FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

Review by summary

All 31 lectures of FS102E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.

Try to recall each summary from the title before revealing it. It stays with you far longer than re-reading does.

Chapter 0 Introduction: Power Given to Build Up

Show summary
  • Ministry ethics is the limiting of your own power for the sake of those who trusted you, and standing inside structures that can hold you to account.
  • Spiritual authority is power given to build people up, and the more power a person holds, the more it needs limits and checks.
  • The course treats the minister's own conduct, gives no legal advice, and names where other courses take up the overlapping subjects.
  • Traditions are described with their strengths and risks and are not ranked; the harmed person comes first in every case of abuse.
  • Labs look at structures, never ask for confession, and keep four promises of privacy.
  • If a lab brings a real harm to light, stop, speak with a trusted person, and call your local emergency number if there is danger now.
Front Back
The central claim Ministry ethics is the limiting of your own power for the people who trusted you, and standing inside structures that can hold you to account; it is not guarding your reputation.
What the course does not do It gives no legal advice, ranks no tradition, and judges no named person or group.
Three ways into a lab In your own place; as an observer with an invented case; with a partner.
If a lab shows a real harm Stop; speak with a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional; call your local emergency number if there is danger now.

One sentence to remember Authority is given for building up, so the more of it you hold, the more you need limits and people who can check you.

This week's action Write down, in one sentence, who in your community could question you about how you use your authority, without fear of what follows.

Chapter 1 Week 1: Power and Spiritual Authority

Show summary
  • Power is the ability to affect others; authority is power a community has recognised; a minister usually holds both, and influence besides.
  • A minister's power comes from role, knowledge, spiritual standing, access, resources and others' dependence. Each can serve or press down.
  • Jesus changes the shape of authority from lordship to service, yet keeps the titles: "for so I am." Peter says the flock is entrusted, not owned.
  • Every tradition places the check somewhere: a bishop, a council, the members, voluntary advisers, a superior. A minister should know where.
  • The minimum for every minister: authority is given to build up those entrusted to it.
Front Back
Authority Power that a community has recognised and given to a person for a place from which to speak and act.
The shape of authority (Mark 10) Not lording it over others; greatness measured in service, as the Son of Man came to serve.
1 Peter 5:3 Elders are not to lord it over those "entrusted" to them; the flock is given into their keeping.
The minimum this course asks Authority is given to build up those entrusted to it, and is held so that it can be questioned.

One sentence to remember Authority is lent to a minister by other people, so that those people may be built up.

This week's action Write down, in one line each, where your own authority comes from and who in your community or beyond it could question you.

Show summary
  • Misuse is usually a drift from good motives, so "Does this person mean well?" is not the test. Ask what the authority is doing to the people under it.
  • Five patterns: control, treating doubt as disobedience, loyalty tests, secrecy that protects the leader, and orders about private life.
  • Eli's household shows a leader who spoke but did not restrain. Nathan shows someone outside the line of authority, and a king who could hear.
  • Psalm 105:15 protects a small, vulnerable people; David in 1 Samuel 24 refuses violence yet speaks plainly. Neither silences a person who has been harmed.
  • The list of signs is for asking questions, not for judging a person. Where harm, abuse or a minor is involved, the harmed person comes first.
Front Back
Five patterns of misuse Control; doubt treated as disobedience; loyalty tests; secrecy that protects the leader; orders about private life.
Eli's household A role used for appetite; the senior priest spoke but "didn't restrain" his sons.
Nathan and David An outsider confronts a king through a story; the king says "I have sinned"; God's own word calls David "anointed" in the rebuke.
Psalm 105:15 in context A word of protection for a few, wandering, vulnerable people, not a shield for leaders against questions.

One sentence to remember Authority drifts from its purpose by small steps, so a minister needs someone placed to notice.

This week's action Choose one of the five patterns and write down one way you could fall into it without knowing, and one person who could tell you.

Show summary
  • Four imbalances separate a minister from a person in care: trust, knowledge, spiritual standing and dependence. None is a fault in the other person.
  • Some people are more exposed: those in crisis or isolated, children, newcomers, migrants, people facing a language barrier, those who depend on the minister.
  • Where a minister holds power over the other person, "she wanted it" or "he agreed" is not a defence: agreement across a slope is not free in the same way.
  • The greater the power, the greater the responsibility for limits, and it cannot be handed to the other person.
  • Instead of leaning on consent: notice the slope, make refusal cheap, bring it into the open, hand over, step back.
Front Back
Four imbalances Trust, knowledge, spiritual standing, dependence.
Why consent is not a defence Agreement across unequal power is not free in the same way, and the minister is the one who sees the slope and holds the role.
Luke 12:48 To whom much is given, much will be required.
What to do instead Notice the slope, make refusal cheap, bring the matter into the open, hand over or step back.

One sentence to remember When a minister holds the power, the limit is the minister's to keep, whatever the other person says.

This week's action Write down two people who depend on you in some way, and one thing you will do this week to make it easy for each of them to say no.

Show summary
  • Every setting places the check somewhere: a bishop, elders and councils, the members, a circle or board, a superior. Each has real strengths and real risks. None is ranked.
  • Five questions test any structure: who hears, who can act, who sees, who is free to say the unwelcome, and what happens to the one who speaks.
  • A body chosen by the minister, meeting rarely and unable to act, is accountability in name only.
  • A minister with no overseer can build one: an outside adviser, a small trusted body, a written promise and a known way to complain.
  • Acts 15 and Exodus 18 show authority that is shared, heard in the open and checked from outside, and each tradition reads them in its own way.
Front Back
Five questions for a structure Who hears a concern; who can act; who sees money, time and closeness; who is free to say the unwelcome; what happens to a person who speaks.
A structure on paper A body that exists in form but is chosen by the minister, rarely meets, or cannot act.
Exodus 18 An outsider tells Moses that carrying everything alone is not good; sharing the load makes him safer and the people better served.
No overseer: what to build An outside adviser, a small trusted body, a written promise, and a known way to complain.

One sentence to remember What matters is not the label on a structure but whether it can hear, see, act and speak without fear.

This week's action Answer the five questions about the structure you are under, or build, in one line each, and mark the weakest answer.

Show summary
  • The lab asks for a map of five kinds of power (information, favour, access, money, time) and, beside each, who could check it.
  • "No one" is the most useful answer on the sheet. It shows where one added step would make the biggest difference.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with an invented parish case, and the partner's way with an invented role.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too. The form asks for no real names.
  • If a lab brings a real harm to light, stop, speak with a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or professional, and use your local emergency number if there is danger now.
Front Back
What the lab practises Mapping five kinds of power and who could check each.
The five rows Information, favour, access, money, time.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
A row marked "no one" Not a mark against you; the place where one small added step helps most.

One sentence to remember A minister who has written down what is held, and who could check it, can see where to add a check.

This week's action Fill in the map on a real sheet of paper, choose one row with no check, and tell one trusted person the step you will take.

Chapter 2 Week 2: Money and Gifts

Show summary
  • Scripture has two voices on a minister's money: the worker may be supported, and nobody may make the work a means of gain.
  • Paul argued strongly for a right to support in 1 Corinthians 9, and in some places chose not to use it. That is a judgement, not a rule for all.
  • John the Baptist told those with power over money to take no more than was fair and to be content with a wage (Luke 3:13-14).
  • Ministers are supported in many ways, and each has strengths and risks; this course ranks none of them.
  • Three questions apply to any money that comes to a minister: who decides, is it open, does it change anything?
Front Back
The two voices The worker may be supported; the work must never become a means of gain.
1 Corinthians 9:12 Paul had the right to support and chose in that place not to use it, so as not to hinder the Good News.
Luke 3:13-14 To those with power over money: take no more than is appointed; be content with the wage.
Three questions Who decides? Is it open? Does it change anything?

One sentence to remember A minister may be supported, but may never use the work as a way to get rich, and the surest check is that someone else knows.

This week's action Write down in plain words how you, or a minister you could one day be, would be supported, and who knows it.

Show summary
  • A conflict of interest is a situation where your own advantage could pull on a decision made for others. Having one is not wrong; hiding it, or deciding alone, is.
  • A bribe blinds without the person knowing, so the safest remedy is another person's eyes beside your own.
  • A gift that is large, private, repeated, timed or tied should not be received in private.
  • Gifts and bequests from the old, ill or dying need special care: do not suggest them, do not draw up the paper, tell the council, urge independent advice.
  • Loans, guarantees and sales to members make debts and pressure. Where dealing is unavoidable, notice, disclose, consult and limit.
  • Law on gifts, wills, fees and tax differs by country; follow local law and your community's rules.
Front Back
Conflict of interest Your own advantage, or that of family or friends, could pull on a decision you make for others.
Deuteronomy 16:19 A bribe blinds the eyes of the wise; the person does not see what they would have seen.
Five marks of a gift Large, private, repeated, timed, tied.
The self-test Would I be ready to say this openly? Who decides?

One sentence to remember You do not have to be rid of every conflict of interest; you have to make sure you are not alone with it.

This week's action Write down any gift, loan or arrangement you or a minister you know could face this year, and name the person who would be told.

Show summary
  • Paul, whose honesty was not in doubt, arranged for an appointed companion so that no one could blame him (2 Corinthians 8:18-21).
  • Shared control means money does not depend on one person being good. It protects givers, community, work and minister.
  • A second person for money should be independent of the minister; a spouse or child is seldom the right choice.
  • A minister should not set his or her own pay alone. Wider bodies, councils or outside advisers can share the decision.
  • Traditions differ on how much is made public; the course requires that someone independent knows and can check.
  • Giving records are never used to favour, press or tell; money given for a purpose is used for it, or the givers are asked.
Front Back
2 Corinthians 8:20-21 Paul arranged an appointed companion so no one could blame him, honourable before God and before people.
A good second person Independent of the minister, trusted by the community, able to say no.
Pay Never set by the minister alone; a body, council or outside group shares the decision.
The minimum on openness Someone independent knows and can check; the community knows the system.

One sentence to remember Money is safest in a community where it does not depend on any one person, including the minister, being good all the time.

This week's action Write down who counts, records and checks the money in the community you know best, and whether any of them is independent of the minister.

Show summary
  • Paul sets sincerity against "peddling the word"; the fault is shaping words by the aim of getting.
  • Acts 5:1-4 is about a pretence of giving, not an amount; Peter says the land and its price were the couple's own. It is never a threat to use on those who give little.
  • Reports bend by rounding up, counting generously, choosing the best week, leaving out losses and changing the count; count the same way and report what failed.
  • A person's suffering belongs to that person; use it only with free agreement, and often leave it out.
  • An honest appeal states purpose and amount, shows who checks, leaves giving free and promises no return.
  • Traditions teach giving differently; whichever is held, promise no result, never read trouble as too little giving, and say where you stand.
Front Back
2 Corinthians 2:17 Not peddling the word: speak with sincerity, as in the sight of God.
Acts 5:1-4 The wrong was a false show of giving, not keeping part; the gift was free.
A story of someone's suffering It belongs to that person; use only with free agreement, or leave it out.
What every minister must do about giving Promise no return, never blame the poor's trouble on their giving, say where you stand.

One sentence to remember Money travels on words, so the minister's first duty in asking is that the words are true and the person is free.

This week's action Take one report, appeal or story you have heard or could give, and check it against the lists: is it true, is it fair to the person, is the giver free?

Show summary
  • The lab practises one skill: for each money matter, ask who decides, who knows and who could check.
  • The passage is Luke 12:15-21; the rich man plans and stores alone, and asks nobody.
  • A gap is a place where one person decides or nobody checks. It is not an accusation, and does not show that anyone has done wrong.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with an invented church, and the partner's way.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too. Use roles, never names.
  • If real harm or missing money comes to light, stop and speak to a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional; for danger now, call the local emergency number.
Front Back
What the lab practises For five money matters: who decides, who knows, who could check.
What a gap is A line where one person decides or nobody independent checks; not an accusation.
The three ways In your own place; the observer's way with an invented church; the partner's way.
If a real harm surfaces Stop; do not investigate alone; speak to a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional.

One sentence to remember A structure that depends on everyone being trustworthy forever is the one most worth looking at.

This week's action Fill in the checklist on a real piece of paper for one place, and choose one small step that adds another person's eyes.

Chapter 3 Week 3: Relationships and Sexual Boundaries

Show summary
  • A dual relationship is two roles held with the same person. The duties of one can pull against the duties of the other.
  • Because the minister holds more power, a second role makes the other person's dependence greater, not smaller.
  • In small and migrant communities many dual roles cannot be avoided. Four steps help: notice, disclose, consult, limit.
  • Favouritism is a quiet dual role. Scripture asks for no partiality in how a minister acts as a minister.
  • Friends in the congregation are not forbidden; they receive no more of the church's attention or favour than any other member.
Front Back
Dual relationship Two or more roles held with the same person, where what is owed in one may pull against the other.
The four steps Notice, disclose, consult, limit.
Why a second role adds risk The other person depends on the minister more, and has less freedom to say no or to complain.
A test for favouritism Could I explain in front of everyone why this person received this role or help?

One sentence to remember A second role does not remove the minister's duty; it makes the other person less free, so the care must increase.

This week's action List the dual roles you hold, using roles and not names, and tell one trusted person about the one that worries you most.

Show summary
  • Agreement does not make a romantic or sexual relationship acceptable between a minister and a person in the minister's care: the power is unequal, and the greater responsibility is the minister's.
  • The boundary covers anyone in your care or under your authority. With a child or young person it is never a question of consent; it is abuse.
  • Vows and marriage add promises; they do not create or remove the unequal power, which is the centre of the harm.
  • Drift begins with small steps: special attention, extra reasons to meet, privacy, sharing your own troubles.
  • A feeling is not an act. When one appears, tell someone outside the situation, add distance and change duties.
Front Back
Why consent is not a defence The minister holds more power, so a "yes" may not be free, and the greater responsibility rests with the minister.
Never a question of consent A romantic or sexual relationship between an adult minister and a child or young person: it is abuse.
Three early signs Special attention; extra reasons to meet; privacy or secrecy.
When a feeling appears Name it early, tell someone outside the situation, add distance, change duties, and do not wait.

One sentence to remember A feeling is not an act, but what you do with it, and what you hide, is yours to answer for.

This week's action Decide, before you need to, whom you would tell if you noticed a growing attachment, and write down their role (not their name).

Show summary
  • Four principles hold for any meeting or message: open, purposeful, limited, free to refuse.
  • Meet where someone could walk in. Home visits stay, with someone told, and a second person where the situation calls for it.
  • Prefer groups and shared channels to private ones. Late, long, personal messages are a common place where drift begins.
  • With children and young people: parents know, two adults or open view, open channels, no secrets. Local law and PT717E give the details.
  • A minister cares how things look so that people can go on trusting, not to guard an image.
Front Back
The four principles Open, purposeful, limited, free to refuse.
A good rule for where to meet Where someone could walk in.
Contact with children and young people Parents know; two adults or open view; channels parents can see; no secrets; local law and written rules apply.
Why appearance matters So that people who trusted the minister can go on trusting, not to protect the minister's image.

One sentence to remember A boundary is not a wall against people; it is a way of keeping the door open for them safely.

This week's action Look at your last ten messages to people you care for. Mark any that were private, personal and late, and decide what you would change.

Show summary
  • A minister's household is part of the minister's service; it is not equipment for the work.
  • A spouse is not an unpaid assistant: roles are asked for, agreed freely and written down; the spouse may say no.
  • Children are not part of the ministry: no use as sermon illustrations without consent, no extra standard, an ordinary childhood.
  • A relative in a church role is a conflict of interest: disclose it, someone else decides, write the terms, review them.
  • Ministry may not take what belongs to the people at home; protect rest, a meal, and the household's voice.
Front Back
1 Timothy 3:4-5 read fairly The household is a place where character shows; it does not mean a minister's family must be perfect.
A spouse in the work Asked, agreed freely, written down; the spouse may say no and may step back.
Employing a relative Disclose it; someone free to say no decides; write the terms; review it; correct as with anyone.
What a minister may not do Take from the household what belongs to it, and call the cost a sacrifice that only others pay.

One sentence to remember A sacrifice chosen by one person and paid by another is not yet a sacrifice; it is a cost passed on.

This week's action Ask one member of your household, in your own words, whether the balance between ministry and home is right, and listen without defending.

Show summary
  • The lab practises one skill: writing a one-page boundary statement for meetings, messages, gifts, dual roles and checks, and testing it by the four principles.
  • Decide the limits first, in a calm hour, and show them to someone. Job speaks of a covenant made before temptation.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with an invented youth-leader case, and the partner's way.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • The most useful finding is often "no one could check mine": it shows a structure to build, and week 5 shows how.
Front Back
What the lab practises Writing a one-page boundary statement and testing it by the four principles: open, purposeful, limited, free to refuse.
The three ways In your own place; the observer's way with an invented youth-leader case; the partner's way.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
If a real harm comes to light Stop; speak with a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional; if there is danger now, call your local emergency number.

One sentence to remember A limit written in a calm hour and shown to another person is much harder to bend in a hard one.

This week's action Finish your boundary statement on a real sheet, and show it, or one line of it, to someone who could check it.

Chapter 4 Week 4: Confidence, Information and Honesty

Show summary
  • People tell a minister private things because of the role; the speaker cannot check what is done with the words, so the minister must be trustworthy and be checked by others.
  • Confidences most often leak through sermon illustrations, prayer chains, staff talk, the household and forwarded messages, not through intent.
  • Do not promise absolute secrecy before you have heard. Offer privacy, name the one exception, and let the person decide how much to say.
  • Silence ends when someone is in danger, a child or a person who cannot protect themselves is at risk, harm is continuing, or a rule or law requires reporting.
  • Traditions differ on the limits of confession. This course requires that no closed room be used to protect a person who is harming another.
Front Back
Discretion Holding a person's private words for the person, so that they are not harmed.
Concealment Holding silence so that a wrong may go on; it serves the wrongdoer or the institution.
What may a minister honestly promise first? To listen and keep it private, except where someone is in serious danger, and to say so before the person speaks.
Where silence ends Danger now, a child or vulnerable person at risk, harm that continues, or a duty set by law or rules.

One sentence to remember What you were told belongs to the person who told you, and a wrong never does.

This week's action Write, in your own words and for your own place, the short sentence you will say before someone begins to tell you something private, and find out where your community's written rules and local law speak on reporting.

Show summary
  • Information a minister holds was given or learned for a purpose, and it is held for the benefit of the person it concerns. A different use needs that person's agreement.
  • A prayer request has a person's permission and asks the listener to pray. Gossip under a religious name has neither, and adds details and guesses.
  • A messaging group cannot take a message back. Do not use it for a person's private matter, and ask before posting names or photos.
  • Keep as few records as the purpose needs, keep facts rather than judgements, keep them where only the right people can reach them, and find out what local law and your community's rules say.
  • Speak of another minister with the aim of repair, in the proper place, saying what you saw, and speak well of colleagues where it is true.
Front Back
Why a minister holds a member's information It came for a purpose and is held for the person's benefit; a different use needs their agreement.
Prayer request or gossip? Did the person ask me to share it, with whom, and would they be glad to hear it said?
A messaging group Cannot take a message back. Keep private matters out; ask before names or photos.
Speaking of another minister Aim at putting things right, speak in the proper place, say what you saw, and speak well where it is true.

One sentence to remember Information is lent to you for a purpose, so use it only for that purpose and for the person it concerns.

This week's action Look at one list, file or group you manage, and ask the six questions about it; change one thing so that fewer people can see more than they need.

Show summary
  • People must rely on a minister's word about the minister, and cannot check it. The more they must rely on it, the more it must be true.
  • Do not let anyone believe about you or your work what you know is not so, even when each word you said was technically accurate.
  • Report figures with what was counted and how, keep different things apart, and include what did not go well.
  • Tell stories that happened or say they are invented; do not tell another's story as yours, or one that has grown with the telling.
  • Decline in the same plain words every time instead of saying "no" to protect a secret. And say "I do not know" when it is true.
Front Back
Why honesty about oneself is a question of power Hearers cannot check a minister's claims and rely on them in weighty matters; a false claim abuses that reliance.
Reporting a figure Say what was counted and how, keep decisions, baptisms and members apart, and report what did not go well.
Declining versus lying Decline in the same words every time. Never say "no" when the answer is "yes".
"I do not know" Part of honesty. Say it, say what you will do, and leave decisions in other fields to those who hold them.

One sentence to remember A minister is believed because of the role, so every claim about oneself must be one a person who knew the facts would call fair.

This week's action Read your own title, biography or résumé, and the last figure you reported, as a stranger would; correct anything that would give a stranger a false picture.

Show summary
  • Concealment in a team is rarely planned. It is a series of kind choices, each of which makes the next easier.
  • The reasons for silence each hold some truth, but none permits covering a wrong; the harmed person's safety comes before any institution's name.
  • Fair confidentiality in a process has a named person, a time, a record, a hearing for the accused, and tells those who must know.
  • Where a concern may involve a crime or harm to a child or vulnerable person, it must not stay only inside the community's own bodies.
  • To raise a concern: write it down, check yourself, go to someone who can act, say it as a concern, ask what and when, and go higher if nothing happens.
Front Back
How concealment grows Through a series of kind choices: kept close, a quiet word, those who spoke told to hush, the person moved on, the record shrunk.
Test of discretion or concealment Who is served by the silence? The person who spoke, or a fair process, is discretion. The wrongdoer or the institution is concealment.
Signs of a cover-up Someone who must know is kept out, people at risk, the witnesses silenced, no end or record, or a need to say what is not so.
Raising a concern Write it down, check yourself, find who can act, say it as a concern, ask what and when, go higher if nothing happens.

One sentence to remember Keeping it in the family is loyalty only when no one in or near the family is left at risk.

This week's action Find out, or write down, whom you would go to in your own community with a concern about a colleague, and whom you would go to if that person were the problem.

Show summary
  • The lab practises one habit: ask what a stranger would believe from a statement, compare it with what is so, and name the gap.
  • A true sentence can leave a false picture. The gap check looks at the picture, not only at the words.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with an invented annual report, and the partner's way.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too. The form asks for no real name.
  • Restate a line so that it is true and still fair to the work, and name a structure, such as a second reader, that could check it.
Front Back
What the lab practises Asking what a stranger would believe from a statement, comparing it with what is so, and naming the gap.
The three ways In your own place; the observer's way with an invented annual report; the partner's way.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.
A structure that checks a report A second reader, a kept record, or a written way of counting, so that one person's pressure does not decide the picture.

One sentence to remember Honesty is judged by the picture a hearer ends up with, so check the gap between what you say and what they believe.

This week's action Fill in the honesty sheet for one real line you give often, and ask one trusted person to read it back and tell you what they believe from it.

Chapter 5 Week 5: Structures of Accountability

Show summary
  • A person's judgement about himself or herself is not a reliable instrument, and the more power one holds, the more it needs an outside check.
  • Jethro's counsel to Moses came from outside the structure and cured overload and sole control by sharing the load, and the power, with others.
  • A companion helps only if free to speak plainly: not under your authority, not dependent on you, knowing your work, willing to say hard things.
  • Three failures: the companion who always agrees, the pact of silence about everything, and the companion used as a shield.
  • Agree in advance what cannot be kept: harm to a person, risk to a child or vulnerable adult, taking money or property.
  • Asking for help is part of caring for the people who depend on you.
Front Back
What Jethro saw (Exodus 18) Not a scandal but sole control and overload; the cure was sharing the load and the power with capable others.
What a companion needs to be able to help Freedom from your authority and favour, knowledge of your work, willingness to say hard things, regular meeting.
Three ways a companion fails Always agrees; a pact of silence about everything; made into a shield for a decision.
What a partnership must say in advance What cannot be kept: harm to a person, a child or vulnerable adult at risk, money or property taken.

One sentence to remember A clear conscience is good to have, but it is not a check; a check is another person who is free to speak.

This week's action Name one person who could meet the conditions of a companion for you, and ask for a first meeting with the six questions from this lecture.

Show summary
  • Support can ask and advise; oversight can act. Oversight appoints, supervises, receives concerns, and corrects or removes.
  • Hebrews 13:17 says leaders "will give account"; used to demand obedience alone, it is quoted against its own second half.
  • Six tests of real oversight: independence, information, access, willingness to act, written terms, protection for the one who raises a concern.
  • Plural leadership gives more eyes and shared load, but it can spread duty thin, shield friends, and become a body guarding its own name.
  • A minister must not decide his or her own pay or discipline; a concern about harm to a person is never treated as a matter of public image.
  • Where no body stands above, a minister can place authority in the hands of outsiders, in writing, known and used.
Front Back
Four functions of oversight Appointing, supervising ordinary work, receiving concerns, correcting and if needed removing.
Six tests of real oversight Independence, information, access, willingness to act, written terms, protection for the one who raises a concern.
What this course requires of any arrangement Some person or body other than the minister, with independence, real information, ways to be reached, and the capacity to act.
Where there is no body above Outside advisers, a written covenant, members told how to reach them, real things to see, a yearly review.

One sentence to remember Oversight is real when someone other than the minister can see the facts, be reached, and act on them.

This week's action Write down who oversees your work or the work you know best, and score it against the six tests with a yes, a no or "not sure" for each.

Show summary
  • A code gives a shared language, a standard set before trouble, protection for the faithful, a route for concerns, and a basis for training.
  • Read any code with eight questions, including what it says it protects, where concerns go, what it says of the person harmed, and what it leaves open.
  • A code binds only those inside the body, does not stand above local law, and is not a substitute for character or judgement.
  • "I broke no rule" does not answer whether someone was harmed; ask what the rule was trying to protect.
  • A personal covenant is short, checkable, first person, shown to someone who can ask, reviewed yearly, and says what the minister will do if it is broken.
  • Where readers differ about written codes, this course requires some promise, in words, made to people who can ask.
Front Back
Three things a code is not Character, a substitute for judgement, a shield against the question of harm.
Two silences to look for in a code Any of: online messages, gifts and loans, ministers' conduct outside work, what happens when a minister leaves the body.
What a good covenant is Short, checkable, first person, shown to someone who can ask, reviewed yearly, with a line for what I do if I break it.
What the course requires where readers differ about codes Some promise, in words, made to people who can ask about it.

One sentence to remember A promise protects people only when it is specific enough to be checked and shown to someone who can ask.

This week's action Write a covenant of six to nine lines, including the last line about what you will do if you break it, and give a copy to one person who can ask.

Show summary
  • Fatigue, loneliness, hurt and success weaken judgement; they explain how people go wrong and never excuse it.
  • Elijah, worn out and afraid, left his servant behind and went alone; the angel sent food and rest first, twice.
  • Early signs prove nothing alone, but together and lasting they say: ask someone; thoughts of self-harm or deep hopelessness call for a qualified person today.
  • Write a plan in a good hour: three signs, two people, what not to decide when tired, what to stop, real rest, when to tell the overseer.
  • If I have done wrong while low, I tell my overseer within a week and put the person affected first.
  • A heavy load is partly the community's affair; those who oversee a minister should ask about it.
Front Back
Four conditions that weaken judgement Fatigue, loneliness, hurt (resentment) and success.
What the angel did first for Elijah Sent food and rest, twice, before any conversation about his calling.
Two things the plan fixes in advance Any of: two people to tell; what not to decide when tired; what to stop and who covers it; real rest; when to tell the overseer.
Why conditions are not excuses The person harmed is no less harmed; knowing the conditions lets a minister build protection beforehand.

One sentence to remember A plan made in a good hour stands between a bad hour and the people who trust you.

This week's action Write the seven lines of your low-time plan, and read it aloud to one person who will be one of your two.

Show summary
  • The lab asks, for six areas, who could see what you do, how often, and whether they could act; it uses roles and no names.
  • A feeling of being accountable is not the same as the fact; the web shows where structure is thick and thin.
  • The task is to find the thinnest place and choose one small step that can be done within a month.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with an invented lone-planter case, and the partner's way.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • If the lab brings a real harm to light, stop, speak to a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional, and call the local emergency number if there is danger now.
Front Back
What the lab asks for each area Who can see it (a role), how often, and whether they could advise, ask for change or stop.
What the lab aims at The thinnest place, and one small step within a month.
The three ways In your own place; the observer's way with an invented case; the partner's way.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too.

One sentence to remember Feeling accountable is not the same as having someone who can see and act.

This week's action Fill in the web on a real sheet of paper, choose one small step, write the role of the person you will ask and the date, and do it.

Chapter 6 Week 6: When Wrong Comes to Light

Show summary
  • A mistake is an error in good faith; a violation breaks a duty the minister knew; abuse uses power over another person to harm that person. The responses differ.
  • The one who did the wrong should not alone decide which kind it was. When unsure, treat it as the more serious kind until outsiders have looked.
  • In abuse, the harmed person's safety and voice come first, and the minister does not run, shape or judge the process.
  • Excuses take shapes: shrinking, blaming, calling it spiritual attack, the staged apology, and hurrying to pardon.
  • David was forgiven, and the harm still followed. Forgiveness from God does not settle the account with the people hurt.
Front Back
Mistake An error made in good faith, with no known duty broken and no use of power over someone; it is admitted quickly and put right.
Violation The breaking of a promise, rule or duty the minister knew about; it is reported to the body that holds the minister to account.
Abuse The use of power, trust or office to harm another person; the harmed person comes first and others lead the process.
Staged apology A statement built to protect the speaker: it says "if", names the discovery and not the deed, and asks everyone to move on.

One sentence to remember When wrong comes to light, first ask what kind of wrong it is and who was hurt, never how bad it looks for us.

This week's action Write down, in one line each, an example of a mistake, a violation and abuse from your own tradition's setting, and who would decide which kind a real case was.

Show summary
  • Taking responsibility has five parts: own it, put those affected first, repair as far as possible, change, and accept oversight. They come in that order.
  • After abuse, the harmed person and that person's supporters decide whether there is contact, and how. The minister does not choose the time or place.
  • Repair costs the person who caused the loss. Where it cannot be made, say so plainly and offer no smaller substitute.
  • A good apology names the deed, says it was wrong, asks what it did, has no "but", and asks for nothing.
  • The first act of responsibility is to tell the body that holds you to account.
Front Back
Five parts of responsibility Own it; put those affected first; repair as far as possible; change; accept oversight.
Zacchaeus (Luke 19:8) Repentance shown in acts that can be checked: half his goods to the poor, and four times back to those he wronged.
What a good apology lacks Explanations that move blame, "if" and "any", the speaker's suffering, spiritual language that closes the matter, and any request for forgiveness.
Matthew 5:23-24 Worship does not replace repair; but where a minister has harmed someone with less power, others make the first contact.

One sentence to remember A person takes responsibility by acts that other people can check, in an order that puts the harmed person and not the self first.

This week's action Name the one person or body that you would tell first if you found you had done wrong, and write down how you would reach that person.

Show summary
  • When harm is disclosed, listen, believe enough to act, think about safety, and do not investigate or mediate alone. Make no promise of secrecy; say whom you must tell.
  • Bring in the people whose work this is: those who protect in your community, overseers, the authorities your local law names, qualified helpers and the person's own supporters.
  • The aim is never to protect the institution, and the harmed person is never pressed to forgive, to stay quiet or to carry the community's peace.
  • Matthew 18:15-17 fits faults between peers. Where a person may have been harmed through power, the first step is to the protectors, not a private word with the one named.
  • Those who report are protected by a written route that bypasses the accused. Punishing the reporter teaches silence.
Front Back
Believe enough to act Take the account seriously and pass it to those whose work it is; it is not a verdict on who is guilty.
Honest promise "I cannot promise to tell no one. I will tell only those who need to know, and I will tell you who and why."
Not alone Do not investigate, question witnesses, confront the person named, or bring the two sides together.
Matthew 18:15-17 A route for a fault between peers; not a procedure for abuse, where the harmed person is not sent back to the one who harmed them.

One sentence to remember When someone tells you of harm, make the person safe, pass it to those whose work it is, and never make the good name of the church the aim.

This week's action Find out whether your community has a written route for reporting a wrong by a minister, and who is named in it. If it has none, write down who an ordinary member could go to.

Show summary
  • Forgiveness belongs to the harmed person, trust to those asked to give it, and office to the body that holds it. One does not settle the others.
  • Cheap forgiveness closes a matter with a kind word; it hurts the harmed person twice and does not help the minister to change.
  • Traditions differ on discipline and return, and each has a strength and a risk. The question for all: who decides, and who speaks for the harmed?
  • No minister has a claim to return. A decision on return is made by a body outside the minister's circle, in writing, after the harmed have been heard.
  • The harmed person is never pressed to forgive or to meet the minister; the person who did wrong is still cared for.
Front Back
Forgiveness The harmed person's letting go of revenge; theirs to give, in their own time; never owed, and not a reason to trust or return.
Restored trust Confidence placed again by those who are asked to give it, built by conduct that others can see over time.
Return to office A decision of the body that holds the office, outside the friendship, resting on safety, checked change and the harmed person's voice.
Cheap forgiveness Forgiveness spoken to end a matter; it silences the harmed person and leaves the minister unchanged.

One sentence to remember Forgiving, trusting and returning are three separate things, with three separate owners, and no one can be made to do any of them on someone else's behalf.

This week's action Find out, for your own community, who decides whether a minister may return to office, and write one question you would want that body to ask first about the harmed person.

Show summary
  • A plan made on a calm day lets you do the right first act on a hard one: tell the right person, protect the harmed, and avoid the usual mistakes.
  • The plan is about roles and structures, never names or confessions. Nobody reads the sheet, it is not marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
  • It covers four days: I find I did wrong; someone tells me of harm; I see a colleague's wrong; the wrong is at the top.
  • A plan that rests on one person, or on a close friend, or on no one outside your circle has a gap. Finding the gap is the point.
  • If the lab brings a real harm to light, stop, speak with a trusted pastor, priest, safeguarding person or qualified professional, and call your emergency number if there is danger now.
Front Back
Why plan in advance In the hour wrong comes to light, fear and loyalty push toward protecting the wrong people; a plan made on a calm day does not.
The honest sentence "I cannot promise to tell no one. I will tell only those who need to know, and I will tell you who and why."
The gap test Is there a person outside my circle I would tell, and who could receive a report about me or the person at the top?
Four promises of the lab Nobody reads what you write; nothing is marked; you may pass on any part; the leader fills in a sheet too.

One sentence to remember Decide on a calm day whom you will tell and what you will not do, because in the hard hour the first thing you do is usually the last thing that helps.

This week's action Choose one outside person you could ask to be the one you would tell, and arrange to talk with that person this month.