무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT603E The Letters of Paul

Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It

목차 37
BT603E The Letters of Paul
제 0 장 · Introduction: Reading Paul
  1. Introduction: Reading Paul
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Paul - Life, Sources, and the Shape of a Career
  1. Lecture 1-1: Who Paul Was — Pharisee, Roman Citizen, Apostle
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Damascus Road — Conversion, Call, or Both
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Acts Alongside the Letters
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Letters, Chronology, and the Pauline Collection
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Letter, the Secretary, and the Congregation That Heard It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Chronology: Dating the Letters and Why It Is Contested
  3. Lecture 2-3: Thirteen Letters, Seven Undisputed: How the Corpus Was Formed and Divided
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: 1 and 2 Thessalonians
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Earliest Letter: Founding a Church and Leaving It
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Dead in Christ and the Coming of the Lord
  3. Lecture 3-3: 2 Thessalonians and the Authorship Question
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Galatians
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Crisis: Circumcision, Table Fellowship, and Antioch
  2. Lecture 4-2: Justification, Faith, and the Works of the Law
  3. Lecture 4-3: Freedom, the Spirit, and the Life That Follows
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: 1 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Divided Church: Factions, Wisdom, and the Cross
  2. Lecture 5-2: Bodies, Marriage, Food, and Idols: Ethics in a Pagan City
  3. Lecture 5-3: Worship, Gifts, Love, and the Resurrection of the Body
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: 2 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 6-1: A Damaged Relationship and the Letter's Difficult Unity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ministry in Weakness: Treasure in Clay Jars
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Collection, the Rival Apostles, and Paul's Boasting
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: Romans 1 to 8
  1. Lecture 7-1: Why Romans, and to Whom: Purpose and Audience
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Human Predicament and the Righteousness of God
  3. Lecture 7-3: Baptism, the Law, the Flesh, and Life in the Spirit
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: Romans 9 to 16
  1. Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Renewed Mind: Worship, Government, and the Weak and the Strong
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Ending of Romans and the People Paul Names
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: Philippians and Philemon
  1. Lecture 9-1: Philippians: Partnership, Joy, and Imprisonment
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2
  3. Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Colossians and Ephesians
  1. Lecture 10-1: Colossians: The Supremacy of Christ and the Colossian Philosophy
  2. Lecture 10-2: Ephesians: One Body, and the Question of Its Authorship
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Household Codes and How They Have Been Used
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: The Pastoral Epistles
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It
  2. Lecture 11-2: Order, Office, and Sound Teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus
  3. Lecture 11-3: 2 Timothy: A Last Letter and Its Portrait of Paul
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: Paul's Theology and His Interpreters
  1. Lecture 12-1: Christ, Spirit, and the Shape of Pauline Theology
  2. Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since
  3. Lecture 12-3: Paul After Paul - Reception, Misuse, and Reading Him Now

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

29분

Of all the questions in Pauline studies, the authorship of 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy and Titus is the one where the critical majority is largest and the stakes for church practice are highest. Most academic introductions written in the last century treat the three letters as written in Paul's name by a later admirer, somewhere between about 80 and 120. A serious minority, including scholars with full command of the linguistic evidence, holds that Paul wrote them. And there is a middle ground occupied by proposals that neither side finds satisfying: a secretary given wide freedom, a disciple compiling genuine notes, a follower writing in a way the ancient world regarded as legitimate continuation rather than deception.

This lecture argues three things. First, the case against Pauline authorship is genuinely strong and should be stated in its strongest form before it is answered; a student who has only heard it caricatured has not heard it. Second, each of its main pillars has a real counter-argument, and the counter-arguments are not merely apologetic reflexes — several of them come from linguists and statisticians rather than from theologians. Third, and most importantly for how the rest of this chapter proceeds, the question of who held the pen is a historical question that is distinct from the question of canonical authority, and every major Christian tradition treats these three letters as scripture regardless of where its scholars land on the first question.

The lecture also examines the grouping itself. These letters have been doubted together because they were first read together, and that sequence deserves scrutiny. The stylistic evidence is not uniform across the three, the manuscript evidence does not distinguish them from one another, and 2 Timothy differs from the other two in genre and content to a degree that some scholars think should have produced a separate verdict long ago.

이 29분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain when and why 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy and Titus came to be treated as a single group, and name at least one scholar who argues that the grouping distorts the evidence.
  • State the five main arguments against Pauline authorship — vocabulary and style, itinerary, developed church order, the changed use of "faith," and the external and manuscript situation — and give the best counter-argument to each.
  • Describe the second-imprisonment hypothesis, say what ancient evidence is appealed to for it, and state its weakness.
  • Distinguish the positions of P. N. Harrison, Anthony Kenny, Lewis Donelson, David Meade and I. Howard Marshall on pseudonymity and its ethics.
  • Explain why a judgement about authorship does not by itself settle a judgement about canonical authority, and illustrate this with a named scholar whose two judgements differ.

As I urged you when I was going into Macedonia, stay at Ephesus that you might command certain men not to teach a different doctrine, neither to pay attention to myths and endless genealogies, which cause disputes, rather than God’s stewardship, which is in faith— — 1 Timothy 1:3-4

World English Bible

I left you in Crete for this reason, that you would set in order the things that were lacking, and appoint elders in every city, as I directed you; — Titus 1:5

WEB

Bring the cloak that I left at Troas with Carpus when you come, and the books, especially the parchments. — 2 Timothy 4:13

WEB

Hold the pattern of sound words which you have heard from me, in faith and love which is in Christ Jesus. That good thing which was committed to you, guard through the Holy Spirit who dwells in us. — 2 Timothy 1:13-14

WEB

These four passages are the debate in miniature. The first two describe journeys and arrangements that no one has succeeded in placing within the framework of Acts. The third is a detail so specific and so useless to a later writer's purposes that it is regularly cited as the single strongest argument for authenticity. The fourth uses the language of a deposit entrusted and guarded — paratheke, a legal and commercial term for goods left in someone's keeping — and that way of speaking about the message is precisely what many readers find un-Pauline.

1. Why the three are read together

The three letters were transmitted separately in the earliest lists we can reconstruct, and ancient writers cite them individually. What made them a unit was modern scholarship. Paul Anton, a Halle theologian, lectured on them together in 1726-1727 under the title that produced the English name "Pastoral Epistles," and the grouping stuck because it is convenient and because the letters do share real features: each is addressed to a named individual with delegated authority rather than to a congregation; each uses a distinctive vocabulary of "sound" or "healthy" teaching (hygiainousa didaskalia, a medical metaphor), "godliness" (eusebeia, a word for religious propriety common in Greco-Roman moral writing and rare in Paul's other letters), and "faithful sayings" introduced as fixed formulas; and each is preoccupied with who may teach and on what basis.

Friedrich Schleiermacher opened the modern critical discussion in 1807 with an open letter arguing against the authenticity of 1 Timothy specifically. Within a few decades the argument had been extended to all three, largely by scholars in the tradition of F. C. Baur, and the group verdict has been the default of critical scholarship since.

Read together or apart?

This is a point where readers will not agree — not about authorship yet, but about method. Luke Timothy Johnson argues that the group verdict is a scholarly artefact: because the letters were assessed as a bloc, features present in one were attributed to all, and 2 Timothy in particular has been convicted on evidence drawn largely from 1 Timothy. Jerome D. Quinn made a related argument from the other direction, proposing that Titus be read first and on its own terms. Against them stand the many scholars — Dibelius and Conzelmann's Hermeneia commentary is the classic statement — who hold that the shared vocabulary and shared situation are strong enough that a common origin is the simplest explanation, and that treating the letters separately multiplies hypotheses without gain. Notice that this methodological disagreement partly determines the outcome of the authorship debate, since the case is much stronger against 1 Timothy than against 2 Timothy.

2. The case against Pauline authorship

Vocabulary. P. N. Harrison's The Problem of the Pastoral Epistles (1921) remains the reference point. Harrison counted the words in the three letters that appear nowhere else in the New Testament — the usual figure is around 175 — and, more tellingly, the words in them that are absent from the ten other letters attributed to Paul but common in Christian writers of the second century. He also counted in the other direction: a long list of the small particles, conjunctions and prepositions that give Paul's argumentative Greek its characteristic movement is missing or rare here. It is the second observation that carries the weight. Unusual nouns can be explained by unusual subject matter; the absence of connective habits is harder to explain that way, because those habits belong to how a writer builds a sentence rather than to what the sentence is about.

Style. The style is different in a way that is easy to feel and hard to quantify. Paul in Romans and Galatians argues: he raises objections, answers them, doubles back, piles up subordinate clauses. The Pastorals largely instruct and list. Where Galatians reasons its way from Abraham to the law to the Spirit, 1 Timothy 3 gives a list of qualities. This is a real difference. It is also the point at which the counter-argument bites hardest, since instructions to a delegate are a different kind of writing from an argument with a congregation.

Itinerary. The letters presuppose movements that cannot be fitted into Acts. Paul left Titus on Crete to appoint elders in every city; Acts records no Cretan mission, only a stop at Fair Havens during the voyage to Rome, with Paul as a prisoner. First Timothy has Paul urging Timothy to remain at Ephesus while he himself went to Macedonia; the sequence in Acts does not match. Second Timothy has Paul leaving Trophimus sick at Miletus and a cloak at Troas, and speaks of a first defence at which no one supported him. Attempts to fit these into the Acts narrative have all required strain.

Church order. The community in view has an enrolment list for widows with a minimum age of sixty, a rule that an accusation against an requires two or three witnesses, a warning against laying hands on anyone hastily, and a settled expectation that overseers and servants are appointed to defined roles with published qualifications. Compare 1 Corinthians, where Paul addresses a congregation with prophets and teachers and tongues and no evident officers at all, and where he settles disputes by argument rather than by procedure. The distance is often described as a generation's worth of development.

"The faith" as a deposit. In Galatians and Romans, pistis most often names an act or posture: trusting, relying, being faithful. In these letters, "the faith" frequently names a content — something one can depart from, be sound in, or guard. The term paratheke in 2 Timothy 1:14, an item left in trust, makes this explicit. The message has become a thing handed over intact. That is a real shift, and it fits comfortably in the period when Christian communities were beginning to define themselves against rival teachings.

External and manuscript evidence. The papyrus codex P46, our earliest substantial collection of Paul's letters and usually dated around 200, does not contain the Pastorals. Marcion's , as reported by Tertullian, did not include them. Clear citation by name begins with Irenaeus in the late second century, though there are earlier probable allusions, in Polycarp in particular.

Is the manuscript evidence clear?

This is a point where readers will not agree about how much the manuscript situation shows. P46 is damaged: its final leaves are lost, and the argument that it never contained the Pastorals rests on calculating from the number of surviving leaves and the average amount of text per page whether there was room. Scholars have run that calculation and reached different results, partly because the scribe's writing becomes more compressed toward the end. Marcion's omission proves little, since he shortened everything that did not suit him and these letters attack exactly the kind of teaching he favoured. Against this, the defenders of authenticity have their own difficulty: the letters' external attestation is later and thinner than for the undisputed letters, and an explanation is owed.

3. The case for Pauline authorship

Genre. These are letters of instruction to a subordinate who holds delegated authority, and antiquity had such a genre. Roman governors received mandata principis, standing instructions from the emperor defining their remit; comparable letters from officials to their deputies survive. Michael Wolter argued in detail that the form of the Pastorals matches this administrative genre. If that is right, then a large part of the vocabulary difference is explained by what these letters are, not by who wrote them: administrative Greek uses administrative words. The argument does not settle the case — a later imitator could equally have chosen the genre — but it removes some of the force of the lexical argument.

Statistics and sample size. The three letters together contain roughly 3,500 words of Greek. Statisticians have repeatedly warned that samples of this size support far weaker conclusions than the literature often draws. Anthony Kenny, a philosopher trained in statistical method, examined ninety-six stylometric features across the Pauline corpus in A Stylometric Study of the New Testament (1986) and concluded that on his measures the corpus did not divide neatly into authentic and inauthentic groups; Titus, not the Timothy letters, was the most anomalous. Kenny did not claim to prove authenticity, and it would misrepresent him to say so. His claim was the more limited and more damaging one: that the stylistic evidence, properly handled, does not carry the weight placed on it. Defenders of the majority position reply that stylometry is not the only argument and that the cumulative case does not stand or fall with it — which is true, and which is also why the cumulative case must be examined pillar by pillar.

The secretary. Paul used secretaries; Tertius names himself in Romans 16:22, and Galatians 6:11 draws attention to Paul taking the pen for the closing lines. A secretary's contribution could range from taking dictation word for word to composing from instructions. C. F. D. Moule proposed that Luke wrote these letters at Paul's direction during Paul's lifetime, which would account for both the differences and the personal detail. The proposal has a real difficulty: it is unfalsifiable in the form usually given. A hypothesis that explains any degree of difference explains nothing in particular. This is the same problem the secretary hypothesis had in Chapter 2 and in the discussion of Colossians, and it should be applied with the same restraint here.

A second imprisonment. If Paul was released after the two years of house arrest with which Acts ends, travelled further, and was arrested again, the itinerary problem largely dissolves. The ancient evidence is real but thin: 1 Clement, writing from Rome late in the first century, says Paul reached "the limits of the west," which some read as Spain, the destination he named in Romans 15:24; the Muratorian Fragment refers to a departure for Spain; Eusebius reports a tradition of release and later re-arrest. Against this: Acts ends where it ends without recording a release, which is strange if the author knew of one; and the second-imprisonment hypothesis was itself partly constructed to accommodate these letters, which makes using it to defend them uncomfortably circular. The honest statement is that the tradition is early enough not to be dismissed and not independent enough to settle anything.

The personal details. This is the strongest single argument, and it is examined at length in Lecture 11-3, so it is only stated here. The request for a cloak left at Troas, the note that Erastus stayed at Corinth and Trophimus was left sick at Miletus, the instruction to come before winter — these serve no doctrinal purpose. Why would a writer inventing a Pauline letter to settle disputes about church order include them?

4. The ethics of writing in another's name

If the letters are not by Paul, what were they? Three answers are in play, and they are not compatible.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Lewis R. Donelson, in Pseudepigraphy and Ethical Argument in the Pastoral Epistles (1986), examined the ancient evidence for how pseudonymous letters were produced and received, drawing especially on the Socratic and Cynic epistles, and concluded that the practice was deceptive by design and was condemned when detected. Bart D. Ehrman has pressed this case at length in Forgery and Counterforgery (2013): ancient writers who discuss the practice call it lying, and the fabricated personal details in such letters exist precisely to secure belief. On this account, the Pastorals a pious literary convention is a modern comfort with no ancient warrant.

David G. Meade, in Pseudonymity and Canon (1986), argued differently: within Jewish tradition, writing in the name of a founding figure was an act of interpretation, a way of asserting that this is what the tradition means now — as chapters were added to Isaiah over centuries and as Daniel was set in an earlier reign. On this reading the attribution is a claim about authority and continuity rather than a claim about the hand that wrote.

I. Howard Marshall proposed a third term, "allonymity," for a work produced within a school by someone who understood himself as transmitting his teacher's mind rather than impersonating him, and who expected to be read that way. Critics reply that this is a category invented to solve a theological discomfort, and that Marshall does not show any ancient reader who understood such letters in that manner.

A student should notice that this dispute is partly about evidence — what did ancient readers actually think? — and partly about what one is prepared to accept about a canonical book. Those two are worth keeping apart even when they cannot be separated.

5. Authorship is not canonicity

The distinction is easy to state and easy to lose. Whether Paul dictated 1 Timothy is a historical question, answered by evidence of the sort surveyed above. Whether 1 Timothy is scripture is a question about the church's reception of the book, answered on different grounds by different traditions: for Catholic and Orthodox Christians principally through the church's tradition and conciliar reception, for the Reformation traditions principally through the church's recognition of a book's authority rather than its conferral of it. On none of these accounts is the historical question the deciding one. The three letters are in every Christian canon; no tradition's canon list depends on a modern stylometric result.

The clearest illustration is Raymond E. Brown, a Catholic priest and one of the most influential New Testament scholars of the twentieth century, who judged the Pastorals pseudonymous and wrote about their canonical authority without reservation. On the other side, scholars who defend Pauline authorship — Towner, Johnson, Marshall in his own way — do not argue that canonicity depends on it. Where the practical stakes really lie is elsewhere: in whether these letters are read as Paul addressing a first-generation situation or as a second generation consolidating, since that judgement colours how one reads the office lists in 11-2 and, for some readers, how normatively one takes the instruction in 1 Timothy 2.

That is what actually hangs on the debate, and it is enough. It is not the case that the canon is at risk on one side or that intellectual honesty is at risk on the other. Both of those claims have been made, and both are overstatements.

The debate, pillar by pillar Neither column is a verdict; each row is a live disagreement Against Pauline authorship The reply Vocabulary and style (Harrison 1921): unusual nouns; missing connective particles; lists rather than argument Sample of c. 3,500 words (Kenny 1986); letters to a delegate are a different genre (Wolter); secretarial freedom Itinerary fits no reconstruction of Acts: Crete, Miletus, Troas, Nicopolis Release after Acts 28 and a second arrest (1 Clement 5; Muratorian Fragment) Developed order: widows enrolled at sixty, procedure for charges against elders Overseers and servants already at Philippians 1:1; congregations aged fast "The faith" as a deposit to be guarded (paratheke), not an act of trusting Paul already transmits fixed tradition (1 Corinthians 15:3); a late-life emphasis Absent from P46; absent from Marcion; named citation begins with Irenaeus P46 is mutilated; the leaf calculation is disputed; Marcion cut what displeased him Separate question: canonical authority. All three letters are canonical in the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions alike, and scholars within each tradition are found on both sides of the historical question. Do not let one answer decide the other.

Read the diagram in rows rather than columns. Each row is a disagreement that competent scholars have not resolved, and the shape of the table is the argument of the lecture: the case against is cumulative, and every element of the cumulation has been contested by someone with the relevant expertise.

6. Further Reading

  • P. N. Harrison, The Problem of the Pastoral Epistles (Oxford, 1921). The foundation of the modern linguistic case; still worth reading directly rather than in summary.
  • Anthony Kenny, A Stylometric Study of the New Testament (Oxford, 1986). A statistician's caution about what small samples can show; his conclusion about Titus is often reported inaccurately, so read him rather than reports of him.
  • Lewis R. Donelson, Pseudepigraphy and Ethical Argument in the Pastoral Epistles (Mohr, 1986). The case that ancient pseudonymity was deceptive by design.
  • David G. Meade, Pseudonymity and Canon (Mohr, 1986). The case that attribution asserted continuity of tradition rather than identity of hand.
  • I. Howard Marshall with Philip H. Towner, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Pastoral Epistles (T&T Clark, 1999). Proposes allonymity; the introduction is the fullest survey of the debate available.
  • Luke Timothy Johnson, The First and Second Letters to Timothy (Anchor Bible, 2001). Argues both for authenticity and, separately, against the practice of judging the three letters together.
  • Bart D. Ehrman, Forgery and Counterforgery (Oxford, 2013). Presses the ethical question further than most; useful precisely because it refuses the softening vocabulary.

핵심 요약

  • P. N. Harrison's The Problem of the Pastoral Epistles (1921) found around 175 words in the three letters absent from the rest of the New Testament, but the stronger observation was the near-absence of Paul's characteristic connective particles — a feature of sentence-building harder to explain by subject matter than unusual nouns are.
  • The letters presuppose an itinerary — Titus left on Crete, Timothy at Ephesus while Paul goes to Macedonia, a cloak and books left at Troas — that does not fit anywhere in Acts; the second-imprisonment hypothesis (1 Clement's "limits of the west," the Muratorian Fragment) tries to solve this but was itself partly built to accommodate the letters.
  • Anthony Kenny's A Stylometric Study of the New Testament (1986) tested ninety-six stylometric features across the Pauline corpus and found Titus, not the Timothy letters, the most anomalous — a result that undercuts the confidence with which the group verdict is usually stated.
  • paratheke (2 Timothy 1:14), "a deposit entrusted," is a legal/commercial term for goods left in someone's keeping, and reflects a shift from Paul's usual sense of pistis as an act of trusting to "the faith" as a fixed content that can be guarded or departed from.
  • P46, the earliest substantial Pauline manuscript (c. 200), does not contain the Pastorals, and Marcion's canon omitted them too — but P46's final leaves are damaged, so whether it ever included them is a disputed calculation, and Marcion cut everything that opposed his own teaching.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: The Pastoral Epistles carry the strongest critical case against Pauline authorship of any letters in the collection — P. N. Harrison's missing connective particles, an itinerary (Crete, Ephesus, Troas) that fits nowhere in Acts, developed church offices with age minimums and witness rules, and a shift from "faith" as trust to "the faith" as a guarded deposit (paratheke, 2 Timothy 1:14). Yet Anthony Kenny's 1986 stylometric study found Titus, not the Timothy letters, the most stylistically anomalous, undermining the confidence of the group verdict, and the letters' small combined sample (about 3,500 words) may be too small for the statistics to bear the weight placed on them. Whether an unnamed later writer honored Paul (Meade's continuity-claim), practiced accepted school convention (Marshall's "allonymity"), or deceived (Donelson, Ehrman), every tradition still reads all three letters as canonical Scripture regardless — Raymond Brown judged them pseudonymous and treated them as fully authoritative all the same.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Harrison's strongest observation was not about rare nouns but about missing particles. Explain why that distinction matters, and say what evidence would be needed to answer it.
  • The secretary hypothesis can accommodate any degree of stylistic difference. Is a hypothesis with that property useless, or is it simply hard to test? What would count as evidence for or against it in a particular letter?
  • Donelson and Meade give incompatible accounts of what an ancient reader would have thought of a letter written in a dead teacher's name. What kind of evidence could decide between them, and does such evidence exist?
  • The second-imprisonment hypothesis rests partly on 1 Clement's phrase about the limits of the west. How much weight can a phrase like that carry, and what does the answer tell you about arguments from early Christian writers generally?
  • Raymond Brown held these letters to be pseudonymous and canonical. Describe, in the terms of your own tradition, how those two judgements can both be held — and where, if anywhere, you find the combination uncomfortable.
  • If Johnson is right that the group verdict was reached by treating the three letters as one, what would a properly separate assessment of 2 Timothy look like? Which arguments from the list above would still apply to it?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.