FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL2E Modern Theology › Review by summary

Review by summary

All 40 lectures of STEL2E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.

Try to recall each summary from the title before revealing it. It stays with you far longer than re-reading does.

Chapter 0 Introduction: What Is Modern Theology, and Why Study It?

Show summary
  • "Modern theology" is a period label for theology written after the Enlightenment's challenges about reason, history and the authority of ancient texts. It is not a compliment or an insult.
  • Some modern theologians revised doctrine to fit Enlightenment ideas. Others rejected those ideas and defended doctrine on new grounds. Most did something more complicated.
  • Colossians 2:8 warns against a philosophy that replaces Christ. 2 Corinthians 10:5 speaks of taking every thought captive to Christ. The course holds real warning and real engagement together.
  • The twelve chapters run roughly in historical order, from the Enlightenment through liberal theology, neo-orthodoxy, reconstructions of God's nature, and theology from many places, to the newest frontiers.
  • The course is a history of doctrine, not a systematic theology. It states disagreements fairly and does not cover the patristic, medieval or Reformation periods.
  • The course includes Vatican II, Rahner, von Balthasar, Zizioulas and global-South theology as major developments, not as footnotes to a German Protestant story.

Topic: This lecture explains what "modern theology" means as a historical period, how the course is organised, and why it tells a wider story than usual.

Remember: "Modern" here names a period beginning with the Enlightenment, not a position. Colossians 2:8 and 2 Corinthians 10:5 together ask for discernment, not for avoiding philosophy.

Caution: The course does not give its own settled view on doctrines, and it does not treat "modern" as meaning either "correct" or "compromised."

One line to carry into ministry: When a new idea arrives, ask what it gained and what it may have lost, and do not simply accept or reject it.

Chapter 1 Chapter 1: The Enlightenment Challenge

Show summary
  • Before the seventeenth century, theologians argued within an inherited order of authority: Scripture, then tradition, creeds and councils, then reasoning. A claim did not have to re-justify its own foundation.
  • Descartes doubted everything that could be doubted. The act of doubting proved a thinker existed: "I think, therefore I am." He then tried to rebuild knowledge, including knowledge of God.
  • Locke argued that no idea is innate. The mind begins as a blank slate, and all knowledge comes from sense experience and reflection on it. He still argued that Christianity is reasonable.
  • Neither man meant to weaken theology. Both thought they were strengthening its foundations.
  • Both placed the start of secure knowledge in the individual knower. A claim now had to pass that individual's own examination, as well as being taught by Scripture or the church.

Topic: This lecture shows how Descartes and Locke moved the starting point of knowledge from inherited authority to the individual reasoning subject.

Remember: Different methods, same shift: a claim's credentials are checked by the individual knower, not only received from the community that hands it down.

Caution: The lecture does not say Descartes or Locke attacked Christianity. It calls that reading a caricature, since both meant to support theology.

One line to carry into ministry: Expect people to ask for reasons they can examine themselves, and help them as Scripture and tradition invite, without treating the question as hostile.

Show summary
  • Kant answered both rationalists and empiricists by asking what structures the mind itself brings to any experience, such as space, time and causality.
  • He divided reality into the phenomenal (what can appear in possible experience) and the noumenal (things as they are in themselves). God, the soul and the world as a whole are noumenal.
  • So pure reason cannot produce knowledge of them. Kant did not say they do not exist, and he did not say reason had disproved anything.
  • He judged the ontological, cosmological and teleological arguments to fail as proofs. He still treated the teleological one with respect.
  • Kant grounded religion in practical reason: freedom, the soul's persistence and God are postulates the moral life requires. Schleiermacher and others built on this closing-off, while reformed epistemology later argued against it.

Topic: This lecture explains Kant's critique of pure reason, why it closed the classical proofs of God as knowledge claims, and his moral alternative for religion.

Remember: Kant's claim is narrow: arguments that move from within experience to what lies outside it cannot give the certainty a proof requires.

Caution: Kant did not claim God does not exist. The lecture also leaves open whether he agrees with Isaiah 55:8-9 or conflicts with Romans 1:19-20.

One line to carry into ministry: Failing to prove God by argument is not the same as showing God is unreal, and Christians can hold their faith on other grounds.

Show summary
  • Hegel rejected Kant's fixed boundary. For him reality is a developing process, which he called Geist (Spirit or Mind), and it comes to full self-knowledge only through history.
  • The dialectic describes how this happens: a thesis meets its tensions (antithesis) and is resolved in a synthesis that becomes a new starting point.
  • Hegel saw Christianity as the highest historical religion. The incarnation shows in story form (representation) what his philosophy states in concepts: the infinite and the finite are united.
  • This made doctrine look like something with its own history, open to the question of what produced a given formulation. Hegel himself meant it as a defence of Christian doctrine.
  • His students split. Right Hegelians saw an ally of orthodoxy. Left Hegelians such as Strauss and Feuerbach saw doctrine as a human product. Scholars still defend both readings of Hegel.

Topic: This lecture explains Hegel's view that reality and doctrine develop through history, and why readers disagreed about whether this defended or dissolved orthodoxy.

Remember: Hegel gave theologians a habit of asking how a doctrine developed historically, and that habit leads straight into the crisis of historicism in chapter 2.

Caution: Hegel did not intend to reduce doctrine to a merely human product. The lecture does not decide whether his system defends or dissolves Christian orthodoxy.

One line to carry into ministry: Studying how a doctrine developed is not the same as denying that it is true, but ask what is left unchanging about God and Christ.

Chapter 2 Chapter 2: Nineteenth-Century Liberal Theology

Show summary
  • Schleiermacher is usually called the first to answer Kant fully. He accepted Kant's limits on theoretical reason and argued that religion was never a form of metaphysical knowledge or a moral code.
  • He placed religion's root in the "feeling of absolute dependence," a constant self-awareness that one's very existence rests on something beyond all finite causes. He called this God-consciousness.
  • Because feeling reports the self's awareness and makes no claim about God as an external object, he thought it was beyond Kant's critique.
  • In The Christian Faith he redescribed doctrine as the church's description of its own God-consciousness shaped by Jesus. Sin is an obstructed God-consciousness. Christ's uniqueness is the unbroken power of his God-consciousness, stated without Chalcedon's two-natures language.
  • Critics, including Barth, said this makes theology a branch of anthropology and cannot secure what is distinctively Christian. Defenders such as Crouter and Gerrish reply that Barth's lens distorts Schleiermacher. The dispute remains open.

Topic: This lecture presents Schleiermacher's answer to Kant, which grounds religion in the feeling of absolute dependence, and the criticisms of that move.

Remember: Schleiermacher moved theology's foundation from proofs and doctrines to the believer's own God-consciousness. This is a serious relocation of the foundation, not a retreat.

Caution: The lecture says he did not mean to demote Christ, and it does not settle whether his method can secure what is specifically Christian.

One line to carry into ministry: Faith includes lived awareness of God, but ask whether that awareness alone can carry the specific content of Christian teaching about Christ.

Show summary
  • Ritschl and Harnack answered the problem Schleiermacher left open. They found what is distinctively Christian in Jesus's own recoverable ethical teaching, not in universal feeling.
  • Ritschl reframed the kingdom of God as an ethical community organised by love. He treated justification and reconciliation as a new ethical relationship with God.
  • Harnack named the "essence" of Christianity as the fatherhood of God, the infinite value of the human soul, and the kingdom as a moral ideal.
  • Harnack's Hellenization thesis said later doctrine, especially Nicene Christology, recast Jesus's message in Greek metaphysical terms and obscured it.
  • Schweitzer said the "essence" looked like nineteenth-century liberal ethics and ignored the Gospels' apocalyptic material. Orthodox critics said John 1:14 already carries metaphysical weight. Historians still debate this.

Topic: This lecture explains how Ritschl and Harnack tried to separate the essence of Christianity from later accretions, and how critics from two sides challenged that method.

Remember: Their project solved Schleiermacher's problem by pointing to Jesus's own teaching, but it relied on historical method to separate essential kernel from later husk.

Caution: The lecture does not say Harnack was dishonest, and it does not decide how much of Nicene Christology was development and how much was importation.

One line to carry into ministry: Be wary of any "simple Jesus" that happens to match our own era's values, and read the Gospels' whole range of language, including future hope.

Show summary
  • Troeltsch took the historical-critical method of Ritschl and Harnack and applied it without exception, to Christianity as to Buddhism, Islam or any other religion.
  • He named three principles: criticism (historical judgments are only probable), analogy (the past is judged by patterns seen now, so a miracle such as a bodily resurrection cannot rest on a text alone), and correlation (every event is tied to its context).
  • Applied consistently, historical method alone cannot certify Christianity as uniquely or finally true. This is the crisis of historicism, and it came from inside liberal theology.
  • Troeltsch proposed that Christianity is valid "for us," not abandoned and not absolute. Orthodox critics said this concedes too much, and thorough relativists said it was inconsistent.
  • This crisis helps explain Barth's neo-orthodoxy, which grounds revelation in God's free self-disclosure, something historical method cannot judge.

Topic: This lecture explains Troeltsch's principles of historical method and the crisis they create for any claim that Christianity is uniquely or absolutely true.

Remember: Troeltsch was a believing theologian following liberal theology's own method to its honest conclusion, not an outside attacker.

Caution: Troeltsch did not conclude that faith should be abandoned. The lecture states both criticisms of his "valid for us" position and declares no winner.

One line to carry into ministry: History can describe and compare, but it cannot by itself confirm the confession that God acted in Christ, so be clear about what kind of claim we are making.

Chapter 3 Chapter 3: Neo-Orthodoxy — Barth and Brunner

Show summary
  • Before 1914, German liberal Protestantism was confident that Christian faith and the moral progress of modern civilisation advanced together. The lecture notes this was not true of every liberal theologian.
  • In October 1914, ninety-three intellectuals signed the Manifesto of the Ninety-Three defending Germany's war conduct. Several of Barth's admired teachers were among them.
  • Barth judged that the failure lay in his teachers' theological method, which offered no brake against identifying a nation's war policy with God's will, not only in their politics.
  • His commentary on Romans (1919, rewritten 1922) declared God "wholly other" (ganz andere), infinitely distinct from every human religious or cultural achievement. God crosses the gap from God's side.
  • Historians caution that 1914 was a catalyst, not the sole cause. Barth's pastoral work at Safenwil had already unsettled him. Neo-orthodoxy was neither a return to pre-modern orthodoxy nor a continuation of liberalism.

Topic: This lecture shows how the First World War and the Manifesto of the Ninety-Three led Barth to break with liberal theology and proclaim God as wholly other.

Remember: Barth's complaint was about method: a theology resting on human capacities had no resource to resist blessing a nation's war.

Caution: Do not treat 1914 as the single cause. The lecture calls it a catalyst that made a forming break public. Neo-orthodoxy was not a simple return to the past.

One line to carry into ministry: Be careful never to equate our nation's or culture's cause with the will of God.

Show summary
  • After the break with liberalism, Barth built a constructive theology in the unfinished Church Dogmatics. Its governing claim is that revelation is God's own free self-disclosure in Jesus Christ, not a human discovery.
  • This stands against Schleiermacher, who began with universal religious feeling. The lecture grants that Schleiermacher chose his starting point to solve a real problem.
  • Barth does not deny that people have religious experiences. He denies that these are revelation, and he treats human religion as an attempt to reach God from the human side.
  • Because Christ is the starting point, even the doctrines of God and election are worked out from him. In Church Dogmatics II/2, Jesus Christ is both the electing God and the elected human being.
  • The Word has three forms, revealed, written and proclaimed, in strict order. Critics say Barth struggles to engage other religions, general experience and historical criticism. Defenders say that criticism assumes the standard Barth denies.

Topic: This lecture explains Barth's mature theology of the Word, in which all Christian doctrine begins from God's self-revelation in Jesus Christ.

Remember: For Barth, revelation has one door, and it opens from God's side: God makes himself known in Christ, and human reason or religion does not reach him.

Caution: Barth does not deny that human religious experience exists. Some evangelical readers worry his event-centred view of Scripture weakens biblical authority. The debate over his critics is unresolved.

One line to carry into ministry: Begin preaching and teaching from what God has made known in Christ, and not from what we think we can reach by ourselves.

Show summary
  • Barth and Brunner were allies who rejected liberal method and agreed that God's decisive self-revelation is in Christ. Their 1934 dispute was a rupture between friends over one question: natural theology.
  • Brunner's "Nature and Grace" argued that fallen humans keep a formal "point of contact" (Anknüpfungspunkt), a bare capacity to be addressed. He gave theological, scriptural (Romans 1:19-20) and pastoral reasons.
  • Barth's reply, "No!", said even a formal point of contact makes revelation partly cooperative and brings back a general anthropology. He read Romans 1 as establishing human guilt, not a capacity.
  • Both use the Word's threefold form, but Barth orders it strictly under Christ. Brunner's use leaves more room for a hearer who can receive it.
  • Scholars still disagree. Some say Barth was right but too harsh, some favour Brunner, and some say Barth's later work makes room for something like Brunner's point. The lecture declares no winner.

Topic: This lecture presents the 1934 dispute between Brunner and Barth over whether fallen humans keep any capacity to receive knowledge of God before revelation.

Remember: The quarrel was narrow and between allies. Brunner defended a bare capacity to be addressed, and Barth rejected it as a concession that reopens the door to human capacities.

Caution: The lecture does not say Barth simply won. Brunner did not propose saving natural knowledge or revive the classical proofs, and the shared threefold vocabulary hides different uses.

One line to carry into ministry: Ask how the gospel reaches real hearers, and keep in mind that serious theologians who agree on Christ can still disagree sharply on this.

Chapter 4 Chapter 4: Existentialist and Hermeneutical Theology

Show summary
  • Kierkegaard attacked Hegel's System. A System can be built about existence, he argued, but no living person can stand inside it, because an existing person still faces an open future.
  • He separated objective truth (what is true) from subjective truth (how a person holds it). "Truth is subjectivity" does not mean truth is whatever one feels.
  • The "leap of faith" is a decision made in trust, not the end of an argument. Kierkegaard was not an irrationalist, but he thought proofs misdescribe faith.
  • Heidegger described Dasein ("being-there") as the being that cares about its own being. It lives authentically by facing finitude, or inauthentically by dissolving into das Man ("the they").
  • The two men never influenced each other and were not one school. Their shared conviction is that existence must be understood from the inside. Bultmann joined them.

Topic: Kierkegaard and Heidegger, two very different thinkers, argued that human existence must be understood through decision and finitude, not from a detached standpoint.

Remember: For Kierkegaard, faith is a risk-laden personal decision before God, not a conclusion of proof, and the way a truth is held matters as much as its content.

Caution: Do not call them one "existentialist school." Heidegger did not write as a Christian, and Kierkegaard was not arguing that faith is arbitrary or that evidence is worthless.

One line to carry into ministry: Faith is a lived decision before God, so invite people to commit themselves, not only to agree with correct statements.

Show summary
  • Bultmann used "myth" in a technical sense. It means ancient, this-worldly language, such as a three-tiered universe and demons, used to express a claim about human existence. It does not mean "false story."
  • Demythologization means interpreting the myth, not discarding it. The aim is to make the gospel hearable for modern people who no longer share the ancient cosmology.
  • Using Heidegger's categories, Bultmann read the kerygma (the proclamation of the cross and resurrection) as a call to leave self-securing life "according to the flesh" for life "according to the Spirit."
  • Barth and others objected, citing 1 Corinthians 15:14, that Bultmann made the resurrection depend on the believer's decision, not on something that happened to Christ.
  • Defenders replied that God's act is a different kind of event from ordinary history. The lecture leaves the dispute open.

Topic: Bultmann proposed demythologization to make the New Testament message speak to modern people, and Barth and others sharply criticised how it treats the resurrection.

Remember: Bultmann wanted to interpret the New Testament's ancient world-picture, not remove the gospel. For him, "myth" is a way of speaking about human existence.

Caution: Do not dismiss Bultmann as saying the Gospels are made up, and do not treat the criticism as settled. The lecture gives both sides and names no winner.

One line to carry into ministry: Explain the gospel in words your listeners can hear, but ask whether your explanation still says that something happened to Christ.

Show summary
  • Tillich's method of correlation says philosophy asks the questions implied in human existence. Theology answers them from revelation, in a form shaped by those questions.
  • He called God "the ground of being," not "a being." He defined faith as "ultimate concern," and idolatry as making something finite ultimate.
  • Critics asked whether this philosophy begins to decide theology's content and replaces the personal, acting God with an abstract principle. Defenders pointed to Tillich's treatment of prayer, revelation and Christ. The lecture leaves it open.
  • Gadamer argued that no reader is free of prejudices (pre-judgments). Understanding comes through a "fusion of horizons" between reader and text.
  • Ricoeur described a "second naivety": after critical questioning, a reader can again be addressed by a text. Gadamer and Ricoeur offer a third way between reduction and ignoring the distance.

Topic: Tillich's correlation of philosophical questions and Christian answers, and the hermeneutical ideas of Gadamer and Ricoeur about how a modern reader understands an ancient text.

Remember: Tillich said answers must meet real questions, and Gadamer and Ricoeur said readers always bring their own horizon. Understanding is a two-way encounter across real distance.

Caution: Gadamer and Ricoeur did not settle the Bultmann dispute, and Gadamer was not writing mainly about Scripture. The lecture also leaves open whether Tillich keeps God's particularity.

One line to carry into ministry: Before giving an answer, ask what question your listener is really asking, and expect both you and the text to be changed by the meeting.

Chapter 5 Chapter 5: Christian Realism and Public Theology

Show summary
  • Reinhold Niebuhr began as a social-gospel pastor in Detroit. He came to doubt that moral appeals could change industrial society after watching the conflict between Henry Ford's plants and labor.
  • In Moral Man and Immoral Society (1932), he argued that individuals can be genuinely unselfish, but groups act less morally. Groups hold more power, hide selfishness more easily, and have no single conscience.
  • He used Romans 3:23 and Jeremiah 17:9 to say sin includes self-deception, even among reformers and the labor movement he supported.
  • His practical conclusion was that justice between unequal groups usually needs organized counter-power, not moral appeal alone.
  • Readers disagree whether his political doctrine of sin is serious Christian doctrine or a thinner general theory of tragedy. Hauerwas later challenged his engagement with power.

Topic: Niebuhr's 1932 argument that groups are less moral than individuals, and that sin must be taken seriously in political life.

Remember: Moral appeal alone rarely moves powerful groups. Niebuhr said justice usually needs organized counter-power, and every side, including reformers, is open to self-deception.

Caution: Niebuhr was not defending existing power or urging despair. The lecture also reports a real dispute over whether his doctrine of sin keeps its full traditional weight.

One line to carry into ministry: Pray and work for justice, but test your own righteous cause for the self-interest it may hide.

Show summary
  • H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture (1951) uses "culture" broadly: language, custom, law, art, technology and moral ideals. The question is wider than church and state.
  • He described five types: Christ against culture, of culture, above culture, in paradox, and transforming culture. Each type has a strength and a risk.
  • Examples include Tertullian, liberal Protestantism, Aquinas, Luther, and Augustine and Calvin. Many readers think Niebuhr favored the fifth type, though the book names no winner.
  • Yoder argued that the scheme is not neutral. Its definition of culture favors "transforming" and treats "against culture" unfairly. Hauerwas argued that it assumes one unified culture and an established church.
  • The lecture treats the typology as useful and contested together, and uses it with its limits in view.

Topic: H. Richard Niebuhr's five types of relation between Christ and culture, and the Yoder and Hauerwas criticism that the typology is not neutral.

Remember: All five types try to honor John 17:15-16, "in the world" yet "not of the world." Each type has a real strength and a real risk.

Caution: Do not treat the five types as a neutral map. Critics say its definition of culture favors some answers, and the lecture does not name one type as correct.

One line to carry into ministry: Use the five types to name how your church actually lives, then ask whether the map itself is shaping your answer.

Show summary
  • Christian realism is better seen as a shared instinct and vocabulary than a fixed platform. It has been used to support very different political positions.
  • Reinhold Niebuhr moved from early pacifism to rejecting it, arguing that refusing force against Hitler's Germany underestimated evil. Later realists disagree about how far his reasoning extends, and he opposed the Vietnam War.
  • Martin Luther King Jr. used Niebuhr's insight that structural injustice needs organized pressure. He departed from Niebuhr by holding to nonviolence on theological grounds. Whether this fully answers Niebuhr remains open.
  • On the church and power, the lecture names three postures: engaged realist pragmatism, Hauerwas-style distinctiveness, and a natural-law middle path.
  • The lecture declares no winner. Chapter 11 returns to Hauerwas and Milbank.

Topic: How Christian realism has shaped just war thinking, the civil rights movement, and the debate over the church's stance toward political power.

Remember: Realism's inheritance is contested. Matthew 5:13-14 and Micah 6:8 are used by people who agree on justice, mercy and humility but disagree about priority under pressure.

Caution: Do not equate Niebuhrian realism with support for a strong national defense. Some realists say that misreads him. The lecture also does not say which church posture is correct.

One line to carry into ministry: Hold justice, mercy and humility together, and be slow to claim that your political position is the only faithful one.

Chapter 6 Chapter 6: Secularization and Bonhoeffer's Legacy

Show summary
  • Bonhoeffer was a Lutheran pastor in the Confessing Church. He joined the resistance and was executed at Flossenbürg on 9 April 1945. Most of his best-known ideas come from fragmentary letters written in Tegel prison.
  • By a "world come of age," he meant people can manage life without invoking God to fill gaps in knowledge. He rejected a "God of the gaps" as theologically dishonest.
  • "Religionless Christianity" targets a specific cultural package of inward, private religion, not faith, church or doctrine. Readers disagree on its range. Bethge and recent scholars read it narrowly, while secular and death-of-God theologians read it expansively.
  • "The church for others" is less disputed. It is continuous with his earlier work and his costly service to others.
  • Because the letters are unfinished, claims about his "mature theology" must stay modest.

Topic: Bonhoeffer's prison letters, their famous phrases, and the scholarly disagreement over what he meant.

Remember: Bonhoeffer targeted a specific form of "religion," and he wanted a church that serves others at real cost. Philippians 2:6-8 and Matthew 25:35-40 anchor this.

Caution: The letters are fragments, written under censorship by a man who did not live to explain them. Do not claim more certainty than the text can support.

One line to carry into ministry: Let the church be known by costly service to others, not by its privileges or its arguments.

Show summary
  • In The Secular City (1965), Harvey Cox welcomed secularization and urbanization as an outworking of biblical themes. He pointed to desacralized nature, politics and values.
  • His case leaned on texts against idols, such as Psalm 115:4-8 and Exodus 20:4-5. Critics said these forbid treating a created thing as God. They do not show that God's authority should leave public life.
  • A second criticism was that Cox underestimated how secularization erodes private belief as well as public religious authority.
  • In Religion in the Secular City (1984), Cox revised part of his own earlier optimism.
  • Cox said a transcendent God authorizes desacralization. This differs from death-of-God theology. Whether his original argument was wrong or only pushed too far remains disputed.

Topic: Harvey Cox's 1965 welcome of the secular city, the criticism it drew, and his own later revision.

Remember: Cox read secularization as compatible with a living, transcendent God. The Bible's critique of idols does not by itself prove the broader step he sometimes took.

Caution: Do not run Cox together with the death-of-God theologians. He never denied that God exists. The lecture also does not say his argument was simply wrong.

One line to carry into ministry: Keep worship of God separate from worship of your culture's habits, and do not assume modern change is either enemy or friend of faith.

Show summary
  • "Death of God" theology was a loose grouping of a few American theologians in the mid-1960s. The 8 April 1966 Time cover, "Is God Dead?", made it famous.
  • Altizer drew on Hegel and Blake. He said the incarnation was God's "death": a transcendent God emptied himself permanently into Christ and the world. This is a metaphysical claim.
  • Hamilton described mainly an experience: believers could no longer feel God's presence. Rubenstein argued from the Holocaust. The lecture says these are three distinct arguments.
  • Nietzsche's "God is dead" was mainly a cultural diagnosis. Altizer used the phrase in a different, metaphysical way.
  • The movement had no seminary, journal or denomination and dissolved by the early 1970s. Fading is not the same as refutation, and the movement was thin and small.

Topic: The brief 1960s "death of God" movement, its different arguments, and its roots in Hegel and Nietzsche.

Remember: "God is dead" did not mean simple atheism. Altizer, Hamilton and Rubenstein meant different things, and the movement was far smaller than its publicity suggested.

Caution: Do not lump it with Bonhoeffer or Cox. They kept God's transcendence. Also, the movement's decline does not prove its arguments were refuted point by point.

One line to carry into ministry: When someone says "God is dead," ask what they mean: a lost feeling, a lost culture of belief, or a claim about God's being.

Chapter 7 Chapter 7: Rethinking God — Process and Open Theism

Show summary
  • The classical doctrine says God is immutable (does not change), impassible (cannot be made to suffer by outside causes), and timeless. Defenders cite Psalm 90:2 and Malachi 3:6.
  • Whitehead, a mathematician and not a theologian, built a process metaphysics in Process and Reality (1929). Reality is made of momentary "actual occasions" of experience, not enduring substances.
  • His God is dipolar. The primordial pole is unchanging and offers each occasion its "initial aim." The consequent pole takes the world's events into God's own experience.
  • This is panentheism ("all in God"), which differs from pantheism (God equals the world) and from classical transcendence.
  • Hartshorne argued that an unaffected God is less perfect, because love requires being affected. Thomists and Reformed theologians reply that God's eternal knowledge includes everything without changing. The lecture leaves this open.

Topic: Whitehead's process metaphysics and dipolar God, and Hartshorne's argument against classical divine immutability and impassibility.

Remember: Process theology began as a philosophical system that Christians later adapted. Its God is both unchanging in character and ordering, and changing in experience of the world.

Caution: Panentheism is not pantheism. The lecture also does not say who wins between Hartshorne and classical theists, and both sides claim to take love and knowledge seriously.

One line to carry into ministry: When people ask whether God is moved by suffering, state both the classical and process answers fairly, and test each against Scripture.

Show summary
  • John Cobb and David Ray Griffin, working at Claremont's Center for Process Studies, turned Whitehead's philosophy into a working Christian theology, with sin, salvation and eschatology reworked along process lines.
  • In process theology, God's power is persuasive, not coercive. God offers each moment its best "initial aim," and each moment is free to accept, modify or resist it.
  • Process theologians say this answers the problem of evil: evil comes from creatures resisting God's aim, not from God's design or permission, because God could never override their self-determination.
  • The standard criticism is that this fits badly with Exodus 15:1-3 and Isaiah 46:9-10, where God acts decisively and God's counsel "shall stand." Thomists, Reformed theologians and open theists press it.
  • Process replies say such texts use an ancient agency idiom, or admit an unresolved tension. A further difficulty is whether petitionary prayer and miracle can mean more than influence.

Topic: Cobb and Griffin's Christian process theology, its claim that God's power is persuasive, how this answers evil, and the criticisms it faces.

Remember: In process theology God cannot coerce, because no one can override a self-determining occasion. God only persuades, and evil comes from creatures resisting God's best aim.

Caution: Process theologians do not say God chooses to hold back power. They say coercive power over creatures is not available at all. Critics reply that Scripture speaks of God acting decisively.

One line to carry into ministry: When you explain suffering, be clear whether you are claiming God could have stopped it, and know that traditions answer that question very differently.

Show summary
  • Open theism comes from within evangelicalism. Clark Pinnock and others in The Openness of God (1994) argue from close reading of texts where God relents, is grieved, or tests someone "to know."
  • Open theists say God knows everything knowable. They deny that a future free choice is yet a fact to be known, so they say omniscience is not denied.
  • Open theism is not process theology. Open theists affirm creation from nothing, God's transcendence, and God's full power to act unilaterally. They deny only exhaustive foreknowledge of free choices.
  • Classical evangelicals reply with Aquinas on God's timeless eternity and Calvin on accommodation, where Scripture speaks of God in human terms. Open theists answer that both are philosophical devices that are hard to test.
  • Jonah 3:10 and Numbers 23:19 are the central texts. The lecture presents the dispute as unresolved, and institutions differ on whether open theism is within evangelical orthodoxy.

Topic: Open theism, its biblical and philosophical case, how it differs from process theology, and the classical evangelical reply.

Remember: Test the two views by one question. Process theology denies that God can act with overriding power. Open theism denies only that God exhaustively knows future free choices in advance.

Caution: The lecture does not declare a winner. Both sides read Jonah 3:10 and Numbers 23:19 as fitting their own view, and the disagreement is among committed evangelicals.

One line to carry into ministry: When people ask whether God changes his mind, show them both texts and both readings, and do not treat open theism and process theology as the same thing.

Chapter 8 Chapter 8: Hope, the Cross, and Catholic Renewal

Show summary
  • Moltmann's experience as a young German soldier and prisoner of war shaped Theology of Hope, but the book also engages Ernst Bloch's philosophy of hope, so biography is not the whole explanation.
  • He argued that eschatology, the doctrine of what God will finally do with history, is the starting point of theology. The resurrection is a promise of where all history is heading.
  • Because Romans 8:18-25 gives hope for the whole creation, Moltmann held that Christian hope cannot be private comfort. It must engage social and political conditions.
  • In The Crucified God, he takes Matthew 27:46 at face value. The Son is truly abandoned and the Father truly grieves, so suffering is located inside the Trinity at the cross.
  • Unlike process theology, his view is Trinitarian, tied to the cross, and argued from Scripture. Both reject impassibility. Critics ask whether a God who can be wounded is a secure ground of hope.

Topic: Moltmann's theology of hope and his claim, in The Crucified God, that the cross places real suffering within God's own life.

Remember: For Moltmann, the cross is an event within God, not only something done to the human Jesus. This is why hope is grounded in a God who has himself suffered.

Caution: Moltmann's suffering God is not process theology's God. His suffering is at one unrepeatable event and comes from the Bible, not from a general metaphysics. Critics still dispute whether it weakens hope.

One line to carry into ministry: Tell people who suffer that the cross shows God is not distant from their pain, and that Christian hope looks toward the renewal of the whole creation.

Show summary
  • Pannenberg argued in Revelation as History (1961) that revelation happens in the public course of "universal history," open to any honest inquirer, not in a private or purely existential encounter.
  • He judged that both Barth and Bultmann had conceded too much by placing the resurrection beyond historical inquiry, in God's free act or in the believer's decision.
  • He defended the resurrection as historically arguable, using the appearance traditions, including 1 Corinthians 15, and its fit with Jewish expectation of a general resurrection. Bultmannian and conservative critics both objected.
  • "Prolepsis" means anticipation. The resurrection is the end of history happening ahead of time for one man, so it discloses history's meaning before history ends.
  • Pannenberg and Moltmann both made eschatology central but differed in method. Pannenberg relied on public historical argument, while Moltmann argued from the cross and Scripture and let hope outrun historical proof.

Topic: Pannenberg's claim that God is revealed in universal history, and that the resurrection can be argued historically and discloses history's end in advance.

Remember: Pannenberg thought faith should not be walled off from public argument. The resurrection, as an anticipation of the end, makes history's whole meaning available now.

Caution: Critics disagree from two sides. Some say historical method diminishes the resurrection, and others say his arguments concede too much to skepticism. The lecture does not settle this, and Pannenberg and Moltmann are not simply allies.

One line to carry into ministry: Be ready to say that the resurrection is a claim about what happened publicly, and be honest that Christians disagree about how to defend it.

Show summary
  • Vatican II (1962-1965) was an ecumenical council called by John XXIII. Its governing aim was aggiornamento, renewing pastoral language and engagement while keeping the unchanging deposit of faith.
  • Dei Verbum describes revelation as God's personal self-communication. Scripture and Tradition flow from one wellspring, and historical-critical methods are endorsed with qualification.
  • Lumen Gentium presents the church as the People of God before treating the hierarchy, develops episcopal collegiality, and affirms the shared mission of the laity.
  • Gaudium et Spes engages the modern world, though some doubt its optimism leaves room for sin. Nostra Aetate repudiated collective Jewish guilt and respects other religions while holding the fullness is in Christ.
  • The council was not of one voice. Conservative and progressive groups negotiated, and Catholics still debate a "hermeneutic of continuity" against one of "rupture."

Topic: The Second Vatican Council, its principle of aggiornamento, and four documents on revelation, the church, the modern world and other religions.

Remember: Aggiornamento means renewing how the faith is expressed and lived, with doctrine's substance unchanged. It does not mean adapting teaching to whatever culture wants.

Caution: Do not treat Vatican II as speaking with one uncontested voice. Its texts contain compromise language, and Catholics still disagree about how to interpret it.

One line to carry into ministry: When you speak about the council, give its documents and its internal debates, and recall that Christ's prayer "that they may all be one" shaped its ecumenical spirit.

Show summary
  • Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar shared Jesuit formation, ressourcement (return to the sources) and a wish to engage modernity seriously. They also disagreed about method, in a disagreement von Balthasar stated in print.
  • Rahner's transcendental method asks what must be true of every human knower for revelation to be received. He holds that all people have an openness to God, itself a gift of grace.
  • Rahner's "anonymous Christian" is a person who responds to grace without hearing the gospel and may be saved through Christ. He did not mean all religions are equally true, and explicit faith stays fuller.
  • Von Balthasar begins with the objective form of revelation, God's "glory," which must first be beheld. He argues for beauty as a third transcendental beside the true and the good.
  • Von Balthasar feared Rahner's method makes revelation confirm a prior human structure. Rahner's tradition replies that the structure is already grace, given in view of Christ. The lecture leaves this open.

Topic: Two Catholic theologians, Rahner and von Balthasar, who both answered modernity but began from different places: the human knower and the beauty of God's revelation.

Remember: Rahner starts from the structure of human openness to God. Von Balthasar starts from the particular, perceivable form of revelation in Christ. They share Trinitarian, Christ-centred theology and Vatican II's patristic roots.

Caution: Do not read this as "traditionalist against modernist." Von Balthasar did not doubt Rahner's pastoral sincerity, and readers still disagree about whether Rahner's qualifications answer the criticism.

One line to carry into ministry: Let people meet the beauty and particular shape of Christ first, while trusting that God's grace may be at work in people before they can name it.

Chapter 9 Chapter 9: The Trinitarian Renaissance

Show summary
  • Rahner complained that the Trinity was affirmed but not used. If it were withdrawn, he suggested, most Christian devotion and writing could go on almost unchanged.
  • He blamed the Western manual structure that treats De Deo Uno (the one God) before De Deo Trino (the triune God). Aquinas himself held that the one God is the Trinity.
  • Rahner's Rule says "the economic Trinity is the immanent Trinity and the immanent Trinity is the economic Trinity." God's saving acts in history truly disclose God's eternal inner life.
  • The "immanent" Trinity is God's inner life in itself. The "economic" Trinity is how Father, Son and Spirit act in creation and salvation.
  • A criticism is that strict identity might make creation, incarnation and the cross necessary to God, not free. Defenders say the rule concerns the reliability of revelation. Rahner opens the chapter, not its center.

Topic: Rahner's complaint that the Trinity had become practically inert, and his rule linking God's saving action in history to God's eternal life.

Remember: Rahner's Rule says the God who saves in history is truly the God who is eternally triune. Knowing God through salvation is knowing God as he is.

Caution: Rahner did not say theologians stopped believing in the Trinity, and he did not blame Aquinas's intentions. His target was a teaching pattern. How strictly to read the rule is still disputed.

One line to carry into ministry: Do not teach the Trinity as a puzzle to accept and set aside. Show how Father, Son and Spirit shape salvation, prayer and the Christian life.

Show summary
  • John Zizioulas, a Greek Orthodox metropolitan, argued independently of Rahner in Being as Communion (1985). His claim is that being is constituted by communion, so the person, not impersonal substance, is basic.
  • He says the Cappadocian Fathers (Basil, Gregory of Nazianzus, Gregory of Nyssa) reversed Greek thought. Persons (hypostasis) come first, and shared substance (ousia) is what the persons hold in common.
  • The Father is the single origin (aitia) of the Son and Spirit. So divine unity rests on a person, the Father, not on an impersonal shared substance.
  • Zizioulas distinguishes a "person," constituted by relation, from an "individual," a self-contained unit. Colin Gunton drew on this to criticize Western individualism.
  • Scholars such as Lucian Turcescu and André de Halleux say Zizioulas reads modern personalist ideas back into the Cappadocians. His defenders say some constructive reading is legitimate. The dispute is unresolved.

Topic: Zizioulas's Orthodox argument that personhood and being are relational, grounded in the Cappadocian Fathers' teaching about the Father as the source of divine unity.

Remember: For Zizioulas, to be a person is to exist toward and from another. This is true first of God, where the Father, Son and Spirit are constituted by their relations.

Caution: Do not treat Zizioulas as a footnote to Rahner. Also, patristic scholars challenge his claim to have simply recovered what the Cappadocians meant, even if his theology may stand on its own.

One line to carry into ministry: Teach that people are made for relationship, not as isolated individuals who later join groups, and that this reflects the God they worship.

Show summary
  • Social trinitarianism, associated with Colin Gunton and Catherine Mowry LaCugna, says the relationship within the Trinity offers a theological model for human community: family, church and wider society.
  • Gunton argued that a recovered Trinity answers modern individualism. LaCugna built on Rahner's Rule to say the Trinity is a practical doctrine whose shape is mutual self-giving communion.
  • Their claim was about the specific structure of divine unity in diversity, equal persons without hierarchy. Some political and feminist theologians used it to criticize domination in church and state.
  • Critics such as Karen Kilby say it risks describing three centers of consciousness, close to three gods. She also says it may project an ideal of community onto God.
  • Gunton and LaCugna affirmed one divine will and substance. John 17:22-23 draws the analogy itself. The lecture does not declare a winner.

Topic: Social trinitarianism, which uses the Trinity's relational life as a model for human community, and the tritheism and projection objections to it.

Remember: Social trinitarians say the Trinity is not only a doctrine about God but a pattern for communion, grounded in Rahner's Rule and Zizioulas's relational ontology.

Caution: The dispute is live. Defenders affirm one will and one substance, but critics say the position's vivid language works in practice like three minds. The lecture asks readers to carry the question forward.

One line to carry into ministry: When you use the Trinity as a model for the church or family, say how far the analogy goes, and do not read your own ideal into God.

Chapter 10 Chapter 10: Liberation, Black, and Global Theologies

Show summary
  • After Vatican II and the 1968 Medellín conference, Gustavo Gutiérrez wrote A Theology of Liberation (1971). He argued that salvation cannot be separated from concrete liberation, though it is not reduced to it.
  • Gutiérrez described three levels of liberation: from unjust structures, from being an object to being a subject in history, and from sin. He did not identify the kingdom of God with any political system.
  • Luke 4:18 and Exodus 3:7-8 are key texts. Both Gutiérrez and Cone read them as showing a God who sees, hears and acts for a specific oppressed people.
  • James Cone said God in Christ is "Black," meaning a theological symbol of God's solidarity with the oppressed, not a claim about Jesus's ethnicity. Readers dispute his use of "Blackness" and "Whiteness" as theological categories.
  • The Vatican's 1984 instruction criticized Marxist categories, while its 1986 instruction affirmed liberation and the option for the poor. Womanist theologians, including Delores Williams with Hagar's story, pressed Cone's own starting point further.

Topic: Liberation theology in Gutiérrez and Cone, the Vatican's two responses, and the womanist challenge to Cone's early work.

Remember: Both theologians begin from the standpoint of the oppressed and read God's character from the exodus. Gutiérrez held that liberation from sin is the deepest level and keeps it from being only political.

Caution: Do not cite only one Vatican document, since 1984 criticized and 1986 affirmed. Womanist theology is not simply a correction of Cone but his tradition's own logic pressed further.

One line to carry into ministry: Read the exodus and Luke 4:18 with those who suffer, and keep concrete help for the poor together with the gospel's call about sin.

Show summary
  • Most of the world's Christians now live in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Andrew Walls argued this fits a recurring pattern in Christian history, not an accident.
  • Doctrine has always been worked out inside a culture. Western theology was one culturally particular achievement among others, not a neutral starting point for everyone.
  • "Contextual theology" is a method, not a set of conclusions. It treats a specific setting as a real conversation partner instead of an obstacle.
  • In Africa, Bediako and Nyamiti propose Christ as the true Ancestor. They keep the communal insight but reject ancestor practices that claim saving power apart from Christ. Some African evangelicals object.
  • In Asia, Pieris asks for a "double baptism" in Asian religiosity and Asian poverty, addressed together. Koyama and Song use farming images and folk stories.
  • There is no single "Global South theology". The examples differ in setting, method, and proposals.

Topic: This lecture explains the shift of Christianity's center to the global South and shows contextual theological method through one African and one Asian example.

Remember: Contextual theology is a method that takes a specific culture seriously as a conversation partner, transforming its categories rather than simply adopting or rejecting them.

Caution: Do not treat "Global South theology" as one school. The lecture also says ancestor Christology is disputed, and it does not settle that dispute.

One line to carry into ministry: Listen to the people's own setting before you speak, and ask what in it can be kept, changed, or refused in the light of Christ.

Show summary
  • Pentecostal and Charismatic Christianity grew to several hundred million people in the twentieth century, yet it had almost no place in academic systematic theology for most of that time.
  • Pentecostalism traces its origin to the Azusa Street revival of 1906 under William J. Seymour. It was notably interracial, though later institutional history did not fully match that.
  • The gap had several causes: early Pentecostal suspicion of academic training, and academic theology treating Pentecostal practices as peculiar or suspect. Walter Hollenweger began to close it.
  • Amos Yong proposes a "pneumatological imagination" (a way of doing all theology that takes the Holy Spirit as seriously as the Father and the Son), drawing on John 3:8.
  • Yong applies this to other religions, seeking the Spirit's work beyond the church with careful testing. Critics fear it blurs faith in Jesus Christ. Yong's defenders say he affirms Christ's uniqueness.

Topic: This lecture asks why Pentecostal theology was so late to enter the academy and what Amos Yong's work on the Holy Spirit added.

Remember: A movement's size and its academic attention do not always match. Pentecostalism was huge long before it was seriously studied by theologians.

Caution: The lecture does not settle the dispute over Yong's view of other religions. It states the critics' concern and his defenders' reply side by side.

One line to carry into ministry: Take seriously voices that the academy has ignored, and test every claim of the Spirit's work carefully, as Scripture asks.

Chapter 11 Chapter 11: Postmodernism, Postliberalism, and Pluralism

Show summary
  • Postmodern philosophy, from the 1960s and 1970s, challenged not one Christian doctrine but the Enlightenment's claim that reason is neutral, universal, and finally authoritative.
  • Lyotard defined the postmodern as "incredulity toward metanarratives", meaning grand stories that justify themselves by appeal to universal standards. He said such stories lost credibility after twentieth-century history.
  • Derrida's deconstruction argues that a text's meaning is never fully fixed or present, so any text can be read against its own assumptions.
  • Foucault's "power/knowledge" claims that what counts as knowledge is bound up with institutions of power. He did not deny that true and false claims differ.
  • The target is reason's claimed neutrality, not reason or truth as such. The critique could be read as good or bad news for theology.

Topic: This lecture explains, as philosophy and not yet as theology, how Lyotard, Derrida, and Foucault challenged the Enlightenment claim that reason stands outside all particular viewpoints.

Remember: These thinkers attacked reason's claim to be a neutral view from nowhere. They saw that claim as one located story among others.

Caution: The lecture rejects the crude summary that "postmodernism says there is no truth". The three thinkers worked separately and would not all accept one label.

One line to carry into ministry: Be fair to a position before you answer it, and do not caricature what thinkers actually said.

Show summary
  • George Lindbeck saw an impasse in twentieth-century theology between two models of doctrine. The first, "cognitive-propositionalist", treats doctrines as fixed factual claims. The second, "experiential-expressivist", treats them as expressions of a prior experience, as in Schleiermacher.
  • Lindbeck judged the first model weak on doctrinal development and the second weak on explaining why real disagreement matters.
  • His "cultural-linguistic" model treats a religion as a language and form of life, and doctrines as grammar rules. He read the Nicene "of one substance" (homoousios) formula this way.
  • "Intratextuality" means the community's own scriptural world absorbs and interprets the wider world, not the reverse. This fits the postmodern doubt about neutral reason.
  • Critics ask whether doctrine can still be true or false about a reality beyond the community's language. Lindbeck said yes; critics are not all satisfied.

Topic: This lecture presents George Lindbeck's postliberal proposal that doctrine works like the grammar of a religious language and way of life.

Remember: On Lindbeck's view, doctrines are rules governing how Christian language may faithfully be spoken and lived, learned by immersion in the community's practices, like a native language.

Caution: Lindbeck says doctrines can still be true in an ordinary sense. Critics doubt his defense is fully successful, and the lecture leaves that question open.

One line to carry into ministry: Form people in the church's stories, worship, and practices, not only in lists of beliefs to agree with.

Show summary
  • Stanley Hauerwas holds that the church's main social task is to be the church: a visible community formed by Christ's story and by practices such as worship and the Eucharist.
  • Hauerwas and John Howard Yoder said H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture typology was not neutral. Its structure favored the "transforming" answer over "Christ against culture".
  • John Milbank argues that "secular reason", including modern social theory, was never neutral. It rests on unacknowledged theological or anti-theological assumptions.
  • Milbank concludes that theology should offer its own account of social life, rooted in the Trinity and peace, as a rival to social theory. Hauerwas's project is narrower, about church practice and ethics.
  • Critics call Hauerwas sectarian, a charge he denies. Critics say Milbank proves less than he claims, since every position having a starting point does not show which one is true.

Topic: This lecture presents Hauerwas's view of the church as a distinct, story-formed community and Milbank's argument that secular reason is not neutral.

Remember: Both thinkers refuse to translate Christian faith into a supposedly neutral secular language. Hauerwas aims at church life and ethics; Milbank aims at a whole academic discipline.

Caution: Hauerwas says he is not calling for withdrawal from society. Whether that denial succeeds, and whether Milbank's case works, remain disputed in the lecture.

One line to carry into ministry: Let the church's worship and shared life be its first witness, while staying answerable to the neighbors around it.

Show summary
  • Three positions: exclusivism (explicit faith in Christ is necessary for salvation), inclusivism (salvation is through Christ alone, but explicit faith is not required), and pluralism (other traditions may be independent paths).
  • John Hick proposes a "Reality-centered" model in which each religion responds to the unknowable "Real". He reads Jesus's divinity as devotional, mythological language and cites the comparable moral fruit of traditions.
  • Paul Knitter began with a "mutuality" model centered on shared work for justice. His later "correlational" model keeps each tradition's particularity while still being pluralist.
  • Alister McGrath says Hick's claims about the Real contradict his own premise that the Real cannot be known. Lesslie Newbigin says pluralism is itself a Western, Enlightenment-shaped standpoint.
  • Both sides appeal to Scripture, such as John 14:6 and Acts 17:26-27. The lecture declares no winner.

Topic: This lecture sets out the debate between the pluralists Hick and Knitter and the evangelical critics McGrath and Newbigin over Christ and other religions.

Remember: Every side reads Scripture. The dispute is about how several biblical texts should be read together, and serious, informed theologians still disagree.

Caution: Do not treat this as a contest between a biblical and an unbiblical view. McGrath does not accuse Hick of bad faith, and the lecture does not name a winner.

One line to carry into ministry: When you speak about other religions, state each view as its own best defenders would, and be humble about where the Scripture leaves room for debate.

Chapter 12 Chapter 12: Evangelical Theology and the Contemporary Frontier

Show summary
  • After the 1925 Scopes trial and its own separatism, American fundamentalism was widely seen as anti-intellectual. "New evangelicalism" arose as a third option, keeping fundamentalist doctrine but changing its posture toward culture and the academy.
  • In The Uneasy Conscience of Modern Fundamentalism (1947), Carl Henry argued that doctrines of sin, the imago Dei, and God's kingdom already gave grounds for social engagement.
  • The movement built institutions on purpose: the National Association of Evangelicals, Fuller Theological Seminary, and Christianity Today.
  • Henry's God, Revelation and Authority defends propositional revelation against Schleiermacher-style liberalism and against Barth's event-centered view, each in a different way.
  • J. I. Packer argued for keeping the substance of the fundamentalist label. A criticism says propositional revelation may undersell Scripture's narrative and poetry.

Topic: This lecture describes how Carl Henry and J. I. Packer led conservative Protestants from withdrawal toward intellectual and social engagement without changing their core doctrines.

Remember: New evangelicalism changed posture, not doctrine: engagement instead of separation, and argument instead of assertion.

Caution: Henry did not deny that Scripture contains narrative and poetry, and he stated Barth's view fairly. The criticism is narrower: that a propositional model privileges one mode of meaning.

One line to carry into ministry: Stay where outsiders can ask you questions, and be ready to give a reasoned answer with humility, as 1 Peter 3:15 asks.

Show summary
  • Evidentialism says belief is rational only if it is self-evident, evident to the senses, or properly inferred from such beliefs. W. K. Clifford held that believing on insufficient evidence is wrong.
  • Alvin Plantinga argued that classical foundationalism's own criterion fails its own test. This does not prove God's existence, but it removes an unexamined starting point against belief in God.
  • Belief in God can be "properly basic", formed directly like memory or sense perception. Plantinga's Aquinas/Calvin model uses the sensus divinitatis, an innate sense of God, with warrant as proper cognitive function aimed at truth.
  • Nicholas Wolterstorff argued that religious "control beliefs" may legitimately shape scholarship, since religiously neutral scholarship is unattainable.
  • In the "Great Pumpkin" objection, Plantinga replies that basic-belief criteria come from clear cases. "Properly basic" does not mean groundless.

Topic: This lecture explains Reformed epistemology, the argument by Plantinga and Wolterstorff that belief in God can be rational without first being proved by argument.

Remember: "Properly basic" means not grounded in an argument. The belief can still be defeated by counter-evidence and must come from a properly working, truth-aimed process.

Caution: Plantinga's objection to foundationalism is limited. It is not a proof that belief in God is rational. The lecture also asks whether it refutes evidentialism or only one version.

One line to carry into ministry: Do not feel that faith is worthless until you win every argument, and do not claim that faith needs no honest scrutiny.

Show summary
  • Analytic theology applies analytic philosophy's tools (clear terms, explicit valid arguments, technical metaphysics) to the content of Christian doctrine itself. The 2009 volume by Crisp and Rea named the field.
  • It differs from Reformed epistemology, which asks whether belief in God can be rational. Analytic theology asks how specific doctrines, such as the Trinity, can be stated precisely and tested by argument.
  • On the Trinity, Hasker models the persons as distinct centers of consciousness. Defenders of the Latin model warn that this risks functional tritheism, and the debate stays open.
  • A criticism says analytic tools may import foreign categories and produce a "new scholasticism". Practitioners reply that clarity helps preaching and prayer.
  • Kevin Vanhoozer answers Lindbeck with a "canonical-linguistic" model: Scripture is the script, and the church performs it. This stands in some tension with Henry's propositionalism.

Topic: This lecture presents analytic theology and Vanhoozer's view of doctrine as direction for the church's performance of the biblical script.

Remember: Henry, Plantinga and Wolterstorff, and analytic theology with Vanhoozer answer three different questions. They are related projects, not one movement.

Caution: The lecture settles neither the Trinity debate nor the dispute over analytic method. It warns against treating these evangelical projects as one seamless school.

One line to carry into ministry: Seek clear understanding of doctrine, but watch that clever argument does not replace worship and faithful practice, as Colossians 2:4 warns.

Show summary
  • Ian Barbour's typology of science and theology has four types: conflict, independence, dialogue, and integration. John Polkinghorne works in dialogue, reasoning "bottom-up" and calling scientific evidence consonant with theism, not proof of it.
  • Sallie McFague argues that monarchical models of God helped justify domination of nature. She proposes an organic model of the world as, in a qualified sense, "the body of God".
  • Critics say her model compromises God's transcendence and the ability to redeem a world that groans (Romans 8:19-22). McFague's side replies that a God who shares vulnerability can still redeem. The lecture settles neither.
  • Transhumanism and artificial intelligence raise open questions about the imago Dei (Genesis 1:27): whether it is cognitive or relational, and whether it survives radical alteration.
  • The closing synthesis names three threads for pastors: elegance is a warning sign, real disagreements among faithful readers are not failures, and each moment poses its own questions.

Topic: This lecture surveys three open frontiers (science, ecology, and AI with transhumanism) and closes the course with what a working pastor or teacher should carry forward.

Remember: Describe a position fairly before judging it, name real disagreements instead of forcing agreement, and treat your own most elegant answer with suspicion.

Caution: The lecture calls the frontier questions open and offers no answers. Polkinghorne's "consonance" is not a proof, and McFague's critics and defenders are both treated as serious.

One line to carry into ministry: Teach each side of a hard question as its own defenders would, and be honest that faithful Christians have reached different conclusions.