FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

A faithful member of the prayer team says quietly after a meeting: "I do not know what is wrong with me. I open my mouth to pray and there is nothing there. I think God has left." A young father tells his small-group leader that he cannot stop feeling guilty. He has confessed again and again, and still the weight does not lift. An older woman who has sung in the choir for decades says, with some shame, that she is not sure any more whether she believes. In each case the person is not asking for a lecture about prayer. They are telling a trusted person something that they have told no one else.

This lecture is about what leaders may do when prayer will not come, when guilt will not lift, when doubt rises, and when the spiritual life seems dark. It is the last lecture of this chapter's teaching and it draws on everything before it. The main claim is a simple one: these are old and honest experiences in the life of faith; they are not by themselves a sign of failure, of sin, or of illness; and sometimes they belong together with a struggle of mind or mood that deserves care. A leader does not decide which. A leader stays beside and, where it seems right, connects.

This course is not medical or psychological advice. It does not diagnose and does not tell any person that their spiritual struggle is "really" a medical condition, or "really" nothing but a spiritual one. It gives no medicine names or treatment and does not replace professional care. A leader never tells anyone to stop or change what a doctor has prescribed.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Explain, from Scripture, that silence in prayer, guilt, doubt and darkness are part of the life of faith and are not in themselves a lack of faith.
  • Say what a leader does when a person cannot pray: listens, offers borrowed words, and does not push.
  • Explain how a leader hears guilt without dismissing it and without adding to it.
  • Explain how a leader hears doubt without defending or arguing.
  • Describe, at a general level, when spiritual struggle and a struggle of mind or mood may be going together, and how to suggest a doctor without implying that faith is the problem.

Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God! For I shall still praise him for the saving help of his presence." — Psalm 42:5

World English Bible

If I say, “Surely the darkness will overwhelm me; the light around me will be night”;" — Psalm 139:11

WEB

even the darkness doesn’t hide from you, but the night shines as the day. The darkness is like light to you." — Psalm 139:12

WEB

In the same way, the Spirit also helps our weaknesses, for we don’t know how to pray as we ought. But the Spirit himself makes intercession for us with groanings which can’t be uttered." — Romans 8:26

WEB

Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24

WEB

because if our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart, and knows all things." — 1 John 3:20

WEB

How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 13:1

WEB

The Psalms ask their own soul why it is in despair, and they ask God how long he will hide his face. They also say that the darkness is not dark to God. Paul says that when we do not know how to pray, the Spirit himself helps us with groanings that cannot be put into words. A father in the Gospels says to Jesus, "I believe. Help my unbelief!" And John says that if our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart. Scripture does not treat dryness, guilt or doubt as proof that faith is gone. It treats them as places where God is still addressed, and still near. What it never does is give a leader permission to hurry a person out of them.

1. When prayer will not come

Prayer can go silent. It may be after a loss, after a shock, in a time of exhaustion, in a time of low mood, in a long season of work and worry, or for no reason that the person can name. The person opens their mouth and there is nothing there. The Bible readings feel empty. The songs cannot be sung. The person looks at others who seem to pray easily and wonders what is wrong with them.

In a church, this silence is often hidden, because it is shameful to say. A leader who says to the congregation that every faithful person prays daily and joyfully, without meaning to, makes the silence worse. People who cannot pray then conclude that they are the exception and keep quiet.

The Bible tells a different story. In the Psalms the speaker is sometimes unable to speak, and the psalms themselves give words. In Romans, Paul says that the Spirit helps our weakness, because we do not know how to pray as we should, and intercedes with groanings that cannot be uttered (Romans 8:26). Wordless prayer is prayer. The person who sits in silence, wanting to pray, is already praying more than they know.

What does a leader do?

  • Listen first, and say little. "Thank you for telling me. I do not think that this means that God has gone."
  • Offer borrowed words. Many people find that when their own words fail, the words of the Psalms or the church's ancient prayers can be held, like a rope. "Would you like me to read one with you? You do not have to say anything."
  • Offer to pray for them, if they wish, and ask before doing so. "Would it help if I prayed for you now, while you just sit?"
  • Do not push. "Try harder" and "pray more" do not help someone who cannot. Do not prescribe a rule or a plan, such as a set number of minutes, a list of readings or a fast.
  • Do not add a verdict. "Perhaps there is sin in your life" is a charge that no leader should make on the evidence of a dry season.
  • Remember the body. Tiredness, poor sleep and low mood all make prayer harder. A leader who gently asks, "How have you been sleeping? How have you been in yourself?" may find that there is more going on than prayer.

2. Guilt: heard, not dismissed and not added to

Guilt is a heavy word. Sometimes a person has done something wrong, knows it, and needs to say so. Confession, forgiveness and putting things right are among the oldest gifts of the church, and different traditions have different ways of offering them. A leader does not tell a person that they have nothing to feel guilty about when they have. Nor does the leader hurry to say, "You are forgiven, so stop feeling bad," as though the weight were a mere habit.

There is another kind of guilt, and the two can look the same from outside. This is a guilt that stays heavy even after the person has confessed, has made things right where they could, and has been assured of forgiveness. It does not match what the person actually did. They feel guilty for events they did not cause, for feelings they cannot help, for things that happened to them, and for the very fact of feeling bad. They may confess the same thing again and again and feel no lighter. They may feel that they are beyond forgiveness.

A leader cannot tell from outside which kind it is, and should not try to decide. The leader's tasks are:

  • Listen to what the person says is wrong, without comment, as long as they need.
  • Do not argue them out of it or into it. "It was not your fault" may be true and may be heard as a dismissal. "Have you asked God to forgive you?" may be heard as an accusation. A gentler sentence is: "That sounds very heavy. I am glad you told me."
  • Offer the church's own ways of hearing confession and giving assurance, if the person wishes and if the leader's tradition provides them. Where the leader is not the right person to hear a confession in their tradition, they say so, and help the person to the right one. Confession is a spiritual act. It is not a form of counselling, and it is not treatment.
  • Hold John's sentence in mind: our heart may condemn us, and God is greater than our heart (1 John 3:20). A heart can be very sure of its own verdict and still be wrong, and the God who is greater than the heart can be trusted.
  • Notice, gently, if guilt does not lift, is out of proportion, or is joined with other signs such as poor sleep, loss of interest, or hopelessness. That is a reason to ask kindly and think about connecting, not a reason to say, "You are depressed."

3. Doubt: heard, not defended

Doubt is not unbelief. Many of the greatest believers have doubted. In Mark 9:24 a father says, in one breath, "I believe" and "help my unbelief", and Jesus does not turn him away. John the Baptist sent from prison to ask whether Jesus was the one, and Jesus answered him with kindness. Thomas wanted to see before he would believe, and Jesus came to him.

A leader who hears a person say, "I am not sure I believe," should not rush to answer. Often the person is not asking for an argument. They are saying that they are afraid they have lost something precious. The first response is: "Thank you for telling me. That must be hard to carry." If the person wants to talk about questions, the leader can listen to them, can say that others have asked the same, and can help find a teacher or a book from their own tradition. A leader does not need to defend God. A leader needs to stay.

It may also help to ask when the doubt started. Sometimes doubt comes after a loss, a betrayal or a shock, and then it is not an argument but a wound. Sometimes it comes with tiredness or a heavy season. Sometimes it follows an experience in a church that left the person hurt or ashamed. A leader who asks, "When did this begin?" with real interest may learn a great deal, and the person may find that they are heard as a person and not as a case to be corrected.

4. Darkness

Some people speak of darkness: a time when God seems far or absent, when everything seems flat, and when the whole spiritual life feels grey. The psalmist speaks of this: "How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever?" (Psalm 13:1) and of a soul that is in despair (Psalm 42:5). And yet the psalmist also says that even the darkness is not dark to God (Psalm 139:11-12).

Some traditions have long had words for seasons when God seems absent, and teach that such seasons can belong to the life of faith and may even deepen it. A leader from such a tradition has something valuable to give. But a leader should be careful. A person in a dark season may not be helped by being told that it is a spiritual gift. It may be that the person is in the grip of something that deserves care.

That is the hard part. From outside, spiritual darkness and a struggle of mood can look very alike. A person who says "God has left me" and is also sleeping badly, has lost interest in things they loved, feels heavy and hopeless, and cannot function as before, may be in a spiritual season, or a season of low mood, or both. The leader does not know. The leader's honest position is: I cannot tell, and I do not need to. What I can do is stay with the person, take both the spiritual and the medical seriously, and make sure they are seen by someone who is trained to understand.

5. When the spiritual and the medical go together

The signs below, when seen together, are reasons for the leader to think about connecting with a doctor or another professional. They are not a diagnosis and not a list to be used for a checklist. They are things that may be seen:

  • The darkness has gone on for a long time and does not seem to lift, or it seems heavier.
  • The person is sleeping or eating very differently from usual.
  • They have lost interest in things that used to matter to them, including things unrelated to faith.
  • They seem to be struggling to manage ordinary tasks.
  • They speak of hopelessness, or of being a burden, or of there being no way out.
  • The guilt or doubt is large and constant, and does not seem to match what the person has done.

A leader who notices some of these can say something like:

"I do not think this is a failure of your faith. I think you are carrying a great deal, and you may need more help than I can give. I would like you to speak to a doctor about how you have been sleeping and how heavy everything feels. I will keep praying for you and I will keep coming. Would you let me help you find someone?"

This sentence does three things. It protects the person's faith from blame. It names the reason (sleeping, heaviness) in the person's own terms. And it promises continued presence: the doctor is an addition and not a replacement for the church.

A leader never tells a person that seeing a doctor shows a lack of faith, and never says that medicine or prayer should be dropped. If the person is already receiving care, the leader encourages them to tell their doctor about the spiritual side too, and does not suggest changing anything. Changes belong to the prescriber or treating professional.

If a person speaks of hopelessness in a way that suggests they may harm themselves or want to die, the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response applies, and urgent danger means emergency services.

6. What hurts, and what helps

What hurts:

  • "Pray more" and "read more", as a cure.
  • "Perhaps there is sin in your life", as a verdict.
  • "You are forgiven, so stop feeling bad", said too soon.
  • Quoting verses at the person, especially verses about joy.
  • Telling the person it is "only" a spiritual season, or "only" their nerves.
  • Sharing what was said with others, as a prayer request, without permission.

What helps:

  • Listening, and saying that being unable to pray is a human thing and a biblical thing.
  • Borrowed words: a psalm, a short ancient prayer.
  • Sitting in silence together, and offering to pray for the person.
  • Asking about sleep, energy and daily life, with real care.
  • Offering the church's own ways of confession and assurance, if wanted.
  • Offering to help find a doctor, and promising to keep coming.

7. Two communities, one task

(an invented example) Wayfarers' Chapel is a house church with about ten members. Dorian, the oldest, says that for some weeks he has not been able to pray and that he is ashamed. The leader, Imani, does not say anything clever. She reads Psalm 42 with him slowly and asks whether he would like her to come on Thursday evenings and read it again. After a few weeks she asks, gently, how he is sleeping and whether he has been to see his doctor lately. He says that he has not been. She offers to come with him. She does not mention it to the group. In a house church this small, the discipline is to keep Dorian's silence private and not keep him alone.

(an invented example) Sacred Heart Cathedral Parish is a large parish with confession available on set days. Marguerite says to a lay volunteer that she has confessed the same thing over and over and cannot believe that she is forgiven. The volunteer, Tomas, does not argue and does not reassure. He says that he is glad she told him, offers to walk with her to see the priest, and asks whether she has been sleeping and eating. She says that she has not. He tells her that he would like her to see a doctor as well as the priest, and the parish care coordinator helps her to find one. In a large parish, the discipline is to see that the spiritual and the medical both happen, and that neither waits for the other.

8. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. Silence in prayer, guilt, doubt and darkness are part of the life of faith. They are not, by themselves, a lack of faith.
  2. Wordless prayer is prayer. Offer borrowed words and company, and do not push.
  3. Guilt is heard, not dismissed and not added to. The leader does not decide which kind it is.
  4. Doubt is heard, not defended. The leader stays, and may help the person find a teacher from their own tradition.
  5. The leader cannot always tell darkness from low mood, and need not. Take both seriously.
  6. When signs are heavy or long, connect to a doctor without implying that faith is the problem, and promise to keep coming.
  7. Never tell anyone to stop or change medicine. Crisis is a different matter: it goes to the crisis course and emergency services. Not medical advice.

When prayer will not come Silence, guilt, doubt and darkness are old and honest experiences of faith Silence Wordless prayer is prayer Offer borrowed words Do not push or prescribe Guilt Hear it, do not dismiss Do not add to it Offer the church's own ways Doubt Hear it, do not defend Ask when it began Help find a teacher Darkness The leader cannot always tell a spiritual season from a struggle of mood, and need not Take both seriously, and stay When the spiritual and the medical go together A reason to connect, never a diagnosis What may be seen Long, heavy, not lifting Sleep or eating very changed Interest lost in many things What may be seen Ordinary tasks hard Hopelessness, "a burden" Guilt or doubt out of proportion The leader says "This is not a failure of faith" "I would like you to see a doctor" "I will keep coming" The leader never Says a doctor shows a lack of faith, or tells anyone to stop or change medicine Hopelessness that suggests harm: the crisis course and emergency services

In short

  • Silence in prayer, guilt, doubt and darkness are old and honest experiences of faith, not by themselves a failure of faith.
  • Wordless prayer is prayer; a leader offers borrowed words and company and does not push or prescribe.
  • Guilt is heard without being dismissed or added to; the leader does not decide whether it is deserved.
  • Doubt is heard and not defended; the leader asks when it began and stays.
  • A leader cannot always tell darkness from low mood, and need not; when signs are heavy or long, connect to a doctor without implying that faith is the problem.
  • Never tell anyone to stop or change medicine; danger goes to the crisis course and emergency services; this is not medical advice.
Front Back
When prayer will not come Wordless prayer is prayer; offer borrowed words and company, do not push, and ask about sleep and daily life.
Guilt Hear it without dismissing it or adding to it; offer the church's own ways of confession; notice if it is heavy, constant and joined with other signs.
Doubt Hear it, do not defend; ask when it began; help find a teacher from the person's own tradition.
Darkness and the doctor The leader cannot always tell and need not; suggest a doctor without blaming faith, and promise to keep coming.

One sentence to remember When prayer will not come, lend words, sit beside, and do not let anyone carry the dark alone.

This week's action Choose a psalm or short prayer that you could read with someone who cannot pray, and think of one person in your community to whom you could offer to read it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Who in your community has been unable to pray? What would they have wanted someone to say or do?
  • How might your community distinguish, without deciding, between a guilt that needs forgiveness and a guilt that will not lift? What would you do if you did not know?
  • When have you heard doubt answered with a defence? How might you respond with "Thank you for telling me"?
  • How can a leader say "I cannot tell whether this is spiritual or something else, and I do not need to" without sounding uncaring?
  • What borrowed words, such as a psalm, a short prayer or a hymn, would you keep ready for someone who cannot pray?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.