FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

A member of a small congregation was nearby when something frightening happened in the neighbourhood. Nobody in the congregation was hurt, but he has not been the same since. He jumps at sudden noises, he says he does not want to go out in the evening, and he tells the group leader that he has not slept properly for a long time. A church secretary was shaken by a sudden, painful piece of news, and in the following weeks she seems to be going through her work as if it were somebody else's. A parent in the parish says only: "I cannot sleep, and when I do, I dream."

This lecture is about the ways people may react after a shock: a sudden, frightening or painful event, whether it happened to them, near them, or to someone they love. It also looks at sleep, because trouble with sleep is among the things leaders hear about most often, in many kinds of difficulty. The lecture is at a general level. It gives a leader a few things to notice, a few things to do, and a clear list of things not to do.

This course is not medical or psychological advice. It does not diagnose, and it does not teach treatment. It gives no medicine names, no sleep remedies, no techniques for handling memories or reactions, and no timetable by which a reaction is judged. It does not apply a name to any person, and it does not replace professional care. How a community responds in the first hours and days of a serious event, and how it responds when someone speaks of ending their life, belong to the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Describe, at a general level, the kinds of reactions people may have after a shock, and explain why they differ so much from person to person.
  • Say why a leader does not ask for the story of what happened, and what a leader does instead.
  • Explain why trouble with sleep is a sign worth gently asking about, and why a leader does not advise on remedies.
  • Name what helps after a shock, what hurts, and when to encourage a person toward a doctor or another professional.
  • Describe how faith reactions after a shock, such as anger or silence toward God, are heard without correction.

Fearfulness and trembling have come on me. Horror has overwhelmed me." — Psalm 55:5

World English Bible

You hold my eyelids open. I am so troubled that I can’t speak." — Psalm 77:4

WEB

I am weary with my groaning. Every night I flood my bed. I drench my couch with my tears." — Psalm 6:6

WEB

It is vain for you to rise up early, to stay up late, eating the bread of toil; for he gives sleep to his loved ones." — Psalm 127:2

WEB

In peace I will both lay myself down and sleep, for you, Yahweh alone, make me live in safety." — Psalm 4:8

WEB

Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18

WEB

The psalms are honest about what fear and trouble do to a person. One psalmist says that fearfulness and trembling have come on him and horror has overwhelmed him. Another says that God holds his eyelids open, and that he is so troubled that he cannot speak. A third is weary with groaning and weeps through the night. At the same time, the Psalms speak of sleep as a gift of God to those he loves, and of a God who is near to the broken-hearted. These two kinds of verse belong together. The first shows that the Bible does not hurry a frightened person to calm. The second offers comfort in its own time. A leader must take great care here: a verse about sleep must never be used to suggest that a person who cannot sleep lacks trust.

1. What a shock is, and what people do after it

By a shock we mean something sudden, frightening or deeply painful that breaks the ordinary sense that life is safe. It may be an accident, a disaster, an act of violence, a sudden loss, a threat, a medical emergency, or something seen or heard that cannot be unseen or unheard. It may have happened to the person, near them, or to someone they love. It may also be a shock that others do not recognise, such as bad news at work, a betrayal, or a sudden move. People are often shaken by events that others around them consider small.

How people react differs very much. There is no right way to react, and no way a person must react. Some people feel it at once, and some days or months later. Some cry, some feel nothing, some talk without stopping, and some go quiet. Some seem fine and carry on with work for a long time and then find themselves not fine. Many people's reactions ease as time passes and as they are among people who care for them. For some they do not ease. A leader cannot tell in advance which, and should not try to guess.

2. What may be seen, at a general level

Here are kinds of things leaders sometimes notice in the days and weeks after a shock. Read them as "these may be seen" and nothing more. None is a verdict.

  • Being on edge: easily startled, restless, unable to relax, watching for danger.
  • Going over it again and again: thoughts or pictures of the event that come back when the person does not want them.
  • Avoiding reminders: places, people, conversations or times of day.
  • Numbness, or a feeling of being cut off from others or from oneself, as if it were happening to someone else.
  • Strong feelings that come and go: tears, anger, fear, guilt ("I should have done something").
  • Tiredness and body complaints: aches, headaches, a stomach that is unsettled.
  • Changes in sleep, which we take up below.
  • Changes in faith: anger at God, a sense that God is far, prayer that will not come, or a sudden, urgent clinging to religion.

These are not signs of weakness. They are the ways people may respond to something that was too much. They are not a measure of faith, and they are not a measure of character. They also have many causes, so the leader still does not label. Again, the three words: notice, ask, connect.

Children and young people react as well, sometimes in ways that look like plain misbehaviour or quietness. A leader who notices a child who seems changed speaks to a parent or carer, gently, and does not question the child. Helping children after a shock belongs to people trained to do it.

3. The leader does not ask for the story

One of the most common mistakes in this area is made out of love. A leader who sees that someone was close to something terrible says: "Tell me what happened. Tell me everything. It will help to get it out." It sounds like . It can do harm.

A person who has just been through a shock may not be ready to tell it, and may be made worse by being pressed to describe it, especially to someone who is not trained to hear it. Details may be repeated in the congregation. The listener may be shaken as well. Above all, pressing a person to talk makes the leader the one who decides when the person speaks. So the rule is simple: let the person decide whether, when and how much to say. A leader may say:

"I am so sorry this happened. You do not have to tell me anything about it. I am here, and if you want to talk, I will listen, and if you do not, we can just sit."

If the person begins to speak, the leader listens, does not ask for details, does not interpret, and does not promise that everything will be kept secret (lecture 4-4). If someone starts to describe harm done to them by another person, or a child at risk, the situation is not only one of care; it is one of safety, and the courses on safe church policy and on crisis response apply.

A leader also does not lead a session in which a group is asked to retell or relive the event. Those are matters for people trained for them, and the course on crisis and trauma response says more about what a community does. This course does not describe any such method.

4. Sleep: a sign worth gently asking about

After a shock, and in many other kinds of difficulty, sleep often changes. A person may find it hard to fall asleep, or wake in the night and not get back to sleep, or sleep far more than usual, or have dreams that frighten them. Poor sleep is both a sign and a cause. A person who is troubled sleeps badly, and a person who sleeps badly finds everything harder to bear.

For the leader, sleep is useful for a particular reason: it is an easy and unshaming thing to ask about. Many people find it hard to say "I am afraid" or "I am low," but they can say "I have not been sleeping." A leader who asks, "How have you been sleeping?" opens a door that is wide enough for the person to come through. The answer may open a conversation about the rest.

What does the leader do with the answer? Not give a remedy. A leader does not advise on sleep remedies, supplements or medicines, and never tells anyone to stop or change anything they have been prescribed. Those matters belong to a doctor or another qualified professional. What the leader may do is listen, say that poor sleep is hard to bear and that it is not a failing, and encourage the person to speak to a doctor if the sleeping trouble is wearing them down or does not seem to ease. A doctor can check the body, ask about the rest of life, and say what else may be needed.

5. Sleep is a gift, and not a test

The Psalms speak of sleep as a gift: "he gives sleep to his loved ones" (Psalm 127:2), and of lying down in peace (Psalm 4:8). These are beautiful verses. They are also easy to weaponise. A person who lies awake at night and hears a leader say, "God gives his beloved sleep, so perhaps you are not trusting him," has been wounded twice: once by the sleeplessness and once by the shame. A verse that describes a gift is not a charge against those who have not yet received it. The same book gives words to a person whom God keeps awake and who cannot speak (Psalm 77:4), and to one who is weary with groaning in the night (Psalm 6:6). The Bible knows sleepless nights and does not blame the sleepless.

The same applies to a person who cannot pray after a shock. Prayer may go silent for a time. A leader does not tell them that they should pray more. The leader may offer to pray with them or for them, if they wish, and may say that the psalmists also had nights when words would not come. The honest psalms of Week 1 and lecture 3-4 return to this.

6. What helps after a shock

The best support is ordinary and mostly practical.

  • Safety first. A person needs to feel safe, in a safe place, with people they trust. If a person is not safe, safety is the first work.
  • Company without pressure. Being near someone, without needing to fill the silence.
  • Practical help. Food, a lift, someone to look after children or an elderly relative, a hand with tasks. A shaken person finds ordinary jobs heavy.
  • Keeping contact. Some people are surrounded in the first days and forgotten later. A leader who comes back, in an unhurried way, in the weeks that follow does something of great value.
  • Permission to react. "Whatever you are feeling is a human way to feel after something like that."
  • An open door to prayer, never a push. Ask before praying with someone, and be ready to take "no" without comment.
  • Gentle encouragement toward help. A doctor or another professional can see what a leader cannot. "I would like you to see someone about how you have been feeling and sleeping. Would you like me to help you find the right person?"

7. What hurts

  • Asking for the story, or for details, whether out of love or out of curiosity.
  • "You should be over it by now," or any statement about how long it ought to take.
  • "At least nobody was hurt," or "at least it was not worse." The person's shock is real, whatever else might have happened.
  • "God has a purpose in this," said too soon.
  • "You must have faith that it will be all right." This lays the burden of belief on the one who is least able to carry it.
  • Telling the story to others, even in the form of a prayer request, without the person's permission.
  • Pushing the person to return at once to the usual pattern as a sign that they are "fine."

8. Faith after a shock

Anger at God, a feeling that God is far away, or silence in prayer are common human ways of facing a shock. They are also ways in which Scripture's own people face it. A leader does not correct them. A leader who hears "Where was God?" does not defend God. The leader says something like: "That is a hard question, and I do not have an answer that would be enough. I am staying with you." Honest questions to God are a form of prayer, and God is able to bear them.

A leader should also notice the opposite: a person who clings suddenly and very hard to religious words, rules or practices, or who says that God has told them to do something that seems out of character or frightening. That is not for the leader to judge or to argue with. It is a reason to keep close, to ask kindly, and to think about connecting with someone qualified. Lecture 3-3 comes back to spiritual and medical language.

9. When the shock is the leader's own, or the community's

Shocks do not only happen to individuals. A congregation may be shaken together: a death in the community, a disaster in the area, news about a respected member, a sudden loss of a building or of a leader. The leader is in the same storm as the people. A leader who is shaken may also not sleep, may be irritable, and may feel guilty for not doing more. This is not weakness. It is why the course returns, in Week 5, to the leader's own mind, and why the leader should also receive help. The course on burnout and staff care speaks to this as well.

10. Two communities, one task

(an invented example) Marsh Road Chapel has about twenty members. A frightening event happened on the road near the chapel, and nobody at the chapel was hurt. A young father, Kwame, who was close to it, has not been sleeping and is jumpy at church. The pastor, Corinne, does not ask what he saw. She sits with him one afternoon and says that he does not need to say a word about it. She asks how he is sleeping. He says: "Badly." She says that this is a hard thing to bear and that it might be worth speaking to a doctor, and offers to go with him to the first appointment if that would make it easier. She says nothing about faith being tested. In a congregation this small, the discipline is for Corinne to guard what Kwame said and not mention it in the prayer-request time.

(an invented example) Holy Redeemer Parish is a large congregation, and a sudden event has affected many families at once. The parish care team could easily become a crowd, with ten visitors all asking, and all hearing the story. The team leader, Dolores, assigns each affected household one contact person who has agreed to come back, and asks the others to leave a note instead of knocking on a door. The contact people are asked not to question anyone for the story, to offer practical help, and to tell Dolores if someone seems very much worse. They are reminded that the parish also has a list of local services, kept in advance. In a large community, the discipline is to make sure that no one is flooded or forgotten.

11. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. There is no right way to react to a shock. Reactions come at once or later, loud or quiet, and often ease with safety and care.
  2. A leader notices, and does not ask for the story. The person decides whether, when and how much to say.
  3. Sleep is a sign worth gently asking about, because it is easy to say and hard to bear.
  4. A leader gives no advice on sleep remedies or medicines and never tells anyone to change what they have been prescribed.
  5. Verses about sleep and peace are gifts, never tests. A sleepless person has not failed.
  6. Safety, company, practical help, keeping contact and an open door are what helps; asking for details and "you should be over it" hurt.
  7. Faith reactions are heard, not corrected. Where reactions seem to be wearing a person down, or a person is in danger, the leader helps them toward professionals.

Diagram 1. After a shock: what may be seen, and what the leader does

After a shock Reactions differ widely; none is a verdict What may be seen On edge, easily startled Thoughts that come back Avoiding reminders What may be seen Numbness or strong feelings Tiredness and body aches Changed sleep and faith The leader does Keeps the person safe Sits with them, no pressure Offers practical help The leader does Asks how they are sleeping Comes back in the weeks after Encourages a doctor, if wearing The leader does not Ask for the story or its details, or press the person to speak Advise on sleep remedies or medicine, or tell anyone to change it Use a verse as a test of faith. Not medical advice.

Diagram 2. Sleep: a door the person can walk through

Asking about sleep An easy question that opens a conversation Ask "How have you been sleeping?" Easier to answer than "Are you afraid?" or "Are you low?" Listen It is hard to bear It is not a failing Do not give a remedy Connect If it wears the person down or does not ease, encourage a doctor A leader never advises on medicine or tells anyone to change it

In short

  • There is no right way to react after a shock; reactions come early or late, loud or quiet, and often ease with safety and care.
  • A leader notices and does not ask for the story or its details; the person decides whether and when to speak.
  • Sleep is an easy, unshaming thing to ask about; a leader gives no remedy and never tells anyone to change medicine.
  • Verses about sleep and peace are gifts, never tests; the Bible knows sleepless nights and does not blame the sleepless.
  • Safety, company, practical help, keeping contact and an open door help; "you should be over it" hurts.
  • If reactions wear a person down or danger appears, encourage a doctor or other professional; urgent danger means emergency services.
Front Back
After a shock Reactions differ widely and are not a measure of faith or character; the leader notices, and does not label.
The story The leader does not ask for it or its details; the person decides whether and when to speak.
Sleep An easy question to ask; the leader gives no remedy and never tells anyone to change their medicine.
Verses about sleep They are gifts, not tests; a sleepless person has not failed in faith.

One sentence to remember After a shock, stay near, ask little, help with ordinary things, and come back.

This week's action Think of one household in your community that has been shaken, and write down one practical thing someone could offer and who would offer it, without asking for the story.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What does your community say about people who are "not themselves" after a frightening event? What does it say about people who seem fine?
  • Why is it a kindness not to ask for the story? When might a leader feel pressure to ask, and where does that pressure come from?
  • How might you ask someone about their sleep in a way that is natural in your setting?
  • Which verses about peace, trust or sleep have you heard used as a test? How might they be offered as a gift?
  • Which kinds of practical help would be most useful in a household that was shaken? Who in your community could offer them?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.