무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT603E The Letters of Paul

Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11

목차 37
BT603E The Letters of Paul
제 0 장 · Introduction: Reading Paul
  1. Introduction: Reading Paul
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Paul - Life, Sources, and the Shape of a Career
  1. Lecture 1-1: Who Paul Was — Pharisee, Roman Citizen, Apostle
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Damascus Road — Conversion, Call, or Both
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Acts Alongside the Letters
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Letters, Chronology, and the Pauline Collection
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Letter, the Secretary, and the Congregation That Heard It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Chronology: Dating the Letters and Why It Is Contested
  3. Lecture 2-3: Thirteen Letters, Seven Undisputed: How the Corpus Was Formed and Divided
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: 1 and 2 Thessalonians
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Earliest Letter: Founding a Church and Leaving It
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Dead in Christ and the Coming of the Lord
  3. Lecture 3-3: 2 Thessalonians and the Authorship Question
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Galatians
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Crisis: Circumcision, Table Fellowship, and Antioch
  2. Lecture 4-2: Justification, Faith, and the Works of the Law
  3. Lecture 4-3: Freedom, the Spirit, and the Life That Follows
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: 1 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Divided Church: Factions, Wisdom, and the Cross
  2. Lecture 5-2: Bodies, Marriage, Food, and Idols: Ethics in a Pagan City
  3. Lecture 5-3: Worship, Gifts, Love, and the Resurrection of the Body
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: 2 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 6-1: A Damaged Relationship and the Letter's Difficult Unity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ministry in Weakness: Treasure in Clay Jars
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Collection, the Rival Apostles, and Paul's Boasting
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: Romans 1 to 8
  1. Lecture 7-1: Why Romans, and to Whom: Purpose and Audience
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Human Predicament and the Righteousness of God
  3. Lecture 7-3: Baptism, the Law, the Flesh, and Life in the Spirit
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: Romans 9 to 16
  1. Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Renewed Mind: Worship, Government, and the Weak and the Strong
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Ending of Romans and the People Paul Names
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: Philippians and Philemon
  1. Lecture 9-1: Philippians: Partnership, Joy, and Imprisonment
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2
  3. Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Colossians and Ephesians
  1. Lecture 10-1: Colossians: The Supremacy of Christ and the Colossian Philosophy
  2. Lecture 10-2: Ephesians: One Body, and the Question of Its Authorship
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Household Codes and How They Have Been Used
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: The Pastoral Epistles
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It
  2. Lecture 11-2: Order, Office, and Sound Teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus
  3. Lecture 11-3: 2 Timothy: A Last Letter and Its Portrait of Paul
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: Paul's Theology and His Interpreters
  1. Lecture 12-1: Christ, Spirit, and the Shape of Pauline Theology
  2. Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since
  3. Lecture 12-3: Paul After Paul - Reception, Misuse, and Reading Him Now

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

39분

At the end of Romans 8 Paul writes one of the most confident paragraphs in his surviving letters: nothing in creation can separate those in Christ from the love of God. Chapter 9 opens with him swearing that he is not lying, and saying that he has great sorrow and unceasing pain in his heart, and that he could wish himself cut off from Christ for the sake of his own people. The two paragraphs are next to each other. Nothing has been said in between to explain the turn.

That gap is the entrance to this lecture. The confidence of chapter 8 rests on the reliability of God's promises. But the people to whom the promises were made — Paul lists them at 9:4-5, and lists them in the present tense — have, in Paul's own account, largely not accepted the Messiah he preaches. If God's word to Israel can come to nothing, then the assurance of chapter 8 is worth nothing either, because it is the same word. This is not a side issue that Paul raises because it happens to be painful to him personally. It is the point at which his whole case can fail.

The lecture argues three things. First, that chapters 9, 10 and 11 are a single sustained argument and must be read as one, because each of them, taken alone, yields conclusions that the other two block. Second, that the disagreement over election in chapter 9 is not a disagreement about whether the text says God chooses — it plainly does — but about what is being chosen for, and that the two great traditions of reading divide on that question rather than on the plain sense of any one verse. Third, that chapter 11 sets a limit which the later church repeatedly overran: it refuses to say that God has finished with Israel, and it explicitly forbids Gentile believers to boast over the branches that were broken off. The history of what was done anyway is part of the exegesis of this passage, not an appendix to it.

Terms used below are given in transliteration with a gloss where they first appear. Where the lecture states that readers disagree, it names representatives on each side and does not declare a winner.

이 39분으로 얻는 것

  • State the question Romans 9 to 11 is answering, show where it was raised earlier in the letter, and explain why chapter 8 makes it urgent rather than optional.
  • Set out the individual-predestination reading of Romans 9 and the election-to-a-role reading, name representatives of each, and identify the verses that are hardest for each.
  • Trace the argument of chapter 11 step by step — remnant, partial hardening, olive tree, "all Israel" — and explain how each step constrains the reading of chapter 9.
  • Describe the three main interpretations of "all Israel will be saved" at 11:26, and the disputed fourth, with named representatives.
  • Define supersessionism, explain what 11:28-29 says about it, and give an accurate account of why this passage was re-examined so intensively after the Second World War.

What shall we say then? Is there unrighteousness with God? May it never be! For he said to Moses, “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.” So then it is not of him who wills, nor of him who runs, but of God who has mercy. — Romans 9:14-16

World English Bible

But it is not as though the word of God has come to nothing. For they are not all Israel, that are of Israel. — Romans 9:6

WEB

But indeed, O man, who are you to reply against God? Will the thing formed ask him who formed it, “Why did you make me like this?” Or hasn’t the potter a right over the clay, from the same lump to make one part a vessel for honor, and another for dishonor? — Romans 9:20-21

WEB

I ask then, did God reject his people? May it never be! For I also am an Israelite, a descendant of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin. — Romans 11:1

WEB

But if some of the branches were broken off, and you, being a wild olive, were grafted in among them, and became partaker with them of the root and of the richness of the olive tree; don’t boast over the branches. But if you boast, it is not you who support the root, but the root supports you. — Romans 11:17-18

WEB

For I don’t desire you to be ignorant, brothers, of this mystery, so that you won’t be wise in your own conceits, that a partial hardening has happened to Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in, and so all Israel will be saved. Even as it is written, “There will come out of Zion the Deliverer, and he will turn away ungodliness from Jacob. — Romans 11:25-26

WEB

Concerning the Good News, they are enemies for your sake. But concerning the election, they are beloved for the fathers’ sake. For the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable. — Romans 11:28-29

WEB

For God has shut up all to disobedience, that he might have mercy on all. — Romans 11:32

WEB

A note on this selection. The passages from chapter 9 and the passages from chapter 11 are placed here together on purpose, and a student should feel the strain between them before reading further. Chapter 9 says that mercy does not depend on human willing or running, and compares God to a potter who may make one vessel for honour and another for dishonour. Chapter 11 says that the hardening is partial, that it lasts until a stated point, that branches broken off can be grafted back in, and that God has shut up all to disobedience in order to have mercy on all. Any account of this passage that finds one of these easy and the other embarrassing has probably not finished reading. In 11:25-26 the double space inside the verse is a break in the World English Bible's text where a scriptural quotation begins; it is reproduced here as printed.

1. Where the question came from

Romans 1:16 announces a Good News that is "for the Jew first, and also for the Greek." Romans 2 turns the accusation of chapter 1 against a Jewish interlocutor. Romans 3:1 then asks directly: "What advantage then does the Jew have?" Paul gives a compressed answer — chiefly, that they were entrusted with the oracles of God — and immediately moves on to the universal indictment of 3:9-20. He does not come back to it for six chapters.

Why the long delay?

That delay is a compositional fact worth noticing. Two explanations are current. On one, Paul postpones the question because he cannot answer it until he has established what by faith is and what it does; only then can he say what remains of Israel's advantage. On the other, favoured by readers who take the Roman congregations' internal situation as the letter's occasion, the delay is rhetorical: Paul builds a case that his Gentile readers will accept, and then springs on them the conclusion that this case does not license contempt for Jews. Both explanations are compatible with the text. Neither can be demonstrated.

What can be demonstrated is that Paul introduces chapters 9 to 11 as an answer to a specific charge, and states the charge himself at 9:6: it is not as though the word of God has come to nothing. Someone, real or constructed, has said that it has. Everything that follows in these three chapters is Paul's reply.

2. Chapter 9: the argument, step by step

Paul's reply proceeds by narrowing and then widening.

The narrowing (9:6-13). "They are not all Israel, that are of Israel." Descent from Abraham has never by itself been the criterion, and Paul proves this from Israel's own scriptures rather than from Christian premises. Abraham had Ishmael and Isaac; the promise ran through Isaac. Rebekah bore twins by one father, and before either had done anything good or bad it was said that the would serve the younger. The choosing, Paul says at 9:11, is "not of works, but of him who calls."

Two observations about this step that are easy to miss. The first is that both examples are about which line the promise runs through, not about the eternal destiny of the individuals named. Ishmael is not said to be damned; Esau is not said to be damned; Genesis and Malachi, from which the two quotations come, are speaking about peoples. The second is that this is exactly the point at which readers begin to divide, because the language Paul uses — "not of works, but of him who calls" — is the language he has been using since chapter 3 about salvation.

The hardest part (9:14-24). Paul raises the obvious objection himself: is there unrighteousness with God? He answers with Exodus 33:19, God's word to Moses about having mercy on whom he has mercy, and with the Pharaoh of Exodus 9:16, raised up for a purpose. Then comes 9:19, "Why does he still find fault? For who withstands his will?" — and Paul's answer to that question is not an argument but a rebuke and an image: who are you to reply against God, and has the potter no right over the clay?

It should be said plainly that this is not a satisfying answer to the question as asked, and that Paul does not appear to think it needs to be. The potter image is drawn from Jeremiah 18 and Isaiah 29 and 45, and in Jeremiah 18 — this is significant — the potter reshapes the vessel in response to the nation's response, which is precisely a conditional use of the image. Whether Paul intends that context to be heard is disputed.

The widening (9:24-33). The vessels of mercy are then identified: "us, whom he also called, not from the Jews only, but also from the Gentiles." Hosea is quoted to show that those who were not a people are called God's people, and Isaiah to show that a remnant will be saved. The chapter closes with the paradox that Gentiles who did not pursue righteousness attained it, while Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness, did not arrive — because they pursued it "as it were by works of the law" and stumbled over the stumbling stone.

3. The two families of reading on election

This is a point where readers will not agree. Two long traditions read Romans 9 in incompatible ways, and both have serious exegetical arguments.

of individuals to salvation and to loss. Augustine, in his later anti-Pelagian works — above all To Simplician on Various Questions (396), where he says he changed his mind on precisely this passage — read Romans 9 as teaching that God's choice of individuals precedes and does not depend on anything in them, including foreseen faith. John Calvin developed this in the Institutes (III.21-24) into a doctrine of double , in which the reprobate are passed over by the same free decision that elects the saved. The strengths of this reading are real: 9:11 excludes works before birth, 9:16 excludes willing and running, and 9:18 says that God hardens whom he desires. The reading takes those clauses at their word and does not soften them.

Election of a people to a role within a purpose. Jacobus Arminius, in his Analysis of Romans 9, argued that the passage concerns God's freedom in the manner by which he saves — by faith rather than by descent — rather than an unconditional decree about individuals. Most modern critical commentary, including that of James Dunn and N. T. Wright, reads the chapter as being about the shape of God's purpose in history and the of Israel within it, on the grounds that Ishmael, Esau and Pharaoh function in Genesis and Exodus as figures in a national story rather than as case studies in personal destiny. Eastern Orthodox commentary, following John Chrysostom's homilies on Romans and Theodoret of Cyrus, has generally read God's foreknowledge as knowledge of the response he foresees and has resisted the unconditional-decree reading; this is not a modern position taken up in reaction to Calvin but a continuous strand of Greek older than the Latin debate. The strength of this family of readings is chapter 11, which says the hardening is partial and reversible, and 11:32, which makes the shutting-up under disobedience instrumental to mercy on all.

The verses each finds hard are worth naming. The individual-predestination reading has to account for 11:23, which says the broken branches will be grafted in again if they do not continue in unbelief — a conditional clause about the very people 9:18 said were hardened — and for 11:32. The election-to-a-role reading has to account for 9:22-23, where "vessels of wrath made for destruction" and "vessels of mercy prepared beforehand for glory" are not obviously about national vocation. Neither difficulty is fatal to its tradition, and students should be able to state both without caricature. A Catholic student will recognise here the older debate between Thomist and Molinist accounts of grace and predestination — a debate the Catholic Church deliberately left open in 1607 and has never closed — and should notice that it does not map neatly onto the Protestant division just described.

4. Chapter 10: the present situation

Chapter 10 is often skipped between the two famous chapters, and skipping it distorts both. It does two things.

It states Paul's own posture: his heart's desire and prayer for Israel is that they may be saved, and he testifies that they have a zeal for God, "but not according to knowledge" (10:2). That sentence is a compliment and a criticism at once, and the compliment is not a rhetorical concession — it is why the situation grieves him.

And it insists on the availability of what he preaches. The word is near, in the mouth and in the heart; there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; whoever calls on the name of the Lord will be saved. This matters for the reading of chapter 9, because a chapter that had just excluded human willing entirely is now followed by a chapter organised around calling, believing, confessing, hearing and preaching. Any account of Romans 9 must be an account that allows Romans 10 to follow it.

One phrase requires care. At 10:4 Paul says that Christ is the telos of the law — the World English Bible renders it "fulfillment," others "end," others "goal." The Greek word can carry termination, purpose, or completion. The choice of English word here has done a great deal of theological work in the history of interpretation, and the honest statement is that the Greek does not decide it; the surrounding argument has to.

5. Chapter 11: the argument that constrains everything before it

Did God reject his people? (11:1-10). Paul's first evidence is himself: "For I also am an Israelite." Then Elijah, who thought he alone was left and was told of seven thousand reserved. So now, "there is a remnant according to the election of grace" (11:5). Note that the remnant is offered as proof that God has not rejected his people — the opposite of the use to which remnant language has sometimes been put.

Is the stumble final? (11:11-16). No: "did they stumble that they might fall? May it never be!" has brought salvation to the Gentiles, which is meant to provoke jealousy, which Paul hopes will save some. His own ministry to Gentiles is, he says at 11:13-14, partly aimed at this. If their fall enriches the world, how much more their fullness?

The olive tree (11:17-24). This is the passage that most directly addresses the Gentile readers, and its tone is a warning. They are a wild olive shoot, grafted in among natural branches, sharing the root's richness. They are not to boast; they do not support the root, the root supports them. They stand by faith and should fear rather than be conceited, for if God did not spare the natural branches he will not spare them either. And the natural branches, if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted back in — for God is able. Paul even notes, at 11:24, that the grafting of the wild olive was itself "contrary to nature," which reverses the direction of condescension his readers might have assumed.

Two things follow. Grammatically, the "you" of these verses is singular and addressed to a Gentile believer; this is not general instruction but a specific caution to a specific readership. Rhetorically, Paul has constructed the whole image so that Gentile security and Jewish rejection cannot both be made permanent — the same clause that guarantees the one dissolves the other.

"All Israel will be saved" (11:25-32). The hardening is porosis — a hardening or dulling — and it is explicitly "partial," and it lasts "until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in." Then: "and so all Israel will be saved."

This is a point where readers will not agree. There are three main interpretations of "all Israel," and a fourth that is seriously argued and seriously contested.

  1. The church — Jews and Gentiles together. Augustine and Calvin read "all Israel" as the whole people of God, the elect of both groups. N. T. Wright argues a version of this in which Israel's vocation is fulfilled in the Messiah and the renewed people that follows him. The argument for it is that Paul has already redefined Israel at 9:6, so that "Israel" in 11:26 need not mean what it meant in 11:25. The argument against is that Paul uses "Israel" ten times in these chapters and, on the most natural reading of the others, means the Jewish people; a shift of reference inside two consecutive verses is a strong claim.
  2. The Jewish people as a whole, at the end, saved through Christ. This is the majority position in modern commentary — Cranfield, Dunn, Fitzmyer, Douglas Moo, Richard Bell — and takes "all Israel" as ethnic Israel considered corporately (not necessarily every individual), brought in at the close of the present age by the Deliverer of the citation that follows. Its strength is the consistency of the word "Israel" and the temporal "until." Its difficulty is that it locates the fulfilment in a future event about which Paul says almost nothing else.
  3. The elect remnant of Israel accumulated across history. On this reading "all Israel" is the total sum of Jews who come to faith throughout the present age, and 11:26 describes a process rather than an event. Its strength is that it needs no special future act; its weakness is that it makes "so all Israel will be saved" a fairly weak conclusion to a chapter that has been building towards something like a reversal.
  4. The disputed fourth: a distinct path. Krister Stendahl, and more explicitly Franz Mussner, Lloyd Gaston and John Gager, argued that Paul does not say Israel will be saved by coming to faith in Christ; the Deliverer comes and turns ungodliness from Jacob, and God's faithfulness is the ground. This is sometimes called the two-covenant or Sonderweg reading. Its supporters point out that 11:26-27 mentions no conversion and cites covenant language; its critics — including E. P. Sanders, who cannot be accused of underrating Judaism, and Douglas Moo from a different direction — reply that 10:9-13 has just insisted there is no distinction and that "whoever calls on the name of the Lord will be saved," and that Paul's stated hope in 11:14 is to "save some of them." The debate is live, and a student should be able to state it without treating either side as motivated only by its politics.

Then 11:28-29, which holds together what most later readers separated: concerning the gospel, enemies for your sake; concerning the election, beloved for the sake of the fathers — "for the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable." The adjective is ametameletos, literally "not to be regretted," "not repented of." And 11:32: God has shut up all to disobedience in order to have mercy on all. Whether the second "all" has the same extension as the first is one of the oldest questions in the interpretation of Paul, and this lecture does not settle it.

And then Paul stops arguing (11:33-36). The depth of the riches, the unsearchable judgments, the ways past tracing out. Some readers, including Karl Barth, take this as the argument's proper conclusion — the point at which an account of God's dealing with Israel has to become praise or become false. Others read it as an honest signal that Paul has not resolved the tension and knows it. The text does not adjudicate between these.

6. Supersessionism, and why this passage was re-examined

Supersessionism is the view that the church has replaced Israel as the people of God, so that the covenants and promises listed at 9:4 have been transferred and Judaism after Christ has no continuing standing before God. It has taken several forms — the claim that Israel's role is simply finished, the claim that Judaism was a preparatory stage now surpassed, and the claim that Israel forfeited the covenant by rejection. All three were widespread in Christian teaching for many centuries, and all three have to reckon with the fact that Romans 11 says the branches were broken off but the tree is the same tree, that the root supports the grafted shoots, and that the gifts and calling are irrevocable.

It is important to be exact about what Romans 11 does and does not establish here. It does not say that Israel's unbelief is a matter of indifference; Paul's grief in 9:1-3 forbids that reading. It does not describe two parallel religions. What it does is refuse the transfer: it denies that God has rejected his people, forbids Gentile boasting in the strongest terms Paul uses anywhere about intra-church attitude, and grounds the refusal in God's character rather than in Israel's performance.

The re-examination of this passage in the second half of the twentieth century was driven by the Shoah and by the recognition — argued at length by Rosemary Radford Ruether in Faith and Fratricide (1974), and by Jules Isaac before her — that centuries of Christian teaching about Jewish rejection had prepared the ground on which modern antisemitism grew. Ruether's thesis, that anti-Judaism is the "left hand of Christology" and therefore structural rather than incidental, was and remains contested; scholars including John Gager accepted much of it, while others argued that she read the New Testament through its worst later reception. What is not contested is that the re-examination happened and that it changed official teaching. The Second Vatican Council's Nostra Aetate (1965) stated that the Jews remain most dear to God, whose gifts and call are without repentance — quoting Romans 11:28-29 — and rejected the presentation of Jews as rejected or accursed. Pope John Paul II, in Mainz in 1980, spoke of the covenant never revoked by God. The Vatican Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews published a document in 2015 whose title is simply the text of Romans 11:29. Many Protestant bodies issued comparable statements from the 1940s onward, and Orthodox churches have participated in the dialogue with their own emphases, though the process has been less centralised.

History is not exegesis

Two cautions belong here. First, this history is not a substitute for exegesis: a reading of Romans 11 is not correct because it is generous, and students should be able to say what in the text supports it. Second, the theological questions left open by these statements are genuinely open — what "never revoked" implies about mission to Jews is disputed within Catholic theology and among Protestants, and the 2015 document itself declines to resolve it. A course can report the state of the question honestly. It cannot close it.

7. What the three chapters do together

Read alone, chapter 9 yields an unconditional divine decree. Read alone, chapter 10 yields a straightforward appeal to believe and confess. Read alone, chapter 11 yields a guaranteed future for Israel. Each of these is a real reading of a real chapter, and each is contradicted by one of the others. The exegetical discipline this passage demands is to hold a reading that survives all three, and to say clearly where one's own tradition finds the strain.

Romans 9 to 11: The Argument and What Each Step Rules Out Each chapter blocks a conclusion the others would otherwise allow 9:6 — The charge: has the word of God come to nothing? Chapter 9 9:6-13 descent was never the criterion (Isaac, Jacob) 9:14-18 mercy, hardening, Pharaoh 9:19-23 the potter and the clay 9:24-33 vessels of mercy from Jews and Gentiles; the remnant; the stumbling stone Chapter 10 10:1-4 Paul's prayer; zeal not according to knowledge; Christ the telos of the law 10:5-13 the word is near; no distinction; whoever calls 10:14-21 hearing, preaching, and hands stretched out all day long Chapter 11 11:1-10 not rejected; a remnant 11:11-16 the stumble is not a fall; jealousy; how much more 11:17-24 the olive tree; do not boast; grafted back in 11:25-32 partial hardening, "all Israel," irrevocable gifts, mercy on all Alone it would allow: an unconditional decree over individuals with no remainder — but ch. 11 makes it partial. Alone it would allow: salvation as simple human decision — but ch. 9 denies it rests on willing or running. Alone it would allow: a guaranteed outcome needing no gospel — but ch. 10 sends preachers and pleads. 11:33-36 — not a conclusion but a doxology. Readers differ on whether that is the answer. "All Israel will be saved" (11:26) — four readings 1. The church, Jews and Gentiles together — Augustine, Calvin; a version in N. T. Wright. 2. The Jewish people corporately, at the end, through Christ — Cranfield, Dunn, Fitzmyer, Moo. Majority view. 3. The sum of the believing remnant across the whole present age — a process, not an event. 4. A distinct path grounded in the covenant — Stendahl, Mussner, Gaston, Gager. Contested by Sanders and Moo alike.

The lower panel of the diagram sets out the four readings of 11:26 side by side so that the disagreement can be seen as a disagreement about the reference of one word. The upper panels are arranged to make the mutual constraint visible: each chapter's shaded box names the conclusion that chapter would license if it stood alone, and the chapter that forbids it.

6. Further Reading

  • C. E. B. Cranfield, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, vol. 2 (Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1979). Verse-by-verse treatment of chapters 9 to 11 from within the Reformed tradition, and unusually firm in rejecting supersessionism.
  • James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9-16, Word Biblical Commentary 38B (Dallas: Word, 1988). The fullest treatment of these chapters in terms of the Jewish-Gentile situation of the Roman congregations.
  • E. P. Sanders, Paul, the Law, and the Jewish People (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1983). Chapter 4 discusses Romans 9 to 11 and argues against the two-covenant reading while insisting on Paul's Jewishness.
  • Krister Stendahl, Paul among Jews and Gentiles (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1976). The short book that reframed the discussion and stated the case that Romans 9 to 11 is the climax of the letter.
  • Franz Mussner, Tractate on the Jews: The Significance of Judaism for Christian Faith, trans. Leonard Swidler (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1984). A Catholic argument for the covenant's continuing validity, worked out from Romans 11.
  • John M. G. Barclay, Paul and the Gift (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2015). Distinguishes six different things "grace" can mean and applies the distinction to Romans 9 to 11 with unusual clarity.
  • Rosemary Radford Ruether, Faith and Fratricide: The Theological Roots of Anti-Semitism (New York: Seabury, 1974). The book that forced the question; read it together with a critical response.
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Letter to the Romans, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018). A careful conservative Protestant treatment that argues position 2 on 11:26 and states the alternatives fairly.
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Epistle to the Romans, in the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, series 1, vol. 11. The standard patristic Greek reading of chapter 9, and the source of much later Eastern treatment.

핵심 요약

  • Romans 9 opens right after chapter 8's confident doxology with Paul swearing he has "great sorrow and unceasing pain" for Israel (9:1-2) — a juxtaposition the lecture treats as the entrance to the whole argument, since if God's word to Israel can fail, chapter 8's assurance (built on the same word) fails too.
  • Romans 9:6-13 narrows election through Isaac rather than Ishmael and Jacob rather than Esau "before either had done anything good or bad" (9:11), while Romans 11:17-24's olive tree warns Gentile believers not to boast because "you do not support the root, but the root supports you" — the two chapters pull in opposite directions and must be read as one argument.
  • Augustine (in To Simplician, 396) and Calvin read Romans 9 as unconditional individual election to salvation or reprobation; Arminius, and most modern commentators including Dunn and Wright, read it as God's freedom in the manner of election within Israel's national story — a division the lecture states does not map onto the individual-predestination verses' hardest counter-text, 11:23's promise that broken branches "will be grafted in again" if they do not continue in unbelief.
  • Four rival readings of "all Israel will be saved" (11:26) are argued: the whole church of Jews and Gentiles (Augustine, Calvin, a Wright variant); ethnic Israel saved at the end through Christ (the majority view — Cranfield, Dunn, Fitzmyer, Moo); the cumulative elect remnant across history; and a distinct covenantal path not through explicit faith in Christ (Stendahl, Mussner, Gaston, Gager), which even E. P. Sanders rejects.
  • Romans 11:28-29's "the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable" was cited directly in the Second Vatican Council's Nostra Aetate (1965) and in a 2015 Vatican document titled with that verse's text, part of the post-Holocaust re-examination driven by Rosemary Radford Ruether's Faith and Fratricide (1974) and its argument that Christian anti-Judaism helped prepare the ground for modern antisemitism.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Romans 9 to 11 answers a crisis chapter 8's confidence creates: if God's promises to Israel (listed at 9:4-5) have failed, the assurance that nothing can separate believers from God's love rests on the same unreliable word. Chapter 9 narrows election through Isaac and Jacob "before either had done anything good or bad" and meets the objection with the image of the potter and the clay; chapter 11 answers with a partial, temporary hardening, an olive tree that forbids Gentile boasting because "the root supports you," and the declaration that "the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable" (11:28-29). Augustine and Calvin read chapter 9 as unconditional individual election; most modern commentators read it as God's freedom in electing a people to a role — and four different readings compete for what "all Israel will be saved" (11:26) even means. Paul does not resolve the tension; he ends in doxology, "the depth of the riches... of God," and the Second Vatican Council later cited this very passage to reject the idea that Christian teaching had superseded God's covenant with Israel.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Paul answers the objection at 9:19 with a rebuke and an image rather than an argument. Is that a failure of argument, a refusal of an illegitimate question, or something else? What would have to be true about the question for the answer to be adequate?
  • The potter image comes from Jeremiah 18, where the potter reworks the vessel in response to the nation's turning. Does that context belong to Paul's use of the image? Argue both sides, and say what would settle it.
  • Set out the strongest case you can for the individual-predestination reading of Romans 9, using only chapter 9. Then set out the strongest case against it, using only chapter 11. What does the exercise show about reading either chapter alone?
  • Romans 11:18 tells Gentile believers not to boast over the branches. Describe, with specific examples if you can, what boasting over the branches has looked like in Christian history — and what the verse requires instead.
  • Of the four readings of "all Israel," which do you find strongest, and which single verse gives your preferred reading the most trouble? Answer the second half honestly.
  • Paul ends in doxology rather than conclusion. Some readers treat that as the argument's proper completion. If you disagree, what would a completed argument have needed to say?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.