Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
목차 27
- Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
- Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
- Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
- Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
- Lecture 4-1: What Happened
- Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
- Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
- Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
- Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
- Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
- Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
- Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
- Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
- Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
- Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
- Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
- Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
- Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
- Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Ask a room of students why a religion spreads in a new country and the answers usually fall into a few families. It came with an empire and was imposed. It came with modern schools and hospitals and was accepted for their sake. It filled an empty space where no strong religion or philosophy already stood. It arrived early and had centuries to grow.
South Korea fits none of these answers well. Christianity arrived late, in the last two centuries of a very old civilization. It arrived in a country with a long literate tradition shaped by Confucianism and Buddhism, and with a strong indigenous religious practice of its own. The foreign power that ruled Korea from 1910 to 1945 was Japan — not a Christian nation, and in its last decade actively hostile to the churches. Yet by the end of the twentieth century, somewhere between a quarter and a third of South Koreans called themselves Christians. In neighbouring Japan, which was open to Western ideas earlier and more thoroughly, the figure has stayed at about one percent.
This lecture sets out that puzzle carefully. It gives the numbers, says where each one comes from, and shows why the numbers are harder to read than they first look. It then explains why historians have found Korea surprising, and closes with two honest limits: the numbers have stopped rising, and we know very little about the northern half of the peninsula.
이 26분으로 얻는 것
- State the approximate share of Protestants and Catholics in South Korea, naming the source and year of each figure, and explain why census figures and church membership figures differ.
- Explain three features of Korean history — no rule by a Christian colonial power, an old literate Confucian-Buddhist civilization, and a late opening to the West — that make Christian growth there surprising.
- Compare the Korean figures with Japan's and explain why the comparison is useful and where it can mislead.
- Describe the plateau and decline in Korean church affiliation since the 2000s in outline, and say what can and cannot be known about Christianity in North Korea.
He made from one blood every nation of men to dwell on all the surface of the earth, having determined appointed seasons, and the boundaries of their dwellings, that they should seek the Lord, if perhaps they might reach out for him and find him, though he is not far from each one of us. — Acts 17:26-27
World English Bible
Surely the islands shall wait for me, and the ships of Tarshish first, to bring your sons from far, their silver and their gold with them, for the name of Yahweh your God, and for the Holy One of Israel, because he has glorified you. — Isaiah 60:9
WEB
Paul spoke these words in Athens, to listeners who had a long philosophical tradition of their own and did not think they needed a new teacher. His claim is that every people has its own "appointed seasons" — its own history, its own timing — and that seeking God happens inside that history, not outside it. That is a useful sentence to keep beside a lecture about why one people's history took the shape it did. Isaiah's picture of ships bringing people "from far" was read by many nineteenth-century missionaries as a promise about distant lands like Korea. We will not use it that way here; the lecture is about evidence, not fulfilment. But it reminds us that Christians have long expected the faith to reach places far from where it began, and have been surprised by where it actually took root.
1. Counting Christians: what the numbers say
Every figure about religion in Korea comes from somewhere, and the source shapes the number. There are three main kinds.
The national census. South Korea's national census (run by Statistics Korea) has asked about religion once every ten years since 1985. The census asks each person to name the religion they identify with. It does not ask whether they attend church, and it does not check anyone's membership. The most recent census that asked the question was taken in 2015. It reported:
- Protestants: about 19.7% of the population (roughly 9.7 million people)
- Catholics: about 7.9% (roughly 3.9 million)
- Buddhists: about 15.5%
- No religion: about 56%
Protestants and Catholics together, then, were roughly 27–28% of South Koreans in 2015. For comparison, the 2005 census had reported about 18% Protestant and about 11% Catholic — about 29% together — and a larger Buddhist share (about 23%). The 2015 figures surprised many observers: the Protestant share went slightly up from 2005, while the Catholic and Buddhist shares went down. Korean sociologists debated the result. Some pointed out that the 2015 census changed its method (much of it was drawn from administrative registers, with the religion question asked only of a sample of households), so the two censuses are not perfectly comparable. Others suggested that members of new religious movements with Protestant roots may have described themselves as "Protestant". The honest summary is that the census shows a large Christian minority whose size has been roughly stable for a generation, not a clear trend in either direction.
Church statistics. The Catholic Church in Korea publishes its own yearly statistics through the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Korea. These count baptized, registered Catholics, and in recent years they have reported close to six million — a little over 11% of the population. That is noticeably higher than the census figure. The difference is not a scandal; it is what you would expect. A person baptized as a Catholic stays on the parish register whether or not they still practise, and some people who are on a register tell a census taker they have "no religion". Protestant denominations also publish membership figures, but because there are hundreds of Protestant bodies, some of which count generously, their combined totals have at times added up to more Protestants than the census found. Historians therefore treat denominational totals with caution.
Opinion surveys. Polling companies such as Gallup Korea have run surveys on religion at intervals since the 1980s, and several research institutes connected to churches run their own. Surveys are useful because they come more often than a census and can ask more questions (how often do you attend? did you grow up in this religion?). They also vary with their wording and sample. Gallup Korea's surveys, for example, found Protestant self-identification at around one-fifth of adults in 2004 and 2014, and noticeably lower — in the high teens — in 2021, with steepest among people in their twenties and thirties.
So when you read that "a third of South Koreans are Christians", or "a quarter", or "a fifth", ask which kind of source is speaking and which year. All three can be honestly reported. A sensible working summary for this course is: Christians of all kinds are somewhere between a quarter and a third of South Koreans, depending on how you count; Protestants outnumber Catholics by about two or three to one; and since about 2000 the combined figure has stopped growing.
2. Japan: about one percent
In Japan, the best-known estimates put Christians at about one percent of the population. The Japanese government's annual religious yearbook, which relies on figures supplied by religious bodies themselves, has reported somewhat more than that (around one and a half percent in recent years); independent surveys usually find about one percent or a little under. Either way, the contrast with Korea is enormous.
The comparison is not arbitrary. Japan and Korea are neighbours with long shared histories of Chinese writing, Confucian ethics and Buddhism. Christianity reached Japan much earlier — Francis Xavier landed in 1549 — and had tens of thousands, perhaps a few hundred thousand, followers by the early seventeenth century, before a long and brutal suppression drove it underground. In the late nineteenth century Japan opened itself to Western learning more quickly and more thoroughly than Korea did, and Protestant missionaries built respected schools and universities there. If modernization and early contact were enough to make a country Christian, Japan should have outpaced Korea. It did not.
A comparison between two countries can mislead as well as teach. Japan and Korea differ in many ways that have nothing to do with Christianity: in the relation between religion and national identity, in their experience of the twentieth century, and in how their family and village structures worked. We will return to those differences in lecture 1-2 of this course. For now it is enough to see why the contrast has fascinated historians.
3. Why the numbers are surprising
Three features of Korean history make large-scale Christian growth unexpected.
1. No Christian colonial power. In much of Latin America, Africa, the Philippines and parts of South and Southeast Asia, Christianity arrived with a European empire or grew under one. Its presence was tied — sometimes closely, sometimes loosely — to the colonial state. Korea's colonizer, from 1910 to 1945, was Japan. The Japanese government did not favour Christianity; for most of the colonial period it treated the churches with suspicion, and from the mid-1930s it required Christians (as it required everyone) to take part in rites at Shinto shrines, a crisis told in Chapter 5 of this course. So the usual picture of "the missionary following the flag" does not fit. In Korea, being Christian could even be a way of being Korean against the empire — though, as later chapters show, the story is more mixed than that sentence suggests.
2. An old, literate civilization. Korea was not a place without books or without a moral philosophy. The Joseon dynasty (1392–1910) was one of the most thoroughly Confucian states in history. Its ruling class, the yangban (the scholar-official aristocracy), were trained in the Chinese classics; the state's legitimacy rested on a particular idea of family duty, ritual and social order. Buddhism had been the dominant religion of the previous kingdom and remained a living tradition, especially among women and in the countryside. Beneath and beside both lay the practices of Korean shamanism (musok), with its specialists, the mudang, who dealt with spirits and misfortune. A theory that says Christianity spreads where it meets a religious vacuum cannot explain Korea: there was no vacuum. (James Huntley Grayson's Korea: A Religious History is a good guide to this crowded religious landscape into which Christianity came.)
3. A late opening. Korea was the last of the East Asian kingdoms to open itself to the Western powers. Nineteenth-century Western writers called it "the Hermit Kingdom". Its first treaty with a Western nation was signed with the United States in 1882; Protestant missionaries did not settle there until 1884–85. The Catholic Church had been present longer, from 1784, but for most of the century it was illegal and repeatedly persecuted. So Korean Christianity had, in effect, about a century — roughly 1885 to 1985 — to grow from a few thousand people to millions.
None of these features is unique to Korea. China also had no Christian colonizer of the whole country and an old literate civilization. But the combination, together with the size and speed of the growth, is why many historians speak of the "Korean case" or the "Korean anomaly".
4. How fast, and when
The growth did not happen evenly. A rough outline, with the sources' usual caution:
- In 1900, Protestants and Catholics together probably numbered in the tens of thousands, in a population of perhaps twelve to seventeen million (estimates for the population itself vary).
- By 1945, Christians of all kinds were perhaps two to three percent of the population, with Protestantism strongest in the north, around Pyongyang.
- The decisive growth came after the Korean War. By the 1985 census, Protestants were about 16% of South Koreans and Catholics about 5%; by 1995, about 20% and about 7%.
The figures for 1900 and 1945 are estimates built from church reports, and historians give different numbers. The shape is clearer than any single point on it: modest growth under Joseon and Japan, then a very steep rise between the 1960s and the early 1990s, and a plateau after that. Chapter 7 of this course examines the explanations sociologists and theologians have offered for the steep rise.
5. A plateau and a decline
Since the 1990s the story has changed. Protestant growth slowed and stopped; surveys since the 2010s show falling religious affiliation among young South Koreans in every religion, not only Christianity. Public trust in Protestant churches in particular has fallen, and surveys commissioned by Christian bodies themselves have recorded that fall. Catholic figures held up longer, then also levelled off, and Mass attendance dropped sharply during the COVID-19 pandemic and has not fully recovered according to the Church's own statistics.
This lecture only flags the change. Chapter 9 of this course takes up the plateau, its causes and what it might mean. It is worth noticing now, though, because it changes the question. For much of the twentieth century scholars asked "why did Korean Christianity grow so fast?" Now they also ask "why did it stop?" — and any explanation of the first has to be compatible with the second.
6. Other Christian bodies
Most of this course is about Catholics and Protestants, because they are the overwhelming majority of Korean Christians. Two smaller traditions deserve mention.
The Orthodox Church came to Korea through a Russian mission that began in 1900 in Seoul. After the Russian Revolution and the Korean War it survived with very few priests, and in the second half of the twentieth century it came under the care of the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople; there is now an Orthodox Metropolis of Korea with its cathedral of Saint Nicholas in Seoul. Its members number a few thousand — a small community with a long and difficult history of its own, not a footnote to someone else's.
The Anglican Church of Korea dates from 1890, when the first Anglican bishop arrived from England. It is small but has been influential beyond its size, including in social movements. Various other Protestant bodies — Holiness, Baptist, Salvation Army, Lutheran, Pentecostal and many independent churches — are counted among "Protestants" in the census.
7. North Korea: what little is known
Before 1945, the northern half of the peninsula was the heartland of Korean Protestantism. Pyongyang had so many churches that missionaries called it "the Jerusalem of the East". After the division of the peninsula in 1945 and the Korean War (1950–53), most Christian leaders who could leave went south, and the government of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea) suppressed organized religion. Chapter 6 of this course tells this story.
What can be said about today must be stated with its limits.
- Official figures. The state-approved Korean Christian Federation has reported a membership of about twelve to thirteen thousand Protestants, and a Catholic association has reported a few thousand Catholics. There are a small number of official church buildings in Pyongyang. Outside observers disagree about how much ordinary religious life these represent.
- Estimates of hidden believers. Christian advocacy organizations have estimated that there are between one and several hundred thousand secret Christians in North Korea. These estimates cannot be checked by any independent method; they are built from the testimony of people who have left the country and from assumptions about how many families kept faith in secret after 1953.
- Testimony about persecution. The United Nations Commission of Inquiry on human rights in North Korea (2014) found, from defector testimony, that Christians are severely persecuted and that possessing a Bible or contact with Christians can lead to imprisonment in political prison camps.
A careful student will hold all three at once: the official figures are what the state wants known; the estimates are uncheckable; the testimony is serious and consistent but comes from people who have left, and who are, understandably, not neutral. Anyone who gives you a precise number of Christians in North Korea is claiming more than can be known.
8. What this means for the rest of the course
The numbers establish that there is a puzzle. They do not solve it. The rest of the course will look at the explanations one by one — early Korean agency and lay leadership (Chapters 2 and 3), the translated Bible in the Korean alphabet (Chapter 3), revival and its practices (Chapter 4), the link between faith and nationhood under Japanese rule (Chapter 5), war and anticommunism (Chapter 6), urbanization and the megachurch (Chapter 7). You will find that each explanation accounts for part of the picture and leaves some of it unexplained. That is the reason for going slowly.
The three boxes do not contradict one another. They answer different questions. A census counts identity; a parish register counts baptisms; a survey counts whatever its question asks.
Each explanation on the left works somewhere in the world. Each meets a difficulty in Korea on the right. That does not make them useless; it means none of them works alone.
5. Going to the Sources
Source: the religion tables of the 2015 Population and Housing Census of the Republic of Korea, published by Statistics Korea (KOSTAT) in December 2016. The tables are available in Korean and partly in English through the KOSIS statistical database (kosis.kr). Statistics Korea's published summary reported, in substance (paraphrased): that the share of the population with a religion had fallen below half for the first time, to about 44%; that Protestantism, at about 9.7 million people, had become the largest single religion, ahead of Buddhism at about 7.6 million; and that Catholics numbered about 3.9 million, down from about 5.1 million in 2005.
A census table is a primary source just as a letter is. It was produced at a particular time, by a particular institution, for particular purposes, and its categories were chosen by someone.
- The census counts what people say their religion is. Name two kinds of people who might be counted as "Protestant" or "Catholic" by the census but not by their church, and two kinds who might be counted by their church but not by the census.
- The Catholic figure fell by more than a million between 2005 and 2015 in the census, while the Church's own registers continued to rise over the same years. What would you need to know before deciding which picture is closer to the truth — or whether they are measuring different things?
- Headlines in 2016 announced that "Protestantism is now Korea's largest religion." Using only the figures above, write one sentence that reports the same result more carefully.
핵심 요약
- Census figures, church registers and opinion surveys count different things. Together they suggest Christians are between a quarter and a third of South Koreans. Protestants outnumber Catholics by about two or three to one.
- Japan, a close neighbour with similar roots and earlier contact, stayed at about one percent Christian. The comparison is useful, but the two countries also differ in many other ways.
- Three features make Korea surprising: no Christian colonial power, an old literate Confucian-Buddhist civilization, and a late opening to the West.
- Growth was steepest between the 1960s and early 1990s, then reached a plateau. Affiliation has fallen among the young in every religion.
- Orthodox and Anglican churches are small but real parts of Korean Christianity. For North Korea, official figures, hidden-believer estimates and testimony each have limits, so no precise number is possible.
Topic: This lecture explains why Korean Christianity is a puzzle for historians and why its numbers must be read with care.
Remember: Always ask which source gives a figure, which year it covers, and what exactly was counted: identity, baptism or attendance.
Caution: The numbers show that there is a puzzle. They do not explain it, and no single explanation works alone.
One line to carry into ministry: When you quote a number about the church, name its source and what it counts, and say "we do not know" where that is true.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- If you grew up in a Korean church abroad, how did people in your church talk about the size of the church in Korea? Did the numbers you heard match the ones in this lecture? Where might the difference have come from?
- Why might a religion that arrived *without* a colonial power have a different relationship with national identity from one that arrived *with* one? What are the gains and dangers in each case?
- Paul told the Athenians that God appoints "seasons" for each people. Without treating history as a proof of anything, how would you describe the particular "season" in which Christianity came to Korea?
- The Orthodox and Anglican churches in Korea are small. What might a very small church see about Korean society that a very large one cannot?
- Why is it important, and difficult, to say "we do not know" about Christians in North Korea? What would it take for you to trust a number?