Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
- Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
- Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
- Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
- Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
- Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
- Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
- Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
- Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
- Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
- Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
- Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
- Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
- Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
- Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
- Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
- Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
- Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
A member of a congregation is away for a few weeks. People are told only that she is "not well". When she returns, the greetings are warm but a little too careful, and nobody asks how she is. A teenager in a youth group is called "mental" as a joke when he is quiet, and the leader laughs with the rest. A pastor, who has been tired and low for months, tells no one, because he has never heard a leader say that this can happen to leaders.
None of these people has been attacked. Nobody meant harm. And yet each has met stigma: a mark of shame that a community puts on a kind of struggle, and on the people who have it. Stigma works through words, looks and silence, and it can be so quiet that the people who carry it do not see it.
This lecture looks at how stigma works in a church, why it exists, what it costs, and how a leader can begin to lessen it. It does this without blame. Stigma is learned in families, schools, workplaces and churches, and almost everyone has been taught some of it. The point is to see it and gently change it.
This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment. It does not tell anyone what a word means in medicine. It looks at the ordinary words and habits of a community.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Explain stigma as a mark of shame carried through words, looks and silence.
- Give at least two examples of each of the three ways stigma shows in a church.
- Explain, without blame, why communities develop stigma and what it costs the person who carries it.
- Say what self-stigma is and why it keeps people from asking for help.
- Offer a plain, kind way to speak about a person who is struggling in mind or mood.
His disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”" — John 9:2
World English Bible
Jesus answered, “Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but, that the works of God might be revealed in him." — John 9:3
WEB
When his friends heard it, they went out to seize him: for they said, “He is insane.”" — Mark 3:21
WEB
Many of them said, “He has a demon, and is insane! Why do you listen to him?”" — John 10:20
WEB
As he thus made his defense, Festus said with a loud voice, “Paul, you are crazy! Your great learning is driving you insane!”" — Acts 26:24
WEB
I am forgotten from their hearts like a dead man. I am like broken pottery." — Psalm 31:12
WEB
There is one who speaks rashly like the piercing of a sword, but the tongue of the wise heals." — Proverbs 12:18
WEB
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
WEB
He won’t break a bruised reed. He won’t quench a dimly burning wick. He will faithfully bring justice." — Isaiah 42:3
WEB
Scripture knows how words and looks shut people out. The disciples ask whose sin caused a man's affliction, and Jesus answers that it was neither his nor his parents' (John 9:2-3). People say of Jesus, "He is insane" (Mark 3:21), and "He has a demon, and is insane!" (John 10:20), and Festus says of Paul, "You are crazy!" (Acts 26:24). These verses are not about illness in Jesus or Paul. They show how quickly a hard word is used against a person whom others do not understand. A psalmist feels forgotten like a dead man (Psalm 31:12). The Proverbs warn about careless and hasty speech. And Isaiah says of the servant of God that he will not break a bruised reed.
1. What stigma is
Stigma is a mark of shame. When a community has stigma about a kind of struggle, it does not only feel sorry for the person who has it. It thinks less of them, or it is afraid of them, or it feels embarrassed by them, or it avoids them. The person may feel it before anyone says a word.
In this course the struggle in question is a struggle of mind or mood: a long heaviness, fear that does not leave, a change in sleep or thinking, or a difficulty that makes ordinary life hard. This course does not label or sort such struggles; it does not diagnose. But it is clear on one point. Many communities, in many countries and traditions, attach more shame to these struggles than to most troubles of the body. A person with a broken leg gets a card and a casserole. A person with a heavy mind often gets silence.
(an invented example) Harbour Road Fellowship has about thirty adults and keeps a prayer list on a board in the hall. When a member has an operation, the name goes up and people sign a card. When another member has been "away" for a month because of a struggle of mind, no name goes up. Nobody decided this. It simply never occurred to anyone to put a name there. The person noticed.
2. Three ways stigma travels
Words. Some words wound. "Crazy", "mad", "nuts", "weak", "attention-seeking", "unstable" and "lazy" are used in many languages, often as jokes or as a way of ending an argument. The same is true of religious words used as accusations: "Your faith is small", "You are not trusting God", "You are giving the devil a foothold." A leader may also use a medical word carelessly, as a general insult ("he is so anxious", "she is obsessed") and so teach the room to use it that way. The words differ from place to place and from language to language. A leader should find out which words carry shame in their own community, not assume they know.
Looks. A look can say what words cannot. It may be a pause when the person comes in. It may be a glance exchanged between two people. It may be a way of speaking more slowly or more gently, which tells the person they are now seen as fragile. It may be that the person is quietly no longer asked to read, to lead, to teach, to look after the children's group, to help in the kitchen, as if they had become unreliable. Some of this is wise: a person who is struggling may truly need a lighter load. But when it happens without a word, it can look to the person like a judgement.
Silence. The quietest form of stigma is no talk at all. Nobody says the person's name in prayer, because nobody is sure what to say. Nobody mentions the absence. The leader's sermons never speak of heavy minds. The announcements speak of surgery and of bereavement, but not of this. Silence tells people what cannot be spoken of in this place.
3. Why it exists: without blame
It is worth asking why communities develop stigma, because the answer shows that most of it is not cruelty.
- Fear and not knowing. A struggle of the mind is harder to see than a struggle of the body, and people are uneasy about what they do not understand. They do not know what to say, so they say nothing, or something safe.
- A belief that it is a moral failure. In many communities, people have learned that a strong person can master their feelings by effort and faith. A person who cannot is thought to be weak. This belief is often held with the best of intentions: a wish to encourage.
- Honour and shame. In some families and communities, a struggle of the mind brings shame on the whole household, and the family may try to keep it private to protect everyone, including the person. Elsewhere, a person is expected to manage their own difficulties alone. These patterns differ between families and between places, and no community has all of them or none. This lecture does not rank any community's ways. It asks only that we see what they cost the person who is struggling.
- Bad experiences. Someone may once have been frightened by a person who was very distressed, or have seen a church handle such a thing badly. People carry those memories.
- Faith itself. A community that teaches that God gives peace may find it hard to speak about a member who does not feel peace. The teaching is true; the silence it produces is the problem.
Everyone has some of these. The leader who finds them in himself or herself is not worse than anyone else. That is where the work begins.
4. What stigma costs
Stigma is not only unpleasant. It has real costs.
- The person hides. People often cover a struggle so that no one will see. They smile at church and say nothing, and they carry it alone.
- Help comes late. A person who fears the words "crazy" or "weak" may put off speaking to a doctor, a counsellor or a pastor, and a family that is ashamed may do the same. Waiting is sometimes harmless and sometimes not.
- Loneliness deepens. Isolation is rarely good for a heavy mind. A community that withdraws, even gently, may make the heaviness greater.
- Faith is hurt. A person told or led to believe that the trouble is a lack of faith may start to doubt that God wants them, and may leave the church.
- Families suffer too. A husband, wife, parent or child of a person who is struggling can feel the same shame and the same silence, and may not tell anyone what they carry. Lecture 5-1 comes back to families and carers.
- Leaders suffer. A leader who thinks a minister must never struggle will not ask for help. Lecture 5-2 comes back to this.
5. Self-stigma
Stigma does not stay outside. A person who has heard the words and seen the looks may begin to say them to themselves: "I am weak", "I should be able to pray this away", "People will think I am mad", "My family will be ashamed." This is self-stigma, and it can be heavier than anything others say. It keeps people from asking, from telling, and from accepting help once it is offered.
A leader cannot lift this by argument. But a leader can show, by ordinary words and ordinary kindness, that the person is not looked down on. A plain sentence such as "I am glad you told me, and I do not think less of you" can matter more than a speech.
6. What Scripture adds
Four pictures help.
Whose fault? In John 9, the disciples see a man who has been blind from birth and ask, "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?" (John 9:2). Jesus answers, "Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but, that the works of God might be revealed in him" (John 9:3). The disciples' question is a very old reflex: when someone suffers, look for the cause in the person or their family. Jesus does not follow the reflex. A leader who is tempted to ask, quietly, "What did this person do to bring it on?" can hear in this passage a gentle correction. We should note, too, that this passage is about blindness, not about the mind. We use it as a picture of a habit of blame, not as a statement about any condition.
Hard words used against others. In the Gospels, people say of Jesus, "He is insane" (Mark 3:21), and some say, "He has a demon, and is insane! Why do you listen to him?" (John 10:20). Festus says to Paul, "You are crazy! Your great learning is driving you insane!" (Acts 26:24). Nothing here suggests that Jesus or Paul was unwell. It shows how quickly such words are used on anyone whom a crowd does not understand or whom it wants to dismiss. If we have heard these words said of someone, and found ourselves nodding, these verses may give us pause.
Being forgotten. A psalmist says, "I am forgotten from their hearts like a dead man. I am like broken pottery" (Psalm 31:12). A leader will hear in this the feeling of a person whom a community has gone quiet about.
The bruised reed. The servant of God "won't break a bruised reed" (Isaiah 42:3). The image is of gentleness toward what is already damaged. It does not tell us how to help; it tells us the spirit in which any help should come.
7. What a leader can do
A leader cannot remove stigma in a week. But small, steady changes matter.
- Notice your own words. Listen for the jokes and labels you use, and for those used around you in a meeting, a group or a family. You need not announce a campaign. You can simply stop using one and, kindly, not laugh at it.
- Use plain and kind words. Instead of "crazy" or "mad", say "struggling", "having a hard time", "unwell" or "having a heavy time of it". Instead of "she is attention-seeking", say nothing, or "I wonder what she needs." Ask the person which words they prefer, because people differ.
- Say it aloud. In a sermon, a prayer or an announcement, mention struggles of mind and mood in the same plain voice you use for illness of the body: "We pray for those who are weary in mind as well as in body." Lecture 6-1 returns to this.
- Put the name on the list, if the person agrees. Ask first. Many people want to be prayed for; some do not want their name used. Do not assume either.
- Keep the door open. Do not take a person off duties without a word, and do not give them every duty back at once. Ask what they would like. Lecture 6-2 says more.
- Say once that going to a doctor or counsellor is not a lack of faith. Many people have never heard this from the front. Lecture 1-3 goes further.
- Do not shame the people who say these words. A person who said "crazy" at the door was probably repeating what they were taught. A quiet word in private does more than a public correction.
8. Before and after
Here are small examples of the same moment, said in a way that carries stigma and in a way that does not.
Before: "She's been off for weeks. I think she's just got a weak spirit." After: "She's been away for weeks. I would like to call and ask how she is."
Before: (the leader says nothing when the quiet teenager is called "mental"). After: "Let us not use that word for a friend. It can hurt." (said gently, once, in private if possible)
Before: "You need to trust God more." After: "I'm glad you told me. I do not think less of you. Would it help if I sat with you for a while?"
Before: The prayer list has a name for every operation and no names for any weariness of mind. After: A line near the top reads, "We pray for all in our community who are unwell in body or mind." Names are added only when the person agrees.
9. A difference of setting
(an invented example) St Odran's Parish is a large congregation of several hundred families, and many of its members have come from other countries. In some of these families, a struggle of the mind is a matter for the household alone, and a person who speaks of it outside the family would bring shame on everyone. The parish's care team does not argue with this. A team member named Imelda learns to ask first, "Would you like us to know, or would you rather it stayed within the family?", and to accept either answer without a judgement. She does not assume that her own preference is the right one for everyone.
(an invented example) The Dunmore Valley Fellowship is a house church of nine adults in a farming district. Everyone knows everyone, and news travels. A member struggling in mind may fear that he cannot hide it, and that any word will go around the village. The leader here makes one promise, and keeps it: "What you tell me, I will not repeat without telling you first." This is a general promise and not an absolute one, and lecture 4-4 says why a leader must not promise total secrecy. It lowers the fear all the same.
The setting is different in each of these places, and so is the form stigma takes. The task is the same: to see it and to be gentle.
10. What a leader takes from this lecture
- Stigma is a mark of shame, carried through words, looks and silence.
- It usually comes from fear, not cruelty, and almost everyone has some of it.
- It costs the person: hiding, late help, loneliness, hurt faith, and strain on families and leaders.
- Self-stigma can be heavier than anything said by others.
- Scripture refuses the reflex of blame and shows that hard words are easily used against those we do not understand.
- A leader can change small things: one word, one sentence from the front, one name on a list when the person agrees, one door kept open.
Diagram 1. Three ways stigma travels
Diagram 2. The same moment, two ways
In short
- Stigma is a mark of shame that a community puts on a kind of struggle, and it travels through words, looks and silence.
- It usually comes from fear, not knowing, a belief that struggle is weakness, and ideas of honour, not from cruelty, and almost everyone has some.
- It costs the person hiding, late help, loneliness, hurt faith and strain on families and on leaders.
- Self-stigma, in which people say the shaming words to themselves, can keep them from asking for help.
- Scripture refuses the reflex of blame in John 9 and shows how hard words are used against those people do not understand.
- A leader can lessen stigma by plain words, speaking of the mind as of the body, and asking the person what they want.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Stigma | A mark of shame put on a kind of struggle and on the person who has it, carried by words, looks and silence. |
| Self-stigma | A person saying the shaming words to themselves, which keeps them from asking for help. |
| John 9:2-3 | Jesus refuses the reflex of asking whose fault an affliction is. |
| A leader's first changes | Plain kind words, speaking of the mind as of the body, asking the person what they want, and keeping the door open. |
One sentence to remember Stigma is mostly learned, not meant, and a leader can begin to change it with one kind word at a time.
This week's action Listen this week for one word or one silence in your community that carries shame about a struggle of mind or mood, and decide on one plain, kind phrase to use instead.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What words in your language carry shame when they are used of a struggle of mind or mood? Write them down without naming anyone.
- Which of the three, words, looks or silence, is strongest in your community? Where have you seen it?
- Why might a person in your community fear that speaking of a struggle would bring shame on a whole family? What would it mean to respect that and still offer kindness?
- What is one plain sentence you could say to a person who tells you they are struggling, which does not carry stigma?
- Harbour Road Fellowship has a prayer list that leaves out weariness of mind. What would be a wise, respectful change in your own setting?