Lecture 2-2: The Documentary Hypothesis in Its Classic Form
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: What Torah and Pentateuch Mean, and Why the Difference Matters
- Lecture 1-2: The Shape of the Five Books: Narrative, Law, and the Seams Between Them
- Lecture 1-3: A History of Reading: Jewish, Patristic, Reformation, and Modern
- Lecture 2-1: Mosaic Authorship, Tradition, and the Rise of Source Criticism
- Lecture 2-2: The Documentary Hypothesis in Its Classic Form
- Lecture 2-3: After Wellhausen: Fragment, Supplement, and the Present Debate
- Lecture 3-1: Creation and Flood Accounts: Enuma Elish, Atrahasis, Gilgamesh
- Lecture 3-2: Law Collections: Hammurabi, Eshnunna, and the Covenant Code
- Lecture 3-3: Treaty and Covenant Forms: Hittite Vassal Treaties and Deuteronomy
- Lecture 4-1: Genesis 1 and 2: Two Accounts, One Creator
- Lecture 4-2: Genesis 3-5: Disobedience, Cain, and the Line of Seth
- Lecture 4-3: Genesis 6-11: Flood, the Noahic Covenant, and Babel
- Lecture 5-1: The Call of Abram and the Shape of the Promise
- Lecture 5-2: Covenant, Circumcision, and the Binding of Isaac
- Lecture 5-3: Jacob: Deception, Wrestling, and the Making of Israel
- Lecture 6-1: The Joseph Narrative as Literature
- Lecture 6-2: Providence, Human Evil, and Genesis 50:20
- Lecture 6-3: Jacob's Blessing, Judah, and the Bridge into Exodus
- Lecture 7-1: Oppression, the Midwives, and the Call of Moses
- Lecture 7-2: The Plagues and the Hardening of Pharaoh's Heart
- Lecture 7-3: Passover, the Sea, and Provision in the Wilderness
- Lecture 8-1: Sinai and the Decalogue
- Lecture 8-2: The Covenant Code and the Ratification of the Covenant
- Lecture 8-3: The Golden Calf, Intercession, and the Tabernacle
- Lecture 9-1: The Sacrificial System of Leviticus 1-7
- Lecture 9-2: Priesthood, Purity, and the Day of Atonement
- Lecture 9-3: The Holiness Code and What It Asks of a People
- Lecture 10-1: Census, Camp, and the Order of the Wilderness March
- Lecture 10-2: Rebellion, the Spies, and the Judgment on a Generation
- Lecture 10-3: Balaam, the Second Generation, and the Plains of Moab
- Lecture 11-1: Deuteronomy as Covenant Document and as Sermon
- Lecture 11-2: The Deuteronomic Code and the Question of Centralization
- Lecture 11-3: Blessing, Curse, and the Death of Moses
Ask a student who has heard of the Documentary Hypothesis — the theory that the Pentateuch was assembled from four originally separate written sources — to explain it, and you will usually get some version of this: "One source calls God Elohim, another calls him Yahweh, so scholars split the text into strands and found four of them." That summary is not exactly wrong, but it is misleading in a way that matters, and it does a disservice to students on every side of the question. It leaves the impression that the theory stands or falls with the divine names, so that a single passage where the pattern breaks down would collapse the whole structure. It also makes Julius Wellhausen sound like a man counting words, which he emphatically was not.
Wellhausen's Prolegomena to the History of Israel (1878, second edition 1883) did not primarily argue that there are four sources. Others had argued that before him, and the four-source division was largely in place by the time he wrote. What Wellhausen did was to arrange those sources in a particular order and to make that order tell a story — a reconstructed history of Israelite worship, moving from many local altars, to a single centralized sanctuary, to an elaborate priestly system administered by a hereditary clergy. The sources were dated by where they fit in that history. It was the historical reconstruction that persuaded a generation, not the vocabulary counts, and any account of the classic Documentary Hypothesis that omits the reconstruction has left out the engine and described the paint.
This lecture presents that argument in the form Wellhausen gave it, names the two predecessors whose work he synthesized — Wilhelm Vatke and Karl Heinrich Graf — and then asks the harder question: how much of the developmental scheme came from the biblical texts, and how much from a nineteenth-century European intellectual atmosphere in which religions were expected to evolve from spontaneous beginnings toward institutional decline. That question is fair to ask, and it must be asked without turning Wellhausen into a cartoon. He was among the finest philologists of his century, and he did not invent his evidence.
이 29분으로 얻는 것
- Identify the four sources of the classic hypothesis with their conventional characteristics, approximate dates, and the reasons each date was assigned.
- Explain why the history of the cult, rather than the divine names, was the load-bearing element of Wellhausen's argument.
- Reconstruct the three-stage cultic development from Exodus 20:24, Deuteronomy 12:5-7, and Leviticus 17:8-9, and state the alternative explanation of the same three texts.
- Name the contributions of Wilhelm Vatke and Karl Heinrich Graf and explain what Wellhausen added to them.
- Assess, in a measured way, the claim that Wellhausen's scheme reflects nineteenth-century assumptions about religious evolution.
But to the place which Yahweh your God shall choose out of all your tribes, to put his name there, you shall seek his habitation, and there you shall come. There you shall bring your burnt offerings, your sacrifices, your tithes, the wave offering of your hand, your vows, your freewill offerings, and the firstborn of your herd and of your flock. There you shall eat before Yahweh your God, and you shall rejoice in all that you put your hand to, you and your households, in which Yahweh your God has blessed you. — Deuteronomy 12:5-7
World English Bible
You shall make an altar of earth for me, and shall sacrifice on it your burnt offerings and your peace offerings, your sheep and your cattle. In every place where I record my name I will come to you and I will bless you. — Exodus 20:24
WEB
You shall say to them, 'Any man there is of the house of Israel, or of the strangers who live as foreigners among them, who offers a burnt offering or sacrifice, and doesn't bring it to the door of the Tent of Meeting, to sacrifice it to Yahweh; that man shall be cut off from his people. — Leviticus 17:8-9
WEB
The centerpiece of Wellhausen's reconstruction was the law of the single sanctuary in Deuteronomy:
Set that beside the altar law in the Book of the :
And beside the priestly regulation in Leviticus:
Wellhausen read these three as three successive stages of Israelite practice. Whether they are three stages or three complementary provisions of one system is the argument this lecture will lay out on both sides.
1. The four sources, briefly
Before the argument, the inventory. The classic hypothesis identified four continuous written documents, conventionally labeled by letters:
J, from the German Jahwist, uses the divine name Yahweh from Genesis onward and was thought to originate in the southern kingdom of Judah, perhaps in the ninth or tenth century BC. Its narrative style is vivid and anthropomorphic: God walks in the garden, closes the ark door, comes down to see the tower. Its interest runs through Abraham, Judah, and the promise of land and blessing.
E, the Elohist, uses Elohim for God until the revelation of the name in Exodus 3, and was located in the northern kingdom of Israel, perhaps in the eighth century. It was said to prefer indirect divine communication — dreams, angels, a voice from heaven — and to show interest in prophets and in the fear of God. E was always the weakest link in the chain: it survives, on the theory, only in fragments, and it is the source most doubted by later scholars, including many who accept the rest of the scheme.
D, the Deuteronomist, is essentially the book of Deuteronomy, characterized by its sermonic style, its insistence on a single sanctuary, its language of love and covenant loyalty, and its distinctive vocabulary. Its dating is discussed below, and it is the anchor of the whole system.
P, the Priestly source, covers Genesis 1, the genealogies, much of Exodus 25-40, nearly all of Leviticus, and much of Numbers. Its style is ordered, formulaic, and precise: measurements, dates, lists, and repeated formulae. It is concerned with the sanctuary, the priesthood of Aaron, sacrifice, purity, and covenant signs such as the sabbath, circumcision, and the rainbow. Wellhausen dated it last, to the exilic or post-exilic period — and that single move is what made his scheme revolutionary.
The order, in the classic form, is J, then E, then a combined JE, then D in the seventh century, then P in the sixth or fifth, with a final redactor combining the whole. The mnemonic JEDP names the sequence of composition, not the order of the text.
2. Why the order mattered more than the inventory
Note what is genuinely at stake in placing P last. On the traditional view, and on the view of most scholars before the mid-nineteenth century, the elaborate priestly legislation of Exodus, Leviticus, and Numbers stood at the beginning of Israel's religious history: the tabernacle, the sacrificial system, and the Aaronic priesthood were the framework within which everything later happened, and the prophets called Israel back to a covenant it had abandoned. Wellhausen inverted this. On his reconstruction, the prophets came first and the law came later; the priestly system was not the foundation of Israelite religion but its final and, in his judgment, degenerate form; and the tabernacle of Exodus 25-40 was not a wilderness structure at all but a retrojection of the Jerusalem temple into the Mosaic period.
This inversion is why the Prolegomena was explosive in a way that a mere division into sources could never have been. It did not simply say that Moses had help. It said that the religion of the — priestly, sacrificial, centralized, ordered — was the end of a development rather than its beginning, and that the vivid, spontaneous religion of the early narratives and the prophets had been buried under it. Whatever one concludes about the evidence, one should be clear about the size of the claim.
3. The three-stage argument from the law of the altar
Here is the reconstruction in its essential form, and it is worth following the steps carefully rather than accepting the conclusion.
Stage one. Exodus 20:24, in the Book of the Covenant, permits an altar of earth and sacrifice "in every place where I record my name." Alongside this, the narratives of Genesis, Judges, and Samuel show altars and sacrifices at many places — Bethel, Shechem, Beersheba, Shiloh, Mizpah, Ophrah — offered by patriarchs, judges, and even non-priests, apparently without censure. Wellhausen took this as the earliest stage: worship at many local sanctuaries, taken for granted and not regarded as irregular.
Stage two. Deuteronomy 12 forbids precisely this. Sacrifice is to be brought to "the place which Yahweh your God shall choose," and Deuteronomy 12:8 explicitly contrasts the new regulation with current practice: "You shall not do after all the things that we do here this day, every man whatever is right in his own eyes." Deuteronomy also makes provision for the consequences of centralization — permitting ordinary slaughter for food away from the sanctuary, providing for Levites displaced from local shrines, converting tithes to money for travel. Those provisions, Wellhausen argued, are exactly what a legal reform would need if centralization were a new policy rather than an existing state of affairs.
Stage three. Leviticus 17 assumes centralization as settled and beyond debate. It does not argue for a single sanctuary or make transitional provisions; it simply legislates on the assumption that all sacrifice occurs at the Tent of Meeting, and prescribes being "cut off" for anyone who does otherwise. A law that assumes what an earlier law had to fight for, Wellhausen reasoned, comes later.
Chain this to the historical books and you get dates. Second Kings 22-23 reports that a law book was found in the temple during the reign of Josiah, around 622 BC, and that the reform which followed consisted precisely in destroying the local shrines and centralizing worship in Jerusalem. Wilhelm Martin Leberecht de Wette had proposed in his 1805 dissertation that this book was Deuteronomy, or its core. If de Wette was right, D is anchored to the late seventh century. P, assuming what D fights for, must be later — exilic or post-exilic. J and E, knowing nothing of centralization, must be earlier. The sequence is fixed, and everything else follows.
That is the actual architecture of the classic . The divine names help sort narrative material into J and E; they do nothing whatever to establish the dates. Remove the cultic reconstruction and the whole scheme loses its chronology, which is to say it loses its point.
4. Vatke and Graf: what Wellhausen inherited
Wellhausen was generous about his predecessors, and it is worth being equally so.
Wilhelm Vatke (1806-1882) published Die biblische Theologie wissenschaftlich dargestellt in 1835, arguing that the priestly law was late and that Israel's religion developed from simpler to more elaborate forms. Vatke taught in Berlin during the years of Hegel's greatest influence there and worked with an explicitly Hegelian framework, in which history unfolds through developmental stages. Wellhausen acknowledged Vatke's priority and described his own debt to him in strong terms. The Hegelian element is a real feature of the scheme's ancestry, not a slur invented by opponents, though it should not be exaggerated either: Vatke's argument was made from texts as well as from philosophy.
Karl Heinrich Graf (1815-1869) argued in 1866 that the priestly legislation was later than Deuteronomy and than the prophets, initially holding that the priestly narrative was early while the priestly law was late — an unstable position he later abandoned under pressure from the Dutch scholar Abraham Kuenen, conceding that narrative and law belonged together and both were late. The resulting position is sometimes called the Graf-Kuenen-Wellhausen hypothesis, which is a fairer name than the shorthand usually used.
Wellhausen's own contribution was not the discovery of the components but the demonstration. He worked through Israel's institutions one at a time — the place of worship, sacrifice, the festivals, the priests and Levites, the endowment of the clergy — and showed, in each case, that the same three-stage pattern appeared. The cumulative effect of five independent institutions yielding the same sequence is what convinced readers, and it is a genuinely powerful form of argument. He also wrote extremely well, which matters more in the history of scholarship than it should.
5. The nineteenth-century frame
Read out or read in?
This is a point where readers will not agree, and the disagreement is not only between believers and critics; it runs through the critical guild itself. The question is how much of Wellhausen's developmental scheme was read out of the texts and how much was read into them from the intellectual atmosphere of nineteenth-century Germany.
The case that the frame shaped the results is not hard to state. Wellhausen's sequence — spontaneous early religion, prophetic ethical height, priestly legalistic decline — maps closely onto a pattern of religious development that was widely assumed in his time and place, and it carries an unmistakable evaluative charge. He described the priestly period in terms that were plainly disparaging, and the scheme flattered a Protestant reading of history in which institutional religion is a falling away from an earlier vitality. Jewish scholars noticed this early and objected: Solomon Schechter's description of as higher anti-Semitism, whatever one thinks of the phrasing, registered a real feature of how the scheme positioned post-exilic Judaism as the degenerate end of a story. Yehezkel Kaufmann later mounted a detailed argument from within critical scholarship that the priestly material is in fact pre-exilic, and that Wellhausen's dating of P was driven by his developmental scheme rather than by the linguistic and institutional evidence.
The case on the other side is equally worth stating. That an argument fits its author's cultural expectations does not make it false, and the observation cuts both ways: the traditional dating also fit the expectations of the people who held it. Wellhausen's evidence was textual — the actual differences between Exodus 20:24, Deuteronomy 12, and Leviticus 17 are on the page, and they do require some explanation. Later scholars have revised his dates in both directions while continuing to accept that the legal collections differ in ways that suggest a history. To dismiss the whole reconstruction as Hegelianism in disguise is to avoid the textual problem rather than to solve it.
6. The alternative reading of the same three texts
Fairness requires setting out the main alternative explanation of the altar laws, since a student who has heard only Wellhausen's reading has heard half the argument.
On this reading, the three texts are not three stages but three provisions with different scopes. Exodus 20:24 may be read as permitting altars at places where God has chosen to make his name remembered — that is, at legitimate places of theophany, not simply anywhere the worshipper prefers; the phrase itself contains a qualification. Deuteronomy 12 may be read as anticipating a settled situation in the land after the wandering, a provision for the future rather than a reform of the present, with the "place which Yahweh your God shall choose" left unnamed precisely because it has not yet been chosen. Leviticus 17 may be read as legislation for the wilderness camp, where the Tent of Meeting was in fact accessible to everyone and where the prohibition of sacrifice elsewhere is a practical rule rather than the endpoint of a centuries-long development. On this account the sequence in the text — Exodus, then Leviticus, then Deuteronomy — is the actual sequence, and the appearance of development is produced by the assumption of development.
Defenders of this reading include Kenneth Kitchen, arguing from ancient Near Eastern legal practice, and Meredith Kline and others arguing from the treaty structure of Deuteronomy, which will be taken up in a later chapter of this course. Whether it accounts for Deuteronomy 12:8 as naturally as Wellhausen's reading does is a question worth pressing; the verse's contrast with "what we do here this day" is not trivial for either side.
There is also a middle range, occupied by a good many scholars, which accepts that the legal collections reflect different periods and settings without accepting Wellhausen's specific sequence, his dating of P, or his evaluative narrative of decline. That the debate has more than two positions is itself something to remember.
7. What survived and what did not
Two verdicts, stated separately because they are often confused.
The four-source model as Wellhausen framed it is no longer the working consensus. E is widely doubted or abandoned; the dating of P is contested, with a substantial body of scholarship arguing for a pre-exilic origin; the assumption of four continuous, complete, parallel documents is precisely what the next lecture will show came under sustained attack from the 1970s onward. The confident synthesis of 1878 is gone.
What did not go away is the set of observations the model was built to explain, and the general conviction that the Pentateuch has a compositional history. The differences between the legal collections remain on the page. The doublets remain. The stylistic clusters remain. Wellhausen's answer has been substantially dismantled; his question has not been withdrawn. Keeping those two facts in the same sentence is the discipline this chapter is trying to teach.
The three panels across the top are the argument itself; the anchor below shows where the dates came from. The warning panel gives the main competing reading of the same evidence, which a student should be able to state as readily as the first. The two boxes at the foot separate what has been abandoned from what has not.
6. Further Reading
- Julius Wellhausen, Prolegomena to the History of Israel, translated by J. Sutherland Black and Allan Menzies (1885; various reprints). The introduction and the chapter on the place of worship are the essential reading.
- Ernest Nicholson, The Pentateuch in the Twentieth Century: The Legacy of Julius Wellhausen (Clarendon, 1998). Sympathetic to Wellhausen and clear about what has and has not survived.
- Yehezkel Kaufmann, The Religion of Israel: From Its Beginnings to the Babylonian Exile, abridged and translated by Moshe Greenberg (University of Chicago Press, 1960). The major argument for a pre-exilic P from inside critical scholarship.
- Kenneth A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Eerdmans, 2003), especially the treatment of law and covenant.
- R. N. Whybray, The Making of the Pentateuch: A Methodological Study (JSOT Press, 1987). A rigorous critique of the criteria used by source critics, by a scholar who was not defending traditional authorship.
- Jean-Louis Ska, Introduction to Reading the Pentateuch (Eisenbrauns, 2006). A Catholic scholar's careful and current survey of the whole question.
- Antony F. Campbell and Mark A. O'Brien, Sources of the Pentateuch: Texts, Introductions, Annotations (Fortress, 1993). Prints the text divided by source, so you can see what the theory actually claims about particular verses rather than reading about it.
핵심 요약
- Wellhausen's Prolegomena to the History of Israel (1878) was persuasive because of its historical reconstruction of Israelite worship — many local altars, to a single centralized sanctuary, to an elaborate priestly system — not primarily because of the J/E divine-name split, which sorts narrative material but does nothing to establish dates.
- The three-stage argument rests on reading Exodus 20:24 (altars "in every place"), Deuteronomy 12:5-8 (one chosen place, explicitly contrasted with "what we do here this day"), and Leviticus 17:8-9 (centralization simply assumed, on pain of being "cut off") as successive stages of practice rather than as three complementary provisions.
- Wellhausen dated Deuteronomy to about 622 BC by identifying it with the law book found in Josiah's temple reform (2 Kings 22-23), following Wilhelm de Wette's 1805 dissertation; everything centralization-naive (J, E) had to precede it, and everything assuming centralization (P) had to follow, placing P in the exile or after.
- Wilhelm Vatke (1835) supplied the developmental, Hegelian framework and Karl Heinrich Graf (1866) argued the priestly legislation was later than Deuteronomy and the prophets — Wellhausen's contribution was demonstrating the same three-stage pattern across five separate institutions (sanctuary, sacrifice, festivals, priests and Levites, clergy endowment).
- Critics from inside the guild, notably Yehezkel Kaufmann, argued the priestly material is actually pre-exilic and that Wellhausen's dating was driven by his developmental scheme rather than by the linguistic evidence; Solomon Schechter separately objected that the scheme cast post-exilic Judaism as religion's degenerate endpoint.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: The classic Documentary Hypothesis is not "Elohim here, Yahweh there" — its real engine was Wellhausen's reconstruction of Israelite worship moving through three stages: many local altars permitted in Exodus 20:24, centralization argued for and against present practice in Deuteronomy 12:5-8, and centralization simply presupposed in Leviticus 17:8-9. Anchoring Deuteronomy to Josiah's law-book discovery in 2 Kings 22-23 (following de Wette, c. 622 BC) let Wellhausen place J and E earlier and P — the priestly system he judged the "final, degenerate" form of Israelite religion — in the exile or after, inverting the traditional order in which law preceded prophecy. Wellhausen synthesized Vatke's developmental framework and Graf's late dating of the priestly law, showing the same three-stage pattern in five institutions, but critics such as Yehezkel Kaufmann pressed a pre-exilic dating for P from inside critical scholarship itself. What survives today is contested — E is widely doubted, P's date is disputed — but the underlying observations (the doublets, the legal differences) have not gone away even as Wellhausen's specific answer has been substantially dismantled.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- The lecture claims that the popular summary of the Documentary Hypothesis — "Elohim here, Yahweh there" — is a caricature that damages students on every side. Explain the specific harm. What false expectation does it create about what would count as refuting the theory?
- Set Exodus 20:24, Deuteronomy 12:5-8, and Leviticus 17:8-9 side by side and read them slowly. Describe the developmental reading and the scope reading of the relationship among them. Which one handles Deuteronomy 12:8 more comfortably, and which one handles the sequence of the books more comfortably?
- Wellhausen's argument gained its force from finding the same three-stage pattern in five independent institutions. Why is a repeated pattern across independent domains a strong form of argument? What would have to be shown to weaken it — and would refuting the pattern in one institution be enough?
- Yehezkel Kaufmann accepted a critical approach to the Pentateuch but argued that the priestly material is pre-exilic. What does his position show about the relationship between source criticism as a method and Wellhausen's particular results?
- Placing P last did not merely re-order documents; it re-ordered Israel's religious history, so that law followed prophecy rather than preceding it. Describe what changes theologically if that inversion is correct, and what changes if it is not. Try to state both without loading the description in advance.
- The lecture insists both that Wellhausen's scheme reflects nineteenth-century assumptions and that noticing this does not refute it. Hold both claims at once and say what work each one does. When is it legitimate to bring an author's intellectual context into an evaluation of their argument?