FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

ST1E Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

Lecture 6-5: Social Trinitarianism and Its Critics

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 46
ST1E Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What the Doctrine of God Is, and Why It Comes First
  1. Introduction: What the Doctrine of God Is, and Why It Comes First
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Prolegomena: Revelation, Religious Language, and the Knowledge of God
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Proper Comes First
  2. Lecture 1-2: Calvin's Opening Move — Knowledge of God and Knowledge of Self
  3. Lecture 1-3: General and Special Revelation
  4. Lecture 1-4: Religious Language and Its Limits
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Existence of God: Arguments and Their Critics
  1. Lecture 2-1: Can God's Existence Be Proved? Setting the Terms
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Cosmological Argument — From the World to a First Cause
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Teleological and Moral Arguments
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Ontological Argument — From Concept to Necessary Existence
  5. Lecture 2-5: Presuppositionalism and Contemporary Atheism
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Incommunicable Attributes of God
  1. Lecture 3-1: Classifying the Attributes, and Divine Simplicity
  2. Lecture 3-2: Aseity and Independence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Immutability and Impassibility
  4. Lecture 3-4: Infinity, Eternity, and God's Relation to Time
  5. Lecture 3-5: Omnipresence
  6. Lecture 3-6: The Unity of God
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Communicable Attributes and the Names of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Omniscience — God's Exhaustive and Personal Knowledge
  2. Lecture 4-2: Wisdom and Faithfulness — Knowledge Ordered and Kept
  3. Lecture 4-3: Holiness and Righteousness — Otherness and Moral Purity
  4. Lecture 4-4: Goodness, Love, Grace, and Mercy — Four Related but Distinct Attributes
  5. Lecture 4-5: Sovereignty and Omnipotence — What "God Can Do All Things" Actually Means
  6. Lecture 4-6: The Revealed Names of God — Self-Disclosure Through Covenant History
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Trinity I: Biblical Foundations and Historical Formation
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Biblical Foundations of the Trinity
  2. Lecture 5-2: Early Heresies — Monarchianism, Adoptionism, and Modalism
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Cappadocian Fathers and the Council of Constantinople
  5. Lecture 5-5: Augustine's Trinitarian Theology and the Filioque Controversy
  6. Lecture 5-6: East and West Compared — Two Starting Points
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Trinity II: Orthodox Doctrine and Modern Debates
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Immanent Trinity and the Economic Trinity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Perichoresis — Mutual Indwelling of the Divine Persons
  3. Lecture 6-3: Eternal Generation and Eternal Procession
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Twentieth-Century Revival of Trinitarian Theology
  5. Lecture 6-5: Social Trinitarianism and Its Critics
  6. Lecture 6-6: Contemporary Debates over Trinitarian Language
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Contemporary Challenges to the Doctrine of God
  1. Lecture 7-1: Process Theology — A God Who Grows With the World
  2. Lecture 7-2: Open Theism and the Future God Does Not Yet Know
  3. Lecture 7-3: Moltmann's Crucified God and the Question of Divine Suffering
  4. Lecture 7-4: Panentheism, Ecology, and the Creator/Creature Distinction
  5. Lecture 7-5: Contemporary Science and the Doctrine of God
  6. Lecture 7-6: Answering Postmodernism and the New Atheism
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Decrees, Creation, Providence, and Pastoral Application
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Divine Decrees and Predestination
  2. Lecture 8-2: Calvinism, Arminianism, and Molinism on the Decrees
  3. Lecture 8-3: Creation Out of Nothing, and the Age of the Earth
  4. Lecture 8-4: Providence — Preservation, Concurrence, Government, and Miracle
  5. Lecture 8-5: The Problem of Evil and Theodicy
  6. Lecture 8-6: Conclusion — Knowing God, Not Only Knowing About Him

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

The twentieth-century revival Lecture 6-4 described did not stay confined to Barth's and Rahner's own proposals. One of its most influential and most contested developments is what has come to be called social Trinitarianism: the proposal, developed at length by the German Reformed theologian Jürgen Moltmann and, in a related but distinct form, by the Croatian theologian Miroslav Volf, that the three divine persons' relational distinctness — their mutual love, mutual self-giving, and equality-in-relation — should function as a genuine model for human community, church life, and even social and political order. Social Trinitarianism has real theological force and real pastoral appeal: it takes seriously the New Testament's own move (examined in this lecture's scripture passage) of grounding human unity directly in the Father-Son relation, and it has been used to resource arguments for equality-in-difference within marriage, church leadership, and society against both flattening uniformity and oppressive hierarchy. It has also drawn serious, sustained criticism — not from theological conservatives dismissing it out of hand, but from theologians, including Karen Kilby, working carefully through what the proposal actually requires and arguing that it risks two different failures: tritheism (treating the three persons as separate enough to model three cooperating human agents) and a subtler danger of reading contemporary social ideals back into the doctrine of God rather than deriving them from revelation.

This lecture states social Trinitarianism's strongest form before turning to its critics, in keeping with this course's discipline of giving a live, contested position its best form before evaluating it.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • State social Trinitarianism's central claim and identify Jürgen Moltmann and Miroslav Volf as its leading representatives, noting one respect in which their projects differ.
  • Explain the biblical warrant social Trinitarians appeal to, particularly John 17:20-23, and state why they read it as more than a loose analogy.
  • State Karen Kilby's central criticism of social Trinitarianism in its own terms, distinguishing the tritheism worry from the "projection" worry as two distinct, though related, objections.
  • Explain why this debate cannot be resolved simply by appeal to orthodoxy, since both sides claim to be defending, not revising, the classical doctrine.

Not for these only do I pray, but for those also who believe in me through their word, that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be one in us; that the world may know that you sent me. The glory which you have given me, I have given to them; that they may be one, even as we are one; I in them, and you in me, that they may be perfected into one; that the world may know that you sent me, and loved them, even as you loved me." — John 17:20-23

World English Bible

This passage is the single most important biblical text social Trinitarians appeal to, and it is worth reading closely rather than skimming for the word "one." Jesus does not merely pray that his followers would be unified in the ordinary sense of getting along; he prays that their unity would be patterned on, and in some sense drawn into, the Father-Son relation itself — "that they also may be one in us," "even as we are one." The passage moves from mutual indwelling within the Godhead (Lecture 6-2's ) to human unity modeled on, and even participating in, that same relation, and states a further purpose: "that the world may know that you sent me, and loved them" — the church's unity is meant to be evidence, visible to outsiders, of something true about God. Social Trinitarians read this passage as doing exactly the theological work they claim: grounding human community directly in the 's own relational life, not merely comparing the two loosely.

1. The strongest form of the claim

Jürgen Moltmann, writing extensively from the 1980s onward (most centrally in The Trinity and the Kingdom), argues that the classical Western tradition, following Augustine's tendency (Chapter 5, Lecture 5-5) to start theological reflection from the single divine essence and treat the three persons as, in a sense, modifications or relations within that one essence, had allowed a subtly monarchical, even monolithic, picture of God to dominate Western theology — a picture Moltmann connects (controversially) to the historical entanglement of monotheism with political absolutism, a single sovereign ruling as the single God rules. Against this, Moltmann proposes recovering what he takes to be a more properly Trinitarian, and more properly biblical, picture: three persons in genuine, loving, non-hierarchical relation, whose unity consists precisely in that relation (their perichoretic love for one another) rather than in an abstract, prior "essence" underlying and explaining away their threeness. On this reading, God's own life just is a community of persons in mutual self-giving love — and if that is what God's own life is like, then human community, particularly the church, and by extension marriage and even broader social and political arrangements, should be patterned after relational equality-in-difference rather than after hierarchical models that place one member permanently over the others.

Miroslav Volf, in After Our Likeness, develops a related but more carefully bounded project, focused specifically on ecclesiology: arguing that a congregation's own structure — how authority, gifts, and mutual submission are distributed among its members — should take its bearings from the Trinity's perichoretic pattern of mutual indwelling and mutual honoring, against ecclesiologies (Volf specifically engages both Catholic and Eastern Orthodox models) that ground church unity in a single office (the papacy, or the bishop) understood as reflecting a more monarchical picture of the Godhead. It is worth noting that Volf's project is narrower and more textually cautious than Moltmann's broader social-political claims — a distinction worth preserving rather than treating "social Trinitarianism" as one undifferentiated position with one spokesman.

The biblical case, as John 17:20-23 above illustrates, is not negligible: Jesus himself draws a direct line from the Father-Son "in us" relation to the unity his followers are to have "even as we are one." Social Trinitarians argue this is exactly the kind of textual warrant that should make a reader take the Trinity-as-model-for-community claim seriously rather than treating it as a modern imposition on ancient texts.

2. This is a point where readers will not agree

Karen Kilby, in an influential and widely cited article ("Perichoresis and Projection: Problems with Social Doctrines of the Trinity," 2000) and later work, presses two distinct objections that deserve to be kept separate, because a defender of social Trinitarianism can concede one while resisting the other.

The first objection is closer to a straightforward doctrinal concern: tritheism risk. If the three persons are described primarily as three centers of loving relation — three "wills," three "consciousnesses," in the more socially vivid versions of the proposal — the description begins to sound less like one being in three persons and more like three beings in intimate relationship, which is precisely the boundary Lecture 6-2's perichoresis was built to police. Kilby does not claim every social Trinitarian actually crosses this line, but she argues the rhetoric of "three persons in loving community" as a model for human community only does the moral and social work social Trinitarians want it to do if the three persons are vivid and distinct enough to be genuinely analogous to three human persons in relationship — and that vividness is exactly what risks compromising the doctrine's insistence on one undivided essence.

The second, subtler objection is about method, and Kilby regards it as the more serious of the two: she argues that theologians typically do not actually derive their social and political commitments (equality, mutuality, non-hierarchy) from careful reflection on the doctrine of the Trinity as classically stated; rather, they bring independently-held social and ethical commitments to the doctrine and then find the Trinity a congenial, prestigious-sounding place to ground them, because "this is how God himself is" carries more rhetorical weight than "this seems like a good way for people to live." If Kilby is right about this direction of dependence, social Trinitarianism's argument has the appearance of deriving ethics from theology while actually doing the reverse — projecting a prior ethical commitment onto an inherently mysterious and only partially comprehensible aspect of God's inner life (recall Lecture 6-3's honest admission of the limits of what can positively be said about the divine relations) and then treating the result as revealed truth rather than as what it actually is: a human ideal given theological cover.

Moltmann and Volf, and other social Trinitarians, have responded to versions of both objections: against the tritheism charge, they typically insist they affirm the classical doctrine of one undivided essence in full and mean their "social" language as an emphasis, drawn from within, rather than a revision from without, of that doctrine — the persons' perichoretic unity, not merely their cooperation, is exactly what grounds the human analogy, they would argue, not a departure from it. Against Kilby's projection charge, defenders respond that Scripture's own move in John 17 (grounding human unity directly in the Father-Son relation) legitimates drawing ethical and ecclesial conclusions from the Trinity, and that the charge of "projection" could in principle be leveled at any use of any doctrine to inform ethics, proving too much if pressed consistently.

3. Where this leaves the reader

Strengths and cautions

This is one of the more actively contested points in contemporary systematic theology, and it will not do to declare Moltmann, Volf, or Kilby simply right or simply wrong. What can be said honestly is this: social Trinitarianism has genuine biblical warrant (John 17:20-23) and identifies something real that a purely abstract, essence-first account of the Trinity can obscure — namely, that the New Testament itself treats the Trinity's relational life as bearing directly on how the church should live together. Kilby's cautions are equally serious and are not raised by theological conservatives hostile to the doctrine's development, but by theologians working from within the same broad, orthodox commitment to Nicene Trinitarianism, worried that a genuinely good pastoral and ethical instinct is being carried by an argument that overstates what can be known, and safely derived, from the doctrine of the .


Social Trinitarianism: Claim and Criticism Moltmann / Volf Trinity's perichoretic love models human community Warrant: John 17:20-23 "that they also may be one in us" Equality-in-difference, not hierarchy or uniformity Karen Kilby's two objections 1. Tritheism risk Vivid "three persons" language strains one undivided essence 2. Projection risk Ethics may be read onto God, not derived from him Both sides claim to defend, not revise, Nicene orthodoxy

5. Going to the Sources

  • Jürgen Moltmann, The Trinity and the Kingdom (1981), especially the introduction and chapter 5, where he lays out the critique of "monotheism" as politically entangled and proposes the social alternative in his own words.
  • Karen Kilby, "Perichoresis and Projection: Problems with Social Doctrines of the Trinity," New Blackfriars 81 (2000) — read the article itself for the fuller, more careful form of the two objections this lecture summarizes.

In short

  • Social Trinitarianism holds that the three persons' mutual love and equality should be a model for human community, church life and society. Jürgen Moltmann and Miroslav Volf are its leading voices.
  • Moltmann fears that starting from one divine essence encourages a monarchical picture of God. He locates God's unity in the persons' loving relation.
  • Volf's project is narrower. He applies the Trinity's pattern of mutual indwelling to church structure, in contrast with models built on a single office.
  • The main biblical warrant is John 17:20-23, where Jesus prays that believers may be one "even as we are one."
  • Karen Kilby raises two objections. Vivid "three persons" language risks tritheism, and ethical ideals may be projected onto God rather than derived from him.
  • Both sides claim to defend Nicene orthodoxy. The lecture declares no winner.

Topic: This lecture presents social Trinitarianism at its strongest and then sets out Karen Kilby's two criticisms of it.

Remember: Social Trinitarians draw on John 17 to say that the Trinity's relational life bears on how the church lives together.

Caution: Kilby's worries come from within Nicene orthodoxy. Moltmann and Volf are not the same, so her criticisms may not fall equally on both.

One line to carry into ministry: When you say "the church should be like the Trinity," ask whether Scripture teaches it or whether you brought the idea to the text.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • State social Trinitarianism's central claim in one or two sentences, then state Kilby's "projection" objection in one or two sentences. Are these two claims actually incompatible, or could a theologian hold a modest version of both?
  • John 17:20-23 grounds human unity in the Father-Son relation. How much theological weight do you think a single, densely theological prayer of Jesus's can bear for building a broader social and political model, as Moltmann attempts? Defend your answer.
  • This lecture distinguished Volf's narrower ecclesiological project from Moltmann's broader social-political claims. Why does that distinction matter when evaluating Kilby's criticism — does her objection apply equally to both, or more to one than the other?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.