Lecture 4-4: Faith Questions and Hard Conversations
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Age and Care
- Lecture 1-2: Ageing Across Cultures: Retirement, Loss, Loneliness, Care
- Lecture 1-3: What a Lay Carer Does, and Does Not Do
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbour and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Preparing and Beginning the Visit
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Memory, Repetition and Silence
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer, Scripture and Worship at the Bedside
- Lecture 2-4: Dignity, Choice and the Words We Use
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Planning One Visit
- Lecture 3-1: The Home Visit and the Body's Limits
- Lecture 3-2: Care Homes and Hospitals
- Lecture 3-3: Privacy, Safety and the Signs of Abuse or Neglect
- Lecture 3-4: Money, Gifts and Keeping Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reading Signs and Knowing Whom to Tell
- Lecture 4-1: Dementia: Staying With a Person Whose Memory Changes
- Lecture 4-2: Loneliness, Loss and Feeling a Burden
- Lecture 4-3: The Family Carer
- Lecture 4-4: Faith Questions and Hard Conversations
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Word to the Family
- Lecture 5-1: Serious Illness, Hospice and Palliative Care
- Lecture 5-2: Accompanying the Dying Across the Traditions
- Lecture 5-3: The Moment of Death and the Days After
- Lecture 5-4: What to Say, What to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Words to Offer and Words to Leave
Older and housebound members have often had a long time to think about God. Some have had a long, faithful life and are at peace. Others have carried questions for years. Some are angry. Some have left the church, or never belonged to one, or follow another faith. Some are troubled by something they did long ago. Some want, very much, to be reconciled with a child or an old enemy before time runs out.
A visitor meets these people in a kitchen or a bedroom, with a cup of tea going cold. The visitor is not a priest, a pastor or a theologian. This lecture asks what a lay carer's part is, and where it stops. The answer follows the course's central claim: listen, do not solve, offer what the person asks for, and pass what is beyond you to the person's own pastor or priest.
이 26분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why a visitor listens to anger and doubt without defending God or scolding the person.
- Describe what a visitor does, and does not do, when a person speaks of an old sin, a regret or a wish for reconciliation.
- Name the matters that belong to a pastor or priest and not to a lay carer, and say how to offer to call them.
- Describe how to treat a person who has left the church or follows another faith or none, without making them a project.
- Say "I do not know" honestly, and explain why not every conversation needs to end in peace.
Oh that I knew where I might find him! That I might come even to his seat! I would set my cause in order before him, and fill my mouth with arguments. I would know the words which he would answer me, and understand what he would tell me." — Job 23:3-5
World English Bible
For my soul was grieved. I was embittered in my heart. I was so senseless and ignorant. I was a brute beast before you. Nevertheless, I am continually with you. You have held my right hand. You will guide me with your counsel, and afterward receive me to glory. Whom do I have in heaven? There is no one on earth whom I desire besides you. My flesh and my heart fails, but God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever." — Psalm 73:21-26
WEB
Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24
WEB
Job wants to find God and argue his case. The writer of Psalm 73 admits to being embittered and "senseless" and ends with a statement of trust that was not available at the start. The father in Mark's Gospel speaks belief and unbelief in the same breath. All three are in the Bible, and in each the Bible lets a troubled person speak plainly.
1. What a visitor is for in these conversations
A visitor can easily feel that a conversation about God is the real reason for coming, and that the visit has been wasted if it did not reach one. This is a mistake of two kinds. It puts a weight on the visitor that the visitor cannot carry. It also changes the person into a task. In lecture 1-4 we saw that visiting in order to produce a result is pressure on a person who may not be able to walk away.
The visitor's part is much smaller and, for that reason, much more useful. It is to be a person to whom things can be said. Many older people have not said the true thing to anyone for years. They did not want to trouble their family, or embarrass their pastor, or sound faithless. A visitor who is not afraid of the question is a rare gift. A visitor who has an answer ready is not.
2. The person who is angry at God
An older member may say, "I have prayed all my life and look at me." Or, "Where was God when my husband was ill?" Or, "I'm finished with all that."
The temptation is to defend God: "God has a plan", "It is not for us to understand", "Remember how much he has done for you." Another temptation is to scold: "You mustn't say that." Do neither. This course does not use the phrase "it is all God's will" or the suggestion that suffering shows too little faith. Neither phrase is kind, and neither is something a lay carer is in a position to claim.
The Bible gives a different pattern. In Job 23 Job wishes he knew where to find God so that he could "set my cause in order before him". He wants an argument, and he says so. Later in the same chapter he says that he goes forward and backward, left and right, and cannot find God. The Psalmist in Psalm 73 says that his soul was "grieved" and his heart "embittered", that he was "a brute beast" before God, and then, in the same breath, that he is "continually with you" and that God has held his right hand. The book of Job ends in a surprising way: God turns on the friends who have given neat answers, and says that Job has spoken rightly (Job 42:7). Scholars read the details of that verse in different ways, and we should not build a doctrine on it. But it is fair to say that the book does not present Job's complaint as the sin. It presents the friends' confident answers as the problem.
So let the anger be said. Say, "That sounds very hard" or "You have a right to be angry." You do not have to agree that God is at fault. You do not have to argue that he is not. Sit with it. Often the anger is the form that love and grief take when they cannot find a place to go.
3. The person who doubts
Doubt is different from anger. It is quieter. It sounds like, "I don't know whether any of it is true. I've been saying the words for eighty years." It may be said with shame.
Do not fix. Do not produce an argument. Do not suggest that the doubt must be sin. The father in Mark 9:24 cries out, "I believe. Help my unbelief!" and Jesus acts. That cry is in the Bible as a prayer. You may say so, gently, if the person is open to it. Then ask, "What would you like, today? A psalm read? Quiet? To talk?" Or perhaps nothing.
4. The person who speaks of an old sin, a regret, or a wrong done to them
Sometimes, late in life, a person tells a visitor something they have never told anyone: something they did, or failed to do, or something that was done to them. It may be small by the world's measure and large to them. It may be a sin in the eyes of their tradition. It may be shame about something they could not help. It may be harm they suffered long ago.
Listen. Do not look shocked, and do not show that you are judging. Thank them for telling you. You may say, "That has been heavy to carry."
Do not judge, and do not pronounce forgiveness. Traditions differ about who hears confession and who may declare forgiveness. In Catholic and Orthodox practice it is a priest. Many Protestant and Pentecostal traditions teach that every believer may speak the gospel's promise to another, and that pastors and elders have a special part. A lay visitor is not the one who decides whether a sin is forgiven, and does not stand in the place of the priest or pastor. If the person asks, "Do you think God can forgive me?", you may say what the person's own tradition says to everyone, such as reading a psalm of mercy, but you do not make a judgement about their case. Say, "I am not the right person to say that for you. Would you like me to ask your pastor or priest to come?"
Ask if they would like their own pastor or priest called, and call them. This is the main thing a lay carer does in this situation. Do it with the person's consent and do not share what they told you unless they ask you to; the pastor or priest can hear it for themselves.
Do not promise secrecy. If what the person tells you suggests that someone is in danger now, or that a child or another person is being harmed, you cannot keep it to yourself. Say so gently, and tell the responsible person (lecture 3-3). Most old sins are not like that, and most can simply be heard.
If the person was the one who was harmed, listen without questions. Do not press for details. Do not tell them to forgive. A person who has carried a harm for sixty years does not need a visitor to hurry them to a conclusion. Offer to help them find someone trained to listen, if they would like it.
5. The wish to be reconciled
Many older people want to make peace before they die: with a child who no longer speaks to them, with a sibling, with an old enemy, with a church that hurt them. This is natural, and it is not always possible.
A visitor may help in a few small ways. Listen to what the person wants to say. Ask, "What would you like to happen?" and also, "What would you be willing to do if the other person said no?" Offer to help them write a letter or make a call, if they ask. Pass on a message only if the person has asked you to and has told you exactly what to say. Do not broker a meeting. That belongs to the family, or to a pastor or priest or a trained mediator, and it carries risks for both sides. Do not pressure either side. Do not say to a child, "He is dying, you must forgive him", or to a person, "You have to forgive her before you go." Forgiveness cannot be ordered, and pressure of that kind often produces a show of peace without the thing itself.
Lecture 5-2 returns to reconciliation at the end of life.
6. The regret
"I should have been a better mother." "If I had gone sooner." "I never said sorry." Regret differs from guilt: it may not be about a sin at all, but a path not taken. The temptation is to console too soon: "You did your best", "At least you had good years". A person who has just said something true about their life can feel that the reply is a way of closing the subject.
Say, "That is heavy." Ask, "What do you wish had been different?" and wait. Do not argue that the regret is wrong. It may be right. Do not say what would have happened, because nobody can know it. If the person wants to hear that they did their best, they will ask.
7. The person who has left the church, or follows another faith, or none
You may visit a person who was once in your congregation and left, perhaps hurt, perhaps tired, perhaps disagreed. You may visit a neighbour who is of another faith or none. In both cases the course is clear:
- The visit does not depend on belief. The person is not a project.
- You do not turn the conversation toward conversion. (Lecture 1-4: visiting in order to produce a decision at the end of a life is pressure on a person who cannot walk away.)
- You respect their practices and words. A person of another faith may want their own prayers, their own holy days, their own visitors, and you do not interfere.
- You are not required to defend your church if they criticise it, and you are not required to agree. You may say, "I'm sorry that happened", if you are sorry. Listen.
- If they ask about your faith, answer simply and honestly, and do not argue.
- If they would like a visit from someone of their own tradition, help to find one.
A person who is of the same church is also not a duty. They are a neighbour.
8. The courage to say "I do not know"
Older people ask hard questions, and some of them have no answer. "Why did this happen to me?" "Will I see my husband again?" "Is it too late for me?" "What is going to happen when I die?"
Traditions answer some of these with confidence and differ among themselves. Others no tradition answers fully. A lay visitor who has a tidy answer to every one is not wise but anxious. A visitor who can say, "I do not know, and I would like to know", has said something more honest and, often, more comforting. You may say what you hope. You may say what your church teaches, if you are asked, and say that other Christians see it differently. You may say, "That is a question for your pastor or priest, and I will ask them to come." What you may not do is invent certainty, or tell a person what will happen to them after death. That is not your place, and readers of different traditions will not agree about it (see lecture 5-2).
9. Not every conversation ends in peace
You may have a conversation with an older person where nothing is resolved. They stay angry. They say, "I don't think it was worth it." They do not want a prayer. They turn their face to the wall. You may leave feeling that you failed.
You have not necessarily failed. You were there, and you did not leave. A person can come to peace over years, or never in your sight; it is not yours to decide. What a lay carer can do is see that the door stays open. Come again, as you said you would.
10. What belongs to the pastor or priest
There are things which a lay carer should not attempt, however kindly. They include hearing confession and giving absolution, administering a (Communion, Anointing of the Sick, Holy Unction, baptism), pronouncing on a person's spiritual condition, and making a pastoral decision such as whether a person may receive Communion, or how to proceed with a funeral. Traditions differ about who does these things and how. In some traditions it is always an ordained priest. In others, a pastor or , or a layperson appointed by the community, and in some, a group of believers. What is common to all is that the visitor asks the person what they want, and, with the person's consent, calls the person's own pastor or priest. Do it early, not at the last minute. If your community has no resident pastor or priest, ask your leader who is available.
If the person has no pastor or priest, or does not want one, that is their choice. You can still stay.
(an invented example) Kwabena is eighty-five and was a lay reader at his assembly for forty years. Since his hip failed three years ago he has not been out. When Ruth, a younger member of his small congregation, visits him, he has been quiet for weeks. Today he says, "I'm done with God. Forty years I read his word and now I lie here." Ruth does not say, "God has not left you." She says, "That sounds very hard, Kwabena." He is silent, and then says that he has been angry since the day he fell. Ruth says, "Would you like to say more, or would you like me to just sit?" He says more. After a while he says that he has not been able to pray. "Would you like me to read a psalm that says what you've said?" she asks. He says no. She sits with him for twenty minutes. Before she leaves, she says, "I will come next Thursday. Shall I ask Pastor Samuel to visit as well, or would you rather I did not?" Kwabena says, "Ask him." Ruth tells the leader that afternoon that Kwabena has asked for a visit from the pastor, and nothing else.
11. In a parish and in a house church
In a parish, the priest or a may already have a rhythm of visits to the housebound, and a lay visitor can help to arrange them; the sacraments of Reconciliation and Anointing of the Sick belong to the priest, and a lay visitor who knows the parish can help the person ask. In an Orthodox community, the priest comes with Holy Unction or the prayers the person needs. In a free church or house church, it may be an elder or the leader of the group. The pattern is the same: ask, call, stay.
Diagram 1. Hard conversations
Diagram 2. Instead of ... try ...
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| "God has a plan." | "That sounds very hard. You have a right to be angry." |
| "You mustn't say that." | "Tell me more about it." |
| "God has forgiven you." (as a pronouncement about their case) | "I'm not the right person to say that for you. Would you like me to ask your pastor or priest to come?" |
| "You did your best." (too soon) | "That is heavy. What do you wish had been different?" |
| "You have to forgive her before you go." | "What would you like to happen? What would you be willing to do?" |
| An answer to every question | "I do not know. I would like to know too." |
핵심 요약
- A visitor's part is to be a person to whom things can be said: listen, do not solve, offer what is asked for, and pass the rest on.
- Anger and doubt are heard without defending God or scolding; Job, Psalm 73 and Mark 9:24 show that the Bible holds them.
- A lay carer hears an old sin or regret without judging or pronouncing forgiveness, and asks the person whether they would like their own pastor or priest called.
- Reconciliation is helped by listening, not brokered or pressured; carry a message only when asked and told exactly what to say.
- A person who has left the church or follows another faith or none is not a project, and the visit does not depend on belief.
- Confession, absolution, sacraments and pastoral decisions belong to the person's own pastor or priest; "I do not know" is an honest answer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A visitor's part | Listen, do not solve, offer what is asked for, and pass what is beyond you to the person's own pastor or priest. |
| Anger at God | Let it be said. Do not defend God and do not scold. Job, Psalm 73 and Mark 9:24 show the Bible allows it. |
| An old sin or regret | Listen without judging. Do not pronounce forgiveness. Offer to call the person's own pastor or priest, with consent. |
| A wish to reconcile | Ask what the person wants. Do not broker alone or pressure anyone. Carry a message only if asked. |
One sentence to remember You do not have to answer the hard question; you have to stay, listen, and call the right person.
This week's action Write down the name and number of the pastor, priest or elder you would call on behalf of a housebound member, and check that you know how to reach them.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why might a visitor feel that a conversation about God is "the real reason" for coming? What does that feeling do to the visit?
- The Bible holds Job's complaint, the Psalmist's bitterness and the cry "Help my unbelief". What does that tell you about what may be said in prayer?
- What is the difference between listening to a person's old sin and pronouncing on it? Why does your tradition place that difference where it does?
- When has someone said "I do not know" to you in a way that helped? What made it honest rather than evasive?
- Who is the pastor or priest you would call, in your community, on behalf of a housebound member? Do you know their name and how to reach them?