FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

29 min

A pastor tells a joke in a sermon about a "crazy" neighbour, and the congregation laughs. In the third row sits a member who has not slept well for weeks and who has decided, on the spot, never to speak to anyone in this church about it. An elder reads out the prayer list on Sunday: "Please pray for Brother Paulo, who has been put on strong tablets for his nerves." Paulo is in the room. A preacher closes a sermon on faith with the story of a woman who "threw away her pills, trusted God and was healed", and nobody in the room knows what became of her next year.

None of these speakers meant harm. Each spoke from love, from habit, or from a wish to encourage. Yet each sentence did something the speaker did not plan. This is the first lecture of the last week of the course. Weeks 1 to 5 asked what a single leader does: notice, stay beside, connect, and look after their own mind. Week 6 asks what a whole congregation can do so that the next person who struggles finds a friendlier room. The first place to look is the one every leader controls every week: the words we use, the way we preach from Scripture, and the way we pray.

The central claim of the course applies here as everywhere: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help. A congregation's speech either teaches that claim or teaches the opposite. Nobody has to announce it. People learn it from what is said, and what is never said.

This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment, and it does not replace professional care. Nothing in this lecture tells a preacher what to say about any condition or any treatment. It asks how we speak so that people feel free to ask for help.

What these 29 minutes give you

  • Name words and habits of speech that carry stigma, say why a speaker may use them without meaning harm, and suggest plain replacements.
  • Describe three ways in which Scripture is used in sermons that can hurt a struggling person, and three ways it can help.
  • Explain why a testimony or a sermon illustration needs permission and care, and why it must never suggest that prayer replaced treatment.
  • Describe how to handle prayer requests, public prayers and prayer with a person so that privacy and dignity are kept.
  • Write, in your own words, a short invitation that a leader could say from the front to tell the congregation that help is welcome.

There is one who speaks rashly like the piercing of a sword, but the tongue of the wise heals." — Proverbs 12:18

World English Bible

Death and life are in the power of the tongue; those who love it will eat its fruit." — Proverbs 18:21

WEB

Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29

WEB

The Lord Yahweh has given me the tongue of those who are taught, that I may know how to sustain with words him who is weary: he wakens morning by morning, he wakens my ear to hear as those who are taught." — Isaiah 50:4

WEB

He won’t break a bruised reed. He won’t quench a smoking flax, until he leads justice to victory." — Matthew 12:20

WEB

Yahweh, the God of my salvation, I have cried day and night before you." — Psalm 88:1

WEB

You have put lover and friend far from me, and my friends into darkness." — Psalm 88:18

WEB

Proverbs knows that careless speech can wound like a sword and that the tongue of the wise heals. The apostle asks for speech that is "good for building up as the need may be". Isaiah's servant has been given "the tongue of those who are taught", and uses it to sustain the weary. Matthew shows a gentleness that does not break a bruised reed. Psalm 88 shows how far Scripture's own prayer-book goes: a prayer in which friends are far away and the darkness is the last word on the page. A congregation that can read all of these aloud has room for most of its people.

1. Why the pulpit comes first

A private conversation reaches one person. A sermon, a notice, a prayer or a joke at the door reaches everyone present, and it does so before anyone has asked a question. A person who is struggling in mind or mood is usually listening to the whole service for one thing: is it safe to say this here? The answer is rarely given in a policy. It is given in a tone, in a word chosen or avoided, in a verse used gently or harshly, and in a silence about the subject that goes on for years.

This lecture is about those everyday signals. It does not ask leaders to preach about mental health every week. It asks them to notice what they are already teaching, and to adjust it where it closes a door.

2. Words that carry stigma, and why people use them

Lecture 1-2 looked at stigma: the words, the looks and the silence. Here we apply it to what is said from the front. Four kinds of speech do most of the damage.

  1. Labels used as jokes or insults. "That is crazy." "He is mad." "She is a bit unhinged." "I am so depressed about the weather." These are everyday phrases in many languages and the speaker usually thinks nothing of them. But a listener who is struggling hears that the word for their experience is a word for something silly or shameful. A joke told from the front tells everyone that this is a subject for laughing at, not for speaking about.
  2. Words that make a struggle a character flaw. "Weak." "Attention seeking." "Lazy." "Self-pity." "Snap out of it." "Pull yourself together." The speaker may be trying to encourage. The listener hears that the trouble is a failure of will, and that asking for help would be an admission of failure.
  3. Words that turn a person into a condition. "The depressed." "A schizophrenic." "She is bipolar." Even a correct word, used as the name of a whole person, shrinks that person to one part of their life. This course names no conditions, but if you meet such a word, a plain habit helps: speak of a person who is struggling or a person who lives with something, and let the person say what they wish to be called.
  4. Spiritual words used as a verdict. "A spirit of fear." "A lack of faith." "Unconfessed sin." Lecture 3-3 asked leaders not to settle between spiritual and medical language from the pulpit, and lecture 3-4 asked them not to read guilt or darkness as a verdict. From the front, the same care applies even more strongly, because the sentence is heard by many people in different situations, and some of them will take it personally.

Why do good people use these words? Mostly because they heard them in their own families and churches, because they sound like encouragement, or because they have never been told otherwise. A leader who finds such a word in their own mouth has not been wicked. They have found a habit, and habits can be changed. There is no need for guilt, and no need for a public apology. A quiet change is enough.

Here are some plain replacements. They are not a rule book, and the right word depends on language and place.

Instead of Try Why
"He is crazy." "He is having a very hard time." Describes the person's situation, not a label.
"Snap out of it." "I am here. What would help today?" Offers company, not a command.
"She is attention seeking." "She seems to need someone to notice." Reads the need, not the motive.
"The depressed", "the mentally ill" "People who are struggling", "people living with a hard illness" A person comes before a condition.
"Just pray about it." "I will pray with you, and I would also like you to talk to someone who can help." Prayer and help together.
"If you had more faith..." (Say nothing like it.) Faith is not a test of health.

(an invented example) Cedarmoor Fellowship is a house church of eleven adults who meet in the home of a retired teacher named Wilhelmina. She has a habit of any strong feeling "hysterics", a word she learned from her mother. One evening, a young member named Ifeanyi says quietly that he has been feeling "heavy" for a long time. Wilhelmina says, "Oh, don't get hysterical." The room goes quiet. Afterwards another member, a nurse called Priya, gently tells Wilhelmina what happened. Wilhelmina is mortified, and the next week she says to Ifeanyi, "I used a word that shut you down. I am sorry. I would like to listen, if you wish." Notice what made this work: nobody was shamed in front of the group, the apology was short, and the door was opened again. In a group of eleven, one person's word is the whole climate.

3. Preaching: how Scripture is used

Scripture is the preacher's tool, and a tool can build or break. Three uses harm a struggling person even when the preacher is sincere.

Scripture as a weapon. A verse aimed at a person: "Rejoice always, so what are you worried about?", "Do not be anxious about anything, so stop worrying." These verses have their own meaning and their own context, and they are not ill-meant. But when they are used as a command to feel differently at once, they add shame to suffering. A person who cannot stop being afraid now believes they are also disobedient. This is exactly what safety line 4 forbids: Scripture is never a weapon.

Scripture as a guarantee. "If you trust God, you will have peace." "God never gives you more than you can bear." These sentences promise a result and then leave the person who does not get the result with a double burden: the original trouble, and the thought that they have failed the test. Hearers who have been through something very heavy often say that these lines sounded like a lie. Scripture promises God's presence and faithfulness; it does not promise that every night will be easy or that every illness will pass quickly.

Scripture as a test of faith. "A strong Christian does not need help." This turns the visit to a doctor, or the telling of a friend, into a sign of weakness. It also, quietly, tells everyone that the leaders must never have a hard time. Lecture 5-2 spoke of a culture of hiding; the pulpit can build it or take it down.

Three uses help.

The honest Scriptures. The Psalms of lament, Job, Elijah under the broom tree, Jeremiah's complaint, Jesus in Gethsemane and the cry from the cross: these can be preached as they are, without hurrying to the happy ending. A preacher who reads Psalm 88 aloud, and says "this is in the Bible, and it ends in the dark", gives a hearer permission. Psalm 88 opens with a cry day and night, and the psalm never turns to praise. It ends with friends far away. A sermon that makes room for that psalm says to the whole room: you are allowed to be here as you are.

The gentle Scriptures. "A bruised reed he will not break." "Yahweh is near to the broken-hearted." These verses are for company, not for fixing. A preacher may say them slowly and leave a space.

The Scriptures of ordinary help. The Bible mentions physicians, bandages, wine and oil, the Good Samaritan's inn, and friends who carry. A preacher can say, without a long argument, that God works through doctors and nurses as well as through prayer. Lecture 1-3 set out that prayer and treatment do not replace each other; a single sentence from the front can carry it.

4. Illustrations and testimonies

Sermons use stories, and the story is often what people remember. Three cautions.

Do not tell a real person's struggle without their free permission. Even with a changed name, a small community knows who is meant. If you want to use something from your own life, think first whether it is yours to tell, and whether the people close to you would agree. A leader who tells, with care, a limited part of their own hard time can lift a heavy silence; lecture 5-2 spoke of this. A leader who tells someone else's story, to illustrate a point, has taken something that was not theirs.

Do not tell a story in which prayer replaced treatment. "She stopped her tablets, trusted God, and has never been ill since." Whatever happened in a particular life, a story like this, told from the front, carries a lesson that listeners will apply to themselves. Someone in the room is on treatment and may think of stopping. This course never advises anyone to stop or change a medicine; changes belong to the person's prescriber or treating professional. A preacher is not that person. The safe course is to leave out any story whose point is that someone left their treatment, and to tell instead stories in which prayer and care travelled together.

Do not make a struggle the hero's trophy. A testimony that moves quickly from "I was in a terrible place" to "and then I was fine" teaches that recovery is quick and faith-powered. Many people, and many families, are in the long middle of a story. Let a testimony include the middle: the slow weeks, the people who helped, the ups and downs. If a member offers to share, help them to decide what to say and what to keep private, and make sure they know they may change their mind.

5. Prayer: in the service, on the list, and beside a person

Public prayer. In the prayers of the church, name the struggling in general terms and without detail: "for those who are anxious or low in spirit, for those who cannot sleep, for those who care for them, and for the doctors, nurses and counsellors who help." Prayers like these tell everyone that the subject belongs in the church's prayer. They also protect privacy, because no one is named.

Prayer requests and lists. This is where confidence is most often lost, by love. A member shares something in a small group; a kind person adds it to the list; the list goes into a bulletin, a group message or a prayer chain. Within a day it has passed through dozens of hands. For anything to do with mind or mood, use this rule: share only what the person has agreed may be shared, in the words they agreed, with the people they agreed. "Please pray for a member who is going through a hard time" is enough if the person says so. Names, diagnoses, medicines, family details and guesses about causes do not belong on a list. If someone asks you to "just tell the prayer chain", ask the person first.

Prayer with a person. Ask first: "Would you like me to pray with you now?" A "no" is a complete answer. Keep the prayer short and plain; avoid a prayer that tells God what is wrong with the person, or that tells the person what to feel, or that makes the prayer a performance for the people nearby. Never make the prayer a way of ending the conversation. Never lay hands on, hold, or pull a person into a prayer without asking; for some people, touch and noise are hard. And do not let prayer replace the other help. A sentence such as "I will keep praying, and I would also like you to speak to someone who can help" holds both.

Pray for everyone, not only the person. Pray for the families and carers, for the doctors, nurses and counsellors, for the leaders who tire. Include the leader. A prayer that says "we are all in need of help" teaches that needing help is not shameful.

Different traditions pray very differently: with written prayers, with open prayer from the floor, with silence, with the laying on of hands, with anointing, with song. This course does not prefer one over another. It asks only that the same care run through all: consent, privacy, gentleness, and no replacement of treatment by prayer or of prayer by treatment.

6. One sentence from the front

If a leader says nothing about mental health from the front for years, the silence itself speaks. A short, calm invitation, said once or twice a year and written in the bulletin where the church has one, can change the room. It need not be long, and it need not name any condition. For example:

"Many of us go through times when our mind or mood is heavy. That is not a failure of faith, and it is nothing to hide. If it is you, or someone you love, please speak to one of our leaders or to your doctor. We will walk beside you, and we will help you find help."

A leader can adapt this in their own words. Two cautions: do not make the invitation a way of promising secrecy you cannot guarantee (lecture 4-4), and do not say it unless the church is ready to respond kindly when someone takes it up. An invitation that is followed by an awkward silence does more harm than none.

If a leader hears from the front, or after the service, that someone is thinking of ending their life, this is not a matter for the sermon or a prayer chain. The course on crisis, suicide and trauma response applies, and anyone in danger now needs emergency services.

7. Two communities

(an invented example) Cedarmoor Fellowship, whom we met above, is a house church with no building, no bulletin and no sermon in the usual sense. Their danger is the single voice of the host. Their opportunity is that every person in the room can be spoken to by name. After the evening with Ifeanyi, they agree on two small things: no one will say "hysterical" or "crazy" in the house, and when a member shares something heavy, they will ask, "Would you like us to pray now, or would you like us to just listen?"

(an invented example) Holy Cross Parish is a large congregation with four services, a printed bulletin, an online prayer list and a team of three preachers. Their danger is the opposite: many voices, no single habit, and a prayer list that reaches hundreds. The parish council asks each preacher to read one short page of "words we are trying to use" and agrees that any prayer request touching on mind or mood is passed on only with the person's own permission, in words they have agreed. The online list gets a plain line at the top: "We share only what people have asked us to share."

The two settings differ in size, in structure and in habit, but the same questions apply: what do our words say, how do we use Scripture, and who decides what is shared?

8. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. A congregation's speech teaches before anyone asks. People decide whether it is safe to speak from what is said and left unsaid.
  2. Change a stigmatising word quietly and without shame. A habit is not a sin.
  3. Scripture is never a weapon, a guarantee of ease or a test of faith. It can give permission, company and honest lament.
  4. Do not tell a story in which prayer replaced treatment. Nobody should be led to change treatment by a sermon.
  5. Prayer requests belong to the person. Share only what they agree to.
  6. One calm invitation from the front opens a door that years of silence close.

Diagram 1. Words that close doors, and words that open them

Words that close doors, and words that open them Usually said in love or from habit -- changed quietly, without shame A joke or a label "That is crazy." The subject becomes a thing to laugh at A flaw of character "Weak", "snap out of it" The trouble becomes a failure of will A verdict in spiritual words "A lack of faith" Shame is added to the suffering Instead: describe the situation "He is having a very hard time." A person comes before a label Instead: offer company "I am here. What would help today?" Prayer and help travel together Scripture is never a weapon, a guarantee of ease or a test of faith Honest laments, gentle verses and ordinary help all belong in the pulpit. A calm invitation from the front opens a door that silence closes.

Diagram 2. Who owns a prayer request

Who owns a prayer request What may go on a list, a bulletin or a group message Ask the person first "May we share this?" What, in which words, and with whom Share the least "A member is going through a hard time" is enough Leave out Names, diagnoses, medicines, family details, guesses about causes A "no" is a complete answer Pray for the struggling in general terms in public prayer, and name no one. A prayer beside a person is asked for first, kept short, and never ends the conversation.

In short

  • A congregation's words, sermons and prayers tell struggling people whether it is safe to speak, before anyone asks a question.
  • Jokes, labels, "weak" and "snap out of it" carry stigma; speakers usually mean no harm, and a quiet change of habit is enough.
  • Scripture is never used as a weapon, a guarantee of ease or a test of faith; honest laments and gentle verses give company.
  • Never tell a story in which prayer replaced treatment, and never tell a real person's struggle without their free permission.
  • Prayer requests about mind or mood are shared only as the person agreed; one calm invitation from the front opens a door.
Front Back
Three harmful uses of Scripture As a weapon, as a guarantee of ease, and as a test of faith.
Testimony caution Ask permission, include the slow middle, and never tell a story in which prayer replaced treatment.
Prayer request rule Share only what the person agreed, in the words they agreed, with the people they agreed.
One invitation from the front A calm sentence that says a heavy mind or mood is no failure of faith and that leaders will walk beside and help find help.

One sentence to remember A congregation teaches whether it is safe to speak long before anyone asks, so choose words, verses and prayers that leave the door open.

This week's action Listen to your community's speech for one week, write down one habit of speech to change, and change it quietly.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the stigma words in this lecture have you heard in your own community, and which have you used? What could a quiet change look like?
  • Which of the three harmful uses of Scripture (weapon, guarantee, test of faith) have you heard most? Which honest Scripture could your community read aloud that it rarely reads?
  • What would you want a member to be asked before their struggle is mentioned in a prayer, a bulletin or a group message?
  • Is your setting more like Cedarmoor Fellowship or Holy Cross Parish? What is the first small change that would suit it?
  • Write the one calm invitation you would be willing to say aloud. What would your community need to be ready for, before you say it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.