무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle

목차 37
BT605E The Historical Books
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

37분

The writers of these books tell you, repeatedly and without apology, that they are working from records you cannot see. Kings sends the reader to a book of the chronicles of the kings of Israel and to another for Judah, more than thirty times between them. Joshua and Samuel both cite a book of Jashar. Chronicles names prophetic records of Samuel, Nathan, Gad, Ahijah and Iddo. Not one of these documents survives. What we have is the argument built from them.

That is the first half of the lecture: what the named sources were, what their citation tells us about the writers, and what it does not tell us. The second half turns to the other kind of source — the material one. Since the middle of the nineteenth century, excavation and epigraphy have produced a body of evidence that stands entirely outside the biblical text and can be interrogated independently of it. Some of it touches these books at very precise points. An Aramaic inscription from Tel Dan refers to the house of David. A Moabite king's own account of his rebellion names Omri. An Assyrian king's account of his campaign against Hezekiah agrees with 2 Kings on the tribute in gold and disagrees on the tribute in silver. Those are real data, and any responsible reading of these books has to reckon with them.

The third section sets out the argument about how much they establish. It is a genuine argument among serious people, and the labels attached to it — maximalist, minimalist — are mostly used by each side about the other. The lecture presents four positions with named representatives and does not adjudicate between them, because the honest state of the question is that it is open. What it does insist on is a distinction that gets lost in the heat: the questions archaeology is equipped to answer are not the questions these books are asking. Neither discipline can convict or acquit the other, because they are not testifying about the same thing.

이 37분으로 얻는 것

  • Name at least four sources cited within these books that have not survived, and explain what their citation implies about how the books were composed.
  • Describe at least five extrabiblical inscriptions or excavated features bearing on this period, stating for each what it establishes and what it leaves open.
  • Set out the Sennacherib material as a worked case of a source that both confirms and contradicts a biblical account, and explain how a historian handles that.
  • State the four main positions in the historicity debate with named representatives, presenting each in the form its own advocates would accept.
  • Explain, with an example, why an archaeological finding cannot settle the question 2 Kings 17 is asking.

The rest of the acts of Jeroboam, how he fought, and how he reigned, behold, they are written in the book of the chronicles of the kings of Israel. — 1 Kings 14:19

World English Bible

Now the rest of the acts of Nadab, and all that he did, aren’t they written in the book of the chronicles of the kings of Israel? — 1 Kings 15:31

WEB

Now the rest of the acts of Hezekiah, and all his might, and how he made the pool, and the conduit, and brought water into the city, aren’t they written in the book of the chronicles of the kings of Judah? — 2 Kings 20:20

WEB

Now the rest of the acts of Solomon, and all that he did, and his wisdom, aren’t they written in the book of the acts of Solomon? — 1 Kings 11:41

WEB

The sun stood still, and the moon stayed, until the nation had avenged themselves of their enemies. Isn’t this written in the book of Jashar? The sun stayed in the midst of the sky, and didn’t hurry to go down about a whole day. — Joshua 10:13

WEB

(and he commanded them to teach the children of Judah the song of the bow: behold, it is written in the book of Jashar): — 2 Samuel 1:18

WEB

Now the acts of David the king, first and last, behold, they are written in the history of Samuel the seer, and in the history of Nathan the prophet, and in the history of Gad the seer, — 1 Chronicles 29:29

WEB

Now the rest of the acts of Solomon, first and last, aren’t they written in the history of Nathan the prophet, and in the prophecy of Ahijah the Shilonite, and in the visions of Iddo the seer concerning Jeroboam the son of Nebat? — 2 Chronicles 9:29

WEB

In the thirty-first year of Asa king of Judah, Omri began to reign over Israel for twelve years. He reigned six years in Tirzah. He bought the hill Samaria of Shemer for two talents of silver; and he built on the hill, and called the name of the city which he built, after the name of Shemer, the owner of the hill, Samaria. — 1 Kings 16:23-24

WEB

Now Mesha king of Moab was a sheep breeder; and he rendered to the king of Israel the wool of one hundred thousand lambs, and of one hundred thousand rams. But when Ahab was dead, the king of Moab rebelled against the king of Israel. — 2 Kings 3:4-5

WEB

Now in the fourteenth year of king Hezekiah, Sennacherib king of Assyria came up against all the fortified cities of Judah, and took them. Hezekiah king of Judah sent to the king of Assyria to Lachish, saying, “I have offended; return from me. That which you put on me, I will bear.” The king of Assyria appointed to Hezekiah king of Judah three hundred talents of silver and thirty talents of gold. — 2 Kings 18:13-14

WEB

Four citations, three different documents, and a writer who assumes his readers might go and look.

Chronicles cites sources too, and cites different ones. Whether these are separate documents, alternative names for sections of a single work, or a way of claiming prophetic authority for the record, is disputed.

Three passages that can be laid beside documents written by people who were not Israelites and had no interest in confirming anything.

1. The books the writers had and we do not

Kings has a standard closing formula for a reign: the rest of the acts of so-and-so, are they not written in the book of the chronicles of the kings of Israel — or of Judah. It appears for almost every king in both kingdoms. The formula is doing at least three things at once, and they are worth separating.

It is a source citation. The writer is telling you where the fuller record stands.

It is a limitation notice. He is telling you that what you are reading is not the fuller record, and by implication that he has chosen what to include. Lecture 1-1 argued that these books are selective; here the selectivity is stated by the writer himself, on almost every page.

And it is an authority claim. Referring a reader to an archive implies that one exists and that the account can be checked against it. Whether the writer's audience could actually have consulted a royal archive in Jerusalem after 587 is another matter — probably not, and the formula may by then have been a literary convention. But conventions of this kind do not usually arise from nothing.

What were these books? Almost certainly not our 1-2 Chronicles, which is a much later work and which cites its own sources. The most economical proposal is that they were royal annals of the kind well attested elsewhere in the ancient Near East: king lists, campaign records, building notices, regnal lengths. That is exactly the kind of material that shows through the surface of Kings in its most colourless passages — Omri bought a hill for two talents of silver and built a city on it. That sentence has no theology in it at all, which is why it is often taken as a fragment of something older and drier that the writer has copied.

Two other named documents are of a different type. The book of Jashar, cited at Joshua 10:13 and 2 Samuel 1:18, is quoted for poetry both times: the sun and moon at Gibeon, and David's lament for Saul and Jonathan. The book of the Wars of Yahweh, cited at Numbers 21:14, is likewise quoted for verse. These look like collections of national poetry rather than administrative records — which is significant, because poetry in Hebrew often preserves archaic language, and some of the oldest Hebrew we possess is embedded in narrative books as quoted song.

A citation proves less

A caution before leaving this. It is tempting to treat every named source as evidence that the narrative around it is reliable. It is not, quite. A citation establishes that the writer had, or claimed to have, material he did not invent. It says nothing about how he used it, how accurate it was, or whether the framework he built around it came from the source or from him. The formula in Kings appears immediately after the theological verdict on each king, never before it, and the verdict is the writer's own.

2. The material witness

Now to evidence of a completely different kind: objects and inscriptions recovered from the ground, which nobody wrote in order to persuade you of anything about the Bible.

The Mesha stele, also called the Moabite Stone, was found at Dhiban in Jordan in 1868 and is now in the Louvre. It is a victory inscription of Mesha king of Moab, in the Moabite language, from the ninth century. In it Mesha states that Omri king of Israel oppressed Moab for many days, that Omri's son continued it, and that Mesha threw off Israelite control. He also refers to taking vessels of Yahweh and dragging them before his own god Chemosh. Set this beside 2 Kings 3:4-5, which reports Mesha as a sheep breeder paying an enormous tribute in wool to the king of Israel and rebelling after Ahab's death. The two accounts agree on the situation — Moabite subjection to the Omride dynasty, followed by successful revolt — and each naturally claims the victory. That is precisely what one expects of two royal inscriptions from opposite sides. There is a further and much-disputed matter: André Lemaire proposed in 1994 that a damaged passage in line 31 reads "house of David." Recent re-examination using new imaging techniques, published by Israel Finkelstein, Nadav Na'aman and Thomas Römer, argued for a different reconstruction. The reading remains contested, and you should treat it as unsettled.

The Tel Dan inscription is not. Fragments of an Aramaic victory stele were found at Tel Dan in northern Israel in 1993 and 1994, in excavations directed by Avraham Biran; the initial publication was by Biran and Joseph Naveh. The author, most probably Hazael of Aram-Damascus or his son, boasts of killing a king of Israel and a king of "the house of David." The letters read bytdwd. This is a ninth-century reference, from an enemy, to a Judaean dynasty named for David. Philip R. Davies and others initially disputed the reading, proposing that the letters formed a place name; that objection has not persuaded most epigraphers, and the mainstream position now treats the reference as secure. What it establishes is important and limited: that within roughly a century and a half of the traditional date of David, a neighbouring kingdom identified the dynasty ruling in Jerusalem by his name. It says nothing whatever about the size of his kingdom, the events of 2 Samuel, or whether he ever ruled Israel as well as Judah.

Assyrian royal inscriptions name Israelite kings four times over in ways that matter. The Kurkh Monolith of Shalmaneser III records the battle of Qarqar in 853, at which a coalition of Levantine kings met the Assyrian army; among them is "Ahab the Israelite," credited with a very large chariot force. The number is usually thought inflated — Assyrian scribes had every reason to magnify the enemy their king defeated — but the presence of Ahab is not in doubt. The Black Obelisk of the same king depicts and names "Jehu son of Omri" bringing tribute, around 841. Note the phrasing: Jehu was not Omri's son and had in fact destroyed Omri's dynasty, but Assyrian scribes still called the kingdom the house of Omri. That is the datum lecture 1-1 used to make its point about proportion. Tiglath-Pileser III records tribute from Menahem, which lines up with 2 Kings 15:19-20, where the Assyrian king is called Pul.

Sennacherib's account of 701 is the richest case, and it deserves its own treatment below.

The Siloam tunnel inscription was discovered in 1880 in the water channel running from the Gihon spring into Jerusalem. It is written in Hebrew, and it describes, in the workmen's own voice, the moment when two teams tunnelling from opposite ends heard each other and broke through. There is no king named in it and no theology; it is a construction memorial. 2 Kings 20:20 credits Hezekiah with making a pool and a conduit and bringing water into the city. The connection is obvious and was accepted for a century, then challenged — John Rogerson and Philip Davies argued in 1996 for a much later, Hasmonean date on palaeographic grounds. Radiometric dating of the plaster and of organic material in it, published by Amos Frumkin, Aryeh Shimron and Jeff Rosenbaum in 2003, supported the eighth-century date, and that is now the general view.

Lachish provides the rare combination of a text, a picture and a ruin. Sennacherib's palace at Nineveh contained a large relief cycle, now in the British Museum, depicting in detail the siege and capture of a city labelled Lachish: the ramp, the siege engines, the defenders, the deportation of the population. Excavation at Tel Lachish, above all by David Ussishkin, uncovered the destruction of Level III, an Assyrian siege ramp, arrowheads, sling stones and a counter-ramp built by the defenders. You can compare the relief to the ground. This is as close as this period comes to a photograph.

The Babylonian Chronicle for the years around 597 records Nebuchadnezzar's capture of the city of Judah, the seizure of its king and the appointment of a king of his own choice — which is 2 Kings 24 from the other side, and it supplies a precise date. Administrative tablets from Babylon list rations issued to Jehoiachin, king of the land of Judah, and his sons, which bears directly on the last four verses of 2 Kings.

3. A worked case: Sennacherib and Hezekiah

Sennacherib's campaign of 701 is described in 2 Kings 18-19, in Isaiah 36-37, in 2 Chronicles 32, and in Sennacherib's own annals, preserved on several clay prisms. Lay them side by side and you get an unusually clear view of what this kind of evidence can and cannot do.

They agree that Sennacherib campaigned against Judah, that he took a large number of fortified cities, that Hezekiah was besieged in Jerusalem, and that Hezekiah paid a heavy tribute. The Assyrian text says Hezekiah was shut up in Jerusalem "like a bird in a cage," which is a striking phrase to find corroborating a biblical siege.

They agree on a number, precisely. 2 Kings 18:14 says thirty talents of gold. Sennacherib's annals also say thirty talents of gold. That is not the sort of coincidence that happens by accident, and it is a strong indication that the writer of Kings had access to real administrative information.

They disagree on another number in the same sentence. 2 Kings 18:14 says three hundred talents of silver; Sennacherib says eight hundred. Various explanations have been offered — different weight standards, the inclusion of goods valued in silver, exaggeration on the Assyrian side, understatement on the Judaean. None is demonstrable.

They disagree on the outcome, and this is the important one. Sennacherib does not claim to have taken Jerusalem. He claims to have shut Hezekiah in it and received tribute, and then his account moves on. 2 Kings 19 reports that the Assyrian army was struck and that Sennacherib withdrew and was later killed at home by his sons — a killing that Babylonian sources independently confirm, some twenty years later. So both sources agree that Jerusalem was not captured, and they give completely different accounts of why.

Here is the point. A historian can establish from this material that the campaign happened, roughly when, roughly how it went, and that Jerusalem survived. No amount of further excavation can establish why Jerusalem survived, because the competing explanations — an angel of Yahweh, a plague in the camp, trouble elsewhere in the empire, a negotiated settlement the Assyrians preferred not to describe — are not the kind of thing that leaves a stratum. 2 Kings is not primarily interested in the first set of questions and is entirely interested in the second.

4. Where the argument actually is

This is a point where readers will not agree. Four positions, each stated as its holders would state it.

William G. Dever is usually filed as a maximalist, a label he rejects; he describes himself as a centrist and has spent a career arguing with both flanks. His position, developed in books such as What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It?, is that archaeology is an independent witness with its own methods, and that when it is allowed to speak on its own terms it broadly supports the existence of an Israelite society in the central highlands from Iron Age I, a real monarchy, and a religious situation considerably messier than the biblical writers approve of. He is blunt that it does not support the conquest narratives of Joshua. His chief target is not conservative apologetics but the Copenhagen school, which he regards as ideologically driven and as ignoring the material record.

Israel Finkelstein holds a position that is often mislabelled and should not be. He does not deny a historical David or Solomon; he argues that they were rulers of a modest highland , not of the empire Kings describes, and that the archaeological remains long attributed to Solomon belong a century later, to the Omride kings of the north. This is the Low Chronology, and it has a specific point of origin: the monumental six-chambered gates and associated buildings at Megiddo, Hazor and Gezer, which Yigael Yadin attributed to Solomon on the strength of 1 Kings 9:15. Finkelstein redated the relevant strata downward by roughly a century on ceramic and stratigraphic grounds. In The Bible Unearthed, written with Neil Asher Silberman, he and his co-author argue further that the great narratives of these books took shape in the seventh century, in the reign of Josiah, and reflect that period's concerns projected backward. Note carefully: this is a chronological and interpretive argument made from within the archaeology of Israel, by an excavator of Megiddo. It is not a denial that Israel had a history.

Thomas L. Thompson and Niels Peter Lemche, with Philip R. Davies at Sheffield, take the more radical position, and trap number five of this course applies with full force. Their case, at its strongest, is methodological. It runs: a text is primary evidence for the time of its composition and only secondarily, if at all, for the time it narrates; the composition of these books is demonstrable only for the Persian and Hellenistic periods; therefore "biblical Israel" — the unified people with a single history — is a construct of that late literature, and reconstructing the tenth century from it is circular. Davies distinguished sharply between historical Israel (a real Iron Age kingdom, known from inscriptions and excavation), biblical Israel (the literary construct), and ancient Israel (the scholarly hybrid of the two, which he argued has no proper existence). Whether or not you accept the conclusions, that three-way distinction is a genuinely useful analytical tool, and it is the reason the position cannot be dismissed as mere scepticism.

Amihai Mazar occupies a middle ground deliberately. His Modified Conventional Chronology splits the difference on the disputed strata, allowing a shorter downward adjustment than Finkelstein's. His substantive point is broader: that the archaeological record for the tenth century is thinner and more ambiguous than either side's confidence suggests, that radiocarbon results have not resolved it, and that the honest description of the period is uncertainty rather than either a confirmed united monarchy or a demonstrated absence of one. Kenneth Kitchen and Iain Provan press from the other flank, arguing that the comparative and epistemological cases both favour taking the texts as serious historical testimony unless there is specific reason not to.

Do not memorise these as a spectrum from believing to unbelieving. The four positions differ on at least three separate axes — the dating of pottery strata, the dating of the biblical texts, and the epistemology of testimony — and a person's answer on one does not determine their answer on the others.

5. What archaeology can and cannot settle

A stratum can tell you that a city was destroyed. It cannot tell you who destroyed it, unless something identifiable was left behind, and the standard warning in the field is that destruction layers do not come with signatures. It can tell you approximately when, within a margin that is often decades wide and occasionally a century wide, and the margin is precisely what the chronology debate is about. It can tell you how large a settlement was, what people ate, whether they used pig bones, what script they wrote, how their houses were laid out, and whether the site was occupied at all in a given century.

It cannot tell you what anyone intended, believed, or repented of. It cannot tell you why Samaria fell in the sense 2 Kings 17 means by "why." And its silences are treacherous in both directions: the absence of remains at a site may mean nothing was there, or that the relevant layer has eroded, or been quarried away by later building, or not yet been dug, or been dug in the wrong place. Jerusalem is the extreme case — the most theologically important site in these books is also one of the least excavable, because people have never stopped living on it.

Two failures of discipline follow, and both are common enough to have names in the field.

The first is treating archaeology as a judge. It is a second witness, giving evidence about matters within its competence. A witness who can testify about the timing of a fire cannot testify about the motive of the arsonist, and a court that asks him to is misusing him. When someone says an excavation has "proved the Bible" or "disproved the Bible," the first question to ask is: proved or disproved which claim, and was it a claim about material remains?

The second is the argument from silence, deployed with more confidence than it can support. That no trace of a given event has been found is a fact about the state of research as well as a fact about antiquity. This cuts both ways, and it is worth noticing that both flanks of the debate use it when convenient: the absence of an Assyrian record of an army's destruction is taken as telling against 2 Kings 19, while the absence of tenth-century monumental architecture in Jerusalem is taken as telling against the united monarchy. Sometimes silence really is significant — if a large fortified city stood somewhere, its walls tend to survive. The judgment is a matter of degree and it should be argued each time, not assumed.

None of this is a counsel of despair, and it is certainly not permission to stop asking. It is a request for accuracy about what has been shown. The books we are studying make claims of several different kinds — that a king reigned this long, that a city fell in this year, that these events happened because a people abandoned their God. The first two are the sort of claim that evidence can bear on, and this course will bring evidence to bear on them repeatedly. The third is the claim the books were written to make, and it will not be settled by a trench.

The Material Witness: What Each Find Does and Does Not Establish Read the third column as carefully as the second Find Establishes Leaves open Mesha stele Dhiban, found 1868 9th century, Moabite Omri named as king of Israel; Moab subject to the Omrides, then in revolt; Yahweh worshipped in Israel. Which side won what. Line 31, read by Lemaire as "house of David," is disputed after new imaging. Treat as unsettled. Tel Dan stele found 1993-94, Biran 9th century, Aramaic An enemy king refers to the ruling house of Judah as the "house of David" within c. 150 years of David. The size, wealth or extent of David's kingdom; anything in 2 Samuel; whether he ruled the north. Shalmaneser III Kurkh Monolith 853 Black Obelisk c. 841 "Ahab the Israelite" at Qarqar; "Jehu son of Omri" paying tribute. Two kings of Kings appear in Assyrian records. Ahab's chariot total is very likely inflated. Jehu was not Omri's son — Assyria used the dynasty's old name. Sennacherib prisms campaign of 701 The campaign; the fall of many fortified cities; Hezekiah besieged, "like a bird in a cage"; tribute of 30 talents of gold, exactly as 2 Kings 18:14 says. Silver: 300 talents (Kings) against 800 (Assyria). And above all WHY Jerusalem was not taken — both sources agree it survived and explain it quite differently. Lachish Nineveh reliefs + Level III (Ussishkin) A siege depicted in an Assyrian palace and excavated on the ground: ramp, counter-ramp, arrowheads, destruction. The relief is Assyrian propaganda as well as documentation; casualty and deportation figures elsewhere are not independent. Siloam inscription found 1880, Jerusalem A Hebrew tunnelling memorial; the 8th-century date supported by radiometric work (Frumkin, Shimron, Rosenbaum 2003). It names no king. The link to Hezekiah comes from 2 Kings 20:20, not from the inscription itself. Babylonian Chronicle + Jehoiachin ration tablets The capture of Jerusalem in 597 with a precise date; a king of Judah drawing rations in Babylon with his sons. Whether 2 Kings 25:27-30 means to end in hope. That is a literary question and chapter 8 will argue it on other grounds. The pattern across the whole table Names, dates, places, scale — often confirmed. Motive, meaning, causation — never. That is not a failure of archaeology. It is its subject matter.

Every row of this table has the same shape, and the shape is the argument of the lecture. The second column is substantial and should not be minimised by anyone who wants these books treated as fiction. The third column is equally substantial and should not be minimised by anyone who wants them treated as settled.

Four Positions — and Three Axes They Differ On Not a single line from believing to unbelieving Kitchen · Provan Comparative and epistemological case: testimony is evidence until shown otherwise. Dever · Mazar Archaeology as an independent witness. Real monarchy; no conquest as described. Mazar: the record is simply ambiguous. Finkelstein Low Chronology: the "Solomonic" gates are Omride. A modest 10th- century polity; the great narratives shaped under Josiah. NOT a denial of an Israelite history. Thompson · Lemche · Davies A text dates its own composition, not what it narrates. "Biblical Israel" is a late construct, distinct from historical Israel and from scholarly "ancient Israel." Three separate axes — a person's answer on one does not fix their answer on the others 1 · Ceramic and stratigraphic dating (the Low Chronology debate: Yadin's gates, Megiddo, Hazor, Gezer) 2 · The date at which these books reached their present form (10th century material? 7th? 6th? Persian? Hellenistic?) 3 · Epistemology — what weight written testimony carries when nothing corroborates it Two failures of discipline to watch for in yourself Using archaeology as a judge rather than a second witness · Arguing from silence with more confidence than silence can carry. Both flanks of this debate do both, and it is easier to notice in an opponent.

The line across the top is a convenience, not a claim. If you plotted these scholars on the three axes in the panel below it, the ordering would change from axis to axis — which is the reason the labels maximalist and minimalist mislead more than they help.

6. Further Reading

  • William G. Dever, What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It? (Eerdmans, 2001) — the case for archaeology as an independent witness, and the sharpest engagement with the Copenhagen school.
  • Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman, The Bible Unearthed (Free Press, 2001) — the Low Chronology and the seventh-century reading, written for a general reader.
  • Amihai Mazar, "The Debate over the Chronology of the Iron Age in the Southern Levant," in The Bible and Radiocarbon Dating, ed. Thomas E. Levy and Thomas Higham (Equinox, 2005) — the middle position, with the technical detail.
  • Philip R. Davies, In Search of "Ancient Israel", 2nd edn (Sheffield Academic Press, 1995) — the three-way distinction between historical, biblical and "ancient" Israel.
  • Thomas L. Thompson, Early History of the Israelite People (Brill, 1992) — the fuller scholarly form of the argument summarised in his later popular book.
  • K. Lawson Younger Jr and William W. Hallo, eds, The Context of Scripture, 3 vols (Brill, 1997-2002) — the primary texts themselves: Mesha, Tel Dan, Shalmaneser, Sennacherib, in translation with notes. Read the inscriptions before reading arguments about them.
  • David Ussishkin, The Conquest of Lachish by Sennacherib (Tel Aviv University, 1982) — the excavation set against the Nineveh reliefs.
  • Kenneth A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Eerdmans, 2003) — the comparative case, densely documented.
  • Megan Bishop Moore and Brad E. Kelle, Biblical History and Israel's Past (Eerdmans, 2011) — the best neutral survey of where each debate in this lecture currently stands.

핵심 요약

  • Kings cites lost royal chronicles, and Chronicles cites prophetic records. The citations show the writers used sources and chose from them. They do not prove that the writer's framework or verdicts are reliable.
  • Finds such as the Mesha stele, Tel Dan, the Assyrian inscriptions, Lachish and the Babylonian Chronicle confirm names, dates and places. Each leaves open questions of size, motive and meaning.
  • On Sennacherib in 701, Kings and the Assyrian annals agree on 30 talents of gold and that Jerusalem survived. They differ on the silver and on why the city was not taken.
  • Dever, Finkelstein, Thompson, Lemche and Davies, Mazar, and Kitchen and Provan differ on pottery dating, text dating and the weight of testimony. Their answers do not line up on one scale.
  • Archaeology is a second witness, not a judge. It can date a destruction but cannot say why Samaria fell in the sense 2 Kings 17 means.

Topic: This lecture reviews the lost sources named in these books and the archaeological evidence, and asks what history and archaeology can and cannot settle.

Remember: Archaeology often confirms names, dates and places. It does not settle motive, meaning or causation, which is what these books mainly claim.

Caution: The lecture does not rule between the four positions. Do not say a find "proves" or "disproves" the Bible without asking which claim, and whether it concerns material remains.

One line to carry into ministry: When someone says archaeology proves or disproves the Bible, ask which claim they mean and whether a trench could answer it.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Kings cites royal chronicles more than thirty times. Write a paragraph arguing that this strengthens the historical value of the book, and a paragraph arguing that it tells us nothing about the reliability of the material the writer chose to include. Which paragraph is more honest about what a citation is?
  • Take the Sennacherib case. You are writing a two-page history of 701 for a general reader. Say exactly what you would assert, what you would attribute to a source, and what you would leave undecided — and give your reason in each case.
  • The Tel Dan inscription is often described as proving the Bible. Rewrite that claim in a form you could defend, then list three things it does not prove that people commonly think it does.
  • State the Copenhagen position on the dating of texts in your own words, in a way its holders would accept. Then set out the single strongest piece of evidence against it and explain why you think it is the strongest.
  • Find a recent report of an excavation in Israel or Jordan in the press. Identify the material claim, the interpretive claim, and the headline. How far apart are the three?
  • The lecture argues that no excavation can answer the question 2 Kings 17:7-8 is asking. Construct the best objection to that claim you can, and then answer it.
  • Both flanks use the argument from silence. Find one example of each in this lecture's account, and say for each whether you think the silence is genuinely significant.

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.