무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT601E The Pentateuch

Lecture 5-3: Jacob: Deception, Wrestling, and the Making of Israel

목차 37
BT601E The Pentateuch
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Study the Pentateuch
  1. Introduction: Why Study the Pentateuch
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Reading the Pentateuch - Name, Shape, and Scope
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Torah and Pentateuch Mean, and Why the Difference Matters
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Shape of the Five Books: Narrative, Law, and the Seams Between Them
  3. Lecture 1-3: A History of Reading: Jewish, Patristic, Reformation, and Modern
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: The Composition Question
  1. Lecture 2-1: Mosaic Authorship, Tradition, and the Rise of Source Criticism
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Documentary Hypothesis in Its Classic Form
  3. Lecture 2-3: After Wellhausen: Fragment, Supplement, and the Present Debate
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: The Ancient Near Eastern World of the Pentateuch
  1. Lecture 3-1: Creation and Flood Accounts: Enuma Elish, Atrahasis, Gilgamesh
  2. Lecture 3-2: Law Collections: Hammurabi, Eshnunna, and the Covenant Code
  3. Lecture 3-3: Treaty and Covenant Forms: Hittite Vassal Treaties and Deuteronomy
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Genesis 1-11 - Creation and the Primeval History
  1. Lecture 4-1: Genesis 1 and 2: Two Accounts, One Creator
  2. Lecture 4-2: Genesis 3-5: Disobedience, Cain, and the Line of Seth
  3. Lecture 4-3: Genesis 6-11: Flood, the Noahic Covenant, and Babel
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: Genesis 12-36 - The Ancestral Narratives
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Call of Abram and the Shape of the Promise
  2. Lecture 5-2: Covenant, Circumcision, and the Binding of Isaac
  3. Lecture 5-3: Jacob: Deception, Wrestling, and the Making of Israel
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: Genesis 37-50 - Joseph and the Descent into Egypt
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Joseph Narrative as Literature
  2. Lecture 6-2: Providence, Human Evil, and Genesis 50:20
  3. Lecture 6-3: Jacob's Blessing, Judah, and the Bridge into Exodus
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: Exodus 1-18 - Deliverance
  1. Lecture 7-1: Oppression, the Midwives, and the Call of Moses
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Plagues and the Hardening of Pharaoh's Heart
  3. Lecture 7-3: Passover, the Sea, and Provision in the Wilderness
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: Exodus 19-40 - Sinai, Covenant, and Tabernacle
  1. Lecture 8-1: Sinai and the Decalogue
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Covenant Code and the Ratification of the Covenant
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Golden Calf, Intercession, and the Tabernacle
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: Leviticus - Holiness, Sacrifice, and Priesthood
  1. Lecture 9-1: The Sacrificial System of Leviticus 1-7
  2. Lecture 9-2: Priesthood, Purity, and the Day of Atonement
  3. Lecture 9-3: The Holiness Code and What It Asks of a People
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Numbers - Wilderness and the Failed Generation
  1. Lecture 10-1: Census, Camp, and the Order of the Wilderness March
  2. Lecture 10-2: Rebellion, the Spies, and the Judgment on a Generation
  3. Lecture 10-3: Balaam, the Second Generation, and the Plains of Moab
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: Deuteronomy - The Law Preached
  1. Lecture 11-1: Deuteronomy as Covenant Document and as Sermon
  2. Lecture 11-2: The Deuteronomic Code and the Question of Centralization
  3. Lecture 11-3: Blessing, Curse, and the Death of Moses
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: The Theology of the Pentateuch and Its Afterlife
  1. Lecture 12-1: Covenant, Land, and Blessing: The Theology of the Whole
  2. Lecture 12-2: Law and Gospel: How Christians Have Read the Torah
  3. Lecture 12-3: The Pentateuch in Judaism, in the New Testament, and in the Church Today

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

46분

The nation is named after a man who cheats. That is not a modern complaint about Genesis; it is a fact the book puts at the centre of its own account. Jacob buys his brother's birthright at the price of a bowl of stew when the brother comes in starving. He impersonates that brother, wearing his clothes and goatskins on his arms, in order to take a blessing from a blind father who asks him twice who he is. He answers, "I am Esau your firstborn." And the narrator does not condemn him.

That refusal is the problem this lecture works on. The Jacob cycle, Genesis 25-36, is the longest sustained narrative in the ancestral material, and it is the one that most resists being turned into an example. It contains no divine rebuke of the deception, no repentance scene, and no statement that the blessing was wrongly obtained — but it also contains a long series of events in which what Jacob did is done back to him with precision. Laban substitutes an elder daughter for a younger one on a dark wedding night, and explains that in his country the younger is not given before the firstborn. Jacob's own sons will bring him a garment soaked in goat's blood and let him draw the wrong conclusion. The narrative renders a verdict by arranging events rather than by pronouncing one, and learning to read that is most of what this lecture teaches.

Four other matters are taken up. The oracle to Rebekah in Genesis 25:23 — "the elder will serve the younger" — is quoted by Paul in Romans 9 and has been a fixed point in Christian arguments about election ever since; the lecture sets out what the oracle says in Genesis, and then places the major traditions on election side by side without adjudicating between them. The Bethel dream gives the promise to a man in flight who has just deceived his family, which raises the question of what the promise is responding to. The wrestling at Peniel is the point at which Jacob is renamed, and it is narrated with a degree of deliberate obscurity — the opponent is called "a man," refuses to give a name, and Jacob concludes he has seen God. And Genesis 34, the rape of Dinah and the massacre at Shechem, is a chapter in which the narrative's habit of withholding judgement becomes hardest to bear, since it ends on a question that no one answers.

이 46분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe how the Jacob narrative responds to Jacob's deceptions without stating a verdict, and give at least three specific instances of the pattern.
  • State what the oracle of Genesis 25:23 says in its own context, explain how Paul uses it in Romans 9, and outline the Reformed, Arminian, Catholic Thomist and Orthodox approaches to election without misrepresenting any of them.
  • Explain the ambiguities of the Peniel narrative — the opponent's identity, the withheld name, the meaning of the new name — and say why the ambiguity is likely deliberate.
  • Set out what Genesis 34 states, what it withholds, and the main interpretive dispute about it, without softening the account.
  • Explain what Robert Alter's literary approach contributes to reading this material, and what it does not settle.

Jacob was left alone, and wrestled with a man there until the breaking of the day. When he saw that he didn’t prevail against him, he touched the hollow of his thigh, and the hollow of Jacob’s thigh was strained, as he wrestled. The man said, “Let me go, for the day breaks.” Jacob said, “I won’t let you go, unless you bless me.” He said to him, “What is your name?” He said, “Jacob”. He said, “Your name will no longer be called Jacob, but Israel; for you have fought with God and with men, and have prevailed.” — Genesis 32:24-28

World English Bible

Almost every clause raises a question. Who is the man? Why does he need to be released before daybreak? What does it mean that he "didn't prevail" against Jacob, and then wounds him with a touch? In what sense has a man who has just sent his family and possessions ahead of him in fear "prevailed"? The narrative gives no answers, and it names the new nation out of this encounter.

1. The birthright, the blessing, and a narrator who will not judge

Genesis 25 introduces the twins with a struggle in the womb and an oracle, and then gives the birthright episode: Esau comes in from the field exhausted, asks for some of the red stew, and Jacob requires the birthright for it. Esau swears and eats, and the narrator adds one evaluative clause — "So Esau despised his birthright" (25:34) — which is the only judgement passed in the whole episode, and it falls on Esau.

Genesis 27 is longer and is told with more attention to physical detail than almost anything else in the book: the smell of the clothes, the hairy skins on the hands and neck, the food prepared to taste like game, the blind father's hands. Rebekah plans it; Jacob's objection is not that it is wrong but that it might not work and might get him cursed. Then:

He came to his father, and said, “My father?” He said, “Here I am. Who are you, my son?” Jacob said to his father, “I am Esau your firstborn. I have done what you asked me to do. Please arise, sit and eat of my venison, that your soul may bless me.” — Genesis 27:18-19 (WEB)

The lie is direct, and it is said to a dying father in the name of a brother. When Esau arrives, the text records Isaac's reaction:

Isaac trembled violently, and said, “Who, then, is he who has taken venison, and brought it me, and I have eaten of all before you came, and have blessed him? Yes, he will be blessed.” — Genesis 27:33 (WEB)

And then Isaac confirms the blessing rather than revoking it. Esau's own summary is the closest the chapter comes to a moral verdict, and it is put in the mouth of the injured party:

He said, “Your brother came with deceit, and has taken away your blessing.” He said, “Isn’t he rightly named Jacob? For he has supplanted me these two times. He took away my birthright. See, now he has taken away my blessing.” He said, “Haven’t you reserved a blessing for me?” — Genesis 27:35-36 (WEB)

Esau's wordplay is on the name: Jacob, Ya'aqov, is connected in the narrative both to 'aqev, "heel" (25:26, he comes out gripping his brother's heel) and to 'aqav, "to supplant, to deceive." The name is a character description before it is a name.

What the narrator does not do is state that Jacob acted wrongly. There is no rebuke from God, no "and Jacob did evil," no repentance. Readers who expect a narrative to guide their moral response find this hard, and the two usual escapes are both bad. One is to defend Jacob — the oracle had already assigned him the position, so he was only claiming what was his — which turns a lie told to a blind man into an act of faith, and which the narrative nowhere suggests. The other is to import a condemnation the text withholds and then explain that God used a flawed man anyway, which is true as far as it goes but converts the story into a lesson before hearing it out.

The third possibility is to notice how the narrative does respond. It responds by arrangement.

  • Jacob exploits the difference between and younger. In Genesis 29 Laban gives him Leah instead of Rachel, and says: "It is not done so in our place, to give the younger before the firstborn" (29:26). The sentence is a comment on Genesis 27 delivered by a man who knows nothing about it.
  • Jacob deceives a father whose eyes are dim, using clothing and the skin of goats. In Genesis 37 his sons deceive him with a garment and the blood of a goat.
  • Jacob takes advantage of Esau's hunger. In Genesis 42-45 his own sons will go to Egypt hungry and be manipulated by a brother they do not recognise.
  • Jacob leaves the land with nothing but a staff (32:10) and returns twenty years later wealthy but limping.

This kind of patterning — an act returning on the actor without any statement that it is doing so — is a recognised feature of biblical narrative, and Michael Fishbane's study of the Jacob cycle ("Composition and Structure in the Jacob Cycle," Journal of Jewish Studies 26, 1975) set out an elaborate symmetrical arrangement of the whole, with the flight from Esau answering the return to Esau, the two encounters with the divine at Bethel and Peniel framing the Laban material, and the oracle at the start answering the reconciliation near the end.

Patterns can be forced

A warning belongs here, and it is the standing warning of this course. The symmetry is attractive, and the more elaborate versions of it are partly the interpreter's construction: the boundaries of the units are chosen, some elements are counted as parallel on thin grounds, and material that does not fit — the birth notices, chapter 34, chapter 36 — has to be set aside or explained. The pattern of measure-for-measure listed above is, I think, clearly in the text, because each item involves a concrete repeated element (the elder-and-younger rule, the goat, the garment). The full is a stronger claim and should be held more loosely.

2. The oracle and the argument about election

The children struggled together within her. She said, “If it be so, why do I live?” She went to inquire of Yahweh. Yahweh said to her, “Two nations are in your womb. Two peoples will be separated from your body. The one people will be stronger than the other people. The elder will serve the younger.” — Genesis 25:22-23 (WEB)

This is a point where readers will not agree. Begin with what the oracle says in Genesis. It is addressed to Rebekah, not to Jacob or Esau. It speaks of "two nations" and "two peoples," not of two individuals only. And what it predicts is service: the elder will serve the younger. In the rest of the Hebrew Bible this is read as a statement about Israel and Edom, whose relations — subjection, revolt, hostility — occupy a good deal of the later narrative and prophecy. Genesis says nothing here about the eternal destiny of either man.

Paul quotes it in Romans 9 in the course of an argument about why the promises to Israel have not failed even though many Israelites have not believed in Jesus:

For being not yet born, neither having done anything good or bad, that the purpose of God according to might stand, not of works, but of him who calls, it was said to her, “The elder will serve the younger.” Even as it is written, “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.” — Romans 9:11-13 (WEB)

The second quotation is from Malachi 1:2-3, which is also about nations: Malachi's "Esau" is Edom, whose territory has been laid waste. Paul's own argument is about God's freedom in choosing, and about the fact that membership in the promise has never been determined simply by descent.

The interpretive dispute concerns what Paul is doing with it, and the traditions divide.

Reformed. On the reading that runs from John Calvin (Institutes III.21-24) through the Synod of Dort to modern defenders such as John Murray and John Piper, Romans 9 concerns individual election to salvation, and the point of "not yet born, neither having done anything good or bad" is precisely that the choice rests on God's purpose and not on anything foreseen in the person. The corporate reference of Genesis 25:23 is granted; the argument is that Paul moves from the corporate case to the principle, which he then applies to individuals in Romans 9:14-24.

Arminian and Wesleyan. Jacobus Arminius and, in the eighteenth century, John Wesley read the chapter as concerning election to service and to privilege rather than to salvation, and held that where individual salvation is in view, election is conditional upon foreseen faith. On this reading Paul's point is that God is free to choose which line carries the promise, which is what Genesis 25:23 actually says, and that this freedom does not entail the unconditional of individuals.

Catholic. The Catholic tradition holds to glory to be gratuitous and not based on foreseen merits, while affirming that grace is genuinely resistible and that God wills the salvation of all. Thomas Aquinas treats predestination in the Summa Theologiae I q.23; the (Session VI) condemned both the view that a person can be saved without grace and the view that the justified are unable to fall away. Within Catholic theology the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century de auxiliis controversy between the Dominican followers of Domingo Báñez and the Jesuit followers of Luis de Molina — over whether efficacious grace works intrinsically or in concert with a middle knowledge of what a free creature would do — was left formally unsettled by Rome, and both schools remain permissible.

Orthodox. Eastern Orthodox theology has generally approached the question through foreknowledge and synergy: John Chrysostom's homilies on Romans read chapter 9 as concerning God's freedom in the ordering of history and God's foreknowledge of response, and John of Damascus distinguished what God wills antecedently from what he permits. The Orthodox emphasis falls on the cooperation of the human will with grace, and the categories of the Western debate — decree, , middle knowledge — are not the ones in which the question is usually posed.

Two observations that belong to the rather than to any of the systems. First, Genesis 25:23 is about peoples and about temporal service; anyone using it for a doctrine of individual eternal destiny is going beyond it, whatever they then do with Romans 9. Second, and cutting the other way, Paul evidently thought the Genesis text bore on something more than Edomite politics, and a reading that reduces Romans 9 to national history has to explain the individual language of Romans 9:14-24. This course does not decide the question, and it should not be decided by an argument from Genesis alone.

3. Bethel: the promise given to a man in flight

Jacob leaves with Esau's threat behind him and stops at a place for the night.

He dreamed. Behold, a stairway set upon the earth, and its top reached to heaven. Behold, the angels of God ascending and descending on it. Behold, Yahweh stood above it, and said, “I am Yahweh, the God of Abraham your father, and the God of Isaac. The land whereon you lie, to you will I give it, and to your seed. Your seed will be as the dust of the earth, and you will spread abroad to the west, and to the east, and to the north, and to the south. In you and in your seed will all the families of the earth be blessed. Behold, I am with you, and will keep you, wherever you go, and will bring you again into this land. For I will not leave you, until I have done that which I have spoken of to you.” — Genesis 28:12-15 (WEB)

The word rendered "stairway" is sullam, which occurs only here in the Hebrew Bible. Its root suggests a ramp or a raised way, and the standard comparison is to the stepped tower — the ziggurat — whose exterior stairway allowed the god to descend to the temple at its base. If that comparison holds, the imagery is of a structure like the one attempted at Babel in Genesis 11, except that here it is not built by anyone and the traffic is initiated from above.

The theological point of the scene lies in its timing. The promise of land, descendants and blessing to the families of the earth is given, in the same terms used to Abraham and Isaac, to a man who is at that moment running away from the consequences of a lie. Nothing in the speech refers to what he has done. Nothing conditions the promise on his improvement.

Jacob's reply is characteristic, and the narrator again declines to evaluate it. He wakes, says the place is dreadful and is the gate of heaven, sets up his stone pillar — and then makes a vow that is phrased as a bargain: if God will be with him and keep him and give him bread and clothing and bring him back safely, then Yahweh will be his God and he will give a tenth (28:20-22). A man who has just been given an unconditional promise responds with terms. The text reports it and moves on.

4. Twenty years with Laban

The Laban material (Genesis 29-31) is where the trickster meets his equal. Jacob works seven years for Rachel, is given Leah, works another seven, and then spends six more in a running contest over flocks in which each man tries to outmanoeuvre the other; wages are changed ten times, according to Jacob (31:41), and Jacob's selective breeding programme is described in detail. The chapters are often skimmed. They should not be, because they are the narrative's answer to chapter 27.

One detail from these chapters bears on the historical question raised in lecture 5-1. When Jacob's household leaves, Rachel steals her father's teraphim, household gods (31:19), and hides them in a camel saddle, sitting on them when Laban searches (31:34-35). E. A. Speiser, drawing on the Nuzi tablets, argued that possession of the household gods carried a claim on the inheritance, so that Rachel was securing her husband's or her own position. That explanation entered many commentaries. It has since been criticised on the ground that the Nuzi evidence does not establish the connection in the form Speiser proposed, and other explanations — that Rachel wanted the protective figures, or that the theft is one more instance of the family's habit of taking things — have been preferred. This is a good example of the general caution stated in 5-1: a background parallel that seems to explain a puzzling detail is attractive precisely because it removes the puzzle, and the removal is not evidence.

5. Peniel

Jacob returns to the border of the land and hears that Esau is coming with four hundred men. He divides his household, prays, sends waves of gifts ahead, sends everyone across the river, and is left alone. Then the wrestling, quoted above.

The narrative is obscure in at least four ways, and the obscurity is too consistent to be accidental.

The identity of the opponent. The text says "a man." Jacob names the place Peniel — "face of God" — and says "I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved" (32:30). Hosea, retelling the episode centuries later, says Jacob "contended with God" and "struggled with the angel" in successive lines (Hosea 12:3-4), which shows that the ambiguity was already there for early readers. Christian interpreters have often identified the man with a pre-incarnate appearance of Christ; Jewish interpretation has often taken him as an angel, in some midrashim specifically the guardian angel of Esau. Genesis identifies him as none of these.

The struggle's outcome. "When he saw that he didn't prevail against him" — the subject is the man, who does not prevail against Jacob, and who then disables him with a touch. A being who can dislocate a hip with a touch was not losing a wrestling match. The narrative gives a contest whose terms it does not explain.

The withheld name. Jacob asks for the name and is not given it (32:29). The refusal is the point at which the scene most clearly signals that Jacob does not control what has happened to him.

The new name and its explanation. The text derives Israel from the encounter: "for you have fought with God and with men, and have prevailed." Hebrew name explanations in Genesis are typically wordplay rather than philology, and this one connects Yisra'el with a root for striving. Modern philologists usually analyse the name differently, as a sentence-name in which El is the subject — "God strives," "God rules," or "may God contend" — since Hebrew names of this shape normally have the divine element as subject rather than object. Both can be true at once: the narrator is telling us what the name means in this story, not offering an etymology.

Two things are worth adding. First, the blessing in this scene is asked for and given — "I won't let you go, unless you bless me" — and it is the second blessing Jacob obtains by holding on to someone stronger than himself. But this one he does not steal, and he is marked for it. Whether the narrative intends that contrast is a reading, not a statement; it is a good reading and I have not found a way to prove it. Second, the limp is permanent. Jacob crosses into the land at sunrise, renamed and injured, and goes to meet the brother he cheated.

6. Esau

The reunion is short and it does not go the way the preparation suggested.

Esau ran to meet him, embraced him, fell on his neck, kissed him, and they wept. — Genesis 33:4 (WEB)

Jacob said, “Please, no, if I have now found favor in your sight, then receive my present at my hand, because I have seen your face, as one sees the face of God, and you were pleased with me. — Genesis 33:10 (WEB)

The second verse links this meeting to the night before: Jacob has seen the face of God and lived, and now he says he has seen his brother's face as one sees the face of God. Whatever the link means, the narrative puts the two encounters side by side deliberately.

It is worth resisting the standard portrait of Esau. Later tradition hardened him considerably — the prophets identify Edom as a hostile neighbour, Obadiah denounces it, rabbinic literature came to use Esau as a cipher for Rome, and Hebrews 12:16 calls him profane. Genesis is more restrained. Esau is impulsive and short-sighted in chapter 25, murderous in intention in chapter 27 after being robbed, and in chapter 33 he runs, embraces, weeps, and initially refuses the gift because he has enough. He is also the one character in the cycle who is never shown deceiving anyone. The brothers part and do not live together, and the text does not say they are reconciled in any deeper sense; but the chapter does not present Esau as a villain, and a teacher who does is importing later material.

7. Genesis 34

Dinah, the daughter of Leah, whom she bore to Jacob, went out to see the daughters of the land. Shechem the son of Hamor the Hivite, the prince of the land, saw her. He took her, lay with her, and humbled her. — Genesis 34:1-2 (WEB)

Then: Shechem wants to marry her; his father negotiates with Jacob; Jacob's sons answer with deceit, requiring that every male in the city be circumcised; on the third day, while the men are in pain, Simeon and Levi kill them all; the other brothers plunder the city and take the women and children. Jacob's response is not about the killing:

Jacob said to Simeon and Levi, “You have troubled me, to make me odious to the inhabitants of the land, among the Canaanites and the Perizzites. I am few in number. They will gather themselves together against me and strike me, and I will be destroyed, I and my house.” — Genesis 34:30 (WEB)

They said, “Should he deal with our sister as with a prostitute?” — Genesis 34:31 (WEB)

The chapter ends on the brothers' question. No one answers it. There is no divine speech in the chapter, no comment from the narrator, and no verdict — the nearest thing comes much later, in Jacob's deathbed poem, where Simeon and Levi are cursed for their anger (49:5-7), and even there the curse is on the violence, not an answer to the question.

Several things should be said plainly. Dinah never speaks. The negotiation about her is conducted between men who are her father, her brothers, her attacker and his father. The brothers use circumcision — the sign of the covenant from Genesis 17 — as a weapon, which makes this the family's most serious deception, and it is performed by the sons of the man who deceived his own father. And Jacob's stated objection is to the danger and the damage to his standing.

There is an interpretive dispute about verse 2 that a student should know about. The verbs are "took," "lay with," and a third which the World English Bible renders "humbled her." A minority reading, argued most fully by Lyn M. Bechtel in 1994, held that the chapter does not describe rape but a socially unacceptable union, and that the offence is one of status and family shame. That argument has been examined and rejected by most subsequent scholarship — Susanne Scholz's monograph Rape Plots (2000) is the fullest response — on the grounds of the verbs used, the parallel language in 2 Samuel 13 and Deuteronomy 22, and the brothers' own characterisation of the act as an outrage. The dispute is worth knowing because it shows how much interpretive work a single verb can be asked to do; it is not a case where the two sides are evenly balanced.

What the chapter does to the argument of this lecture is this. The Jacob narrative's method of withholding judgement is a genuine literary technique, and elsewhere it produces a rich and subtle account of a man and his consequences. Here it produces a chapter in which a woman is assaulted, a city is massacred, and the last word is a question. A reader may reasonably find that the technique has costs.

8. Bethel again, and Esau's genealogy

Genesis 35 returns Jacob to Bethel, where God appears again and renames him — again.

God appeared to Jacob again, when he came from Paddan Aram, and blessed him. God said to him, “Your name is Jacob. Your name shall not be Jacob any more, but your name will be Israel.” He named him Israel. God said to him, “I am God Almighty. Be fruitful and multiply. A nation and a company of nations will be from you, and kings will come out of your body. The land which I gave to Abraham and Isaac, I will give it to you, and to your seed after you will I give the land.” — Genesis 35:9-12 (WEB)

The repetition of the renaming (32:28 and 35:10) is a standard exhibit in source criticism, where the two are assigned to different documents. Read as a finished narrative, the second is a confirmation: the name given in the dark by an unnamed opponent is now given openly, in the place where the promise was first made to him, with the full covenant formula attached. Both explanations are available and they are not mutually exclusive.

Then Rachel dies giving birth to Benjamin, Reuben sleeps with his father's concubine in a single unexplained verse, Isaac dies and is buried by both his sons, and Genesis 36 gives the descendants of Esau: chiefs, clans, and "the kings who reigned in the land of Edom, before any king reigned over the children of Israel" (36:31). The non-chosen brother gets a full and honourable genealogy, and he gets kings first. Whatever the choice of Jacob means in Genesis, it does not mean that Esau's line is erased or that it fails to prosper.

9. Alter, and what a literary reading gives

Robert Alter's The Art of Biblical Narrative (1981) argued that the Hebrew Bible's narratives are works of deliberate literary art whose techniques can be described — narrative reticence, the type-scene, the significance of dialogue over description, the use of repeated key words, the withholding of interior states — and that reading them as artless compilations or as doctrinal deposits misses most of what is there. The Jacob cycle is one of his central exhibits. On his account, the absence of moral commentary in Genesis 27 is not a gap to be filled by the reader's theology but a technique with a purpose: it forces the reader to judge, and it keeps the character irreducible to a lesson. He reads the wordplay on Jacob's name, the recurring garments, the goats, and the elder-and-younger motif as a deliberate network rather than as the residue of transmission.

What the literary reading gives is a way of taking the narrative's silences as meaningful rather than as defects. What it does not settle is anything historical or compositional. Alter's method describes the finished text and is largely indifferent to how the text came to be; a narrative can be artfully arranged and still be composite, and demonstrating literary design in Genesis 27 does not show that one author wrote it, any more than demonstrating a seam shows that no one arranged the result. Readers who use literary unity as an argument against source analysis, or source analysis as a reason to ignore literary design, are both making an inference the evidence does not support.

The diagram sets Jacob's three deceptions against the events that answer them, and marks how much of the correspondence is stated by the text and how much is the reader's inference.

A Ledger the Narrator Never Totals What Jacob does, what is done to him, and how much the text actually says What Jacob does What answers it Stated, or inferred? Exploits the elder/younger order: buys the birthright, takes the blessing (25, 27) Laban gives Leah for Rachel: "the younger before the firstborn" (29:26) Laban says the rule aloud. The link to ch. 27 is the reader's — but hard to miss. Uses goatskins and his brother's clothes to fool a father who cannot see (27) His sons bring him a robe dipped in goat's blood and let him conclude (37:31-33) Shared props (garment, goat), shared method. No cross- reference in the text. Trades on a brother's hunger (25:29-34) His sons go to Egypt hungry and are handled by a brother they do not recognise (42-44) Inference. The resemblance is thematic, not verbal — the weakest row in this table. Takes a blessing by impersonation (27:19) Asks for a blessing under his own name at Peniel, and is renamed and lamed (32:24-31) The name question ("What is your name?") echoes 27:18. A strong reading, still a reading. What the narrator never says No divine rebuke of the deception. No repentance scene. No statement that the blessing was wrongly got. The only explicit verdict in Genesis 25-27 falls on Esau: "So Esau despised his birthright" (25:34). Caution Rows 1 and 2 rest on repeated concrete elements and are secure. Row 3 is thematic and could be coincidence. A fuller chiastic scheme for the whole cycle (Fishbane) claims more than this table does — hold it more loosely.

6. Further Reading

  • Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative, rev. ed. (New York: Basic Books, 2011), and his translation and commentary in The Hebrew Bible: A Translation with Commentary, vol. 1 (New York: Norton, 2019). The literary method and its application to the Jacob cycle.
  • Michael Fishbane, "Composition and Structure in the Jacob Cycle (Gen. 25:19-35:22)," Journal of Jewish Studies 26 (1975): 15-38. The influential symmetrical analysis of the cycle; read it alongside the criticisms of over-elaborate chiastic schemes.
  • Claus Westermann, Genesis 12-36: A Commentary, trans. John J. Scullion (Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1985). The fullest critical commentary on the Jacob material.
  • Nahum M. Sarna, Genesis, JPS Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1989). Excellent on the name wordplay, on Peniel, and on the Jewish interpretive tradition surrounding Esau.
  • Susanne Scholz, Rape Plots: A Feminist Cultural Study of Genesis 34 (New York: Peter Lang, 2000). The fullest treatment of the interpretive history of Genesis 34, including the response to Bechtel's reading.
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018), and Ben Witherington III, Paul's Letter to the Romans: A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004). Two substantial commentaries on Romans 9 that reach different conclusions about individual and corporate election; reading them together is more useful than reading either alone.
  • Brevard S. Childs, of the Old and New Testaments (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1992). For the question of how a narrative like the Jacob cycle functions theologically in a that also contains Romans 9.
  • Terence E. Fretheim, Abraham: Trials of Family and Faith (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2007). Though centred on Abraham, its treatment of divine promise given to morally compromised people bears directly on Bethel.

핵심 요약

  • The narrator never condemns Jacob's deceptions of Esau and Isaac — no divine rebuke, no repentance scene — but the text responds by arrangement: Laban gives Jacob the elder daughter before the younger and states the rule aloud (29:26), and Jacob's own sons later deceive him with a garment dipped in goat's blood (37:31-33), just as he deceived Isaac with goatskins and a garment (27:15-16).
  • The oracle to Rebekah in Genesis 25:23 ("the elder will serve the younger") concerns two nations and temporal service, not individual eternal destiny; Paul quotes it in Romans 9:11-13 alongside Malachi 1:2-3 in an argument about election, and the traditions divide sharply — Reformed (Calvin, individual election to salvation), Arminian/Wesleyan (election to service, conditioned on foreseen faith), Catholic (Aquinas on gratuitous predestination, the unresolved Báñez-Molina de auxiliis dispute), and Orthodox (Chrysostom and John of Damascus on foreknowledge and synergy).
  • At Bethel (28:12-15) the promise of land, seed, and blessing is given in full, unconditionally, to a man actively fleeing the consequences of a lie he has just told, and Jacob's own response is to convert an unconditional promise into a bargain ("if God will be with me... then Yahweh will be my God," 28:20-22) — which the narrator again reports without evaluating.
  • The wrestling at Peniel (32:24-28) is deliberately obscure in four ways: the opponent is called only "a man" (Hosea 12:3-4 later calls him both God and an angel), the man who "didn't prevail" against Jacob disables him with a single touch, the name Jacob asks for is withheld, and the renaming to Israel is explained by wordplay on "striving" even though modern philologists usually analyze Yisra'el as a sentence-name with God as the grammatical subject ("God strives" or "God rules").
  • Genesis 34 (Dinah's rape and the massacre at Shechem) ends on the brothers' unanswered question ("Should he deal with our sister as with a prostitute?", 34:31) with no divine speech, no narratorial verdict, and Jacob's own recorded objection concerned only the danger to his household, not the killing — the clearest case in the cycle where the narrative's habit of withholding judgment, per Robert Alter's literary account, has a real cost.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Israel is named after a man who cheats his brother out of a birthright and impersonates him to steal a blessing, and Genesis never states that this was wrong — instead the narrative renders its verdict by arrangement, having Laban deceive Jacob with the same elder-before-younger substitution (29:26) and having Jacob's own sons deceive him with a blood-soaked garment (37:31-33) just as he deceived Isaac. The promise given to Jacob in flight at Bethel (28:12-15) is unconditional and comes with no reference to what he has just done, which he immediately answers by turning it into a bargain (28:20-22); twenty years later he is renamed Israel after a deliberately obscure night wrestling match at Peniel in which the unnamed opponent "did not prevail" yet disables him with a touch and refuses to give his own name. The oracle behind all of this, "the elder will serve the younger" (25:23), concerns two nations rather than individual salvation in its own setting, which is exactly the exegetical point Paul's use of it in Romans 9 has generated centuries of confessional disagreement over — Reformed, Arminian, Catholic, and Orthodox traditions each locate the passage's force differently. And the cycle's technique of narrative silence, illuminating everywhere else, reaches its limit in Genesis 34, which ends on an unanswered question after a rape and a massacre, with no verdict from God, the narrator, or even Jacob, whose sole recorded complaint is that his sons have endangered him.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • The narrator condemns Esau for despising his birthright and says nothing about Jacob's lie. What is the effect on a reader of a verdict placed on one side only? Is it better described as the narrator taking Jacob's side, or as the narrator declining to take a side and letting one exception show?
  • Laban's line about the younger and the firstborn is spoken by a man who knows nothing of Genesis 27. Does that make the correspondence stronger evidence of design or weaker? Consider what a narrator gains by putting the comment in the mouth of an outsider.
  • Genesis 25:23 concerns two nations and a relation of service. Paul uses it for something larger. Is that a legitimate extension, a change of subject, or something else? Answer without deciding the election question itself.
  • The Peniel opponent is called a man, refuses to give a name, and is identified as God by Jacob. Suppose the ambiguity is deliberate. What does it achieve that a clear identification would not?
  • Genesis 34 ends on the brothers' question and nobody answers it. Is that a failure of the narrative or an achievement of it? Would your answer change if the chapter concerned someone in your own community?
  • Alter's approach makes the narrative's silences meaningful rather than defective. Does that method have a limit — a point at which a silence really is a gap rather than a technique? How would you tell the difference?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.