Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Every day we give and receive reasons. "Take an umbrella, because the sky is dark." "He must be at home, since the lights are on." A sermon, a letter from a bishop, a theology book and a quarrel over the church budget are all full of reasons too. Most of the time we do not notice the structure of what we are saying. This lecture shows that structure, which we call the bones of an argument, so that you can see it in the things you read and hear, and in what you say yourself.
An argument, in the sense used in this week, is not a quarrel. It is a set of statements in which some (the premises) are offered as reasons for another (the conclusion). Seeing the bones does not make you cold or clever. It lets you read someone fairly: you can say, "Here is what she is claiming, and here is why." It also helps you speak plainly. And it keeps one more thing in view: argument is a tool of theology, and it is not the whole of theology.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Name the claim (conclusion) and the premises in a short argument, using the words that often signal them.
- Explain the difference between a valid argument and a sound argument, with an everyday example.
- Find a hidden assumption in a short argument and state it plainly.
- Draw a simple map of an argument with boxes and arrows.
- Say how argument differs from persuasion and from witness, and why argument is not all of theology.
Paul, as was his custom, went in to them, and for three Sabbath days reasoned with them from the Scriptures," — Acts 17:2
World English Bible
explaining and demonstrating that the Christ had to suffer and rise again from the dead, and saying, “This Jesus, whom I proclaim to you, is the Christ.”" — Acts 17:3
WEB
Therefore as sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin; and so death passed to all men, because all sinned." — Romans 5:12
WEB
So then as through one trespass, all men were condemned; even so through one act of righteousness, all men were justified to life." — Romans 5:18
WEB
What the text says. Acts 17:2-3 tells us that Paul "reasoned" with people "from the Scriptures", and the next verse describes him "explaining and demonstrating". The words show that explaining a claim and giving grounds for it were part of how the message was spoken in that synagogue. The verses do not tell us the exact steps of his reasoning, and they do not say that reasoning was all that happened. In Romans 5, Paul sets one thing beside another in a pattern: "as ... even so". The pattern is a good example of structure, because one part of the sentence is set against the other so that the reader sees how they match.
A tradition's reading. Readers differ about what Romans 5:12-21 is saying. Many Western writers, following Augustine, have read "all sinned" as speaking of a shared inheritance of sin and guilt in Adam. Many Eastern writers have put more weight on the inheritance of death and of a weakened nature. Many Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox readers have each worked out their own accounts, and they do not all agree. The doctrine itself belongs to the doctrine courses. We use the passage here only as an example of how Paul's reasoning is built.
Our judgement. Looking at the structure of a passage helps us read it more carefully. It does not tell us which reading of a hard passage is right, and we should not treat these verses as proof for any single account.
1. Claim, premise, conclusion
Start with a small example.
The sky is full of dark clouds. When the sky is full of dark clouds, rain often follows. So it will probably rain. So I will take my umbrella.
There are four statements. The last one, "I will take my umbrella", is what the speaker decides. Before it comes "it will probably rain", which is a claim supported by the first two statements. Those first two are the reasons offered for it.
Three words help here.
- A claim is a statement that something is true or ought to be done. "It will rain" is a claim.
- A premise is a claim that is used as a reason for another claim. "The sky is full of dark clouds" is a premise.
- A conclusion is the claim that the premises are supposed to support. "It will probably rain" is a conclusion.
The same claim can play different parts. "It will probably rain" is a conclusion in the first step and a premise in the next: because it will probably rain, I will take my umbrella. Arguments often run in steps like this, one conclusion becoming the premise of the next.
Ordinary speech gives hints. Words like because, since, for and given that usually come before a premise. Words like so, therefore, thus, hence and it follows that usually come before a conclusion. These words are not a rule. A writer may leave them out, and a word like "since" can also mean "from the time that". But they are good places to begin looking.
2. Two questions to ask of any argument
Once you see the bones, there are two separate questions you can ask.
First: if the premises were true, would the conclusion follow? An argument is valid when the conclusion would have to be true if all the premises were true. Here is a valid argument.
Every apple in this basket is red. This fruit is an apple from this basket. So this fruit is red.
If the first two statements are true, the third has to be true. Notice that validity says nothing about whether the premises are in fact true. Here is another valid argument.
Every apple in this basket is blue. This fruit is an apple from this basket. So this fruit is blue.
The premise is false (apples are not blue), but the form is valid: if the premises were true, the conclusion would be. Validity is about the link between premises and conclusion.
An argument can also fail at the link while the parts sound true.
Every apple in this basket is red. This fruit is red. So this fruit is an apple from this basket.
Both premises may be true, and the fruit may be a tomato. The conclusion does not have to follow, so the argument is invalid.
Second: are the premises in fact true? An argument is sound when it is valid and all its premises are true. A sound argument gives you a true conclusion. If an argument is valid but a premise is false, it is not sound, and it does not show you its conclusion.
That is why two questions are needed. "Does it follow?" is a question of validity. "Is it so?" is a question of truth. People often argue about the second question when the real problem is the first, and the other way round.
A word of caution. Many everyday and theological arguments are not meant to be valid in this strict way. They are meant to make a conclusion probable or reasonable, and we shall look at those in lecture 5-2. The strict test is still a useful place to start, because it shows what would have to be added to make the argument stronger.
3. Hidden assumptions
Most arguments leave something unsaid. Suppose someone says:
The meeting was cancelled, so we cannot hold the prayer evening.
The premise is "the meeting was cancelled". The conclusion is "we cannot hold the prayer evening". Something is missing: the prayer evening depends on that meeting. Perhaps the hall was booked for it, or the leader is the same person. That unstated claim is a hidden assumption. Writers call an argument with a missing premise an enthymeme (say "EN-thi-meem"); you do not need the word, only the idea.
Hidden assumptions are not wrong in themselves. We cannot say everything. The skill is to find them and say them aloud, because the argument is only as good as what it leans on. Often the quarrel between two people is really about an unstated assumption that neither has said.
Here is a theological-sounding example (an invented example):
This hymn is very old. So it is better than the new songs.
The hidden assumption is that old things are better than new ones. Once it is said, the speaker can look at it, and so can the listener. Someone else might say, "Is that always true? Some old hymns have not lasted, and some new songs may be good." The argument is not destroyed. It is clearer.
4. Drawing the bones as a map
It helps to draw an argument. Write each statement in a box. Put the premises above, the conclusion below, and draw an arrow from premises to conclusion. If a premise is hidden, write it in a dotted box.
For the umbrella:
- Box A: The sky is full of dark clouds.
- Box B: Dark clouds are often followed by rain.
- Arrow from A and B to Box C: It will probably rain.
- Arrow from C to Box D: I will take my umbrella.
The map has no tone of voice and no clever phrases. It only shows what is claimed and what supports what. When you map a paragraph from a book, you often find that three sentences carry the argument and the others give examples, explain a word or add a story. That is useful to know. And you may find that the paragraph does not argue at all: it describes, prays or tells a story.
5. Finding the premises in a theological text
Here is a short invented extract, followed by its map (an invented example):
Our congregation should keep a weekly time for silence. People who are always speaking cannot listen well, and listening is part of worship. So the service needs a place where nobody speaks.
The conclusion is the first sentence, that the congregation should keep a weekly time for silence; the last sentence says it again in other words. Premises: people who are always speaking cannot listen well; listening is part of worship. Hidden premise: a time of silence in the service would help people listen. The writer states the conclusion first and gives the reasons after, which is a common pattern.
Do this kind of reading slowly. Take one paragraph. Underline the claim. Ask "Why does the writer say so?" Write down the answers, which are the premises. Then ask "What would I have to believe for these premises to lead to that claim?" That is the hidden assumption.
You will notice that a good argument can still be disagreed with. You may reply that the premises are not true, or that the conclusion does not follow, or that a hidden assumption is doubtful. All three are fair replies. Knowing which of the three you mean is already a gain.
6. Argument, persuasion and witness
An argument is not the same as persuasion. Persuasion is anything that moves a person to believe or do something: a good reason, but also a warm voice, a beautiful hymn, a crowd, fear, or friendship. Some persuasion is honest and some is not. An argument offers reasons that a listener may weigh, and if the reasons are poor the listener can see so. Reasons are a respectful way to persuade, because they leave the other person free to judge.
A witness is different again. A witness says what they have seen, heard, received or lived: "This is what happened to me", "This is what the church has handed on to me", "This is what I trust". Much of Scripture and of Christian life is witness. A witness is not a weak argument. It belongs to another kind of speech, and it is judged differently: we ask whether the witness is truthful and in a position to know, not whether the premises lead to a valid conclusion. A student of theology needs to tell when a text is arguing, when it is witnessing, when it is praying and when it is telling a story. Treating a psalm as a chain of premises misses what it is.
This is a point where readers will not agree: how much of theology is argument. Some writers, in the scholastic tradition of the medieval universities and in many later schools, hold that theology is in large part careful reasoning from what has been revealed, and that clear argument is a form of faithfulness: it honours the truth by being exact about it. Others, including many in the Orthodox and mystical traditions and many Pentecostal and Anabaptist readers, stress that theology is first worship, practice and testimony, and that too much stress on argument turns a living faith into a debate. The first view is weak if it forgets that people are not saved by winning arguments. The second is weak if it uses "we cannot argue about this" to avoid giving any reasons at all. This course requires only that you can tell argument from other speech, and that where you use argument you use it honestly.
7. A word about Paul
Return to Acts 17:2-3. Paul is said to have reasoned and explained "from the Scriptures". What did that look like? Luke does not give the steps. It is fair to say that it included giving reasons. It would go beyond the text to say that Paul used a particular school's method, or that reasoning was all he did. The verse invites us to value reasons without making them the only thing that matters.
In Romans 5 we see a clear pattern, one man and one man, one act and one act, a "so then" and a "even so". Readers who map the passage find a comparison more than a chain of premises, and they disagree about how far the comparison runs. Mapping helps us see what is being claimed, and it shows where the disagreement begins. It does not decide it.
Diagram 1. An argument as a map
Diagram 2. Argument, persuasion, witness
In short
- An argument offers premises as reasons for a conclusion; words such as "because" and "so" often mark them.
- An argument is valid if the conclusion would have to be true when the premises are; it is sound if it is valid and the premises are in fact true.
- Most arguments leave a premise unsaid; naming that hidden assumption is often where real disagreement is found.
- Drawing an argument as boxes and arrows shows what is claimed and what supports what.
- Argument, persuasion and witness are different kinds of speech, and argument is not the whole of theology.
- Readers differ on how large a part argument plays in theology, and on how to read Romans 5:12-21.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Premise and conclusion | A premise is a reason offered; the conclusion is the claim it is supposed to support. |
| Valid and sound | Valid: the conclusion must be true if the premises are. Sound: valid, and the premises are in fact true. |
| Hidden assumption | An unstated premise the argument leans on; say it aloud and look at it. |
| Argument, persuasion, witness | Reasons to weigh; anything that moves a person; what someone has seen, received or lived. |
One sentence to remember An argument is a map of reasons: draw it, ask "does it follow?" and "is it so?", and remember that argument is a tool of theology and not all of it.
This week's action Take one paragraph you read this week, underline its conclusion, and write down its premises and one hidden assumption.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Take the argument "The meeting was cancelled, so we cannot hold the prayer evening." What is the hidden premise? Can you think of a case in which the hidden premise would be false?
- Give an example of an argument that is valid but not sound, and an example of one that seems sound but is not valid.
- Choose one paragraph from a book or a sermon you know. Which sentence is the conclusion, and which are the premises? Is any part of it witness, prayer or story rather than argument?
- Why might an honest argument be more respectful of a listener than a very moving story? When might a story or a witness be the right thing to offer instead?
- Acts 17:2-3 says Paul "reasoned" from the Scriptures. What can we say about this from the text, and what would go beyond it?