무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole

목차 37
BT605E The Historical Books
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

55분

There is a way of teaching the historical books that goes like this. Israel is given a land on condition of obedience. Israel disobeys. Prophets warn. Israel keeps disobeying. Israel loses the land. The books exist to demonstrate the connection. Everything fits, the eight books become one argument, and a class can be given the whole corpus in twenty minutes.

That summary is not false. It is very nearly the argument the books make about themselves, and Judges states it almost in those words at 2:11-19, and 2 Kings 17 states it again at the fall of Samaria. Any serious account of these books has to include it. The trouble is that it is elegant, and elegance in the study of ancient literature is a warning sign rather than an achievement. A scheme that accounts for everything usually does so because the things it could not account for have quietly been left out — and in this case they were left out by the summarizer, not by the editors, because the editors put them in the text and left them there.

So this lecture has two halves that pull against each other, and they are meant to.

The first half builds the synthesis. It takes four themes that run through all eight books — land, kingship, temple, exile — and shows that each of them is held in the text as a double thing rather than a simple one. The land is a gift and a condition. Kingship is permitted and dangerous. The temple is the place where the divine name dwells and a thing that can be trusted as a charm. Exile is judgement and is not the end. Underneath all four sits the scheme of retribution, and the scheme is real. It is not something scholars imposed; it is the explicit reasoning of the narrator at the decisive moments.

The second half breaks the synthesis, on the text's own evidence. Josiah, the best king in the entire history, is promised by a prophet that he will go to his grave in peace, and is then killed on a battlefield in early middle age. Manasseh, whom the same book identifies as the worst king Judah ever had and the direct cause of the exile, reigns for fifty-five years, longer than anybody else in either kingdom. And the guilt that destroys Jerusalem is transferred to a generation born after the offender died, in flat contradiction of a law that this same history elsewhere quotes with approval. These are not obscure difficulties dug out by hostile critics. They are load-bearing walls of the narrative, and the scheme cannot carry them.

The lecture leaves them standing. It does not resolve them, and it will point out that the ancient editors of Chronicles did try to resolve two of them, which is evidence that the strain was felt from the beginning. Then it ends where the corpus ends, on the fact that Kings and Chronicles do not finish in the same place, and that the difference between the two endings is a difference in what a reader is left holding.

이 55분으로 얻는 것

  • Set out the four themes of land, kingship, temple and exile, and state the double-sidedness of each with a text for both sides.
  • State the retribution scheme as the historical books state it, and distinguish a juridical account of it from an act-consequence account.
  • Name at least three places where the scheme fails on the text's own evidence, and explain precisely what fails in each.
  • Describe how Chronicles handles the deaths of Josiah and the reign of Manasseh differently, and say what that shows about how the difficulty was perceived in antiquity.
  • Compare the last four verses of Kings with the last two verses of Chronicles and state what each does to a reader.

So Yahweh gave to Israel all the land which he swore to give to their fathers. They possessed it, and lived in it. Yahweh gave them rest all around, according to all that he swore to their fathers. Not a man of all their enemies stood before them. Yahweh delivered all their enemies into their hand. Nothing failed of any good thing which Yahweh had spoken to the house of Israel. All came to pass. — Joshua 21:43-45

World English Bible

Now Joshua was old and well advanced in years. Yahweh said to him, “You are old and advanced in years, and there remains yet very much land to be possessed. — Joshua 13:1

WEB

It shall be, when he sits on the throne of his kingdom, that he shall write himself a copy of this law in a book, out of that which is before the priests the Levites. It shall be with him, and he shall read from it all the days of his life; that he may learn to fear Yahweh his God, to keep all the words of this law and these statutes, to do them; that his heart not be lifted up above his brothers, and that he not turn aside from the commandment, to the right hand, or to the left; to the end that he may prolong his days in his kingdom, he and his children, in the midst of Israel. — Deuteronomy 17:18-20

WEB

I will be his father, and he shall be my son. If he commits iniquity, I will chasten him with the rod of men, and with the stripes of the children of men; but my loving kindness shall not depart from him, as I took it from Saul, whom I put away before you. Your house and your kingdom shall be made sure forever before you. Your throne shall be established forever.”’” — 2 Samuel 7:14-16

WEB

But will God in very deed dwell on the earth? Behold, heaven and the heaven of heavens can’t contain you; how much less this house that I have built! Yet have respect for the prayer of your servant, and for his supplication, Yahweh my God, to listen to the cry and to the prayer which your servant prays before you this day; that your eyes may be open toward this house night and day, even toward the place of which you have said, ‘My name shall be there;’ to listen to the prayer which your servant shall pray toward this place. — 1 Kings 8:27-29

WEB

But if you turn away from following me, you or your children, and not keep my commandments and my statutes which I have set before you, but shall go and serve other gods, and worship them; then I will cut off Israel out of the land which I have given them; and this house, which I have made holy for my name, will I cast out of my sight; and Israel shall be a proverb and a byword among all peoples. — 1 Kings 9:6-7

WEB

It was so, because the children of Israel had sinned against Yahweh their God, who brought them up out of the land of Egypt from under the hand of Pharaoh king of Egypt, and had feared other gods, and walked in the statutes of the nations, whom Yahweh cast out from before the children of Israel, and of the kings of Israel, which they made. — 2 Kings 17:7-8

WEB

Four themes, and for each of them the text says two things.

Land, as fulfilled gift:

Land, as unfinished condition, eight chapters earlier in the same book:

Kingship, as permitted and limited — Deuteronomy allows a king and immediately constrains him:

Kingship, as unconditional promise:

Temple, as the place of the name and not a container for God:

Temple, as a building that can be cut off:

Exile, as explained judgement:

Eight passages. Four pairs. Notice before going any further that in three of the four cases the two sides of the pair stand in the same book, and in the first case within eight chapters of each other. Whoever assembled this material was not troubled by the juxtaposition, or was troubled and left it anyway. Either way, a reading that keeps only one side of a pair is keeping less than the text offers.

1. Land: a gift with a clause attached

Begin with the theme that occupies the most physical space in the corpus. Roughly nine chapters of Joshua are lists of boundaries and towns. That is not an accident of preservation; it is a statement about what mattered.

The land in these books is never simply territory. It is given. The verb is used relentlessly, and the giver is named every time. Joshua 21:43-45 is the high point: everything promised, everything delivered, nothing failed. Walter Brueggemann's study of the theme argues that land in Israel's traditions functions as the concrete form of the promise — the place where the relationship becomes visible and testable — and that Israel's story can be read as a movement between landlessness and land, in both directions.

But the gift comes with a clause, and the clause is stated at the moment of arrival rather than added later in disappointment. Joshua 23, printed in the last lecture, tells the people at the moment of maximum security that the same God who brought the good things will bring the evil ones if they serve other gods. The land is held, not owned.

And there is a third element that is easy to miss and that undermines any tidy reading: the gift is described as complete and as incomplete in the same book. Joshua 21:45 says nothing failed; Joshua 13:1 says very much land remains to be possessed; Judges 1 gives a list of places the tribes could not take. Chapter 2 of this course examined how the models of Israel's emergence deal with that, and the redaction models in the last lecture each have an account of it — Smend, you will recall, built an entire redactional layer on exactly these passages. What matters theologically is that the corpus refuses to say either that the promise was fully realized or that it failed. It says both, and it leaves the reader to hold them.

One further point, which will matter in the next lecture. In Deuteronomy the gift of the land is explicitly detached from Israel's :

Don’t say in your heart, after Yahweh your God has thrust them out from before you, saying, “For my righteousness Yahweh has brought me in to possess this land”; because Yahweh drives them out before you because of the wickedness of these nations. — Deuteronomy 9:4 (WEB)

That verse is a control on the land theology. It denies the inference that possession proves righteousness — which is the inference every later reader has been tempted to draw, and the inference on which a certain use of these books depends.

2. Kingship: allowed, and never trusted

The second theme is the one on which the corpus is most obviously divided, and chapter 5 of this course dealt with the division in detail at 1 Samuel 8-12. Here we are interested in the settled result.

Three positions coexist in the text. Deuteronomy 17 permits a king and hedges him with restrictions so severe that they read as a critique: no multiplying of horses, no multiplying of wives, no accumulation of silver and gold, and a personal copy of the law to be read for life so that his heart is not lifted above his brothers. It is a licence written by someone who expects the licensee to abuse it. 1 Samuel 8 treats the request for a king as a rejection of God and lists what a king will take — sons, daughters, fields, a tenth, and finally the people themselves. And 2 Samuel 7 promises David a house forever, in terms which include a guarantee that misconduct will be punished without the promise being withdrawn.

The history that follows does not choose between these. It runs them simultaneously. Solomon acquires exactly the horses, wives and gold that Deuteronomy 17 forbids, and the narrator makes the connection plain enough for anyone who knows the law. Every northern king is condemned; most southern kings are condemned; and yet the dynasty continues, and the reason given, repeatedly, is David.

The deepest form of the question is whether the Davidic promise is conditional. Psalm 89 and Psalm 132 stress the two sides differently, and the history itself contains both formulations: the unconditional one at 2 Samuel 7:14-16, and conditional ones at 1 Kings 2:4 and 1 Kings 9:6-7. Cross, as the last lecture noted, treats the conditional forms as exilic insertions, which is a composition answer to a theological question. But even a reader who rejects that analysis has to reckon with both formulations being present in the finished book, and with the fact that the book ends with the dynasty deposed and one of its members eating at a foreign table.

What the corpus achieves through this doubleness is something an unambiguous position could not achieve. Kingship is real, God-given, and worth having; and it is also the institution that took the country to ruin. Both statements are in the text about the same institution.

3. Temple: the place of the name, and the thing that can be trusted wrongly

Solomon's prayer at the dedication is the theological centre of the temple theme, and the striking thing about it is how carefully it avoids saying that God lives in the building.

Moshe Weinfeld argued at length that Deuteronomy and the literature shaped by it operate with what is usually called a name theology: God dwells in heaven, and what is present in the sanctuary is his name — his self-designation, his availability to be addressed. The formula is everywhere in the corpus: the place where Yahweh will cause his name to dwell; "my name shall be there." Tryggve Mettinger has traced this as a deliberate development away from older language of the divine glory filling the sanctuary. Whether the development is as clean as Weinfeld proposed is disputed, but the language of 1 Kings 8:27 is not disputed: heaven and the heaven of heavens cannot contain God, much less this house.

Set against that is the danger the same theme carries, and here the historical books are illuminated by a prophet who was watching the last years of Judah:

Thus says Yahweh of Armies, the God of Israel, “Amend your ways and your doings, and I will cause you to dwell in this place. Don’t trust in lying words, saying, ‛Yahweh’s temple, Yahweh’s temple, Yahweh’s temple, are these.’ — Jeremiah 7:3-4 (WEB)

Jeremiah is attacking a specific confidence: that the presence of the sanctuary guarantees the safety of the city. That confidence is not a distortion invented by wicked people; it is a reasonable inference from the deliverance of Jerusalem in 701, narrated in 2 Kings 19, when Sennacherib withdrew and the city stood. Chapter 8 examined that episode. A generation that had been taught the lesson of 701 had every reason to expect it to hold in 587, and the historical books have to explain why it did not.

Their answer is 1 Kings 9:6-7: the house is God's, and God can throw it out of his sight. The temple is not a guarantee. And then 2 Kings 25:9 records, in a flat sentence, that he burnt Yahweh's house. There is no theological commentary attached to the burning. The commentary was given in advance, at the dedication, three hundred and eighty years earlier in narrated time.

4. Exile: judgement, and not the end

The fourth theme is where the corpus does its heaviest work, because the exile is the event that all of it is addressed to.

The judgement side is explicit at 2 Kings 17:7-23 for the north and at 2 Kings 24:1-4 for the south. The passage on Samaria is the fullest theological statement in the whole history: a list of what was done, a list of the warnings sent, and a conclusion. It is a sentence handed down, not a lament.

The other side is less obvious and more important. Solomon's dedication prayer, at 1 Kings 8:46-50, anticipates the exile in detail — captivity in a far country, repentance there, prayer directed back toward the land and the city and the house — and asks that such prayer be heard. Whatever you conclude about when that prayer was written, its presence in the book means the work provides an instruction for people already deported. Hans Walter Wolff built his reading of the whole corpus on that instruction. It does not promise a return. It says what to do.

And there is Deuteronomy 4:25-27, quoted in this chapter's overview, which continues in verses 29-31 with a promise that seeking from there will find. Again: not a guaranteed restoration, but a door not closed.

So the fourth doubleness. The exile is deserved, and the corpus refuses to say it is final.

5. The scheme underneath: retribution

Now the thing that ties the four together, and the most dangerous idea in this chapter.

The historical books explain events by moral cause. Obedience yields security in the land; disobedience yields loss of it. Judges 2:11-19 is the frame of an entire book stated as a repeating cycle. The regnal formulae of Kings grade each king by one criterion and correlate his reign with the fortunes of the state. 2 Kings 17 gives the causes of the northern collapse as a list of religious offences, not as a list of Assyrian army corps.

Gerhard von Rad's classic account of this described the corpus as governed by a doctrine of retribution, sustained by the word of God moving through history and enforcing itself. That description has stood for seventy years and it is broadly right about what the text does.

How does retribution work?

This is a point where readers will not agree, and the disagreement is about the mechanism rather than the pattern. Klaus Koch argued in an influential 1955 essay that Old Testament texts do not generally present a judge weighing an offence and assigning a penalty, but something more like a built-in consequence: an act sets in motion a sphere that returns upon the actor, and God's role is to superintend that return rather than to impose an unrelated punishment. Koch's evidence was largely in the wisdom and prophetic literature, and the phrase usually used for his proposal in English is the act-consequence connection. Others — Jon Levenson among them — have insisted that the framework is genuinely juridical, that Deuteronomy 28 reads like a treaty with sanctions because it is modelled on treaties with sanctions, and that a treaty sanction is imposed, not organic. The two accounts predict differently in one respect worth noticing: on Koch's, the consequence follows the deed closely and naturally; on the juridical account, a sovereign may defer, remit, or transfer a penalty, and that is not an anomaly but a prerogative. Keep both in mind for the next section, because the failures of the scheme look different depending on which mechanism you assume.

Whichever account you take, retribution is doing real explanatory work in these books, and it is doing something valuable. It is the reason the corpus does not explain the defeat of Israel by the strength of Assyrian gods. Every other ancient Near Eastern nation that lost a war had that explanation available and most took it. Israel's historians took the harder one. The next lecture will argue that this is one of the most remarkable things about the collection.

But it does not work everywhere, and the places where it does not work are not small.

6. Where it fails, first: Josiah

Josiah is the summit of the history's evaluation. The formula at 2 Kings 23:25 is unique: no king before him and none after him turned to Yahweh with all his heart, soul and might, according to all the law of Moses. In a book that grades every monarch, that is the highest possible mark.

He is also given a specific prophetic promise. When the law book is found and Josiah tears his clothes, the prophet Huldah is consulted, and this is what she sends back:

because your heart was tender, and you humbled yourself before Yahweh, when you heard what I spoke against this place, and against its inhabitants, that they should become a desolation and a curse, and have torn your clothes, and wept before me; I also have heard you,’ says Yahweh. ‘Therefore behold, I will gather you to your fathers, and you shall be gathered to your grave in peace, neither shall your eyes see all the evil which I will bring on this place.’”’” They brought back this message to the king. — 2 Kings 22:19-20 (WEB)

Gathered to your grave in peace. Then, six chapters later:

In his days Pharaoh Necoh king of Egypt went up against the king of Assyria to the river Euphrates: and king Josiah went against him; and Pharaoh Necoh killed him at Megiddo, when he had seen him. His servants carried him in a chariot dead from Megiddo, and brought him to Jerusalem, and buried him in his own tomb. The people of the land took Jehoahaz the son of Josiah, and anointed him, and made him king in his father’s place. — 2 Kings 23:29-30 (WEB)

He was about thirty-nine. He died of arrow wounds on a battlefield, in a war that was not his, having intercepted an Egyptian army moving north. Judah lost its independence within three months of his death; his son Jehoahaz reigned for three months and was deported to Egypt.

Now consider what the scheme requires. The best king in the history should have the best outcome available. He receives instead a violent early death, and the country's collapse begins immediately. And the narrator says nothing. There is no explanation offered, no fault identified, no comment of any kind. The verse that reports the death of the most highly praised king in the book is shorter and flatter than the verses that report the accession of nonentities.

The various attempts to make this fit are worth stating, because seeing them fail is instructive. Some read "in peace" as meaning only "before the disaster," so that Huldah's promise is about not seeing of Jerusalem rather than about the manner of death; the promise is then technically kept, since Josiah died twenty-two years before 587. That is a possible reading of the words, and it is the reading that saves the prophecy — but it requires "gathered to your grave in peace" to be compatible with being shot on a battlefield, which is not the natural sense of the phrase in Hebrew or in any other language. Others suggest a fault: that Josiah should not have gone out against Necho. The book of Kings says nothing of the kind. And a reader who supplies a fault the text does not supply has stopped reading the text and started repairing it.

The honest description is this. The book of Kings contains a prophecy of a peaceful death and a narrative of a violent one, and offers no reconciliation. If the retribution scheme is a complete account of how these books explain events, this is a place where the books do not explain.

7. Where it fails, second: Manasseh

The second failure runs the other way and is even harder.

Manasseh was twelve years old when he began to reign; and he reigned fifty-five years in Jerusalem: and his mother’s name was Hephzibah. — 2 Kings 21:1 (WEB)

Fifty-five years is the longest reign recorded for any king of Israel or Judah. And this is the king of whom the same book says:

“Because Manasseh king of Judah has done these abominations, and has done wickedly above all that the Amorites did, who were before him, and has made Judah also to sin with his idols; therefore thus says Yahweh, the God of Israel, ‘Behold, I bring such evil on Jerusalem and Judah, that whoever hears of it, both his ears shall tingle. — 2 Kings 21:11-12 (WEB)

Worse than the nations Israel dispossessed. The direct cause of the exile, named as such twice. And he dies old, in his bed, after more than half a century on the throne, and is buried in his own garden, and is succeeded by his son.

Length of reign is not an incidental detail in this corpus. Deuteronomy 17:20 makes it the reward attached to a king who keeps the law: "to the end that he may prolong his days in his kingdom." The history reports the years of every reign as a matter of course, and readers are clearly expected to notice them. On the terms the books themselves establish, Manasseh received the reward the law attaches to obedience, in the largest measure ever recorded, and the book states his wickedness in the strongest terms it has.

Put the two failures side by side and the shape of the problem is clear. The best king dies young and violently; the worst king dies old and peacefully. That is not a marginal exception to the scheme. It is the scheme inverted at both ends, in the two most theologically weighted reigns in the book.

8. Where it fails, third: guilt transferred to people who were not there

The third failure is different in kind, because here the book contradicts not the outcome but the law.

The reason given for the destruction of Jerusalem is Manasseh, who died in about 642:

Surely at the commandment of Yahweh came this on Judah, to remove them out of his sight, for the sins of Manasseh, according to all that he did, and also for the innocent blood that he shed; for he filled Jerusalem with innocent blood: and Yahweh would not pardon. — 2 Kings 24:3-4 (WEB)

The events being explained happened in 597 and 587 — forty-five to fifty-five years after Manasseh's death, to a population that included people who had not been born when he reigned. And the law in Deuteronomy says:

The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers. Every man shall be put to death for his own sin. — Deuteronomy 24:16 (WEB)

It would be possible to argue that the historian simply did not know that law, or held some older view of collective guilt untouched by it. That argument is not available, because the historian quotes the law, approvingly, as the reason for a king's restraint:

As soon as the kingdom was established in his hand, he killed his servants who had slain the king his father: but the children of the murderers he didn’t put to death; according to that which is written in the book of the law of Moses, as Yahweh commanded, saying, “The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, nor the children be put to death for the fathers; but every man shall die for his own sin.” — 2 Kings 14:5-6 (WEB)

So the same book, in the same theological idiom, praises a king for refusing to punish children for their fathers, and then explains the national catastrophe as the punishment of children for their father. Both statements are deliberate. Neither is a slip.

Some things can be said in mitigation and should be said accurately. Deuteronomy 24:16 is a rule for human courts, addressed to judges, and its subject is judicial execution; it does not obviously legislate for divine action, and other texts in the same corpus speak of God visiting iniquity to the third and fourth generation. A distinction between a court's competence and God's is defensible and has been defended. The corporate character of ancient Israelite thinking about a people is also real: a nation is a continuous body, and its history is one history. Ezekiel 18, written in the exile, argues at length against exactly the proverb that the fathers ate sour grapes and the children's teeth are set on edge — which shows that the objection was live at the time and that at least one prophet answered it.

All of that is true, and none of it dissolves the difficulty. The point stands: 2 Kings has an explanation of the exile that its own law forbids a human judge to use, and the book does not tell us how to hold the two together. On the juridical account of retribution mentioned above, a sovereign may defer a penalty, and Manasseh's punishment falling on a later generation is a deferral rather than an injustice. On Koch's act-consequence account, that move is much harder, because a consequence that returns on somebody else is not a consequence in Koch's sense at all. Notice that the choice between the two accounts of the mechanism is not decorative; it changes whether this text is a difficulty or a doctrine.

9. A fourth, smaller, and worth naming

There is a further pattern that a careful reader of Kings will notice and that fits none of the schemes cleanly. Good kings are repeatedly given a qualification: Asa, Jehoshaphat, Joash, Amaziah, Azariah, Jotham each receive a favourable verdict followed by the note that the high places were not taken away. So the evaluation apparatus itself has a category for partial obedience with unclear consequences. And Ahab, at 1 Kings 21:27-29, humbles himself after Naboth's murder and is told that the evil will come in his son's days instead of his own — another deferral, this time explicit and presented as mercy. The scheme is not applied mechanically even by the narrator who invented it.

10. What Chronicles does about it

Here is the piece of evidence that shows this is not a modern complaint. The Chronicler, writing later, working with Samuel-Kings or with a source very close to it, addressed both of the great failures directly.

On Josiah, Chronicles supplies the missing fault:

But he sent ambassadors to him, saying, “What have I to do with you, you king of Judah? I come not against you this day, but against the house with which I have war. God has commanded me to make haste. Beware that it is God who is with me, that he not destroy you.” Nevertheless Josiah would not turn his face from him, but disguised himself, that he might fight with him, and didn’t listen to the words of Neco from the mouth of God, and came to fight in the valley of Megiddo. — 2 Chronicles 35:21-22 (WEB)

In Kings, Josiah simply goes and is killed. In Chronicles, an Egyptian pharaoh delivers a word from God, Josiah does not listen, and dies. The gap has been closed. A disobedience is now on record, and the death has a cause.

On Manasseh, Chronicles supplies the missing repentance:

Therefore Yahweh brought on them the captains of the army of the king of Assyria, who took Manasseh in chains, and bound him with fetters, and carried him to Babylon. When he was in distress, he begged Yahweh his God, and humbled himself greatly before the God of his fathers. He prayed to him; and he was entreated by him, and heard his supplication, and brought him again to Jerusalem into his kingdom. Then Manasseh knew that Yahweh was God. — 2 Chronicles 33:11-13 (WEB)

Manasseh is punished — deported, in chains — and then repents and is restored. The long reign is no longer an unpunished wickedness; it is the reign of a man who was disciplined and turned. And in Chronicles the exile is not blamed on Manasseh at all; the causes are located in the last kings and in the generation that actually went.

What the Chronicler does

This is a point where readers will not agree about what the Chronicler is doing here. One reading, which chapter 9 of this course set out, is that Chronicles is a corrective rewriting: the theology of Kings had a visible hole in it, and the Chronicler patched it, at the cost of historical plausibility. Sara Japhet and H. G. M. Williamson have argued, in different ways, that this misdescribes the project. On their account Chronicles is answering a different question for a different community — a small province with a rebuilt temple and no king — and it operates with a principle of immediate retribution, in which each generation receives its own outcome, precisely because a post-exilic congregation needed to know that it was not condemned by Manasseh. There is also a historical consideration that cuts across the literary one: Assyrian records list Manasseh as a tribute-paying vassal of Esarhaddon and Ashurbanipal, and a summons of a vassal king to the imperial court is a documented Assyrian practice, so the Chronicler's episode is not intrinsically impossible even though Kings does not mention it.

Either way, the observation this lecture needs is the same. An ancient editor, working within the same theological tradition, looked at the deaths of Josiah and Manasseh and found the account in Kings unsatisfactory, and did something about it. The strain in the retribution scheme is not something modern criticism invented. It was felt inside the .

And Kings did not adopt the fix. Both books stand. Whatever one thinks of the Chronicler's solution, the tradition kept the version without a solution, and kept it first.

11. Two endings

Which brings us to the last thing. These books do not end in one place.

Kings ends like this:

In the thirty-seventh year of the captivity of Jehoiachin king of Judah, in the twelfth month, on the seven and twentieth day of the month, Evilmerodach king of Babylon, in the year that he began to reign, lifted up the head of Jehoiachin king of Judah out of prison; and he spoke kindly to him, and set his throne above the throne of the kings who were with him in Babylon, and changed his prison garments. Jehoiachin ate bread before him continually all the days of his life: and for his allowance, there was a continual allowance given him of the king, every day a portion, all the days of his life. — 2 Kings 25:27-30 (WEB)

Chapter 8 of this course set out the long argument about these verses — Noth reading them as a bare last dated fact, von Rad reading them as the Davidic line kept alive on purpose. Both readings survive because the text supports both. What is not in dispute is what happens: a descendant of David is alive, is treated well, and is dependent, permanently, on a foreign king's daily allowance. The house of David ends the book as a pensioner. Also worth knowing: ration tablets excavated at Babylon, from the reign of Nebuchadnezzar, record allotments of oil to "Yaukin king of the land of Yahudu" and his sons. The last four verses of Kings describe an arrangement of a kind that is externally attested.

Chronicles ends like this:

Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that Yahweh’s word by the mouth of Jeremiah might be accomplished, Yahweh stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia, so that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying, “Thus says Cyrus king of Persia, ‘Yahweh, the God of heaven, has given all the kingdoms of the earth to me; and he has commanded me to build him a house in Jerusalem, which is in Judah. Whoever there is among you of all his people, Yahweh his God be with him, and let him go up.’” — 2 Chronicles 36:22-23 (WEB)

The last word of the Hebrew Bible, in the Jewish canonical order, is a verb of ascent: let him go up. The book breaks off mid-decree — Ezra 1:1-4 continues the same text — and the effect of stopping there is that the collection closes on an unfinished permission. Not a return achieved; a return authorized, with the going still to be done.

Two endings, and they leave a reader holding different things. Kings leaves you with a man eating at another king's table every day of his life, and a burned temple twenty-six verses earlier. Chronicles leaves you at a doorway. Neither is a summary of the other, and the difference is not decoration. It is the difference between a work written to explain a catastrophe and a work written for a community that had come out the other side of one — and the canon has kept both, in that order, which is itself a decision about how the story is to be heard.

12. What to carry away

Four themes, each held double. A retribution scheme that is genuinely the explanatory frame of these books and genuinely fails at its two most important test cases. An ancient repair of those failures, in Chronicles, which the tradition preserved alongside the unrepaired version rather than instead of it. And two endings that do not agree.

If you find that unsatisfying, the dissatisfaction is the correct response and should be kept rather than resolved. A theology of the historical books that has no loose ends has been tidied by its author. The books themselves are not tidy, and the untidiness is where they are most worth reading: a tradition that keeps a prophecy alongside its own falsification, and a book that blames the exile on a man dead half a century while quoting a law that forbids exactly that, is a tradition that did not edit itself into consistency when it easily could have.

The scheme, and the three places it does not hold Four themes held double · one explanatory frame · and its counter-evidence, left standing What the text affirms What the same text also affirms Land — given, and all of it (Josh 21:43-45) Nothing failed of any good thing. Land — held on a clause (Josh 13:1; 23:15-16) Very much land remains; and it can be lost. Kingship — promised forever (2 Sam 7:14-16) Chastened, but never withdrawn. Kingship — fenced and feared (Deut 17:18-20) A licence written expecting abuse; 1 Sam 8 warns. Temple — the name dwells (1 Kgs 8:27-29) Heaven cannot contain him; his name is there. Temple — can be cast off (1 Kgs 9:6-7) And is: 2 Kgs 25:9, without comment. Exile — deserved judgement (2 Kgs 17:7-8) A sentence handed down, not a lament. Exile — not the end (1 Kgs 8:46-50) Instructions for people already deported. Retribution holds all four together — and it very nearly works Josiah Best king in the book (2 Kgs 23:25). Promised a grave in peace (22:20). Shot at Megiddo, aged about 39. No comment. Manasseh Worst king in the book (2 Kgs 21:11). Named as the cause of the exile. Reigned 55 years — the longest of any king. Transferred guilt 587 blamed on a king dead 55 years (24:3-4), though Deut 24:16 forbids it and 2 Kgs 14:6 quotes that law with approval. Kings ends (25:27-30) A king of Judah on a daily allowance, at a foreign table, for life. Chronicles ends (36:22-23) A decree breaking off mid-sentence, on a verb of ascent: let him go up.

Read the diagram downward. The top half is the synthesis and it is defensible. The amber row is what the synthesis cannot absorb, and it is in the text at the two points the text cares about most. The bottom row is where the corpus stops, twice, differently.

6. Further Reading

  • Gerhard von Rad, Old Testament Theology, volume 1 (Harper, 1962), especially the section on the Deuteronomistic theology of history — the classic statement of the retribution reading, and still the clearest.
  • Walter Brueggemann, The Land: Place as Gift, Promise, and Challenge in Biblical Faith, 2nd edition (Fortress, 2002) — the land theme across the whole canon, with the double-sidedness argued rather than assumed.
  • Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (Oxford University Press, 1972) — the source of the name-theology discussion and of the treaty-form analysis of the sanctions.
  • Tryggve N. D. Mettinger, The Dethronement of Sabaoth: Studies in the Shem and Kabod Theologies (Gleerup, 1982) — the case that name theology is a deliberate development, and the qualifications it needs.
  • Klaus Koch, "Is There a Doctrine of Retribution in the Old Testament?", in James L. Crenshaw, ed., in the Old Testament (Fortress, 1983) — the act-consequence proposal in English, in a volume that also contains the replies to it.
  • Sara Japhet, The Ideology of the Book of Chronicles and Its Place in Biblical Thought (Peter Lang, 1989) — immediate retribution as the Chronicler's own theology rather than as a patch.
  • H. G. M. Williamson, 1 and 2 Chronicles, New Century Bible (Eerdmans, 1982) — a commentary that argues the Josiah and Manasseh passages carefully against the Kings parallels.
  • Marvin A. Sweeney, King Josiah of Judah: The Lost Messiah of Israel (Oxford University Press, 2001) — a book-length treatment of what Josiah's reign and death do to the theology of Kings.
  • Jon D. Levenson, Sinai and Zion: An Entry into the Jewish Bible (Harper, 1985) — covenant, treaty and temple read together, from a Jewish perspective that a Christian reader should not skip.
  • Donald E. Gowan, Theology of the Prophetic Books: The Death and Resurrection of Israel (Westminster John Knox, 1998) — useful for setting the historical books' account of the exile beside the prophetic accounts, including Ezekiel 18.

핵심 요약

  • Land, kingship, temple and exile are each held double: gift and unfinished task, promise and fence, God's name and a house that can be cast off, deserved judgement and not the end.
  • Retribution holds the four together, and the books state it themselves. Von Rad calls it a doctrine of retribution. Koch reads an act-consequence link, while Levenson reads a juridical covenant with imposed sanctions.
  • The scheme fails with Josiah, the best king, who was promised a grave in peace (2 Kings 22:20) but was killed at Megiddo. The narrator gives no comment.
  • It also fails with Manasseh, the worst king, who reigned 55 years. The exile is blamed on him, though 2 Kings 14:6 quotes the law against punishing children for their fathers.
  • Chronicles supplies a fault for Josiah and a repentance for Manasseh. Japhet and Williamson read this as a different project, not a patch. The strain was felt inside the canon, and both books stand.
  • Kings ends with Jehoiachin on a foreign allowance, and Chronicles ends on an unfinished decree: "let him go up."

Topic: This lecture sets out the four themes and the retribution scheme of the historical books, shows where the scheme fails, and compares the two endings.

Remember: The retribution scheme is the books' own frame, and it fails at Josiah, Manasseh and the transfer of guilt. The canon kept the failures and did not edit them away.

Caution: Do not tidy the books into one neat argument, and do not supply faults the text does not give (for example, blaming Josiah). The lecture leaves the difficulties standing.

One line to carry into ministry: Do not teach that good people always prosper and bad people always suffer. Scripture itself keeps the cases that break that rule.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • For each of the four themes, find one further text on each side of the pair, from a book this lecture did not use for that theme. Does the doubleness hold across the corpus, or is it concentrated in particular books?
  • State the retribution scheme in one sentence, as a defender of it would state it. Then state the strongest objection to it drawn only from 2 Kings. Which sentence took longer to write, and why might that be?
  • Huldah promises Josiah a grave in peace. Set out the reading that saves the prophecy and the reading that does not, and say what each costs. Is there a third option that neither saves nor abandons it?
  • Manasseh reigns fifty-five years. Suppose you were the exilic editor of Kings and had noticed this. What could you have done about it, and why might you have chosen to do nothing?
  • Compare 2 Kings 14:6 with 2 Kings 24:3-4. Write the strongest defence you can of the position that these two texts are consistent. Then write the strongest case that they are not. Do not decide.
  • Chronicles supplies Josiah with a fault and Manasseh with a repentance. Is that better history, better theology, both, or neither? Answer in a way a reader who disagrees with you would recognize as fair.
  • Read 2 Kings 25:27-30 and 2 Chronicles 36:22-23 to someone who does not know the books, without telling them which is which, and ask what each one leaves them expecting. Report what they said.
  • Koch's act-consequence account and the juridical account of retribution differ over whether a penalty can be deferred or transferred. Take one text from this lecture and show that the two accounts read it differently. Which account handles that text with fewer additional assumptions?
  • This lecture claims that a theology of the historical books with no loose ends has been tidied by its author. Test that claim against a study Bible introduction or a systematic theology you have to hand. What did it leave out, and was the omission innocent?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.