무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

목차 37
BT605E The Historical Books
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

53분

This course said at the outset that it would not hurry past four texts: the ban in Joshua, the rape and dismemberment of the Levite's concubine in Judges 19, the killing in Esther 9, and the dissolution of marriages in Ezra 10. It did not hurry past them. Chapter 2 set out the ban and the main positions on it; chapter 3 gave Judges 19 a lecture section of its own; chapter 11 dealt with Esther 9 rather than treating it as an appendix; chapter 10 put Ezra 9-10 next to Nehemiah 13 and refused to reconcile them with Ruth. This lecture does not repeat that work.

It asks a different question, which is the one a student actually faces. Not what these texts mean, but how to put them in front of other people. There is a distance between having understood a difficult text in a seminar and being able to teach it to fifteen adults on a Wednesday evening, some of whom have been in a war, some of whom have been assaulted, some of whom will repeat whatever you say to somebody else. That distance is what this lecture is about.

Then it does something the course has been building toward and has deliberately postponed. These books have been used to authorize the taking of other people's land and the killing of the people on it. That is not a slander invented by critics of the Bible; it is a matter of documented record, in several centuries and on several continents, by people who could read and who thought they were being faithful. The lecture states the record, and then does the part that matters: it sets out the exact interpretive steps by which the text was made to yield that conclusion. "These books have been misused" is a sentence that teaches nothing, because it leaves the reader unable to recognize the misuse when it is happening in front of them, or in their own mouth. A reading has a structure. The structure can be named, and once named it can be interrupted.

And then, having said that, the lecture says what these books give that is not available anywhere else, because a course that ended on the abuses would be as dishonest as one that never mentioned them. There is something in this collection that the rest of ancient literature does not contain, and it has to do with what a nation is willing to write down about itself.

It closes by telling you what to read next. It does not summarize the course. You were there.

이 53분으로 얻는 것

  • Set out a defensible teaching approach for each of the four difficult texts, including what to say first and what not to do at all.
  • Describe the three-step reading by which Joshua has been turned into a warrant for conquest, identify which step does the decisive work, and name documented historical cases of that use alongside at least one reading of the same books from the position of the dispossessed.
  • Identify texts inside these books that block the conquest reading, and explain how each one blocks it.
  • State what the historical books preserve that comparable ancient royal literature does not, without overstating the claim.
  • Name specific next reading, in more than one category, for continued work on these books.

Now therefore fear Yahweh, and serve him in sincerity and in truth. Put away the gods which your fathers served beyond the River, in Egypt; and serve Yahweh. If it seems evil to you to serve Yahweh, choose this day whom you will serve; whether the gods which your fathers served that were beyond the River, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land you dwell: but as for me and my house, we will serve Yahweh.” — Joshua 24:14-15

World English Bible

They utterly destroyed all that was in the city, both man and woman, both young and old, and ox, and sheep, and donkey, with the edge of the sword. — Joshua 6:21

WEB

When he had come into his house, he took a knife, and laid hold on his concubine, and divided her, limb by limb, into twelve pieces, and sent her throughout all the borders of Israel. It was so, that all who saw it said, “There was no such deed done nor seen from the day that the children of Israel came up out of the land of Egypt to this day! Consider it, take counsel, and speak.” — Judges 19:29-30

WEB

The Jews struck all their enemies with the stroke of the sword, and with slaughter and destruction, and did what they wanted to those who hated them. — Esther 9:5

WEB

Ezra the priest stood up, and said to them, “You have trespassed, and have married foreign women, to increase the guilt of Israel. Now therefore make confession to Yahweh, the God of your fathers, and do his pleasure; and separate yourselves from the peoples of the land, and from the foreign women.” — Ezra 10:10-11

WEB

The course began with a choice put to a people at the end of Joshua's life, and it is worth having in front of us, because the whole of this lecture is about what is done with that choice by people who read it afterwards.

Notice what is presupposed and rarely noticed: Joshua tells this generation that their own ancestors served other gods, and that some of them are still doing so. The founding assembly of the people is addressed as a mixed and unreliable body. That is not the way founding documents usually talk.

And here are the four texts, in the order this course met them. They are printed together, without comment, because that is how they will meet you.

1. First, a rule about order

Before the four texts individually, one rule that applies to all of them, and to every hard text you will ever teach.

Describe before you evaluate. Say what the text actually says — the whole of it, including the parts that make your position harder — before anyone in the room, including you, says whether it is good or bad. This is not a device for suspending judgement indefinitely. It is a way of making sure the judgement, when it comes, is about the text and not about a summary of the text that was arranged to produce it.

The reason this matters practically is that both of the ways of getting a difficult text wrong are shortcuts past description. A defensive reading reaches for an explanation in the first minute — it is hyperbole, it is only expulsion, it is the ancient world — and having produced the explanation, never returns to look at what was on the page. A dismissive reading reaches for a verdict in the first minute — this is genocide, this is misogyny — and having produced the verdict, likewise never returns. Both leave the class knowing less about the passage than when they came in. Both feel like rigour.

The second rule follows from the first: do not teach one of these texts without enough time. A hard text raised in the last eight minutes of a session is worse than a hard text not raised at all, because the people it lands on hardest have nowhere to put it and no chance to speak. If you have twenty minutes, teach something else.

2. The ban

What to say first. Say what herem means and what the texts command. The word is usually rendered "devote to destruction" or "utterly destroy"; it designates something removed from ordinary use by being given over to God, and in the war texts that means killed. Joshua 6:21 lists the categories: man and woman, young and old, and the animals. Deuteronomy 20:16-18 commands it for the cities of the land and gives a reason, which is the fear of religious contamination. 1 Samuel 15 applies it to Amalek and makes Saul's failure to complete it the ground of his rejection. That is the material. A student should hear it in full before hearing anything about it.

Then the positions, as chapter 2 gave them. The rhetorical reading, associated with Kenneth Kitchen and K. Lawson Younger, which sets these accounts beside Egyptian and Assyrian campaign reports and argues that totalizing language of annihilation was a conventional way of reporting victory, not a body count — an argument with real comparative evidence behind it. The displacement reading, which stresses the vocabulary of driving out and notes that the same peoples reappear alive in Judges. The canonical-development reading, which places these texts within a trajectory. And the position of those, Eric Seibert among them, who hold that each of these moves reduces the difficulty without removing it and that the honest course is to say so.

What not to do. Do not present any one of these as the solution and close the topic. A class that leaves believing the problem has been solved has been given something that will break the first time they meet a serious objection. Say instead what is true: that each approach handles part of the difficulty, that none of them handles all of it, and that thoughtful believers in every tradition live with a remainder.

Do not moralize at the ancient world as a way of ending the conversation, either. "They were primitive" is not an analysis; it is a way of not having to think about a text that is in your own scriptures.

Who is in the room. Assume that somebody present has seen a war, or has family who did. In much of the world this is not a remote possibility. That person will not hear Joshua 6 as a hermeneutical puzzle. Do not stage the discussion as a debate to be won, and do not require anyone to speak.

3. Judges 19

What to say first. The narrative facts, plainly and without ornament: a Levite's secondary wife leaves him; he goes to retrieve her; on the way home they lodge in an Israelite town; the men of the town demand the guest; the host offers his own virgin daughter and the woman; the Levite puts the woman out; she is raped through the night; she is found at the door in the morning; the Levite tells her to get up, receives no answer, puts her on a donkey, takes her home, and cuts her into twelve pieces. Then a war kills tens of thousands of Israelites, and it ends with the surviving Benjaminites being supplied with wives by two further abductions.

Then the two things that are most often missed. First, the narrator does not approve. There is no comment of any kind on the Levite's conduct, and the absence of comment is not endorsement — this is a book that comments freely when it wants to, and the closing refrain about there being no king and everyone doing what was right in his own eyes is placed immediately after these chapters. Second, the woman never speaks. She has no recorded word in the entire chapter. Phyllis Trible's treatment in Texts of Terror (1984) named this and named her as an unnamed victim whose story the tradition kept but did not mourn, and Trible's chapter is the single most useful thing a teacher can read before teaching this passage.

What not to do. Do not use this chapter as a sermon illustration of moral decline. It is regularly deployed that way — as an example of how bad things get without a king — and that use makes an instrument of a woman who was already made an instrument twice in the story, once by the Levite and once by the narrator's political point. If the passage teaches something about a society, it teaches it by refusing to look away from one specific person, and a teacher who abstracts her back into an illustration has undone the only thing the text does for her.

Do not read the rape aloud without warning. Say what the passage contains before you turn to it, and make it genuinely possible for someone to leave the room without explaining themselves. Statistically, in a group of any size, you are teaching this to survivors.

Do not allegorize. Attempts to read the woman as a figure of Israel or of the church are old and are still made, and they have the effect of making her not a person.

A positive suggestion. Some teachers read Judges 19 together with 2 Samuel 13, the rape of Tamar, and ask what the two narratives do differently. Tamar speaks; the woman of Judges 19 does not. That comparison gives a class something to do besides recoil, and it keeps the discussion attached to the text.

4. Esther 9

What to say first. The mechanics, which are routinely misdescribed in both directions. The edict of chapter 8 does not order an attack; it grants the Jews the right to assemble and defend themselves against those who attack them, because under Persian law as the book presents it the earlier decree could not be revoked. The killing is then reported: five hundred in Susa on the first day, the ten sons of Haman, three hundred more in Susa on a second day granted at Esther's request, and seventy-five thousand in the provinces. Three times the narrator says that they did not lay their hands on the plunder — a detail the text clearly considers important, and which distinguishes the action from ordinary reprisal, whether or not you find that distinction sufficient.

Two readings of the killing

Then the disagreement. This is a point where readers will not agree, and the disagreement has been sharp for a long time. One reading emphasizes that this is a story of a threatened minority in a foreign empire, that the numbers belong to the genre of court tale rather than to a chronicle, that the second day and the hanging of Haman's sons' bodies are narrated as reversal — the fate prepared for Mordecai falling on Haman's house — and that a persecuted community's fantasy of survival is a different moral object from a state's programme of killing. Another reading holds that a text is not excused by its genre, that seventy-five thousand is what the book says, and that the celebration attached to the killing is what makes the chapter hard rather than the killing alone. Both readings are held by serious people, Jewish and Christian.

What a Christian teacher owes here, specifically. Esther 9 has a reception history that a Christian teacher must know about before opening the chapter. From Luther onward, this book and this chapter in particular were used in Christian polemic to characterize Jews as vengeful, and that characterization has a long and murderous downstream history in Europe. That does not make the chapter easy, and it does not settle the interpretive question. It does mean that a Christian who raises Esther 9 in order to criticize it is standing in a tradition of doing so which was not motivated by ethics, and has an obligation to say so out loud. The safeguard is straightforward: teach this chapter beside the violence texts in your own tradition's scriptures and your own tradition's history, not as an exhibit from somebody else's.

5. Ezra 10

What to say first. What was actually done. An assembly in the rain; a decision; a commission that sat for three months; and a list of names — priests, Levites, singers, gatekeepers, and laymen by clan — of the men who had married foreign women. The text records that they sent them away, and that some had children by them. It does not record what happened to the women or the children afterwards. It does not say where they went, or who fed them. The narrative simply stops.

Then the tension the keeps open. Ruth is a Moabite. Deuteronomy 23:3 excludes Moabites from the assembly to the tenth generation. The book of Ruth ends by making that Moabite the great-grandmother of David, and Ezra-Nehemiah requires the dissolution of exactly such marriages. Chapter 10 of this course set both books out and declined to subordinate one to the other, and this lecture will not do it either. What can be said is that a tradition which preserved both was not seeking a single policy, and that a reader who quotes one of them as the Bible's position on the question is quoting half of it.

Then the record of use. Texts about separation have been enlisted in modern arguments for enforced ethnic and racial separation. The best-documented theological case is twentieth-century South Africa, where the scriptural argument for separate development rested principally on Genesis 11 and Acts 17:26 — the dispersal of nations and the appointment of their boundaries — with the post-exilic separation texts, Ezra and Nehemiah among them, brought in as supporting evidence for the maintenance of a distinct people. That case was formally repudiated by the churches that had made it, and the Belhar Confession of 1986 was written against it. Teach the repudiation together with the use; a class that hears only that the Bible was misused, and not that the misuse was answered from within the same tradition, learns half a lesson.

What not to do. Do not solve this by declaring Ezra wrong and Ruth right, or the reverse. Both moves are available and both are shortcuts. The community Ezra was governing was small, recently reconstituted, and had watched a comparable community in the north disappear; the fear behind the policy was not irrational, and saying so is not endorsing the policy. And the women are still in the text, unnamed, sent away with the children. Let the class hold both facts at once. That is the actual skill this course has been trying to teach.

6. The record: how Joshua was made into a warrant

Now the harder half.

The historical books, and Joshua above all, have been used to authorize the seizure of inhabited land and the killing of its inhabitants. This is documented in specific places by specific people who left writings. Here is how the reading works, because the mechanism is the point.

Step one: identification. A community identifies itself as Israel — not as resembling Israel, but as occupying Israel's position in the covenant. It reads its own migration as an exodus, its founding covenant as the covenant, its enemies as the enemies of God's people. This step is not in itself wrong or unusual; every Christian tradition applies Israel's story to itself in some way, and the Psalms are sung in the first person by people who are not ancient Israelites. The step becomes dangerous only in combination with the next two.

Step two: mapping. The land the community wants is mapped onto Canaan: a land promised, a land whose present occupants hold it without right. The occupants are mapped onto Canaanites or Amalekites — that is, onto peoples the text places under a divine sentence. Once that mapping is made, the moral status of the current inhabitants has been settled before any facts about them are considered. In North American colonial writing this mapping was explicit; in the Afrikaner tradition the land was Canaan and the trek was the exodus; in Latin America the conquest was preached as the giving of a promised land.

Step three: transfer of the command. The ban texts are read as normative precedent rather than as narrative about a single commanded act at a single time against named peoples. What God commanded there becomes what God permits, or requires, here. This is the decisive step, and it is a specific and identifiable interpretive move: turning a narrative into a rule.

Three steps, each of them a move that can be named. Note that step three is where the argument is actually load-bearing, and it is also the step that the biblical text itself gives the least support to, since the ban commands in the are attached to named nations in a named territory and are not generalized.

Documented cases. Colonial New England: sermons and histories of the seventeenth century, including writing produced during King Philip's War in 1675-76, applied the categories of Canaanite and Amalekite to Native peoples, and the language of the promised land to the colony. The Puritan legal argument for taking land — that unenclosed land was legally vacant — travelled alongside a biblical argument that it was providentially given. Cromwell's campaign in Ireland in 1649 was reported by Cromwell himself in the language of divine judgement on a guilty people. In South Africa, the Great Trek was narrated as an exodus, and the vow taken before the battle at Blood River in 1838 was commemorated annually for a century and a half as a covenant. In the Spanish conquest of the Americas, the analogy with Israel's conquest of Canaan was drawn by defenders of the wars — and was attacked, at length and in detail, by Bartolomé de las Casas, who argued that the Canaanite precedent could not be transferred, that the wars were unjust, and that the peoples of the Indies had committed no offence against Spain. That the argument was made and answered in the sixteenth century is worth knowing: the objection is not a modern invention.

Read from the other side. The same books have also been read, and read powerfully, by people with no land and no power. The exodus and the crossing of the Jordan are central to African American spirituals and to the rhetoric of the American civil rights movement; the same narrative underlies much of Latin American . And it is precisely here that Robert Allen Warrior's essay "A Native American Perspective: Canaanites, Cowboys, and Indians" (1989) made its uncomfortable contribution: Warrior pointed out that the exodus story to which liberation theology appeals does not stop at the Red Sea, that it continues into the conquest, and that indigenous readers may find themselves cast as Canaanites in a story other people are using for liberation. That essay is short, and it should be read rather than summarized.

The general lesson is uncomfortable and worth stating plainly. The identification move is available to anybody. The text does not assign the roles. A community reading Joshua will place itself as Israel, and whoever is in the way will be Canaan, and there is nothing in the mechanics of the reading that prevents this — which is why the resistance has to come from somewhere else.

A live case, named and not adjudicated. These books are invoked today in argument about the land between the Jordan and the Mediterranean, by parties who disagree profoundly, and the scholarly literature on the subject — Michael Prior's The Bible and Colonialism is the best-known example — is itself contested, and is criticized both for its handling of the biblical texts and for its politics. This course is not competent to settle a contemporary political dispute and does not attempt it. What it can say is what it has said above: that the three-step reading is identifiable, that it is used by more than one party in more than one conflict, and that a student who can recognize the steps is better equipped than one who has only been told that the Bible has been misused.

7. What blocks the reading, from inside the books

If the identification move is always available, then the safeguards have to be textual, and there are several. A student should be able to produce them from memory.

Possession is not proof of righteousness. Deuteronomy states this in advance and in the strongest terms, precisely because it anticipates the inference:

Don’t say in your heart, after Yahweh your God has thrust them out from before you, saying, “For my righteousness Yahweh has brought me in to possess this land”; because Yahweh drives them out before you because of the wickedness of these nations. Not for your righteousness, or for the uprightness of your heart, do you go in to possess their land; but for the wickedness of these nations Yahweh your God does drive them out from before you, and that he may establish the word which Yahweh swore to your fathers, to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob. — Deuteronomy 9:4-5 (WEB)

Twice in two verses: not for your righteousness. Every conquest theology in the historical record has depended on the inference that this verse forbids.

God does not take sides on request. On the night before the first battle in the land, Joshua meets an armed figure and asks the obvious question:

When Joshua was by Jericho, he lifted up his eyes and looked, and behold, a man stood in front of him with his sword drawn in his hand. Joshua went to him, and said to him, “Are you for us, or for our adversaries?” He said, “No; but I have come now as commander of Yahweh’s army.” Joshua fell on his face to the earth, and worshiped, and said to him, “What does my lord say to his servant?” — Joshua 5:13-14 (WEB)

The answer to "are you on our side" is "No." The commander of Yahweh's army declines the category. Joshua is not told he is wrong to fight; he is told that the question of whose side God is on is not a question he gets to ask.

The line is not ethnic. Chapter 2 made this point from the narrative arrangement, and it is worth repeating here because it is the most powerful internal block of all. Rahab, a Canaanite and a prostitute, is spared with her whole household and is incorporated into Israel; Achan, an Israelite of the tribe of Judah with a full genealogy, is destroyed with his household. The two stories are placed side by side. Whatever the book is doing, it is not dividing humanity by ancestry.

The ban is bounded. The commands are directed at named peoples in a named territory. Later Jewish interpretation drew the consequence explicitly: the Mishnah records the ruling that since Sennacherib came up and mixed the nations, the ancient peoples can no longer be identified, and the laws attached to them therefore have no present application. That is a formal closing of the category, made within the tradition that holds the texts as law.

Israel's does not exempt Israel. Amos states this as bluntly as it can be stated:

Are you not like the children of the Ethiopians to me, children of Israel?” says Yahweh. “Haven’t I brought up Israel out of the land of Egypt, and the Philistines from Caphtor, and the Syrians from Kir? — Amos 9:7 (WEB)

Other peoples have exoduses too. And the historical books make the same point structurally rather than by assertion: the people who received the land by the standard of Joshua 23 are expelled from it by the same standard in 2 Kings 17 and 25. This is the block that the conquest reading can never absorb, because it comes attached to the identification itself. Anybody who claims Israel's role in these books has also claimed Israel's judgement, and Israel's judgement in these books is dispossession. A community that reads Joshua as its charter has, in the same act, read 2 Kings as its forecast.

8. What these books give that nothing else does

Having said all that, here is the other half, and it is not a consolation prize.

A national archive that records its founders' crimes. Compare the historical books with the royal inscriptions of their neighbours. Assyrian annals record victories; they do not record defeats. The Mesha inscription from Moab records Mesha's successes. Egyptian campaign reliefs record triumph. This is the norm: royal texts are produced by and for the king, and they say what the king wants said. Now read this:

Nathan said to David, “You are the man. This is what Yahweh, the God of Israel, says: ‘I anointed you king over Israel, and I delivered you out of the hand of Saul. I gave you your master’s house, and your master’s wives into your bosom, and gave you the house of Israel and of Judah; and if that would have been too little, I would have added to you many more such things. Why have you despised Yahweh’s word, to do that which is evil in his sight? You have struck Uriah the Hittite with the sword, and have taken his wife to be your wife, and have slain him with the sword of the children of Ammon. — 2 Samuel 12:7-9 (WEB)

The founder of the dynasty, in the national literature of that dynasty, told to his face by a named prophet that he is an adulterer and a murderer — and the accusation preserved, in detail, with the victim named. Solomon, who built the temple, is reported to have taxed the country into revolt and to have built shrines for foreign gods. Israel's first king is rejected. Jacob is a deceiver, Moses a killer, Gideon ends by making an object the people prostitute themselves to. Whatever process produced this collection did not sanitize it, and it easily could have.

A defeat explained as one's own fault. This is the point at which it is easy to overclaim, so here is the accurate version. The move of explaining a national disaster by one's own god's anger rather than by a foreign god's strength is not unique to Israel: the Mesha inscription says Chemosh was angry with his land, and Mesopotamian texts explain of cities by a god's abandonment. What is unusual about Israel is not the idea but what was done with it — the scale on which it was worked out, over eight books and centuries of narrated time, into a sustained connected argument; the fact that it was preserved by the defeated party and not commissioned by a victorious one; and above all the fact that the literature survived the state whose failure it recorded, and became the founding text of a community that had no king, no army and, for a time, no temple. Most national theologies of defeat vanished with the nations that produced them. This one turned into a way of continuing without a nation.

A prophetic record kept inside the royal record. Nathan against David, Ahijah against Solomon and Jeroboam, Elijah against Ahab over a judicial murder and a stolen vineyard, Micaiah against four hundred court prophets, Huldah consulted by a king. In each case the tradition preserved the confrontation. A literature in which the person who tells the king he is a murderer is the hero is a literature with a permanent internal check, and much of the later Jewish and Christian capacity to criticize rulers on religious grounds comes from these books rather than from anywhere else.

Named women in a narrative world that mostly did not name them. Rahab, Deborah, Jael, Achsah, Delilah, Ruth, Naomi, Hannah, Abigail, Michal, Bathsheba, the woman of Tekoa, the widow of Zarephath, the Shunammite, Athaliah, Jezebel, Huldah, Esther, Vashti. Not all of them are treated well by their narrators, and the corpus remains overwhelmingly a record of men. But the collection preserves stories in which women act decisively and are named for it, and this is worth noticing beside the fact — held at the same time, not cancelled by it — that the woman of Judges 19 is never given a name at all.

A refusal to end well. Kings ends with the temple burned and a king on a foreign allowance. Judges ends in civil war. There is no restoration in these books, no vindication, no closing scene in which the argument comes right. The corpus was assembled by people who could have written themselves an ending and did not.

You have finished a survey. A survey is not a competence; it is a map of where the work is. Here is what to do with it.

Read the books straight through, twice, in different orders. Once as Joshua-Judges-Samuel-Kings, followed by Chronicles, Ezra-Nehemiah, Ruth and Esther — the Christian arrangement. Once as the Jewish canon has them: Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings as the Former Prophets, with Ruth, Esther, Ezra-Nehemiah and Chronicles among the Writings and Chronicles last. Chapter 1 argued that arrangement is interpretation. Test that claim yourself by feeling the difference.

Read the prophets against the history. Amos and Hosea beside 2 Kings 14-17; Isaiah 1-39 beside 2 Kings 16-20; Jeremiah beside 2 Kings 21-25; Ezekiel beside the exile; Haggai and Zechariah 1-8 beside Ezra 1-6. The historical books tell you what happened and why; the prophets are the voices the historical books say were sent, and reading them together changes both.

Read one full-scale commentary on one book, all the way through. Not a survey and not a study Bible. Choose a book you found difficult and take one serious commentary from beginning to end — Trent Butler or Richard Nelson on Joshua, Barry Webb on Judges, P. Kyle McCarter on Samuel, Mordechai Cogan and Hayim Tadmor on Kings, Sara Japhet or H. G. M. Williamson on Chronicles, Joseph Blenkinsopp on Ezra-Nehemiah, Jon Levenson or Adele Berlin on Esther. One commentary read completely teaches more than ten consulted.

Read the ancient sources themselves, in translation. The Mesha inscription, the Tel Dan inscription, the annals of Sennacherib and the Lachish reliefs, the Cyrus Cylinder, the Babylonian Chronicles, the Jehoiachin ration tablets. William Hallo and K. Lawson Younger's The Context of Scripture or the older Pritchard collection will give you all of them with notes. Chapter 1 warned against using archaeology as a referee; the way not to misuse it is to read the primary documents rather than summaries of what they are said to prove.

Read outside your own tradition. If you are a Protestant, read a Jewish commentator on Samuel and a Catholic one on Chronicles. If you are Catholic or Orthodox, read the Protestant critical tradition on Kings. These books belong to more than one community, and the readings they have produced are not interchangeable.

Read the reception history. Trible on Judges 19. Warrior's essay. Las Casas. The documents of the churches that repudiated their own use of these texts. This is not an optional supplement to ; it is evidence about what the texts do when they are let out of the classroom.

Then go and teach one of them. Choose the passage you are least comfortable with — not the one you like. Prepare it properly, give it enough time, describe before evaluating, and find out what you actually think when someone in the room disagrees with you. Everything in this course was preparation for that, and none of it counts until it is done.

How Joshua was turned into a warrant — and what stands in the way Three interpretive steps, each one nameable · and five texts inside the books that block them 1 · Identification We are Israel — not merely like Israel. Our migration is the exodus; our covenant is the covenant. 2 · Mapping This land is Canaan. Its inhabitants are Canaanites or Amalekites — already under sentence. 3 · Transfer of command The ban becomes a rule rather than a narrative. Commanded then equals permitted now. Step 3 carries the weight — and has the least textual support. What stands in the way, inside the books themselves Deuteronomy 9:4-5 Not for your righteousness. Twice. Joshua 5:13-14 Are you for us or for our adversaries? — No. Rahab and Achan (Joshua 2, 6, 7) The Canaanite lives; the Israelite dies. The ban is bounded Named peoples only; the Mishnah closes the class. Amos 9:7, and the shape of Kings Other peoples have exoduses. And whoever claims Israel's role has claimed Israel's judgement: dispossession. And what this collection holds that comparable royal literature does not Founders' crimes kept 2 Samuel 12 names the victim, in David's own book. Defeat as one's own fault Not unique — Mesha says it too. Unique: it outlived the state. The prophet in the record The man who calls the king a murderer is the hero. The rule that governs all of the above when you teach it Describe before you evaluate — and do not open one of these texts without enough time to finish it.

The top band is a mechanism, not an accusation. The point of drawing it as three boxes is that each box is a move somebody makes, and a move can be refused. The middle band is where the refusal comes from. The bottom band is why the books are worth the trouble.

6. Further Reading

  • Phyllis Trible, Texts of Terror: Literary-Feminist Readings of Biblical Narratives (Fortress, 1984) — the chapter on Judges 19 is essential before teaching that passage; the whole book is short.
  • Robert Allen Warrior, "A Native American Perspective: Canaanites, Cowboys, and Indians," Christianity and Crisis 49 (1989), reprinted in R. S. Sugirtharajah, ed., Voices from the Margin — read the essay itself, not a summary of it.
  • Michael Prior, The Bible and Colonialism: A Moral Critique (Sheffield Academic Press, 1997) — documents the use of these texts in Latin America, South Africa and the modern Middle East; polemical and contested, and to be read together with reviews that dispute it.
  • Bartolomé de las Casas, In Defense of the Indians, translated by Stafford Poole (Northern Illinois University Press, 1992) — the sixteenth-century refusal of the Canaanite analogy, argued point by point.
  • Eric A. Seibert, The Violence of Scripture: Overcoming the Old Testament's Troubling Legacy (Fortress, 2012) — the position that declines to defend these texts, stated by someone who is not trying to leave the church.
  • Richard S. Hess and Elmer A. Martens, eds., War in the Bible and Terrorism in the Twenty-First Century (Eisenbrauns, 2008) — a range of positions on the violence texts, several of which this course does not adopt.
  • John J. Collins, Does the Bible Justify Violence? (Fortress, 2004) — a short, careful treatment of exactly the question this lecture asks, from a scholar who has no stake in exonerating the texts.
  • Jean-Pierre Ruiz, Readings from the Edges: The Bible and People on the Move (Orbis, 2011) — a Catholic reading of biblical migration and land texts from the perspective of migrants.
  • Willie James Jennings, The Christian Imagination: Theology and the Origins of Race (Yale University Press, 2010) — on how identification with Israel was bound up with the formation of racial categories in the colonial period.
  • Allan Boesak and others, A Moment of Truth: The Confession of the Dutch Reformed Mission Church 1982 — the documents surrounding the Belhar Confession, for the repudiation as well as the use.
  • Mordechai Cogan and Hayim Tadmor, II Kings, Anchor Bible 11 (Doubleday, 1988) — recommended above as a full commentary to read from beginning to end; its handling of the Assyrian sources is a model.

핵심 요약

  • Teach hard texts by describing before evaluating, and never without enough time. Defensive and dismissive readings both skip description. The lecture gives an approach for the ban, Judges 19, Esther 9 and Ezra 10.
  • Joshua became a warrant for conquest in three steps: identification with Israel, mapping land and people onto Canaan and Amalek, and transfer of the command. Step three carries most weight, with least support.
  • Documented cases include colonial New England, Cromwell in Ireland, South Africa and the Spanish conquest, where Las Casas refused the analogy. Warrior shows the exodus story can cast indigenous readers as Canaanites.
  • Texts inside the books block the reading: Deuteronomy 9:4-5, Joshua 5:13-14, Rahab and Achan, the bounded ban, and Amos 9:7 with the exile.
  • The books keep their founders' crimes, the prophet who confronts the king, many named women, and refuse a happy ending. Defeat as one's own fault is not unique; its scale is.
  • The lecture ends with a reading plan: read the books straight through, then the prophets, a full commentary, ancient sources, outside your tradition, and reception history. Then teach one passage.

Topic: This lecture shows how to teach the four hardest texts, how Joshua has been made a warrant for conquest, what blocks that reading, and what the books uniquely preserve.

Remember: The conquest reading follows three nameable steps, and the books themselves block it, since anyone who claims Israel's role also claims Israel's judgement.

Caution: The lecture does not settle contemporary land disputes. It also warns that raising Esther 9 as criticism stands in a Christian tradition of polemic that must be named. Do not call the problem solved.

One line to carry into ministry: Before teaching a violent text, give it enough time, warn the room, describe it fully, and teach it beside your own tradition's violence and not as someone else's exhibit.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Take one of the four difficult texts and write a fifteen-minute teaching plan for it: what you say first, what you show, what question you ask, and how you end. Then write down what you would do if someone in the room said the text was indefensible.
  • The lecture argues that the defensive reading and the dismissive reading fail in the same way. State that argument in your own words. Is it fair to both, or does it treat one more gently than the other?
  • Work the three-step reading in reverse. Take a historical case named in this lecture and identify, from the primary sources you can find, which of the three steps its authors made explicit and which they left unstated. What follows from a step being left unstated?
  • Joshua asks whether the commander is for Israel or for its adversaries and is told "No." Argue that this verse is a genuine block on the conquest reading. Then argue that it is not, since Joshua goes on to fight and win. Which case is stronger?
  • The lecture says that the identification move is available to anybody and that the text does not assign the roles. If that is right, is there any use of Israel's story by a later community that is safe? Describe the conditions under which it would be.
  • This lecture claims a Christian teacher has a specific obligation when raising Esther 9. State the obligation, and say whether you think it is well grounded. What would be lost by ignoring it?
  • The Mesha inscription also explains defeat by a god's anger. Given that, restate as precisely as you can what is actually distinctive about the historical books' account of the exile. Then check your restatement for anything you cannot defend.
  • Choose the passage in this course you are least comfortable teaching. Name the discomfort exactly — is it the content, its reception history, or your own uncertainty about what it means? Then decide what you will read before you teach it.
  • Of the categories of next reading listed at the end of this lecture, which one are you least likely to do? Say why, honestly, and then decide whether the reason is a good one.

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.