FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil

Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs

Contents 31
STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
  3. Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
  4. Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
  1. Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
  3. Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
  4. Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
  2. Lecture 4-2: Analogy
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
  4. Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
  2. Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
  3. Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
  4. Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More
  3. Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross
  4. Lecture 6-4: Neither Enemy nor Servant: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Philosophy and My Theology on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

Lecture 2-1 asked what it is to know. Lecture 2-2 asked how reason, revelation and faith fit together. This lecture asks a sharper question: must a person have evidence before believing? Everyone agrees that we should not believe things for no reason at all. The disagreement begins when we ask what counts as a reason, and whether some beliefs may be held without being proved from others.

Three ideas from epistemology help here: evidentialism, foundationalism (with its basic beliefs) and Reformed epistemology. We explain each with everyday examples, say what each is trying to protect, and name a weak point of each. The lecture does not rank them. Two parts are harder than the rest, the argument about the rule of evidence and the "Great Pumpkin" objection. You may read them slowly or skim them; the lecture still works without them.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • Explain evidentialism in a sentence, with its strength and its weak point.
  • Explain why a chain of reasons must stop somewhere, and what a basic belief is, with everyday examples.
  • Describe the idea of Reformed epistemology in a sentence or two, and name one objection to it.
  • State what each of the three positions wants to protect.
  • Say why none of these positions is a proof text for faith, and what the course requires of you.

Oh taste and see that Yahweh is good. Blessed is the man who takes refuge in him." — Psalm 34:8

World English Bible

Jesus said to him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are those who have not seen, and have believed.”" — John 20:29

WEB

What the text says. Psalm 34:8 invites the reader to "taste and see" that God is good: it speaks of a kind of knowing that comes by trying, by trust and by experience. In John 20:29 Jesus speaks to Thomas, who had asked to see, and says that those who have not seen and yet believe are blessed.

What traditions read. Some readers draw from Psalm 34:8 that experience is a kind of evidence for faith. Others say that a psalm of praise is not a theory of evidence at all. John 20:29 has been read as a word that is gentle to Thomas and as a blessing on later believers; some readers stress that the Gospel itself was written so that people may believe (John 20:31), which suggests that witnesses matter. Readers weigh these differently.

Our judgement. Neither verse settles whether belief needs evidence. A person who holds that evidence is required, and a person who holds that some belief may be held without proof, can each read both verses in good conscience. We read them here as the occasion for the question, not as its answer.

1. Why a chain of reasons must stop

Suppose I say: "I believe my friend will arrive on Thursday." You ask, "Why?" I say, "She wrote to me." You ask, "Why do you believe the letter is from her?" I say, "I know her handwriting." You ask, "Why do you trust your memory of her handwriting?" I say, "Well... I just remember it."

Notice what has happened. At each step I gave a reason, and each reason rested on something else. If you kept asking "why?" I would sooner or later reach something for which I have no further reason to give. I may point to my memory, to what I see before me or to what seems plainly so. This is not a shameful point. No chain of reasons can go on for ever. Either it stops somewhere, or it goes round in a circle, or it never ends. Most people think that a chain that never ends proves nothing, and that a circle is no good either. That leaves stopping places.

2. Foundationalism and basic beliefs

Foundationalism is the view that our knowledge is like a building: some beliefs rest on other beliefs, but at the bottom lie beliefs that do not rest on others. These are the basic beliefs, the foundation. A basic belief is one that I hold without having proved it from some other belief.

Everyday examples of beliefs that many people take as basic:

  • Memory: "I had breakfast this morning." I did not work it out. I simply remember.
  • The senses: "There is a table in front of me." I do not argue my way to it. I see it.
  • Other minds: "That person feels pain like me." Nobody proves it first. We take it as so, and later reasons only confirm it.
  • Simple truths of reason: "If all dogs are animals and Rex is a dog, then Rex is an animal."

If beliefs like these were not allowed to count until proved, it is hard to see how we could believe anything at all. So foundationalism looks reasonable. The next question is: which beliefs are allowed to be basic, and who decides? A long tradition said: only beliefs that are certain in themselves, such as simple truths of reason, or evident to the senses. We may call this a strict foundationalism. Beliefs that are not like that must be supported by reasons drawn from beliefs that are.

3. Evidentialism

is the view that a person should believe something only in proportion to the evidence for it. It is an old and honourable idea. A nineteenth-century English philosopher, W. K. Clifford, is often cited as having put it sharply: that it is wrong to believe on thin evidence, because a belief affects what we do and what others do. You do not have to agree with him to see what he was worried about. A ship-owner who ignores the warnings about his ship and tells himself it is fine does wrong, even if the ship happens to arrive safely.

Applied to faith, evidentialism asks: what is the evidence that God exists, or that Christ rose? Many Christians accept the question and answer it. Some point to arguments from reason (lecture 3-4 will read these fairly), to the witness of Scripture, to history, to experience and to the lives of believers. In the Catholic tradition, a good many thinkers hold that there are truths that reason can approach as groundwork for faith, which is a way of treating evidence as relevant. Many Protestant and Evangelical writers likewise take historical and rational evidence to be important and useful.

What evidentialism wants to protect: honesty and responsibility in belief. We should not believe whatever is comfortable, and should not demand that others do.

Its weak points: critics raise two. First, what counts as evidence? If only certain things may count, the rule may be too narrow to fit how ordinary people reasonably believe many things. Second, a critic points to the rule itself: "believe only what is supported by evidence" does not seem to be something that can be supported by evidence of the kind it requires. A defender may reply that the rule is a plain matter of sound thinking and does not need such support, and the discussion goes on.

4. Reformed epistemology

In the later twentieth century a group of philosophers, many of them Reformed or otherwise Protestant Christians, put forward another view, now often called Reformed epistemology. The philosopher most often associated with it is Alvin Plantinga; we give only the idea, not the details of his work.

The idea starts from foundationalism, with a twist. It asks why the list of basic beliefs should be as short as the strict foundationalist says. If memory and the senses are allowed to be basic, even though they cannot be proved without circle, why should belief in God not be allowed too, in the right circumstances? Think of a person who looks up at the night sky or feels a deep sense of guilt and gratitude and finds herself believing that God made all this and is to be thanked. On this view, such a belief arises naturally, like a memory, without being argued from other beliefs. In the right circumstances, and when the person's faculties are working properly, it may be a properly basic belief.

The thinkers who hold this often draw on the sixteenth-century Reformer John Calvin, who wrote of a natural sense of the divine in people. They do not say that arguments for God are worthless. They say that a person need not have such arguments in hand to believe reasonably, just as a person need not have proved that the past exists in order to believe reasonably that it does.

What it wants to protect: the reasonableness of the ordinary believer, who may never have read a single philosophical argument, and the freedom of faith from the demand that it first pass an examination set by someone else.

Its weak points: an objection that was put in a vivid way is called the Great Pumpkin objection. If belief in God may be basic without argument, critics ask, why may not someone say that belief in a Great Pumpkin who returns each autumn is basic for them, and so is also reasonable? A reply from supporters is that being basic is not a free licence. A basic belief arises in suitable conditions and may be challenged and given up if good reasons against it appear, and so not every belief claiming to be basic is allowed. Critics in turn ask who decides what the suitable conditions are, and whether the reply gives the believer a protection that others do not have. The discussion is still alive.

5. How the positions differ

This is a point where readers will not agree. Thoughtful Christians divide here, and so do non-Christians. Those who press evidentialism say that belief which cannot give reasons is open to every kind of error, and that Christians, who believe that truth matters, should be ready to show their reasons. They say that this is respectful of those who do not believe, since it offers a shared way to talk. Their weak point is the question of the rule itself, and the worry that most people believe most things without having examined the evidence. Those who press Reformed epistemology say that belief in God can be reasonable even without arguments, because the same is true of many beliefs everyone holds, and that to demand more of faith than of memory is unfair. Their weak point is the Great Pumpkin question, and the worry that the position makes belief hard to test. A third group, including many Catholic and many Orthodox thinkers, would say that this whole way of putting the matter is too narrow: that knowing God is more than holding a belief with or without evidence, and that arguments, experience, the life of the church and God's own grace work together. Their weak point is that, without some clear account, it is hard to say what would count against a claim. This course requires that you state each of these positions so that its holders would accept it, name each weak point and give reasons for your own view if you have one. It does not require you to take a side.

6. What each wants to protect

It helps to put the three side by side, as questions of care.

  • Evidentialism cares for honesty. It wants us not to believe more than we can show.
  • Reformed epistemology cares for ordinary faith. It wants us not to make believers pass a test that no one passes in everyday life.
  • The wider approach cares for the wholeness of knowing God. It wants us not to shrink faith into a single operation of the mind.

These cares are not opposed. A Christian can hold all three and still weigh them differently. What would be a mistake is to say that one care shows that the others are not a care at all.

7. A caution about proof texts

It is tempting to look for a verse that settles the matter. "Taste and see" seems to support experience; "blessed are those who have not seen" seems to support faith without proof; the call to be ready to give a reason for one's hope seems to support evidence (we meet that verse in week 5). Each can be quoted by one side, and each is also read by another. Scripture was not written to settle a twentieth-century debate in epistemology. Use it as a source of the question and as a guide to the life of faith, but not as a ruling.


Diagram 1. Three positions on belief and evidence

Where does the chain of reasons stop? Basic beliefs, and three ways of caring for belief My friend will come on Thursday She wrote to me I know her handwriting I remember it a basic belief: no further reason Evidentialism Cares for honesty. Weak point: what counts as evidence, and does the rule meet its own test? Reformed epistemology Cares for ordinary faith. Belief in God may be basic. Weak point: the Great Pumpkin question. The wider approach Cares for the wholeness of knowing God. Weak point: what would count against a claim? None is ranked. All can be held with some weight. Cautions Every chain of reasons stops somewhere: a basic belief is not a shameful one. Being basic is not a licence: a basic belief can still be challenged. Do not use one verse as a ruling in this debate; each side reads the same verses.

In short

  • No chain of reasons can go on for ever; it must stop at beliefs that are not proved from others, called basic beliefs.
  • Evidentialism says to believe in proportion to evidence; it cares for honesty, and its weak points are what counts as evidence and whether its own rule meets its own test.
  • Reformed epistemology holds that belief in God may be properly basic, like memory; it cares for ordinary faith, and the Great Pumpkin objection is a weak point.
  • Basic is not a licence: a basic belief can still be challenged and given up.
  • A wider approach holds that knowing God involves arguments, experience, the church and grace together, and has its own weak point.
  • The course asks you to state each position fairly and to give reasons for your own view, not to take a side.
Front Back
Basic belief A belief held without proving it from another belief, such as memory, what I see or the existence of other minds.
Evidentialism Believe in proportion to the evidence; it protects honesty; critics ask what counts as evidence.
Reformed epistemology Belief in God may be properly basic, like memory; it protects ordinary faith; the Great Pumpkin objection is a challenge to it.
Why no proof text Each side reads the same verses, and Scripture was not written to settle a debate in epistemology.

One sentence to remember Every chain of reasons stops somewhere, and the question is not whether we have basic beliefs but which may be held and how they can still be tested.

This week's action Pick one belief you hold and write down your reasons, then ask which of them is basic.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Take a belief of yours that you are sure of and ask "why?" three or four times. Where does the chain stop? Is the stopping place reasonable?
  • Which of the examples of basic belief (memory, the senses, other minds, simple truths of reason) would you be least willing to give up? Why?
  • What would a person who presses evidentialism say to protect honesty? What is the weak point in the rule that "belief should fit the evidence"?
  • State Reformed epistemology so that a holder of it would say, "Yes, that is my view." Then explain the Great Pumpkin objection and the reply to it.
  • Why is it a mistake to use Psalm 34:8 or John 20:29 as a decisive proof text in this debate?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.