Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
- Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
- Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
- Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
- Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
- Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
- Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
- Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
- Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
- Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
- Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
- Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
- Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
- Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
- Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
- Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
- Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
- Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
A deacon notices that a quiet member of the congregation has, for some days, been full of energy. He talks fast, he is making plans to start three new ministries, and he says he hardly needs to sleep. Some weeks later the same member stays at home and will not answer the phone. A small-group leader hears a member say, quietly, that people are watching her and that messages are being sent to her that nobody else can see. She is frightened, and she asks the leader not to tell anyone. A youth worker finds that a teenager's moods change so sharply from one week to the next that the family no longer knows who will come to the door.
This lecture is about two kinds of difficulty that leaders often find hard to talk about: moods that swing a long way from the person's usual self, and experiences that other people around the person do not share. It is at a general level. It gives a leader a few things to notice, a few things to avoid, and one main direction: do not argue, do not agree, and connect sooner.
This course is not medical or psychological advice. It does not diagnose, it names no condition, it gives no medicine names and teaches no treatment, and it does not replace professional care. A leader never tells anyone to stop or change what a doctor has prescribed. How a community responds when someone is in danger belongs to the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Describe, at a general level, what a leader may notice when a person's mood or energy swings far from their usual self, and why a leader does not label it.
- Explain why unusual experiences are not for the leader to judge as "real" or "unreal", and what a leader asks instead.
- Say why a leader neither argues with a frightened person nor agrees with what frightens them.
- Explain why, in these situations, a leader connects sooner and does not wait and see, and say how to offer that connection kindly.
- Name what hurts and what helps, and say what a leader does when someone may be in danger.
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
World English Bible
We exhort you, brothers, admonish the disorderly, encourage the faint-hearted, support the weak, be patient toward all." — 1 Thessalonians 5:14
WEB
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18
WEB
A friend loves at all times; and a brother is born for adversity." — Proverbs 17:17
WEB
The Bible tells leaders to listen before they answer, and to treat each person as that person needs: to warn those who are out of order, to encourage the faint-hearted, to support the weak, and to be patient with everyone. It does not give one rule for all. A fast-talking, sleepless member and a frightened, withdrawn member are not helped in the same way. The verses ask for attention, patience and a willingness to carry some of the weight, and they promise that the Lord is near to the broken-hearted. None of these verses is a way of judging whether a person is well. They are a way of staying beside someone.
1. Two things this lecture does not do
First, it does not name conditions. Words for particular conditions have meanings that only a trained professional can use properly, and a leader who learns a name tends to start looking for the name in people. A leader who says, "I think she has such-and-such," has left the leader's work and stepped into someone else's, and has often said something that is wrong.
Second, it does not give a checklist. A list of signs can be useful, but only when it leads to one thing: do not label, ask kindly, connect. The signs below are what a leader "may see". They are not a test that a person passes or fails.
2. Swings of mood: what may be seen
Everyone's mood goes up and down. A leader who thought every good day or bad day was a sign of trouble would see trouble everywhere. What makes a leader pause is a change that is large, that is unlike the person, that others have noticed, or that is getting in the way of ordinary life or safety.
A higher stretch. The person may have much more energy than usual and seem to need very little sleep. They may speak fast and jump from one subject to the next. They may make large plans, feel unusually sure of themselves, or become irritable when others do not keep up. They may spend or give away more than is wise, or take risks that are not like them. They may say that God has given them a task that must be done at once.
A lower stretch. The person may withdraw, stop answering messages, stop coming, lose interest in what they loved, and seem flat or heavy. Lecture 2-2 spoke of low mood at a general level.
Back and forth. What troubles families and leaders most is often the contrast: the person who was brimming over last month is silent this month, and nobody knows what to make of it.
There is a particular risk for a church. A higher stretch may be mistaken for zeal. The member who is up before dawn, praying for hours, full of plans and speaking boldly may be praised and given more to do. When the energy falls, the same person may be called discouraged, backslidden or lazy. Neither response is wise. It is possible to be glad that someone is full of energy and still ask, "How have you been sleeping?" It is possible to be concerned about a large change and still honour the person's faith.
No number of days or weeks is given here as a threshold, on purpose. A leader cannot count their way to a decision. What a leader can do is notice a change that worries them and let that worry lead to a kind question.
3. Unusual experiences: not the leader's to judge
Some people see, hear, feel or believe things that those around them do not share. They may be sure that others are watching or speaking about them, that they are being followed or that something is wrong with the world that nobody else can see. They may hear a voice. Their speech may become hard to follow, or they may seem confused about where they are or what day it is. Sometimes this is frightening to the person, and sometimes it is not.
A church must be careful here, because many Christian traditions speak of dreams, visions, a voice of God and a strong sense of being led. A leader is not the judge of whether a particular experience is of God, of the person's own mind, or of something else. Even leaders who have long experience in discerning disagree about this, and lecture 3-3 will take up the way spiritual and medical language relate. This lecture asks for a smaller thing.
Instead of asking, "Is it real?", a leader asks, "How is this for you?" The helpful signs are not whether the experience matches what the leader believes. They are things like these:
- Is the person frightened or distressed by it?
- Are they unable to sleep, eat, or look after themselves because of it?
- Are they cut off from the people who love them, or afraid of them?
- Does the person seem unable to tell what is happening around them from what is happening inside them?
- Is there any sign of danger, to the person or to anyone else?
Where the answer to any of these is yes, the leader takes it seriously whatever its source, and moves toward connecting the person with help. Where the experience is calm and the person is living their life, a leader may simply listen and keep in touch. The leader's job is not to decide what the experience is. It is to notice how the person is, and to stay beside them.
4. Do not argue, and do not agree
A frightened person who is sure of something does not need a debate. Telling them, "That is not true, nobody is watching you," rarely helps. It tells the person that the leader has not understood, and it may end the conversation. A leader who argues for a long time may also frighten the person further.
The opposite is also unhelpful. If a leader says, "Yes, I can see that they are following you," the leader has joined in a belief that may add to the person's fear. It may also make later help harder.
There is a third way, and it is not difficult to say.
"I can hear how frightening this is for you. I do not see it the way you do, but I believe that you are scared, and I am here. Have you been able to sleep?"
This acknowledges the feeling without agreeing or disagreeing with the belief. It uses the person's own words ("frightening", "scared") and not the leader's. It turns, gently, to something concrete and shared: sleep, food, safety, who is near. A leader should speak calmly and in short sentences, ask permission before touching or moving closer, and offer a quiet place with fewer people if that is possible.
A leader also does not begin a long prayer that names what the person is afraid of, or that tells it to leave. Lecture 3-3 explains why: whatever a community believes about spiritual matters, such prayer in the middle of a frightened conversation can deepen the fear and can delay the help that is needed. A short, gentle prayer, if the person welcomes it ("Lord, be near to her tonight, and give her rest"), is a different thing.
5. Connect sooner
Lecture 2-1 taught three words: notice, ask, connect. In many kinds of difficulty a leader may take time. Here the leader should connect sooner and not wait and see. The reason is not that these experiences are always serious. The reason is that, when a person is very unlike themselves, is frightened, is not sleeping, or has lost touch with what others can see, it is safer for them to be seen by a doctor or another qualified professional quickly, and a leader cannot tell from outside how serious it is.
A leader can offer the connection in a way that is kind and does not accuse:
"I am worried about how you have been sleeping and how frightened you have felt. I would like you to see a doctor, not because anything is wrong with your faith, but because I think you deserve more help than I can give. Would you let me help you find the right person? I can come with you."
Several points about the offer:
- Say why, in terms of what you have seen and how the person feels, not in terms of a label. "I am worried about your sleep" is better than "I think you are unwell."
- Say that this is not a verdict on their faith or their character. Many people fear exactly that.
- Offer to help and to go along. The person may be afraid, or may not trust doctors, or may not be able to organise the appointment.
- Involve family or friends the person trusts, and with the person's agreement where that can be had. Whether and when to share information without agreement is a matter of the law and of professional ethics, and the rules differ: check locally. The course on counselling ethics, confidentiality and referral explains the principles. Never promise absolute secrecy if you are not sure you can keep it.
- Keep a list in advance of the local doctors and services in your area, and who can be reached in an emergency. Find out before you need it, and check locally.
If you learn that the person is already receiving care, do not tell them to stop or change anything, and do not scold them if they say they have stopped. Changes in treatment belong to the prescriber or the treating professional. You may say, "I think it would be good to tell your doctor about that," and offer to help.
6. When there may be danger
Danger is not a neutral matter. If someone may be in danger now, or may be a danger to others, especially to children or to other people who cannot protect themselves, the leader does not wait and does not carry the matter alone. The leader stays with the person if it is safe, and calls the local emergency services. A person who speaks of ending their life is a matter for the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response, and this lecture does not take it further.
7. Families, and the cost of silence
The family of a person like this is often frightened and often tired. They may be ashamed. They may have been told by neighbours, or by someone at church, that it is a spiritual failing. They may have kept it hidden for a long time. A leader who comes with understanding can lift a great weight. A leader who comes with a judgement adds to it. Lecture 5-1 comes back to families and carers.
A leader should also guard what they have been told. A prayer request such as, "Please pray for our brother, who has been talking strangely," shared in a meeting without the person's agreement, can do lasting harm. It may be the kind of word that follows someone for years.
8. What hurts, and what helps
What hurts:
- Arguing with the person, or mocking what they say.
- Agreeing with what frightens them.
- it attention-seeking, sin, weak faith or the work of a particular spirit, as a verdict.
- Praising a high-energy stretch as spiritual strength and then blaming the low stretch that follows.
- Gossip, and sharing it as a prayer request without permission.
- Waiting, "to see if it passes", when the person is frightened, sleepless or unlike themselves.
- Crowding the person with people, noise or questions.
What helps:
- A calm voice, short sentences, and a quiet place.
- "How is this for you?" and "How have you been sleeping?"
- Acknowledging the feeling without arguing for or against the belief.
- Staying beside the person, in a way they can bear.
- A kind, early offer to connect with a doctor, and to go along.
- Care for the family, and for the person's privacy.
9. Two communities, one task
(an invented example) Pilgrim Hill Fellowship is a house church of about fourteen people. Anselm, a member known for his quiet manner, has been up all night for several nights and tells the group, with great energy, that he has been given a vision and that everything must change by the end of the month. The leader, Mirela, does not argue, and she does not praise him in front of the group. After the meeting she asks him quietly how long it has been since he slept. He says that he does not need sleep. She says that she is worried about him and would like him to see a doctor, not because his faith is in question, but because she cares about him. She offers to ask his brother to go with him. She does not mention it in the prayer-request time. In a house church this small, the discipline is to keep a confidence while not keeping Anselm alone.
(an invented example) Calvary Heights Community Church is a large congregation. A member of the congregation who attends the Tuesday group tells the leader, Bao, that she is afraid and that people are speaking about her. Bao is tempted to say that nothing is wrong, and then to say that he will pray against it. He says neither. He says that she must be very frightened, that he is glad she told him, and that he would like to help her get some rest and some help. He asks whom in her family she trusts. The church has a short list, prepared in advance, of local doctors and services, and a named person who knows how to use it. In a large church, the discipline is to make sure that the person is not passed from helper to helper while nobody takes the next step.
10. What a leader takes from this lecture
- A large change that is unlike the person is a reason to ask kindly, not a reason to label.
- A higher stretch of energy may be mistaken for zeal, and the lower stretch that follows may be blamed. A leader does neither.
- Unusual experiences are not the leader's to judge. The leader asks, "How is this for you?" and watches for distress, sleeplessness, fear and danger.
- Do not argue and do not agree. Acknowledge the feeling, stay calm, and turn to what is shared.
- Connect sooner. Offer a doctor kindly, say that it is not a verdict on faith, and offer to go along.
- Never tell anyone to stop or change medicine, and never promise absolute secrecy.
- Danger is not neutral. Where someone may be in danger, call emergency services. Not medical advice.
In short
- A large change in mood or energy, unlike the person, is a reason to ask kindly and to connect; the leader does not label, and gives no medicine advice.
- A higher stretch of energy may be taken for zeal, and a lower stretch for laziness; the leader avoids both mistakes.
- Unusual experiences are not for the leader to judge; the leader asks "How is this for you?" and watches for distress, lack of sleep, fear and danger.
- Do not argue and do not agree; acknowledge the feeling, speak calmly, and stay.
- Connect sooner in these situations, say that it is not a verdict on faith, offer to go along, and never tell anyone to stop or change medicine.
- Danger is not neutral: where someone may be in danger, call emergency services.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Swings of mood | A large change unlike the person is a reason to ask kindly and connect; do not label, and do not mistake a high stretch for zeal. |
| Unusual experiences | The leader does not judge whether they are real; the leader asks how they are for the person and watches for distress, sleeplessness, fear and danger. |
| Do not argue, do not agree | Acknowledge the feeling, not the belief, and turn to what is shared: sleep, food, safety, who is near. |
| Connect sooner | Offer a doctor kindly, say it is not a verdict on faith, offer to go along; never tell anyone to change medicine. |
One sentence to remember Do not argue, do not agree, stay beside the person, and connect sooner.
This week's action Write down, in your own words, one sentence you could say to a frightened person that acknowledges the fear without arguing or agreeing, and one sentence that offers to help them find a doctor.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- How does your community speak about a person who is full of energy and plans? How might a leader be glad for such a person and still ask about sleep?
- Which experiences, such as dreams, visions or a sense of being led, are spoken of with respect in your tradition? How can a leader honour them and still ask, "How is this for you?"
- Why is it better to acknowledge a person's fear than to argue with it or agree with it? What would you say in your own words?
- What would you need in place, in advance, to connect a person quickly with a doctor? Who in your community could keep the list?
- What does your community do with a worry about a person, such as a prayer request or a chat in the corridor? How could you guard the person's privacy?