Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
- Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
- Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
- Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
- Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
- Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
- Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
- Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
- Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
- Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
- Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
- Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
- Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
- Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
- Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
- Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
- Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
- Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
An elder who has chaired the finance meeting for years sits through the last two meetings without speaking, and leaves quickly. A worship leader, usually full of ideas, sends a short message saying she cannot lead this month and gives no reason. A mission team leader's co-leader, whom the whole team looks to, has begun to cancel calls and answer in single words. A pastor notices that the youth leader, a younger man he mentors, looks as if he has not slept and has stopped joining the prayer before services.
Each of these is a fellow leader. They are the people who would normally be the ones to notice and help. Now they are the ones who may need it. This lecture is about that situation. It is harder than caring for a member, because roles, authority, reputation, friendship and the future of the work are all mixed in. It does not tell anyone what is wrong with a colleague. It describes how to notice, stay beside and connect when the struggling person is a leader, and how to protect both the person and the community.
The central claim of the course holds: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help. Another leader is also someone who has a mind and limits and receives help.
This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment, and it does not replace professional care.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Explain why caring for a fellow leader is different from caring for a member, and name the particular difficulties.
- Describe a first private conversation with a colleague that is kind, asks permission and avoids labels.
- Say how to protect the person's privacy and the community's trust at once.
- Describe how decisions about duties, time away and return can be made with, not about, the person.
- Distinguish a struggle of mind or mood from misconduct, and say what to do if the two are tangled.
- Explain what a small or isolated community can do when there is no one else to turn to.
When one member suffers, all the members suffer with it. Or when one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it." — 1 Corinthians 12:26
World English Bible
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9
WEB
For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:10
WEB
We exhort you, brothers, admonish the disorderly, encourage the faint-hearted, support the weak, be patient toward all." — 1 Thessalonians 5:14
WEB
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5
WEB
So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13
WEB
The body of Christ is pictured as one body in which, when one member suffers, all the members suffer with it (1 Corinthians 12:26). That includes the members who lead. Paul asks us to bear one another's burdens (Galatians 6:2), to encourage the faint-hearted and support the weak (1 Thessalonians 5:14). The preacher in Ecclesiastes says that if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow, and warns of the person who is alone when he falls (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10). Proverbs speaks of wise guidance and of counsel like deep water, drawn out by a person of understanding (Proverbs 11:14, 20:5). Job's friends, at their best, sat on the ground and said nothing for seven days (Job 2:13). A leader who struggles has a claim on all of this.
Why a fellow leader is different
When the struggling person is a member of the congregation, the leader's role is plain: notice, stay beside, connect. When the struggling person is a fellow leader, several things become tangled.
- Roles and authority. The colleague may be the leader's senior, or junior, or equal, or the leader's own pastor, mentor, employer or friend. The one who notices may be the one who answers to the person.
- Reputation. A leader is trusted, and may fear that the community's trust will be lost if the struggle is known. The colleagues may fear it too.
- Duties. The colleague has people who rely on them: a pulpit, a ministry, a team, a budget. Their struggle touches others.
- Friendship. Colleagues are often friends, and friendship can make it easier to speak or harder.
- Privacy. A leader's difficulty may be quickly noticed and quickly talked about. A community is hungry for news of its leaders.
- Silence. As lecture 5-2 explained, many leaders hide. The one in difficulty may deny it kindly and firmly.
- Fear on both sides. The colleague who notices may be afraid of offending, of being wrong, or of becoming responsible. The one struggling may be afraid of being replaced.
- Small places. In a house church, a mission team or a single-pastor congregation there may be no one else to ask.
None of these is a reason to look away. They are reasons to act with care.
The first private conversation
If you notice a change in a fellow leader, the first step is a quiet word, in private, soon, and kind. The earlier it is, the easier it usually is. This is lecture 4-1 applied to a colleague. A few principles.
Choose a place and a time. A private place where you will not be interrupted, not after a meeting in a corridor, and not in front of others. Allow enough time. Do not choose a moment when the person is about to preach or to chair.
Ask permission. "I have noticed something and I care about you. May I ask you about it?" If the answer is no, accept it, and say that the door is open.
Say what you have seen, not what you think it means. "You have been quiet in the last meetings, and I wondered how you are." Not: "I think you are depressed" or "you are burnt out" or "you are in sin". No labels. A leader is not a diagnostician.
Ask, then listen. "How are you, really?" Then wait. Do not fill the silence. Do not argue, fix or explain. Proverbs 18:13 is as true here as anywhere: to give answer before hearing is folly and shame.
Receive a denial gracefully. "I am fine" may be true, may be a way of protecting oneself, or may be a first test of whether you can be trusted. Say, "All right. I am here if you want to talk, and I will ask again." Then do ask again, in a few weeks, gently.
Do not make promises you cannot keep. Do not promise absolute secrecy. Say what you will keep private and the limits: "I will not repeat what you tell me without telling you first. If I believed someone was in danger, I could not keep silent, and there may be duties under the law or under our church's rules. I will check what applies." This is the principle in lecture 4-4: check locally.
Offer something small and specific. "Would you like me to take Thursday's meeting?" "Could I come with you to see someone, if you decide to?"
Do not pray at the person. Offer prayer, and ask if they want it. A prayer that is really a rebuke is a weapon.
Do not turn it into a verdict. If the person says they are struggling, do not say they must stop leading, and do not say they must carry on. Say, "Thank you for telling me. What would help?"
Connecting a leader to help
A leader may be better placed than most members to find help, and also less willing. A few ways in which connecting is different.
- Care from outside. A colleague in the same congregation or team may not be the right person to give care, because they work together and share the community. The person may prefer to see someone away from the congregation. This is not a rejection of the colleague.
- A doctor or other proper professional is the right place to start for the struggle itself. The colleague helps the person reach one, offers to come to the appointment, and does not ask what was said.
- A person from the denomination, the agency or the wider network may help with the work side: time away, cover, and support. Many churches and agencies have a person for this. Find out what yours has, in advance: check locally.
- The person's own tradition's spiritual care, such as a confessor, a spiritual guide, an from another church, may be an additional help alongside professional care. It does not replace it.
- The person's family may already know and may be carrying a great deal (lecture 5-1). They are not there to be reported to, but to be remembered.
The colleague never tells the person to stop or change any medicine or treatment. That belongs to the person's own prescriber or treating professional.
Who needs to know?
The hardest question is often: who else should be told? There is no one answer, but there are guides.
- Start with the person. Ask them who knows, who they want to know, and what they would like said. Most leaders, once asked, will have a view.
- Tell as few people as the work needs. A small group of trusted leaders, such as one or two elders or board members, may need to know that a colleague needs time, without knowing why.
- Say as little as is needed about the reason. "He is unwell and is taking some time" is true, kind and enough. The congregation does not need details. A rumour fills any silence, so the community should be told simply and early what it needs to know about cover and care, and what it does not.
- Do not use the news for anything else. Not for discussion of the person's future, not for politics, not for a warning. Do not use it to settle old arguments.
- Never promise absolute secrecy. If the matter involves danger to someone, or the law requires a report, you cannot keep silent. Rules differ by country, region and role: check locally.
- Write down only what is needed, and keep it where only the right people may see it.
Decisions about duties
A common mistake is to decide for the person, quickly, without asking. Another is to wait until the community is in crisis. A better path is steady and shared.
- Make decisions with the person, not about them. "What would help? Do you want to carry on, lighten the load, or take time away?"
- Offer cover without strings. Cover for a service, a meeting or a pastoral round is a gift, not a charge.
- Keep it temporary unless the person and their professionals say otherwise. "Until we all agree it is time to review."
- Review gently. Ask, "How are you finding it?" at a time agreed in advance. Let the person set the pace of return.
- Protect the person's standing. Time away for care is not discipline. A community should be able to say, with respect, "He is taking time to look after himself, and we are grateful for his service."
- Welcome the person back without conditions of shame and without requiring a public account.
- Think about the work too. A ministry or a team cannot be left empty. Sharing duties (lecture 5-3) is the practical side of care.
This lecture does not say whether a particular leader should stay in post. That belongs to the person, their professionals and the people responsible under the church's own rules.
When it is tangled with misconduct
A struggle of mind or mood is not misconduct. Misconduct, such as harm to another person, abuse of trust, or misuse of money, is not excused by a struggle, and it is not a mental-health matter. If a colleague's behaviour has harmed or may harm someone, especially a child or a vulnerable person, the safety of the person harmed comes first. The course on safe church and child protection and the course on ministers' own ethics set out what must be done, and reporting duties differ by country, region and role: check locally. A leader should not hold such a matter alone, and should not wait to see if it settles.
It is also possible that the two are mixed: a person who is struggling has done something wrong. A community must then hold two things together. The person's struggle gets care. The harm done gets attention, with proper process. Neither cancels the other. Do not use a person's difficulty as an excuse to avoid dealing with harm, and do not use harm as a reason to avoid caring for the person.
If a colleague's trouble includes thoughts of harming themselves or of not wanting to live, do not leave them alone, and contact emergency services if there is danger now. The course on crisis, suicide and trauma response teaches what to do.
Small, isolated and unusual settings
(an invented example) Cresswell Lane House Church meets in a home, with a leader, Anselm, and about a dozen members. When Anselm's quiet withdrawal worries the group, there is no elder and no board. A member, Dilnoza, who does not lead, asks to speak with him. He says he does not know who he would tell. Dilnoza offers to ask the pastor of a larger church in the district, whom she knows, whether he would be willing to meet Anselm, and Anselm agrees. The group agrees to share the hosting, and says to each other, "He is tired, and we are helping."
(an invented example) In a large church with a paid staff, a senior associate, Tobias, tells the senior pastor privately that he has not been well. The senior pastor listens, thanks him, and asks what he would like said and to whom. The two agree on a short note to the staff team. The pastor then asks the church's board chair, in confidence, for guidance on leave. Tobias sees a doctor, and the staff cover some of his duties. When he returns, he does so first for half-days, which he chooses.
(an invented example) Nomvula is the director of a small non-profit that trains volunteers. Her deputy, Henryk, has changed in recent weeks. The board chair, who has little time, tells Nomvula to "sort it out". Nomvula says she will speak with Henryk, but asks the board chair to write down what the organisation offers to staff in time of difficulty, so that she is not inventing it. She finds that there is nothing. She asks the board to begin one.
In an immigrant congregation a leader's struggle may be known by the whole community, and the family may bear shame in two cultures. In a mission team in a far place the leader may have no peers nearby. In each setting the same steps hold: a quiet word, permission, no labels, offer a way to a proper professional, tell as few as needed, decide with the person, and welcome them back. Distance can be bridged by phone or video, with the person's consent.
Two mistakes among leaders
The two mistakes return. The first treats a leader's struggle as only a spiritual failing: "a leader should have more faith", "the person has lost their anointing". That is not a kindness and it is not Scripture. The second leaves out the spiritual: the colleague is handed to a clinic and the community never mentions them again. Both leave a person alone. A leader who struggles still has a faith and a community, and needs both prayer and proper care.
What a leader takes from this lecture
- A fellow leader is harder to help, because roles, reputation, duties, friendship and privacy are mixed in.
- Begin with a private word: ask permission, say what you have seen and not what you think it means, listen, accept a denial, and do not promise absolute secrecy.
- Connect the person to a doctor or proper professional, to care from outside the congregation and to support from the church or agency.
- Tell as few as the work needs and say as little as possible about the reason; decide with the person.
- Keep struggle and misconduct apart: each gets its own response, and safety of anyone harmed comes first.
- Small and isolated settings can still find someone outside, by phone or visit.
5-1. Why a fellow leader is different
5-2. From a private word to a shared plan
In short
- Caring for a fellow leader is harder than caring for a member because roles, reputation, duties, friendship and privacy are mixed in; none of this is a reason to look away.
- The first step is a private word that asks permission, says what you have seen, uses no labels, listens, accepts a denial, and promises no absolute secrecy.
- Connecting means a doctor or proper professional, care from outside the congregation, and support from the church or agency; no one advises changing a medicine or treatment.
- Tell as few people as the work needs, say as little as possible about the reason, and make decisions with the person, not about them.
- A struggle of mind or mood is not misconduct, and misconduct is not excused by a struggle; the safety of anyone harmed comes first, and each gets its own response.
- Small and isolated communities can look outside for help, by phone or by visit.
- This course is not medical or psychological advice and does not replace professional care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First step with a colleague | A private word: ask permission, say what you saw, no labels, listen, accept a denial, no absolute secrecy. |
| Who needs to know | Ask the person first; tell as few as the work needs; say as little about the reason as you can. |
| Decisions about duties | Made with the person; cover without strings; temporary; reviewed gently; return without shame. |
| Struggle and misconduct | Kept apart: care for the struggle, process for harm, and safety first for anyone harmed. |
One sentence to remember A leader who struggles is still a member of the one body, and the body suffers with them.
This week's action Ask yourself, without names, who in your community would notice if a leader were struggling, and who the leader could safely tell. Write one step that would make that safer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your community, what happens when a leader goes quiet? Think of customs and rumours, without any names.
- Which of the difficulties listed here would be strongest in your setting: authority, reputation, friendship, privacy, a small place?
- How would you begin a private conversation with a colleague? What would you say that names what you saw but not what you think it means?
- Who, in your setting, should know that a leader needs time away, and who should not? What can be said so that rumour has no room?
- Cresswell Lane, the large church and the non-profit are very different. Which is closest to yours, and what is the first small change that would make a fellow leader safer to speak?