Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
- Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
- Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
- Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
- Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
- Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
- Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
- Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
- Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
- Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
- Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
- Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
- Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
- Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
- Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
- Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
- Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
- Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
- Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
- Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
- Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
- Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
- Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
- Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
- Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
- Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
- Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
- Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
- Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
- Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
- Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
- Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
- Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
Judges is the one book of the Old Testament that tells its reader in advance how to read it. Between the tribal list of chapter 1 and the first individual account in chapter 3 stands a short paragraph, 2:11-19, which sets out a sequence: Israel does evil, Yahweh's anger is kindled, Israel is sold into an enemy's hand, Israel is distressed, Yahweh raises up a judge who saves them, and then the judge dies and it happens again. Almost every commentary reproduces this sequence, usually as a wheel. That is not a distortion. The sequence really is there, and the individual accounts really are fitted to it.
But the paragraph contains a clause that the wheel diagram cannot represent, and this lecture is largely about that clause. Verse 19 does not say that when the judge died Israel returned to where it had been. It says that they "dealt more corruptly than their fathers." The frame itself announces deterioration. Whatever else the editor is doing, he is not describing a repeating equilibrium; he is describing a decline that happens to be organized in repeating episodes. The rest of the book bears this out in a way that is visible to anyone willing to lay the accounts side by side and note which parts of the sequence are present and which have gone missing.
This lecture does three things. It reads the frame closely and derives from it a checklist of six moves. It applies that checklist across the book, from Othniel — three verses, every move present, nothing else said — to Samson, where several moves have vanished. And it then handles three matters of background that the following two lectures assume: what the word shofet (judge) means in this book, what to do with the book's chronological figures, and what to make of Martin Noth's once-dominant proposal that pre-monarchic Israel was a sacral league on the Greek model.
이 32분으로 얻는 것
- Set out the six-move pattern of Judges 2:11-19 from the text itself, and quote the clause that makes it a decline rather than a repetition.
- Compare the Othniel account with the Jephthah and Samson material and name at least four specific elements of the pattern that are weakened or absent in the later cases.
- Explain what `shofet` denotes in Judges, with reference to its use outside the Bible, and say why the English rendering "judge" misleads students.
- State the chronological problem created by adding the book's year-figures, and evaluate two proposed solutions.
- Summarize Noth's `amphictyony` hypothesis, name two of its principal critics, and explain the evidential grounds of their objections.
Yahweh raised up judges, who saved them out of the hand of those who plundered them. Yet they didn’t listen to their judges; for they played the prostitute after other gods, and bowed themselves down to them: they turned aside quickly out of the way in which their fathers walked, obeying the commandments of Yahweh. They didn’t do so. When Yahweh raised them up judges, then Yahweh was with the judge, and saved them out of the hand of their enemies all the days of the judge: for it grieved Yahweh because of their groaning by reason of those who oppressed them and troubled them. But when the judge was dead, they turned back, and dealt more corruptly than their fathers, in following other gods to serve them, and to bow down to them; they didn’t cease from their doings, nor from their stubborn way. — Judges 2:16-19
World English Bible
The children of Israel did that which was evil in the sight of Yahweh, and forgot Yahweh their God, and served the Baals and the Asheroth. Therefore Yahweh’s anger was kindled against Israel, and he sold them into the hand of Cushan Rishathaim king of Mesopotamia: and the children of Israel served Cushan Rishathaim eight years. When the children of Israel cried to Yahweh, Yahweh raised up a savior to the children of Israel, who saved them, even Othniel the son of Kenaz, Caleb’s younger brother. The Spirit of Yahweh came on him, and he judged Israel; and he went out to war, and Yahweh delivered Cushan Rishathaim king of Mesopotamia into his hand: and his hand prevailed against Cushan Rishathaim. The land had rest forty years. Othniel the son of Kenaz died. — Judges 3:7-11
WEB
Yahweh’s anger was kindled against Israel; and he said, “Because this nation have transgressed my covenant which I commanded their fathers, and have not listened to my voice; I also will not henceforth drive out any from before them of the nations that Joshua left when he died; that by them I may prove Israel, whether they will keep the way of Yahweh to walk therein, as their fathers kept it, or not.” So Yahweh left those nations, without driving them out hastily; neither delivered he them into the hand of Joshua. — Judges 2:20-23
WEB
Read verse 19 twice. The comparative — "more corruptly than their fathers" — is the single most important word in the frame, and it is the word the wheel diagram cannot draw.
Five verses, and every element of the frame is present in order: evil, anger, selling, servitude, cry, raised saviour, spirit, victory, rest, death. There is no dialogue, no complication, no character detail, and no flaw. Othniel is the pattern with a name attached.
A second explanation, and not obviously the same as the first. In 2:3 the remaining nations are a punishment; here they are a test. The book offers both without reconciling them, and 3:1-4 adds a third: they are left so that later generations who had not known war might learn it.
1. The frame, and the six moves
Set out formally, 2:11-19 yields the following sequence. It is worth memorizing, because everything in this lecture is a comparison against it.
- Israel does what is evil in Yahweh's sight, specified as serving the Baals and the Ashtaroth — that is, the local gods of the land, Baal being the Canaanite storm and fertility god and Ashtoreth (plural Ashtaroth) a goddess associated with him in the Ugaritic texts.
- Yahweh's anger is kindled.
- He sells them into the hand of an enemy, and they cannot stand before their enemies.
- They groan, cry out, are distressed.
- Yahweh raises up a judge, is with that judge, and saves them through him.
- The judge dies, and Israel turns back — worse.
Two features of this list are frequently overlooked. First, the cry in verse 18 is not described as repentance. The text says the groaning moved Yahweh, "for it grieved Yahweh because of their groaning by reason of those who oppressed them." It is distress, not contrition, that produces the deliverer. Some accounts later in the book will make this explicit; Judges 10:10-16 has Israel confess in properly penitential language, and God refuses them before relenting anyway. The book is more interested in divine forbearance than in Israelite reform.
Second, verse 17 adds a move that the standard wheel leaves out: even during a judge's lifetime, Israel does not listen to the judge. The deliverance is real but does not produce obedience. This matters because it removes the possibility of reading the book as a story of successive reformations that keep failing; the reformations are not really happening in the first place.
2. Applying the checklist: what goes missing
Lay the six moves against the successive accounts and the pattern erodes visibly. What follows is a summary; students should verify each line against the text rather than take it from a lecture.
Othniel (3:7-11). All six moves, in order, with no complications. This is the control case.
Ehud (3:12-30). The moves are present, but the account has become a story — and a story told with a broad relish for the grotesque, including the detail of the fat closing over the blade and the servants waiting outside because they assume the king is relieving himself. Ehud's method is deception and assassination. Nothing in the text condemns it; nothing commends it either.
Deborah and Barak (4-5). The cry is present, the deliverer is raised, and victory follows. But the appointed military leader refuses to go without Deborah, and the killing blow is struck by a woman who is not an Israelite at all. The chapter states explicitly (4:9) that the honour will not be Barak's.
Gideon (6-8). The cry is present, but the response now begins with a prophet who rebukes rather than delivers (6:7-10). The deliverer requires two signs and a fleece tested twice. The account ends with an ephod — a cultic object of some kind — set up at Ophrah, of which the text says plainly that all Israel "played the prostitute after it there." A judge's own career now generates the apostasy that begins the next cycle.
Abimelech (9). Not a judge at all. He is Gideon's son by a Shechemite concubine, he murders seventy brothers on one stone to make himself king, and he dies when a woman drops a millstone on his head. There is no cry, no divine raising up, and no rest. The chapter is a hole in the pattern, and its placement immediately after Gideon's ephod is unlikely to be accidental.
Jephthah (10-12). The cry has become complicated: God initially refuses (10:13-14), then acts. The deliverer is a man his own family expelled, a leader of a band of "vain fellows," negotiated with by elders who need him. His victory is followed by a vow whose consequence chapter 11 reports and does not evaluate, and then by a civil war (12:1-6) in which Gileadites kill forty-two thousand Ephraimites at the Jordan fords over a difference in pronunciation. Israel is now killing Israel.
Samson (13-16). There is no cry. The Philistine oppression is announced, and God acts without being asked. The deliverer is announced before birth by a divine messenger — the fullest annunciation in the book — and proceeds to break, in sequence, essentially every term of the vow that defines him. He judges Israel twenty years and delivers no one but himself, until the final scene, which he requests as revenge for his eyes rather than for Israel. The formula "the land had rest" never appears in his account at all.
That last observation is the cleanest single piece of evidence for the decline reading. The phrase "the land had rest forty years" (or eighty) closes the Othniel, Ehud, Deborah, and Gideon accounts. After Gideon it stops. Whatever happens in the second half of the book, rest is not among the outcomes.
Designed or collected?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Not everyone accepts that the erosion is deliberate design. On one side, Barry Webb (The Book of Judges, 2012) and Dennis Olson read the book as a single, carefully arranged literary composition in which the deterioration is authorial and load-bearing. On the other, Wolfgang Richter argued in the 1960s that behind Judges lies an older collection of independent hero stories — a Retterbuch, "book of deliverers" — which a later editor framed with the theological paragraph in chapter 2; on that view much of what we read as designed decline is a byproduct of gathering heterogeneous material, with the framing formula applied more heavily to some units than others. Susan Niditch, working from folkloric parallels, similarly stresses the independent life of the individual tales before the collection. The two views are not wholly exclusive: an editor can compose a decline out of inherited pieces. But the difference matters for how much weight a reading may place on the arrangement.
3. What a shofet is
The Hebrew noun is shofet, from the root sh-p-t. English "judge" is a defensible translation and a misleading one. In this book the shofet is essentially never shown deciding a legal case. Othniel goes out to war. Ehud assassinates. Gideon musters. Jephthah negotiates and fights. Samson does whatever Samson does. The one figure who does hold something like court is Deborah, who sits under a palm and to whom "the children of Israel came up for judgment" (4:5) — and she is introduced first as a prophetess.
The root's semantic range in West Semitic is wider than modern English "judge." It covers governing, ruling, and vindicating as well as adjudicating. Outside the Bible, the eighteenth-century BC letters from Mari use a cognate title, shapitum, for a governor or district administrator with military as well as judicial responsibilities. Much later, and much further west, the chief magistrates of Carthage bore a Punic title that Latin authors transliterated as sufetes — the same root, functioning as the head of a state. Neither parallel proves anything about the Israelite institution, and the gaps in time and place are large; what they show is that the root naturally covers leadership, and that a translator's choice of "judge" imports a courtroom that the Hebrew does not require.
There is one further complication in the book itself. Judges 10:1-5 and 12:8-15 list six figures — Tola, Jair, Ibzan, Elon, Abdon, and Shamgar is sometimes counted with them — about whom almost nothing is said except their home town, the length of their tenure, and in several cases their numbers of sons and donkeys. These are conventionally called the "minor judges," and they fit the deliverer pattern hardly at all: no oppressor, no cry, no battle. Alberto Soggin, Abraham Malamat, and others have argued that these notices preserve the memory of a genuinely different institution — a settled, possibly hereditary local office — which the editor has interleaved with the deliverer stories. If so, the book's word shofet covers two things, and the pattern of chapter 2 describes only one of them.
4. The chronology, and why it does not add up
Judges supplies numbers freely: eight years of servitude, forty years of rest, eighteen years, eighty years, twenty-three years, twenty-two years, and so on. Add the oppression figures and the tenures together and the total for the book alone comes to roughly 410 years, before adding anything for Joshua's lifetime, for Eli and Samuel, for Saul's reign, or for David's forty years.
That total collides with 1 Kings 6:1, which dates the founding of Solomon's temple 480 years after the exodus. The 480 has to accommodate the wilderness period, Joshua, the whole of Judges, Eli, Samuel, Saul, David, and the first four years of Solomon. It cannot, if the Judges figures are consecutive.
Two families of solution have been proposed, and each has a cost.
Overlapping judgeships. The judges were regional, not national: Jephthah in Gilead east of the Jordan and Samson on the Philistine coastal border could have been contemporaries without either narrative mentioning the other. On this reading the figures are real but not additive. John Bright and, in a different key, Kenneth Kitchen have argued along these lines, and the case is strengthened by the book's own geography — the tribal coalitions differ from account to account, and no episode involves all twelve tribes. The cost is that the text nowhere signals the overlap; the synchronisms have to be supplied by the interpreter, and different interpreters supply different ones.
Schematic numbers. Forty years is a generation, and eighty is two. That "the land had rest forty years" appears repeatedly, and that the sum of certain groupings produces round figures, suggests the numbers function as periodization rather than arithmetic. This is the more common position in current scholarship. Its cost is that it makes the figures unavailable as historical data of any kind, and it must still explain why some numbers are conspicuously not round — Cushan Rishathaim's eight years, Jabin's twenty, Jephthah's six.
Is the 480 exact?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Kitchen (On the Reliability of the Old Testament, 2003) treats the overlaps as a straightforward and well-attested feature of ancient regional chronologies and regards the problem as soluble. Others, including many who work primarily on the archaeology of the period, regard the 480 of 1 Kings 6:1 as itself schematic — twelve generations of forty — and therefore not a fixed point that the Judges figures need to fit. Notice that the second position is not a claim that the numbers are false; it is a claim about what kind of numbers they are. Deciding between them is not something this course will do for you.
5. Noth's amphictyony, and what happened to it
Meaning of the term
For roughly thirty years after 1930, the standard account of pre-monarchic Israel was Martin Noth's. Noth proposed that the twelve tribes were bound together in an amphictyony — a term borrowed from the Greek world, where it named a league of neighbouring city-states organized around a shared sanctuary, the best known being the league centred on Delphi. Noth argued that Israel was such a league: twelve tribes precisely because the number allowed each to take a monthly turn maintaining a central shrine, meeting at that shrine (Shechem, then Shiloh), bound by rather than by a state, and having no permanent central government. On this reconstruction the judges are the league's occasional leaders, and the book of Judges describes the league under stress.
The proposal explained a great deal at once, which is precisely why it should be examined carefully. It accounted for the number twelve, for the lack of a monarchy, for the covenant ceremony at Shechem in Joshua 24, for the ad hoc character of leadership, and for the tribal muster.
The criticisms accumulated through the 1960s and 1970s and have not been answered.
- The Greek analogy is thin. Georg Fohrer and Roland de Vaux both pressed the point that the Greek and Italian leagues are attested a good deal later than the period in question, that their defining feature was the shared maintenance of a specific sanctuary, and that no Israelite text describes any such rota. The twelve-monthly duty roster is Noth's inference, not a datum.
- The central sanctuary is not in evidence. The narratives locate worship at Shechem, Shiloh, Bethel, Mizpah, Gilgal, Ophrah, Dan, and a Levite's private shrine in Ephraim. A. D. H. Mayes, in Israel in the Period of the Judges (1974), argued that this distribution is what the sources actually show and that a single normative shrine has to be read into them.
- The tribes are not stable at twelve. The lists differ. Judges 5 names ten and omits Judah and Simeon entirely; Judges 1 organizes differently again; the Joseph tribes are sometimes one and sometimes two. A league defined by its number is awkward when the number is not fixed.
- The muster is not a league institution. In every battle account the participants are a subset, and Judges 5 explicitly reproaches Reuben, Gilead, Dan, and Asher for staying away — with no suggestion that any mechanism existed to compel them.
Noth's hypothesis is today a minority position, and it is important to be clear about what its decline does and does not settle. It does not establish that the tribes had no shared identity; the Song of Deborah presupposes that a summons could be issued across tribal lines and that failure to answer was blameworthy, which implies some real bond. What has collapsed is the specific institutional model — a formal league of a fixed number of members organized around one sanctuary. Norman Gottwald and others have proposed quite different models of tribal association, and the question of what held early Israel together remains genuinely open. Students should be wary of textbooks that still present the amphictyony as settled fact, and equally wary of the opposite error of concluding that "tribal Israel" is therefore a fiction.
6. Where the elegance is dangerous
A final caution, since this lecture has argued for a pattern and a decline. The strongest evidence for the decline is the disappearance of the rest formula after Gideon and the relocation of the enemy from outside to inside. That evidence is good. But two things resist the scheme.
First, the book's own explanations of why the nations remain are three, not one, and they do not agree: punishment (2:3), test (2:22), and military training for a generation that had not known war (3:2). An editor pursuing a single tidy theology would not have left all three standing. Their presence is a sign that the material has more than one voice in it.
Second, the erosion is uneven. Jephthah's speech to the Ammonite king in 11:14-27 is a competent piece of diplomacy that reviews three centuries of territorial history; it is not the work the "declining deliverers" scheme would predict at that point in the book. Samson's annunciation narrative in chapter 13 is the most elaborately theological birth account outside the patriarchal stories. If the decline were the author's only interest, these passages would not be there in the form they take. The pattern is real, and it is not the whole of the book.
The table is the argument in its checkable form. The third column is the strongest single piece of evidence: the rest formula stops after Gideon and never returns. The fourth column is the second strongest: the enemy migrates inside.
6. Further Reading
- Martin Noth, Das System der zwölf Stämme Israels (Kohlhammer, 1930) — the amphictyony hypothesis in its original form; see also his The Deuteronomistic History (English translation, JSOT Press, 1981).
- A. D. H. Mayes, Israel in the Period of the Judges, Studies in 29 (SCM, 1974) — the most careful dismantling of the amphictyony, and still the standard reference for the debate.
- Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges, NICOT (Eerdmans, 2012) — reads the frame and the individual accounts as a single designed composition.
- Susan Niditch, Judges: A Commentary, OTL (Westminster John Knox, 2008) — the counterweight: the tales had independent lives before the frame.
- Kenneth A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Eerdmans, 2003), chapter 5 — the fullest defence of overlapping judgeships and of the figures as usable data.
- J. Alberto Soggin, Judges: A Commentary, OTL (Westminster John Knox, 1981) — on the "minor judges" as evidence of a distinct office.
- Dennis T. Olson, "The Book of Judges," in The New Interpreter's Bible vol. 2 (Abingdon, 1998) — a clear, teachable account of the deterioration reading.
핵심 요약
- Judges 2:11-19 gives a six-move pattern: Israel does evil, Yahweh is angry, Israel is sold to an enemy, they groan, Yahweh raises a judge, and the judge dies. Verse 19 says they then acted worse, so the frame describes decline.
- Othniel shows every move with nothing added. Later accounts lose parts. The rest formula stops after Gideon, Abimelech breaks the pattern, Jephthah ends in civil war, and Samson has no cry.
- Scholars differ on whether the decline is designed (Webb, Olson) or a by-product of framing older hero stories (Richter, Niditch). The book also gives three reasons for the nations remaining: punishment, test and training.
- The Hebrew shofet is shown mostly leading and fighting, not deciding cases, so "judge" can mislead. The book's year-figures sum to about 410 years, against 480 in 1 Kings 6:1. Overlapping judgeships and schematic numbers are two proposed solutions.
- Noth's amphictyony, a league of tribes around one sanctuary, is now a minority view after criticism by Fohrer, de Vaux and Mayes. The tribes probably still shared some bond.
Topic: This lecture reads the pattern in Judges 2:11-19, shows how it erodes across the book, and covers the meaning of shofet, the chronology problem, and Noth's amphictyony.
Remember: The frame is a decline, not a wheel. Verse 19 says Israel became worse, and after Gideon the land never has rest again.
Caution: The pattern is real but not the whole book. Jephthah's diplomacy and Samson's birth account run against it, and scholars disagree whether the decline is designed or accidental.
One line to carry into ministry: In Judges, distress moves God to rescue; do not read rescue as proof that the people had repented.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Write out Judges 2:11-19 as a numbered list of moves in your own words. Then read Judges 6:1-10 and mark which moves are present, which are modified, and what has been added. What does the addition do to the pattern?
- The trigger for deliverance in 2:18 is groaning rather than repentance, and 10:10-16 goes further by having God refuse an explicit confession. Construct the strongest theological account of why the book presents it this way, and then state the strongest objection to your account.
- "Judge" is a poor translation of `shofet` for this book, but every English version uses it. Propose an alternative, then list what your alternative loses. Is there a rendering that loses less than "judge" does?
- Take the two solutions to the chronological problem — overlapping judgeships and schematic numbers — and apply each to the specific figures in chapters 10-12. Which handles the non-round numbers better, and why?
- Noth's amphictyony collapsed for reasons that are largely evidential. Yet the Song of Deborah clearly assumes some inter-tribal obligation. What minimal account of tribal association survives the criticisms of Noth, and what evidence would be needed to say more?
- Richter's proposal of an older "book of deliverers" and Webb's reading of a unified literary composition make different predictions about what we should find in the text. Name one observation that would count in favour of each.