "very likely", "possible but unlikely". The farmer says "it looks like rain".
This matters for theology in two ways. First, we can say honestly that one reading of a text is stronger than another without pretending that the weaker one is impossible. Second, "I cannot prove it" is not the same as "I have no reason". A person may have good reasons for a belief that do not amount to proof, and a person may lack proof for a belief and still hold it responsibly. How much support is enough for different kinds of belief, especially belief in God, is discussed in lecture 2-3 and in lecture 3-4. Here we only need the idea that support comes in degrees.
The opposite error is also real: treating a weak reason as if it were strong because we want the conclusion. Honest reasoning asks "How strong is this, really?" and is willing to say "not very".
3. The four sources: a map
When Christians reason about a theological question, they draw on four things. This is a map of where reasons come from, and each part needs a short explanation.
- Scripture: the Bible, read in its books, kinds of writing and settings.
- Tradition: what the church has handed down: creeds, councils, the teaching of earlier writers, worship and practice.
- Reason: careful thinking, including the tools of this week: definitions, distinctions and arguments.
- Experience: what people have lived through, in their own lives and in the life of the church, and what is learned from the world.
Some Christians speak of these four together. A Methodist-inspired way of speaking, often called the Wesleyan quadrilateral, names Scripture, tradition, reason and experience. Other traditions do not use that name but make use of the same four things in their own ways.
This is a point where readers will not agree: how the four are weighed. Many Protestant churches hold that Scripture is the supreme authority, and that tradition, reason and experience serve it and are tested by it. They hold this because they believe that only Scripture is God's word written, and that everything else is human and can err. Roman Catholic teaching holds that Scripture and tradition belong closely together in the handing on of the faith, and that the teaching office of the church has the task of interpreting both. This view is held because the church existed before the New Testament was gathered, and because it believes Christ has given the church the means to teach faithfully. Orthodox churches speak of Scripture as read within the living tradition of the church, in its worship and in the writings of the Fathers, and many Orthodox writers prefer not to separate the two at all. Pentecostal and charismatic communities often give a large place to the experience of the Spirit in the life of a believer and a community, held together with Scripture. Each side has a weak point to answer. The view that Scripture alone is the supreme authority must explain why people reading the same Scripture reach different conclusions, and who is to judge. The view that gives tradition a joint place must explain how to tell when a tradition has strayed. The Orthodox view must explain what to do when traditions differ. The place given to experience must explain how an experience is tested, since experiences differ. What this course requires is not that you choose a map, but that you can say which sources a writer is using, how much weight the writer seems to give each, and whether the writer is honest about it.
4. Proof-texting
Proof-texting is lifting a verse, or part of one, out of its setting and using it as if it settled a question. It is a poor argument for several reasons. The verse may belong to a different kind of writing, such as a poem or a story, than the question requires. The verse may say something other than the writer needs when its sentence and chapter are read. Another verse may seem to point in the opposite direction, and a person who has chosen only one has hidden the difficulty. And one verse can rarely carry the whole weight of a long, contested question.
Here is a short invented example (an invented example):
A speaker says, "The Bible says, 'Test all things,' so we must test every teaching of the church before we believe any of it."
Look at it as an argument. The premise is a short quotation. The conclusion is a long and strong claim. The hidden premise is that "test all things" means "believe nothing until you have tested it yourself, and put the church's teaching on the table". Read in its setting, the verse sits among short instructions to a community about prophecy and about holding on to what is good, and the letter does not state the speaker's conclusion. A listener who has seen the setting can say so, and the speaker can reply that the principle is wider than the setting. The argument may still be made, but it needs more than the verse.
This does not mean that quoting Scripture is a mistake. Scripture is the first source for most Christian reasoning. It means that a good use of a verse states what the text says (in its setting), what a tradition has read in it, and what the writer concludes, and keeps these apart. That is the same rule that the course applies to every lecture, and here you see why.
What to do instead of proof-texting:
- Read the passage around the verse, and ask what kind of writing it is.
- Ask what the passage meant for its first readers, as far as we can tell.
- Look at other passages on the same subject, including those that seem to point another way.
- Ask how other readers, in other traditions and times, have understood it.
- State your conclusion as your own judgement, with the strength you honestly think it has.
5. Putting it together: an example in a theological key
Suppose a student asks, "Did the early Christians read the same word for 'church' in the same way throughout the New Testament?" There is no single verse that answers it. A good answer is inductive: look at many uses of the word, notice patterns, and see which account explains the largest number with the fewest strained readings. It may be that the word sometimes names a local gathering and sometimes a wider body. That is a conclusion with a degree of support. A careful scholar says, "The evidence best fits this account, though some uses are hard", and does not say "the Bible proves".
Notice what has happened. The student did not need certainty, and did not give up. The claim was weighed, the evidence was tested, and the answer was stated with the strength it deserves. That is the habit we are after.
Diagram 1. Three kinds of reasoning
Diagram 2. The four sources, as a map
In short
- Deduction gives certainty if its premises are true; induction gives a degree of support from cases seen; best-explanation reasoning picks the story that fits the facts best.
- Support for a claim comes in degrees; "I cannot prove it" is not "I have no reason".
- Scripture, tradition, reason and experience are a map of the sources of theological reasons.
- Traditions weigh the four differently, and each has a weak point it must answer.
- Proof-texting lifts a verse out of its setting to settle a question; it is poor because one verse rarely carries a whole contested question.
- A better way states what the text says, what a tradition reads and what I judge, and says how strong the case is.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Deduction, induction | Deduction: certain if the premises are true. Induction: from cases seen to cases unseen, with a degree of support. |
| Best explanation | Choose the story that accounts for the most facts with the fewest strained extras; it is not a proof. |
| The four sources | Scripture, tradition, reason and experience; traditions weigh them differently. |
| Proof-texting | Using a verse out of its setting as if it settled a question; a poor argument. |
One sentence to remember Most of our reasoning gives degrees of support and not proof, so say how strong a case is and do not claim more than the reasons carry.
This week's action Next time you hear a verse used to settle a question, read the verses around it and ask what kind of writing it is.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Give one example from your own life of each of deduction, induction and reasoning to the best explanation. Which was easiest to find?
- Why can an induction never be certain, and why is it still useful? How would a bad sample weaken it?
- How do you decide whether one explanation is better than another? What makes an explanation "loose" and not strong?
- Traditions weigh Scripture, tradition, reason and experience differently. State one way of weighing in a form that a person who holds it would accept, and say what weak point that person would admit.
- Think of a verse you have heard used to settle a question. What would you need to ask about its setting before you could say whether it settles it?