Lecture 6-4: Honest Review Without Counting People
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Age and Care
- Lecture 1-2: Ageing Across Cultures: Retirement, Loss, Loneliness, Care
- Lecture 1-3: What a Lay Carer Does, and Does Not Do
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbour and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Preparing and Beginning the Visit
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Memory, Repetition and Silence
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer, Scripture and Worship at the Bedside
- Lecture 2-4: Dignity, Choice and the Words We Use
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Planning One Visit
- Lecture 3-1: The Home Visit and the Body's Limits
- Lecture 3-2: Care Homes and Hospitals
- Lecture 3-3: Privacy, Safety and the Signs of Abuse or Neglect
- Lecture 3-4: Money, Gifts and Keeping Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reading Signs and Knowing Whom to Tell
- Lecture 4-1: Dementia: Staying With a Person Whose Memory Changes
- Lecture 4-2: Loneliness, Loss and Feeling a Burden
- Lecture 4-3: The Family Carer
- Lecture 4-4: Faith Questions and Hard Conversations
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Word to the Family
- Lecture 5-1: Serious Illness, Hospice and Palliative Care
- Lecture 5-2: Accompanying the Dying Across the Traditions
- Lecture 5-3: The Moment of Death and the Days After
- Lecture 5-4: What to Say, What to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Words to Offer and Words to Leave
At the end of a year, someone will want to know how the visiting team has done. The easiest answer is a number: so many visits, so many people, so many hours. A number is short, it fits on a page, and a leader can say it aloud at a meeting. It is also nearly useless for what matters in this course.
What matters is whether the people visited felt met. That cannot be counted. A man who is 88 may feel more met by one ten-minute call that finished when he was tired than by ten longer visits that left him exhausted and polite. A woman who has asked a team never to visit again may be telling it the truth that most helps it.
This lecture is about how a team can look honestly at its work without turning people into units. It asks a small group of simple questions, asks them of the right people, listens to the answers, chooses a couple of changes, and does not use the result as a score. The course gives no statistics, and this lecture does not teach the team to make its own.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why a visiting team should review its work at least once a year, and why counting visits misleads.
- List the questions an honest review asks.
- Describe ways of asking older members themselves, with their consent and without pressure.
- Explain why a person who declines visits is not a failure, and why visiting less may be right.
- Describe what a team does with what it hears.
But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly." — Matthew 6:3-4
World English Bible
I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase. So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:6-7
WEB
Which of you men, if you had one hundred sheep, and lost one of them, wouldn’t leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness, and go after the one that was lost, until he found it? When he has found it, he carries it on his shoulders, rejoicing." — Luke 15:4-5
WEB
Each passage can be misused in a discussion of review. Jesus warns against doing good to be seen, but he does not forbid a team to ask whether its work is good. Paul says growth is God's, but he does not excuse bad planting. The shepherd in Luke does count, but he counts in order to find the one who is missing. Read slowly and keep all three in view.
1. Why look at all
A team that never looks at its work drifts. The same people are visited because they are easy to visit. The same hours are used because they suit the visitors. A rhythm that was right three years ago goes on after the person it was made for has changed. Nobody is careless. Nobody asked.
A review is the way a team keeps its attention on the person and off itself. It is not an examination of the visitors, and it is not a performance for the congregation. It is a group of people asking, with their older members, "Is this still right?"
2. Why not count
Counts are tempting for good reasons. They are easy to keep, they seem fair, and a leader who has to explain the team's work to a committee has something to say. But they carry four problems.
They measure what is easy. A visit can be counted. Whether the person felt known cannot. What can be counted begins to steer what is done.
They reward more. If the number of visits is the sign of success, a team will visit more often, for shorter times, and perhaps people who would rather be left alone. Visits become something to tick.
They turn people into units. An older member becomes "one of forty". This course began by saying that a person is a member of the body before being a recipient of help. A tally forgets it.
They hide the one who is missing. A rising total can sit beside a quiet failure to visit the person who is hardest to reach.
Some counting is practical and harmless. The private list in lecture 6-1 notes when a person was last seen, so that no one is forgotten for months. That is counting to notice who is missing. The shepherd in Luke 15 does that. It is the opposite of counting to show success. The first is for the person; the second is for the team. A fair test is: who is the number for?
A caution here. The shepherd's story is not a method for review. It is about the joy of finding the lost, and we use only the small point that care knows who is absent.
3. Not a trumpet
Jesus tells his hearers not to "sound a trumpet" when they do merciful deeds (Matthew 6:2) and to do them "in secret" (6:3-4). A team's annual review, if it became a presentation for the congregation, with figures and happy stories, would be the trumpet. Stories about named people would break the privacy the team promised. Even without names, a story can identify someone in a small congregation.
The passage does not mean a team cannot look at its own work. Jesus is speaking about a person who gives in order to be seen. A team that asks, among itself and with the people it visits, whether its care is good is doing something quite different. What the team reports outward can be modest and plain: that the work goes on, what the whole congregation can do, and what has changed.
4. Planting and watering
Paul says to the Corinthians, "I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase" (1 Corinthians 3:6). The context is a quarrel: some say "I follow Paul" and others "I follow Apollos," and he tells them that both are servants and the growth is God's. Applied here, the point is that a team is not responsible for the harvest. It cannot make a person feel at peace, or well, or glad of its visits. What it can do is plant and water as well as it can, and ask whether it is doing so.
This is not an excuse. Faithful watering means asking whether the water reaches the plant. Comparing one team with another, or this year with last year, is the very quarrel that Paul rebukes. Ask about the work itself.
5. The questions
A small, honest review can be done in an evening. The questions below are an example, and a team should change them to suit its own life.
| About the people visited | About the team |
|---|---|
| Did the people we visited feel met, and how do we know? | Did we keep the safety rules and the written promise of confidence? |
| What did they say they wanted? What did they say they did not? | Did we pass things on well (lecture 6-3), or did we try to carry them? |
| Which times, doors and words worked? Which did not? | Are our carers well? Has anyone asked for a pause? (lecture 6-2) |
| Who did we not reach, and why? | Did the whole congregation stay in the work, or did we become its excuse? (lecture 6-1) |
| Who has asked us to stop, and what did they tell us? | Did we say thank you, and to whom? |
| What do older members on the team notice that the rest of us miss? | What is the one thing we would change? |
Notice what is not on the list: "How many visits did we make?" A team may keep that number for its own use, but it does not appear in the review.
6. Asking the older members themselves
The best source for answers is the people visited. Asking them well is a skill in its own right.
- Ask with permission, and let them say no. "We are thinking about how we might do this better. May I ask you three questions? You can say no."
- Ask someone other than the usual visitor. People are slow to criticise the person who comes to their door. An older member on the team, or a team member the person knows less well, can ask more freely.
- Ask about particulars. "Fine" and "lovely" are the usual polite answers. "What do you like best about the visits? Is there a time of day that is better? Is there anything you would change?" will go further than "Are you happy with the visits?"
- Offer more than one way. Some people prefer a conversation, some a short telephone call, some a written note, some to speak to a person they trust.
- Make room for silence. If the person says nothing, that is an answer too.
- Do not ask while the usual visitor is in the room.
- Write down only what they allow. Keep the notes without names, and keep them to the point.
- For those who cannot easily answer, such as a person with dementia or one who is very unwell, ask the family if the person wishes it, and watch for how the person seems to be at ease. Do not claim to know what they would say.
A team member who is 80 and asks a neighbour over tea will often learn more than a printed form can. Take care not to turn it into an interview: the question is a conversation, and the answer can be a shrug.
7. The person who declines
Some people say no to visits. Some say it plainly and some by being out when the visitor arrives. A team can feel hurt or worried. Neither is the right response.
A person may decline for many reasons: they have friends and family enough, they are private, they are busy, they dislike visitors, they have been hurt by a church, they follow another faith or none, they are tired, they would prefer a call, or they simply do not wish to be someone's project. Their reason is theirs. It is not necessarily a verdict on the visitor.
So the team does three things. It thanks the person, leaves the door open, and offers to ask again, once, after some time or when something changes. It does not argue and it does not count the refusal as a defeat. And it asks itself, quietly, whether anything in the way it asked could have been better.
8. A team that visits less
A team that visits less, and visits better, may be doing exactly right. Perhaps two people no longer want weekly visits and prefer a monthly one. Perhaps a call replaces a drive. Perhaps the team has found that visiting four people well is better than visiting twelve badly.
Check one thing before celebrating. Are we visiting less because the people asked, or because we are tired? Lecture 6-2 gave the signs of weariness. The review is the place to ask honestly which it is. It is not shameful if the answer is "tired". It is the reason for a pause, a new volunteer or a smaller list that is named openly.
9. What the team does with what it hears
A review that changes nothing makes people stop answering. After the evening:
- Choose two changes at most. More than two will not be done.
- Say who will do each one and by when. A change with no name has no one.
- Tell the people who answered, if they agreed. "You told us the afternoons were better. We have changed the day." That is the strongest encouragement to speak next year.
- Tell the congregation in general terms. The work goes on, here is what ordinary members can do, here is what is changing.
- Do not blame a visitor. A pattern is a pattern of the team, and the coordinator carries it.
- Thank. Name something specific and good that was heard.
Shape the evening itself plainly: ninety minutes at most, a prayer or a moment of quiet according to the community's custom, the questions, two choices, and thanks. A shorter check every three months, ten minutes at a regular meeting, keeps the habit alive.
(an invented example) A parish team of fourteen has always recorded the number of visits and given it to the parish council each January. This year the coordinator, Tomasz, says: "I would like us to ask a different question." Halina, a member of the team who is 81, agrees to ask six of the people they visit, over tea, three things: what they like, what they would change, and whether the day suits them. She comes back with a page of notes without names. Four people said the Tuesday afternoon visit clashed with a favourite radio programme. One said she liked the visitor but not the way the visitor always asked about her sister. One had never said she was afraid of the dog the visitor sometimes brought. Another had been waiting two months for a call back about a lift. The team changes the day, stops asking after the sister unless she mentions her, leaves the dog at home and rings about the lift that week. They also learn that one man, Mr. D., said he would prefer not to be visited. They thank him, tell him the door is open and leave him alone. In January the coordinator tells the council: "We changed the day, the habits and the list, and the people we visit have told us what they want." The council asks for a number. He says that the team has not made one and offers instead to tell the council what changed.
10. A caution about what you learn
None of this is simple. A person's honest answer may still be partial. Politeness, fear of losing the service and a wish to please can colour what is said. A team that has asked in good faith has not thereby learned the whole truth. It has learned a little more than it knew, and that is what an honest review is for.
Diagram 1. An honest review in six moves
Diagram 2. Questions for the evening
| Ask | Do not ask |
|---|---|
| "What do you like about the visits? What would you change?" | "Are you satisfied with the visits?" |
| "Does the day and time suit you?" | "How many visits have you had this year?" |
| "Is there something you wish we had asked?" | "Who is your best visitor?" |
| "What would you keep if we changed everything else?" | "Would you recommend us to a friend?" |
핵심 요약
- A team that never looks at its work drifts, so it reviews at least once a year with its older members.
- Counting visits misleads: it measures what is easy, rewards more, turns people into units and hides who is missing.
- The test for any count is who it is for; a list kept to notice who is missing differs from a total kept to show success.
- Ask older members with consent, by someone other than their usual visitor, about particulars, and write down only what they allow.
- A person who declines visits is not a failure; the team thanks them, leaves the door open and does not argue.
- Choose two changes, name who does them, tell those who answered, and ask again; a team that visits less and better may be doing right.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The main review question | Did the people we visited feel met? Which doors, words and times worked? |
| Why not count visits | It measures what is easy, rewards more, turns people into units and can hide the person who is missing. |
| Asking older members | With consent, by someone other than the usual visitor, about particulars, with room to say no or stay silent. |
| A person who declines | Not a failure; thank them, leave the door open, ask again once, do not argue. |
One sentence to remember The measure of a visiting team is whether the people it visits felt met, and the only way to learn that is to ask them, gently and without a count.
This week's action Choose one older person you know well, ask them, with their permission, what they would keep and what they would change about the way they are visited or kept company, and write down nothing but what they allow.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does your community count now, and who is the number for?
- Think of a time you answered "fine" when the true answer was longer. What would have made it easier to say more?
- Who in your community could ask older members the three questions without making them feel inspected?
- In the invented example, one man asked not to be visited. What did the team do right? What would you have found hard?
- If a team visits less this year than last, how would you tell whether that is good news or tiredness?