Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
- Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
- Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
- Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
- Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
- Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
- Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
- Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
- Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
- Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
- Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
- Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
- Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
- Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
- Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
- Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
- Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
- Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
- Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
- Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
- Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
- Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
- Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
- Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
- Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
- Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
- Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
- Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
- Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
- Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
- Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
- Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
- Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
The first king of Israel is rejected twice, in two chapters two chapters apart, for two different things, and the second rejection turns on a command to destroy a population entirely. This lecture is about how a reader should handle that.
Three claims organise it. The first is that Saul was, by the book's own account, a capable and largely successful war leader, and that the caricature of a doomed incompetent is not supported by the text. Trap number five of this course warns against stock villains, and Saul is the standing example in these books. Chapter 14 credits him with victories against Moab, Ammon, Edom, Zobah, the Philistines and the Amalekites; the same chapter shows him building an army out of any capable man he found; and the men who go through the night to retrieve his body from a Philistine wall at the end of the book are the men he rescued in chapter 11.
The second claim concerns the rejections. The offence at Gilgal in chapter 13 — offering a sacrifice after waiting seven days for a prophet who did not come — has struck many readers as disproportionate to a sentence of dynastic extinction, and their unease is not naive; it is the starting point of a serious body of scholarship. The offence in chapter 15 is different in kind: a direct order was given and was not carried out. What the two have in common, and whether the narrative treats Saul fairly, is genuinely contested, and this lecture sets out the main positions with their representatives.
The third claim is about the command in chapter 15 itself, and here the lecture must be careful about scope. The ethical problem of the ban — Hebrew herem, the devoting of a population to destruction — was set out in full in lecture 2-2 of this course, where the principal approaches were named and weighed: the argument from ancient war rhetoric and its conventional exaggeration, the reading that the texts describe dispossession rather than slaughter, the appeal to development within the canon, and the position that refuses a defence and lets the difficulty stand. This lecture does not repeat that survey. It does something narrower and, for a student who has read chapter 2, more useful: it asks what is distinctive about 1 Samuel 15, and shows that three features of this chapter put particular pressure on approaches that work better in Joshua. No land is at stake here. The stated ground is retribution for something done centuries earlier. And the plot of the chapter depends on an exact accounting of exactly who and what survived, which is an awkward foundation for a reading built on rhetorical exaggeration.
The lecture ends with the last sixteen chapters, and specifically with the way the narrative treats Saul once he has been rejected. Two scenes matter most: the occasions in chapters 24 and 26 when Saul weeps and calls David more righteous than himself, and the night at Endor when a woman whom Saul had driven out of the land gives him the last meal of his life. Neither scene is required by any apologetic purpose, and any account of this book has to say why they are in it.
이 42분으로 얻는 것
- Describe Saul's military and administrative achievements as the book reports them, and explain why the stock portrait of him is a misreading.
- Set out what happens at Gilgal in chapter 13, state at least three proposals about what Saul's offence was, and name representatives of each.
- Explain what is distinctive about the command in chapter 15 compared with the ban texts in Joshua, and say what pressure each distinctive feature puts on the standard approaches.
- State the tension between 1 Samuel 15:11 and 15:29 and describe at least two ways interpreters have handled it, without resolving it in a sentence.
- Explain the "History of David's Rise" hypothesis and the apology comparison, name its supporters and its critics, and identify the passages that are hardest for an apologetic reading to explain.
Samuel said, “Has Yahweh as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of Yahweh? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams. For rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft, and stubbornness is as idolatry and teraphim. Because you have rejected Yahweh’s word, he has also rejected you from being king.” — 1 Samuel 15:22-23
World English Bible
Thus says Yahweh of Armies, ‘I have marked that which Amalek did to Israel, how he set himself against him on the way, when he came up out of Egypt. Now go and strike Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and don’t spare them; but kill both man and woman, infant and nursing baby, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’” — 1 Samuel 15:2-3
WEB
Samuel said to Saul, “You have done foolishly. You have not kept the commandment of Yahweh your God, which he commanded you; for now Yahweh would have established your kingdom on Israel forever. But now your kingdom shall not continue. Yahweh has sought for himself a man after his own heart, and Yahweh has appointed him to be prince over his people, because you have not kept that which Yahweh commanded you.” — 1 Samuel 13:13-14
WEB
It grieves me that I have set up Saul to be king; for he is turned back from following me, and has not performed my commandments.” Samuel was angry; and he cried to Yahweh all night. — 1 Samuel 15:11
WEB
Also the Strength of Israel will not lie nor repent; for he is not a man, that he should repent.” — 1 Samuel 15:29
WEB
Now the Spirit of Yahweh departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from Yahweh troubled him. — 1 Samuel 16:14
WEB
He said to David, “You are more righteous than I; for you have done good to me, whereas I have done evil to you. — 1 Samuel 24:17
WEB
The woman came to Saul, and saw that he was very troubled, and said to him, “Behold, your handmaid has listened to your voice, and I have put my life in my hand, and have listened to your words which you spoke to me. — 1 Samuel 28:21
WEB
When the inhabitants of Jabesh Gilead heard concerning him that which the Philistines had done to Saul, all the valiant men arose, and went all night, and took the body of Saul and the bodies of his sons from the wall of Beth Shan; and they came to Jabesh, and burnt them there. — 1 Samuel 31:11-12
WEB
The most quoted verse in the book, and it is almost always quoted without its chapter. Read where it stands, it is a rebuke for failing to complete a massacre. That does not make its principle false, and the principle — that obedience is not purchasable with religious observance — is repeated by the prophets and taken up in the New Testament. It does mean that anyone who uses this verse as an uncomplicated maxim has not read the twenty-one verses before it.
State it before interpreting it. The command is comprehensive, it names the categories explicitly, and the reason given is an event placed generations in the past.
The first rejection, and the sentence is dynastic. Note the phrase a man after his own heart, which in Hebrew idiom means a man of God's own choosing rather than a testimonial to David's character — a distinction worth keeping in view when you reach 2 Samuel 11 in chapter 6 of this course.
Eighteen verses apart, in one chapter, and the same Hebrew verb stands behind grieves in the first and repent in the second.
A sentence that has troubled readers in every century, and which the lecture will not smooth over.
Saul says this, weeping, having just been spared. He says something very like it again in 26:21. The narrator lets him.
The woman at Endor, speaking to the king who had outlawed her profession on pain of death. What she then does is cook him a meal.
The last act of the book. It is performed by the town Saul saved in chapter 11, and it costs them a night march into Philistine-held territory.
1. Saul as the book actually reports him
Begin where the caricature does not.
Now when Saul had taken the kingdom over Israel, he fought against all his enemies on every side, against Moab, and against the children of Ammon, and against Edom, and against the kings of Zobah, and against the Philistines: and wherever he turned himself, he defeated them. He did valiantly, and struck the Amalekites, and delivered Israel out of the hands of those who plundered them. — 1 Samuel 14:47-48 (WEB)
That is a summary of the sort Kings gives to a successful king. Add to it the picture in 13:19-22, where the Philistines maintain a monopoly on ironworking so that no Israelite smith exists and only Saul and Jonathan possess a sword or spear — a detail that fits what archaeology shows of the transition to iron in this region, and which means Saul's campaigns were conducted by a militia armed with farm tools. Add 14:52, which reports that whenever Saul saw a capable man he took him into his service: that is the beginning of a standing army, an administrative innovation, and the text records it without complaint. Add chapter 11, where Saul's response to a threat of mutilation against Jabesh Gilead is to muster the whole country in a day and to refuse, afterwards, to execute the men who had mocked him.
Saul's failures, when they come, are the failures of a man under pressure who acts and is wrong to have acted. The rash oath in 14:24 that nearly kills Jonathan is characteristic: it is an excess of zeal, not a lack of it, and the people overrule it. This is a portrait with weight. Whatever the narrative's ultimate verdict, it is not the portrait of a fool.
A broken number
A note on the regnal formula. Chapter 13 opens with the standard notice of a king's age at accession and length of reign, and in the Hebrew text the numbers are missing or corrupt: literally it reads that Saul was a year old when he became king and reigned two years over Israel. The WEB renders it as best it can — Saul reigned a year; and when he had reigned two years over Israel — and the awkwardness in the English reflects a real awkwardness in the Hebrew, not an error of translation. The verse is absent altogether from the principal manuscripts of the Greek . Acts 13:21 gives Saul a reign of forty years, and the reign must in any case have been long enough for Saul's son Ishbosheth to be forty years old at his father's death, according to 2 Samuel 2:10. This is a textual problem, it has never been solved, and the honest procedure is to report it rather than to choose a number. Trap number four of this course applies: a figure you cannot defend should not be asserted.
2. The first rejection: Gilgal, chapter 13
The situation is desperate. A Philistine force is at Michmash; the Israelite militia is deserting into caves and across the Jordan. Samuel had set a seven-day appointment. Saul waits the seven days, and on the seventh, with his army dissolving, he offers the burnt offering himself. Samuel arrives as he finishes.
Samuel's charge is that Saul has not kept the commandment of Yahweh, and the sentence is that his kingdom will not continue.
This is a point where readers will not agree, and the disagreement is about what the offence was.
That Saul usurped a priestly function. This is the traditional reading and it is the one most students arrive with. The difficulty is that the text does not say so. Samuel does not accuse him of sacrificing; he asks what he has done and then charges him with disobeying a commandment. And elsewhere in these books, sacrifice by a king passes without comment: David sacrifices in 2 Samuel 6 and 24, Solomon in 1 Kings 3 and 8. If a general prohibition existed, Kings does not seem to know about it.
That Saul disobeyed a specific standing instruction. V. Philips Long argues that 10:8, where Samuel tells Saul to go down to Gilgal and wait seven days until he comes, is precisely such an instruction, and that chapter 13 is its test. On this account the point is not the sacrifice but the waiting: Saul was told to wait for a word and he acted instead, at exactly the moment when waiting would have cost him something. The chapter reinforces this by having Samuel arrive as soon as the offering is finished. Long's reading makes the episode coherent, and its weakness is the long gap between 10:8 and 13:8 with three chapters of unrelated material in between — which a source critic naturally reads as evidence that 10:8 was inserted to supply the missing instruction.
That the charge is disproportionate, and the narrative knows it. David M. Gunn, in The Fate of King Saul, presses this hard. Saul does everything a responsible commander could do; he waits the full period; he acts only when the army is dissolving; and he loses his dynasty for it. Gunn reads Saul as a genuinely tragic figure, caught in what he calls the dark side of God — a God who in this book raises a king reluctantly, gives him a task, and then rejects him for a fault that in another man might have been overlooked. Gunn is not making a devotional point in reverse; he is arguing that the narrative itself generates sympathy for Saul and that readers who feel it are responding to the text rather than misreading it.
That the material is Judahite apologetic. Diana V. Edelman, in King Saul in the Historiography of Judah, and in a different register Baruch Halpern, in David's Secret Demons, argue that our sources for Saul come to us through a tradition committed to the legitimacy of the house that replaced him. On this view the rejection accounts do the work that dynastic changes always require: they explain why the previous ruler had to go. That does not mean the accounts are invented. It means they are interested testimony, and interested testimony is the ordinary condition of ancient royal historiography rather than a special defect of this book.
Notice, again, what the positions do not dispute. Nobody denies that the sentence is severe. The dispute is over whether the severity is explained by a specific disobedience, by the narrative's tragic design, or by the interests of the tradition that transmitted it.
3. The second rejection: Amalek, chapter 15
Now the harder chapter.
What the text says, before anything is done with it. Samuel delivers a command in the name of Yahweh of Armies. The ground is stated: what Amalek did to Israel on the way up out of Egypt. The instruction is to strike Amalek and put everything under the ban — utterly destroy in the WEB, Hebrew herem, the devoting of persons and property to destruction so that nothing is taken as spoil — and the categories are itemised: man and woman, infant and nursing baby, ox and sheep, camel and donkey. Saul musters, warns the Kenites to withdraw, attacks, and takes Agag the king alive; he and the people spare the best of the livestock and destroy what is worthless. Samuel is told in the night that God regrets making Saul king. In the morning Saul greets him with the claim that he has performed the commandment, and Samuel replies by asking about the noise of sheep. Saul says the people took the animals to sacrifice. Samuel delivers the words in 15:22-23. Saul confesses, twice, and asks for honour before the elders. Samuel finally returns with him, and then has Agag brought and cuts him to pieces at Gilgal.
The background is in two earlier texts. Exodus 17:14-16 records a battle with Amalek during the wilderness journey and an oath of perpetual war; Deuteronomy 25:17-19 commands Israel, once it has rest in the land, to blot out the memory of Amalek, adding the detail that Amalek attacked the stragglers at the rear — the feeble, the weary — and did not fear God. So the command in 1 Samuel 15 is presented as the execution of a standing obligation, not as a new instruction.
What is distinctive about this chapter. Lecture 2-2 set out the main approaches to the ban and this lecture will not restate them. What it can do is show why 1 Samuel 15 is not simply another instance.
No land is at stake. The ban texts in Deuteronomy and Joshua are attached to the occupation of territory: the nations of Canaan are to be destroyed or driven out so that Israel may live there without being drawn into their worship. That framing supplies whatever coherence those texts have, and it supports the reading that the underlying reality was dispossession. It is absent here. Amalek is a nomadic or semi-nomadic people of the southern steppe; Israel is not settling their land, and the chapter shows no interest in taking it.
The ground is inherited. The stated reason is an ambush at the exodus. Whatever period one assigns to Saul, that is centuries earlier. The text is therefore explicitly assigning to one generation the liability of another, which is a problem the conquest texts raise less directly and which the Bible elsewhere addresses in the opposite direction — Deuteronomy 24:16 forbids executing children for their fathers, and Ezekiel 18 argues at length that the son does not bear the father's guilt. The tension is inside the , and it is sharp.
The plot depends on an exact accounting. This is the observation that bears most heavily. A reading which treats the language of total destruction as conventional ancient war rhetoric — the argument associated with Kenneth Kitchen and K. Lawson Younger Jr., set out in lecture 2-2 — has real support in comparative texts, where kings routinely claim to have annihilated enemies who demonstrably survived. But in 1 Samuel 15 the entire narrative turns on the difference between complete and incomplete execution. Agag is alive and the sheep are audible. The chapter is a story about a man who did ninety per cent of what he was told and lost his kingdom for the remaining ten. That plot requires the command to have been meant literally by the narrator, whatever the literary conventions of royal inscriptions elsewhere. A student who has adopted the hyperbole reading needs to be able to say what it does with this chapter.
And Amalekites keep appearing. In 27:8 David raids Amalekites. In chapter 30 an Amalekite raiding party burns Ziklag and David pursues them; four hundred of them escape on camels. In 2 Samuel 1 an Amalekite brings news of Saul's death. In 1 Chronicles 4:43, in the reign of Hezekiah, Simeonites strike the remnant of the Amalekites who escaped. And Haman in the book of Esther is called an Agagite, which lecture 11-1 will show is almost certainly a deliberate link back to this chapter. So the canon does not narrate the annihilation as having occurred, even after telling us that Saul carried it out from Havilah to Shur. Any account of the chapter has to hold that fact steadily: the book that condemns Saul for incomplete destruction goes on describing the survivors.
Two further difficulties, stated and not resolved. The first is Samuel's own act in 15:33. Having taught that God prefers obedience to sacrifice, Samuel hews Agag in pieces before Yahweh in Gilgal, at a sanctuary. Whatever this is, it is a religious act, and the chapter does not comment on it. The second is the pair of verses on divine regret. In 15:11 God says it grieves him that he made Saul king, and in 15:35 the narrator repeats it; in 15:29 Samuel says that the Strength of Israel does not lie or change his mind, for he is not a man, that he should repent. The verb is the same in all three places. Interpreters have handled this in three main ways: that the two uses are different senses of a flexible verb, one emotional and one about revoking a decision; that the juxtaposition is deliberate and the chapter means to hold both, with 15:29 spoken by Samuel in a particular argumentative situation rather than as a general theological statement; and that 15:29 is a later insertion by someone uncomfortable with 15:11. Each of these is held by competent readers. None of them makes the difficulty vanish, and the honest report is that a single chapter says both things.
Later use of Amalek
On the use of this text. One further duty, and it should be brief and factual. The designation "Amalek" has been applied to later enemies in Jewish and in Christian polemic, sometimes as a way of placing an opponent outside the ordinary obligations owed to human beings; the Purim connection through Haman the Agagite gave the label a continuing liturgical presence. That reception history is part of what a teacher of this chapter is handling, and lecture 12-3 of this course returns to the general question of how these books have been used. The point here is narrow: a text that names a people as permanently under sentence has a history of being extended, and knowing that is part of reading it responsibly. It is not an argument for or against any of the interpretive approaches above.
4. After the rejection: chapters 16 to 31
David is anointed in chapter 16, and the sentence that follows the anointing is one of the strangest in the book: the spirit of Yahweh departed from Saul, and an evil — or injurious, or troubling — spirit from Yahweh tormented him. Two things should be said about it. First, the Hebrew Bible in this period does not operate with a developed idea of an independent power of evil; distressing and destructive agency is regularly attributed to God's court, as it is in 1 Kings 22 and Job 1. Second, the narrative uses the affliction to bring David into Saul's household as a musician, so that the two are bound together before they are opposed. Whether Saul's condition should also be described in medical terms is a question modern readers ask and the text does not; what the text describes is a man subject to episodes of rage and despair from which music brought relief.
The long middle of this section is the pursuit: the women's song crediting David with ten thousands and Saul with thousands, the spear thrown twice, the flight, Jonathan's loyalty to the man who will displace his own succession, the priests of Nob massacred for helping David, the years as a fugitive commander in the Judean wilderness and finally in Philistine service.
Two scenes deserve special attention because they cut against the simplest account of the book's purpose.
Chapters 24 and 26, in which David twice has Saul at his mercy and twice refuses to strike the anointed king, are widely regarded as variants of one tradition — a doublet on the same grounds discussed in the previous lecture. What matters here is what Saul is given to say. He weeps, calls David his son, and says: You are more righteous than I; for you have done good to me, whereas I have done evil to you. Then in 26:21: I have sinned. Return, my son David... Behold, I have played the fool, and have erred exceedingly. A tradition constructing a villain does not give him the recognition scene.
Chapter 28, at Endor. Samuel is dead. The Philistines are massed. Saul inquires of God and receives nothing — not by dreams, not by Urim, not by prophets. So the king who had expelled the mediums from the land goes in disguise to find one. The chapter is careful: the woman is afraid, she recognises Saul, the apparition of Samuel gives him no comfort at all but only confirms the sentence and tells him that tomorrow he and his sons will be with him. Saul collapses full length on the ground, having eaten nothing all day and all night.
And then the woman — whom the king had outlawed, who has just risked her life, and who gains nothing — insists that he eat. She kills the calf she has, bakes bread, and sets it before him. He refuses; his servants and the woman together persuade him; he eats, and goes out into the night to die.
The narrator does not moralise about necromancy here, and does not make the woman a monster. She is the only person in the chapter who does anything for Saul. Readers have long noticed that this is the last meal of the first king of Israel and that it is provided by someone he had criminalised. Whatever theory of the book's composition you hold, this scene has to be accounted for, and no apologetic purpose requires it.
Chapter 31 ends the book on Mount Gilboa. Jonathan and two brothers are killed; Saul, wounded by archers, asks his armour bearer to finish him and, refused, falls on his own sword. The Philistines fasten the bodies to the wall of Beth Shan. And the men of Jabesh Gilead march through the night, take the bodies down, and bury the bones under a tamarisk tree, and fast seven days. The book that opened with a woman's song about the mighty being brought low ends with the mighty brought low and buried by the people he had once rescued. The frame is not an invention of commentators; the text names Jabesh Gilead in chapter 11 and again in chapter 31, and expects the reader to remember.
5. The apology of David, and why it is not the whole story
This is a point where readers will not agree. Leonhard Rost, whose work on the Succession Narrative lecture 6-3 examines, also identified a distinct block running roughly from 1 Samuel 16 to 2 Samuel 5, commonly called the History of David's Rise. P. Kyle McCarter Jr., in an influential article, argued that this block functions as an apology in the technical ancient sense: a document defending the legitimacy of a ruler who came to power irregularly. His comparison was the Apology of Hattusili III, a Hittite king of the thirteenth century BC who seized the throne from his nephew and left a text explaining why the goddess had chosen him and why his predecessor had forfeited the office. The parallels are structural: the new man is divinely designated, his rise is not sought by him, the old ruler is shown to be at fault, and the new man is repeatedly cleared of complicity in his predecessor's death.
And the David material does answer accusations, sometimes conspicuously. David never kills Saul, and is twice shown refusing to. He is absent from the battle in which Saul dies, and the text takes trouble to explain why. He executes the Amalekite who claims credit for the killing. He mourns Saul and Jonathan in a lament of real quality, preserved in 2 Samuel 1. He is not present when Abner is murdered, or when Ishbosheth is murdered, and he punishes both killings. Baruch Halpern argues that this pattern of insistent exculpation is itself evidence that the accusations existed and had force.
The strongest objection to reading the whole as apologetic is the material this lecture has just surveyed. An apology has no use for a Saul who is sympathetic, and less use still for a Saul who is dignified in his last hours. Nor does it need the notice in 1 Samuel 27 that David spent over a year in the service of a Philistine king and told him he had been raiding Judah when he had not, or the account of David marching out with the Philistine army against Israel and being sent back only because the Philistine commanders did not trust him. Those chapters are, at best, awkward. Diana Edelman would say the tradition kept them because they were too well known to suppress; a literary reader would say the narrative is more interested in ambiguity than in vindication. Both answers are available, and the fact that the material is there constrains any account.
6. Further Reading
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel, Anchor Bible 8 (Doubleday, 1980), and his article "The Apology of David," Journal of Biblical Literature 99 (1980) — the text-critical work on 13:1 and 15, and the Hittite comparison.
- David M. Gunn, The Fate of King Saul (JSOT Press, 1980) — the fullest reading of Saul as a tragic figure; the chapters on the rejections are the ones to start with.
- V. Philips Long, The Reign and Rejection of King Saul (Scholars Press, 1989) — the case that the rejection accounts are coherent, built on 10:8 as a standing instruction.
- Diana V. Edelman, King Saul in the Historiography of Judah (JSOT Press, 1991) — a historian's reconstruction of Saul's reign that treats the biblical account as interested testimony.
- Baruch Halpern, David's Secret Demons: Messiah, Murderer, Traitor, King (Eerdmans, 2001) — argues that the David narratives answer charges that were actually circulating.
- Robert Alter, The David Story (W. W. Norton, 1999) — the running commentary on chapters 15, 24, 26 and 28 is exceptionally good on how the narrator handles Saul.
- Walter Brueggemann, First and Second Samuel, Interpretation (John Knox, 1990) — theological exposition that refuses to make chapter 15 comfortable.
- Eric A. Seibert, Disturbing Divine Behavior: Troubling Old Testament Images of God (Fortress, 2009) — introduced in lecture 2-2; his treatment of the Amalekite command is the clearest statement of the position that declines to justify it.
- K. Lawson Younger Jr., Ancient Conquest Accounts (JSOT Press, 1990) — the comparative study behind the rhetorical-convention argument; read it to test that argument against chapter 15 yourself.
핵심 요약
- Saul, as the book reports him, was a capable war leader who fought on every frontier. The portrait of a doomed incompetent does not fit. His reign length cannot be recovered from the damaged text of 13:1.
- At Gilgal (chapter 13) Saul offers a sacrifice after waiting seven days. His offence is read as priestly usurpation, disobedience to 10:8 (Long), a disproportionate charge in a tragic design (Gunn), or Judahite apologetic (Edelman, Halpern).
- Chapter 15 differs from Joshua: no land is at stake, the ground is an old ambush, and the plot turns on an exact count of survivors. That strains a rhetorical-hyperbole reading, and Amalekites keep appearing later.
- Chapter 15 says God grieves (15:11) and also does not repent (15:29), using the same verb. Interpreters handle it as two senses, deliberate juxtaposition, or a later insertion. The Amalek label has also been extended to later enemies.
- After his rejection Saul weeps and calls David more righteous than himself, and the woman at Endor gives him his last meal. McCarter compares the David material with the Apology of Hattusili III, but these sympathetic scenes strain a purely apologetic reading.
Topic: This lecture reviews Saul's reign as reported, his two rejections at Gilgal and over Amalek, and the debate over whether the David material is an apology.
Remember: The book gives Saul real achievements and some dignity, even as it records his rejection. Obedience is the issue in 15:22-23, but that verse stands in a chapter about a total ban.
Caution: The lecture does not repeat the survey of the ban from lecture 2-2 or settle Saul's offence at Gilgal. Do not quote 15:22 as a plain maxim without its chapter.
One line to carry into ministry: Read a rejected figure fairly, including the moments the text gives him dignity, and do not let a famous verse stand apart from its chapter.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Write a one-paragraph obituary of Saul using only 1 Samuel 11, 14 and 31. Then write another using only chapters 13 and 15. What does the difference tell you about how the book has been read?
- Set out the three main proposals about Saul's offence at Gilgal. Which of them can be defended entirely from chapter 13 itself, without appeal to 10:8 or to a theory about the tradition?
- Gunn argues that the narrative itself generates sympathy for Saul. Find three details in chapters 13 to 31 that support him and one that resists him. Does sympathy for a rejected king imply that the rejection was unjust?
- Lecture 2-2 set out four approaches to the ban. Take each in turn and say specifically what it does with 1 Samuel 15, given that the plot depends on an exact accounting of survivors. Do not choose between them; identify what each must claim.
- Deuteronomy 24:16 forbids putting children to death for their fathers, and Ezekiel 18 argues at length that a son does not bear his father's guilt. 1 Samuel 15:2-3 gives inherited liability as its reason. Describe this tension without resolving it, and say what a reader who takes the whole canon seriously has to do with it.
- 1 Samuel 15:11 and 15:29 stand in one chapter. State each of the three standard handlings in a sentence, then say which you find least satisfactory and why. Notice whether your answer is driven by the Hebrew or by a prior conviction about God.
- Read chapter 28 slowly and write down everything the woman at Endor does. Then say what her presence in the narrative achieves, and what it would cost the book to remove her.
- McCarter compares the David material with the Apology of Hattusili III. List the passages in 1 Samuel 16-31 that fit an apologetic purpose and the passages that work against one. Which list is longer, and does length settle anything?